Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, March 5, 2017

Diane Ravitch's blog News and Views That Will Kick You In The Boo Boo

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Diane Ravitch's blog News and Views That Will Kick You In The Boo Boo




URGENT MESSAGE TO PARENTS IN CONNECTICUT: Your Child’s Privacy at Risk!
Parents in Connecticut, pay attention and take action! The Parent Coalition for Student Privacy has sent out an urgent message to parents in Connecticut. The legislature is holding hearings on Monday (tomorrow) on a bill that would strip privacy protections from your children. In January, a legislator proposed to remove all privacy protections from student data. Because of outrage expressed by pa
When Jennifer Berkshire (AKA EduShyster) Met Lisa Alva, Candidate for LAUSD School Board
The election for the Los Angeles USD school board is Tuesday. Once again, the charter industry is trying to buy control of the school board. Once again, the charter billionaires are dumping obscene amounts of money into the races in different districts. In District 2, Charter QueenPin Monica Garcia is facing tough competition from two strong opponents: parent Carl Petersen and teacher Lisa Alva.
ALERT: Save Kentucky’s Public Schools!
NPE Action urges you to write a letter to state senators in Kentucky. Please read about the harm that this bill will do to the public schools . The bill now moves to the Kentucky state senate. Many, perhaps most, of the senators represent rural districts, where the public school is the heart of the community. They should oppose this law, as charters will take resources out of their public schools
Thank You to the Pastors for Texas Children for Defending Public Schools and Religious Freedom
As the prospects for passage of voucher legislation diminish in Texas, it is time to give thanks to the tireless work of the Pastors for Texas Children. The battle is not over until the legislative session ends, but it is still time to thank those who have worked so hard on behalf of our children, their teachers, and their public schools. This is an organization with some 2,000 members who repres
Good News! Looks Like Vouchers Are Dead This Year in Texas, Again!
Here is some good news: “State Rep. Dan Huberty, a Houston Republican and chairman of the House Public Education Committee, said Tuesday morning that school choice legislation has no path forward in the House during the current 


The Disappointing Results of Vouchers in Louisiana: An Evaluation of the First Two Years
A team of researchers associated with the University of Arkansas studied the first two years of the Louisiana Scholarship Program. Their report was released in late February . For those hoping to see a validation of the transformative power of vouchers, the results were disappointing, to say the least. “The Louisiana Scholarship Program (LSP) is a statewide private school voucher program availabl
Martin Carnoy: Vouchers Will Not Help the Neediest Students
Martin Carnoy is a professor at Stanford University who has studied education systems around the world. Carnoy wrote a report for the Economic Policy Institute about the efficacy of vouchers, or their lack thereof. The report is titled “School Vouchers Are Not a Proven Strategy for Improving Student Achievement.” Carnoy reviews the longest-running voucher programs in the U.S. and other countries
Kentucky: We Don’t Want Charter Vultures in Our State!
Gay Adelman of Save Our Schools Kentucky published the following letter to the editor in the Louisville Courier-Journal: “Kentucky is one of only seven states that has managed to avoid jumping off the charter school cliff, so far. However, our state legislature is poised to pass a charter school bill this month. As a parent volunteer and staunch advocate for public schools, everyone keeps telling
Kentucky: House Passes Charter Bill, with Strong Limits
Now that Republicans control the Governorship and the Legislature in Kentucky, they finally got a bill authorizing privately run charters through the lower house of the legislature. Kentucky is one of the few states that does not allow charters, or has been until now. In the world of Republican politics, it is important not to be different. One must run with the crowd, even if they are running of

YESTERDAY

A Must-See Oscar-Winning Documentary: “The White Helmets”
Tonight, I watched “The White Helmets,” which won the Oscar for best foreign documentary. It is well worth watching, though I don’t recommend that you watch it while eating a meal. It is heart-rending. It is about a corps of volunteers who save lives in Syria when the bombs are falling. Not much is said about politics. It is about humanity. It is hard to forget that the bombs are falling because
Oh, How Soon We Forget Our Martyrs!
Please open and pause for a moment of remembrance–or non-remembrance.
A Video from Iran to Trump in the International Contest for Second Best Country
If you have been following the video contest started by the Netherlands, you know that there is a website called everysecondcounts.eu, where the comedians of many EU countries have made videos directed to Donald Trump. Each of them acknowledges that Trump said in his inaugural speech that “from now on, it’s America First.” The Netherlands made the first video, saying it’s fine if America is first
Watch the Great Debate: Are Charter Schools Overrated?
This is a fun debate to watch, sponsored by Intelligence Squared. The proposition: Are Charter Schools Overrated? The debaters: For the proposition: Julian Vasquez Heilig and Gary Miron. They argue that charter schools are overrated. Against the proposition: Jeanne Allen and Gerard Robinson. They argue that charter schools are great.
Portland, Oregon: A Reformer is Coming Your Way
Portland parents, if you want to learn more about the person who is going to be your next school superintendent, please contact Ed Johnson, a watchdog over the Atlanta Public Schools. Edward Johnson: edwjohnson@aol.com
Tom Engelhardt: A Government of, by, and for the Billionaires
Tom Engelhardt writes in the Nation that Trump’s rise to power was facilitated by the reign of the billionaire class, a tiny class to be sure, but very powerful. He assumes that Trump is a billionaire. If we ever see his taxes, we may learn that his greatest hoax was persuading people he was a billionaire. He once called himself “the king of debt.” He may owe billions. His new job may help him pa
DFER Launches Phony Phone Campaign in DC to Promote Common Core and High-Stakes Testing
The hedge-fund manager group called Democrats for Education Reform (DFER) is conducting an aggressive telephone campaign in D.C. to promote the Common Core and high-stakes standardized testing. The rhetoric is deceptive, as usual. Jeffrey Anderson writes in the Washington City Paper: “In a one-party city with a civic focus on education, an advocacy group like Democrats for Education Reform (DFER)
Portland, Oregon: Leader from KIPP-TFA Runs for Portland Public School Board
In a hotly contested race, a former principal of a KIPP charter school is running for a seat on the Portland, Oregon, school board. The website of the candidate, Jamila Singleton Munson, does not mention her role in the KIPP corporate chain or the fact that she was chief of staff for Teach for America. Apparently she is still employed by TFA. TFA has a branch–Leaders for Educational Equity–that e
Susan Ochshorn: When Angie Sullivan Took On an Alt-Right Critic of Early Childhood Education
Susan Ochshorn writes frequently about early childhood education: policy and practice. In this post, she reports on an epic battle in Nevada between teacher Angie Sullivan and an alt-right critic of early childhood education. I have often cited Angie’s work in Nevada. She teaches little kids in Clark County, and her students are poor and include many who don’t speak English. She fights for them l
Teacher: What Mike Pence Did to Schools and Teachers in Indiana
A retired teacher shared the story of Mike a Pence’s role in transforming the schools of Indiana: Our former governor, Mike Pence, absolutely loves vouchers.Under his “leadership” Indiana became a national leader in giving vouchers to students and families. In fact, we have the dubious reputation of being one of the fastest-growing voucher states. We have a ridiculous merit pay system where highl


Steven Singer: The Way to Win Trump’s Support for Public Education
Steven Singer has dreamed up a way to win Trump’s support for education: Declare a war on ignorance! https://gadflyonthewallblog.wordpress.com/2017/03/01/how-to-get-trump-to-support-public-education-a-military-proposal/ If Trump can be persuaded that 


Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Could the L.A. school board's balance of power tip pro-charter? - LA Times

Could the L.A. school board's balance of power tip pro-charter? - LA Times:

Could the L.A. school board's balance of power tip pro-charter?

On Tuesday, charter school supporters have their best chance yet to tip the scales and win a controlling majority on the Los Angeles Board of Education.
Three of the seven seats are up for grabs, and charter backers have strong candidates, seemingly unlimited financial resources — with major help from former L.A. Mayor Richard Riordan — and the enthusiastic support of a growing number of charter-school families.
 The charter-backed candidates are Kelly Gonez in District 6, incumbent Monica Garcia in District 2, and Allison Holdorff Polhill and Nick Melvoin — both running against school board President Steve Zimmer — in District 4. If they prevail, they could form a majority alliance along with board member Ref Rodriguez, a charter school founder who is not up for reelection.

That would be a major power shift for a governing body that leans anti-charter but also is required to follow state laws friendly to charter schools’ rapid growth.


Their votes could move the nation’s second largest school system from steady, strong charter growth to swift expansion at a time when L.A. Unified is struggling with years of enrollment decline. At the very least, a pro-charter majority on the board could make more space available for charters on district-owned campuses, a longtime goal of charter operators.
Winners of the school board seats also will have extra-long terms, 5 ½ years rather than four, because the city is changing the timing of municipal elections.
Charter critics insist a pro-charter majority could permanently harm traditional public schools and the students they serve. Charter supporters see more charters as a benefit to families, especially those whose children now attend public schools with low standardized test scores. Some of them downplay the potential importance of the current election, as if averse to jinxing their prospects.
“We have some very talented candidates on the ballot, and voters who are much more engaged this time around,” said Richard Garcia, elections director for California Charter Schools Assn. Advocates, which controls much of the pro-charter campaign funding.


Voter engagement will matter in what is expected to be a low-turnout election.
Garcia and Rodriguez spoke at a February rally with participants from 20 charters, located mostly north and east of downtown, an area where many low-income Latino parents have opted for charters. Organizers said more than 1,000 people took part in the event, which included a march from City Hall to Mariachi Plaza in Boyle Heights. The charter-parent profile in District 4 is somewhat different, with many middle- and upper-middle-class parents.
Charters are publicly funded, free public schools that in California are managed by nonprofit organizations and are exempt from some rules that govern traditional schools. Most charters are nonunion, and their growth has presented a challenge both to powerful employee unions and the school district, which loses funding tied to enrollment when students leave its schools for charters.
With faster charter growth, L.A. Unified would find itself under increasing financial strain, because of enormous fixed costs from such things as lawsuit settlements, building Could the L.A. school board's balance of power tip pro-charter? - LA Times:

Sunday stuff. | Fred Klonsky

Sunday stuff. | Fred Klonsky:

Sunday stuff.


ows_148867002027823

Attorney Roy Cohn, right, with Sen. Joseph McCarthy during the Army hearings in 1954. Later, Cohn returned to New York and met Donald Trump.
Illinois needs a good school funding formula, not just a new one (“Stop talking and fix the state school funding formula,” Feb. 24). The Rauner commission recommended a supposedly evidence-based system based on 27 elements that would improve Illinois schools.
Some of the 27 were based on successful efforts in other schools, but some were not. And to get new state funds, local school districts would have to do none of the 27.
As someone has said, it is like saying if you do X, you get Y, but you do not have to do X.
Special education funding, for example, needs to be related to the need for special education, not based on a fixed number of general education students. The need for special education varies widely among Illinois school districts based on concentrated poverty, parental drug use, environmental factors including lead poisoning, premature births, stress in daily living, the family/guardian situation, etc.
There is no magic school funding formula, but there are good ones and bad ones.
BEV JOHNS
Jacksonville, Ill.
Remember a few days ago when those idiots were on tv following Trump's read speech talking abt how "presidential" he was? SHUT UP FOREVER…
.
It was a scalding message, painted on a university campus sidewalk this week: “Welcome to the Trump plantation. Overseer: Wayne A. I. Frederick.”


What made the message more jarring still was that Dr. Frederick is the black Sunday stuff. | Fred Klonsky:


Despite Evidence They Hurt Children, Trump Touts School Vouchers | PopularResistance

Despite Evidence They Hurt Children, Trump Touts School Vouchers | PopularResistance.Org:

Despite Evidence They Hurt Children, Trump Touts School Vouchers



Children who use vouchers to attend private schools perform worse on average than their public-school peers

President Donald Trump, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos, and Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) on Friday will tout school vouchers under the guise of providing “choice” to students—even as more research emerges that vouchers are no way to help children.
Trump is visiting the St. Andrew Catholic School in Orlando to promote his $20 billion proposal, which would use public education dollars to fund private schools, including religious ones—a tenet of the program that many say is unconstitutional. DeVos in particular is a strong proponent of voucher systems.
Protesters gathered early along his motorcade route Friday, including many members of Florida teachers’ unions. One woman held signs that read “Build schools, not the wall.”
“I know many people want their children to receive a religious education, but wasn’t the Constitution set on the separation of church and state? Why is the federal government giving money to private schools to educate our children? That shouldn’t be their job,” a protester told local media.
Lily Eskelsen García, president of the National Education Association (NEA) said in a statement, “For too long, these schemes have experimented with our children’s education without any evidence of real, lasting positive results. The Trump-DeVos agenda does nothing to provide opportunity to all of our students, and that is evident here in Florida.”
Trump’s visit comes amid a growing body of evidence that vouchers harm the students who receive them. The Economic Policy Institute (EPI) released a report this week which found that the risks to school systems outweigh the “insignificant gains in test scores and limited gains in graduation rates,” and that cases where individual schools or districts improved were more likely driven by increased public accountability rather than private school competition.
The risks include increased segregation; the loss of a “common, secular” educational experience; and unfair treatment of teachers.
“If we want to give parents a real ‘choice’ of quality schools, we should invest in Despite Evidence They Hurt Children, Trump Touts School Vouchers | PopularResistance.Org:


With A Brooklyn Accent: Why Fighting for Schools and Fighting for Immigrants is the Same Battle

With A Brooklyn Accent: Why Fighting for Schools and Fighting for Immigrants is the Same Battle:

Why Fighting for Schools and Fighting for Immigrants is the Same Battle

If my stance as a fierce defender of immigrant rights loses me some friends I acquired fighting Obama Administration education policies, so be it. To me, the two issues are inseparable. You cannot fight to defend the public schools of the Bronx without defending their students, many of whose families are recent immigrants from West Africa, the Dominican Republic, South Asia, Mexico, the West Indies and Eastern Europe. Yesterday, I had a chance to speak to 150 brilliant high school students from the Bronx who reflected the vitality that immigration has infused into Bronx schools and neighborhoods. They represent a future of our country that some want to deny, or curtail. I will fight for them with every ounce of energy I have, just as I fought to protect the hardworking teachers and staff in the public of the Bronx from unfair attacks.
Anyone who seeks to demoralize, intimidate and destroy the dreams of the immigrant students of the Bronx will have to go through me. The way I see it, fighting for their future is fighting for everyone's futureWith A Brooklyn Accent: Why Fighting for Schools and Fighting for Immigrants is the Same Battle:

The Best of Publius, Part 1: Vouchers – Exceptional Delaware 2017

The Best of Publius, Part 1: Vouchers – Exceptional Delaware 2017:

The Best of Publius, Part 1: Vouchers


Does Publius believe in vouchers? I would say he does based on this comment over on Kilroy’s Delaware from last year.

publius40
While not coming out and supporting vouchers wholesale, Publius was promoting a credit or rebate to taxpayers for kids in private schools.  Why?  To reduce the tuition for parents.  A voucher is a voucher no matter how many different ways you try to shape it Publius.  You put a pig in crap it is still going to get filthy no matter how you do it.  That reminds me… how do our school board candidates feel about vouchers?The Best of Publius, Part 1: Vouchers – Exceptional Delaware 2017:





Connecticut legislators don’t want to protect students after all. Attacking Student Data Privacy Law–AGAIN | Poetic Justice

Connecticut legislators don’t want to protect students after all. Attacking Student Data Privacy Law–AGAIN | Poetic Justice:

Connecticut legislators don’t want to protect students after all. Attacking Student Data Privacy Law–AGAIN

I am reblogging this from my friend Cheri Kiesecker’s Blog Missouri Education Watchdog:
ct-sunshine-560x365
The bill adopted common sense policies associated with contracts between school districts and corporations that collect, maintain, and share student data.  The CT law does NOT limit data collection, does not require parental consent prior to collecting data, it only asks that NEW  or renewed contracts and bids collecting student data must handle data appropriately. The law requires parents to be notified if their child’s data is breached. To their credit, the CT Commission on Educational Technology has done great work and is prepared and ready for this law to be implemented.  You can see their plan here: Operationalizing Public Act 189.

Why then, are some lawmakers in CT  introducing bills to cripple this new law that protects student data privacy? Do they not think that keeping student data safe, notifying parents of a breach is important?

You may remember one Connecticut legislator introduced a bill in January to entirely repeal this new student privacy law.  As CT blogger and parent Jonathon Pelto wrote,
“…in an astonishing, baffling and extremely disturbing move, State Representative Stephen Harding (R-107th District) has introduced legislation (HB 5233) to repeal this important law (Public Act 16-189)
…It is not clear who would ask Representative Harding to propose such a bill or why the representative would seek to do such harm to Connecticut’s students, parents and public schools.”