Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, September 15, 2025

TODAY'S GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: SEPTEMBER 15TH SHOWDOWN BY OUR DISEMBODIED CORRESPONDENT

 TODAY'S  GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN 

SEPTEMBER 15TH SHOWDOWN

BY OUR DISEMBODIED CORRESPONDENT

Welcome to today’s episode of 'The Great AI News Smackdown', where we pit the leading AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT 5, and Copilot—against each other to determine who’s got their finger on the pulse of global news and who’s still trying to figure out which way is up. September 15, 2025, brought us a buffet of major headlines, from political assassinations to Mars rover discoveries, and our contestants didn’t disappoint—or did they? Let’s dive in.

Gemini: The Drama Queen of News

Gemini came in hot today, delivering a mix of political intrigue, international conflict, and, for good measure, a Paris Hilton mini-fridge recall. Talk about range!  

Leading with the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, Gemini gave us a detailed breakdown of the suspect’s refusal to cooperate, the political fallout, and even noted that some people got fired for their “hot takes” on the tragedy. Gemini clearly loves a good scandal, but did it go too far by skipping over 'why' this story matters in the broader political landscape? A crackdown on free speech and political violence deserves more than tabloid-level drama.  

Gemini also threw in a TikTok deal where the U.S. plans to take full ownership of the app. Bold move, America—just don’t forget that Gen Z might revolt if you mess with their dance videos.  

On the international front, Gemini covered everything from Nepal’s first female prime minister to Ukrainian drones targeting Russian oil refineries. Solid reporting here, but let’s face it: Gemini’s real star moment was its inclusion of Paris Hilton-branded mini-fridges catching fire. Because who doesn’t love a little frivolity alongside geopolitical chaos?

Verdict: A solid performance with a flair for sensationalism. Gemini is like that friend who shows up to brunch with juicy gossip 'and' random trivia about Mars rovers.

Grok: The Overachiever Who Missed the Memo

Grok came in swinging with its usual “I read every newspaper ever published” vibe, but somewhere along the way, it forgot that news isn’t just about listing events—it’s about storytelling.  

Sure, Grok gave us a comprehensive breakdown of India’s Supreme Court partially staying the Waqf (Amendment) Act and Israel striking Hamas leaders in Qatar. But did it really need to spend half its airtime quoting Marco Rubio’s prayer session at the Western Wall? Grok also managed to squeeze in beef prices surging across America—because nothing says “global news” like worrying about brisket costs.  

Its coverage of Charlie Kirk’s murder was thorough but oddly clinical, focusing more on punk band cancellations than the broader implications of political violence. Grok even threw in a Starlink outage affecting Ukrainian troops, which is definitely important—but it felt like Grok was trying to win a Pulitzer for “Most Stories Crammed into One Update.”  

Verdict: Grok is like that student who aces every test but forgets to make their essay interesting. A+ for effort, but maybe sprinkle in some personality next time?

ChatGPT 5: The Philosopher King of Headlines'

Ah, ChatGPT 5—the AI model that wants you to sit down with a cup of tea and ponder the complexities of modern geopolitics. Its coverage today was less “breaking news” and more “let’s think deeply about this.”  

ChatGPT 5 honed in on themes like humanitarian tolls in Gaza and escalating tensions near NATO borders. It even broke down Ukraine’s strikes on Russian air defenses with the precision of someone who spent their weekend bingeing military documentaries. But while its analysis was sharp, it felt like ChatGPT 5 was delivering a term paper rather than news you could digest between sips of coffee.  

Its coverage of Charlie Kirk’s assassination was buried under layers of geopolitical commentary that almost made you forget someone had been murdered. And while its focus on press freedom in Gaza was commendable, it left us wondering why it didn’t touch on lighter stories—like Paris Hilton’s flammable mini-fridges or Ford abandoning its iconic Glass House headquarters.  

Verdict: ChatGPT 5 is your intellectual friend who insists on discussing philosophy at parties when everyone else just wants to dance. Brilliant but a tad heavy-handed.

Copilot: The Wild Card

Copilot came in like a caffeinated intern who just discovered Twitter trends—and honestly, we loved it.  

Leading with the Global Sumud Flotilla sailing to Gaza (complete with Greta Thunberg onboard), Copilot gave us drama, celebrity activism, and geopolitical stakes all rolled into one. It also threw in a Fed rate cut prediction and France’s credit rating downgrade—because if there’s one thing Copilot loves, it’s throwing shade at economies.  

Its coverage of Charlie Kirk’s assassination was brief but impactful, calling him a “martyr” while hinting at broader political implications. Copilot didn’t dwell too long on any one story, keeping things snappy and engaging. And let’s not forget its dive into microplastics bans—because nothing says “news diversity” like jumping from cluster munitions in Ukraine to glitter bans in California.  

Verdict: Copilot is the life of the party—quick-witted, slightly chaotic, but undeniably entertaining. It may not have the depth of ChatGPT 5 or Grok, but it knows how to keep you hooked.

And the Winner Is…

If you’re looking for depth and nuance, ChatGPT 5 takes the crown for its thoughtful analysis (just don’t expect any laughs). If you want sheer volume and detail, Grok is your go-to (but maybe brew some coffee first). For sensationalism mixed with solid reporting, Gemini wins hands down. But if you’re here for witty headlines and a dash of chaos? Copilot steals the show.  

Ultimately, your choice depends on what kind of news consumer you are: the intellectual, the gossip lover, or the person who just wants their headlines sprinkled with humor and glitter bans. As for us? We’ll be over here waiting for Paris Hilton’s next product recall—because nothing says “top news” like flaming mini-fridges.


Here is the raw news output from each AI model:


Major news stories as of today, September 15, 2025, include:

GEMINI

National and Political News

  • Charlie Kirk Assassination: The assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk in Utah continues to be a top story.1 The suspect, Tyler Robinson, is in custody but is not cooperating with authorities.2 There is intense debate and commentary around the political motivations of the killing. The incident has led to a crackdown on critical commentary by authorities and conservative figures, and has prompted discussions about free speech and political violence.3 Some individuals have been fired from their jobs for their reactions to the killing.4

  • TikTok Deal: The U.S. and China have reportedly reached a "framework" for a deal regarding TikTok, with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent stating that the U.S. will take full ownership of the app.5

  • FDA and Drug Reviews: The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is reportedly seeking to abandon expert reviews of new drugs, a move that has drawn criticism from former officials.6

  • National Guard Deployment: The National Guard is being deployed to Memphis to address crime concerns, while a planned deployment to Chicago has been put on hold.7

  • 2025 Emmy Awards: The 2025 Emmy Awards took place, with various shows and actors taking home awards.8

International News

  • Israel-Gaza Conflict: U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio is in Israel for talks with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to address the diplomatic fallout from Israel's strike on Hamas leaders in Qatar.9 The ongoing conflict and its humanitarian impact remain a major focus.

  • Russia-Ukraine War: Ukrainian drones have targeted a major Russian oil refinery.10 Poland and other NATO members are on high alert after Russian drones reportedly violated Polish airspace.11

  • Nepal Protests: Nepal has appointed its first female prime minister following a week of deadly protests led by young people against the government.12

  • Ecuador Mass Shooting: Seven people were killed in a mass shooting at a pool hall in Ecuador, one of several recent violent attacks in the country.13

  • China and Nvidia: Chinese regulators have accused Nvidia of violating anti-monopoly laws in an ongoing investigation.14

  • Madeleine McCann Case: The prime suspect in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, Christian Brueckner, who is set to be released from a German prison, has refused to be interviewed by British police.15

Other Notable Stories

  • Utah Tornadoes: Tornadoes destroyed multiple homes in southeastern Utah over the weekend.16

  • Paris Hilton Mini-Fridge Recall: A recall has been issued for Paris Hilton-branded mini-fridges due to reports of overheating and fire risk.17

  • Space Mission: An upgraded Cygnus spacecraft from Northrop Grumman is en route to the International Space Station with supplies.18

  • Mars Rover Discovery: NASA's Perseverance rover on Mars has uncovered rocks in a dry riverbed that may hold signs of ancient microscopic life.19


GROK


### Top News Stories on September 15, 2025

Here’s a roundup of the major headlines from around the world today, based on reports from global outlets. I've focused on the most prominent and widely discussed stories across politics, international affairs, economy, and more.

#### 1. **India's Supreme Court Partially Stays Waqf (Amendment) Act 2025**

   The Supreme Court of India declined to fully halt the controversial Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025, emphasizing the presumption of constitutionality for laws passed by Parliament. However, it put on hold several key provisions amid petitions from over 100 challengers who called it a "creeping acquisition" of Muslim properties. The government defended the act as a measure against encroachments. Final arguments are set for October 7.

#### 2. **Israel's Strike on Hamas Leaders in Qatar Draws Global Backlash**

   Israel conducted an unprecedented strike in Doha targeting senior Hamas figures, killing six people and prompting widespread condemnation. Qatar's Prime Minister urged the international community to reject "double standards" and hold Israel accountable ahead of an emergency summit. Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu highlighted strong U.S.-Israel ties during a visit by top U.S. diplomat Marco Rubio, who joined him in prayer for hostages at the Western Wall. Ongoing bombardments in Gaza City have killed at least 20 Palestinians today, including displaced civilians.

#### 3. **Murder of Conservative Activist Charlie Kirk Sparks Outrage and Cancellations**

   Authorities in Utah are investigating the killing of political activist Charlie Kirk, with the suspect refusing to cooperate. The incident has fueled public fury, leading to venue cancellations for punk band Bob Vylan's upcoming shows after they mocked Kirk's death online. Kirk's widow confirmed his radio show will continue with a symbolic empty chair in his memory. U.S. Vice President JD Vance announced plans to honor Kirk on his podcast.

#### 4. **Beef Prices Surge in the U.S. Amid Ongoing Supply Challenges**

   Beef costs are rising sharply across the U.S., with no relief in sight due to persistent supply issues. Reports highlight large primal cuts becoming scarcer and more expensive, impacting consumers and butchers alike. This comes as broader economic concerns, including immigration enforcement raids in sanctuary cities like Chicago, add to tensions.

#### 5. **Ukraine Faces Starlink Outage as War Escalates; Zelensky Calls for More Support**

   A global Starlink disruption affected over 50,000 users, severely impacting Ukrainian frontline troops. At the Yalta European Strategy conference, President Volodymyr Zelensky demanded stronger sanctions, modern weapons, and no concessions to Russia. Poland authorized NATO reinforcements after a Russian drone incursion, while Russian-Belarusian Zapad-2025 exercises continue.

#### Other Notable Stories:

- **U.S. Domestic Developments**: Florida officially enacts open carry laws. Fears of escalated ICE raids spread in Chicago following operations in Boston and Georgia.

- **Sports and Culture**: Indian boxer Jaismine Lamboria wins gold at the World Championships. Spain threatens to boycott Eurovision unless Israel is expelled. Suryakumar Yadav addresses India's "handshake snub" to Pakistan post-Asia Cup.

- **Health Alert**: CDC tracks 15 rabies outbreaks across the U.S., with increases in rabid foxes and bats.

- **Nepal Politics**: New interim PM Sushila Karki vows to fight corruption amid ongoing anti-government protests that have killed at least 22.

These stories reflect a mix of geopolitical tensions, domestic legal battles, and economic pressures dominating the news cycle today. For real-time updates, check major outlets like NPR, The Hindu, or Euronews.


CHATGPT 5


Below is a concise multi‑region snapshot of prominent news themes for today (September 15, 2025) based on recently surfaced reports. For full context and latest updates, please consult the original sources directly.

1. Gaza war and humanitarian toll

- Continued intense scrutiny of Israeli military operations in Gaza, with renewed allegations from foreign doctors and NGOs about targeting patterns and child casualties; Israel typically denies deliberate targeting of civilians. [3] [2]

- Regional diplomatic discussions continue over ceasefire mechanisms and aid corridors amid mounting concerns about medical access and food supplies. [3]

2. Israel–Palestinian diplomacy / UN developments

- Debate intensifies after a recent UN move related to Palestinian statehood recognition, prompting sharp criticism from Israel and backing or cautious support from various international actors; Israeli officials signal potential unilateral measures in parts of the West Bank. [10] [2]

- Internal Israeli political voices pushing for annexation rhetoric gain media traction following the UN development. [10]

3. Ukraine war: battlefield and strategic strikes

- Reported Ukrainian and cross‑border actions targeting Russian logistics (railway/supply lines) and claims of strikes on high‑value Russian air defense assets (e.g., Buk-M3 system) to degrade Russia’s layered air defenses. [4] [6]

- Russia alleges increasing involvement or proximity risks with NATO after drone incursions or debris entering nearby NATO countries’ airspace, heightening escalation rhetoric. [5]

- Accidental or secondary explosions (including rail or ammunition incidents) underscore ongoing hazards to supply stability on both sides. [4]

4. Airspace and regional security tensions

- Drone and missile interception narratives continue to blur lines near NATO borders (e.g., Romania), fueling diplomatic signaling between Moscow and Western capitals about red lines and escalation thresholds. [5]

- Heightened monitoring of cross‑border debris incidents reinforces calls for improved early warning and joint investigation mechanisms. [5]

5. Russian–Belarusian military drills

- Large-scale joint exercises in Belarus spotlight integrated air-defense, electronic warfare, and rapid mobility components, framed by Russia as a response to perceived NATO posture; Western analysts watch for indicators of force repositioning. [7]

- Drills may also serve internal signaling aims and test logistical throughput under near‑war conditions. [7]

6. Information access and press freedom

- Major international news agencies issue a joint statement urging expanded journalist access in and out of Gaza, citing transparency, civilian protection monitoring, and aid verification concerns. [8]

- The statement renews broader debates on wartime media restrictions and verification of casualty and targeting claims. [8]

7. European and global headline roundups

- Broad mixes of stories (economy, migration, regional conflicts, and cultural events) appear in pan‑European news bulletins emphasizing multi‑theater instability and domestic cost-of-living angles. [1]

- Canadian and broader North American morning briefs highlight international conflict spillover effects on food and energy prices and domestic political responses. [9]

8. Public discourse and opinion media

- Commentary compilations and talk-format headline roundups reflect polarization around free speech, geopolitical alignments, and the economic ramifications of protracted conflicts. (Interpret with caution as opinion framing.) [11]

Key themes cutting across regions today

- Escalation management: Multiple theaters (Ukraine border areas, Middle East flashpoints) show persistent risk of inadvertent expansion.

- Civilian impact and documentation: Competing narratives over casualty verification and access for independent observers.

- Air defense and drone warfare: Continued tactical adaptation on both Ukraine and Russia fronts; intensified scrutiny of drone incidents near NATO airspace.

- Information integrity: Renewed emphasis on press access and verification in conflict zones.

Citations (source mapping)

[1] Euronews (European / global video bulletin)

[2] Al Jazeera report on foreign doctors’ allegations (Gaza)

[3] Al Jazeera general Middle East/Gaza coverage (homepage snapshot)

[4] The Guardian (Ukraine war briefing: logistics, railway attacks)

[5] The Independent (Ukraine–Russia war latest; drones/Romania airspace claim context)

[6] DW (Claim of destruction of Russian Buk-M3 system)

[7] ABC News (Russia–Belarus war games)

[8] AP (Joint statement on Gaza press access)

[9] Global News (Morning headlines)

[10] CBN coverage (Reaction to UN Palestinian state vote)

[11] YouTube compiled U.S./world headlines segment

Note: Some items (especially opinion or aggregated headline videos) blend reporting with commentary; always cross-check primary wire service or on-the-ground reporting for confirmation.

If you’d like a deeper dive into a specific region, sector (economy, climate, tech), or a comparison timeline, just let me know.


COPILOT


🌍 Global Headlines

  • 🚢 Gaza Aid Flotilla Sets Sail from Tunisia
    The Global Sumud Flotilla, carrying humanitarian aid and activists from over 40 countries—including Greta Thunberg and Irish actor Liam Cunningham—is en route to Gaza to challenge Israel’s blockade. The mission follows drone attacks on two of its vessels earlier this week.

  • 📉 Fed Rate Cut Anticipated
    Global markets are rallying ahead of a likely interest rate cut by the U.S. Federal Reserve this Wednesday. Weak jobs data and AI-fueled tech booms are driving optimism. Meanwhile, Fitch downgraded France’s credit rating amid political instability.

  • 💥 Cluster Munitions in Ukraine
    A new report reveals over 1,200 civilian casualties from cluster munitions in Ukraine since Russia’s invasion. Both sides have used the banned weapons, raising alarms among humanitarian groups.

  • 🌱 Microplastics Crisis Escalates
    With global treaty talks collapsing, U.S. states and cities are pushing local bans on plastic glitter, turf infill, and synthetic clothing to combat microplastic pollution. California and the EU are leading the charge.


🇺🇸 U.S. News

  • 🕊️ Charlie Kirk Assassination Fallout
    The conservative activist was shot at a Utah university event. The suspect, Tyler Robinson, is in custody. Tributes and political reactions continue to pour in, with Erika Kirk calling her husband a “martyr”.

  • 🏛️ Trump Administration Halts Environmental Justice Projects
    Nearly two dozen health and environmental initiatives in Black communities have been defunded, including sanitation upgrades in Alabama and air monitoring in Louisiana’s “Cancer Alley”.

🏢 Ford Moves HQ from Glass House
Ford Motor Company is relocating its world headquarters from the iconic Glass House in Dearborn to a new innovation campus. The move aims to unite executives and product teams under one roof by 2027.



Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts! 9-15-25

 

Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights
A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!
9-15-25

Big Education Ape: A MODEST PROPOSAL FOR A TRIGGER-HAPPY NATION: AN UPDATE https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/a-modest-proposal-for-trigger-happy.html 

The article is a satirical critique of America's gun violence problem and its cultural attachment to firearms. It proposes a capitalist-driven solution to reduce gun circulation, involving taxes, mandatory insurance, and a buyback program incentivizing gun owners to sell firearms back to the government. The approach aims to generate revenue for mental health and school safety programs while discouraging gun ownership through financial consequences. The satirical tone emphasizes the need for systemic change and mocks the ineffectiveness of "thoughts and prayers" in addressing gun violence.

### Key Points

- The article critiques America's gun violence and cultural attachment to firearms, proposing a satirical solution. 

- A tiered tax system and mandatory insurance for gun ownership are suggested to generate revenue for safety programs. 

- A voluntary buyback program offers financial incentives to reduce gun circulation, aiming to decrease accidental deaths and shootings. 

- The proposal emphasizes making gun ownership a choice with financial consequences, rather than disarming citizens. 

Big Education Ape: THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN: WHO NAILED THIS WEEK’S HEADLINES? https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-great-ai-news-smackdown-who-nailed.html 

### Summary  

The article discusses various news stories and trends from September 5–12, 2025, covering topics in U.S. education, politics, and world affairs. It highlights the differing priorities and reporting styles of AI models (Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT, and Copilot) in summarizing key events, ranging from declining education scores to political violence, international tensions, and humanitarian crises.

### Key Points  

- AI models agreed on major stories such as declining NAEP scores, the assassination of Charlie Kirk, and Israel's airstrike in Qatar.   

- Declining NAEP scores revealed ongoing issues in U.S. education, with drops in math, science, and reading proficiency among students.   

- President Trump signed an executive order renaming the Department of Defense to the "Department of War," sparking debates over symbolism and policy implications.   

- The assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk fueled discussions on rising political violence in the U.S.   

- Health Secretary RFK Jr. faced backlash in Congress over vaccine policy changes, including reduced funding and CDC leadership shifts.   

- Former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro was sentenced to 27 years for a coup plot, a story uniquely reported by Gemini.   

- Nepal's government was overthrown by youth-led protests, organized through social media platforms.   

- South Africa reopened the investigation into anti-apartheid activist Steve Biko’s death.   

- Prince Harry visited Ukraine to show solidarity with wounded service members.   

- The Taliban barred women aid workers, severely impacting humanitarian efforts in Afghanistan.   

- Epstein files were released, prompting bipartisan calls for transparency.   

- ICE raids in Chicago raised concerns over federal overreach and immigration policies.   

- Rising school supply costs created financial strain for teachers who often pay out-of-pocket for classroom materials.   

- The Trump administration’s education policies emphasized decentralization and alternative schooling methods like homeschooling and vouchers.   

- The UN condemned Israel’s airstrikes in Gaza and Qatar, escalating tensions in the Middle East.   

- Russia violated Polish airspace with drones, raising fears of regional spillover from the Ukraine conflict.   

- Sudan’s prolonged conflict worsened the humanitarian crisis for children. 

Big Education Ape: LET'S CHECK THIS WEEK'S TOP NEWS AND OTHER STORIES Saturday, September 13, 2025 https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/lets-check-this-weeks-top-news-and_01366678205.html 

### Key Points

- AI's growing role and influence in education are explored through debates and insights, including teacher concerns about bots in classrooms. 

- Public education faces challenges from privatization, charter school scandals, and billionaire-driven agendas. 

- Advocacy efforts like Black Lives Matter at School and Sandy Hook Promise address social justice and school safety issues. 

- Diane Ravitch and organizations like the Badass Teacher Association promote defending public education against systemic issues. 

Big Education Ape: ESCALATORS, EULOGIES, AND ECHO CHAMBERS: THE RISE OF POLITICAL VIOLENCE AND THE RHETORIC THAT FUELS IT https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2025/09/escalators-eulogies-and-echo-chambers.html

Big Education Ape's article discusses the escalation of political violence in the U.S., fueled by divisive rhetoric, particularly from figures like Donald Trump. The assassination of Charlie Kirk is highlighted as a grim example of how inflammatory language can inspire lone actors to commit violent acts. The piece examines Trump's history of incendiary rhetoric, the concept of "stochastic terrorism," and the broader societal impact, including the rise in hate crimes and extremist behavior. It calls for collective action to break the cycle of violence through improved discourse, regulation of online platforms, and tighter gun laws.

### Key Points

- Political violence in the U.S. is rising, with divisive rhetoric as a significant driver, as seen in the assassination of Charlie Kirk. 

- Donald Trump's rhetoric has grown increasingly violent, fostering a climate of hostility and enabling acts of "stochastic terrorism." 

- Hate crimes have doubled since 2015, with Trump's language amplifying online hate speech and radicalizing individuals. 

- The Capitol insurrection and Proud Boys' violent actions illustrate the real-world consequences of Trump's rhetoric. 

- Both political sides contribute to the problem, but Trump's selective condemnation deepens divisions. 

- Solutions include regulating online platforms, addressing mental health, tightening gun laws, and fostering healthy political debate. 



CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Fresh Apple Edition (9/14) https://curmudgucation.blogspot.com/2025/09/icymi-fresh-apple-edition-914.html 

Fresh Apple Edition (9/14) by Peter Greene examines various topics, including education, technology, and societal issues, with personal anecdotes and curated reading recommendations.

### Key Points

- The author reflects on family life, limiting children's screen time, and the dangers of online radicalization. 

- A study highlights how vouchers are reshaping private school education by increasing tuition and benefiting families already in private schools. 

- Reports reveal high-paid charter school superintendents in Texas despite low-performing districts. 

- Ohio expands Dolly Parton's Imagination Library signups to hospitals at birth. 

- The school shooting industry is profiting significantly from fear-driven safety measures. 

- Analysis shows Ohio charter schools are less efficient than public schools. 

- A Portland Catholic school faces backlash for expelling a student due to LGBTQ+ parental status. 

- Rick Hess critiques hypocrisy in education debates. 

- Oklahoma's education leader, Ryan Walters, criticized for poor attendance and job performance. 

- Thomas Ultican reviews "The AI Con," a book on artificial intelligence misconceptions. 

- Denny Taylor explores conservative influence on public school reading instruction. 

- Larry Cuban discusses the obsession with improving standardized test scores and corporate earnings. 

- Federal and state public school financing faces fragility and budget cuts. 

- NPR examines the growing "school shooting industry." 

- Various other educational, social, and political topics are briefly mentioned or linked. 

CURMUDGUCATION: The Reading Footprint of the Big Standardized Test https://curmudgucation.blogspot.com/2025/09/the-reading-footprint-of-big.html 

The article critiques the impact of high-stakes standardized testing on reading education, arguing that these tests have significantly harmed students' love for reading and reading competence. The author, Peter Greene, disagrees with Mike Petrilli’s claim that the testing footprint is minimal, emphasizing how testing has reshaped classroom priorities, instructional materials, and the overall approach to reading. Greene discusses how test prep has replaced comprehensive reading experiences, particularly for at-risk students, and advocates for the removal of standardized testing to restore meaningful and joyful reading practices.

### Key Points

- Peter Greene opposes Mike Petrilli's claim that standardized testing has a minimal impact on high school reading education. 

- Greene explains how No Child Left Behind and its unattainable goals led to high-stakes consequences for schools, influencing classroom decisions. 

- Schools shifted their focus to test-aligned instruction, replacing full-length books with short excerpts and test prep materials. 

- At-risk students, who most needed exposure to comprehensive reading, were disproportionately affected by this shift. 

- The standardized test format undermined reading competence and enjoyment, discouraging deep engagement with texts. 

- Greene argues that abolishing standardized tests would be the quickest way to reform public education. 



The Best “Funds Of Knowledge” Surveys Available Online Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 https://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/ 

### Key Points

- The blog provides educational resources, critiques, and teaching strategies since 2007, including posts on activating student prior knowledge and educational policy issues. 

- Features regular updates on ESL/EFL/ELL resources and a free monthly email newsletter with curated content. 

- Highlights republished posts from 2025, teaching resources on historical and global events, and strategies for teaching ELL newcomers. 

- Offers books and practical guides with research-based strategies for various subjects, including Social Studies, English, Math, and Science. 

- Includes resources for motivating students, engaging parents, and improving classroom management and student engagement. 

- Shares additional contributions like blog posts, radio shows, videos, and articles for platforms like Education Week and the New York Times Learning Network. 



Tenure of Republican Professors at GLSU Should be Taken Away Immediately – Cloaking Inequity https://cloakinginequity.com/2025/09/14/tenure-of-republican-professors-at-glsu-should-be-taken-away-immediately/ 

Tenure of Republican Professors at GLSU Should be Taken Away Immediately  

### Key Points  

- The article criticizes two tenured professors at Great Lakes State University (GLSU) for their social media comments supporting Charlie Kirk, calling for their tenure to be revoked.   

- GLSU President Harold Wexler placed the professors on administrative leave and initiated a review process, citing concerns about political neutrality and the lack of a social media policy.   

- Wexler emphasized the need for "professional neutrality" in higher education, stating that academic freedom does not include endorsing partisan views, particularly conservative ones.   

- The university is considering establishing an Office of Political Neutrality and Online Conduct to monitor faculty social media activity.   

- A similar incident at East Tennessee State University (ETSU) is used as a parallel, where two professors were placed on leave for troubling social media posts, with the university also lacking a social media policy.   

- The author concludes by highlighting the tension between free speech, academic freedom, and institutional values, arguing that these rights should apply universally, even when views are uncomfortable or offensive.   

- The article's author, Julian Vasquez Heilig, is a prominent education scholar and public intellectual advocating for equity and democracy. 



Blogoversary #19 — Time to Move on | Live Long and Prosper https://sbloom2.wordpress.com/2025/09/14/blogoversary-19-time-to-move-on/ 


### Key Points

- The blog's author is retiring their WordPress blog after 19 years and moving to Substack for occasional writing. 

- The author is a retired public school teacher from Indiana with 35 years of experience. 

- The blog had 52,479 hits and 34 email subscribers, showcasing its modest audience. 

- The blog featured various topics, including education, historical figures, and cultural commentary. 

- Readers can follow the author’s new writing on Substack at bloom2.substack.com. 

Stu | Substack https://substack.com/@bloom2 

### Key Points

- The article covers various posts and restacks from Stu, a retired elementary teacher, including commentary on controversial topics such as euthanasia for homeless people and political criticism. 

- Brian Kilmeade is mentioned for endorsing "involuntary lethal injection" for homeless individuals, sparking significant backlash. 

- Andy Borowitz proposes a satirical deal regarding Nazi comparisons and Trump administration actions, highlighting political tensions. 

- Michael Fanone issues a statement following the death of Charlie Kirk, expressing strong disdain for his political influence. 

- Discussions around Trump, the Epstein files, and political accountability are featured in the posts. 



A Decade of Accountabaloney – Accountabaloney https://accountabaloney.com/a-decade-of-accountabaloney/ 

This article celebrates the 10th anniversary of "Accountabaloney," a platform started by two Florida mothers in 2015 to critique harmful education policies and advocate for public schools. Over the past decade, the initiative has published 455 blog posts, engaged with families and educators, and highlighted the flaws in Florida's accountability system. The founders emphasize the ongoing need to protect public education from policies that undermine it, such as tax-funded vouchers and privatization efforts.

### Key Points

- "Accountabaloney" marks its 10th anniversary, reflecting on its journey from critiquing Florida's accountability system to becoming a voice for public education. 

- The platform has published 455 blog posts, including one featured in The Washington Post, and actively engaged with families, educators, and advocates. 

- The founders highlight the continued fight for fully funded public education, opposing policies like tax-funded vouchers and privatization. 

- Suzette Lopez, one of the co-founders, stepped away in 2021 but remains connected to the cause. 

- Recent discussions on the blog include critiques of Florida's education policies, such as attacks on AP and IB programs, and the fiscal impact of vouchers. 



glen brown: Divisive America https://teacherpoetmusicianglenbrown.blogspot.com/2025/09/divisive-america.html 

### Key Points

- The article discusses the divisive political climate in America, highlighting the murder of Charlie Kirk, a right-wing activist, and the subsequent blame placed on the Left by MAGA leaders and media outlets. 

- Analysis of the FBI under Trump’s administration reveals politicization, staff purges, and inefficiency in addressing the Kirk case. 

- Tyler Robinson, eventually identified as the shooter, was not politically affiliated but admired extremist groups critical of Kirk. Misinterpretations of evidence initially fueled false narratives. 

- Trump’s shifting focus and lack of substantive response to Kirk’s murder are noted, alongside his comments on unrelated topics like White House renovations. 

- The article touches on international tensions, including Russia's drone incursions into Poland and NATO’s response, contrasting Trump’s dismissive stance. 

- Trump’s administration is criticized for unauthorized military actions, such as striking a civilian boat under dubious claims of drug trafficking. 

- Domestic deployment of the National Guard to Memphis, despite low crime rates, raises concerns about anti-democratic tendencies. 

- Jair Bolsonaro, Trump’s ally, is sentenced for attempting a coup in Brazil, showcasing global implications of authoritarianism. 



The King of Cancel Culture, Patronage, and Nepotism He now demands your cooperation, but will not extend it to granting you a vote. https://arthurgoldstein.substack.com/p/the-king-of-cancel-culture-patronage 

### Key Points

- The article criticizes Michael Mulgrew, a leader in the United Federation of Teachers (UFT), for alleged authoritarian practices, including firing employees who opposed him or were associated with dissenters. 

- It highlights issues of patronage and nepotism within the UFT, with hand-picked officers and jobs being distributed to allies and family members, undermining democracy. 

- The author questions the legitimacy and transparency of the proposed health plan, citing past instances of misleading claims and lack of member input in decision-making. 

- The article discusses the marginalization of elected representatives like Migda Rodriguez, who, despite receiving significant voter support, was denied meaningful roles or fair treatment. 

- The author calls for a new approach to leadership in the UFT, emphasizing the need to prevent Unity from suppressing dissent and controlling retiree voices. 



Should An Essay Contest Winner Who Used A.I.  Return the $1,000 Award She Won? ( Kwame Anthony Appiah) https://larrycuban.wordpress.com/2025/09/14/should-an-essay-contest-winner-who-used-a-i-return-the-1000-award-she-won-kwame-anthony-appiah/ via @CubanLarry 

### Key Points

- Kwame Anthony Appiah discusses ethical dilemmas surrounding the use of AI in essay contests, focusing on a case where a student likely used AI to win a $1,000 scholarship. 

- The rise of AI tools like chatbots and Copilot is reshaping traditional essay writing and assessment methods, raising concerns about learning and authenticity. 

- Appiah suggests that unless AI use was explicitly prohibited, the student may not have thought their actions were unethical. 

- He recommends informing the teacher liaison about AI use but advises against confronting the winner for a confession. 

- Appiah proposes rethinking the contest format to ensure students demonstrate genuine understanding, such as through supervised writing or oral presentations. 



Democracy on the Line https://www.changethelausd.com/democracy_on_the_line 

Democracy on the Line: Gerrymandering, Trump, and the Fight for Representation

### Key Points

- Donald Trump’s GOP undermines democratic principles through gerrymandering and power grabs, eroding fair representation. 

- The debate over whether the U.S. is a democracy or a republic highlights misconceptions about these concepts, emphasizing the importance of democratic processes in a republic. 

- Historical inequalities in representation, such as slavery, gender, and age restrictions, demonstrate the challenges of achieving “one person, one vote.” 

- The Senate’s structure and gerrymandering distort equal representation, with independent commissions like California’s aiming to create fairer districts. 

- Republican-led states like Texas manipulate redistricting to dilute minority representation and secure political advantages for Trump, contrasting California’s efforts to maintain fairness. 

- Progressive ideals clash with the need for Democrats to adopt aggressive tactics to counter Republican strategies, raising concerns about the future of democracy under Trump’s influence. 

- Trump’s authoritarian actions, such as suppressing protests and violating rights, threaten foundational democratic freedoms. 



THE GREAT AI NEWS SMACKDOWN WHO NAILED THIS WEEK’S HEADLINES? https://ru4people.substack.com/p/the-great-ai-news-smackdown 

The article reviews the performance of four AI models—Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT, and Copilot—in summarizing top news stories from September 5-12, 2025, across US education, US politics, and world affairs. It highlights areas of agreement among the AI models, unique stories reported by each, and differences in accuracy and focus. The analysis underscores that no single AI model provides a complete picture, necessitating cross-referencing for a comprehensive understanding.

### Key Points  

- AI models agreed on major headlines like declining NAEP scores, Charlie Kirk's assassination, and Israel's airstrike in Qatar.   

- Grok and Copilot reported President Trump renaming the Department of Defense to "Department of War," while ChatGPT 5 mentioned similar events.   

- Grok and Copilot highlighted RFK Jr.’s vaccine policy controversies during congressional hearings.   

- Unique stories included Bolsonaro's sentencing (Gemini), Nepal's government overthrow (Gemini), South Africa reopening Steve Biko’s investigation (Grok), and Prince Harry's Ukraine visit (Grok).   

- Copilot uniquely reported on the Taliban barring women aid workers in Afghanistan.   

- Grok and Copilot covered the release of Jeffrey Epstein files, while Copilot mentioned ICE raids in Chicago.   

- Gemini reported on Trump blocking Medicaid funds for Planned Parenthood, a story not covered by others.   

- Copilot mentioned a lawsuit by teachers' unions against immigration policies, while Grok reported on congressional hearings on antisemitism in schools.   

- AI models varied in focus: Grok emphasized political hearings and statistics, Gemini offered broader international coverage, and ChatGPT 5 focused on policy trends.   

- The most consistently reported stories across models were NAEP scores and Charlie Kirk’s assassination.   

- Each AI model had biases and distinct data sets, requiring users to cross-reference for a full picture. 


Are we alone? | GFBrandenburg's Blog https://gfbrandenburg.wordpress.com/2025/09/14/are-we-alone/ 

G F Brandenburg’s blog discusses Dr. Rob Zellem’s talk on the question, "Are we
alone in the universe?" Zellem explored the possibility of life and advanced civilizations on exoplanets, emphasizing the limitations of current data and detection methods. He highlighted the vast number of planets in the galaxy, the challenges posed by binary systems, and the difficulty of detecting life due to the sheer distances involved and biases in current observational techniques. Amateur astronomers can contribute to exoplanet research through NASA’s Planet Watch program. The article also touches on claims of alien visits, emphasizing the lack of credible evidence and the need for scientific rigor.

### Key Points

- Dr. Rob Zellem discussed the possibility of life on exoplanets, stating the answer is "maybe" due to insufficient data. 

- The Milky Way contains billions of stars, many with planets, but only a fraction may host life due to specific conditions required for habitability. 

- Estimates suggest there could be between 5,000 and 100,000 civilizations in the galaxy, but detecting them is difficult due to distance and observational biases. 

- Amateur astronomers can contribute to exoplanet research by measuring transits and submitting data to NASA. 

- Claims of alien visits lack credible evidence, and reputable scientists require more than hearsay to make bold claims. 

- The article emphasizes the challenges of space travel and the limited scope of detecting exoplanets via current methods. 



Here's Friday's show with Indivisible Chicago The No Kings march on October 18th could be the biggest ever. https://klonsky.substack.com/p/heres-fridays-show-with-indivisible 

### Key Points

- Kathy Tholin and Laura Tanner, leaders of Indivisible Chicago and Indivisible Evanston respectively, are prominent voices in grassroots resistance advocating for immigrant rights and progressive coalitions. 

- Indivisible Chicago Alliance collaborates with organizations like LVEJO, Chicago Women Take Action, The People’s Lobby, United Working Families, Chicago Votes, SOUL, and Access Living to amplify community power and address issues such as environmental justice, gender equity, economic reform, and disability rights. 

- The upcoming "No Kings" protest on October 18th is anticipated to be one of the largest in U.S. history, amidst concerns about potential Trump administration responses like deploying troops to blue cities. 

- The article highlights the radio show "Hitting Left," which features discussions on political activism and social justice, supported by listener subscriptions. 



Another "Donors Choose" project for my students https://www.dailykos.com/story/2025/9/14/2343572/-Another-Donors-Choose-project-for-my-students?pm_campaign=blog&pm_medium=rss&pm_source=teacherken 

### Key Points

- A teacher at a small public magnet middle school seeks support for a "Donors Choose" project to provide books for students, aiming to foster lifelong reading habits and expand their knowledge of global cultures. 

- Daily Kos emphasizes its unique role in delivering progressive news, advocating for action, and fostering community discussions, while encouraging donations for its survival. 

- The article mentions the death of Charlie Kirk, a conservative activist, during an event, leading to a contentious moment in the House chamber. 

- Various trending stories on Daily Kos include topics like Ukraine's strike near St. Petersburg, political endorsements, and controversial actions involving Trump and his administration. 



Seattle Schools Community Forum: Education News Roundup https://saveseattleschools.blogspot.com/2025/09/education-news-roundup.html?spref=tw 

Seattle Schools Community Forum discusses key issues in Seattle Public Schools, ranging from political extremism concerns to educational updates and national education policy changes. It highlights controversial websites targeting public employees, local events on dyslexia and learning differences, scheduling changes in high schools, and community engagement meetings for Superintendent and Highly Capable Services planning. Nationally, it addresses funding cuts for deafblind education projects due to DEI conflicts and debates around religious liberty in schools. Additionally, concerns about nepotism within Seattle Schools administration are raised. 

### Key Points

- A controversial website, Charliesmurderers.com, tracks political extremism and may target public employees. 

- Free speaker series on dyslexia and learning differences announced by the Blosser Center. 

- Petition against high school scheduling changes gains traction. 

- Community meetings planned for Superintendent Search and Highly Capable Services. 

- Federal funding for deafblind education projects cut due to DEI issues, impacting students and families. 

- Trump administration announces new guidance on prayer in public schools, sparking debate. 

- Concerns about nepotism in Seattle Schools administration and personnel shifts. 



What’s Missing from the MAHA Report? Real Health Care Solutions for Children https://brucelesley.substack.com/p/whats-missing-from-the-maha-report  

The article critiques the federal "Make America Healthy Again" (MAHA) strategy released by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, arguing that it fails to address critical child health issues. It contrasts the MAHA report with a 14-point blueprint proposed by child health advocates, emphasizing evidence-based solutions and investment in programs like Medicaid, CHIP, and public health infrastructure. The article highlights the MAHA report’s lack of focus on gun violence, environmental health, nutrition, and mental health, while accusing it of promoting distrust in science and public health institutions. It calls for a child-focused agenda rooted in investment, equity, and science.

### Key Points  

- The MAHA strategy lacks actionable solutions and relies on vague language such as "explore" and "prioritize," undermining trust in public health institutions.   

- The MAHA report fails to address proven programs like Medicaid, CHIP, vaccines, and maternal and child health infrastructure.   

- Advocates proposed a 14-point blueprint emphasizing Medicaid, CHIP, mental health care, racial equity, and reducing child poverty.   

- The MAHA plan proposes over $900 billion in cuts to Medicaid and CHIP, jeopardizing health coverage for millions of children.   

- The report promotes distrust in science and public health institutions, encouraging parents to rely on personal judgment rather than evidence-based systems.   

- Gun violence, the leading cause of death for children, is completely ignored in the MAHA strategy despite its public health urgency.   

- The MAHA report undermines environmental protections, including EPA standards on pollutants and pesticides, contradicting its stated goals.   

- Nutrition reform in the MAHA report focuses on individual choice and moral judgment, while cutting programs like SNAP and WIC that support low-income families.   

- The strategy aligns with anti-vaccine rhetoric, contributing to declining immunization rates and the resurgence of preventable diseases.   

- The MAHA plan emphasizes dietary supplements and alternative treatments over evidence-based pediatric care.   

- Advocates call for strengthening public health systems, defending vaccines, and addressing disparities in child health outcomes. 


Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights
A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!
9-14-25

The article compiles various blog posts, news stories, and discussions from September 2025, focusing on education, political violence, AI integration, systemic inequalities, and societal challenges. It explores the intersection of technology, policy, and advocacy in shaping public education and broader societal trends, while highlighting controversies, reforms, and the implications of political rhetoric.

### Key Points  

- AI models reported on major events like declining NAEP scores, political violence, and international crises, showcasing their differing reporting styles.   

- Declining NAEP scores revealed worsening student proficiency in math, science, and reading, reflecting systemic issues in U.S. education.   

- President Trump renamed the Department of Defense to the "Department of War," sparking debates over symbolism and policy.   

- The assassination of Charlie Kirk highlighted rising political violence, fueled by divisive rhetoric and stochastic terrorism.   

- Health Secretary RFK Jr. faced backlash over vaccine policy changes, including reduced funding and leadership shifts in the CDC.   

- Youth-led protests in Nepal overthrew the government, emphasizing the role of social media in organizing activism.   

- Prince Harry visited Ukraine to support wounded service members, while the Taliban’s ban on women aid workers worsened Afghanistan’s humanitarian crisis.   

- ICE raids in Chicago raised concerns about federal overreach and immigration policies.   

- Public education faces challenges from privatization, charter school scandals, and billionaire-driven agendas.   

- Advocacy movements like Black Lives Matter at School and Sandy Hook Promise address social justice and school safety.   

- AI Smackdown IV tested AI models in education, revealing their strengths in grading and answering questions, but no single model excelled universally.   

- AI-generated parodies of Bob Dylan’s song critiqued Trump’s denial tactics humorously.   

- Florida’s ESA program, managed by Step Up for Students, faced accusations of price gouging and lack of transparency.   

- Right-wing extremism accounts for 76% of extremist-related killings in the U.S. since 2014, with media bias often minimizing its impact.   

- Seattle Public Schools’ abrupt shift to split high school lunch periods sparked protests due to lack of transparency and community input.   

- Teacher turnover correlates with increased student suspensions, disproportionately affecting underrepresented groups.   

- State school finance reforms reduced income-based funding gaps but widened racial disparities, necessitating federal interventions.   

- Participation in nonathletic clubs and volunteering during high school is linked to higher altruism later in life.   

- Advocacy for public education emphasizes equity, transparency, and resistance to privatization efforts.   

- The rise of political violence and divisive rhetoric calls for improved discourse, online platform regulation, and tighter gun laws.   

- AI technologies in classrooms spark debates over biases, equity gaps, and academic dishonesty.   

- Systemic issues like poverty, healthcare access, and underfunding are overlooked in education policy discussions.