Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, January 19, 2013

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 1-19-13 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch








Milwaukee: No Model for America

Recently I wrote a post maintaining that choice had failed in Milwaukee, and that the city would be better off if it had a single public school system, doors open to all, receiving public support and public funding and civic energy. Uniting behind public education makes more sense than supporting three separate systems, none of which do well for studnts.
The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel published my post as an opinion piece. So far, my views have been critiqued by two other opinion pieces. One is by the research director of a free-market organization that advocates for vouchers, who says (ironically) that my call for unity around public schooling is “divisive.” This article gave me a 

Parents, Beware! Is Your Child for Sale?

This appeared on the New York City parent blog:
NYC Public School Parents
Independent voices of New York City public school parents
FRIDAY, JANUARY 18, 2013
Parents beware! NY and eight other states plan to share your child’s confidential school records with private corporations without your consent!
New York is one of five states that have agreed to share confidential NYC student and teacher data in Phase I with the “Shared Learning Collaborative” or SLC, a project of the Gates Foundation.
The other states and districts in Phase I include North Carolina (Guilford Co.), Colorado (Jefferson Co.), Illinois 


NY State Commissioner King Threatens NYC Children

New York Commissioner of Education has warned New York City that if the union and the mayor don’t reach a deal on teacher evaluation, he will withhold over $1 billion, in addition to the $250 million already at stake in Race to the Top funding.
He is holding the children and their education hostage unless the parties submit to his will.
With his long (two year) history in a charter school, he knows all there is to

Can You Do This?

A reader comments:
* *
What do the following major problems have in common?
1. Severe budget cuts to schools, bashing of teachers, lack of a broad based curriculum for developing critical and creative thinking students and cheating scandals?
2. Allowing civilians to buy assault weapons that can be used to murder innocent children and adults?
3. Inadequate menta

The Business Model and the Bus Strike in NYC

New York City is now in the midst of a school bus strike, stranding more than 100,000 students.
As usual, each side blames the other for intransigence.
But there are a few facts that should be remembered for context.
The Bloomberg administration has had complete control of the school system since 2002 and negotiated all existing contracts.
In 2006, then Chancellor Joel Klein gave a contract for $15.8 million to business turnaround consultants Alvarez 

What You Need to Know about “Right to Work” Laws

Now that Michigan has become the 24th state to pass a “right to work” law, there is considerable confusion about the reasons for such legislation. Many corporations have long wanted such laws so they could be free of the demands of unions. Many rightwing politicians have wanted to decimate unions to remove their ability to fund liberal political campaigns.
This writer, Paul Cole, a labor activist, explains what the legislation means.
Representatives designated or selected for the purposes of collective bargaining by the majority of the employees in a unit appropriate for such purposes, shall be the exclusive representatives of all the employees in such unit for the purposes of collective bargaining in respect to rates of pay, wages, hours of employment, or 

Arkansas: Charters, Segregation, the Waltons

A judge in Arkansas ruled that the state must continue to stay involved in desegregation efforts but then ruled that charters skimming white students are okay. Even Arkansas objects vets saw the contradiction.
And not coincidentally, Republicans are moving to strip the state board of education of its power to rule on charter applications. The Walton family wants more privatization, faster.
Says a local commentator:
“Re charter schools: Judge Marshall is a heckuva judge. If he says no reasonable fact-finder could argue that charter schools breach the 1989 agreement, that’s an opinion worth respecting. But no reasonable fact-finder could deny that open enrollment charter schools have skimmed middle income and white students from the Little Rock School District as a whole, particularly at the middle school level, and thus made it harder to desegregate those schools. As a matter of law, that might be irrelevant. His analysis focused on charter schools and the 

What English Classes Should Look Like in the Common Core Era

Carol Jago is an experienced English teacher, author, and former president of the National Council of Teachers of English.
Jago writes here about what high school English classes should look like in the Common a core era.
She served on the NAEP assessment committee that set the ratio of 70-30 for test developers.
Here is the key point:
“What seems to be causing confusion are the comparative recommended percentages for informational and 

It’s Good to Have Friends in High Places

Thanks to G.F. Brandenburg for finding this astonishing piece of investigative journalism.
You have to read this article. It is amazing.
It helps us understand the cronyism between the D.C. Office of State Superintendent of Education, Arne Duncan, Michelle Rhee, the Broad Superintendent’s Academy, nd Rupert Murdoch’s Wireless Generation.

Diane in the Evening 1-18-13 Diane Ravitch's blog

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 3 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog: The Mess in NYC by dianerav This is a statement by Leonie Haimson, founder of Class Size Matters in NYC and a founder of Parents Across America on the collapse of negotiations over a teacher evaluation deal between the city and union: If the Governor goes ahead with punishing NYC children for the mayor’s failures by subtracting $250 million from state aid, it will be terribly unfair. Yet there is little doubt that most parents will blame Bloomberg for this latest fiasco, as the just-released Quinnipiac poll shows that NYC voters trust the UFT by 53 to 35... more »

So You Wanna Buy a School Board Seat… | EduShyster

So You Wanna Buy a School Board Seat… | EduShyster:


So You Wanna Buy a School Board Seat…

As recent history has conclusively demonstrated over and over, elected school boards are often the biggest obstacles to closing the achievement gap forever and ushering in a bright future of excellence and innovation for our most motivated scholars. But purchasing an entire school board and taking it private can be an expensive proposition. And with so many un-excellent and non-innovative voters out there, even a massive ed-vestment can’t guarantee an excellent outcome.
Don’t despair, savvy edupreneur. Individual school board seats can be purchased for as little as $37,000, leaving you with plenty of big donors left to tap when it’s time to scale up your transformational venture come election time. Want to see how it’s done? Climb aboard the EduShyster express and join me on an all-expenses-paid trip to what must be the reformy-est place in America: Minneapolis, USA.

Go with a fresh face
It is a true fact that freshness and innovation go hand in glove, so when the Twin Cities’ reformiest elites wanted

Teacher evaluations: Is there really enough time for reliable classroom observations? | Get Schooled

Teacher evaluations: Is there really enough time for reliable classroom observations? | Get Schooled:


Teacher evaluations: Is there really enough time for reliable classroom observations?

A middle school teacher I admired for her innovation pulled me aside once to tell me she was leaving the district. Her tendency to stray from the script put her at odds with the new principal.
When I shared the news later with a neighbor, an educator herself, her reaction shocked me: “Good riddance. My son never knew what was going on in that class because the teacher was always going off on a tangent.”
I learned a lesson. What’s outside-the-box teaching to one parent may be a crate of goo to the next.
Through having twins — one with a penchant for flights of fancy, the other with feet firmly planted on the ground — I have seen firsthand that personality plays a role in how well a student relates to a teacher. My son prefers strict standards, frequent quizzes and no projects that demand glue, poster boards or costumes. My daughter likes personal journals, classes that meander and any event that requires wearing a hat.
That’s why I regard promises of objective …

What kids want Obama to do in second term

What kids want Obama to do in second term:


What kids want Obama to do in second term



What do young people want President and Congress to do over the next four years? Here some of them tell us in a video that is a project of The Children’s Leadership Council, a national coalition of child and youth organizations. The video was produced by SparkAction.

How test anxiety affected a young boy


In this era of high-stakes standardized tests, a subject that gets short shrift is test anxiety and how it affects young students.
Text anxiety is a type of performance anxiety, and it can severely affect a student's ability to do well. Here is one mother's story of how test anxiety affected her elementary school son and what she did about it. Written by Kathleen Muthler, who is a teacher in Pennsylvania, this appeared on the website @thechalkface.com.
Read full article >>

Louisiana Educator: MET Project Dissected

Louisiana Educator: MET Project Dissected:


MET Project Dissected

Math teacher and blogger Gary Rubinstein has dissected and uncovered serious flaws in the Gates sponsored study of effective teacher evaluation systems called the MET project (Measures of Effective Teaching). It turns out that if we look carefully at the data from the MET study we find that the basic assumptions for focusing on revised teacher evaluation and dismissal procedures as a way of improving public education are really not justified.

One of the most basic assumptions driving the major revamp of teacher evaluation and dismissal procedures in Louisiana is that poor teaching must be the primary cause of low student performance in some Louisiana schools. Our reformers (Jindal, White and big business) believe that all you have to do to improve education is to create a system that fires the worst teachers and trains all the remaining teachers to teach effectively. The new laws passed by Jindal will require the firing of the lowest performing teachers each year and provide all the others feedback on how their students are doing on state tests so they can set proper goals for improvement. Finally Louisiana teachers will watch videos of supposedly great teachers doing what is considered effective teaching so 

SRC faces a loud, angry crowd over school closings - Philly.com

SRC faces a loud, angry crowd over school closings - Philly.com:


SRC faces a loud, angry crowd over school closings

January 18, 2013|By Kristen A. Graham, Inquirer Staff Writer
  • Parents and students proclaim their opposition to closing 37 city schools. SRC Chairman Pedro Ramos, referring to calls for a moratorium on closings, said: "All of the inaction has caught up with the district."
Shouting, waving signs, and drowning out officials, hundreds of students, parents, and community members angry at plans to shut 37 Philadelphia schools lashed out Thursday night at the School Reform Commission.
"I have never been more disappointed in this city as a whole," said Naeemah Felder, parent of a daughter at Pepper Middle School, one of the schools slated for closure in June.
"I want to stay in my neighborhood, because McCloskey is closest to where I live," fourth grader Lamar Robinson said. McCloskey School is also on the closure list.
"AMY is a unique school. You will destroy it," said Dennis Dorfman, longtime counselor at Alternative for Middle Years Program at James Martin School. AMY at James Martin is slated to move to the Penn Treaty Middle School building.
Story continues below.
"We know what you want. Stop privatizing our schools," an audience member yelled.
District officials have said they must close dozens of schools to save the nearly bankrupt school 

Philadelphia School Reform Commission votes not to renew city's oldest charter school

The Philadelphia School Reform Commission said Thursday night that the district's oldest charter school did not deserve to be renewed because of low test scores and financial problems.

Daily Kos: so it's Saturday, and I usually reflect on teaching

Daily Kos: so it's Saturday, and I usually reflect on teaching:


so it's Saturday, and I usually reflect on teaching

and that will be part this piece.  But this is a morning where I have a lot on my mind.
As I write this, sitting in my local Starbucks, about 1/4 of our students and a number of our faculty and staff are wearing their bright red school sweatshirts and are spending the day volunteering at the DC Homeless Shelter as their participation in the day of service.  I wanted to join them, but am on the edge of a cold, and was exhausted by the end of the week - I actually slept for 11 hours last night.   The students might get a real treat - the adults had to provide their birthdays and social security numbers, which is standard procedure for being cleared by the Secret Service.  In other words, they are likely to encounter at least some of the Obama family, perhaps even the President.
What is more important is this:  many of students come from families that do not have much.  And yet they will learn from this event, as from others to which we take them from time to time, that even if you lack material 

UPDATE: Schools’ Design Can Play Role in Safety + Lance Armstrong Is Right About One Thing | toteachornototeach

Lance Armstrong Is Right About One Thing | toteachornototeach:



Schools’ Design Can Play Role in Safety, Student Engagement

Schools’ Design Can Play Role in Safety, Student Engagement
Joplin Interim High School social commons
By Jaclyn Zubrzycki
A building alone does not create a school culture. But research shows that school buildings can affect students’ morale and academic performance. Now, school officials are moving away from the “cells and bells” design marked by long, locker-lined hallways of windowless classrooms, and toward more open, flexible buildings aimed at creating a sense of community and collaboration.
Such new designs tie together a shift to a more technology-driven, collaborative, student-centered approach to education with an effort to improve students’ safety, engagement, and community.
The goal is to get students feeling more invested in their school communities; improved student engagement is 


Lance Armstrong Is Right About One Thing

LanceLiesLance Armstrong Is Right About One Thing

by Victor Dorff
The “Lance Armstrong Story” has the potential to become a classic American literary tragedy, on a par with “Death of a Salesman.” His deceptions and self-denial, combined with his fame and status as hero/icon, make him a perfect leading character, both deeply flawed and a product of his time and place in our society.
There is a significant portion of the American population today that operates under a “win-at-all-costs” ethic, which produces a lot of pressure to cheat. Once cheating begins – in a sport, in a business, or in a classroom ¬- it becomes harder and harder for those who don’t cheat to compete against the cheaters. After a while, it becomes easy to rationalize dishonesty, because cheating becomes the new normal.
In stark contrast to the South African swimmer who admitted to cheating to win his gold medal, Armstrong is now taking some personal responsibility for contributing to the culture of cheating surrounding his sport. By 

The Past Lives on in the Present: Customized Learning then and Now | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

The Past Lives on in the Present: Customized Learning then and Now | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:


The Past Lives on in the Present: Customized Learning then and Now

Pupils are working on their own. The second and third grade reading class of 63 pupils … is using a learning center and two adjoining rooms. Two teachers and  the school librarian act as coordinators and tutors as the pupils proceed with the various materials prepared by the school’s teachers and … developer, The Learning and Research Development Center at the U. of Pittsburgh. Each pupil sets his own pace. He is listening to records and completing workbooks. When he has completed a unit of work, he is tested, the test is corrected immediately, and if he gets a grade of 85% or better he moves on. if not, the teacher offers a series of alternative activities to correct the weakness, including individual tutoring, There are no textbooks. There is virtually no lecturing by the teacher to the class as a whole. Instead, she is busy observing the child’s progress, evaluating his tests, writing prescriptions, and instructing individually or in small groups of pupils who need help.*
The school is Oakleaf elementary near Pittsburgh (PA) and the time is 1965. Implemented across all grades, the 

Schools Matter: A weapon of mass distraction

Schools Matter: A weapon of mass distraction:


A weapon of mass distraction

Submitted to the Christian Science Monitor, Jan. 18, 2013
I suspect that the common core standards’ elitist reading lists (sample items in “Are you as well-read as a 10th grader?” Jan. 17) are designed to get educators and the public arguing about what should be on the reading lists, rather than focusing on the far more important question of whether we should have common core standards and tests at all.
There is no evidence that standards and tests improve school achievement. The huge sums of money budgeted for standards and for tests to enforce the standards should be used to protect children from the effects of poverty, the real reason so many students struggle in school.

Stephen Krashen
Original article: http://www.csmonitor.com/Books/2012/0625/Are-you-as-well-read-as-a-10th-grader-Take-our-quiz/The-Odyssey-by-Homer

If Duncan Addressed the Violence He CAN Do Something About

Imagine if Arne were willing to heed the advice of teachers on what they know most about--the effects of testing! From HuffPo:


Duncan On Guns Tests In Schools: Hard To Teach Kids Scared Of Being KilledFailing or Not Graduating


By PHILIP ELLIOTT 01/17/13 06:25 PM ET EST AP

Share on Google+
Arne Duncan Guns In Schools
Popout
GET EDUCATION ALERTS:
WASHINGTON -- Too many students worry more about being killed by a gun tests than learning in the classroom, Education Secretary Arne Duncan said on Thursday, as he cautioned that firearms tests alone do not make schools better safer .

. . . .
"This was only a first step. We need a lot less children being shot dead tested. We need a lot less