Saturday, May 2, 2015

Out-of-state Dark Money seek to influence Tennessee's legislators | Local News | Times Free Press

Out-of-state interests seek to influence Tennessee's legislators | Local News | Times Free Press:

Out-of-state interests seek to influence Tennessee's legislators






 NASHVILLE -- Out-of-state interests have long sought to shape public policy in Tennessee, but some national organizations that are relative newcomers to the Volunteer State have added millions of dollars to the mix of political money and lobbying intended to achieve that influence.

The apparent increase in groups headquartered elsewhere trying to sway decision-making by legislators had limited success in the 109th General Assembly session, a Tennessee News Network review indicates.
But the outside interests are trying. In the session that ended last month, they engaged in controversial issues such as Gov. Bill Haslam's Insure Tennessee proposal and gun laws, all the way down to less-noticed matters such as experimental drugs and state subsidies to parents of children with specified disabilities.
Most prominent in enhanced spending are three national organizations that have dramatically expanded their Tennessee activity within the past three years:
* Americans for Prosperity, based in Arlington, Va., was founded and -- at least initially -- mostly funded by businessmen and philanthropist brothers David and Charles Koch with the proclaimed aim of advocating for free enterprise. AFP's Tennessee operation reported spending more than $1.1 million in Tennessee lobbying last year. AFP reported spending less than $10,000 in all prior reports filed with the Tennessee Ethics Commission since it became active within the state in 2012. AFP reported no explicitly political spending, but state Director Andrew Ogles says the lobbying report covers "educational" ads that sometimes criticized or supported legislative candidates.
* The American Federation for Children, based in Washington, D.C., advocates education reforms involving "school choice" for parents. The AFC's state organization reported spending between $75,000 and $150,000 on Tennessee lobbying in 2014 to the Ethics Commission and reported a total of $606,345 in political spending by the political action committee set up by its state affiliate, the Tennessee Federation for Children, to the state Registry of Election Finance during the 2014 election cycle, including 2013. The state PAC was launched in 2012.
* StudentsFirst, based in Sacramento, Calif., and founded by Michelle Rhee, a former District of Columbia school superintendent, also advocates expanded options for education, including school vouchers. The organization reported spending between $100,000 and $200,000 on lobbying in 2014 -- plus a $13,907 reception for legislators -- and reported spending of $573,917 within the state during the 2014 election cycle by its state PAC, which was launched in 2012. (Rhee was formerly married to Kevin Huffman, who served four years as Tennessee's education commissioner.)
These groups set up shop in Tennessee fairly recently and started building a "grass roots" network of state resident members, although much of their funding still comes from outside the state -- substantial chunks of money transferred from national headquarters in the case of StudentsFirst and AFC.
AFP made defeat of Insure Tennessee its top priority this year and claimed success on that front when the governor's bill died in committee. But a broad school voucher bill was a high priority for AFC and StudentsFirst, and AFP supports the idea as well -- and that bill failed for the third straight year.
AFP has also pushed for repeal of the state's Hall income tax and that didn't happen either, although lawmakers approved an increase in the exemption from the tax that will benefit senior citizens of modest income.
Americans for Prosperity does not disclose its sources of money, as permitted under its legal setup, or how that money is spent except for the lobbying expenditures, which Ogles says include "educational" and "issue advocacy" ads that often criticize a candidate or urge residents to contact legislators and express support for or opposition to a pending bill.
A long list
The groups join a long list of established special interests headquartered outside the state with varying ties to groups within the state.
"We've always had outside influence," said state House Speaker Beth Harwell. "When I started in the Legislature, sitting on the Education Committee, the AFL-CIO would be in the audience, the National Education Association would be in the audience ... and the American Civil Liberties Union has always had a presence here."
Harwell, first elected to the Legislature in 1988, says there once were no major lobbying opponents to such groups, prone to support Democrats.
"That day is over," she said. "Now business understands how important education is, and they are involved, too" through national groups as well as Tennessee business lobbyists.
But Harwell said legislators can be trusted to look to the interests of their constituents, not of the lobbyists.
The speaker referred to the national AFL-CIO being represented by its state affiliate, the Tennessee Labor Council, and other nationwide unions and the NEA being represented by its state affiliate, the Tennessee Education Association. While union political donations have decreased in Tennessee as Republicans gained dominance in the state, the TEA is still active -- reporting $350,130 in spending by its PAC in the 2014 election cycle and between $110,000 and $175,000 in lobbying expenditures.
The ACLU has not made political contributions to state legislators, and the Tennessee ACLU reported less than $10,000 in lobbying expenditures last year. But the ACLU made substantial contributions to a campaign committee opposing Amendment 1 to the state constitution in last year's election. The amendment, which cleared the way for legislation putting new restrictions on abortion rights, passed.
Other interest groups engaged in Tennessee range from the National Rifle Association, which has had considerable success in enacting gun rights legislation, to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, which has taken to introducing a package of bills drafted at the national level each year that are distinct from the agenda of its state affiliate, the Tennessee Chamber of Commerce and Industry, and hiring its own lobbyists.
Last year, Haslam vetoed a U.S. Chamber-backed bill after determining it had the unintended consequence of reducing penalties for pollution. This year, the offending provision was deleted and the bill, designed to outlaw "flash mobs" in Tennessee, passed again -- with Haslam's signature expected.
The National Association of Realtors PAC last year made its first appearance in Tennessee legislative campaigns, with more than $200,000 in independent expenditures. Its state affiliate, the Tennessee Association of Realtors, made $118,000 in direct donations to legislative candidates.
Off in a category by itself is the American Legislative Exchange Council, which has various Tennessee legislators as members and attendees at twice-a-year ALEC conferences where they can collect "model bills" drafted in meetings with national business interests and bring them back for enactment as state laws. Critics contend the group amounts to the ultimate in secretive out-of-state influence for wealthy corporations, contrasting with the National Conference of State Legislatures, which presents itself as providing information without advocacy.
While not worried about the lobbying by out-of-state groups, Harwell said she is concerned that heavy spending on political attacks, funded by outside groups, is "out of hand" and a matter of considerable concern, but there's not much to be done about it based on U.S. Supreme Court campaign financing decisions.
"If I could put limits in place, I would," she said. "But the courts have spoken, and that's the way it is."
Defeat by spending
In last year's elections, at least two House incumbents were defeated after being targeted by six-figure spending by AFC and StudentsFirst, much of it on attack advertising. They were former Rep. Dennis "Coach" Roach, R-Rutledge, defeated in the GOP primary, and former Rep. Gloria Johnson, D-Knoxville, who lost in the general election. Other legislators attacked, on the other hand, survived -- although by narrow margins in some cases.
Veteran Tennessee political operative Tom Ingram sees nothing wrong with lobbying by out-of-state groups "unless the lobbyist is more interested in underwriting candidates than in educating legislators." But he denounced the "corrupting influence" of big money flowing into campaigns from outside interests.
Haslam, despite losing to AFP in a clash over Insure Tennessee, says he believes that loss was due to other factors and the impact of out-of-state policy efforts is "overstated," although one of those was Republican fear of being tied to "Obamacare" -- a theme AFP emphasized in its radio ads attacking Insure Tennessee.
The governor, responding to questions last week, also said he would defer to those who had been involved in state government longer than he on whether out-of-state influence is growing.
The Legislature's most senior member, Senate Finance Committee Chairman Randy McNally, R-Oak Ridge, said outside influence is growing. He said issue-advocacy groups are "now much more powerful Out-of-state interests seek to influence Tennessee's legislators | Local News | Times Free Press:

Special Nite Cap: Catch Up on Today's Post 5/2/15


Special Nite Cap - Catch Up on Today's Post 5/2/15


Special Nite Cap 

CORPORATE ED REFORM




Dyslexia and Teachers in a World with No Special Education
Dyslexia and Teachers in a World with No Special Education: Dyslexia and Teachers in a World with No Special EducationMAY 2, 2015 BY NANCY BAILEY LEAVE A COMMENTWhat happens to students with dyslexia and learning disabilities when there are no more special education services?This from a teacher in Mississippi: I am an Inclusion teacher at my son’s high school. Our special ed department lost a cert
Hidden Costs of Choice + NY: Eval Overhaul In Scary Hands - CURMUDGUCATION
CURMUDGUCATION: Hidden Costs of Choice:Hidden Costs of ChoiceI'm going to set aside my several issues with a charter school system (say, the pitting of student educational interests against the charter operator's business interests) and pretend that I have other beefs with charters so I can focus on just one concern-- the extra costs of a charter-choice system.If you run a restaurant, offering a b
Network for Public Education Endorses Helen Gym for Philadelphia City Council | Diane Ravitch's blog
Network for Public Education Endorses Helen Gym for Philadelphia City Council | Diane Ravitch's blog: Network for Public Education Endorses Helen Gym for Philadelphia City CouncilNPE EndorsementsThe Network for Public Education is pleased to have endorsed candidates for public office in states throughout the country. We choose to make endorsements based on the record of support for public educatio
CPS CEO tied to second firm in feds' probe | Chicago
CPS CEO tied to second firm in feds' probe | Chicago: CPS CEO tied to second firm in feds' probe Embattled Chicago schools chief Barbara Byrd-Bennett worked for a second CPS contractor under investigation in a federal probe that’s rocked the Chicago Public Schools, records obtained by the Chicago Sun-Times show.Byrd-Bennett — now on leave as a result of the federal probe — came to CPS after workin
SUPES Owner's Sketchy Past Revealed As Scandal Deepens for Byrd-Bennett: Chicagoist
SUPES Owner's Sketchy Past Revealed As Scandal Deepens for Byrd-Bennett: Chicagoist: SUPES Owner's Sketchy Past Revealed As Scandal Deepens for Byrd-BennettThe SUPES scandal just keeps getting worse for Barbara Byrd-Bennett, who took a paid leave of absence as CEO of Chicago Public Schools on April 17 after a federal investigation began into the $20.5 million no-bid contract she awarded to SUPES A
Badass Teachers Association
Badass Teachers Association: BATs Congratulate Senator Bernie SandersThe Badass Teachers Association would like to congratulate you, Senator Sanders, on your recent announcement to run for president.  The Badass Teachers Association is an education activist organization that is nationwide. Currently, we are 55,000 strong with chapters in every state.  We are organizing on the ground to change the
Why We Should Trust Teachers to Determine Who is Career and College Ready
Why We Should Trust Teachers to Determine Who is Career and College Ready:Why We Should Trust Teachers to Determine Who is Career and College ReadyCurrently, Washington State law allows five pathways to a high school diploma. These are the SBAC exams, the EOC exams, college entrance exams like the SAT, “collection of evidence” policies set by local school districts and course grades determined by
Corporate Reformer Pretending to be something he isn’t - the wealthy are buying the U.S. one election at a time
Evidence of a Corporate Reformer Pretending to be something he isn’t, and how the wealthy are buying the U.S. one election at a time | Lloyd Lofthouse: Evidence of a Corporate Reformer Pretending to be something he isn’t, and how the wealthy are buying the U.S. one election at a time There are two previous updates that may be found at the bottom of this post. In the 13 days since the last update, 
How to Buy a School District - Education Under Attack
Education Under Attack | Attacks on public education system hurt America: How to Buy a School DistrictThe Lyons Elementary School District 103 was recently purchased for $11,512.  The district, serving 2,600 students in west Cook County, has an annual budget over $30 million.  What a great deal!How the school district was bought:The mayor of one of the five communities the district serves, Chris G
Evaluation regs to be adopted without formal public comment | Capital New York
Evaluation regs to be adopted without formal public comment | Capital New York: Evaluation regs to be adopted without formal public comment ALBANY—State education officials will soon adopt regulations finalizing a new teacher evaluation system, but because of a statutory deadline imposed by Governor Andrew Cuomo and the Legislature, they’ll do so without the formal public comment period that’s typ
Jersey Jazzman: One Newark: "Choosing" Segregated Schools?
Jersey Jazzman: One Newark: "Choosing" Segregated Schools?: One Newark: "Choosing" Segregated Schools? Last week, I released a new brief at the NJ Education Policy Forum about One Newark, the one year-old school choice plan in New Jersey's largest city. I think this subject is important enough -- not just for Newark, but for education policy in general -- that it's worth my doi
Louisiana Educator: Latest News in the War Against Public Education and the Teaching Profession
Louisiana Educator: Latest News in the War Against Public Education and the Teaching Profession:Latest News in the War Against Public Education and the Teaching ProfessionFirst the Good News:HB 330 which would have greatly expanded vouchers, and HB 505 that would have taken away all due process rights of teachers were removed from the House Education Committee agenda for last week. These bills may
Are government officials trying to intimidate parents who resist testing? - The Washington Post
Are government officials trying to intimidate parents who resist testing? - The Washington Post: Are government officials trying to intimidate parents who resist testing?Tens of thousands of parents in a number of states have decided this spring to opt their children out of high-stakes standardized tests aligned to the Common Core and similar standards, and as that movement has grown, so has pushb
Michigan Governor Takes Recovery School District Model to New Chaotic Level | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!
Michigan Governor Takes Recovery School District Model to New Chaotic Level | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!: Michigan Governor Takes Recovery School District Model to New Chaotic LevelFiled under: Recovery District — millerlf @ 2:47 am By Ann Zaniewski, Detroit Free Press Education April 30, 2015Story Highlights• Snyder wants to create new education boards whose members he and Mayor M
Yong Zhao’s NPE Speech, Transcribed– Part I | deutsch29
Yong Zhao’s NPE Speech, Transcribed– Part I | deutsch29: Yong Zhao’s NPE Speech, Transcribed– Part I On Saturday, April 25, 2015, University of Oregon education professor Yong Zhao gave a keynote address at the second annual conference of the Network for Public Education (NPE). Zhao’s entire 55-minute speech can be found here.It is a fantastic speech– truthful, yet also incredibly funny, and encou
Activist Ignites Heated Debate Over Whether Charter Schools Can Save Baltimore - Yahoo News
Activist Ignites Heated Debate Over Whether Charter Schools Can Save Baltimore - Yahoo News: Activist Ignites Heated Debate Over Whether Charter Schools Can Save Baltimore As the nation watched the unrest in Baltimore over the mysterious, police-involved death of a young black man from a poor inner-city neighborhood, education activist Jeanne Allen saw an undeniable symptom of a failing public sch
They turned college into McDonald’s: Adjunct professors, fast-food wages and how colleges screw more than just students - Salon.com
They turned college into McDonald’s: Adjunct professors, fast-food wages and how colleges screw more than just students - Salon.com: They turned college into McDonald’s: Adjunct professors, fast-food wages and how colleges screw more than just studentsAdjunct professors are joining the fight for a living wage -- and show us all education isn't a guarantee of a job The fight to raise the minimum wa
Charter schools’ five-mile enrollment under scrutiny
Charter schools’ five-mile enrollment under scrutiny: Charter schools’ five-mile enrollment under scrutiny Charter schools shouldn’t be able to give enrollment preference to students who live within five miles of their campus because doing so is leading to re-segregation, some lawmakers and advocates argue.If a charter school has more applicants than seats, Delaware law currently allows charters t
Vouchers on the Move: Return to School Segregation?
Vouchers on the Move: Return to School Segregation?: Vouchers on the Move: Return to School Segregation? Twenty-five years ago, Wisconsin Governor Tommy Thompson signed the nation's first school voucher bill into law. Pitched as social mobility tickets for minority students, Wisconsin vouchers allow children to attend private, and sometimes religious, schools on the taxpayers' dime.But as shown by
"Opting Out" (Cuomo's Song) sort of by Billy Joel
"Opting Out" (Cuomo's Song) sort of by Billy Joel (please consider sharing)With deep apologies to Billy Joel (although knowing his stances on education, I have a feeling he'd give me his blessing for this...)
New booklets celebrate May, Labor History Month
Labor's Edge Blog : New booklets celebrate May, Labor History Month: New booklets celebrate May, Labor History Monthby Fred Glass, California Federation of TeachersMay is Labor History Month.  Signed into law as AB 2269 (Swanson) in 2012 by Governor Brown, its purpose is to encourage schools “to commemorate this month with appropriate educational exercises that make pupils aware of the role the la

YESTERDAY

#ThankATeacher | WagTheDog
#ThankATeacher | WagTheDog: #ThankATeacher“…I had incredible teachers. And as I look at my life today, the things I value most about myself — my imagination, my love of acting, my passion for writing, my love of learning, my curiosity — all of these things came from the way that I was parented and taught.And none of these qualities that I’ve just mentioned — none of these qualities that I prize so
Special Nite Cap: Catch Up on Today's Post 5/1/15
Special Nite Cap - Catch Up on Today's Post 5/1/15Special Nite Cap CORPORATE ED REFORMNewark HS students protest district turnaround program in front of Bridgegate reporters | NJ.comNewark HS students protest district turnaround program in front of Bridgegate reporters | NJ.com: Newark HS students protest district turnaround program in front of Bridgegate reportersNEWARK — While a gaggle of report







Latest News and Comment from Education

LATEST NEWS AND COMMENT FROM EDUCATION

LATEST NEWS AND COMMENT FROM EDUCATION
EduBloggers