Friday, September 16, 2011
Tom King's Blog of De-Fog!: Better Learning for ALL!:Locking the Locker Room Door!
Getting Teacher Evaluation Right | LFA: Join The Conversation - Public School Insights
Getting Teacher Evaluation Right
This week, the American Education Research Association and National Academy of Education hosted Getting Teacher Evaluation Right: A Challenge for Policy Makers, which highlighted concerns of education researchers with using value-added modeling (VAM, a model that measures a teacher's contribution to student test scores) in teacher evaluations.
The consensus of the research community: Most believe VAM is not appropriate as a primary measure for evaluating individual teachers. The standardized test score data used in these models is just not reliable, given issues with the small sample size of classrooms, the nonrandom assignment of students to classrooms, and the fact that while a student might, for example, work on reading skills with a teacher, a parent, a tutor and a
Schools Matter: Get Ready for Boston Schools' CorporatePower Compact
Get Ready for Boston Schools' CorporatePower Compact
The outcome of this coming Monday's meeting is a forgone conclusion, so any citizen who may have hoped to influence the final contents to the new compact (read the Boston Globe editorial on the proposed Compact) should not waste your time crafting a public comment. King William (Gates) already has his tax-sheltered corporate jet
An open letter to Michael Moore from Sharon Higgins
Bored? Art tells a history of a school. « Fred Klonsky's blog
Bored? Art tells a history of a school.
There’s an interesting piece at Salon about the impact of testing mania and the resulting disappearance of non-tested subjects from the school curriculum. Subjects like art and music.
And the way it has made school boring.
“The research is not clear,” writes (Diane) Ravitch, “but a great deal of anecdotal evidence suggests that affluent districts are preserving a balanced curriculum, while poor and minority students are likely to have larger classes and
THE PERIMETER PRIMATE: An open letter to Michael Moore
An open letter to Michael Moore
NYC Public School Parents: We take the city to court over charter co-locations!
We take the city to court over charter co-locations!
"March for Jobs and Justice: Oct. 15 in Washington, D.C.." September 15, 2011. NYSUT: A Union of Professionals. www.nysut.org
March for Jobs and Justice: Oct. 15 in Washington, D.C.

NOTE: The MLK March for Jobs and Justice with labor, faith-based, civil rights and community support was rescheduled for 11 a.m. Saturday, Oct. 15, in Washington, D.C. The official unveiling of the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr., monument will be the following day.
NYSUT leaders from across the state are signing up to participate in this mass March for Jobs and Justice organized by the National Action Network and co-chaired by AFT President Randi Weingarten. Forty-eight years after the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. delivered his "I Have a Dream" speech that advanced civil rights legislation, this march will call attention to the need for a livable wage and jobs.
While planning is still in the early stages, at least we know that buses for NYSUT participants will leave from many of the union’s 16 Regional Offices that Saturday morning. Members should check with their local leaders for details. The AFT will provide NYSUT marchers with T-shirts, water bottles and subway passes to get from the bus drop-off point - RFK Stadium - to the opening rally, which begins at noon at Constitution Avenue and 17th Street, adjacent to the National Mall. The march to the
Blue Book Looks a Little Gray | Edwize
Blue Book Looks a Little Gray
Sep. 16, 2011
1:49 pm
by Maisie McAdoo
No Comments
Filed under: NYC DOE
The DOE’s annual 600-plus-page Enrollment–Capacity–Utilization Report 2009-10, universally known as the Blue Book, is the official word on how much space is available in every school in the city. But the results of an audit released today by the city comptroller show that the Blue Book data is inaccurate.
The particulars are a little technical, but the impact is not. The DOE uses the Blue Book to decide on co-locations. It is also used to assign students to a building, add grades, bring in special education programs, and determine the multi-billion-dollar capital spending plan.
But in 23 percent of school rooms that auditors checked on, the Blue Book either gave the wrong size or the wrong function. For example, the room was described as a resource room but was really being used as an office, or the room was reportedly big enough for 28 kids when actually it could
Local News | Defiant Tacoma teachers to stay on strike | Seattle Times Newspaper
Defiant Tacoma teachers to stay on strike
Striking Tacoma teachers remain off the job despite a court order that told them to report for work, and schools are closed for a fourth...
The Tacoma News Tribune
Striking Tacoma teachers remain off the job despite a court order that told them to report for work, and schools are closed for a fourth straight day as the teachers union and school district prepare for a courtroom faceoff Friday.
Teachers also plan a rally Friday morning at the school district's downtown administration building.
They returned to picket lines Thursday morning, and later more than 1,500 of them gathered in the Tacoma Dome. More than 90 percent voted to continue their
Final Thoughts, For Now, on the CEO Study of Wisconsin Admissions « Student Activism
Final Thoughts, For Now, on the CEO Study of Wisconsin Admissions
In CEO’s report on racial disparities in UW admissions, they highlight an extremely misleading statistical concept — that of “odds ratios” — to leave the false impression that black and Latino applicants to UW are hundreds of times more likely to win acceptance than whites. They also leave more than a thousand students of color out of their applicant sample, inflating admissions percentages for blacks and Latinos by excluding weak applicants from that pool and distorting statistics on Asians by excluding all applicants of Southeast Asian origin from their study.
In addition to all that, they engage in a variety of petty manipulations of data, as when they scale their admissions rates chart to begin at 50% rather than 0%, thus dramatically enhancing the visual impact of the graph at the expense of accuracy and readability.
Strangely missing in all this statistical sleight-of-hand is any straightforward statement of the magnitude of the
Feeling Down? Think Public Ed has Failed? Read This! - Teacher in a Strange Land - Education Week Teacher
Feeling Down? Think Public Ed has Failed? Read This!
This is a good week to remember heroic teachers: the teachers who led their children, holding hands, away from the smoking World Trade Center towers on 9/11; the teachers in Baton Rouge and Houston who welcomed a dozen terrified "Katrina kids" into their already-overcrowded classrooms, improvising seating, books and assignments.
This amazing story from Vermont crossed my desktop today:![]()
I'm sure you've all heard about Hurricane Irene's effects on our small, beautiful state. Maybe you've also heard about the heroic efforts of the state's teachers in ensuring that students have a school to attend. I just came back from one such school in tiny Moretown, a community
How Did CEO Arrive at Their Admission Rate Numbers? « Student Activism
How Did CEO Arrive at Their Admission Rate Numbers?
Last night I posted an introduction to the Center for Equal Opportunity’s report on the use of race in assessing applicants to the University of Wisconsin at Madison, and attempted to untangle their preposterously misleading claim that black students have a 576-to-1 advantage in admissions. This morning I’ll be tackling CEO’s claims as to the rates at which student applicants of various racial groups are admitted to UW.
The CEO study’s author, Althea Nagai, claims on the report’s first page that in 2007 and 2008 “UW admitted more than 7 out of every 10 black applicants, and more than 8 out of 10 Hispanics, versus roughly 6 in 10 Asians and whites.” The university’s own public records for those years, however, show admissions rates of just 42% and 55% for black and Latino students, respectively, compared to a 55% rate of acceptance for white applicants and a 56% rate for Asians. According to UW, in other words, white, Asian, and Latino students were accepted at
Schools Matter: More Than 4 of 10 Children Born into Poverty Will Remain There
More Than 4 of 10 Children Born into Poverty Will Remain There
"every day KIPP students are proving that demographics do not decide destiny."
Feinberg began his KIPP pitch with a favorite "African custom of greeting one another with 'How are the children?' with an expected answer of 'All the children are well.'"
The oft-repeated platitude and this bit of African custom fit nicely into the KIPP brand of positive psychology nonsense, but it has almost no connection to the grinding realities of poverty that remain the invisible elephants
This Week In Education: Thompson: Reviewing Tavis Smiley's "Too Important To Fail"
Thompson: Reviewing Tavis Smiley's "Too Important To Fail"
It took three viewings of much of Tavis Smiley's PBS report, "Too Important to Fail," in order to fully appreciate it. I encourage you to take at least one look. In the report, Smiley synthesizes the best of all types of reforms in overcoming the challenges faced by black males, celebrating the best of the new generation of accountability hawks, and showing why we need schools like Chicago's Urban Prep Academy and Philadelphia's Promise Academy. He also addresses issues like emotional trauma and peer influences in poor schools, the need for preschool and reading for
Charts: Denying Poverty Versus Ignoring It
AM News: Republican Candidates Differ Over Immigrant Tuition
White House details plans for more digital learning USA Today: The White House will unveil plans Friday for a research center that aims to bring more digital learning into the nation's classrooms.
Huntsman: Don't punish children of illegal immigrants USA Today: GOP presidential hopeful Jon Huntsman said today he's with his rival Rick Perry when it comes to providing in-state tuition to some children.
L.A. Times wins press award for controversial teacher grading HuffPost: The Los Angeles Times won the Associated Press Media Editors First Amendment Sweepstakes Award on Thursday for "Grading the Teachers," a groundbreaking analysis of public school test scores that showed good teachers make a measurable difference in the classroom but often go unrecognized and unrewarded.
New York’s Race to the Top setbacks more extreme than most Gothamist: Tisch called the legal decision “a setback in the court system.” And the city Department of Education’s second-in-command, Shael Polakow-Suransky, said, “I’m confident we’re going to get to an agreement around this in the coming period, because we have to.”
Newark Is Betting on a Wave of New Principals NYT: Cami Anderson, the new schools superintendent, has recruited 17 new principals to run nearly a quarter of the city’s schools, part of an ambitious plan to rebuild the troubled district.
MORE NEWS ITEMS BELOW
Pursuing teaching as a second, third career NYT: As the baby boomers reach retirement age, some of those anticipating a new career are enrolling at community colleges and in state-approved or private programs to convert their professional expertise to the classroom.
N.Y. hands off part of teacher evaluation effort NYT: New York City will not rank educators based on their students’ standardized test scores, but will use similar effectiveness scores developed by the state.
Despite court order, Tacoma teachers stay out Seattle Post-Intelligencer: Teachers overwhelmingly voted to continue their strike Thursday afternoon and defy what the school district believes is a court order mandating they return to work.
D.C. schools prepare for nation's first sex-education standardized testing Washington Post: D.C. public and public charter schools, which annually test student progress in reading and math, will also measure what they know about human sexuality, contraception and drug use starting this spring.
PBS documentary on Baltimore schools premieres Baltimore Sun: Baltimore city schools are featured in a documentary set to debut on PBS stations nationally Tuesday. 'The Learning' looks at lives of Filipino teachers in city schools.
Fact Sheet: Digital Promise Initiative | The White House
Fact Sheet: Digital Promise Initiative
“Digital Promise” Factsheet
Digital Promise is a new national center created by Congress with bipartisan support to advance technologies that can transform teaching and learning. It is being launched today with startup funds and support from the Department of Education as well as the Carnegie Corporation of New York and the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation.
Answering the President’s call to action, a number of prominent leaders in education and technology will help lead Digital Promise. Board members, who were appointed by Secretary of Education Arne Duncan based on recommendations from the House of Representatives and United States Senate, include John Morgridge (Chairman Emeritus of Cisco), Larry Grossman (former President of NBC News), Irwin Jacobs (co-founder of Qualcomm), Gilman Louie (founder of In-Q-Tel), Eamon Kelly (President Emeritus of Tulane University), Mark Dean (IBM Fellow and Vice President), Shae Hopkins (Executive Director and CEO, Kentucky Educational Television), Vince Juaristi (CEO & President, Arbola, Inc.), and Shirley Malcom (Head of the Directorate for Education and Human Resources Programs, American Association for the Advancement of Science). For more information, go to: www.digitalpromise.org.
To realize the potential of learning technology, Digital Promise will work with leading educators, researchers, technology firms, and entrepreneurs on three key challenges:
- Identifying breakthrough technologies. For years, researchers have been working on developing educational software that is as effective as a personal tutor. Preliminary results from a DARPA/Navy “digital tutor” project suggest that we can reduce the time required to become an expert in IT from years to months. Achieving similar results in subjects such as math would transform K-12 education. Digital Promise will begin its work by partnering with technology firms and researchers to map the R&D landscape,identifying opportunities for breakthroughs in learning from the cradle through a career.
- Learning faster what's working and what's not. Internet startups do rapid evaluations of their sites, running test after test to continually improve their services. When it comes to education, R&D cycles can take years, producing results that are out of date the minute they're released. Digital Promise will work with researchers and entrepreneurs to develop new approaches for rapidly evaluating new products.
- Transforming the market for learning technologies. With more than 14,000 school districts and outdated procurement systems, it’s difficult for entrepreneurs to break into the market and it’s also tough to prove that their products can deliver meaningful results. Meanwhile, the amount we invest in R&D in K-12 education is estimated at just 0.2% of total spending on K-12 education, compared to 10-20% of revenues spent on R&D in many knowledge-intensive industries such as software development and biotech. Digital Promise will work with school districts to create “smart demand” that drives private-sector investment in innovation.
Other Initiatives Being Announced with the Launch of Digital Promise
Creating a League of Innovative Schools:In partnership with Digital Promise, leading schools, school districts, and networks such as the District of Columbia Public Schools; Mooresville Graded School District, North Carolina; High Tech High in San Diego, California; York County School Division, Virginia; E.L. Haynes in Washington, DC; Malden High School, Malden, Massachusetts; and the New Tech High Network, are coming together to launch a League of Innovative Schools. The League will be a coalition of schools dedicated to innovation in learning technologies and significant improvements in educational outcomes. The League will explore key steps it can take to help the learning technology market, including:
- Rapid testing of promising new technologies.Internet companies like Netflix and Amazon don’t make decisions on the basis of hunches. They use rapid, low-cost experimentation to continually improve their products. Similar opportunities exist for learning technologies. Schools with the flexibility to try new things and the data systems to capture the results offer opportunities for trials, both identifying what works and doing rapid prototyping to refine new tools. Working together, these schools can accelerate the pace of learning and innovation.
- Creating a buyers’ consortium to demand better prices and higher quality.New Hampshire, Vermont, Rhode Island, and Maine formed a consortium called the New England Common Assessment Program to buy testing materials together, getting a higher quality product at a lower cost. Members of the League can band together to improve their purchasing power for emerging solutions.
- Encouraging entrepreneurs to develop game-changing innovations by promising to buy them.By using what’s called an “Advance Market Commitment,” five countries and the Gates Foundation agreed to purchase large quantities of a vaccine that hadn’t been developed yet – a vaccine to immunize kids in developing countries against diseases such as pneumonia and meningitis. The private sector responded, and today that vaccine is on the market and could help save the lives of 7 million children by 2030. Similarly, a consortium of schools and school districts could encourage entrepreneurs to develop new solutions that deliver dramatic improvements in student learning outcomes.
New Investments by NSF on Cyber-learning: In support of the Administration’s initiative, the National Science Foundation will announce $15 million in new awards to support research that is developing next-generation learning environments.
Innovative research projects and prototypes include:
- "GeoGames" that help students analyze data across geographical areas to solve real-world challenges;
- Robots that use non-verbal cues to teach vocabulary to kids;
- Systems that create augmented reality for students with hearing disabilities;
- Tools for family learning about energy management using data from home thermostats; and
- Online tutors that assess a student's real-time comprehension and tailor learning strategies.
New Analysis by Council of Economic Advisers on Learning Technology Market: A well-trained workforce is essential to economic growth and competitiveness, and the skills of the entire workforce depend critically on the educational foundation established during the K-12 school years. Well-designed instructional software can provide personalized learning, adapting to the needs of individual students and evolving as the student progresses, which can be an important complement to other educational reform efforts. Educational technology holds the promise of substantially improving outcomes for K-12 students, but there are significant challenges in bringing new products to market.
A new analysis by the Council of Economic Advisers, to be released in conjunction with the launch of Digital Promise, examines the learning technologies market and steps that could be taken to reduce barriers for entrepreneurs. The CEA analysis found substantial promise for education technology, but identified two key challenges for entrepreneurs: (1) it is difficult for producers of these technologies to demonstrate the effectiveness of their products to potential buyers, and (2) market fragmentation creates barriers to entry by all but the largest suppliers. The CEA analysis concluded that the spread of broadband Internet and Common Core State Standards have improved the landscape for educational technologies, but these factors alone are likely insufficient for a “game changing” advance. Additional steps are needed to identify measures that could provide local school systems with greater access to good information about the effectiveness of various educational technology products and give prospective developers of these products access to customers on a scale sufficient to encourage entry into the market.
Leading Researchers Working Together to Determine What Works in Learning Technology:Supporting the goals of Digital Promise, the Urban Education Lab, hosted by the University of Chicago’s Urban Education Institute, will launch a new national alliance of over 35 of America’s top education-policy researchers intended to help improve the educational outcomes of our country’s most disadvantaged children. The new Urban Education Lab will seek to:
- Assemble inter-disciplinary teams of leading education-policy researchers and practitioners to carry out randomized controlled trials of the sort common in medicine, to provide “gold standard” tests of a wide range of policies that have the potential to be fundamental for improving schooling outcomes in U.S. urban areas;
- Combine the results of these randomized experiments with benefit-cost analysis to help policymakers ensure that investments in education generate the greatest possible social returns;
- Help disseminate new research findings with the goal of having every school and child in the country benefit from “best practices” identified by rigorous social science analysis.
Affiliates of the new Urban Education Lab already have numerous studies underway, including how to improve classroom learning environments through better use of technology.
Launch of 2012 National STEM Video Game Challenge:In partnership with Digital Promise, a coalition of leading technology companies, community-based organizations, and educational non-profits are today announcing year two of the National STEM Video Game Challenge. The competition harnesses the appeal of making and playing video games to foster motivation for STEM subjects (science, technology, engineering and mathematics). The Challenge—inspired by President Obama’s Educate to Innovate campaign—was developed by the Joan Ganz Cooney Center at Sesame Workshop and E-Line Media and is sponsored by the AMD Foundation, Entertainment Software Association, Microsoft X Box 360 and the CPB-PBS Ready to Learn Initiative. Outreach partners include the American Library Association, the American Association of School Librarians, Boys and Girls Club of America, Girl Scouts of the USA, the George Lucas Educational Foundation, One Economy Corporation, International Game Developers Association, and BrainPOP.
Leading Video Game Company Establishes Education Prize: Valve, creator of best-selling video game franchises and leading technologies, is stepping into the educational arena due to interest from teachers, students, researchers, and fans after the release of Portal 2, a brain-challenging puzzle game. Valve will run a competition next year where middle- and high-school students and teachers can create levels of Portal 2 to be used in the home and classroom while competing for prizes worth $250,000. As a start, Valve will be giving out free copies of Portal, the first in the series, which is rated for teens. For more information, go to:www.learnwithportals.com.
The Nature Conservancy and Morgridge Family Foundation Partnering to Create Digital Content for Kids: The Nature Conservancy is announcing a $2 million gift from the Morgridge Family Foundation to support the development of new digital educational content based on its conservation science. The Nature Conservancy has more than 500 scientists working on conservation around the country. Through this program, the Conservancy will make their research available to hundreds of thousands of students and educators, taking its messages and content into the classroom and the home at scale. The platform will launch in the spring of 2012 with plans to translate content into other languages.
Tech Firms Providing Recommendations and Support for Digital Promise: To further the goals of Digital Promise, TechAmerica Foundation – through an effort dubbed the Recommendations for Education and Advancement of Learning (REAL) Agenda – will assemble a commission of leading technology leaders and outline a set of initial R&D and policy priorities for the inaugural years of Digital Promise. The TechAmerica trade association will also publicize the effort and identify funding sources from among its 1,000 member companies. In addition, the Information Technology Industry Council (ITI) has committed to helping incubate Digital Promise by providing counsel from education technology experts, identifying funding sources, and partnering to promote the mission of the initiative. The Software and Information Industry Association (SIIA) will provide counsel on the initiative’s agenda, promote industry and investor involvement and funding, and disseminate information on its efforts to support the development of innovative learning technologies.
Seattle School Board Election Debate at Town Hall | Seattle Education
Seattle School Board Election Debate at Town Hall
Press release from The Stranger:
School Board Election Debate at Town Hall
Four Serious Challengers on Fall Ballot Could Tip Balance of District Power
Audience Will Vote via Text Message for Debate Winners
WHERE: Town Hall Seattle, upstairs
WHEN: Wednesday, September 28, 7:30 to 9:00 p.m.
WHO: All school board incumbents and challengers in the general election, moderated by KIRO’s Dave Ross
RESERVE YOUR SEAT: Tickets are free; go online to guarantee your seat (http://strangertickets.com/events/3945184/a-debate-in-four-school-board-races)
After a three-year run of controversies, ranging from school closures to a $1.8 million-dollar alleged fraud scandal
Shanker Blog » Collective Bargaining Teaches Democratic Values, Activism
Collective Bargaining Teaches Democratic Values, Activism
Some people must have been startled by President Obama’s decision to draw a line in the sand on collective bargaining in his jobs speech to the Congress last week. Specifically, the President said: “I reject the idea that we have to strip away collective bargaining rights to compete in a global economy.”
Given the current anti-union tenor of many prominent Republicans, started by Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker, it seems pretty clear that worker rights is shaping up to be a hot-button issue in the 2012 campaign. Collective bargaining rights as presidential campaign plank? It wasn’t that long ago that anything to do with unions was considered to be an historic anachronism – hardly worth a major Republican presidential candidate’s trouble to bash. Times have changed.
In that context, President Obama’s very strong defense of collective bargaining is noteworthy, especially because the somewhat prosaic process of collective bargaining is the heart of trade unionism. It is at the bargaining table that workplace power is balanced, and the voice of employees is heard. It is where, as huma


State law says it is illegal for public unions to strike. So they are in violation. ... (September 16, 2011, by LittleLordFauntleroy) Read more