Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

Fixing the No Child Left Behind law: How the House and Senate plans differ - LA Times

Fixing the No Child Left Behind law: How the House and Senate plans differ - LA Times:

Fixing the No Child Left Behind law: How the House and Senate plans differ




Both the House and Senate have passed fixes to the No Child Left Behind law, the signature educational achievement of the George W. Bush administration, which requires schools to meet strict testing requirements.

But as the chambers try to agree on a solution, lawmakers remain sharply divided over key issues.

The House bill, which would curtail federal standards and permit states to impose their own curricula, did not garner a single Democratic vote, and President Obama has threatened to veto it.

Rep. John Kline (R-Minn.), chairman of the House Education and Workforce Committee, emphasized the need to end the current policy "where Washington's priorities have outweighed what parents, teachers and local leaders know what is best for their children." Kline labeled it a "one-size-fits-all approach, which landed many schools in the failing category."

He will head a committee expected to convene in September to reconcile House and Senate bills. Here's a look at questions and answers surrounding the legislation:

What do the House and Senate bills agree on?

Both measures take steps to ease the effect of federal testing and return greater control over education to states. They would also lessen federal say over establishing nationwide achievement standards, like the so-called Common Core, which critics have labeled an attempt to federalize what students are taught.

The bills would repeal what opponents see as the more onerous requirements of the No Child Left Behind law, such as mandating that students make adequate yearly progress or be sanctioned. Lawmakers view these requirements as denying schools the flexibility to deal with the needs of individual students.

Both chambers have made it clear that the Education Department should not be involved in standards assessments and would prohibit the federal government from getting involved in or imposing curricula on states.

"While there are important differences, the consensus supporting the framework for the House and Senate bills is the same: Continue the law's important measurements of academic progress of students but restore to states, school districts, classroom teachers and parents the responsibility for deciding what to do about improving student achievement," said Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn), chairman of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee.

Both bills maintain annual assessments in third through eighth grades and once in high school, while aiming to end the era of high-stakes testing. States would still need to publish breakdowns of test results by student groups.

What's in the House bill?

Although the bill requires annual testing, it would let parents and children opt out without repercussions to their schools. The bill repeals many regulations in the No Child Left Behind law to restore control to states and schools. House Republicans see this as eliminating duplicative programs and instead allowing local educators to spend funds where they believe they will have the greatest benefit.

The bill also adds language supporting school choice and stronger charter school programs.

It allows for federal assistance that goes to children in low-income families to be transferred to a new public Fixing the No Child Left Behind law: How the House and Senate plans differ - LA Times: