Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, December 17, 2010

Job candidate sues UK, claiming religion cost him the post | courier-journal.com | The Courier-Journal

Job candidate sues UK, claiming religion cost him the post | courier-journal.com | The Courier-Journal

Job candidate sues UK, claiming religion cost him the post

BY PETER SMITH • PSMITH@COURIER-JOURNAL.COM • DECEMBER 10, 2010

No one denies that astronomer Martin Gaskell was the leading candidate for the founding director of a new observatory at the University of Kentucky in 2007 — until his writings on evolution came to light.

Gaskell had given lectures to campus religious groups around the country in which he said that while he has no problem reconciling the Bible with the theory of evolution, he believes the theory has major flaws. And he recommended students read theory critics in the intelligent-design movement.

That stance alarmed UK science professors and, the university acknowledges, played a role in the job going to another candidate.

Now a federal judge says Gaskell has a right to a jury trial over his allegation that he lost the job because he is a Christian and "potentially evangelical."

“The record contains substantial evidence that Gaskell was a leading candidate for the position until the issue of his religion or his scientific position became an issue,” U.S. Senior District Judge Karl