Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, November 16, 2019

TOP POSTS THIS WEEK 11/16/19 #REDFORED

Big Education Ape


TOP POSTS THIS WEEK 11/16/19







TOP POSTS THIS MONTH 11/16/19






POSTS THIS WEEK 11/16/19

TODAY

The Family Friendly Schools Act: A Set Up For “Soft Policing” Schools To Profit Impact Investors? – Wrench in the Gears

The Family Friendly Schools Act: A Set Up For “Soft Policing” Schools To Profit Impact Investors? On November 6, 2019, former San Francisco District Attorney, California Attorney General, Senator, and presidential candidate Kamala Harris introduced the Family Friendly Schools Act . If passed, the bill would create a five-year grant program to restructure 500 elementary schools to “better align”
Educator Unions Stand Together Grieving Saugus School Shooting

Educator Unions Stand Together Deeply Saddened by Another Tragic School Shooting and Deaths Leaders Demand an End to Gun Violence and Quick Action by Lawmakers Four state and national education union leaders issued the following statement in the wake of the early morning shooting at Saugus High School in Santa Clarita, California that has already claimed the lives of two students and critically
Pennsylvania: Protect Your Public Schools and Their Funding! Say NO to Vouchers! | Diane Ravitch's blog

Pennsylvania: Protect Your Public Schools and Their Funding! Say NO to Vouchers! If you live in Pennsylvania, please let your legislators know that you oppose the diversion of public funds to private and religious schools. Stop the DeVos agenda now! Vouchers do not help students or schools or districts! Multiple studies have shown that vouchers divert funding from public schools and reduce servi
Teachers at D.C.’s only unionized charter school sign a contract, a first for the city - The Washington Post

Teachers at D.C.’s only unionized charter school sign a contract, a first for the city Teachers and staff members at Mundo Verde Bilingual Public Charter School are nearing a historic moment: They’re a vote away from settling with their bosses on a union contract, the first time that has happened at a D.C. charter school. Workers at the popular language immersion charter school in Northwest Wash
CURMUDGUCATION: Betsy DeVos Accuses FBI Of Ignorance, Blames Public Education (And More)

Betsy DeVos Accuses FBI Of Ignorance, Blames Public Education (And More) Never let it be said that Betsy DeVos won't go out of her way to blame US public education for all the ills of the country, real or imagined. In retrospect, it seems like an oversight that she hadn't had a "Kids These Days" moment, but now that omission has been corrected. The young FBI agents are ignorant, and public educa
Chicago’s teachers approve their contract. – Fred Klonsky

CHICAGO’S TEACHERS APPROVE THEIR CONTRACT Chicago teachers, members of the Chicago Teachers Union bargaining unit numbering 25,000, have approved the agreement negotiated between the CTU bargaining team and the Chicago Public Schools board of education. The vote came two weeks after an eleven day strike that put thousands of teachers on the picket lines and in the streets for nearly daily mass p
Schools, Education Issues in DC’s Ward 8 – Education Town Hall Forum

SCHOOLS, EDUCATION ISSUES IN DC’S WARD 8 Our November 14, 2019 featured a discussion of issues in Ward 8 schools with the DC council member for the ward, Trayon White, along with Anacostia high school social worker Nathan Luecking and DCPS community engagement officer and Ward 8 parent Sharona Robinson. DC’s eastern- and southernmost ward, Ward 8 has the most children in the city–and some of its
Do NYS Graduation Measures Adequately Prepare Students for Career and/or College? | Ed In The Apple

Do NYS Graduation Measures Adequately Prepare Students for Career and/or College? We all know that the primary purpose of high school is to keep teenagers and parents apart to reduce patricide, matricide and infanticide, that being said … Over the past month I have blogged a number of times over the current year-long process to review graduate measures, commonly known as high school graduation r
The Wrong “Scientific” for Education | radical eyes for equity

The Wrong “Scientific” for Education The release of National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) 2019 scores in math and reading , announced as an “emergency” and “devastating,” has thrown gasoline on the rhetorical fire that has already been sweeping across media—a call for “scientific” research to save public education in the U.S.: Schools Should Follow the ‘Science of Reading,’ Say Nati
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Watch Out for Talking with the Times on HCC

Watch Out for Talking with the Times on HCC HCC or probably any other topic. The last several years have seen the Times skew their writing on public education. Whether it's because part of their writing is funded by the Gates Foundation (and the Times clutches its pearls if you even suggest that the Foundation gives them guidance on what to write and how to write) and/or input from the Editorial
Some Questions for the Ohio House of Representatives | Live Long and Prosper

Some Questions for the Ohio House of Representatives The Ohio House of Representatives has passed a bill that would prevent public school students from being penalized for their religious beliefs in science (and, I presume any other) class. In other words, a student in a geology class could assert that the Earth was 6,000 years old…a student taking astronomy could claim that the stars are simply
Does the bill just passed by the Ohio House allow students to be wrong in science class without penalty if they cite religious reasons? - The Washington Post

Does the bill just passed by the Ohio House allow students to be wrong in science class without penalty if they cite religious reasons? (Update: Interview with bill sponsor, more detail) Did lawmakers in Ohio’s House pass legislation that says it’s okay for students to be wrong in science class as long as their reasoning is based on religious beliefs? That’s what critics in the state are saying
CURMUDGUCATION: OH: Outlawing Facts

OH: Outlawing Facts The Ohio House of Representatives is ready to help students take a bold step forward into the post-fact world. Wednesday they passed (and when I say "they," I mean the s olid vote-as-a-bloc GOP ) HB 164 . It's called the "Ohio Student Religious Liberties Act of 2019" and it sets out to accomplish a few things: It removes the limits on exercising expression of student religiou
THIS WEEK Education Research Report

Education Research Report THIS WEEK Education Research Report Recent trends in adult literacy in the United States by Jonathan Kantrowitz / 16h Between 2012/14 and 2017, the average scores for U.S. adults with less than a high school education increased in literacy, while, for adults with a high school education, they decreased in both literacy and numeracy. The National Center for Education Stat
This Week With Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... The latest news and resources in education since 2007

Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 This Week With Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... The latest news and resources in education since 2007 Around The Web In ESL/EFL/ELL by Larry Ferlazzo / 9h BiljaST / Pixabay Five years ago I began this regular feature where I share a few posts and resources from around the Web related to ESL/EFL
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG A site to discuss better education for all Slaying Goliath: The Passionate Resistance to Privatization and the Fight to Save America's Public Schools CLICK HERE TO Pre-order NOW TODAY Kentucky: New Governor Invites Teachers to Lead Inaugural Parade! by dianeravitch / 29min Newly elected Governor Andy Beshear has invited teachers to lead his inaugural p

YESTERDAY

Wendy Lecker: The fallout of school takeover laws - StamfordAdvocate

Wendy Lecker: The fallout of school takeover laws What does Colin Kaepernick have to do with public schools? By silently kneeling during the national anthem to protest racial injustice, Kaepernick displayed the kind of civic engagement that is the goal of public education. Kaepernick’s actions inspired other athletes, at the professional, college and high school levels, to join in the silent, re
Follow These #EdJustice Superstars on Twitter AND Standing with Puerto Rico | Schott Foundation for Public Education

Follow These #EdJustice Superstars on Twitter | Schott Foundation for Public Education Follow These #EdJustice Superstars on Twitter It’s that time of the year again... the Schott Foundation’s second annual list of 10 Education Justice Superstars to follow on Twitter! Spice up your feed with knowledge and inspiration from these influential and energized advocates. They’re leading the way, pushing
Jeff Bryant: Striking Teachers Are Fighting For Much More Than Paychecks | OurFuture.org by People's Action

Striking Teachers Are Fighting For Much More Than Paychecks | OurFuture.org by People's Action Striking Teachers Are Fighting For Much More Than Paychecks While national news outlets hail the conclusion of a historic teacher strike in Chicago, another important story often overlooked by national reporters is the ongoing struggle to defend public education in the months that follow successful stri
New Charter Schools Division Director Named - Year 2019 (CA Dept of Education)

State Superintendent Tony Thurmond Appoints Stephanie Farland as the New Director of the Charter Schools Division Stephanie Farland , a consultant on charter school oversight in California, said she sees the benefits that students can receive when there is no labor agreement. But she also sees the price that young or new teachers pay because of high involvement, home visits and long hours. “Char
Seattle Schools Community Forum: PTA Fundraising and Spending; Let's Talk

PTA Fundraising and Spending; Let's Talk A really informative article from The Atlantic on PTA fundraising. Wonder if the new Board make-up, what with a former president of the SCPTSA and a former SCPTSA Board member, might have the courage to tackle this one. But there is not just an "opportunity gap" but this: A 2017 report from the left-leaning Center for American Progress found that of the r
It's Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... A VERY BUSY DAY | The latest news and resources in education since 2007

Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 Twenty-Second School Shooting Of The Year – How Many More Have To Happen? by Larry Ferlazzo / 3h The New York Times article headlined California School Shooting Is Another Nightmare Made Real – and the videos below – tell the story of what happened yesterday. It was the twenty-second school shooting t
Something stinks about the takeover of HISD [Opinion] - HoustonChronicle.com

Something stinks about the takeover of HISD [Opinion] Residents of this community are increasingly frustrated with the upheaval in the Houston Independent School District. As Houstonians who work directly with the educators, parents and students in the district, we don’t blame them. But something doesn’t add up in the state’s decision to take over HISD. Houston schools have been on an improvemen
Report: Michigan’s takeover of Detroit schools was ‘a costly mistake’

Report: Michigan’s takeover of Detroit schools was ‘a costly mistake’ The state was supposed to solve intractable problems that elected school officials in Detroit could not. It made things worse, according to a newly released report on the 15 years during which the Detroit school district was largely controlled by state-appointed officials. The study, which was commissioned by the current schoo
Michael Bloomberg Says He May Run for President: Why He Won’t Be my Choice | janresseger

Michael Bloomberg Says He May Run for President: Why He Won’t Be my Choice New York City’s former three-term mayor, Michael Bloomberg, a multi-billionaire businessman, is exploring whether to join other Democrats running for President in 2020. It is said that he would be a Democratic centrist, and we know that he has contributed positively to the national conversation promoting gun control and a
Vulture Voucher Bill Latest in Mike Turzai’s Quest to Please Betsy DeVos in PA | gadflyonthewallblog

Vulture Voucher Bill Latest in Mike Turzai’s Quest to Please Betsy DeVos in PA The best way to help a struggling public school is to cannibalize it. At least that’s what Betsy DeVos thinks – and so does her Pennsylvania puppet Mike Turzai. The Republican Speaker of the state House is expected to propose a school voucher bill Monday that will treat Harrisburg Schools as nothing more than carrion
Education Through Friendship: One Man’s Story (Part 1) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Education Through Friendship: One Man’s Story (Part 1) I have been writing this blog for over a decade. It has focused nearly always on how state and district policies–most of which aim to reform practices– are formed and what happens to them as they trickle down into classrooms. In other words, I have described and analyzed the institution of schooling both past and present and how policies, if
Los Angeles: UTLA Endorses Bernie Sanders | Diane Ravitch's blog

Los Angeles: UTLA Endorses Bernie Sanders Tonight, the United Teachers of Los Angeles endorsed Senator Bernie Sanders for the Democratic nomination for president. LOS ANGELES — United Teachers Los Angeles, the second-largest teachers’ local in the country, is proud to endorse Senator Bernie Sanders for US President in the 2020 Primary Election, making UTLA the first teachers’ union in the countr
Charter School Industry’s Data Plan Goes Bust

Charter School Industry’s Data Plan Goes Bust I think that it is incredibly ironic…that the same people who have resisted charter school transparency are now the ones demanding [public schools] to be transparent. ” – LAUSD Board Member Jackie Goldberg The School Performance Framework (SPF) should have been killed off the moment it was revealed that Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) Boa
Louisiana Educator: Poverty vs District School Performance

Poverty vs District School Performance This ranking lists all Louisiana school systems and certain individual schools in order of increasing poverty. The table includes the district performance scores and the letter grade as assigned by the LA Department of Education for 2019. (Click on the image to magnify) It is noteworthy that the districts and schools with the smallest percentage of high pov

NOV 14

The problem with K.J.’s comeback • SN&R Extra

The problem with K.J.’s comeback Sacramento didn’t author Kevin Johnson’s political downfall. Will the city support the accused molester’s makeover as a celebrity restaurant owner? Dear Sacramento, Did you forgive or forget? Or did you never believe the girls at all? It’s a late Friday morning inside Fixins Soul Kitchen, and Oak Park’s buzziest new restaurant is steady with early lunch traffic.
NC teacher: Education is political - EducationNC

Education is political On a recent Sunday morning, I woke up to see tremendous chatter on social media concerning the budget impasse in the North Carolina General Assembly. The discussion included the lack of educator raises, the failure to expand Medicaid, unacceptable working conditions, and a shortage of support staff. This discussion quickly evolved into the formation of a new social media g
Oakland School Board meeting turns chaotic after protesters take over, forcing board to leave | abc7news.com

Oakland School Board meeting turns chaotic after protesters take over, forcing board to leave OAKLAND, Calif. (KGO) -- Wednesday's Oakland School Board meeting turned into chaos after protesters upset about school closures disrupted things and then took over the meeting forcing the board to leave. "Out with the school board, in with democracy," said one speaker. It took only minutes for proteste
The Implications of Sacramento City Unified's Ongoing Budgetary Challenges for Local and State Policy | Policy Analysis for California Education

The Implications of Sacramento City Unified's Ongoing Budgetary Challenges for Local and State Policy Authors: Carrie Hahnel , Hannah Melnicoe Year of publication: November 2019 Sacramento City Unified School District (SCUSD), California’s thirteenth largest school district, faces a looming deficit and must make significant budget adjustments to avoid state intervention. This case study explores
CURMUDGUCATION: Pearson In Your Pants

Pearson In Your Pants Pearson, the edu-product giant that hopes to eat the world, just announced a new product. It's part of the overall Pearson vision-- and nobody does large-scale vision like Pearson. They see everything happening in a "digital ocean. " They have ideas about an "assessment renaissance" so huge that it took me five posts to write about it ( here's the shorter version ). And jus
Students forced to advocate for themselves on impact of climate change

Students take their future into their own hands on climate change activism Why aren’t schools helping them? When high school senior Destiny Watford learned that state officials had approved a building permit for a giant incinerator that would burn 4,000 tons of trash every day and emit more than a thousand pounds of lead and mercury every year, less than a mile away from her school in Baltimore,
Too few parents talking to kids about race and identity, report finds

Too few parents talk to their kids about race and identity, report finds Ten percent of parents discuss race often with their children Too few parents and teachers are talking about race, gender and other identity traits with children often enough, which means they are missing out on critical opportunities to teach children to become tolerant of differences from an early age. That’s one of the m
Walton Foundation and UNCF Collaborate to Lure Young African Americans into Disruption Movement | Diane Ravitch's blog

Walton Foundation and UNCF Collaborate to Lure Young African Americans into Disruption Movement A friend share this link about a program in which the United Negro College Fund is funded by the far-right Walton Family Foundation to give summer internships to young African Americans to work in organizations that undermine public education, unions, and the teaching profession. The purpose of the pr
Statewide Red for Ed Day of Action to see national backing at rally next week | News | mdjonline.com

Statewide Red for Ed Day of Action to see national backing at rally next week The national president of the American Federation of Teachers will join teachers, school administrators and legislators next week as public education advocates plan a statewide rally for public education . The day, dubbed the Red for Ed Day of Action, will kick off with a morning rally Tuesday at the Indiana Statehouse
Should a Cooperating Teacher Make Things More ‘Real’ for His Student Teacher? | Teacher in a strange land

Should a Cooperating Teacher Make Things More ‘Real’ for His Student Teacher? Thought experiment: You’re a successful veteran male HS teacher, firing on all instructional cylinders. You take your first student teacher. Your classes this year are right where you want them—the students have begun to trust each other and their own ideas and skills. They’re functioning well. And now—you’re going to
Equity in Theory, Privilege in Practice – Have You Heard

Equity in Theory, Privilege in Practice In the latest episode of Have You Heard , we tackle a fraught and timely question.Why do progressive parents so often act to preserve their own privilege, and that of their children, even as they say they’re committed to challenging inequality? We talk to Margaret Hagerman, author of White Kids: Growing Up with Privilege in a Racially Divided America . Ful
NYC Educator: Today's Grievances

Today's Grievances I have a girl in my class who imitates me. Sometimes she stands behind my back and mimics my movements. Other times, she anticipates exactly what I'm going to say, stands up, and says it before I can. I have to say, I find this very disappointing. The key issue, in my view, is having teenagers in my class who are smarter than I am. I mean, who the hell do they think they are d
How School Choice Works: The School Has the Choice to Close Mid-Year and Transfer Its Students | deutsch29

How School Choice Works: The School Has the Choice to Close Mid-Year and Transfer Its Students How school choice works: Florida parents and students think they have chosen a charter school. School decides to close mid-year. Parents and students are informed less than three weeks prior to closure that they will be transferred to another charter school. Original, “chosen” school has apparently mad
CURMUDGUCATION: NAEP Board Gets DeVosian Additions

NAEP Board Gets DeVosian Additions Education Secretary Betsy DeVos just announced six new appointees (and one returnee) to the National Assessment Governing Board. These are the folks that oversee the National Assessment of Educational Progress aka NAEP aka the nation's report card aka that big standardized test that everyone tries to use to prove a point every year . So who did we get? Returnee

NOV 13

Low teacher morale 'has reached a tipping point:' Study

Teacher morale has 'reached a tipping point,' new survey shows With work stoppages cropping up in all corners of the U.S. , it’s clear that many American teachers are in a bad way. The sunny optimism that likely propelled them into the field is rapidly fading as the result of low salaries, insufficient funding, and the often complicated social-emotional needs of their students. This is according
HFT Criticizes TEA Takeover of HISD | Houston Press

Accountability for some? HFT Members are asking what about failing charter schools? Suggesting that politics, not concern for students, is behind the Texas Education Agency decision to take over the Houston ISD school board, Houston Federation of Teachers President Zeph Capo Monday charged the state agency with a continued attempt to privatize education in the state — supporting charters not pub
Tonight! A Bipartisan Requiem (or Celebration) for the Failure of No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top | Diane Ravitch's blog

Tonight! A Bipartisan Requiem (or Celebration) for the Failure of No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top Political Morning Education reports a big event in D.C. tonight where partisans of the test-and-punish education policies of the past twenty years will gather to rededicate themselves to their failed programs. Will these advocates for accountability accept any accountability for the misguid
More than 765 Charter Schools Closed in Three Years | Dissident Voice

More than 765 Charter Schools Closed in Three Years Currently, about 3.2 million students are enrolled in roughly 7,000 privately-operated charter schools across the country. This represents less than 7% of all students and 7% of all schools in the country. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, more than 765 charter schools closed between 2014-15 and 2016-2017, 1 leaving tho
Organizations with the Audacity to Blame Teachers for Poor NAEP Reading Scores!

Organizations with the Audacity to Blame Teachers for Poor NAEP Reading Scores! The latest “criticize teachers for not teaching the ‘science’ of reading” can be found in “Schools Should Follow the ‘Science of Reading,’ say National Education Groups” in the Gates funded Education Week. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation funds most of the organizations in this report that criticize public schools
Campbell Brown’s “The 74” Does Not Like Elizabeth Warren | Diane Ravitch's blog

Campbell Brown’s “The 74” Does Not Like Elizabeth Warren Campbell Brown was a CNN anchor. Then she became the new face of the Education Disruption movement after the disappearance of Michelle Rhee. Brown advocated for charters and vouchers and she opposed teachers’ unions and teacher tenure. She claimed in various articles in the New York City press that the schools were overrun by teachers who
CURMUDGUCATION: FTC Cracks Down On Edu-Influencers

FTC Cracks Down On Edu-Influencers One of the small tricks that education marketers have developed is to enlist teachers as brand ambassadors. Teachers are, after all, the voices most often trusted by other teachers, so it's got to be a real boost if you can get Mrs. Teachwell to tout your product on Twitter or Instagram or Pinterest. And the beauty of it is that Mrs. Teachwell may come cheap--
With A Brooklyn Accent: A New Goal in My Pedagogy-Stress Reduction

A New Goal in My Pedagogy-Stress Reduction Throughout my many years teaching at Fordham, I was probably not best known for my kindness. Yes, I gave my students lots of personal attention and and made sure they had an opportunity to express themselves, but I also pushed them HARD, asking them to write long research papers that had to be handed in ON TIME. No one took my courses without doing a lo
What Does the Slippage in NAEP Reading Scores Mean about our Schools? our Children? our Society? | janresseger

What Does the Slippage in NAEP Reading Scores Mean about our Schools? our Children? our Society? The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) is considered the most reliable indicator of trends in American public education. The test is administered to samples of students and is used to track long-range trends. Nobody reports on the NAEP scores of specific students. Nobody judges school
Education in DC’s Ward 8 – Education Town Hall Forum

Education in DC’s Ward 8 Our show, Nov. 14, will focus on issues around public education in Ward 8, DC’s eastern- and southernmost ward with the city’s largest number of kids–and some of its poorest residents. We will be talking about the variety of issues that the ward faces with respect to public education, including safe passage; budget cuts to neighborhood schools; health; and charter school
NYC Educator: Why Are Teachers Targeted and What Can We Do About It?

Why Are Teachers Targeted and What Can We Do About It? After reading yet another week of press coverage that shows little or no awareness of who we are or what we do, I have to take a moment and look at why we are where we are in the press. There are a number of reasons, and none of them are good. Fifteen years ago, crappy press coverage and too many conversations with people who didn't know wha
Shanker Blog: Social Identity Development in the Age of Accountability | National Education Policy Center

Shanker Blog: Social Identity Development in the Age of Accountability According to a recent NPR article , the “majority of parents” do not talk to their children about social identity, which refers to group membership based on characteristics such as religion, gender, national origin, race, family makeup, and socio-economic status. The article presents results from a report , co-published by Th
On Getting an Award | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

On Getting an Award On October 25, 2019, I received an award from the Alumni of the Stanford University Graduate School of Education for Lifetime Achievement. Three other graduates of GSE received awards for Excellence in Education. Here is what I said upon receiving the award. I thank my family and friends who have come out tonight. Two people who I wish were here tonight are not. They helped m
With A Brooklyn Accent: The Importance of Leaving Footprints- Lessons From the Slave Narratives and "Footnote Four"

The Importance of Leaving Footprints- Lessons From the Slave Narratives and "Footnote Four" During the last few years, it has been a matter of extreme frustration to me that I have been able to do little to prevent our country from "going off the rails." I saw what was coming four years ago, warned people about it, and had virtually no influence on anybody that didn't already share my views In t

NOV 12

The Stink of Segregation Needs to End in Steel Valley Schools | gadflyonthewallblog

The Stink of Segregation Needs to End in Steel Valley Schools I am a teacher at Steel Valley Schools . I am also an education blogger . In order to belong to both worlds, I’ve had to abide by one ironclad rule that I’m about to break: Never write about my home district. Oh, I write about issues affecting my district. I write about charter schools , standardized testing , child poverty , etc. But
NYC Public School Parents: What's really behind the city, state and national drop in NAEP scores

What's really behind the city, state and national drop in NAEP scores The results of the biennual national tests called NAEPs were released on October 30, showing stagnant or declining test scores in reading and math in nearly all states in the decade since 2009. “O ver the past decade, there has been no progress in either mathematics or reading performance, and the lowest-performing students ar
Schools Matter: TN's Latest Grades on School Funding

TN's Latest Grades on School Funding Tennessee has been at or near the forefront of education reformers' thirty-year crusade to come up with a cheap and easily-measured scheme to gauge education productivity. In 1992, Tennessee formalized its chosen "accountability" strategy by writing into state statute Bill Sanders' value-added algorithms, which the wizened tobacco-chewing agricultural statist
Are teachers allowed to think — or expected to simply follow directions? - The Washington Post

Are teachers allowed to think — or expected to simply follow directions? Last week I published a story about the degrading exercise teachers go through in securing basic supplies for their students because the schools don’t. I asked teachers to tell me about their supply stories and received more than 1,200 responses, and they are still coming in. This is a look at another problem teachers face,
St. Paul group steps up fight against new charter schools - StarTribune.com

St. Paul group steps up fight against new charter schools District board chairwoman signs onto the campaign seeking moratorium. A group committed to reining in charter school growth in St. Paul is sharpening its message and strategy. Members appeared before the school board recently to pursue support for a moratorium on new charter schools and the expansion of existing ones. Such moves are chall
Little Rock teachers to go on strike over district's control

Little Rock teachers to go on strike over district’s control LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) — Little Rock teachers will go on strike for one day this week over an Arkansas panel’s decision to strip their collective bargaining power and complaints about state control of the 23,000-student district, union officials said Monday. Full Coverage: Strikes The strike that will take place Thursday will be only t
On Poetry and Prose: Defining the Undefinable | radical eyes for equity

On Poetry and Prose: Defining the Undefinable As a professor of first-year writing, I spend a good deal of time helping students unpack what they have learned about the essay as a form and about writing in order to set much of that aside and embrace more nuanced and authentic awareness about both. Photo by Taylor Ann Wright on Unsplash Teaching writing is also necessarily entangled with teaching
HISD teachers' union believe TEA takeover is politically motivated | abc13.com

'We need answers': HISD teachers still in dark over takeover HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) -- Five days after the state announced it was taking over HISD , plenty of questions remain. At union headquarters Monday afternoon, the Houston Federation of Teachers offered its take on the Texas Education Agency's decision to appoint a board of managers and superintendent to oversee the state's largest school d
Are Black girls being pushed out of San Francisco Schools? - SF PUBLIC SCHOOL MOM

Are Black girls being pushed out of San Francisco Schools? I’ve been reading Dr. Monique Morris’ book “Sign and Rhythm, Dance the Blues this long weekend. It has so many great quotes, I can’t stop highlighting it! This quote serves as a summary of the themes covered in her book: “Black girls, are overrepresented along the school discipline continuum, we need to understand the conditions they per
Jane Nylund: Oakland Is in the Sights of the “Destroy Public Education” Crowd, Who Control the Board | Diane Ravitch's blog

Jane Nylund: Oakland Is in the Sights of the “Destroy Public Education” Crowd, Who Control the Board Jane Nylund, parent activist in Oakland, wrote the following warning after reading about the ouster of the Disrupters in Denver. Parents and activists and concerned citizens must organize and oust the agents of Disruption: Oakland also must flip 4 board seats next year. The Walton-bought board ha
How Schools Are Using The Trump Impeachment Inquiry To Teach Key Skills : NPR

How Schools Are Using The Trump Impeachment Inquiry As A Teachable Moment For the fourth time in history, Congress is considering impeaching the president of the United States. For teachers around the country, it's an opportunity to explore concepts and skills that are often relegated to textbooks. We asked social studies teachers from around the country how — if at all — they're using this teac
When a Bake Sale Isn't Enough: Crowdfunding for School Projects

When a Bake Sale Isn’t Enough: Crowdfunding for School Projects From international food festivals and popcorn sales to fun runs and penny wars, many educators are taking matters into their own hands to raise much-needed funds. With nearly half of public school funding nationwide coming from local taxes, annual budgets vary drastically from one school district to another. According to the Nationa
Record levels of stress ‘put teachers at breaking point’ | Education | The Guardian

Record levels of stress ‘put teachers at breaking point’ ‘Burnt-out’ school staff are suffering severe psychological problems, reveals report Teachers are suffering from more severe psychological problems than at any point this century, experts have warned. In an alarming report they reveal the school workforce is being pushed to “breaking point”. Education Support , a charity that gives mental
Success Academy Class Of 2020 Sheds 239 Scholars Along The Way | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

Success Academy Class Of 2020 Sheds 239 Scholars Along The Way The New York Post recently ran an editorial about the SAT scores of the Success Academy senior class of 2020. Of all the different numbers they referenced, one that I took note of was 114 — the apparent number of students in the senior class. The class of 2020 is the third graduating class of Success Academy. The class of 2018 had 17
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Stand Up for Student Data Privacy

Stand Up for Student Data Privacy Don't let the feds do to COPPA what they did to FERPA. Is your child's information for sale to the highest bidder? I hope not. Children's Online Privacy Protection Act ( COPPA ) is a law created to protect the privacy of children under 13. From the Missouri Watchdog blog : The Federal Trade Commission is considering several changes to this law that protects chil

NOV 11

In Memoriam of WWII Latino Veterans and Their Families | Cloaking Inequity

In Memoriam of WWII Latino Veterans and Their Families Thank you to all of the veterans who have courageously served our country. This post is dedicated to my tía Minnie Cadena who recently passed and was a participant in the University of Texas Voce Oral History Project and my tío John G. Reyes who was KIA 1944. This post is also dedicated to the all of the Heilig, Scott, Vasquez and Cadena who
Valerie Jablow: D.C. Ripped Off By Charter Real Estate Deals | Diane Ravitch's blog

Valerie Jablow: D.C. Ripped Off By Charter Real Estate Deals Valerie Jablow is a parent in D.C. whose blog follows the ethical scandals of public officials and the charter industry in her hometown. This one is a doozy. It is so crazy that I can’t summarize it. Somewhere in this Pink Panther-style story are the moneymakers. The guys who finance the real estate: Turner Agassi. Tennis star Andre Ag
How ZIP codes determine the quality of a child's education

How ZIP codes determine the quality of a child’s education ALLENTOWN, Pa. (AP) — Students at Allentown’s Harrison-Morton Middle School look forward to hearing the squeaky wheels of the technology cart approaching their classroom, though the iPads they hold may not be the latest models and time with them is limited. A luxury in Allentown schools, such technology has become a necessity for many su
Oakland school board closes meeting to public, citing protests | EdSource

Oakland school board closes meeting to public, citing protests Open meetings expert says shutting out the public runs against spirit of state’s law. W hen the Oakland school board meets next Wednesday, it may again decide to ban the public from its meeting due to fears that protesters who have disrupted previous meetings will return. But an expert warns that meeting in a room separated from the
John Thompson: 'Home is here': DACA walkout features love for Oklahoma

'Home is here': DACA walkout features love for Oklahoma ‘Home is here’: DACA walkout features love for Oklahoma G iven the criticism of immigrants these last few years , one might be surprised by the message Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals students are delivering to our city. But the “home is here” message DACA students preached during Friday’s OKCPS walkouts exemplifies the best of Oklaho
Betsy DeVos Might Outlast Them All | HuffPost

Betsy DeVos Might Outlast Them All Education Secretary Betsy DeVos is one of the Trump administration’s most reviled Cabinet members. Here’s why she’s here to stay. Betsy DeVos ’ confirmation hearing in January 2017 made her a universal punchline. When asked about her thoughts on guns in school, she famously pointed to the need to protect students from grizzly bears. When asked about her opinion
NYC Educator: What Better Measures Student Achievement--Teacher Grades or Crappy Tests?

What Better Measures Student Achievement--Teacher Grades or Crappy Tests? The NY Post is on the case of students who pass English and math but fail state tests. Evidently the only conclusion they can reach is that this is grade inflation. As usual, neither City Councilman Robert Holden, the fraud-alleging complainant, nor the paper has bothered to examine what is actually on those state tests. T
School Closures Threaten to Destroy Neighborhoods, This Time in Cleveland | janresseger

School Closures Threaten to Destroy Neighborhoods, This Time in Cleveland Right now in Cleveland, Ohio we can watch the latest battle in a war that has spread across the nation’s big city school districts. It is a fight about the definition of a high school—a misunderstanding between the technocrats who have imposed something called “portfolio school reform” school choice and the families who wa
La. Schools Graded F for 4+ Years Mostly Serve Low-Income Students of Color | deutsch29

La. Schools Graded F for 4+ Years Mostly Serve Low-Income Students of Color On November 06, 2019, Louisiana’s 2019 school and district grades were made public. To herald the occasion, the Baton Rouge Advocate published an article entitled, “44% of Louisiana Public Schools Need Major Improvements; 45K Students Attend F-Rated Schools.” This headline comes one week after Louisiana’s 2019 National A
FTC poised to remove parent consent, weaken children’s privacy law. COPPA – Missouri Education Watchdog

FTC poised to remove parent consent, weaken children’s privacy law. COPPA The Federal Trade Commission is considering several changes to this law that protects children’s online information. The FTC is accepting comments from the public, deadline December 9, 2019. Let them hear from you; tell the FTC: Do NOT Weaken COPPA. Do NOT Give Edtech a Consent Exception. See Sample letters here , here , h

NOV 10

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Happy Birthday, Mom Edition (11/10)

Happy Birthday, Mom Edition (11/10) Today is my mother's birthday, so there will be cake involved later. She's a pretty swell lady, so it's a day worthy of cake. Also, if you look to the right, you'll see that I've revamped the blog list and added a section of websites of interest that aren't necessarily blogs. So you can poke through that if you like. In the meantime, here's some reading from l
Educators Question State Takeover of HISD | American Federation of Teachers

Educators Question State Takeover of HISD HOUSTON— American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten and Texas AFT and Houston Federation of Teachers President Zeph Capo issued the following statements in response to the Texas Education Agency’s announcement that it plans to take over local control of the Houston Independent School District: Capo said: “This is a power grab to disenfran
Catch Up With Curmudgucation And Check Out Peter Greene On Forbes

CURMUDGUCATION CLICK HERE Digital Curriculum And Lesson Management Is A Crock 74 by Peter Greene / 20h Ed Tech overpromises in so many areas, but one the great lies is that implementing This Year's Great New Program is going to save teachers just oodles of time. It never does. It particularly never does when it comes to the kind of software leviathan's used to manage curriculum and lesson plans.
What is ‘Quality’ Music? Choosing the Best Materials for Our Students. | Teacher in a strange land

What is ‘Quality’ Music? Choosing the Best Materials for Our Students Back in the day, when I was an early-career teacher, I was sitting at the judges’ lunch table, at a music festival. It was my first time serving as an adjudicator and the other judges were well-known veteran band directors. One of them was expounding on the poor literature choices made by young band directors. He claimed that
Experts Worry Active Shooter Drills In Schools Could Be Traumatic For Students : NPR

Experts Worry Active Shooter Drills In Schools Could Be Traumatic For Students A regular drumbeat of mass shootings in the U.S., both inside schools and out, has ramped up pressure on education and law enforcement officials to do all they can to prevent the next attack. Close to all public schools in the U.S. conducted some kind of lockdown drill in 2015-2016, according to the National Center fo
EdAction in Congress November 10, 2019 - Education Votes

EdAction in Congress November 10, 2019 Tell senators to VOTE NO on DeVos ally nominated as appellate judge The Senate is expected to vote early this week on Steven Menashi’s nomination to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit—a position in which he could do even more harm than he already has. Just days ago, the New York Times confirmed that as acting general counsel under Education Se
CATCH UP WITH MARK ANTHONY NEAL - NewBlackMan (in Exile)

NewBlackMan (in Exile) CATCH UP WITH MARK ANTHONY NEAL NewBlackMan (in Exile) Athlete in Progress: Dina Asher-Smith by Mark Anthony Neal / 9h 'Nike has joined forces with American designer and Off-White founder Virgil Abloh to release Athlete in Progress , a new women’s line inspired by the drama, adrenaline and tenacity of track and field players. To debut the collection, Abloh invited a host of
Show-Trial Rhetoric Took Down Ascend Charter's Founder - The Atlantic

The Show-Trial Rhetoric That Took Down a Charter-School Founder About 10 years ago, Steven Wilson founded the Ascend charter school in Brooklyn. Ascend is now a network with 15 schools; they serve mostly poor kids of color from kindergarten to high-school age, and they work. Test scores there outstrip New York City averages . Some charter schools have become notorious for excessively punitive di
John Thompson: How Billionaire “Reformers” Messed Up the Public Schools of Tulsa | Diane Ravitch's blog

John Thompson: How Billionaire “Reformers” Messed Up the Public Schools of Tulsa John Thompson, historian and recently retired teacher in Oklahoma, assays the damage that corporate reformers and their patrons have inflicted on the public schools of Tulsa. The district is overflowing with Broadies and has Gates money. What could possibly go wrong? The Tulsa Public Schools (TPS) offers an excellen
Schools Matter: Feinstein and Other "Democrats" Supporting DC Vouchers

Feinstein and Other "Democrats" Supporting DC Vouchers Got this email from Pete Farruggio: Just got this letter from California senator Dianne Feinstein (below) defending her support for vouchers, and revealing that she intends to interfere with the school system in Washington DC by co-sponsoring a voucher bill with a Republican. With her billionaire husband, she represents to me the state of th
NYC Educator: Portrait of Half an ATR

Portrait of Half an ATR A few days back, I wrote about another attack on tenure , quite similar to many that had preceded it. Someone sent me this piece on ATRs , which somehow eluded my attention. The headline screams, " DOE spends $100M per year keeping excess teachers on the payroll ." The word "excess" suggests these teachers aren't needed, which is far from correct. In my experience, though
CURMUDGUCATION: Digital Curriculum And Lesson Management Is A Crock

Digital Curriculum And Lesson Management Is A Crock Ed Tech overpromises in so many areas, but one the great lies is that implementing This Year's Great New Program is going to save teachers just oodles of time. It never does. It particularly never does when it comes to the kind of software leviathan's used to manage curriculum and lesson plans. The sheer volume of data entry for these programs
Seattle Schools Community Forum: The Return of Moss Adams to SPS

The Return of Moss Adams to SPS Who is Moss Adams? I'll let them tell you: Moss Adams is a fully integrated professional services firm dedicated to assisting clients with growing, managing, and protecting prosperity. The district used Moss Adams, oh so many years ago, when the district had a superintendent in the form of Joe Olchefske (who ran this district into debt with a slate Board who rubbe

NOV 09



Top Posts This Week 11/9/19 #Redfored

Big Education Ape TOP POSTS THIS WEEK 11/9/19 The real story of New Orleans and its charter schools - The Washington Post Bill Gates spent hundreds of millions of dollars to improve teaching. New report says it was a bust. - The Washington Post TOP POSTS THIS WEEK 11/2/19 #REDFORE




Big Education Ape

The Family Friendly Schools Act: A Set Up For “Soft Policing” Schools To Profit Impact Investors? – Wrench in the Gears

The Family Friendly Schools Act: A Set Up For “Soft Policing” Schools To Profit Impact Investors? – Wrench in the Gears

The Family Friendly Schools Act: A Set Up For “Soft Policing” Schools To Profit Impact Investors?


On November 6, 2019, former San Francisco District Attorney, California Attorney General, Senator, and presidential candidate Kamala Harris introduced the Family Friendly Schools Act. If passed, the bill would create a five-year grant program to restructure 500 elementary schools to “better align” schedules to the work day. The legislation authorizes $1,300,000,000 per year from 2020 to 2024 to pay for the program.
Co-sponsors include five Democratic senators: Kirsten Gillibrand (NY); Richard Blumenthal (CT); Jeff Merkley (OR); Sherrod Brown (OH); and Michael Bennet (CO). Ostensibly this legislation is to aid  working families by extending the school day with support from community partners. It is being presented as an “economic growth and child development strategy.” In my assessment, child development = human capital management for impact investment purposes.
While it is true that families struggle with child care before and after school, the motivation behind this bill has less to do with taking care of vulnerable communities and more to do with the planned expansion of pay for success finance and “cradle to career” pipelines for impact investors.
The collection of data and the monitoring of students and families this entails will require an expansive system of what I am calling “soft” policing. We may replace school police officers with social workers, but control of Black and Brown populations is still the primary goal. This shift will be justified as fiscally prudent, “what works” public policy, though it is predicated on predictive profiling.
Harris’s bill will usher in a new era of privatization, one in which CONTINUE READING: The Family Friendly Schools Act: A Set Up For “Soft Policing” Schools To Profit Impact Investors? – Wrench in the Gears

Educator Unions Stand Together Grieving Saugus School Shooting

Educator Unions Stand Together Grieving Saugus School Shooting

Educator Unions Stand Together
Deeply Saddened by Another Tragic School Shooting and Deaths Leaders Demand an End to Gun Violence and Quick Action by Lawmakers


Four state and national education union leaders issued the following statement in the wake of the early morning shooting at Saugus High School in Santa Clarita, California that has already claimed the lives of two students and critically wounded others.
The following can be attributed to California Teachers Association President E. Toby Boyd, California Federation of Teachers President Jeff FreitasNational Education Association President  Lily Eskelsen García and American Federation of Teachers President  Randi Weingarten:
“We are once again rocked to our core by another senseless and cowardly shooting that has taken two of our precious students, left several students fighting for their lives today and the community of Saugus terrorized by the violence they hoped and prayed would never happen to them. We stand together during these difficult moments, sending love and healing thoughts to the victims and their families, our fellow educators and school employees who without a doubt did everything possible to protect their students, and the community that has been wounded today. 

“More than five million educators and school employees from California and across the country are standing strong with Saugus as they pick up the pieces and try to make sense of this tragedy. We dream of the day when these acts of gun violence no longer threaten our students’ safety and well-being. Our children cannot wait any longer for this dream to come true. We owe it to our students and our educators to make our schools and communities safe and welcome spaces, and we will do everything we can to make that happen. We call on all federal and state lawmakers to take quick action to put an end to these tragic shootings by passing meaningful and sensible gun reform. Our students and our communities are counting on you.”
The 310,000-member California Teachers Association is affiliated with the 3 million-member National Education Association, the nation’s largest professional employee organization, representing elementary and secondary teachers, higher education faculty, education support professionals, school administrators, retired educators and students preparing to become teachers.
The California Federation of Teachers represents 120,000 faculty and school employees in public and private schools and colleges, from early childhood through higher education. It is the statewide affiliate of the American Federation of Teachers, a union of 1.7 million professionals that champions fairness; democracy; economic opportunity; and high-quality public education, healthcare and public services for our students, their families and our communities.
Sonoma County Gazette
Educator Unions Stand Together Grieving Saugus School Shooting

Pennsylvania: Protect Your Public Schools and Their Funding! Say NO to Vouchers! | Diane Ravitch's blog

Pennsylvania: Protect Your Public Schools and Their Funding! Say NO to Vouchers! | Diane Ravitch's blog

Pennsylvania: Protect Your Public Schools and Their Funding! Say NO to Vouchers!


If you live in Pennsylvania, please let your legislators know that you oppose the diversion of public funds to private and religious schools. Stop the DeVos agenda now! Vouchers do not help students or schools or districts! Multiple studies have shown that vouchers divert funding from public schools and reduce services to most students, and that the students who use vouchers actually lose ground compared to their peers who stay in public schools


Dear Carol,

On Monday, November 18,The House Education Committee is scheduled to vote on voucher legislation under House Bill 1800 (Rep. Turzai, R-Allegheny). House Bill 1800 establishes a voucher program for students in the Harrisburg School District, which entered state receivership in June.  Adding tuition and transportation outlays, House Bill 1800 is estimated to cost the Harrisburg School District $5.5 million to $8.5 million. Could your district be next?
SEND YOUR EMAIL NOW BY CLICKING HERE.
Then call your representatives and ask them to vote NO on HB 1800.
You can find their number below, along with a sample script for your call:
House member contact info:

Sample Script
My name is (your name) and I am calling to let (your representative’s name) know that I am opposed to House Bill 1800 and any attempt to give public money to private schools with vouchers. Let’s support our public schools, not private schools with vouchers. Thank you.

Thanks for all you do!
Carol Burris


Teachers at D.C.’s only unionized charter school sign a contract, a first for the city - The Washington Post

Teachers at D.C.’s only unionized charter school sign a contract, a first for the city - The Washington Post

Teachers at D.C.’s only unionized charter school sign a contract, a first for the city



Teachers and staff members at Mundo Verde Bilingual Public Charter School are nearing a historic moment: They’re a vote away from settling with their bosses on a union contract, the first time that has happened at a D.C. charter school.
Workers at the popular language immersion charter school in Northwest Washington formed the D.C. charter sector’s only union in July. Another school, Chavez Prep Middle, formed a union in 2018, but negotiations stalled and school leaders shut down the campus before reaching a labor agreement with educators.


Charter schools are publicly funded and privately run, and unlike the traditional public school system, their teachers are not typically unionized. But across the country, teachers at a relatively small but growing number of charter campuses are organizing.
Many leaders of the charter school movement oppose unionization, believing it results in the same bureaucratic thicket that charter schools were created to escape.
But union leaders view the Mundo Verde contract as a significant win and hope it serves as a model for educators at other schools who hope to unionize.
“D.C. has been a petri dish for all of the different kinds of structures of educating children,” said Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers. “You now not only have a blueprint for D.C. schools, but for thousands of schools around the country.”
The American Federation of Teachers, the nation’s second-largest teachers union, represents the union CONTINUE READING: Teachers at D.C.’s only unionized charter school sign a contract, a first for the city - The Washington Post

CURMUDGUCATION: Betsy DeVos Accuses FBI Of Ignorance, Blames Public Education (And More)

CURMUDGUCATION: Betsy DeVos Accuses FBI Of Ignorance, Blames Public Education (And More)

Betsy DeVos Accuses FBI Of Ignorance, Blames Public Education (And More)

Never let it be said that Betsy DeVos won't go out of her way to blame US public education for all the ills of the country, real or imagined. In retrospect, it seems like an oversight that she hadn't had a "Kids These Days" moment, but now that omission has been corrected. The young FBI agents are ignorant, and public education is to blame. That's been the headline from this speech, but there's so much more to see.

DeVos was accepting another award, this time from the Independent Women's Forum, an organization founded to provide an alternative to feminism. They actually grew out of the collection of women who formed the "Women for Judge Thomas" committee, a group that got together to defend nominee Clarence Thomas from that scurrilous hussy, Anita Hill. They've been active in opposing various forms of feminism, though they do seem to support the Violence Against Women Act. One of the banners on their website announces that "recognizing progressive privilege is the first step to ending it."

Last week, at their annual awards gala, they handed out three awards. Larry Kudlow was a conservative tv talker picked by Trump to head the National Economic Council. Dana Milbank said Kudlow "may have been more wrong about the economy than anyone alive," but the IWF dubbed him a "Gentleman of Distinction." Kristy Swanson, who was in the Buffy the Vampire Slayer movie, got a CONTINUE READING: 
CURMUDGUCATION: Betsy DeVos Accuses FBI Of Ignorance, Blames Public Education (And More)


Chicago’s teachers approve their contract. – Fred Klonsky

Chicago’s teachers approve their contract. – Fred Klonsky

CHICAGO’S TEACHERS APPROVE THEIR CONTRACT




Chicago teachers, members of the Chicago Teachers Union bargaining unit numbering 25,000, have approved the agreement negotiated between the CTU bargaining team and the Chicago Public Schools board of education.
The vote came two weeks after an eleven day strike that put thousands of teachers on the picket lines and in the streets for nearly daily mass protests.
Late Friday night, with 80% of the vote counted from 80% of the schools, votes for approval were running at 81%.
I found no information on what schools the vote was coming from or whether that information will be made available later.
79% approved the deal after the seven-day 2012 strike. The 2016 CBA received a 72% vote of approval.
Teachers have reason to be proud of their unity and militancy during the bargaining.
Members will receive a 16 percent hike over the five year length of the agreement. That is a long time compared to most contracts, and to the 3-year deal that the CTU CONTINUE READING: Chicago’s teachers approve their contract. – Fred Klonsky
Screen Shot 2019-11-16 at 7.32.27 AM

Schools, Education Issues in DC’s Ward 8 – Education Town Hall Forum

Schools, Education Issues in DC’s Ward 8 – Education Town Hall Forum

SCHOOLS, EDUCATION ISSUES IN DC’S WARD 8

Our November 14, 2019 featured a discussion of issues in Ward 8 schools with the DC council member for the ward, Trayon White, along with Anacostia high school social worker Nathan Luecking and DCPS community engagement officer and Ward 8 parent Sharona Robinson.


DC’s eastern- and southernmost ward, Ward 8 has the most children in the city–and some of its poorest residents. The discussion featured some of the most pressing issues in Ward 8 schools, including basic funding (many had severe budget cuts this year alone, on top of decades of inequitable funding in both budgets and modernizations) as well as public safety issues.
Guests agreed that more resources are needed, but they also have to be targeted and aligned better, so that it is not just the available students who benefit, but all students in need. Guests also noted that the lack of a systemic, sustained approach to school support—community schools; wrap-around services; parent resource centers—has harmed the ward’s provision of public education, as it prevents policies and approaches from bearing fruit.
The ward also lacks a trauma center and hospital, which puts pressure on schools to function in that place—or to have students travel far (sometimes with school staff) to get the services they need.
Recognizing the depth of those needs, schools in Ward 8 do provide a number of peer-to-peer CONTINUE READING: Schools, Education Issues in DC’s Ward 8 – Education Town Hall Forum

Do NYS Graduation Measures Adequately Prepare Students for Career and/or College? | Ed In The Apple

Do NYS Graduation Measures Adequately Prepare Students for Career and/or College? | Ed In The Apple

Do NYS Graduation Measures Adequately Prepare Students for Career and/or College?


We all know that the primary purpose of high school is to keep teenagers and parents apart to reduce patricide, matricide and infanticide, that being said …
Over the past month I have blogged a number of times over the current year-long process to review graduate measures, commonly known as high school graduation requirements.
The elephant in the room, the topic that will not be discussed is equity.
Educational funding in New York State is dramatically inequitable,
Despite New York’s equalizing State aid system, there remain tremendous disparities between New York State school districts in fiscal resources available to support education. In 2015-16, approved operating expenditure per pupil ranged from $11,072 for the district at the 10th percentile to $21,135 for the district at the 90th percentile, a 91 percent difference.
 In a class of thirty students the difference between the 10th percentile and the 90th percentile of $300,000 per class!
This deeply corrupt system is embedded in state law. Most funding comes from property taxes (local budgets in the Big Five cities), the differences across the state, as described above, are enormous. The Foundation Aid formula is CONTINUE READING: Do NYS Graduation Measures Adequately Prepare Students for Career and/or College? | Ed In The Apple

The Wrong “Scientific” for Education | radical eyes for equity

The Wrong “Scientific” for Education | radical eyes for equity

The Wrong “Scientific” for Education

The release of National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) 2019 scores in math and reading, announced as an “emergency” and “devastating,” has thrown gasoline on the rhetorical fire that has already been sweeping across media—a call for “scientific” research to save public education in the U.S.:
While the media and the public seem historically and currently convinced by the rhetoric of “scientific,” there is a significant irony to the lack of scientific evidence backing claims about the causes of NAEP scores; for example, some have rushed to argue that intensive phonics instruction and grade retention legislation have caused Mississippi’s NAEP reading gains while many have used 2019 NAEP scores to declare the entire accountability era a failure.
Yet, none of these claims have the necessary scientific evidence to make any of these arguments. There simply has not been the time or the efforts to construct scientific studies (experimental or quasi-experimental) to identify causal factors in NAEP score changes.
Another problem with the rhetoric of “scientific” is that coinciding with that CONTINUE READING: The Wrong “Scientific” for Education | radical eyes for equity

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Watch Out for Talking with the Times on HCC

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Watch Out for Talking with the Times on HCC

Watch Out for Talking with the Times on HCC


HCC or probably any other topic.

The last several years have seen the Times skew their writing on public education.  Whether it's because part of their writing is funded by the Gates Foundation (and the Times clutches its pearls if you even suggest that the Foundation gives them guidance on what to write and how to write) and/or input from the Editorial Board, I don't know.

What I do see is a steady decline of balanced reporting and it's troubling.




Now I see there is a call out from the Times asking parents with HCC experience to contact a reporter.  But let's see how it's phrased:


As we continue to explore this topic, we want to hear from you and we want your perspective and questions to improve our coverage: What are the hoops students must jump through to be admitted to gifted programs in your school district? What does gifted learning look like in your school’s classrooms? What stories do you have of racial segregation in these programs?
Hoops and segregation? Where is the "what do you like and what don't you like" in seeking out parents and their experience?

I find the survey kind of odd.

What options does your district offer for advanced learning? How are they delivered, and how do they differ from what you think is normally offered?  

I'm not sure I understand what this means? Are asking about "normally CONTINUE READING: 
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Watch Out for Talking with the Times on HCC


Some Questions for the Ohio House of Representatives | Live Long and Prosper

Some Questions for the Ohio House of Representatives | Live Long and Prosper

Some Questions for the Ohio House of Representatives

The Ohio House of Representatives has passed a bill that would prevent public school students from being penalized for their religious beliefs in science (and, I presume any other) class. In other words, a student in a geology class could assert that the Earth was 6,000 years old…a student taking astronomy could claim that the stars are simply luminous elements that move above the flat surface of the Earth above the sun, the moon, and the planets…and not be penalized on their research papers or tests.
So…I have some questions…
WOULD A TEACHER HAVE TO ACCEPT ALL RELIGIOUS BELIEFS?
If one student claims that both male and female humans were created after all the other creatures (Genesis 1:1 through 2:3) and another one claims that male humans were created before plants and animals, and female human beings were created after (Genesis 2:4-2:25) would they both be entitled to a correct grade?
How about a student who claimed that the Universe (and the Earth) was created by the god Ptah, who brought things into existence just by imagining them? Or that the Earth was created by the god Atum, who had sex with his [sic] own feminine energy and brought forth other gods…who then had sex and gave birth to the air, water, humans and everything else?
The Ohio House on Wednesday passed the “Student Religious Liberties Act.” Under the law, students can’t be penalized if their work is scientifically wrong as long as the reasoning is because of their religious beliefs.

Instead, students are graded on substance and relevance.

Every Republican in the House supported the bill. It now moves to the Republican-controlled Senate.
WHAT IS THE POINT OF HAVING ANY SCIENTIFIC CURRICULUM?
Do we accept answers from students who variously claim that the Universe/Earth is 41,000 years old, 24 trillion years old, or 6,000 years old? If CONTINUE READING: Some Questions for the Ohio House of Representatives | Live Long and Prosper

Does the bill just passed by the Ohio House allow students to be wrong in science class without penalty if they cite religious reasons? - The Washington Post

Does the bill just passed by the Ohio House allow students to be wrong in science class without penalty if they cite religious reasons? - The Washington Post

Does the bill just passed by the Ohio House allow students to be wrong in science class without penalty if they cite religious reasons?







(Update: Interview with bill sponsor, more detail)
Did lawmakers in Ohio’s House pass legislation that says it’s okay for students to be wrong in science class as long as their reasoning is based on religious beliefs?
That’s what critics in the state are saying is allowed in the “Ohio Student Religious Liberties Act of 2019” (see text below), which passed this week 61 to 31 in the Republican-dominated legislative chamber and will move on to the GOP-controlled Senate.


But the bill’s sponsor, state Rep. Timothy Ginter (R), says that’s not so. So does Charles Haynes, founding director of the Religious Freedom Center at the Freedom Forum Institute, which is the the education and outreach partner of the Freedom Forum and the Newseum in Washington D.C.
The legislation, HB 164, would do the following if it became law, according to an analysis from the Ohio Legislative Service Commission, a bipartisan agency that provides the Ohio General Assembly with budget and fiscal analysis:
  • Allow students to engage in religious expression in the completion of homework, artwork or other assignments
  • Prohibit public schools from rewarding or penalizing a student based on the religious content of a student’s homework, artwork or other assignments
This is the specific language in HB 164:
Sec. 3320.03. No school district board of education, governing authority of a community school established under Chapter 3314. of the Revised Code, governing body of a Sec. STEM school established under Chapter 3326. of the Revised Code, or board of trustees of a college-preparatory boarding school established under Chapter 3328. of the Revised Code shall prohibit a student from engaging in religious expression in the completion of homework, artwork, or other written or oral assignments. Assignment grades and scores shall be calculated using ordinary academic standards of substance and relevance, including any legitimate pedagogical concerns, and shall not penalize or reward a student based on the religious content of a student’s work.
Ginter was quoted by WKRC as saying: “Under House Bill 164, a Christian or Jewish student would not be able to say my religious texts teach me that the world is 6,000 years old, so I don’t have to answer this question. They’re still going to be tested in the class and they cannot ignore the class material."
But Gary Daniels, chief lobbyist for the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio, said the measure does in fact allow students to answer homework questions and other assignments incorrectly, based on religious doctrine rather than science — and not be marked wrong. Cleveland.com quoted him as saying: “Under HB 164, the answer is ‘no,’ as this legislation clearly states the instructor ‘shall not penalize or reward a student based on the religious content of a student’s work.' ”
It also quoted Amber Epling, spokeswoman for Ohio House Democrats, as saying that based on the analysis from the Ohio Legislative Service Commission, she believes students can be scientifically incorrect based on religion and not be penalized.
Numerous states in recent years have considered scores of anti-science bills — usually aimed at affecting classroom discussion on evolution and climate change. Those measures typically take one of two approaches, according to the nonprofit National Center for Science Education, which seeks to CONTINUE READING: Does the bill just passed by the Ohio House allow students to be wrong in science class without penalty if they cite religious reasons? - The Washington Post

CURMUDGUCATION: OH: Outlawing Facts

CURMUDGUCATION: OH: Outlawing Facts

OH: Outlawing Facts


The Ohio House of Representatives is ready to help students take a bold step forward into the post-fact world. Wednesday they passed (and when I say "they," I mean the solid vote-as-a-bloc GOPHB 164.

It's called the "Ohio Student Religious Liberties Act of 2019" and it sets out to accomplish a few things:

It removes the limits on exercising expression of student religious beliefs. The old, struck-out language  said the board of education could limit said expression to lunch period or other noninstructional time. That's the piddly stuff.


Under the new language, "religious expression" (the stuff no longer limited to non-instructional time) includes prayer, gatherings (clubs, prayer groups, etc), distribution of written materials, and, well, anything religious, actually, including wearing religious gear or "expression of a religious viewpoint" (as long as it's not obscene or indecent or vulgar). Cue the Church of the Flying Spagetti Monster and the local Satanic Temple; if a student offers a prayer to Satan in the middle of English class and some Christians in the class find that indecent and vulgar, can it be suppressed? Congratulations to the first batch of lawyers and judges that are going to have to sort this out. Double congratulations to whatever government body ends up being responsible for determining which religions are state-certified to be protected under this law.

Students hall have access to school facilities before, during and after school that school hours to the same extent that secular activities may do so. Place your bets now on how many schools will simply CONTINUE READING: 
CURMUDGUCATION: OH: Outlawing Facts