Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, November 16, 2019

KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG 
A site to discuss better education for all

Slaying Goliath: The Passionate Resistance to Privatization and the Fight to Save America's Public Schools



TODAY

Kentucky: New Governor Invites Teachers to Lead Inaugural Parade!

Newly elected Governor Andy Beshear has invited teachers to lead his inaugural parade! Governor-elect Beshear recognizes that angry teachers powered his upset election over the loser, Matt Bevin, who showered contempt on teachers. And paid for it. A group of Kentucky teachers will serve as the grand marshals for the inauguration parade. It’s set for Dec. 10 in Frankfort. “In my first inauguration
Chicago: Teachers Union Members Endorse New Contract!

Members of the Chicago Teachers Union adopted the agreement reached with the Mayor that provides significant new benefits for students. This is now known as “Bargaining for the Common Good.” STATEMENT: For Immediate Release| ctulocal1.org CONTACT: Chris Geovanis, 312-329-6250 , 312-446-4939 (m) , ChrisGeovanis@ctulocal1.org CTU members vote overwhelmingly to accept tentative agreement New contrac

YESTERDAY

Peter Greene: Can the State of Ohio Outlaw Facts?

Perhaps you laughed, perhaps you were astonished when you read that Republicans in Ohio in the House voted for a law that would allow a student’s religious beliefs to give the wrong answers on science tests. Peter Greene shows that the proposed bill is even worse than we thought. He begins: It’s called the “Ohio Student Religious Liberties Act of 2019” and it sets out to accomplish a few things:
Florida: Teachers Reject Governor DeSantis’ Bonus Plan

The Florida Education Association rejected Governor Ron DeSantis’ bonus plan. Bonus plans have a long history of failure. Nov. 14, 2019 CONTACT: Joni Branch, (850) 201-3223 or (850) 544-7055 FEA reacts to DeSantis bonus plan announcement TALLAHASSEE — The Florida Education Association (FEA) was disappointed to learn Thursday that what Gov. Ron DeSantis envisions as a way to properly compensate ex
Pennsylvania: GOP Speaker Pushes DeVos Plan for Vouchers

Republican Mike Turzai, Speaker of the House in Pennsylvania, is encouraging the state to adopt the Betsy DeVos agenda for diverting public funds to religious and private schools. Turzai’s agenda is described here by Lawrence Feinberg, a school board member in Haverford Township and director of the Keystone State Education Coalition. Feinberg writes: The 2022 race for governor’s race has begun, a
North Carolina: A Mother Sends Her Children to a Charter School But Is Shocked When She Finds Out About the Real Estate Deal

Larry Lee, an education advocate and blogger in Alabama, posted the story of a North Carolina mother who enrolled her sons in charter school, taking a blind leap of faith. She is a diligent mother, so she attended board meetings and followed her sons’ progress closely. But then she inquired about who and what was behind this charter school and she was gobsmacked. Lee was interested in the story b
Ohio: House Passes Bill Allowing Students to Get Credit for Wrong Answers in Science If Answers Are Based on Their Religion

We are entering into a strange era where religious belief is being permitted to trump scientific fact. Ohio legislators in the House passed legislation allowing students to receive credit for wrong answers on science tests if their answer is based on their religious beliefs. Does anyone think that actions such as this one will prepare students to live and thrive in the modern world? Will students
Wisconsin: It’s Time to Hold Legislators Accountable for School Success!

The Resistance has opened a new front in Wisconsin! The proper place for accountability is at the top: with those who decide how much money is available, and those who write the laws and the mandates and the regulations. The legislature determines whether funding is available to reduce class size, to provide adequate staff, to offer appropriate compensation to those who work in the schools. The l
Wisconsin: Join the Resistance! Here! Now!

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Contacts: Heather DuBois Bourenane, Executive Director, Wisconsin Public Education Network, (608) 572-1696, hdb@WisconsinNetwork.org ; Dr. Julie Underwood, President of the Wisconsin Alliance for Excellent Schools board of directors, julie.madison.wisconsin@gmail.com , (608) 469-2287 View this release online here . Lawmakers Held Accountable for Votes on Education with Repor

NOV 14

Los Angeles: UTLA Endorses Bernie Sanders

Tonight, the United Teachers of Los Angeles endorsed Senator Bernie Sanders for the Democratic nomination for president. LOS ANGELES — United Teachers Los Angeles, the second-largest teachers’ local in the country, is proud to endorse Senator Bernie Sanders for US President in the 2020 Primary Election, making UTLA the first teachers’ union in the country to endorse a presidential candidate. Toni
Kentucky: Matt Bevin Concedes Defeat

The Kentucky governor’s race is over at last. Matt Bevin conceded defeat. Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin on Thursday conceded to Attorney General Andy Beshear after a recanvass of votes confirmed Mr. Beshear’s victory in last week’s governor’s election . “We’re going to have a change in the governorship based on the vote of the people,” Mr. Bevin, a Republican, said in a brief speech from a podium in f
Jack Hassard: Read the Transcript! No Quid Pro Quo! Bribery!

Jack Hassard, having taught science education for many years, is scrupulous about evidence. So he took seriously Trump’s demand that everyone read the transcript of his “perfect” phone call with the president of Ukraine. He gives a close reading to that transcript here. What transpired, he says, based on the transcript, was not a “quid pro quo.” A this-for-that can be completely legitimate: You m
Texas: A Power Grab to Squeeze the Public Out of Public Education

Parent activist Lynn Davenport posted this warning about a “public-private partnership” that leaves out the public. Corporate interests are plotting to privatize public schools while hiding behind the facade of the “portfolio model,” a term used to deceive the public of Grand Theft Public Schools. Davenport writes: The new oil in Midland is student data. The Midland Collective Impact initiative u
Walton Foundation and UNCF Collaborate to Lure Young African Americans into Disruption Movement

A friend share this link about a program in which the United Negro College Fund is funded by the far-right Walton Family Foundation to give summer internships to young African Americans to work in organizations that undermine public education, unions, and the teaching profession. The purpose of the program is to build a “robust pipeline of African Americans engaged in education reform in America.
Shawgi Tell: Charters Open and Close Like Day Lilies

Shawgi Tell is a professor of education at Nazareth College in New York. He points out that “More than 765 Charter Schools Have Closed in Three Years.” This is what Disrupters refer to as “high-quality seats.” Here today, gone tomorrow. Currently, about 3.2 million students are enrolled in roughly 7,000 privately-operated charter schools across the country. This represents less than 7% of all stu
Justin Parmenter: Why N.C. Governor Cooper Vetoed a Pay Raise for Teachers: It Was a Sham!

Justin Parmenter, an NBCT teacher in North Carolina, explains in this article why Democratic Governor Roy Cooper vetoed a pay raise for educators passed by the ultra-conservative state legislature. He begins: Asheville City Schools full-time instructional assistant Angel Redmond is in her 4th year with the school system and her 21st year in education. Angel has a degree in psychology, and her dut

NOV 13

CNN: Deval Patrick Will Enter the Democratic Primary Contest

CNN reports that former Governor Deval Patrick of Massachusetts will throw his hat in the ring. After leaving government, Patrick entered the private sector and was employed by Bain Capital, the same firm where Mitt Romney made his fortune. Patrick’s entry, like potential candidate Bloomberg, will weaken Joe Biden, the current front-runner in most states.
Nancy Bailey: Who Is to Blame for Poor NAEP Reading Scores? Here Are Their Names

Nancy Bailey read a list of organizations who were blaming teachers for not adhering to the “science” of reading and thus blaming teachers for NAEP reading scores. She got steamed and pointed out that none of these individuals or organizations criticizing teachers are known as teachers themselves. She got so steamed that she names names in this post. These are the organizations, she says, that ha
See This Documentary: “American Factory”

Reader David Kristofferson recommended this documentary , which is streaming on Netflix. I regret putting any money in Reed Hastings’ coffers, but this is a very compelling program. “American Factory” tells the story of a GM factory in Ohio that closed, putting thousands of workers out of work. A few years after the closing, a large Chinese company named Fuyao arrives to revive the factory, dedic
Laura Chapman: The Disrupters Refuse to Slink Away Despite Massive Failure

Last night there was a grand event at the Kennedy Center where veterans of the Bush and Obama education world joined together to wring their hands about the crisis at hand. The crisis is not the mess they made of American education for the past 20 years. The crisis is that the tests are not hard enough, the punishments are not tough enough, and the nation needs to buckle down and keep on testing
Leonie Haimson: Why NAEP Scores Went Flat or Declined

Leonie Haimson explains here why NAEP scores have been flat or declined for the past decade: the combination of the recession of 2008 (and its aftermath) and the Common Core was a hard blow to students and teachers. She writes: The poor results are most likely a consequence of several factors, including the damaging double whammy experienced by schools in 2009-2011 – when the great recession hit,
Campbell Brown’s “The 74” Does Not Like Elizabeth Warren

Campbell Brown was a CNN anchor. Then she became the new face of the Education Disruption movement after the disappearance of Michelle Rhee. Brown advocated for charters and vouchers and she opposed teachers’ unions and teacher tenure. She claimed in various articles in the New York City press that the schools were overrun by teachers who were sexual predators, protected by the union. She created
Gary Rubinstein: Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy Grows But Continues to Have High Attrition Rates

Gary Rubinstein read a story in the local Rupert Murdoch newspaper saluting Eva Moskowitz’s charter chain for its high SAT scores, but then noticed how many students were in the senior class . (Billionaire media mogul Rupert Murdoch is a multimillion-dollar donor to the Success Academy charter chain.) What school advertises its SAT scores? Success Academy! Gary noticed that of the students who st

NOV 12

The Secret to Trump’s Alliance with Turkey

A fascinating story appeared on the New York Times website tonight. The relationship is based on Jared Kushner’s friendships with Turkish sons-in-law. Guys like him. Read this: By David D. Kirkpatrick and Eric Lipton ISTANBUL — Behind President Trump’s accommodating attitude toward Turkey is an unusual back channel: a trio of sons-in-law who married into power and now play key roles in connecting
Support Little Rock Educators with a Donation

I hope you will join me by donating to Bread for Ed, which supports the strike of the teachers in Little Rock. The Walton-controlled State Board stripped them of their collective bargaining rights. They are demonstrating for their students, their right to organize, and for democracy.
Tonight! A Bipartisan Requiem (or Celebration) for the Failure of No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top

Political Morning Education reports a big event in D.C. tonight where partisans of the test-and-punish education policies of the past twenty years will gather to rededicate themselves to their failed programs. Will these advocates for accountability accept any accountability for the misguided practices they have foisted on American education? Will they hold themselves accountable for the billions
Little Rock: Teachers Will Strike This Thursday!

Grassroots Arkansas reports that the teachers of Little Rock will strike this Thursday. It will be a one-day strike. The State Board of Education (a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Walton family) stripped the local union of its collective bargaining rights and is trying to destroy and privatize public education in that city. For the billionaire Waltons, Little Rock is the petri dish that is near a
John Richard Schrock: Trump’s War Against Science

The federal government has an important role in the support and advancement of science. Science should be free of political influence. Decision making should not be based on partisanship. Yet, as science professor John Richard Schrock shows, politics have often intruded on decisions about which policies to fund and what to make public. He cites bad decisions over the years under both Republican a
Why Mike Klonsky Will Not Vote for Bloomberg

Mike Klonsky explains why he in not excited about the prospect of Michael Bloomberg’s candidacy for president. He writes: Why is this billionaire Republicrat media tycoon and former New York mayor even considering jumping into a crowded Democratic primary as a 14-to-1 longshot? He knows the odds as well as anyone. One, because he can afford to, and two, he wants to be a hedge against the progress
Breaking News: The Supreme Court Will Allow Sandy Hook Lawsuit Against Gun Manufacturer to Go Forward

A headline from the Boston Globe, just posted (I don’t have a link because, although I am a subscriber, the Globe website does not permit me to log in.) The Supreme Court is letting a lawsuit proceed against the maker of the rifle used in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting. The justices rejected an appeal Tuesday from Remington Arms that argued a 2005 federal law shields firearms manufactu
Jane Nylund: Oakland Is in the Sights of the “Destroy Public Education” Crowd, Who Control the Board

Jane Nylund, parent activist in Oakland, wrote the following warning after reading about the ouster of the Disrupters in Denver. Parents and activists and concerned citizens must organize and oust the agents of Disruption: Oakland also must flip 4 board seats next year. The Walton-bought board has recently closed two schools, Roots and Kaiser Elementary, and there is talk of accelerating the “Blu
New York Times: How Warren Plan Would Reduce Billionaires’ Fortunes

The New York Times published an analysis of how Elizabeth Warren’s tax plan would affect the giant fortunes of the nation’s billionaires. If you subscribe to the Times, you can see how each of the biggest billionaires is affected. Although they would pay big taxes, they would still be billionaires. Bill Gates denounced Warren’s plan at a Times-sponsored event, claiming that Warren would tax away

NOV 11

Charles Blow: Why You Must Never Vote for Bloomberg

Today in the New York Times, columnist Charles Blow wrote a scathing critique of Bloomberg, based on his “stop and frisk” policy. He wrote: Let me plant the stake now: No black person — or Hispanic person or ally of people of color — should ever even consider voting for Michael Bloomberg in the primary. His expansion of the notoriously racist stop-and-frisk program in New York, which swept up mil
Teresa Hanafin on Nikki Haley and Her Loyalty to the Orange One

Teresa Hanafin writes Fast Forward for the Boston Globe almost daily She wrote about Nikki Haley’s new book and her defense of Trump. Haley was on one of the cable talk shows and she said Trump should not be impeached because he did not get the Ukrainian president to hold a press conference and he did give Ukraine the money that Congress appropriated. This is akin to saying that a bank robber sho
D.C.: Charter Enrollment Declines for First Time Since 1996

While we are on the subject of the District of Columbia, here’s an interesting tidbit. Despite the drumbeat about “waiting lists,” charter enrollment declined, and enrollment in public schools increased. The numbers are not large but they seem to reflect a trend. Charter enrollment also declined in Michigan, DeVos’s domain. Maybe parents are getting tired of schools that open and close like day l
Valerie Jablow: D.C. Ripped Off By Charter Real Estate Deals

Valerie Jablow is a parent in D.C. whose blog follows the ethical scandals of public officials and the charter industry in her hometown. This one is a doozy. It is so crazy that I can’t summarize it. Somewhere in this Pink Panther-style story are the moneymakers. The guys who finance the real estate: Turner Agassi. Tennis star Andre Agassi opened his own charter school in Las Vegas. He promised t
33 Writers: Please Stop Using Term “Quid Pro Quo”

This letter appeared in the New York Times on To the Editor: A plea from 33 writers: Please use language that will clarify the issues at hand. Please stop using the Latin phrase “quid pro quo” regarding the impeachment inquiry. Most people don’t understand what it means, and in any case it doesn’t refer only to a crime. Asking for a favor is not a criminal act; we frequently demand things from fo
Dana Milbank Explains Quid Pro Quo

A column such as this one by Dana Milbank explains why I read the Washington Post every day. And it serves to remind us of the value of Latin (I took two years of Latin in high school and wish I had studied it for four years. Regrets.) He writes: Et tu, Mulvaney? Three weeks ago, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi unveiled the impeachment inquiry with a Latin phrase spoken by Julius Caesar when he crosse
New York Times: Elizabeth Warren Is Making Billionaires Nervous

The New York Times published an editorial chastising the billionaires who are outraged by Senator Warren’s proposed tax on billionaires. No plan emerges through Congressional hearings unscathed, and you can bet K Street lobbyists will work overtime to protect the nation’s 607 billionaires. The Times said: When Bill Gates founded Microsoft in 1975, the top marginal tax rate on personal income was

NOV 10

Peter Greene Explains Why Market Forces Do Not Provide Charter School Accountability

Charter promoters have long argued that traditional forms of accountability like auditing and financial and academic oversight are unnecessary because the magic of the market will hold them accountable. If parents enroll their children, that is all the accountability that is necessary. Peter Greene explains in this article why the market does not create accountability for charter schools. It has
Bill Phillis: An Experiment in Ohio That Will Probably Never Be Repeated

Bill Phillis, retired deputy commissioner of the state education department, is a watchdog for Ohio schools, especially finances. Charter schools in Ohio are called “community schools.” He writes: 2015 Auditor of State Report on Community School Student Attendance Counts In 2014, the State Auditor’s office conducted an unannounced head count in 30 Ohio site-based charter schools. One charter had
Jan Resseger Reviews Andrea Gabor’s Dissection of the New Orleans “Miracle”

Jan Resseger is one of the keenest analysts of the assault on public education today. In this post , she reviews Andrea Gabor’s excellent article in Harper’s magazine about the privatized district of New Orleans. She begins: When Hurricane Katrina struck New Orleans in September of 2005, I was serving in the Justice & Witness Ministries of the United Church of Christ, a mainline Protestant denomi
John Thompson: How Billionaire “Reformers” Messed Up the Public Schools of Tulsa

John Thompson, historian and recently retired teacher in Oklahoma, assays the damage that corporate reformers and their patrons have inflicted on the public schools of Tulsa. The district is overflowing with Broadies and has Gates money. What could possibly go wrong? The Tulsa Public Schools (TPS) offers an excellent case study in data-driven, market-driven school reform. Before No Child Left Beh

NOV 09

David Dayen: Thumbs Down on Bloomberg Candidacy

The Billionaires are not happy with the recent rise of Elizabeth Warren. They don’t like her proposal to tax people with more than $50 million. Bill Gates hinted that he might vote for Trump over Warren. The nerve of that woman, threatening to tax the 1%! Now it seems that another billionaire might join the race. David Dayen of The American Prospect is not pleased. November 8, 2019 Dayen on TAP O
A Gift for You: A Fabulous Production of “42nd Street”

If you love Broadway musicals as much as I do, you will love this PBS Great Performances production of the classic “42nd Street.” The show will no longer be available after November 29; after that date, you will have to pay to view it. I have seen the original movie and I have seen the show twice on Broadway. This is the best production yet. It is a stunning use of cinematography to capture the t
Philadelphia: Kendra Brooks Made History in the Election!

For the first time in 70 years, a third-Party Candidate was elected to the City Council in Philadelphia. Kendra Brooks of the Working Families Party just won a seat that has long been Republican. Working Families Party candidate Kendra Brooks held an insurmountable lead of 10,000 votes over her nearest rival, according to unofficial election returns. The insurgent third-party candidate, who campa
William Mathis: What to Do with a Dead Horse? Beat It Even Harder.

William Mathis, a member of the Vermont Board of Education and managing director of the National Education Policy Center, reviews reactions to the dismal scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP). The people who inflicted high-stakes testing insist that more and more and more testing is needed. More of the same policies that have already failed will surely work if we keep d


Nancy Bailey: If Only Students Could Sue Betsy DeVos and the Corporate Reformers for the Damage They Have Done

Nancy Bailey writes here about the long-term damage that corporate reformers (the Disruption movement) have inflicted on two generations of students. If only students could sue them for ruining their schools! If only teachers could sue 


Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all