Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, March 25, 2011

Films and School Reform | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Films and School Reform | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Films and School Reform

Erin Gruwell

Image via Wikipedia

More than 3000 miles separate English teacher Erin Gruwell at Wilson High School in Long Beach (CA) in the film “Freedom Writers” from middle school math teacher Roland Pryzbylewski (Mr. P.) in Baltimore (MD) in HBO’s “The Wire.” Based upon an actual novice white teacher, the celluloid Gruwell, played by Hillary Swank, spurs her class to overcome poverty, gang banging, and utter pessimism about their future to write in their journals and eventually go to college. Mr. P, also a novice white teacher, played by Jim True-Frost, tries hard to get his 8th graders, to learn fractions, long division, and probability and stay out of selling drugs. Mr. P, however, is a fictitious character.

Yet what separates the two films about teaching urban youth under grim conditions is not that one teacher is