Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Morning UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-23-12 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch


Charters Riding High in CT

No matter what the calendar says, it’s springtime for charters in Connecticut.
The State Education Commissioner Stefan Pryor was a member of the board of Achievement First, a charter chain in Connecticut. He believes in charters, like his colleague John King, the state commissioner in New York, whose only experience was in the charter sector (Uncommon Schools).
Jonathan Pelto has been writing about the massing of hedge fund money in support of the charter agenda in 


More Pre-School Madness in CT. (Link Added)

I posted this morning about the “standards” for pre-schoolers in Connecticut.
The teacher I quoted added this comment:
http://www.sde.ct.gov/sde/lib/sde/PDF/CCSS/Pk_to_Kindergarten_Mathematics_Continuum.pdf
Sorry Dr. Ravitch, I put in two links to the language arts standards and didn’t include the link to the math standards. The above link takes you to the math standards. I love the one about preschoolers being able to describe real graphs. Also the one which expects preschoolers to “discuss strategies to estimate and compare length, area, temperature and weight.” Have any of these people read Piaget?

Who Paid for the $1 Million Ad in Chicago?

Fred Klonsky has the inside scoop on who paid for the $1 million ad that has filled the airwaves in Chicago after the teachers’ strike.
He says the money came from Ravenel Boykin Curry IV and his wife Celerie. Fred’s brother Mike Klonsky says that other hedge fund managers joined to pay for the ads.
Curry is a board member of the Wall Street hedge fund manager organization called “Democrats for Education


The Charter Referendum in Washington State

Here is a list of organizations that have spoken out for and against the referendum on the ballot to permit charter schools and a “parent trigger” to create even more charter schools in Washington State.
Look at the list and see if you can tell which one has grassroots support from parents and teachers.
Earlier posts have described how this ballot proposal was funded by some of the richest men in the state, not public school parents. The voters in Washington have turned down charters three times previously. Some people never take no for an answer. Let’s see what happens in November.

Good News for History Teachers!

Good news for history teachers: the Stanford History Education Group has developed history assessments that use documents and historical resources to ask thinking questions, not bubble questions.
In the 1990s, history education was a priority. California and other states created history frameworks for K-12, and it appeared that history would get the time, attention and resources it needed.
But that moment of high possibility came to an end with the passage of No Child Left Behind. History teachers have been in a quandary ever since, as they saw their subject marginalized and reduced to an afterthought.

No Room for Career Educators in TN?

Tennessee was one of the first states to win a Race to the Top award.
Tennessee was the birthplace of value-added assessment, which was developed by agricultural statistician William Sanders in the late 1980s. Sanders knew how crops can be measured by yearly growth, why not learning? If they don’t grow as expected, it’s the farmer’s fault, right?
Tennessee is a model now for other reasons. It has been taken over by the corporate reform philosophy, and 


Who Paid for the Anti-Union Ads?

During the strike, there was an outpouring of ads undermining and attacking the union. This blogger wondered who was paying for them. The group is called Education Reform Now. It is the non-profit arm of Democrats for Education Reform. DFER, as it is known, is the political action group of Wall Street hedge fund managers.
So many of them went to Andover, Exeter, Deerfield Academy, and other elite private schools. But for some


Do Democrats Support Vouchers?

An article in the recent issue of Education Week suggests that there is support for vouchers among Democrats at the state and local level.
The article cites Newark Mayor Cory Booker, but he is an outlier.
It also quotes the head of a group called the American Federation for Children. This group attracts support for 


My Version of the Pattern on the Rug

There comes a time when the seemingly disparate parts of a puzzle fit together. Or the time when you see the pattern on the rug.
That’s when you see that the attacks on teachers, the concerted efforts to roll back collective bargaining rights, the frequent–and false–claims that public education is failing, the advocacy for virtual schools, movies like “Waiting for Superman,” laws that advance privatization….a pattern emerges.
These are not isolated events.
Read my take on the pattern.


The Pattern on the Rug

A reader sees how the pieces of the reform movement fit together:
I think that all the double-speak is just to divert attention away from the major process of dismantling education that has been taking place across the country, and the smoke and mirrors is to conceal the intention to ultimately declare brick and mortar schools obsolete and teachers expendable and unnecessary. Effectively, the goal is to not have teachers anymore.
One online teacher I work with put it this way recently, “We’re just glorified graders now.” Honestly, for a teacher, 


He Didn’t Get the Job

Kenneth Bernstein explains why he didn’t get the job:
“I was once interviewed for a teaching position where because I had done my own homework I knew that the principal wanted everyone on the same page at the same time.
I was being interviewed by the department chair and an assistant principal. Having signed an open contract for that district, the only question on the table was at what school I would teach. It was clear they wanted me, 


What Are We Doing to Pre-Schoolers?

A reader asks whether we have lost our minds.
http://www.sde.ct.gov/sde/lib/sde/PDF/CCSS/PreK_ELA_Crosswalk.pdf
http://www.sde.ct.gov/sde/lib/sde/PDF/CCSS/PreK_ELA_Crosswalk.pdf
The links above take you to draft Connecticut documents relating to CCSS for preschoolers. The introduction states that the adoption of CCSS for K-12 “has naturally led to questions regarding standards for preschool and/or prekindergarten students.” The next section talks about a work group that has been charged with the task 

School Tech Connect: Will Someone Go Say Something?

School Tech Connect: Will Someone Go Say Something?:


Will Someone Go Say Something?

Man, I hate Facebook commenting. It's the sign of lazy management at a newspaper. Anyway, will someone with a Facebook account go over to this Indiana-based Gannett paper and let Michael Hicks know that his column probably makes sense to an economics professor, but that in the reality of the classroom, he's wrong? I'd do it, but I'm not in the walled garden known as Facebook.

He's wrong because of the sheer numbers, too. Numbers of minutes, I mean.

The coming increase in the time spent on assessment--- all in the name of teacher evaluation--- is going to be a huge problem, as I've droned on about a million times. All of these standardized assessments, taken as a whole

The Sunday Mail. « Fred Klonsky

The Sunday Mail. « Fred Klonsky:


The Sunday Mail.


Photo: Chicago Teachers Solidarity Campaign.
John Dillon’s Pension Vacabulary Part 2 of Structural Revenue Problem. The State of Illinois is only one of seven states left in the entire nation operating under a flat tax.

Diane Ravitch asks, “Do Democrats support vouchers?” 
How a political poem was bullied out of me. Molly Meachem.
Happy birthday Miles, Ray and Bruce.
Rahm is a conduit between

NYC Educator: What Do You Do When Truth Doesn't Matter?

NYC Educator: What Do You Do When Truth Doesn't Matter?:


What Do You Do When Truth Doesn't Matter?

In the United States today, you can pretty much sell anything. Maybe those of us who've been trying to respond the the education "reform" movement have been going about it all wrong. Is it really a good idea to simply address the issues media brings up? Maybe we should ignore them and simply start attacking the media. I mean, sure, there are good reasons to do so.

What can you say about an education summit hosted by Rush Limbaugh aficionado Brian Williams? What can you say about a major network that excludes 

Daily Kos: Three important musical birthdays today

Daily Kos: Three important musical birthdays today:


Three important musical birthdays today

All three are musical giants.
Each probably deserves a music-video heavy diary of his own
let me offer one of my favorites for each:
John Coltrane, born in 1926:
Popout
Ray Charles Robinson, born in 1930:
Popout
Bruce Springsteen, born in 1949 (and don't worry about dark video at beginning):
Popout
Perhaps you might want to add a favorite clip of one of these in the comments?

An Education Engine - Woodbridge, VA, United States, ASCD EDge Blog post - A Professional Networking Community for Educators

An Education Engine - Woodbridge, VA, United States, ASCD EDge Blog post - A Professional Networking Community for Educators:


Looking Ahead

An Education Engine

In this election year we continue hearing about “twenty-first century” skills. But what we should be talking about, IMHO, is what’s after the twenty-first century threshold. At the outset, the challenge seemed to be to simply be able to manage the data with which we are inundated. But as the tools to manage data have become more and more user-friendly, the next challenge is to find contexts for the pertinent information we encounter … context provided by the experience and expertise we bring to understanding information. When we have meaningful understanding of information, insight is created, the kind of insight that identifies opportunities for innovation. There is a shift from mere information management to insight.

Another major change we are experiencing is movement from the simple realization that we live in a global economy to actively contributing to a communal marketplace of ideas. The first 

Schools Matter: Today in NYC

Schools Matter: Today in NYC:


Today in NYC


Please consider coming to this event and help spread the word!


PARENTS "Won’t Back Down"
FROM FIGHTING THE CORPORATE TAKEOVER OF OUR SCHOOLS!

The film “Won’t Back Down” is backed by conservative billionaires Rupert Murdoch and Philip Anschtuz. The law portrayed in the movie, called parent trigger, claims to be about parent empowerment but actually promotes the privatization of public schools and blaming teachers for struggling schools. The movie claims to be 'inspired by actual events' but not a single school in the country has successfully used Parent Trigger. 

This Sunday, at the red carpet world premiere of the movie, JOIN us in showing Hollywood & the paparazzi the REAL parents who "won't back down."

=> Sunday at 4:30pm
Ziegfeld Theatre
Meet at corner on 54th st. and 6th Ave. Midtown
Subways: B, D, E to 7th ave, N, Q, R or F to 57th St.-7th Ave.

For more info, call or Email Julian Vinocur (212) 328-9268,julian@aqeny.org

Anti-Union Ads in Chicago Paid for By Hedge Funds, Billionaires | FDL News Desk

Anti-Union Ads in Chicago Paid for By Hedge Funds, Billionaires | FDL News Desk:

Anti-Union Ads in Chicago Paid for By Hedge Funds, Billionaires

By:  Wednesday September 19, 2012 6:17 am


I wish I had known about this before the Chicago Teachers Union suspended their strike and returned to work, but it may shed some light on the timing of the suspension. At the least, it provides a little more context for what teachers unions have to deal with on the ground.
Apparently the above anti-union ad played non-stop on television in Chicago throughout the strike. It’s the product of Education Reform Now, a group that also sometimes goes by Democrats for Education

DFER Fake Democrats for Education Privatization (click on Picture) 
IT IS A RULE: YOU CAN'T BE AGAINST PEOPLE AND FOR CORPORATIONS AND CALL YOURSELF A DEMOCRAT...EVER!

Daily Kos: Romney to teacher "I didn't ask you a question"

Daily Kos: Romney to teacher "I didn't ask you a question":



Sorry to post twice in one day. When I saw this I had to share it. It has only received around 300 views so far, and it really needs to go viral. It is a video of a CO teacher describing her experience at a round table with Mitt Romney. According to the teacher, Romney was going on about schools failing and how we need a voucher system. When she said she had an answer for that he told her "I didn't ask you a question."
The video has captions, but I have also included a partial transcript below the fold.
When i was asked to speak with Mitt Romney it seemed like a very important thing to me, and I wanted to put a lot of careful thought into what I would say. So, I went to the 

A thank-you letter to Chicago teachers from some Georgia colleagues | Get Schooled

A thank-you letter to Chicago teachers from some Georgia colleagues | Get Schooled:


A thank-you letter to Chicago teachers from some Georgia colleagues

I have published two pieces by the Teaching Georgia Writing Collective, which is a group of educators, parents and citizens who engage in public writing and public teaching about education in Georgia. The group had its impetus in Athens and includes UGA professors.
The collective defines its goals as:  1) empowering educators to reclaim their workplace and professionalism, 2) empowering families to stand up for their children and shape the institutions their children attend each day, 3) empowering children and youth to have control over their education, and 4) enhancing the education of all Georgians.
Here is a third essay from the group:
Dear Chicago Teachers,
The Chicago Teachers Union strike will go down as a significant event in history when educators 

Schools Matter: GUEST POST: Instructed to Ignorance, Douglas Storm

Schools Matter: GUEST POST: Instructed to Ignorance, Douglas Storm:


GUEST POST: Instructed to Ignorance, Douglas Storm

[Original post can be found HERE.]



[Instructional Hoops for Sale from Pearson]

I started out thinking I could assert that the school curriculum (the "what" of instruction) is irrelevant but that is of course not what I would mean to say.

Rather, curriculum is ALL possible responses to all possible utterances.* That means the space of instruction (fancy critical theory calls this the "scene")--home, church, playground, friend's home, school bus, school, classroom, hallways, iPad, laptop, Xbox, etc.--and everything flowing into and out of it, is curricular content. Content is utterance and response. It is what we allow to be uttered and what we allow to be a proper response 

At School, Overweight Children Carry A Heavy Burden : NPR

At School, Overweight Children Carry A Heavy Burden : NPR:


At School, Overweight Children Carry A Heavy Burden

Study Guide: Program or Be Programmed - Ten Commands for a Digital Age | Technology on GOOD

Study Guide: Program or Be Programmed - Ten Commands for a Digital Age | Technology on GOOD:



Mom angry that male vice principal spanked child | ABC News Blogs - Yahoo! News

Mom angry that male vice principal spanked child | ABC News Blogs - Yahoo! News:


Mom angry that male vice principal spanked child

Mom Angry That Male Vice Principal Spanked Her Daughter
Rather than spend two days in in-school suspension for allegedly letting another student copy her classwork, Taylor Santos, a well-regarded student and athlete at Springtown High School, near Fort Worth, Texas, chose to get paddled.
As her mother, Anna Jorgensen, told ABC News affiliate WFAA-TV in Dallas, Taylor didn't want to miss any classes because "her grades are very important to her."
So Santos went to the vice principal's office to request a paddling. She called her mom, who said that as long as her daughter was OK with it, so was she. According to school policy, parents who don't want their children to subject to corporal punishment must submit a written statement each year.

Cartoons on Common Core Standards | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Cartoons on Common Core Standards | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:


Cartoons on Common Core Standards

For this monthly* post of cartoons, I have selected images about the impending Common Core curriculum standards in math and English for K-12 students. While many countries have a national curriculum, the U.S. does not. Since the Common Core standards have been adopted by 46 states and the District of Columbia, the U.S. will soon have a national–not federally mandated–one.
According to a recent analysis of the Common Core standards there are two justifications for states adopting the standards (Brookings Study of Common Core):
1. Because current state standards vary greatly across the country resulting in unequal access to knowledge and skills, Common Core standards will be higher, uniform, and equitable for all students. When tests of those common standards are implemented in 2014-2015,  the quality of teaching and learning will improve. Students will then score far better on international achievement tests and the U.S. economy will grow.
2. By standardizing curriculum and assessments across states, multiple textbooks and instructional materials in 

ChipIn: US Ed Reform: the comic

ChipIn: US Ed Reform: the comic:


What's This All About?

This is a page set up by Dan Archer and Adam Bessie, co-creators of a comic that explains the flipside to the US education reform debate: the one that went untold in films like "Waiting for Superman", that is generally left out of mainstream media discussion. For more info, scroll down for a comprehensive introduction to the topic.

By clicking the "chipin!" button to the right, you can send money via paypal to us: $8 buys you a copy of the comic, plus $2