Thursday, September 4, 2014

Inside the Mammoth Backlash to Common Core | Mother Jones

Inside the Mammoth Backlash to Common Core | Mother Jones:



Inside the Mammoth Backlash to Common Core

How a bipartisan education reform effort became the biggest conservative bogeyman since Obamacare.

—By 
common core
Illustration: Chris Buzelli
ONE NIGHT LAST SEPTEMBER, a 46-year-old Veterans Administration research manager named Robert Small showed up at a public meeting with state education officials in Ellicott City, a well-to-do Maryland suburb, with a pen, a notebook, and an ax to grind. Small had been doing some homework on the main topic of the event, a set of math and language arts standards called Common Core that had recently been introduced in schools across the country, including his kids'. Fresh from work in a crisp, checkered shirt, he stood up in an overflow crowd and channeled his inner Henry V. "I want to know how many parents here are aware that the goal of the Common Core standards isn't to prepare our children for world-class universities—it's to prepare them for community college!" An off-duty police officer approached, and Small began to shout. "You're sitting here like cattle!" Out came the handcuffs. "Hey, is this America?" Small bellowed, as he jostled with the officer. "Parents, you need to question these people! Do the research!"
The police department later dropped the charge of second-degree assault of a police officer; Small, for his part, said he held no grudge against the cops. But avideo of the incident, which racked up more than a million views on YouTube, set off a firestorm of right-wing outrage. On his radio show, Glenn Beck confessed he couldn't sleep after watching the clip. "This is the way it used to happen in Mother Russia, not America. It's Dictatorship 101."
The educational initiative that has inspired such a remarkable outpouring of fury began as a bipartisan endeavor so anodyne, nerdy even, that it proceeded for years with virtual consensus among policymakers of all stripes. Republican governors once enthusiastically signed on to the initiative—but now they (especially those contemplating presidential bids) are scrambling to distance themselves, and around the country state lawmakers are seeking to halt the implementation of the standards. Perhaps second only to Obamacare, Common Core has become a rallying cry on the right, evoking the kind of anguish and horror once reserved for the so-called death panels. And unlike health care reform, Common Core has tapped into a vein of outrage on the left as well.
Over the last two years, the bipartisan coalition that brought the standards into being has been supplanted by a growing movement of activists who variously claim that they are too tough, too easy, too liberal, too invasive, too extensive, or all of the above. What might have been the last realm of public policy in which bipartisan consensus still reigned has been riven by an opposition as eclectic as it is disjointed—what other issue unites the John Birch Society in common cause with a former member of the radical Weathermen?
One Florida lawmaker alleged that Common Core will "attract every one of your children to become as homosexual as they possibly can."

COMMON CORE EMERGED from the ashes of No Child Left Behind, the Bush-era education reform law that tied federal funding for the nation's schools to new, mandatory standardized tests. It was a time of sometimes-chaotic trial and error among educational reformers, who feared American students were falling further behind their counterparts in Finland or (gulp) China. But many teachers and parents were frustrated by an approach that seemed to punish Inside the Mammoth Backlash to Common Core | Mother Jones:
Posted by at

Nite Cap 9-4-14 #BATsACT #RealEdTalk #EDCHAT



James Baldwin said it best: 

"For these are all our children, and we will profit by or pay for whatever they become."


A BIG EDUCATION APE NITE CAP




Yo Sac Bee: You Hate Teachers, You Hate Public Education and Love the 1%, We get it!
Editorial: Teacher protections that hurt students are indefensible – unless you’re state’s top education official - Editorials - The Sacramento Bee: Yo Sac Bee: You Hate Teachers, You Hate Public Education and Love the 1%, We get it!Editorial: Teacher protections that hurt students are indefensible – unless you’re state’s top education officialBy the Editorial BoardPublished: Thursday, Sep. 4, 201
1 by mike simpson / 58min 
Marie Corfield: My Response to Tom Moran
Marie Corfield: My Response to Tom Moran: My Response to Tom MoranIn case you missed it, earlier this week fellow educators and bloggers, Ani McHugh (Teacherbiz), Mark Weber (Jersey Jazzman) and I wrote a joint open letter to Star Ledger editorial director, Tom Moran, regarding his continuous support of the racist policies of Newark Superintendent Cami Anderson's One Newark plan. In addition to po
1 by mike simpson / 1h 
9-4-14 Curmudgucation
CURMUDGUCATION: The Broad Foundation Makes a ChangeLast week the folks at the Broad Academy (motto: "You're a superintendent because you say you are") dropped some new on the education world. If you need a refresher (or just a fresher) on what the Broad Academy is, just click over to this tutorial. In the meantime, just remember that a dream is a wish your heart makes, and if your heart
2 by mike simpson / 1h 
“I felt Strange and Guilty”: Annie Tan @TeachForAmerica alum speaks | Cloaking Inequity
“I felt Strange and Guilty”: Annie Tan @TeachForAmerica alum speaks | Cloaking Inequity: “I felt Strange and Guilty”: Annie Tan @TeachForAmerica alum speaksTeach For America recently announced that they were sending more teachers of color than ever before to teach for short term stints in America’s schools. They expect to be lauded for this.What is Teach For America? Read here.Have you ever experi
1 by mike simpson / 1h 
9-4-14 LA School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD
LA School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District): Tech startup innovates teacher evaluation systemTech startup innovates teacher evaluation system Via NY Times | by Farhad Manjoo Halfway through the last school year, Leila Campbell, a young humanities teacher at a charter high school in Oakland, Calif., received the results from a recent survey of her st
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
Education Research Report UPDATE 9-4-14
Education Research Report: Teacher Attrition and Mobility: Results From the 2012–13 Teacher Follow-up SurveyOf the 3,377,900 public school teachers who were teaching during the 2011–12 school year, 84 percent remained at the same school (“stayers”), 8 percent moved to a different school (“movers”), and 8 percent left the profession (“leavers”) during the following year. About 30 percent of public
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
9-4-14 Ed Notes Online
Ed Notes Online: Congrats to John Elfrank-Dana who has now successfully battled two abusive principalsIf this were Atlanta, Almonte would be leaving in handcuffs..... Ed NotesBergtraum HS principal leaves after caught pushing kids into substandard online courses & violating sped rights; sadly she will now likely go and ruin some adult ed program. Congrats to John ElFrank-Dana who has now succe
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
SBE News Release for September 3, 2014 - State Board of Education (CA Dept of Education)
SBE News Release for September 3, 2014 - State Board of Education (CA Dept of Education): State Board of Education Commends Higher Education’s Endorsement of Common Core and Comprehensive, Coordinated Approach for ImplementationIn an unprecedented action, the four systems of higher education announced their endorsement of Common Core standards and have engaged in a comprehensive, coordinated appro
by mike simpson / 2h 
9-4-14 With A Brooklyn Accent: Why Charter School Leaders Are Behind Attacks on Teachers Unions and Public Schools
With A Brooklyn Accent: Why Charter School Leaders Are Behind Attacks on Teachers Unions and Public SchoolsIf you ever wonder why famous charter school leaders like Eva Moskowitz or Steve Perry don't just run their schools quietly and let the results speak for themselves and instead devote much of their time attacking teachers, teachers unions and public schools, consider this. When the hiring fre
by mike simpson / 2h 
Restoring The SUPER In Tendent – redqueeninla
Restoring The SUPER In Tendent – redqueeninla: Restoring The SUPER In TendentWritten by redqueeninla in LAUSD When my home town built a new school in the early ’70′s, a whole era vanished in concert with the disappearance of gilded letters proclaiming the “Superintendent’s Office” within. I never did figure out what a “Superintendent” was and I was always vaguely disappointed that wing, located ne
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
REPA III – The Wrong Direction | Live Long and Prosper
REPA III – The Wrong Direction | Live Long and Prosper: REPA III – The Wrong DirectionYesterday, by a vote of 7 Ayes to 3 Nays, the Indiana State Board of Education passed REPA III, rules which define the qualifications for public school educators. This version contains the Career Specialist Permit which gives non-educational professionals the right to teach in Indiana high schools.LOCAL CONTROLWh
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
California teacher unions appeal ruling on job protections - LA Times
California teacher unions appeal ruling on job protections - LA Times: California teacher unions appeal ruling on job protectionsRandi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, criticized a court ruling limiting job protections, but also wants teachers to consider common-sense changes. (John Hanna / AP)By HOWARD BLUMEcontact the reporterCalifornia's two largest teacher unions h
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
Gene V Glass: Education in Two Worlds: William Mathis on "Economics, Education and Sitting Bull"
Gene V Glass: Education in Two Worlds: William Mathis on "Economics, Education and Sitting Bull": William Mathis on "Economics, Education and Sitting Bull""William Mathis is Managing Director of the National Education Policy Center, a former school superintendent and member of the Vermont state board of education. In this essay, his opinions and analysis reflect something
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
Opening The Door To the Space In-Between by EDWARD BERGER
Opening The Door To the Space In-Between: Opening The Door To the Space In-Betweenby EDWARDBERGER on SEPTEMBER 4, 2014There are questions we don’t ask because…? Maybe we never thought about the possibilities and couldn’t form the question. Or, maybe we thought about the possibilities and decided that what we imagined couldn’t happen – even if the changes wrought would make a significant contributi
1 by mike simpson / 2h 
9-4-14 Schools Matter - 69 Hoops and No Appeal: Teacher Observation--Memphis Style
Schools Matter: 69 Hoops and No Appeal: Teacher Observation--Memphis StylePoint one that has to be remembered: half of Tennessee teacher evaluations are based on invalid, unreliable, and unfair test scores.  The other half is based on observations. Teachers who worked for months on a new observation process last year were eventually dismissed when they disagreed with the two most outrageous aspect
1 by mike simpson / 7h 
9/3/2014 – The Education Conversation ‘Reformers’ Want Versus The One They Get
9/3/2014 – The Education Conversation ‘Reformers’ Want Versus The One They Get: 9/3/2014 – The Education Conversation ‘Reformers’ Want Versus The One They GetSeptember 3, 2014 SubscribeTHIS WEEK: Hating Teachers … Grit Not So Good … Music Lessons Help Disadvantaged Kids … Never-Ending Testing … Fox News Lauds Arming TeachersTOP STORYThe Education Conversation ‘Reformers’ Want Versus The One They G
1 by mike simpson / 7h 
Morning Wink 9-4-14 AM Posts #edchat #edreform
BIG EDUCATION APE - MORNING WINK  AM POSTSLISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-4-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for allDiane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: The Politico Top 50Thank you to Politico magazine for naming me one of the Top 50 political figures whose ideas are making a difference. The bio says “For standing up for teachers, not tests.” I
3 by mike simpson / 7h 
LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-4-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: The Politico Top 50Thank you to Politico magazine for naming me one of the Top 50 political figures whose ideas are making a difference. The bio says “For standing up for teachers, not tests.” I am honored to be in such illustrious company!2 by dianeravitch / 10min hide  //  saveMarc Tucker Calls for a New Accountability SystemMarc
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher
Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.: Fight for 15.1 by Fred Klonsky / 5min hide  //  saveRobin Potter. Karen Lewis at the National Lawyers Guild.- Chicago activist and attorney Robin Potter sends this: The National Lawyers Guild is holding its national convention starting Thursday in Chicago. The NLG is a pivotal progressive organization
2 by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Engaging Parents In School… | Going Beyond Parent "Involvement"
Engaging Parents In School… | Going Beyond Parent "Involvement": Interesting Idea: “Digital Parent Volunteers”Here’s an interesting idea from George Couros: You might also be interested in The Best Sources Of Parent Engagement Advice For Teachers.5 by Larry Ferlazzo / 2h hide  //  save“A Checklist for Back to School Night”A Checklist for Back to School Night is a useful post for every te
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Wait What? - For whom the bell tolls…
Wait What?: For whom the bell tolls…With Election Day less than nine weeks away, Connecticut teachers, parents and public school advocates continue to wait for an indication as to whether any of the candidates for governor will truly stand up against the tide of the corporate education reform industry, including their absurd, unfair and expensive Common Core testing scheme. Tens of […] The post Fo
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Answer Sheet
Answer Sheet: No, helicopter parents aren’t ruining kids after allThere is no end to the articles and blog posts about overprotective helicopter parents who won’t let their children do anything for themselves and are raising children who can’t operate independently. There probably are some of these parents — but does the helicopter hysteria match the reality. No, says Alfie Kohn, in the following
by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Times Urges Mayor Murray to Take Control of the School BoardIn one of the most shameful and disrespectfully written editorials I've ever read in the Times, they urge the Mayor and the City Council to make taking over the majority of the Seattle School Board positions a top legislative priority.It's a funny thing because I JUST today wrote the Board about a couple o
by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL
Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL: All The Interviews I’ve Done With Authors Over The Past 3 Years — In One Place!My latest Ed Week Teacher post brings together all the interviews I’ve done with authors over the past three years. Here’s an excerpt from one:3 by Larry Ferlazzo / 1h 9-3-14 Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & E
by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Jersey Jazzman - A Reply To A Reply from @tomamoran
Jersey Jazzman: A Reply To A Reply from @tomamoranTom,Contrary to your beliefs, no one called you a racist. You know this: you put our other criticisms of you in quotes, but not the one where you allege we call you racist.What we said was that you support One Newark, a racist school reorganization policy. Which it is.You say:Maybe you folks should take a pill, and engage people who disagree with y
by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 the becoming radical | A Place for a Pedagogy of Kindness
the becoming radical | A Place for a Pedagogy of Kindness (the public and scholarly writing by P. L. Thomas, Furman University): Grade Retention ResearchGrade Retention Research Alexander, K.L., Entwisle, D.R., & Dauber, S.L. (1994). On the success of failure: A reassessment of the effects of retention in the primary grades. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Allensworth, E. M. (2004).
by mike simpson / 8h 
4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit 9-4-14
4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit: LA Times: the story retold — SUPT. DEASY’S EARLY AND AVID SUPPORT OF iPADS UNDER INTENSE SCRUTINYCritics question Deasy video – and much more –  promoting iPads before bidding began By Howard Blume and James Rainey | http://lat.ms/1vS847t Supt. John Deasy appeared in a 2011 video for Apple promoting the iPad, saying it would "change the landscape o
by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Hemlock on the Rocks
Hemlock on the Rocks: Accountability - ChangeTheLAUSDhttp://www.changethelausd.com/accountability.html Accountability - ChangeTheLAUSD"It was controversial?"- John Deasy (1)At the beginning of this month, Superintendent Deasy was mocking opponents of his plan "to provide an iPad to every Los Angeles student, teacher and school administrator." (2) Yesterday he cancelled the proj
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 Perdido Street School Week
Perdido Street School: APPR Teacher Evaluation System Mess ThreadJames Eterno at ICEUFT blog describes how you can get the same score in the APPR teacher evaluation system and either be "developing" or "ineffective," depending upon, well, nobody's sure what it depends upon:We knew teachers at a phasing out school would be at a huge disadvantage in terms of the ratings in Advanc
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
Shanker Blog » Why Teachers And Researchers Should Work Together For Improvement
Shanker Blog » Why Teachers And Researchers Should Work Together For Improvement: Why Teachers And Researchers Should Work Together For ImprovementPosted by Bill Penuel on September 4, 2014Our guest author today is Bill Penuel, professor of educational psychology and learning sciences at the University of Colorado Boulder. He leads the National Center for Research in Policy and Practice, which inv
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
Common Core's Five Big Half-Truths :: Frederick M. Hess
Common Core's Five Big Half-Truths :: Frederick M. Hess: Common Core's Five Big Half-Truthsby Frederick M. Hess  •  Sep 4, 2014 at 8:37 amCross-posted from Education Week Print Send RSS ShareSchool is back in session, and debate over the Common Core is boiling in key states. As governors and legislators debate the fate of the Common Core, they hear Core advocates repeatedly stress five impressive
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
9-4-14 empathyeducates - 6 Things White Parents Can Do to Raise Racially Conscious Children
empathyeducates – 6 Things White Parents Can Do to Raise Racially Conscious Children: 6 Things White Parents Can Do to Raise Racially Conscious ChildrenPhotograph; iStock Image | First Book.By Bree Ervin | Originally Published at Everyday Feminism and re-published at EmpathyEducates with their permission. August 30, 2014Talking about race is challenging for many parents, especially White parents.T
1 by mike simpson / 8h 
Sacramento News & Review - Did Kevin Johnson work behind the scenes to fire Sacramento labor leader Bill Camp? - News - Local Stories - September 4, 2014
Sacramento News & Review - Did Kevin Johnson work behind the scenes to fire Sacramento labor leader Bill Camp? - News - Local Stories - September 4, 2014: Did Kevin Johnson work behind the scenes to fire Sacramento labor leader Bill Camp?A look at the fight for strong mayor and Measure L and the SEIUBy Cosmo Garvin cosmog@newsreview.comOne thing you’d expect the Sacramento Central Labor Counci
by mike simpson / 8h 
CA goes it alone on special ed testing :: SI&A Cabinet Report :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet
CA goes it alone on special ed testing :: SI&A Cabinet Report :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet: SEPTEMBER 04, 2014CA goes it alone on special ed testingby Kimberly Beltran(Calif.) California is moving forward with a plan to develop and administer its own assessment for cognitively disabled students after learning barely a month ago that it would not be allowed to t
by mike simpson / 9h 
Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: A color-coded visual of Chicago's reform failure
Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: A color-coded visual of Chicago's reform failure: A color-coded visual of Chicago's reform failureBlaine Principal Troy LaRaviereThanks to Blaine Principal Troy LaRaviere for sharing this excellent color-coded visual on Reading Growth in Chicago's Public & Charter Schools. @TroyLaraviere on Twitter calls it a "visual of Chicago's Charter Reform Failure."
by mike simpson / 9h 
NYC Educator: In Which I Am Booted Out of a Very Low Venue
NYC Educator: In Which I Am Booted Out of a Very Low Venue: In Which I Am Booted Out of a Very Low VenueYesterday, I went to the trailer to prepare. I went up to the second floor and found all my Stuff, which I then had someone help me bring down to the trailer. Afterward, we placed it all in the abandoned file cabinet and ran back to the building. I went to my AP to file the outside evidence abou
by mike simpson / 9h 
Op-Ed: In All-Charter School Districts, Ideology Trumps the Facts - NJ Spotlight
Op-Ed: In All-Charter School Districts, Ideology Trumps the Facts - NJ Spotlight: OP-ED: IN ALL-CHARTER SCHOOL DISTRICTS, IDEOLOGY TRUMPS THE FACTSPAUL TRACTENBERG | SEPTEMBER 4, 2014Mounting evidence indicates that charter schools can’t live up to their hypePaul TractenbergOne of the latest and most ardently pursued urban education reform is the all-charter school district. New Orleans, Detroit,
by mike simpson / 9h 

YESTERDAY

On Honest and Civil Conversation (Simmer Down Now) | The Jose Vilson
On Honest and Civil Conversation (Simmer Down Now) | The Jose Vilson: On Honest and Civil Conversation (Simmer Down Now) SEPTEMBER 3, 2014 JOSE 1 COMMENTThe first audience reaction to my speech at the Network for Public Education came from a older, burly white man with big hands and a soft voice. Not that any of this scares me much since I’m from the hood, but context matters.“Jose, I’m glad you’r
1 by mike simpson / 19h 
Pearson: Inside the Belly of a Very Troubled Beast | Alan Singer
Pearson: Inside the Belly of a Very Troubled Beast | Alan Singer: Pearson: Inside the Belly of a Very Troubled Beast"And the noise was in the beast's belly like unto the questing of thirty couple hounds." -Le Morte d'Arthur by Sir Thomas Malory, Book 1, chapter XIX, c. 14769Being trapped in the belly of the beast is scary. In the Old Testament, Jonah was trapped in the belly of a great f
1 by mike simpson / 19h 
The Wal-Mart-ization of Education: Wal-Mart Wants Classrooms to Run More Like a Business, Teachers Are Fighting Back | Randi Weingarten
The Wal-Mart-ization of Education: Wal-Mart Wants Classrooms to Run More Like a Business, Teachers Are Fighting Back | Randi Weingarten: The Wal-Mart-ization of Education: Wal-Mart Wants Classrooms to Run More Like a Business, Teachers Are Fighting BackAs part of Wal-Mart's back-to-school marketing efforts, the company recently launched a series of teacher appreciation videos, ads, hashtags and di
1 by mike simpson / 19h 
Reflections of a BadAss Teacher – Year Two - Badass Teachers Association
Badass Teachers Association: Reflections of a BadAss Teacher – Year TwoGetting ready for work this morning, I experienced something I had never felt before.I was not ready to go back to work.  I am sure that my working at the school for four weeks during the summer had something to do with it.  But it was more than that.  Trying to pinpoint exactly what it was at first was hard.  Last year I had f
1 by mike simpson / 19h 
Nite Cap 9-3-14 #BATsACT #RealEdTalk #EDCHAT
James Baldwin said it best: "For these are all our children, and we will profit by or pay for whatever they become."A BIG EDUCATION APE NITE CAP4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit 9-3-144LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit: DEASY: “Dear LAUSD Family, I would like to speak to you personally…” but instead here are two links to the same memo I sent to the Board of Ed yesterda
3 by mike simpson / 20h 




Posted by at
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)