Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, March 25, 2013

MORNING UPDATE LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 3-25-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch




How Closing Schools Blights Communities

This writer explains why closing schools blights communities and causes economic Decline.
Officials in Chicago assert that hey are saving money by closing 50+ schools,but the ripple effect of school closings will leave devastated communities behind, costing taxpayers far more than any allied savings.
Unfortunately, Chicago officials are looking on the schools as if they were chain stores that did not turn a profit. In fact, they are in most places the hub of the community.


Bad Timing for a Report Lauding Mayoral Control

The Center for American Progress is supposedly a liberal organization, but it is a cheerleader for corporate reform. It has published report after report endorsing the main ideas of No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top.
It just released a new report that lauds mayoral control.
Those of us who live in cities under mayoral control know that the primary result is not to improve education or to help struggling children, but to stifle the voices of parents, students, teachers, and community members. Under mayoral control, governance is transferred to the mayor and the power elite, few of whom have children in public schools or even attended one. Mayoral control snuffs out democracy.
The timing of this report comes just as the mayor of Chicago unilaterally decided to close more than 50 public 

Randi Weingarten and Gates’ Phillips on Teacher evaluation

Randi Weingarten and Vicki Phillips of the Gates Foundation have jointly written an article bout teacher evaluation.
At a time when teachers and the teaching profession and teachers’ unions are under attack in states across the nation, how important is teacher evaluation?
What do you think?

Chicago Tribune Continues Its Assault on Public Schools

In an editorial today, the Chicago Tribune says it is time to “unchain the charters” because they have along waiting list.
The “waiting list” is sheer propaganda. No one knows if it exists. No one knows how many duplications there are. No one acknowledges that charters spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to generate demand and “waiting 

Should the Common Core Standards Have Been Field Tested?

Marc Tucker and others scoffed when I said that the Common Core standards should have been field tested in a few districts and states before they were imposed on the 46 states.
No one knows whether they will improve achievement. No one knows if they will widen or narrow the gaps between different groups. No one knows if the awkward mapping makes sense. No one knows if he standards are developmentally appropriate for the various grades. No one knows whether the standards are realistic or 

Susan Ohanian Responds to Marc Tucker re Common Core

Twice MarcTucker wrote blog posts saying that I was wrong about the Common Core. In his second post, he challenged my assertion that parts often standards were developmentally inappropriate, and he cited experts (but not teachers) who agreed with him.
Here, Susan Ohanian responds to Tucker:
:
Arguing about the content of the Common Core State (sic) Standards is a dangerous diversion, steering us away from the important question of Who decides?
I don’t accept the premise of the very existence of these standards, but leaving that point aside, I do have a question for the “leading scholars” of the Validation Committee of the Common Core State (sic) Standards

Occupy the DOE: See You There!

Contact: United Opt Out National FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Email: unitedoptoutnational@gmail.com
Website: http://unitedoptout.com
OCCUPY THE US DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION 2.0
The Battle for Public Schools
Administrators of the public education advocacy group UNITED OPT OUT NATIONAL are hosting the second annual event on the grounds of the US Department of Education in Washington, DC on April 4-7, 2013. We ask all of those in support of teachers, students and public schools to attend. The third day will include an organized march to the White House.
The event is a four-day gathering of progressive education activists endeavoring to resist the destructive 

Can We Stop the Disaster in Chicago?

Robert George, former classroom teacher and currently national director of Save Our Schools, lives in the Chicago area.
Here he urges everyone to join the March 27 rally against the mass school closings.
Thoughts on a disaster…
Have you ever witnessed a disaster? Where you troubled, shaken to your core, reminded of the need to live every day as if it is your last? Would you do anything you could to have found a way to keep what you encountered from happening or 

The Most Brilliant Post of the Day

If you read nothing else today, read this post by the blogger who calls himself Crazy Crawfish.
In a blinding flash of insight, he sees the pattern on the rug of the corporate reform movement.
I won’t say anything more.
Just read it.

Diane in the Evening 3-24-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 2 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: *To infinity ... and beyond!* NYC Parents and Students Mobilizing for Real Reform by dianerav As the mayoral election of 2013 approaches, New York City parents and students are speaking up about what is most important to them. They got hold of an old school bus, painted it blue, and are driving around the city to raise awareness among other parents and students. The article linked here shows how parents and their children are trying to inform voters and the candidates about Do Americans Believe in Equality of ... more »

UPDATE Our interview with @ctulocal1 president Karen Lewis + The Gap No One Wants to Talk About – @ the chalk face

The Gap No One Wants to Talk About – @ the chalk face:



Our interview with @ctulocal1 president Karen Lewis did a few things for me

Here’s the interview on Blog Talk Radio. What’s remarkable is that she spent so much time with us considering how busy things are going to be.
In any event, I had a few persistent thoughts after the interview.
One, the formula for underutilization in Chicago is partly based on square footage. That was a really interesting tidbit. So, is this kid per square foot? If the ratio is low enough, the school gets closed? Well, given that, what’s the ratio in an abandoned building?
Two, the broader connections that Ms. Lewis underscored. This is about more than just schools and education. It’s about poverty, wealth and income inequality, social class, and race. It is undeniable at this point that current reform initiatives are anything but paternalistic, liberal do-gooder racism run amok. If our only problem was dealing with the neoliberals and free market ideology, that would be a war on one visible front. But with liberal do-


Education Policy Flap Canvey Island, Essex (UK)

“A school’s decision to ban triangular flapjacks after a pupil was hurt has been labelled ‘half-baked’ by critics,”reports News UK BBC.*
This flap over food puts into perspective U.S. education reform debates about VAM, KIPP, and CCSS, but the UK controversy has prompted some debate as well: “It’s very silly. You’d have thought teachers would have more pressing concerns on their minds than the shape of snacks and puddings,” explains one source.
The incident is covered further at News Essex BBC (with video including advert you cannot skip) and The 


The Gap No One Wants to Talk About

The achievement gap is misleading because it keeps the focus on all the wrong things. That gap is simply a metric for a root cause gap—the inequity gap.
But even more troubling is that addressing the achievement gap or simply allowing the term itself to be a default fact is ultimately a tremendous distraction that serves the privileged.
The gap no one wants to talk about is the ever-widening wealth gap in the U.S.
Consider a typical (and, again, distracting) claim: But the top 20% income earners pay 64% of taxes!
Ever wonder why? Because, in 2009, the top 20% made 59% of the income:
Table 7: Distribution of income in the United States, 1982-2009
Income
Top 1 percentNext 19 percentBottom 80 percent
198212.8%39.1%48.1%
198816.6%38.9%44.5%
199115.7%40.7%43.7%
199414.4%40.8%


By all means, give @educationweek your suggestions about #commoncore

Please, dear reader, head on over and tell them what you think.

Rand Paul pushes federal school vouchers

Rand Paul pushes federal school vouchers:


Rand Paul pushes federal school vouchers

Sen. Rand Paul (By Reuters/Kevin Lamarque)
Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.).
(By Reuters/Kevin Lamarque)
Sen. Rand Paul, a rising star in the Republican Party, is pushing for a federal voucher program that sounds similar to one advanced by Mitt Romney when he was running for president.
Paul, from Kentucky, co-sponsored an amendment to Senate budget legislation with Sen. Lamar Alexander, a Republican from Tennessee who was once secretary of education. The “school choice” amendment calls for using $14.5 billion in current Title 1 funds, which are targeted to students who attend high-poverty schools, to cover 11 million students, at $1,300 per child. The money would follow a student at any accredited public or private student a family chooses.
During the last presidential campaign, Republican candidate Romney talked about how education funding should “follow the child” — a euphemism for a system of vouchers that would give public money to families to pay for tuition at private schools, 

Bring Your Own Tech to School… and Become a Hacker! | toteachornototeach

Bring Your Own Tech to School… and Become a Hacker! | toteachornototeach:


Bring Your Own Tech to School… and Become a Hacker!

Bring Your Own Tech to School… and Become a Hacker! 
by John Pavley
Getting a new computer is quite a traumatic experience for me. On my personal Mac Mini (vintage 2009) I have all my favorite apps installed and all my folders and files just where I like them. I have all my accounts, system settings, network settings, and fonts customized and optimized. It took me weeks of trial and error to get it set up so I can focus on thinking and producing and not getting distracted by missing bits and bytes.
Over the years Apple has helped out by allowing me to “migrate” my data, accounts, apps, and network settings every time I buy a new Mac (which isn’t often). And Google helps with synchronizing my bookmarks and browser plugins when I sign in to Chrome. I don’t use iCloud or Google Drive, but I do use Dropbox to ensure important documents follow me around as I wander from machine to machine. These tools all help me feel at home on th

Modern School: Youth Poverty At An All-Time High

Modern School: Youth Poverty At An All-Time High:


Youth Poverty At An All-Time High


Empty Pockets (Image by barbaranixon from Flickr)

A new report from the Washington DC-based Urban Institute indicates that the overall percentage of wealth of those in their 20s and 30s has been dropping steadily and is now at its lowest level since records have been kept, the WSWS reports.

The study, “Lost Generation? Wealth Building Among Young Americans,” found that young people aged 29-37 saw a 21% decline in their accrued wealth over the past few decades, while those who are 74 and older saw their wealth increase by 150%. One explanation is that older Americans are more likely to have defined-benefit pensions, which have become 

UPDATE: Tony at the Red Line Tap + Every Chicago public school is my school. | Fred Klonsky

Every Chicago public school is my school. | Fred Klonsky:



Tony at the Red Line Tap.

tonyattheredline
“Richie Imperial Porter, Marty.”
“Comin’ right up, Klonsky.”
“Damn. Look who decided to drop by,” said Tony as I saddled up to the bar.
“Why do we say saddled up when we sit at a bar,” I asked? “We don’t say that we saddled up to a table.”
“Why are roads closed, but bridges are out,” asked Tony?
“It’s not like my union president demanded to saddle up to the table for pension negotiations.”
“That’s okay,” said Tony. “I try and stay away from tables anyway.”
“I kind of noticed,” I said. “Bars are definitely your oeuvre .”
“That kind of reminds me something my cousin Francois always says.”
“C’mon Tony. You don’t have a cousin named Francois.”
“No. I do. He’s from Baton Rouge.”
“Baton Rouge?”
“Louisiana.”
“I know where Baton Rouge is.”
“Yep. Old cousin Francois. He goes by the name, Tex.”
“Christ, Tony. That is the oldest joke in the book – He goes by the name Tex because be didn’t want to be called 


Every Chicago public school is my school.

Every Chicago Public School is my School
Cada Escuela Pública de Chicago es mi Escuela
Chaque école publique de Chicago est mon école
Setiap Sekolah Chicago Public adalah Sekolah saya
كل مدرسة شيكاغو العامة هي مدرستي
每一个芝加哥公立学校是我的学校
Svaka škola Chicago Javni je moja škola
Jeder Chicago Public School ist mein Schule
Každý Chicago Public School je moje škola
Bawat Chicago Public School ang aking School
Tá gach Poiblí Chicago Scoil mo Scoil
Ogni Scuola di Chicago Public è la mia scuola
すべてのシカゴ公立学校は私の学校です
모든 시카고 공립 학교 내 학교이고,
Kiekvienas Chicago Public School yra mano mokykla
هر مدرسه عمومی شیکاگو مدرسه من است
Każda szkoła chicagowska publiczny jest moja szkoła
Cada Chicago Public School é a minha escola
Fiecare Școala de la Chicago public este scoala mea
Каждый Чикагской школы общественного моя школа
ہر شکاگو پبلک سکول میرا اسکول ہے
Mỗi Chicago Public School là trường học của tôi

- H/T Abraham Duenas



Ten minute drawing. Anyone but Rahm?

Anyone but Rahm.

Click on drawing to enlarge.

The CORE slate, headed by Karen Lewis, file 5,000 signatures for CTU election.

Tammy & Brian
Executive Board Candidates Tammy Vinson and Brian Hallberg and CORE Co-chair Al Ramirez (not pictured) deliver the nominating petitions.
Any doubt that the leadership of the CTU has member support that is deep and wide was washed away today as 5,000 signatures were filed for the upcoming union election.  The names of President Karen Lewis and others of those who represent the Caucus of Rank-and-File Educators (CORE) received  five times the signatures that were required. The nominating petitions came from schools in every part of the city.

Schooling in the Ownership Society: Murdoch wants FCC to change rules so he can grab L.A. Times

Schooling in the Ownership Society: Murdoch wants FCC to change rules so he can grab L.A. Times:


Murdoch wants FCC to change rules so he can grab L.A. Times

Rupert Murdoch's criminal media empire could expand even more wildly in the U.S. if he's able to get the F.C.C. to get rid of some of its basic regulations. Murdoch's NewsCorp company is stepping up lobbying efforts revise a media ownership rule that would prevent the company from acquiring The L.A.Times and other newspapers in markets in which it already owns television stations.

British billionaire Murdoch is also moving to get billions in U.S. public school district contracts for his Amplify Corp., contracts which would give him access to records and data pertaining to every student and their family in the district. This while he and his media companies are still being investigated for criminal use of wire taps and 

Parent/Teacher Conferences–More Cartoons* | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Parent/Teacher Conferences–More Cartoons* | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:


Parent/Teacher Conferences–More Cartoons*

If readers following this blog have not yet guessed it, I am a sucker for cartoons about school reform policies, classroom practice, and larger education issues. Cartoonists have the knack of getting to the basic point, albeit, with exaggeration, even caricature. Sometimes, they hit the bullseye and say what needs to be said even if it makes the reader wince. Getting the viewer to smile, maybe chuckle, and mutter: “how true” is the cartoonist’s reward.
Here is another set of cartoons about exchanges between teachers and parents that may elicit groans, laughter, or flinches. Enjoy.
130128_cartoon_068_a17039_p465
ndw0125l

The Educated Reporter: Common Core State Standards and STEM: Raising the Bar for Student Learning

The Educated Reporter: Common Core State Standards and STEM: Raising the Bar for Student Learning:


Common Core State Standards and STEM: Raising the Bar for Student Learning

EWA recently held a one-day seminar focused on STEM education at the University of Maryland-Baltimore County. We invited some of the journalist attendees to contribute blog posts from the sessions. Today's entry is from education reporter Erica Green of the Baltimore Sun. You can find additional resources from the seminar, including materials from many of the presenters, here.

The new Common Core State Standards are looming over school districts across the country, and educators are gearing up to radically ramp up the level of rigor of classroom curricula. But, according to education experts—even those divided on the quality of the new curricula— the standards hold the most promise for simply getting back to the basics.

“We are not able to fill our top universities with people who can do arithmetic,” said W. Stephen Wilson, a professor of mathematics at the prestigious Johns Hopkins University, where he said students enter the 

Jersey Jazzman: Bye-Bye Ben Chavis

Jersey Jazzman: Bye-Bye Ben Chavis:


Bye-Bye Ben Chavis

Diane Ravitch reports the latest news about one of the darlings of the reformy, Ben Chavis:

Politicians and pundits flicked to the school to sing its praises and to heap honor and recognition on Ben Chavis, its leader. Chavis flaunted his “no excuses” style and his disdain for liberal softies. His schools had some of the highest scores in the state so it was hard to argue with success.

As the media took turns lionizing Chavis, they failed to notice that he had managed to lose the American Indians and to tilt the enrollment heavy towards Asians.

But Chavis encountered another problem last year when an audit revealed that some $3.8 million 

Missouri Education Watchdog: Student Data Privacy Lawsuit Against DOEd. FERPA = Tracking from Cradle to Grave

Missouri Education Watchdog: Student Data Privacy Lawsuit Against DOEd. FERPA = Tracking from Cradle to Grave:


Student Data Privacy Lawsuit Against DOEd. FERPA = Tracking from Cradle to Grave



From Washington Post and Lawsuit charges Ed Department with violating student privacy rights:

The U.S. Education Department is being sued by a nonprofit organization for promoting regulations that are alleged to undercut student privacy and parental consent. The rules allow third parties, including private companies and foundations promoting school reform, to get access to private student information.

The Electronic Privacy Information Center has been fighting for the department over 2011 regulations involving the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, also known as FERPA,  

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: WEEKEND QUOTABLES

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: WEEKEND QUOTABLES:


WEEKEND QUOTABLES

Trumbull Elementary student Daqueeta Holland, 10, left, sobs as she and friend Dyanna Davis, 10, lament that they'll be separated next year when Trumbull closes. (Chicago Tribune)
CTU Pres. Karen Lewis
“Performance has creeped back in the conversation. Every time you look up, they’ve changed the bar on what this is going to be about.” -- Sun-Times
Ald. Bob Fioretti
"I think they set them all up for failure. And then what they set up even worse was the communities and the parents and the faculties and the administration against each other." -- Ward Room
Cook County Board Pres. Toni Preckwinkle
Preckwinkle
"I don't know how the superintendent can say he's going to keep all the kids safe. I don't know what possessed him to say that." -- Reader 
Melissa Harris-Perry 
Now I  know there has been an outcry from communities,  in part because the