Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, June 25, 2017

CURMUDGUCATION: Problems with Performance-Based Compensation

CURMUDGUCATION: Problems with Performance-Based Compensation:

Problems with Performance-Based Compensation


Bellwether Education Partners want to overcome the obstacles standing in the way of performance-based compensation (aka "merit pay" aka "fun ways to reduce total personnel costs for a school district"). But if you want writer Jen Bolson Meer's fancy definition, that's "Performance-based compensation is an approach where some or all monetary compensation is related to how employee performance is assessed relative to stated criteria."

Meer takes a moment to attack the traditional steps and lanes payment system. Advanced degrees and years of experience, she says, do not make teachers any better. And by "better" we mean "correlated to higher student scores on a narrow, invalid Big Standardized Test." That's pretty much the only way we could hope to make the absurd argument that neither additional education nor years of experience make teachers any better at our jobs. 

That argument poorly made, Meer is on to her main point. Why is there no model, no "playbook" for PBC in the teaching world. Meer says that's because in all versions, there are winners and losers. She has three possible versions of PBC

1) Stick with a traditional “step and lanes” system, but teachers only move up a step if they meet a minimum specified level of performance

Nobody gets a raise unless she makes her numbers; "ineffective" teachers would stay stalled on a single step for years, just like all of the teachers in places like North Carolina. Meer says that winners would be programs that benefitted from  the "freed up" money saved  by all the people not getting raises. 

There are two problems with that. One is that money would be "freed up" which h is an idea carried 
CURMUDGUCATION: Problems with Performance-Based Compensation:

Seattle Schools Community Forum: A New Twist at the Board Meeting This Week

Seattle Schools Community Forum: A New Twist at the Board Meeting This Week:

A New Twist at the Board Meeting This Week

Image result for New Twist ANIMATED GIF

The Board is having a special Work Session this week along with the regular Board meeting.   The Work Session will address:

There will be a special School Board work session on June 28 to discuss the budget, waitlist process and a path forward. The work session will take place at the beginning of the regularly scheduled School Board meeting. 

Additional Background: The district has started to move waitlists at Option Schools where seats are available, and at attendance area schools that can accommodate additional students with their current staffing allocations. At the June 28 work session, staff will present recommendations on waitlist moves, various scenarios and implications.  
A path forward on what?  Waitlists or the budget?

They have scheduled an hour for this -from 4:20 pm-5:20 pm- and must adhere to that schedule in order to keep the rest of the Board meeting on time.  You CANNOT speak at the Work Session but testimony to the Board will start at 5:30 pm.  (I see that the agenda includes both the Superintendent's Comments and the Consent Agenda from 5:20-5:30 pm which seems very short.)   

I would say that the Board needs to make clear to staff there MUST be time for 
Seattle Schools Community Forum: A New Twist at the Board Meeting This Week:




Schools Matter: Ravitch for "eventual absorption" of Charter Schools

Schools Matter: Ravitch for "eventual absorption" of Charter Schools:

Ravitch for "eventual absorption" of Charter Schools

Image result for NPE issues a position statement on charter schools

Diane Ravitch's Network for Public Education (NPE) recently published a position statement on charter schools that directly challenges her widely-heralded commitment to quality public schools for all children who choose them.

NPE's new statement on charter schools explicitly acknowledges that Ravitch and her corporate union patrons support the continued operation of the nation’s 7,500 segregated charter schools, now draining away billions of public dollars each year for the principal benefit of racist corporate colonizers in urban communities (my bolds): 

. . . we recognize that many families have come to depend on charter schools and that many charter school teachers are dedicated professionals who serve their students well. It is also true that some charter schools are successful. We do not, therefore, call for the immediate closure of all charter schools, but rather we advocate for their eventual absorption into the public school system. We look forward to the day when charter schools are governed not by private boards, but by those elected by the community, at the district, city or county level. 



Unfortunately for the supporters of quality public schools for all children who choose them, NPE offers no plan for how Schools Matter: Ravitch for "eventual absorption" of Charter Schools:


Federal Education Policy History – A nonpartisan educational resource

Federal Education Policy History – A nonpartisan educational resource:

Federal Education Policy History
A nonpartisan educational resource


Image result for Federal Education Policy History


White People Keep Finding New Ways to Segregate Schools – Mother Jones

White People Keep Finding New Ways to Segregate Schools – Mother Jones:

White People Keep Finding New Ways to Segregate Schools

As schools across the country continue to become more segregated, a collection of towns is making the problem even worse.



For the past few years, residents in the city of Gardendale, Alabama, have been pushing to take over a county high school, a middle school, and two elementary schools from the greater Jefferson County school system, one of several districts still bound by a federal desegregation order. Residents argue that they want local control. The city’s mayor went so far as to tell the Washington Post that it was about “keeping our tax dollars here with our kids, rather than sharing them with kids all over Jefferson County.” Opponents of the plan, though, claim the move is mired in racial overtones and the pursuit of a divided system that benefits Gardendale’s families at the expense of others in the county. 
In April, a federal judge ruled that although the community’s efforts to separate from the countywide district were in fact racially motivated, Gardendale could start its own district of 2,134 students this fall with two elementary schools and could eventually purchase a $55 million high school from Jefferson County, as long as it established a court-approved desegregation plan within three years. That plan, though, is now on hold—both the case’s plaintiffs, who wanted to block the split, and Gardendale’s attorneys, who were upset the judge’s ruling gave them two schools instead of the desired four, opted to appeal the decision to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. 
Gardendale is just one of many communities—often small, wealthier enclaves—which have attempted to secede from larger school districts across the country over the past 15 years, sparking a nationwide debate about modern segregation.
report released this week by the education nonprofit EdBuild documents the reach of the movement. Since 2000, researchers find, there have been 71 attempts by communities to secede from larger school districts, and, so far, 47 communities have been successful. Another nine, from Malibu, California, to Daphne, Alabama, are currently considering breaking away. Yet another nine community’s plans have White People Keep Finding New Ways to Segregate Schools – Mother Jones:
 Image result for big education ape segregation

Image result for big education ape segregation

Image result for big education ape segregation
Image result for big education ape segregation

Florida files criminal charges against Akron-area charter school founder - News 5 Cleveland

Florida files criminal charges against Akron-area charter school founder - News 5 Cleveland:

Florida files criminal charges against Akron-area charter school founder



FAIRLAWN, Ohio - According to our partners at the Akron Beacon Journal and Ohio.com, the founder of Newpoint Education Partners and Cambridge Education is facing racketeering charges for improperly using private and public funds earmarked for students’ education.
Florida State Attorney William “Bill” Eddins charges that Marcus May used thousands of dollars parents paid for student lunches and uniforms and millions more from Ohio and Florida taxpayers to pay for home mortgages, plastic surgery, world travel, credit card debt and more.
Criminal charges filed last week in Florida against Marcus May also allege he improperly used private and public funds earmarked for students’ education to expand his charter school empire in Columbus, Akron, Cleveland and Dayton. Company officials told Akron Beacon Journal and Ohio.com they have asked for May's resignation.
The Fairlawn company's website says it serves 3,000 students at 24 charter schools in Cleveland, Cincinnati, Dayton, Columbus, Akron, Youngstown and Canton.
The website states that Charter Education uses "two school models; K–8 and Dropout Prevention (DOP) High School," with a mission  to:
"...dedicate ourselves to improving the lives of the students we serve by providing authentic learning experiences in a collaborative, nurturing environment that will build a foundation for students’ success in school, at future work, and in life."Florida files criminal charges against Akron-area charter school founder - News 5 Cleveland:


The Whole Newpoint Charter School Scandal  – Rick’s Blog -http://ricksblog.biz/?p=53801


Eid Mubarak: Eid al-Fitr 2017: When is it, how do Muslims around the world celebrate and why does the date change? | The Independent

Eid al-Fitr 2017: When is it, how do Muslims around the world celebrate and why does the date change? | The Independent:

Eid al-Fitr 2017: When is it, how do Muslims around the world celebrate and why does the date change?

It is the 'festival of breaking the fast' and comes at the end of the month of Ramadan 

Image result for Eid Mubarak


Every year across the globe Muslims gather together to celebrate Eid as the month-long fasting of Ramadan comes to an end.
Eid al-Fitr translates from Arabic as the “festival of breaking the fast” and involves a range of celebrations as friends, family and the entire Muslim community come together.
The exact date of Eid is yet to be determined as it depends on the lunar cycle but we know it is likely to be on one of two days at the end of June.
Here is everything you need to know about Eid-al-Fitr:

When is Eid?

Eid will take place on either Sunday 25 or Monday 26 June.
Saudi Arabia announced the first day of Eid will be held on Sunday, 25 June, with Turkey and Muslim communities in Europe, Australia and North America set to follow.
However, Bangladesh, India and Pakistan are likely to begin their celebrations on Monday, 26 June.
As the Islamic calendar is based on the lunar cycle, the day is set when a new moon is sighted – but there is no exact definition of what this means. 
There is little agreement within the faith about whether the moon must be spotted with the naked eye or not and whether it should be seen in the country where the celebrations are happening.
The result of the varying interpretations of the rule is that Eid falls on a different day depending on what sect, mosque or region you are in.
As there are either 354 or 355 days in the Islamic year, the day that Eid falls on in the Gregorian calendar changes annually.

Why are Muslims celebrating?

Muslims have been fasting and going without food and water from dawn to sunset for an entire month. As the days are longer during the summer, Muslims in the UK are fasting for 19 hours a day.
Fasting during the holy month of Ramadan is one of the five pillars of Islam and Muslims believe that it was during this month the Quran was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad. The end of Ramadan is greeted with the celebration of Eid-al-Fitr.

How do Muslims celebrate Eid?

Traditionally, Eid is celebrated for three days and is a national holiday in Muslim countries. In the UK most people tend to celebrate for a day and will take a day off work and school.
Like with most holidays, people celebrate differently, but Muslims will gather together at the mosque for a prayer in the morning and then spend the day with friends and family.
As it’s the first day for a month where food can be eaten during daylight hours, more often than not a lot of it is served up during the celebrations!

What is the difference in Eid-al-Fitr and Eid-al-Adha?

There are two Eids every year. Eid-al-Fitr translates to “festival of breaking the fast” and marks the end of the month of Ramadan, whereas Eid-al-Adha, which takes place two months later, is the festival which coincides with the annual pilgrimage to Mecca.
It is also known as the “sacrifice feast” and honours Prophet Abraham's sacrifice of his son Ishmael, as an act of submission to God's command.

How to wish someone a nice Eid

The phrase commonly used by Muslims is “Eid Mubarak”, which is Arabic for blessed Eid.
Those who are celebrating will greet each other with this phrase throughout the day.Eid al-Fitr 2017: When is it, how do Muslims around the world celebrate and why does the date change? | The Independent:
Image result for Eid Mubarak

Star Date 2017: What is the State of the Resistance to the War?

Star Date 2017: What is the State of the Resistance to the War?:

Star Date 2017: What is the State of the Resistance to the War?

Pleas e join Internet radio host Dr. James Avington Miller Jr. for an interactive show about the state of the War on Public Education.

STAR DATE 2017: CAPTAIN'S LOG: The state of the resistance to the War on Public Schools, Teachers, Families, and communities will be discussed, studied, considered, and exposed.

Dr. Miller wants you to call in and respond:
WHAT SAY YOU TO THESE QUESTION?
IS THERE A REAL RESISTANCE?
HAS THERE EVER BEEN A REAL RESISTANCE?
If SO - BY WHO? WHEN? WHERE? HOW?

What is your assessment? 

Are we winning the war?

Are we losing the war?
Is there a standoff?

WHAT SAY YOU????

This is our lives, careers, and futures. Please call in and express your feelings and emotions on these questions.

Silence is NOT an option.

RESISTANCE MATTERS
RESISTANCE IS NOT FUTILE
RESISTANCE IS THE HIGHEST FORM OF EXPRESSION OF DEMOCRACY 
RESISTANCE IS SURVIVAL

Please click on the website below to listen live:


2:00 PM PDT
4:00 PM CDT
5:00 PM EDT
or
A direct listen-in line only
Station 1 - 716-748-0150
To call-in and interact live
Station 1 888-627-6008 toll free



Image result for captains log animated gif

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: What Day Is It Now Edition + Catch up with CURMUDGUCATION

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: What Day Is It Now Edition (6/25):

ICYMI: What Day Is It Now Edition


I'm pretty sure that before this summer is over, I will miss one of these Sunday reading lists, because the three week old twins in my house exert some sort of time warping field. But today I'm on it. Here are some things to read from the past week. And remember-- if you like it, pass it on. 

Um, Teacher Retention Is Not Just a DCPS Problem 

Despite the fact that they are reportedly more awesome than ever, DC public schools are having some trouble holding onto staff. Go figure. A look at why schools might be having such problems.

Why Teachers Suck..

Yes, you know it's going to be the reverse, but a nice addition to the Clever Attateacher files

Is School Choice Just Expanding Privilege 

That is the question. Does school choice cut into support for students who needed the most in the first place?

When a Community Loses Its Schools

Closing schools comes with a number of prices, including costs to the community at large.

Intersection of Philanthropy and Dark Money

There are many, many, many dollars being thrown behind ed reform. Exactly where are they coming from? 

The Structure of Educational Reform

You'll probably disagree with a lot of this (I certainly do). But Andy Smarick remains the refomster most likely to take a thoughtful look at the tension between the goals of reform and traditional conservatism.

Charter Schools Do Bad Stuff Because They Can

Jeff Bryant gives a well-sourced overview of charter misbehavior.

Things That Principals Know About Great Teachers

Another piece cheering on the real qualities of actual teachers. At a minimum, food for thought.

White People Keep Finding New Ways To Segregate Schools

From Mother Jones, a piece that looks at ed reform through a different lens, and shows how creative white folks have been about getting their children away from black and brown students.

Newpoint Charges As Bad As We Reported

A careful look at one Florida charter scam. It's worth studying, because this model can be pulled off in many states.

ECOT Continues Tax Funded Ad Blitz Despite Layoff Announcement

Ohio's premiere cyber school is in trouble. The state wants its money back because ECOT's been lying about enrollment. ECOT is laying off hundreds of workers. But somehow they can still spend taxpayer dollars on advertising.

Putting the "i" in School

The latest Have You Heard podcast from Jennifer Berkshire and Jack Schneider looks at personalized learning

Well-Funded Non-Profits Pave the Way to Privatization

Over at Living in Dialogue, John Thompson has been taking a look at the book The Givers, a tough look at what modern philanthropy is doing to our society.

The Fart-Free Classroom

A look at the practical reality of negotiating with 160 different persons in your classroom, every day.


 CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: What Day Is It Now Edition (6/25):

Catch up with CURMUDGUCATION


Defending Kids Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Defending Kids Diane Ravitch's blog
A site to discuss better education for all





Ohio: ECOT Uses Taxpayer $$ to Fight Accountability

The Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow (ECOT) has collected hundreds of millions of dollars from Ohio taxpayers to pay for online schooling st home. The owner of ECOT makes large campaign gifts to legislators. The “school” delivers 

New Mexico: TFA Alum Takes the Reins as State Chief

Many teachers in New Mexico were relieved when Hanna Skandera resigned as Commissioner of the Public Education Department. Skandera never met the minimum legal requirement to hold the post; she had never been a teacher. She was a protege of Jeb Bush and wanted to bring the Florida model of high-stakes testing, accountability, and privatization to New Mexico. She subscribed to her mentor’s radical


Denver: I’m With Tay for the Denver School Board!

Denver has a seven-member school board that is completely controlled by corporate reformers from Democrats for Education Reform and others with no stake in the schools other than to push more testing and more privatization. 

Jeff Bryant: Why Is There Bipartisan Support for Charter Scams and Corruption?

Jeff Bryant points out an irony that should enrage every taxpayer and citizen: Both major political parties love charter schools, despite the numerous scandals that accompany unregulated, unaccountable charters. http://educationopportunitynetwork.org/charter-schools-do-bad-stuff-because-they-can/ Here is a part of his great piece on the malfeasance that is now commonplace in the charter industry.
Steven Singer: A Radical Proposal to Provide an Excellent Education for Every Child

Steven Singer finds that there is a missing ingredient in the present discourse about School Reform. Reformers think they have made great strides if they open more opportunities for choice. What reformers have not been willing to do is to guarantee that every child has the right to an excellent education. We know what excellent education looks like. It is the education that the 1% demand for thei

YESTERDAY

A Question for Facebook Users

I have had complaints from regular readers that they are unable to put my blog posts on Facebook. A reader wrote this earlier today: “When I try to share your blog from Word Press on Facebook only your name shows up many times. Just tried it with your messages about Arizona and James Wilson. Does Zuckerberg not like you? I don’t know if others have this problem but I think you are being censored.
New Jersey: The Plot to Preserve Christie’s Control of State Board of Education Thickens

I wrote earlier that Chris Christie, evidently the most unpopular governor in New Jersey’s history, is dumping the president and vice-president of the state board of education so he can continue to control education after he has left office. If he has his way, his cold, dead hand will strangle public education long after he is replaced. I got more information from a member of Save Our Schools NJ,
Indianapolis: Public Protest on Tuesday Against School Closings and Privatization

Parents and teachers will gather in Indianapolis on Tuesday to protest the ongoing corporate assault on public schools. 5:15 pm in front of IPS headquarters It is NOT about the kids. It is NOT students first. It is all about the money transferred from public schools to private bank accounts. “Community coalition to demonstrate Tues at IPS. The group intends to challenge the Mind Trust/Stand for C
New Jersey: Lame Duck Governor Christie Deposes Leaders of State School Board

With time running out on his term as Governor, Chris Christie removed the president and vice-president of the state school board. Critics said he was trying to lock in his control of the board long after his tenure in office. Christie has battled with the teachers union and favors privatization of public education. Although New Jersey is one of the top performing states in the nation, Christie re
Scott Sargrad: Invest in Public Schools, Not Vouchers

Scott Sargrad is in charge of K-12 education policy at the Center for American Policy. CAP has been one of the leading advocates for privately managed charters. This article explains in lucid pros e why vouchers are a terrible strategy and how they actually harm most children who use them. He could have written the same article about charters, which suck money and top students away from public sc
James Wilson: It Is Wrong to Expect All Students to Meet Requirements Designed for Elite Students

James Wilson believes that it is harmful to youth to expect all to meet the same rigorous academic standards. Some will excel in career and technical education or other fields. He writes: “The imposition of the University of California A-G entrance requirements on all high school students is inappropriate and extremely harmful. The UC system was constructed to be a system of elite universities fo
Arizona: Acute Teacher Shortage, 22% of Teachers Not Fully Qualified

After years of underfunding public education and diverting money to charters and vouchers, Arizona is coping with an acute teacher shortage. “On a Saturday in late April, Principal Theresa Nickolich gave her best recruiting pitch to every person who walked in the door. “Come teach at Clarendon Elementary School in the Osborn School District, she told the candidates at the job fair. “You’ll be par


SHOCKER! Massive Charter Scandal Stretches from Ohio to Florida

The Akron Beacon-Joirnal reports on a multi-state charter scandal. “The founder of an Akron-area charter school company is accused of using thousands of dollars parents paid for student lunches and uniforms and millions more from 
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: