Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, July 6, 2019

KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all



KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG 

A site to discuss better education for all

Big Education Ape: My New Book Was Just Announced! | Diane Ravitch's blog -https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/05/my-new-book-was-just-announced-diane.html

Big Education Ape: My Favorite Things | Diane Ravitch's blog @dianeravitch - http://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/07/my-favorite-things-diane-ravitchs-blog.html




Andrea Gabor: The Slow But Steady Decline of the Charter Industry
Andrea Gabor is one of the most interesting education writers around. She holds the Bloomberg Chair in Business Journalism at Baruch College. Her articles appear on sites read by people in the business world. Yet she has a firm grasp of education issues. Her latest book, After the Education Wars , has the best discussion of New Orleans education issues that I have seen. Her book The Man Who Inven
An Exchange About Destroying a Significant Work of Art That Some Find Offensive
An activist named Julie wrote me on my personal email to explain why it was morally necessary to destroy the painting called “Life of Washington” that is hanging in a San Francisco public high school. The painting is shown here . It is a WPA mural, painted in the 1930s by a prominent Russian immigrant artist. Victor Arnautoff, the Russian immigrant who made the paintings in question, was perhaps

YESTERDAY

Lloyd Lofthouse: Maybe Partition Is the Best Answer
Lloyd Lofthouse is a writer, a former member of the military, and a faithful reader and contributor to the blog. When I read this comment, I almost fell off my chair laughing. I’m all for these [red] states leaving the union and forming their own country. This new country will call itself Trumplandia. Then Trump will resign as president (to escape all the investigations and legal threats) of the
Is it Just or Patriotic to Paint Over Art That Offends Someone?
Larry Cuban posts here an opinion piece that appeared originally in the New York Times about a decision by the San Francisco School Board to paint over (and thus destroy) a Depression-Era mural that is highly critical of the U.S. The artist Victor Arnautoff was a Russian immigrant and a Communist. His mural “Life of Washington” depicted George Washington and other Founding Fathers in a very negat
Jersey Jazzman: What You Need to Know About Newark
Jersey Jazzman, aka Dr. Mark Weber, teacher, scholar, and blogger, brings the facts about the Newark schools up to date . He does so in part because of Senator Cory Booker’s campaign, which has prompted news stories about the “Newark miracle.” Bottom line: Don’t believe in miracles, at least secular miracles.
Red Queen in LA: Deciphering the Charter Chaos and Shape-Shifting
This is another brilliant post by Sara Roos, known as Red Queen in LA. She read the report of the leaked emails among charter advocates. She notes their double talk, their rhetorical legerdemain, their organizations that pop up like mushrooms, then morph into new organizations. Behind this seeming chaos is a steady purpose: to disrupt and destroy public education. Behind the chaos is the steady f
Los Angeles: Did Austin Beutner Clear His Major Policy Speech with the Charter Lobby?
Blogger MIchael Kohnhaas says that Los Angeles Superintendent Austin Beutner precleared a major policy speech with charter lobbyists. He provides documentation . Critics feared that the charter majority was choosing Beutner to do their bidding. This post suggests they chose well. The story about the secret plan was reported by the Los Angeles Times here . The Plan is to win control of the board,

JUL 04

Charles Foster Johnson: This Land Really Does Belong to You and Me
Charles Foster Johnson, leader of Pastors for Texas Children, reflects on the meaning of citizenship: America is not a geography. Or nationality. Or ethnicity. America is an idea. A truth. That idea, that truth, is this: “That all men are created equal and endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights, among them life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” Jefferson was right, that i
Teresa Hanafin on Trump’s Parade
The Boston Globe has a daily feature called Fast Forward written by Teresa Hanafin. I enjoy reading whatever she writes. Here she is in Trump’s parade: All I wish on this Fourth of July holiday weekend is that Trump doesn’t embarrass us any more than he already has with his co-opting of the DC celebration for partisan political purposes and a grandiose exercise in self-flattery. Blowing up what h
In Which Fred Klonsky Agrees with Thomas Friedman
Fred Klonsky proclaims his agreements with NY Times columnist Thomas Friedman. “If Democrats can choose a nominee who speaks to our impending challenges, but who doesn’t say irresponsible stuff about immigration or promise free stuff we can’t afford, who defines new ways to work with business and energize job-creators, who treats with dignity the frightened white working-class voters who abandone
Trump Celebrates July 4 with Weapons of War on the Mall
Trump aims to be our very own Il Duce. Having seen (on TV) the great military parades in North Korea, Moscow, and Beijing, where the Maximum Leader commands all attention, Trump wants the same adulation. He has joked about serving a third term because his base won’t let him leave. He has admired the fact that Kim is President for Life. His delusions of his own magnificence are limitless. Any day
A True American Patriot and a Hero of Public Education
Neema Avashia learned that her middle school in Boston was going to close. She decided that she would stand and fight. She did. She is a true patriot. She made a difference. She defeated the powerful. She is a hero of the Resistance. She joins the honor roll of this blog. She writes: My gloves came off the day representatives of my school district told us they would be closing our school . Our st
Steven Singer: American Public Schools Are Great!
Steven Singer wrote this last year, but it remains pertinent and on the money. He says that there is a narrative spun by Disrupters that American schools are in “crisis” and are “failing.” He says this is baloney, or bologna, whichever spelling you prefer. Singer says that American public schools are among the best in the world. He writes: Critics argue that our scores on international tests don’
Linda Lyon: Teachers Are the True Patriots!
Linda Lyon served honorably for many years in the U.S. Air Force. She retired with her wife to Arizona where she became involved in the local school board. A strong and forceful person, she eventually was elected president of the Arizona School Board Association. She is a strong advocate for well-funded public schools. Some weeks ago, she read that the Arizona Chamber of Commerce wanted to hold a

JUL 03

Ex-Governor Rick Snyder Will Not Teach at Harvard, as Backlash Grows Against Him
Michigan Ex-Governor Rick Snyder will not teach at Harvard, The outcry over Snyder’s role in the Flint water crisis made his position at Harvard untenable. Former Gov. Rick Snyder has pulled out of a prestigious fellowship at Harvard University after the Ivy League school faced immense criticism for the governor’s track record in the Flint water crisis. Snyder announced midday Wednesday his decis
Pennsylvania’s Expensive, Ineffective Cyber Charters
From the Keystone State Coalition, administered by Lawrence Feinberg: Started in November 2010, daily postings from the Keystone State Education Coalition now reach more than 4050 Pennsylvania education policymakers – school directors, administrators, legislators, legislative and congressional staffers, Governor’s staff, current/former PA Secretaries of Education, Wolf education transition team m
Michigan: Gov. Whitmer Wants to Impose Deformers on Benton Harbor
Thomas Pedroni of Wayne State University writes that Governor Gretchen Whitmer wants to impose corporate reform organizations on Benton Harbor to “save” the underfunded district. A cruel hoax. She is carrying forward the foul legacy of Republican Governor Rick Snyder. Michigan Gov Whitmer Grants Benton Harbor Schools a Trojan Horse-load of School Privatizers Michigan Democratic Governor Gretchen
Washington State: “Bold Experiment” with Charters Is Flunking
Give Bill Gates credit for persistence. He wanted charter schools in Washington State and he wouldn’t give up. The state held four referendums about whether to authorize private charter schools, and the idea was defeated time after time after time. Until 2012. Gates and his billionaire buddies raised a multimillion dollar war chest that completely overwhelmed the opposition of the PTAs, the Leagu
Carol Burris Responds to Charter Industry Critique of NPE’s “Asleep At the Wheel”
Last March, the Network for Public Education released a report written and researched by Carol Burris and Jeff Bryant, titled Asleep At the Wheel. It reviewed grants awarded by the federal Charter Schools Program and found that about a third of the grants went to charters that either never opened or closed soon after opening. It also reported that the CSP administrators did not conduct due dilige

JUL 02

Border Patrol Agents: Their Secret Commications
ProPublica posted excerpts from what had been a secret Facebook page where 9,500 border patrol agents exchanged messages. Their contents are disgusting: racist, sexist, cruel, crude. The article begins: Members of a secret Facebook group for current and former Border Patrol agents joked about the deaths of migrants, discussed throwing burritos at Latino members of Congress visiting a detention fa
Larry Lee: What Does Texas Know, But Alabama Does Not Know?
Larry Lee has been following the saga of the Gulen charter that plans to open in a rural county in Alabama. In this post , he notes that the Texas State Board of Education turned down the same charter leader that Alabama’s charter commission approved. He wonders what led a bipartisan majority in Texas to reject the charter application. Texas has many Gulen charters. Why did they reject this one?
Peter Greene: On Reading “Winners Take All,” a Morality Tale for Our Times
Peter Greene read and loved Anand Giridharadas’ Winners Take All: The Elite Charade of Changing the World. So did I, which is why it is on my short list of books I recommend for summer reading. Peter writes: Every so often you come across a book that unpacks and reframes a part of the universe in a way that you can never unsee. Winners Take All by Anand Giridharadas has been a book like that for
Jersey Jazzman: Do Test Scores Go Up When Tests Are Harder?
Jersey Jazzman untangles a simpleminded assertion by New Jersey Reformers: Harder Tests Make kids smarterand Cause scores to go up. We have been hearing this claim since NCLB was enacted. And we must ask, what’s the connection between scores going up and learning more? Test prep can drive scores higher too.
Oklahoma: Teachers Accuse For-Profit Charter Chain of Fraud
Former teachers at for-profit Epic charter chain claim they were compelled to inflate enrollment. Charter spokesperson denies it. Administrators at Epic Charter Schools have been allowing, encouraging or pressuring teachers to manipulate students’ enrollment for years in order to improve employees’ bonus pay, according to at least seven former teachers. Four of the teachers allege the practices i
Gary Rubinstein: This Article is Propaganda for TFA and Charter Schools
Gary Rubinstein writes here about an article he was surprised to read in Chalkbeat. He was surprised because he expects more of Chalkbeat. The article lauds a young TFA teacher who has just finished her first year. He writes: The basic premise is that Angelique Hines a first year TFA teacher placed in a brand new charter school in Tennessee is featured in a series of interviews by Chalkbeat calle
Peter Greene: The Case That Could Shed the Wall of Separation
Peter Greene writes here about a case that could knock down the wall of separation between church and state. With two Trump appointees, the Supreme Court appears poised to rule in favor of state support for religious school tuition. Despite the fact that voters overwhelmingly reject vouchers (when the public is asked to voice its view). Despite the fact that studies consistently show that childre

JUL 01

A Note to Readers
I was traveling in Italy yesterday (birthday) and offline. I just read your lovely comments, and I thank you one and all for your kind words. I am now in a farmhouse in rural Tuscany, and it is as beautiful as represented in the movies. Only moreso.
My Favorite Cause: Please Support NPE and NPE Action
This is my favorite cause. Please join and support if you want to be part of the Resistance. The Network for Public Education began in 2013, founded by Anthony Cody and me. Since its humble beginnings, the Network has grown to 330,000 followers on its mailing lists. NPE led the protest against the appointment of Betsy DeVos, generating over 100,000 emails to the Senate in a matter of days. Since
My Father’s Favorite Singers and Favorite Songs
My father was born in Savannah, Georgia. He was the youngest of a very large family and the only boy. He was called “Cracker” all his life because of his home state. As a teen, he longed to be on the stage, and he dropped out of high school to give it a try. He was briefly in vaudeville, where he teamed up with a tall beautiful brunette from Savannah named Lillian Wise. They had an act called “Th
My All-Time Favorite Movie (and a Few Current Favorites)
My all-time favorite movie is “ Singin’ in the Rain. ” I have lost track of how many times I have seen it. Every time I see it, I enjoy it all over again. Gene Kelly and Donald O’Connor are a great singing and dancing team. Nineteen-year-old Debbie Reynolds is beautiful, adorable, fresh, a wonderful ingenue. The music is delightful. TCM has an excellent history of the movie, which is about Hollyw
My Favorite Television Programs
There is something I must explain about my taste in entertainment. I don’t like horror films, and I don’t like graphic violence. That considerably narrows the range of what I watch. I want to be entertained or learn, not to be terrified or depressed by what I choose to see. Having said that, I confess that one of my TV favorites (now an oldie) was “The Wire.” It is a series about the long-running
Today Is My Birthday
I was born 81 years ago in St. Joseph’s Hospital in Houston, Texas, at 12:01 am. Eighty is the new 60. No, the new 50. Or 40. I am third of eight children. My mother was born in Bessarabia and came to this country when she was 9 years old. She was a very proud graduate of the Houston public schools. My grandfather in Houston was a tailor. My father grew up in Savannah. He was a mischievous boy, I

JUN 30

Carol Burris: Who Is Ferdinand Zulueta?
Carol Burris wrote this post on learning that the National Charter Schools Conference was honoring charter chain founder Ferdinand Zulueta. I am dumfounded that Fernando Zulueta is being honored by the National Charter Schools Conference. He and his brother run one of the most notorious for-profit charter management companies in the country, Academica. The Office of Inspector General’s audit of t
National Charter School Conference Honors Its Heroes
One of our readers and frequent commenters—Joe Nathan— was elected to the Charter School Hall of Fame and will be honored at the National Charter Schools Conference. Joe helped to write the first charter law in the nation in Minnesota. He and Ted Kolderie ensured that charters would be deregulated and would not confirm to Albert Shanker’s template on unionized schools approved only by local schoo
Great Britain: School Privatization Run Amok
Thanks to Leonie Haimson for sending along this paper . The “academy” concept began under a Conservative government that believed private enterprise was infinitely wiser than public anything. Corporations and wealthy individuals were encouraged to “buy” control of schools by putting up a large sum. Things seem to going swimmingly for the idea. This is a small excerpt. When I was part of the Koret
Missouri: This is How Much the Legislature Loves Its Suburban Moms!
This is a great opinion article by Tony Messenger, a regular columnist for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, which is one of the nation’s great newspapers. It is an Open Letter addressed to Missouri’s Suburban Moms and written in the voice of the state Republican party. This is the party that loves women so much that it voted to eliminate all abortions, even in the case of rape, incest, or a threat to
St. Louis: Can the District Recover After Years of “Oppressive Rule”?
Jeff Bryant writes about the obstacles faced by districts where state control is coming to an end. He takes St. Louis as his prime example., One urban district that faces an especially steep climb out of the abyss of oppressive rule is St. Louis. When I first reported from St. Louis in 2017, I found a school system which had been designed to be the gem of the Midwest had instead been decimated. F
St. Louis: Four New Charters, One Charter Closes
St. Louis will get four new charters, including another KIPP and a private school that turned charter so families would no longer pay tuition. A charter plagued with financial mismanagement and suspicion of inflated enrollment will close. Kairos Academies is enrolling sixth-graders for its personalized learning-themed middle and high school opening in the Marine Villa neighborhood. It’s the only
Maurice Cunningham: A Privatizing Philanthropist Buys Space in the Boston Globe
Maurice Cunningham is a Professor at the University of Massachusetts who writes a blog that”follows the money.” He also happens to be one of the heroes in my new book “Slaying Goliath.” I n this post , he warns that philanthropists are using their vast resources to buy control of the news, in this case, the Boston Globe . You may recall that Eli Broad gave the Los Angeles Times $800,000 a year yo

JUN 29

Peter Greene: DeVos Puts Profits Over Students (Are You Surprised?)
Peter Greene writes here about Betsy DeVos’s recent decision to roll back Obama-era regulations intended to protect students against predatory for-profit colleges. Sadly, this is what we have come to expect from a Secretary of Education who is more interested in protecting the free market than protecting students against fraud. Greene writes that DeVos rolled back the Obama-era requirement that s
FAIR: The NewYork Times Hates Bernie Sanders
Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting (FAIR) reports on the New York Times’ consistently biased reporting about Bernie Sanders. it seems fair to say that the New York Times wants to knock Senator Sanders outif the Race. Why?
Jan Resseger: Florida’s Education Disaster
In this post , Jan Resseger surveys the war against public schools in Florida. Sue Legg summarized the abject failure of Jeb Bush’s A+ Plan here . The drive to privatize public schools was masterminded by Jeb Bush, with the help of Betsy DeVos, a compliant Republican Legislature (including some who own or operate charter schools), and a zest to give public money to entrepreneurs and grifters. Ass
Oklahoma: The Billionaire Who Bought the University of Tulsa and Stifled the Liberal Arts
D Read this sad story. A billionaire with too much money and no vision buys the University of Tulsa. His plan gutted the liberal arts, raised default teaching loads across the university from five courses per year to eight, eliminated all academic departments, created new divisions to house surviving programs (including one called “Humanities and Social Justice”), and established a “Professional
Matt Barnum: Is Laurene Powell Jobs Reinventing the High School?
Let us give credit to Chalkbeat: It is not afraid to give an equivocal review to one of its funders, billionaire Laurene Powell Jobs. Barnum presents the facts about the spotty record of LPJ’s XQ Initiative. Her goal, she said, is to “reinvent” the high school. She has given grants of $10 million to a variety of high schools, each of which has its own plans and ideas. These high schools are suppo
Mercedes Schneider: All Student Records in NOLA Will Be Audited After Scandal
Mercedes Schneider reports a welcome development in New Orleans: in the wake of a grade-fixing scandal, all student records will be audited. As she says, it is about time. After so much boasting from NOLA, it’s time to check the facts. She writes: This is a long time coming. As a result of the grade-fixing scandal at a New Orleans charter high school– a scandal that resulted in 49 percent of the
Ann Cronin: This is How to Assess Student Achievement
Veteran educator Ann Cronin offers her plan to assess real student achievement. Skip the standardized tests and assess what students know and can do. She shows how it can be done, saving every state and district millions now wasted on the testing industry.
Another Reformer Organization Pops Up
There seems to be no shortage of money to create new corporate reformer organizations, and they seem to open faster than anyone can keep track of them. Here is a new one: Results for America. You will recognize the names of 




Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all


Friday, July 5, 2019

WATCH THE VIDEO: Strong Public Schools Presidential Forum #REDFORED #CTA #StrongPublicSchools #ra19 #nea #neara19 #houston

Strong Public Schools Presidential Forum

Strong Public Schools Presidential Forum





Join NEA President Lily Eskelsen García as she hosts the Strong Public Schools 2020 Presidential Forum on Friday, July 5!
We’ll be sitting down with former Vice President Joe Biden, Former HUD Secretary Julián Castro, Mayor Bill DeBlasio, Sen. Kamala Harris, Gov. Jay Inslee, Sen. Amy Klobuchar, former Rep. Beto O’Rourke, Rep. Tim Ryan, Sen. Bernie Sanders, and Sen. Elizabeth Warren.
Educators are poised to play a major role in choosing the president of the United States, and we can’t wait to sit down with these candidates to discuss the public schools our students and educators deserve.


WHERE TO WATCH the #StrongPublicSchools forum can be found here: http://bit.ly/SPS2020Forum


America’s largest labor union, the National Education Association, will host 2020 presidential candidates at its annual Representative Assembly in Houston. Educators are poised to play a major role in choosing the president of the United States. And now we are taking this energy to the 2020 campaign where we will lead a conversation about the schools our students deserve.

The strike that brought teachers unions back from the dead - Vox

The strike that brought teachers unions back from the dead - Vox

The strike that brought teachers unions back from the dead
When these Chicagoans walked off the job in 2012, they changed the future of organizing.

On the morning of September 10, 2012, the bells rang to open Chicago’s public schools, but there were no teachers in the classrooms.
The night before, negotiations with Chicago’s reform-minded mayor, Rahm Emanuel, had gone south, and the new activist leaders of the city’s 25,000-member teachers union, clad all in red, walked out. Surrounded by a throng of cameras, they declared that their members would go on strike for the first time in 25 years.
“It looks like a sure bet in hindsight, but at the time, not so much,” recalls Jesse Sharkey, a former high school social studies teacher and chess-team coach who was part of a new guard that took over the Chicago Teachers Union in 2010. “I can remember hearing, ‘They can’t do that!’”
City leaders had been closing schools for years as part of an education reform platform; teachers were becoming easier to fire under new accountability rules. But the strike was a risk they felt they had to take. “We were okay with it,” says Stacy Davis-Gates, who was one of the many black educators to walk out that day (she is now the Chicago union’s vice president). “We had no other choice.”
The teachers needed a new contract, and the two sides were at odds; Emanuel, who’d served as President Barack Obama’s chief of staff and was a year into his job as Chicago’s mayor, wanted to pair raises with layoffs, and the new union leadership wouldn’t accept. They went on strike to demand not only better compensation but also that officials deemphasize standardized tests in determining teacher pay. They wanted smaller class sizes too. They adopted a simple slogan: The Schools Students Deserve.

The strike — the first walkout in a major city since Detroit teachers sought better pay in 2006 — ended nine days later, but not before Emanuel would pursue a court order to try to force teachers back to school. (He failed.) The union won concessions on many of the issues it cared most about: a 16 percent raise over four years, less emphasis on test scores in evaluating teachers, the right for laid-off teachers to get first dibs on new job openings at CONTINUE READING: The strike that brought teachers unions back from the dead - Vox

5 Effective Techniques For Improving Student Performance With the Help Of Psychology + 10 Things Every New Teacher Should Know Teacher Habits

5 Effective Techniques For Improving Student Performance With the Help Of Psychology - Teacher Habits

5 Effective Techniques For Improving Student Performance With the Help Of Psychology



Guest Writer: Michael Gorman
5 EFFECTIVE TECHNIQUES FOR IMPROVING STUDENT PERFORMANCE WITH THE HELP OF PSYCHOLOGY
There are many different methodologies that exist today that claim to improve learning for the student. They promise to improve the way students learn as well as the way teachers teach. Having worked with services like EssaysOnTime.com, and also running an essay service, I can confidently say that I am firmly in the education industry. I have attended tons of seminars, team meetings, conferences, and watched a lot of media on the matter and all I see is a plethora of different methodologies by well-meaning speakers that claim they will work. 
Granted, some of the information out there is actually helpful. However, some of the stuff that is being peddled to teachers really has no empirical data to back it up and turns out to have little to no utility in the classroom. 
I decided to go out and do some thorough research, and I came across a publication by the Coalition for Psychology in Schools and Education (CPSE). The whole idea behind the document was to outline 20 principles that are based on psychological science and seek to show what parts of a student’s psychology are the most instrumental to CONTINUE READING: 5 Effective Techniques For Improving Student Performance With the Help Of Psychology - Teacher Habits
10 Things Every New Teacher Should Know

Guest Writer: Kurt Walker
Being a teacher is a tough job, and the toughest part of it is usually the first year because it will be a completely new experience for you that comes with many unexpected factors and responsibilities.
In your first year as a teacher, you should accept and embrace your status of “the new teacher”; denying it would be pointless. This year you will learn a lot, so you might feel overwhelmed at some point.
Therefore, to help you make your first year a bit easier and less stressful, in today’s post we’re presenting our top 10 things every new teacher should know.
  • Learn About Classroom Management

Even mothers have trouble managing their kids and they only have to deal with 2-4 of them, not a whole classroom. Therefore, you should learn about classroom management for your own good and peace of mind. Kids can be hard to manage, but with clear expectations, consistent followthrough, and mutual respect, your first year can be a success. For good advice on classroom management, check out CONTINUE READING: 10 Things Every New Teacher Should Know



Los Angeles: Did Austin Beutner Clear His Major Policy Speech with the Charter Lobby? | Diane Ravitch's blog

Los Angeles: Did Austin Beutner Clear His Major Policy Speech with the Charter Lobby? | Diane Ravitch's blog

Los Angeles: Did Austin Beutner Clear His Major Policy Speech with the Charter Lobby?

Blogger MIchael Kohnhaas says that Los Angeles Superintendent Austin Beutner precleared a major policy speech with charter lobbyists. He provides documentation. Critics feared that the charter majority was choosing Beutner to do their bidding.
This post suggests they chose well.
The story about the secret plan was reported by the Los Angeles Times here.
The Plan is to win control of the board, the Mayor’s office, Sue the district, fight the teachers’ union.
Ben Austin’s email to charter supporters is quoted. Austin, you may recall, founded the billionaire funded Parent Revolution. He likes to pawn himself off as a “liberal,” who just happens to love charters and win Walton funding. His Patent Revolution spent millions trying to persuade poor parents to sign petitions to turn their public schools over to charter chains. It was a bust. The Revolution never happened. But Ben has now moved on and has created another AstroTurf group called “The Kids’ New Deal.”
Howard Blume writes:
The overriding issue of the email is how to overcome setbacks at the hands of the teachers union. Leaders of the union had vilified charters in the lead-up to the strike, saying that rapid charter growth was undermining traditional public schools by siphoning away motivated students and their families — and the public funding that travels with them. One day during the walkout was devoted to a march on the local headquarters of the California Charter Schools Assn.
Meanwhile, at the state level, charter supporters had spent big on losing candidates in the 2018 race for governor as well as Tuck’s bid for state superintendent. A central concern was that the growth of charters would be halted or even reversed.
[Ben] Austin asserted in his email: “As Machiavelli says, it’s better to be feared than loved. Right now we are neither.”

“Classrooms and Hope” — Mike Rose’s Reflection for the Holiday Weekend | janresseger

“Classrooms and Hope” — Mike Rose’s Reflection for the Holiday Weekend | janresseger

“Classrooms and Hope” — Mike Rose’s Reflection for the Holiday Weekend

If you care about children, it is pretty easy to get discouraged in a country where state budgets are shorting schools, where we celebrated the 4th of July yesterday with tanks, and where children are being warehoused at the southern border in unsanitary, unsafe, and frightening conditions.
It is the holiday weekend when we celebrate who we want to be as a nation.  Where is there something hopeful we can focus on in 2019?  The UCLA education professor and wonderful writer, Mike Rose contemplates this question in a blog post earlier this week: “What in our lives acts as a counterforce to the dulling and blunting effects of evil, helps us see the good, hold to it, and work toward it?”
Rose, the educator who wrote a book about a four year trip across the United States—a journey in which he visited hundreds of classrooms and observed teachers—answers his own question: “I realized that for me a longstanding source of hope, of what might be, is the classroom, or more exactly, all that the classroom represents at its best: a sanctioned space for growth, learning, discovery, thinking and thinking together,”
In this post Rose describes what his visits to public schools helped him realize: “These trips to Calexico, to Baltimore, to Eastern Kentucky, to a nation within a nation in northern Arizona brought forth new cultural practices, new languages, new gestures.  I was fortunate to have been escorted into so many classrooms, so many homes, to have been guided into the everyday events of the communities I visited, for the invitation eased the unfamiliarity and discomfort that could have been present on all sides. What I experienced was a kind of awe at our variety, yet an intimate regard, a handshake on the corner, a sense of shared humanity.”
Rose continues: “The journey was odd for me in another way, considering my own teaching history.  My work in the classroom has mostly been with people whom our schools, public and private, have failed: working-class and immigrant students, students from nonmainstream CONTINUE READING: “Classrooms and Hope” — Mike Rose’s Reflection for the Holiday Weekend | janresseger

The Politics of Art in a San Francisco High School (Bari Weiss) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

The Politics of Art in a San Francisco High School (Bari Weiss) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

The Politics of Art in a San Francisco High School (Bari Weiss)


This op-ed column appeared in the New York Times June 28, 2019.
Bari Weiss (@bariweiss), a staff writer and editor for the Opinion section, is the author of the forthcoming “How to Fight Anti-Semitism.”
27Weiss-jumbo.jpg
More than $8,000. That was the amount John Ashcroft’s Justice Department spent on blue curtains to cover up the busty Spirit of Justice statue and her bare-chested male equivalent, the Majesty of Law, in the department’s Great Hall in 2002. The Victorian move against the Art Deco sculptures spurred a thousand lampoons. “A blue burqa for justice,” my colleague Maureen Dowd memorably called it. In The Harvard Crimson, a young Pete Buttigieg wrote, “It seems odd that an infant is supposed to feed on them, and a grown man is expected at some point to behold them, but for a period in between we feel the need to see to it that no child ever sees a breast.”

I wonder, then, what Mr. Buttigieg, now on the presidential campaign trail, would make of the San Francisco school board’s unanimous decision on Tuesday night to spend at least $600,000 of taxpayer money not just to shroud a historic work of art but to destroy it.
By now stories of progressive Puritanism (or perhaps the better word is Philistinism) are so commonplace — snowflakes seek safe space! — that it can feel tedious to track the details of the latest outrage. But this case is so absurd that it’s worth reviewing the specifics.
Victor Arnautoff, the Russian immigrant who made the paintings in question, was perhaps the most important muralist in the Bay Area during the Depression. Thanks to President Franklin Roosevelt’s Works Progress Administration, he had the opportunity to make some enduring public artworks. Among them is “City Life” in Coit Tower, in which the artist painted himself standing in front of a newspaper rack conspicuously missing the mainstream San Francisco Chronicle and packed with publications like The Daily Worker.
Arnautoff, who had assisted Diego Rivera in Mexico, was a committed Communist. “‘Art for art’s sake’ or art as perfume have never appealed to me,” he said in 1935. “The artist is a critic of society.”
This is why his freshly banned work, “Life of Washington,” does not show the clichéd image of our first president kneeling in prayer at Valley Forge. Instead, the 13-panel, 1,600-square-foot mural, which was painted in 1936 in the just-built George Washington High School, depicts his slaves picking cotton in the fields of Mount Vernon and a group of colonizers walking past the corpse of a Native American.
“At the time, high school history classes typically ignored the incongruity that Washington and others among the nation’s founders subscribed to the declaration that ‘all men are created equal’ and yet owned other human beings as chattel,” Robert W. Cherny writes in “Victor Arnautoff and the Politics of Art.”
In other words, Arnautoff’s purpose was to unsettle the viewer, to provoke young people into looking at American history from a different, darker perspective. Over the past months, art historians, New Deal scholars and even a group called the Congress of Russian Americans have tried to make exactly that point.
“This is a radical and critical work of art,” the school’s alumni association argued. “There are many New Deal murals depicting the founding of our country; very few even acknowledge slavery or the Native genocide. The Arnautoff murals should be preserved for their artistic, historical and educational value. Whitewashing them will simply result in another ‘whitewash’ of the full truth CONTINUE READING: The Politics of Art in a San Francisco High School (Bari Weiss) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice