Latest News and Comment from Education

Wednesday, May 6, 2020

Shanker Blog: The Crucial Role of State Policy in the Impending School Budget Crisis | National Education Policy Center

Shanker Blog: The Crucial Role of State Policy in the Impending School Budget Crisis | National Education Policy Center

Shanker Blog: The Crucial Role of State Policy in the Impending School Budget Crisis


Last week, we published a report on the probable implications of the coronavirus pandemic for K-12 education funding. My co-author Bruce Baker and I present a bunch of data on the impact of the 2007-09 "Great Recession" on education funding, as well as outcomes illustrating states' responses to the budget crisis caused by the recession. Using insights from these descriptive analyses, we offer a set of recommendations for minimizing the harm of the coronavirus recession on school budgets. 
I won't go through our findings and recommendations individually; you can download the full report, or read the executive summary. I do want to discuss on one overarching theme of the recommendations, and it's very simple: any truly effective response to the impending budgetary crisis cannot consist solely of a federal assistance package. The way states fund public schools has to change, with a forward-thinking focus on faster recovery from this crisis as well as systems better equipped to handle future crises. Chess rather than checkers.
To be clear, federal funding will be absolutely crucial in smoothing the large decreases in revenue that will occur. Without this federal help, there will likely be cuts to school budgets (and those of other public services) so severe that recovery in many states may be a matter of decades rather than years. Moreover, districts serving larger shares of disadvantaged students will bear a disproportionate amount of the harm. Accordingly, we recommend that federal funds be drawn out in two "phases" over a 5-7 year period, and that states be required to distribute them in a manner that targets assistance to those districts that need it the most. But this won't be enough.
In our report, we discuss how the 2009 federal "stimulus package," which was passed through states and distributed to districts over a two year period, did not, of course, prevent school funding cuts entirely, CONTINUE READING: Shanker Blog: The Crucial Role of State Policy in the Impending School Budget Crisis | National Education Policy Center