Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, August 6, 2012

Shanker Blog » Schools Aren't The Only Reason Test Scores Change

Shanker Blog » Schools Aren't The Only Reason Test Scores Change:


Schools Aren’t The Only Reason Test Scores Change

In all my many posts about the interpretation of state testing data, it seems that I may have failed to articulate one major implication, which is almost always ignored in the news coverage of the release of annual testing data. That is: raw, unadjusted changes in student test scores are not by themselves very good measures of schools’ test-based effectiveness.
In other words, schools can have a substantial impact on performance, but student test scores also increase, decrease or remain flat for reasons that have little or nothing to do with schools. The first, most basic reason is error. There is measurement error in all test scores – for various reasons, students taking the same test twice will get different scores, even if their “knowledge” remains constant. Also, as I’ve discussed many times, there isextra imprecision when using cross-sectional data. Often, any changes in scores or rates, especially when