Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, February 11, 2013

MORNING UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 2-11-13 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch




New Orleans Reform Group: Choice Falls Short

As we all know, New Orleans has been presented as a national model of school reform: eliminate public schools, open lots of charters staffed by inexperienced young teachers, watch for miraculous results.
But now a major promoter of the all-charter model–the Cowen Institute at Tulane University– has released a



The Fleecing of Public Education

This is a guest post by Peter DeWitt on a topic that should concern us all.
We lack the infrastructure to be testing factories, and that shouldn’t be our job in the first place.
If the nightly news really wanted to look into the Fleecing of America, they need not look further than the serious fleecing that companies are doing to American schools. At a time when school budgets are being severely cut, 



Providence, RI, Students Plan “Zombie” Protest Against High-StakesTesting

Students in Providence, Rhode Island, will hold a Zombie protest against high-stakes testing outside the Rhode Island Department of Education headquarters on Wednesday afternoon.
State Commissioner Deborah Gist may not be there, as she is participating in a conference at the conservative 



1% Elite Vs. Steve Zimmer in L.A.

The 1% really really really wants to beat Steve Zimmer.
Zimmer is a member of the Los Angeles school board who is up for re-election.
He is a former teacher (and TFA) in Los Angeles.
He is the target of a heavily funded campaign to oust him.
The LA Fund for Public Education (controlled by Superintendent Deasey) has paid for billboards featuring a 


How Florida Politicians Are Wrecking the Schools

You may be lucky enough (or unlucky enough) to hear Jeb Bush boasting about the “Florida miracle.”
A useful contrast to his spiel is the story of this teacher in Florida, who is leaving a job she loved.
She didn’t want to leave, but it became clear to her and some of her colleagues that the politicians had taken control and squeezed the joy out of teaching and learning.
The politicians “came up with grandiose-sounding programs, such as “No Child Left Behind,” which instead 


Must-Read: The Inside Story of the Texas Testing Debacle

Tom Pauken has written a fascinating and informative article about how Texas became the leader of the testing movement and how testing became an instrument to destroy local control.
Pauken is a prominent Republican. He just concluded a term on the Texas Workforce Commission.
He became an outspoken opponent of the testing regime, as he saw that it was bad for students and bad for the workforce.
The only beneficiary of the testing obsession seems to be the testing company Pearson, which won a contract 

Warning to College Profs: Here Comes the NCLB Generation!

Kenneth Bernstein recently retired as a high school teacher of government.
He regularly blogs as Teacherken at the Daily Kos, which is how I met him. He is–and I hesitate to write this–an almost saintly man, deeply devoted to students, teaching, education, and the betterment of humanity.
In this article, written in the journal of the American Association of University Professors, Ken explains to the professoriate that the students of the NCLB generation are woefully unprepared for the intellectual demands of college.
Please do not blame their teachers, he writes. Their teachers were compelled by federal policy to teach to tests 

Everything You Wanted to Know About Michelle Rhee

 
Here is Michelle Rhee, as reviewed by Mercedes Schneider in part viii of her study of the board of the National Council of Teacher Quality.
Mercedes Schneider is a teacher in Louisiana who holds a Ph.D. In statistics and research methods.
Here she is at her best, doing a close examination of the life and work of Michelle Rhee.

My Vacation in Cuba

I just returned from an amazing week in Cuba. I went there legally, from Miami to Havana.
I wanted to go someplace warm in mid-winter but I didn’t want to sit on a beach in the sun. I wanted to learn. It took quite a lot of digging to discover that the U.S. government has granted licenses to a number of tour agencies to arrange trips to Cuba for U.S. citizens.
Last November, a high school chum in Houston told me she had just returned from Cuba, and she gave me the name of her agent, who is based in New York City. Her name is Myriam Castillo, and I found her via this article in Forbes because she doesn’t have a website. Some of the other agencies that organize people-to-people trips 

Diane in the Evening 2-10-13 Diane Ravitch's blog

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 5 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog: Georgia: “The Chaos Theory of Running Our Schools” by dianerav Myra Blackmon, a columnist for the Athens, Georgia, Banner-Herald, explains how the state legislature is determined to destabilize and disrupt public education with a wacky “parent trigger” bill. Read her terrific analysis here. It won’t do anything to improve education nor will it “empower” parents, but it will make ALEC and others advocates of privatization very happy. Amazing Reporting on New Orleans Charters by dianerav Bobby Jindal went to Virginia to boast of the miraculous transformation ... more »

UPDATE: The pension fight at street level + Stop closing Chicago public schools + John Dillon. Repesentative Sosnowski’s constitutional amendment. Say it ain’t so, Joe. « Fred Klonsky

John Dillon. Repesentative Sosnowski’s constitutional amendment. Say it ain’t so, Joe. « Fred Klonsky:


The pension fight at street level.

The leadership of the We Are One coalition of Illinois public employee unions is holding their pension summit with legislative leaders today. It is scheduled for 1PM in Burr Ridge.
The Governor says he will drop by.
State Democratic Party Chairman who happens to be House Speaker Michael Madigan told We Are One to drop dead.
Meeting with the legislative leaders is the right thing for the unions to do. The legislative leaders are the ones 



Stop closing Chicago public schools.

darwin school
My kids are all grown up now. I have grand kids who go to public school in Brooklyn.
On these chilly Chicago mornings I walk Ulysses at about 7:30. Just as kids are walking to Darwin Elementary School.
Our neighborhood school. My neighborhood school for 40 years.
Some of the older kids walk by themselves. The younger ones walk with a parent.
Last week a dad was trying to walk the dog and his young son who obviously decided he wanted to ride his bike 


John Dillon. Repesentative Sosnowski’s constitutional amendment. Say it ain’t so, Joe.

tumblr_lp85ad0HxA1qkyl0xo1_500-1
In the Shakespearian tragicomedy Merchant of Venice, a seminal moment arrives when the evil moneylender Shylock demands his pound of flesh to be cut off nearest the heart of loan-victim Antonio.  Defenders of the threatened plaintiff beseech the judge to reconsider the ridiculousness of the original contract, one ultimately ending in the death of another.  The judge, a brilliant and disguised heroine, warns that it cannot be done: breaking contracts would set a precedent in the state which would result in the destruction of all confidence in Venice and with its business partners beyond the sea. 

Teachers Rock in School: But what about out of School? – @ the chalk face

Teachers Rock in School: But what about out of School? – @ the chalk face:


Teachers Rock in School: But what about out of School?

pov1pov2At this point you’re probably aware of my dissatisfaction with Jon Stewart and his tepid interview with the “radical” Michelle Rhee.  OK I’m moving on–from Jon–not Rhee.
I want to go back to one of the statements that she made in the interview.  However, if you have the stomach to do so and follow Ms. Rhee, you know she makes this statement regularly:
The research is very clear.  That of all the in school factors that exist, it’s the quality of the teacher in the front of the classroom everyday that has the most impact…
And what about OUT OF SCHOOL FACTORS?
Like

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: WEEKEND QUOTABLES

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: WEEKEND QUOTABLES:


WEEKEND QUOTABLES

Diane Ravitch
The embargo seems as antique as the now ancient slogans.The sooner the embargo is lifted, the sooner there will be normal relations between our countries. -- My vacation in Cuba
Wendy Lecker, Connecticut Adocate
It is time for both parents and taxpayers to wake up. Millions upon millions of our hard-earned tax 

A teacher evaluation session out of ‘Star Wars’

A teacher evaluation session out of ‘Star Wars’:


A teacher evaluation session out of ‘Star Wars’

yodaThink “Star Wars.” That’s how award-winning Principal Carol Burris of South Side High School in New York frames her newest post on Year Two of New York’s controversial educator evaluation system. Burris has for more than a year chronicled on this blog (here and here and here, for example) the implementation of the system, which ignores research by using student standardized test scores to assess teachers and which has already started tonegatively impact young people. Burris, named the 2010 New York State Outstanding Educator by the School Administrators Association of New York State, is the co-author of the New York Principals letter of concern regarding the evaluation of teachers by student test scores. It has been signed by more than 1,535 New York principals and more than 

A REAL paradigm shift in education

American public education has been in trouble for a lot longer than many people believe, according to the author of the following post. He is Marion Brady, a classroom teacher for years who has written history and world culture textbooks … Continue reading →

Legislation Alert: Student Assessment Bill 5587, Online Learning Bills HB 1431 and HB 1423 « Seattle Education

Legislation Alert: Student Assessment Bill 5587, Online Learning Bills HB 1431 and HB 1423 « Seattle Education:


Legislation Alert: Student Assessment Bill 5587, Online Learning Bills HB 1431 and HB 1423

Is a High-Stakes Testing Moratorium Possible in Florida? | Scathing Purple Musings

Is a High-Stakes Testing Moratorium Possible in Florida? | Scathing Purple Musings:


Is a High-Stakes Testing Moratorium Possible in Florida?

For such an idea to be taken seriously, the voice had to belong to someone of significance. It does. Powerful Senate President Don Gaetz hasn’t been backing off his statement that there’s danger that Florida’s entire accountability system could implode. Now this is an interview with the editors of the Panama City News Herald:
Having Gaetz — who’s hardly a squish on education reform — on board should persuade the rest of Capitol to take a giant step back and re-evaluate.
Not only did the Niceville Republican express well-deserved skepticism of the teacher evaluat

UPDATE: The Vote for the Levies + Seattle Schools Community Forum: Music Teachers - The Grammys Appreciate You

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Music Teachers - The Grammys Appreciate You:


House Finance Committee to Hear From Taskforce on Ed Funding

The House Finance Committee will be convening at 1:30 p.m. to receive a briefing from the Joint Task Force on Education Funding on funding K-12 public education under McCleary.

You can watch live here.  I was told by Chair Reuven Carlyle's office that the tape usually makes its way onto the log for viewing later within several hours. 


The Vote for the Levies

That deadline for that vote is now a little more than 36 hours away.  Frankly, I doubt there are that many undecided votes out there.  (I think no matter the outcome, the voting patterns will be interesting to watch as they may be an early warning for the Board elections in November.)

No matter the vote, we do need to pull together as a district.  The unity of purpose of parents is just as important as it is for the Board or district staff.   Parents and communities ARE the best voice for our district.

I think the discussion around the interim plan for next year has been interesting to view because it shows the need to find regional solutions.  To that end I would hope that PTA presidents in each of the five regions (or however many people feel is important) would join together to work for solutions.  (I know that most of the PTA presidents in the NE did indeed meet but unfortunately, it did not include all of them and decisions were made 


Music Teachers - The Grammys Appreciate You

From Citizens for Public Schools:

Something amazing happened at the Grammy tonight, a new category has been established, an award to the best music teacher of the year. Could someone with connections, please let the members of the Grammy know that due to NCLB and Race To The Top, music teachers have become extinct in most urban U.S. cities? So, maybe the Grammy could use their influence and contact our President to let him know how much more important music education is to high stake testing!

From the NY Times:


The Grammy Awards are adding a new honor for music teachers. Neil Portnow, the president of the National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences, announced the new award for music educators, which will be 

Districts to seek NCLB waiver whether or not they’re invited | EdSource Today

Districts to seek NCLB waiver whether or not they’re invited | EdSource Today:


A collaborative of California school districts known as the California Office to Reform Education, or CORE, plans to move forward with its application for a waiver from the most severe provisions of No Child Left Behind by the end of the month, the next deadline for states to apply. CORE intends to proceed with or without Gov. Jerry Brown’s blessing or U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan’s invitation.
“We believe we will have a compelling application, given that the state has not been successful, and hope that the secretary will see it that way,” said Rick Miller, a consultant with Capitol Impactand executive director of CORE.
Miller said CORE has been in talks with both Brown’s and Duncan’s offices for a number of months and those are continuing. He said they would welcome the governor’s approval, but it’s not essential. “The state cannot veto the waiver application, but can comment on it,” Miller said.
Education Secretary Arne Duncan testifying before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee about NCLB waivers.  Source:  U.S. Dept. of Education photo by Leslie Williams. (Click to enlarge).
Education Secretary Arne Duncan testifying before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee about NCLB waivers. Source: U.S. Dept. of Education photo by Leslie Williams. (Click to enlarge)
There is disagreement on whether the federal education law allows individual districts to apply for waivers. During a hearing last Thursday before the U.S. Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, Senator Lamar Alexander, R-Tennessee, pressed Duncan on the issue, saying he believes it’s not in the statute. Rather than taking a position on the legality of district waivers, Duncan said his biggest concern is capacity. With 15,000 school districts that could potentially apply, it would be unmanageable

Daily Kos: How the US is NOT number 1:

Daily Kos: How the US is NOT number 1::


How the US is NOT number 1:

The United States is one of only three countries that do not mandate paid parental leave out of 177 nations, according to researchers at McGill and Harvard universities. The other two are Papua New Guinea and Swaziland.
That is from an article today's Washington Post titled Landmark family leave law doesn’t help millions of workers.By the way, officially I am not covered, because I did not have 1250 hours in at my current school before Leaves on the Current found out about her cancer and I had to take time off.   So this is an issue on which I have some sensitivity.
Especially when I read something like this:
And even when workers are covered by the law, they are sometimes penalized for taking advantage of it, as court cases and 5,375 labor violations show. Workers covered by the law have been fired 


Krugman writes on "The Ignorance Caucus"

in this New York Times column, which I highly recommend.
He starts by noting that Eric Cantor last week gave what his office touted as a major speech, and that we should be glad they so informed us,
Otherwise, a read of the speech might have suggested that he was offering nothing more than a