Latest News and Comment from Education

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Nite Cap 6-12-14 #BATsACT #RealEdTalk #EDCHAT #P2



James Baldwin said it best: 

"For these are all our children, and we will profit by or pay for whatever they become."


A BIG EDUCATION APE NITE CAP




McEducation | educarenow
McEducation | educarenow: McEducationPosted on June 12, 2014 | Leave a comment“There is an assumption that western education, western knowledge, is something that is superior…there is an idea that we have evolved to a higher level of being, and that these people, however lovely the are, they’re going to benefit from this superior knowledge.”                                                        
The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full Swing
The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full Swing: The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full SwingBy: Justin BaragonaOn Tuesday, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf M. Treu ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in the Vergara vs. California court case. Essentially, the judge stripped teachers of due process and ruled that tenure is unconstitut
California officials debate whether to defend teacher protections | Reuters
California officials debate whether to defend teacher protections | Reuters: California officials debate whether to defend teacher protectionsBY SHARON BERNSTEINSACRAMENTO Calif. Wed Jun 11, 2014 8:47pm EDT0 COMMENTSinShareShare thisEmailPrintSuperintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson speaks at the 2014 California Democrats State Convention at the Los Angeles Convention Center March 8, 201
What’s the Future of Unions? | Gatsby In L.A.
What’s the Future of Unions? | Gatsby In L.A.: What’s the Future of Unions? The recent ruling in the Vergara v. California lawsuit, in which Judge Rolf Treu struck a body blow against the power of teachers’ unions by declaring that five of California’s laws protecting teacher tenure, firing and seniority were in violation of the state constitution’s guarantee of equal education to all children, ha
SPECIAL Mid Day Banana Break 6-12-14 #soschat #edreform
Big Education Ape - Mid Day Banana BreakThe untold data crises at LDOE | Crazy Crawfish's BlogThe untold data crises at LDOE | Crazy Crawfish's Blog: Crazy Crawfish's BlogZesty Louisiana Education PoliticsThe untold data crises at LDOEPosted on June 12, 20140 There is a data crisis at LDOE. Almost all of the data collection systems are failing. The data, statistics and reports being generated are
The untold data crises at LDOE | Crazy Crawfish's Blog
The untold data crises at LDOE | Crazy Crawfish's Blog: Crazy Crawfish's BlogZesty Louisiana Education PoliticsThe untold data crises at LDOEPosted on June 12, 20140 There is a data crisis at LDOE. Almost all of the data collection systems are failing. The data, statistics and reports being generated are garbage. Data is being ferried back and forth between the department and school districts usin
Dogs, Ponies and Teacher Evaluation - Teacher in a Strange Land - Education Week Teacher
Dogs, Ponies and Teacher Evaluation - Teacher in a Strange Land - Education Week Teacher: Dogs, Ponies and Teacher EvaluationBy Nancy Flanagan on June 11, 2014 8:09 PMIn a recent incarnation of the endless (and mostly pointless) Twitter skirmishes re: test scores as reliable indicators of teacher quality, a "reformer" described the "dog and pony shows" he used to stage for the
NYC Educator: Will the Vergara Case Make Us Rich?
NYC Educator: Will the Vergara Case Make Us Rich?: Will the Vergara Case Make Us Rich?By Special Guest Blogger Rolf M. ReformeoI read the "tentative decision" in the Vergara case.  The concluding paragraph quoted my hero, Alexander Hamilton.  Having been so inspired, I will inform you of my "tentative decision" by introducing two more quotes of Mr. Hamilton:"When the sword
6-12-14 The Whole Child Blog — Believing in Students So They Believe In Themselves — Whole Child Education
Believing in Students So They Believe In Themselves — Whole Child Education: THE WHOLE CHILD BLOGBelieving in Students So They Believe In ThemselvesJune 12, 2014 by Whole Child PodcastDownload Podcast Now [Right-Click to Save]Ask educators why they went into teaching, and the majority will respond that they wanted to make a difference in the lives of young people. That initial idealism, however, i
“California PTA urges sane homework loads” | Engaging Parents In School…
“California PTA urges sane homework loads” | Engaging Parents In School…: “California PTA urges sane homework loads”California PTA urges sane homework loads is the headline of a Washington Post piece. Here’s an excerpt: The effort began at Burbank’s John Burroughs High School, where PTA members took action after seeing our film, Race to Nowhere. Suzanne Weerts and Tina McDermott, both mothers at t
6-12-14 @ The Chalk Face
@ THE CHALK FACE: POST VERGARA FALL OUT: Nothing says it any better than this from Brian Jones:POST VERGARA FALL OUT: Nothing says it any better than this from Brian Jones:.by David Greene / 4min Fighting Vergara in California and ElsewhereAs a former legal historian and inner city teacher, I’m offended by Judge Rolf Treu’s one sentence legal justification of the key issue in Vergara v California.
6-12-14 With A Brooklyn Accent:: Why Teachers Need Tenure and Due Process
With A Brooklyn Accent: Message from a Florida Teacher on the Discriminatory Impact of High Stakes Testing on Students in High Poverty CommunitiesBut there is something about teacher accountability that everyone seems to be missing. I worked at a school with an extremely transient population for two years. We had more than a 50% transiency rate in a highly impoverished neighborhood. For purposes o
Shanker Blog » Is Teacher Attrition Actually Increasing?
Shanker Blog » Is Teacher Attrition Actually Increasing?: Is Teacher Attrition Actually Increasing?Posted by Matthew Di Carlo on June 12, 2014Over the past few years, one can find a regular flow of writing attempting to explain the increase in teacher attrition. Usually, these explanations come in the form of advocacy – that is, people who don’t like a given policy or policies assert that they are
6-12-14 Schools Matter: Brian Jones: "If teacher tenure prevented achievement, Mississippi would have stellar schools.
Schools Matter: Brian Jones: "If teacher tenure prevented achievement, Mississippi would have stellar schools. . ."from NYTimes:Brian Jones, a former New York City public school teacher, is the Green Party's candidate for lieutenant governor of New York. He blogs at "No Struggle, No Progress." He is on Twitter.UPDATED JUNE 12, 2014, 12:55 PMAmerica is the land of misdirected an
6-12-14 LA School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD
LA School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District): New flexibility for LA Unified’s breakfast in the classroomActress Sofia Vergara promoting Breakfast in the Classroom programPhoto courtesy L.A. Fund A successful program aimed at providing free classroom breakfast to low-income students in Los Angeles Unified has quietly made a change: it will now allow
4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit 6-12-14
4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit: Hiltzik: WHY THAT RULING AGAINST TEACHER TENURE WON’T HELP YOUR SCHOOLCHILDREN ANY MORE THAN DEASY’S iPADSWho's behind the teacher tenure verdict? Millionaires. Think they have your kids' interests at heart?   by Michael Hiltzik in the LOS ANGELES TIMES | http://lat.ms/Uws2VK   Isn't he really the problem? L.A. Schools Supt. John Deasy, awaiting the Ver
Budget deal shifts payments to cover mandate claims :: SI&A Cabinet Report :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet
Budget deal shifts payments to cover mandate claims :: SI&A Cabinet Report :: The Essential Resource for Superintendents and the Cabinet: JUNE 12, 2014Budget deal shifts payments to cover mandate claimsby Tom Chorneau(Calif.) A tentative budget agreement still under negotiation would delay Gov. Jerry Brown’s plan to pay off all the money owed schools from past apportionment deferrals and use s
Free online course arms parents with basics to get involved in education issues | EdSource Today
Free online course arms parents with basics to get involved in education issues | EdSource Today: Free online course arms parents with basics to get involved in education issuesJune 12th, 2014 | 1 Comment | By John FensterwaldShare on facebookShare on twitterShare on emailShare on pinterest_shareMore Sharing Services13Ed100 walks parents through a range of California school issues and policies in
6-12-14 Ed Notes Online
Ed Notes Online: Anti-Tenure People Try to Have it Both Ways...flaws in reasoning... were in full bloom from the minute Judge Treu announced that court was in session. How else to explain the paradox by which teacher tenure laws apply to the state’s wealthiest school districts and its poorest, but only violate the civil rights of students in the latter? Or how about the related and even paradoxier
LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 6-12-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Kevin Welner: The Silver Lining in the Vergara DecisionKevin Welner, director of the National Educational Policy Center in Colorado, is both an education policy analyst and a lawyer. He read the Vergara decision and saw a bright side. While he was struck by the weak evidence for the judge’s conclusion, he thinks the case might open
Terrible Twos | EduShyster
Terrible Twos | EduShyster: Terrible TwosEduShyster turns two years old—and confronts some fiercely urgent questions…So what are some of the big lessons you learned this year?That when you establish yourself as an obnoxious online presence, you go over surprisingly well when peoplemeet you in real life. And that when you use a combination of facts and whimsy, and basically say the same things over
6-12-14 the becoming radical | A Place for a Pedagogy of Kindness by P. L. Thomas, EdD
the becoming radical | A Place for a Pedagogy of Kindness (the public and scholarly writing by P. L. Thomas, Furman University): What We Tolerate (and for Whom) v. What the Rich Demand: On Teacher QualityTwo of the best teachers and education advocates I respect and listen to carefully, Nancy Flanagan and Susan Ohanian, had an important exchange on Twitter recently: “Vergara ruling rhetoric stern
Frankenstein Fears His Monster: The Gates Foundation Wants You To Boycott High-Stakes Tests | I AM AN EDUCATOR
Frankenstein Fears His Monster: The Gates Foundation Wants You To Boycott High-Stakes Tests | I AM AN EDUCATOR: Frankenstein Fears His Monster: The Gates Foundation Wants You To Boycott High-Stakes TestsBy I AM AN EDUCATOR on June 12, 2014“…the Gates Foundation agrees with those who’ve decided that assessment results should not be taken into account in high-stakes decisions on teacher evaluation o
6-12-14 Wait What? - Jonathan Pelto: Gubernatorial Candidate and A Really Nice Guy
Wait What?: Wait What? Pelto To Run For GovernorPress Release:  6/12/2014 Pelto To Run For Governor - Will Covert from Exploratory Committee to Candidate Committee for Governor Former state legislator Jonathan Pelto is announcing that he will be a candidate for Governor this year and that he and his Lt. Governor candidate, Ebony Murphy, will be converting their exploratory committee into a candida
Answer Sheet 6-12-14
Answer Sheet: Real learning doesn’t ‘look like 6-year-olds slumped in chairs … staring at iPads’ — parent tells school boardMassachusetts parent Tassia Thomas gave the following testimony to the Cambridge School Committee — a panel of seven members that sets policy and oversees Cambridge Public Schools – earlier this month. It appeared in Cambridge Day, which said it had lightly edited her comment
solidaridad: RELEASE: 2013 LAUSD BOE Runner Up Robert D. Skeels Endorses Dr. George McKenna for the District 1 Special Election
solidaridad: RELEASE: 2013 LAUSD BOE Runner Up Robert D. Skeels Endorses Dr. George McKenna for the District 1 Special Election: RELEASE: 2013 LAUSD BOE Runner Up Robert D. Skeels Endorses Dr. George McKenna for the District 1 Special ElectionFor Immediate ReleaseJune 11, 2014ContactRobert D. Skeels http://twitter.com/rdsatheneRELEASE: 2013 LAUSD BOE Runner Up Robert D. Skeels Endorses Dr. George
Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Duncan's foul support for Vergara. He must go.
Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Duncan's foul support for Vergara. He must go.: Duncan's foul support for Vergara. He must go.Main backers of corporate-style school reform, Duncan, Rhee & Gates. Today’s court decision is a mandate to fix these problems. -- Arne DuncanArne Duncan's support for the anti-teacher Vergara decision in California, describing it as a "mandate" and an "op
That Full-page Union-bashing Ad in USA Today | deutsch29
That Full-page Union-bashing Ad in USA Today | deutsch29: That Full-page Union-bashing Ad in USA TodayJune 12, 2014Remember that five-story billboard five-story billboard in Times Square in  December 2013  and the accompanying full-page ad in the New York Times blaming American Federation of Teachers (AFT) President Randi Weingarten for 2012 US PISA scores?Both were the work of a union-busting “no
Judge strikes down California’s teacher tenure laws: A made-up statistic helped him reach the decision.
Judge strikes down California’s teacher tenure laws: A made-up statistic helped him reach the decision.: Fuzzy Math225919The guesstimate that struck down California’s teacher tenure laws.By Jordan WeissmannGrossly ineffective.GuidoVrola / iStockThis week Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu handed the education reform movement a stunning legal victory, when he struck down California’s teache
Protections of Teacher Tenure Do Not Hurt Students - NYTimes.com
Protections of Teacher Tenure Do Not Hurt Students - NYTimes.com: Job Protections Do Not Hurt StudentsBrian Jones, a former New York City public school teacher, is the Green Party's candidate for lieutenant governor of New York. He blogs at "No Struggle, No Progress."UPDATED JUNE 11, 2014, 6:42 PMAmerica is the land of misdirected anger. This time, teachers in California are on the recei
6-12-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Math Pathways, Middle School, and Equitable AccessThe District has claimed that equitable access to quality programs and services for all students is important to them. They say that, but where are the efforts to provide equitable access beyond the flowery talk?In one step towards equitable access the District math department has standardized math placement in midd
Karen Lewis explains actual TENURE as she speaks truth to power | Reclaim Reform
Karen Lewis explains actual TENURE as she speaks truth to power | Reclaim Reform: Karen Lewis explains actual TENURE as she speaks truth to powerPosted on June 12, 2014by Ken PrevitiTenure has never meant that a teacher cannot be fired in grades K-12. Tenure never was and still isn’t a job for life. Tenure for American K-12 teachers means due process – no more, no less. It prevents demi-gods, tyra
6-12-14 Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL
Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL: The Day After The “Vergara” Decision: Here Are More Thoughtful Reflections From Around The WebHere are some more thoughtful reflections on yesterday’s Vergara decision that I’m adding to California Court Rules It’s All The Teachers’ Fault: Informed Student Advocates Pursue Reforms that, Unlike Vergara v. California, Actuall
6-12-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher
Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.: Karen Lewis. The California tenure decision. “The moguls are drinking champagne.”[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9Fb1lsn6i4&feature=youtu.be}4 by Fred Klonsky / 2h 6-11-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacherFred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teach
Vergara Decision Is Latest Attempt to Blame Teachers and Weaken Public Education | Diane Ravitch
Vergara Decision Is Latest Attempt to Blame Teachers and Weaken Public Education | Diane Ravitch: Vergara Decision Is Latest Attempt to Blame Teachers and Weaken Public EducationJudge Rolf M. Treu, who decided the Vergara case, declared that he was shocked -- shocked! -- to learn from Professor Raj Chetty and Professor Thomas Kane of Harvard about the enormous harm that one "grossly ineffecti
Gates Foundation urges delay in using tests for teacher evaluation - The Washington Post
Gates Foundation urges delay in using tests for teacher evaluation - The Washington Post: Gates Foundation urges delay in using tests for teacher evaluationBY LYNDSEY LAYTON June 10The Obama administration is resisting mounting calls for a moratorium on using student test scores to evaluate teachers, students and schools.On Tuesday, the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which has invested more th
The Neighborhood Council’s Mandate – redqueeninla
The Neighborhood Council’s Mandate – redqueeninla: The Neighborhood Council’s MandateWritten by redqueeninla in COLA, Culver CityWhere do plebs find power?When a corporation moves into town does the community have any recourse? After all, if they own land or a business, what right does the community have to what happens with another’s land, the company’s business prerogative, their right to make m
Vergara Decision Blames Teachers, Ignores Injustices for Students in Poorest Communities | janresseger
Vergara Decision Blames Teachers, Ignores Injustices for Students in Poorest Communities | janresseger: Vergara Decision Blames Teachers, Ignores Injustices for Students in Poorest CommunitiesPosted on June 12, 2014 by janressegerEarlier this week California Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu struck down tenure and seniority protections for California’s K-12 school teachers.  This is the case of Verga
6-12-14 Curmudgucation
CURMUDGUCATION: Are Reformsters Under Attack?I have generally avoided picking on quotes from That Woman that appear in her joint blogventure with Jack Schneider, mostly because I think it's a worthy experiment that deserves some place to breathe. But recently she dropped an extraordinary quote that I can't let pass. It happened in a discussion of unions, specifically discussing the need for bridge
6-12-14 Perdido Street School
Perdido Street School: City Council Passes Bill Requiring Charter School Data To Be Made PublicErin Durkin at the Daily News: The city will be required to publish reports that reveal the demographic mix and academic records of every charter school sharing space with a district school under a bill the City Council passed Wednesday. Officials will have to list the number of kids who get free lunch,

YESTERDAY

McClatchy High law academy emphasizes community connections - Education - The Sacramento Bee
McClatchy High law academy emphasizes community connections - Education - The Sacramento Bee: McClatchy High law academy emphasizes community connectionsBy Loretta Kalblkalb@sacbee.comPublished: Wednesday, Jun. 11, 2014 - 8:02 pmA tightly knit group of Sacramento students last week became the first to complete McClatchy High School’s Law and Public Policy Academy, a three-year curriculum that aims
Aftermath: What the Vergara Decision Means | CAPITAL & MAIN
Aftermath: What the Vergara Decision Means | CAPITAL & MAIN: Aftermath: What the Vergara Decision MeansSHAREBy Steven MikulanJune 11, 2014 in EducationLeft: Students Matter’s David Welch. Right: Teachers speak out about Vergara ruling.Reagan Duncan has taught a combined kindergarten-first grade class in Vista for 10 years. When she heard about Tuesday’s ruling in the Vergara v. California tria
Reports of Career Technical Ed’s demise are greatly exaggerated | EdSource Today
Reports of Career Technical Ed’s demise are greatly exaggerated | EdSource Today: Reports of Career Technical Ed’s demise are greatly exaggeratedJune 11th, 2014 | Add a Comment | By David Gordon / commentaryShare on facebookShare on twitterShare on emailShare on pinterest_shareMore Sharing Services0David GordonAs a longtime proponent of Career Technical Education, I feel compelled to provide addit
La. BESE Member Jane Smith to Governor Jindal: Drop CC and PARCC | deutsch29
La. BESE Member Jane Smith to Governor Jindal: Drop CC and PARCC | deutsch29: La. BESE Member Jane Smith to Governor Jindal: Drop CC and PARCCJune 11, 2014Below is an open letter written to Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal by Louisiana Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) member and Jindal-appointee, Jane Smith.Smith wants to encourage Jindal to follow through on his plans to drop CCS
LA schools parent committee battling district to elect its own leadership | Pass / Fail | 89.3 KPCC
LA schools parent committee battling district to elect its own leadership | Pass / Fail | 89.3 KPCC: LA schools parent committee battling district to elect its own leadershipAnnie Gilbertson | June 11th, 2014, 4:21pmPhoto by Derek Bruff via Flickr Creative CommonsThe Los Angeles Unified School District has warned members of two parent committees if they organize their own leadership, as they would
Corporate Money fighting back in support of Common Core | Capital New York
Business groups fighting back in support of Common Core | Capital New York:Business groups fighting back in support of Common Core ALBANY—Critics of the Common Core in New York have been winning the debate about the controversial education standards, but now they'll face a counterattack backed by a considerable investment.High Achievement New York, a nonprofit coalition of mostly business groups,
One Thing Is Certain, Duncan Must Be Dumped | John Thompson
One Thing Is Certain, Duncan Must Be Dumped | John Thompson: One Thing Is Certain, Duncan Must Be DumpedPosted: 06/11/2014 4:55 pm EDT Updated: 2 hours ago I'm Old School. I celebrate compromise. I believe our handshakes must be good, contracts must be honored. Especially in the effort to improve schools, the politics of destruction are wrong.I don't believe in drawing lines in the sand, except in
Nite Cap 6-11-14 #BATsACT #RealEdTalk #EDCHAT #P2
James Baldwin said it best: "For these are all our children, and we will profit by or pay for whatever they become."A BIG EDUCATION APE NITE CAPLISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 6-11-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for allDiane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: The Vergara Trial Teachers Were Not “Grossly Ineffective”I was curious to learn wh






McEducation | educarenow

McEducation | educarenow:



McEducation

“There is an assumption that western education, western knowledge, is something that is superior…there is an idea that we have evolved to a higher level of being, and that these people, however lovely the are, they’re going to benefit from this superior knowledge.”                                                                                               Helena Norberg-Hodge

Standardization “Works”(?)
McDonald’s is one of the most successful corporations in the history of the world.  They are now present in 121 countries and experience “lackluster” earnings of $28.1 billion in 2013.  By any superficial measure of success, McDonald’s is there.
And how did they do this?
By instituting a highly managed process of standardization that insures that a Big Mac in Vietnam tastes exactly like a Big Mac in New York.
From Citizendium: “The standardized McDonald’s hamburger has meat that weighs 1.6 ounces (45 grams) and measures 3 and 5/8 inches (9.2cm) across; and is garnished with a quarter of an ounce of chopped onion, a teaspoon of mustard, a tablespoon of ketchup and a pickle slice one inch in diameter. The Big Mac is likewise standardized with two patties and a sauce.”
Why does this work?
Again, from Citizendium: “Ritzer (2000) argues that McDonald’s has succeeded so well because it offers consumers, workers, and managers a maximum degree of efficiency, calculability, predictability, and control through non-human technology.”
McDonald’s “works” because it has a standardized set of processes which increase predictability, efficiency and control, and decreases as much as McEducation | educarenow:

The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full Swing

The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full Swing:



The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full Swing



By: Justin Baragona


AFT

On Tuesday, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf M. Treu ruled in favor of the plaintiffs in the Vergara vs. California court case. Essentially, the judge stripped teachers of due process and ruled that tenure is unconstitutional. The lawsuit was brought up, ostensibly, by nine students from poor economic areas of California who felt that poorly performing teachers, who were protected by tenure, hurt their educational progress. In reality, it was the brainchild of so-called education reform organizations like Students Matter and Michelle Rhee’s StudentsFirst, with the high-powered legal team for the plaintiffs funded by tech billionaire David Welch.
PoliticusUSA’s Rmuse covered the basics of the decision on Wednesday, pointing out the corporate elements at play and showing that this is really nothing more than a union-busting measure by ‘reformers’ who are dead set on profiting off of standardized testing materials and privatized education. The dream of Rhee and her minions is to push charter schools into inner-cities and other poorer areas of the country. Knowing that these schools will likely not be able to keep up with rigid, across-the-board testing standards, they can have local and state administrators further defund these schools even more and have them lose their accreditation. That is when the corporate hawks come into the areas with the charter schools, fully prepared with Common Core textbooks and learning materials via Silicon Valley, and paid for with vouchers from the state via taxpayer money.
The American Federation of Teachers bemoaned this decision, as they know that this is just the tip of the iceberg. AFT President Randi Weingarten released the following statement on Tuesday:


“While this decision is not unexpected, the rhetoric and lack of a thorough, reasoned opinion is disturbing. For example, the judge believes that due process is essential, but his objection boils down to his feeling that two years is not long enough for probation. He argues, as we do, that no one should tolerate bad teachers in the classroom. He is right on that. But in focusing on these teachers who make up a fraction of the workforce, he strips the hundreds of thousands of teachers who are doing a good job of any right to a voice. In focusing on who should be laid off in times of budget crises, he omits the larger problem at play: full and fair funding of our schools so all kids have access to the classes—like music, art and physical education—and 
The Vergara Court Decision Shows Us That The War On Teachers Is In Full Swing:

California officials debate whether to defend teacher protections | Reuters



California officials debate whether to defend teacher protections | Reuters:



California officials debate whether to defend teacher protections

SACRAMENTO Calif. Wed Jun 11, 2014 8:47pm EDT
Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson speaks at the 2014 California Democrats State Convention at the Los Angeles Convention Center March 8, 2014.   REUTERS/David McNew



Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson speaks at the 2014 California Democrats State Convention at the Los Angeles Convention Center March 8, 2014.
CREDIT: REUTERS/DAVID MCNEW

RELATED TOPICS

(Reuters) - California officials were wrangling on Wednesday over whether to appeal a court ruling that overturned some job protections for public school teachers and could change the way educators are hired and fired in the most populous U.S. state.
The ruling, a major setback for teacher unions that could also have national implications, came in response to a lawsuit complaining the protections hurt poor and minority students by effectively funneling incompetent teachers to schools in disadvantaged areas at disproportional rates.
"We’re still reviewing the implications of the judge’s ruling," said Lara Azar, a spokeswoman for state Superintendent of Education Tom Torlakson, who is running for re-election with teacher union backing. "It’s far too early to answer that question" of whether to appeal.
The ruling, which won praise from the Obama administration, comes amid intense debate over how to reinvigorate a U.S. public school system that leaves American children lagging counterparts in countries such as Finland and South Korea.
But the politics of education reform are changing, with more Democrats signing onto the notion, spelled out in the lawsuit and supported by many Republicans, that it is too difficult to fire incompetent teachers in California.
Backers of the lawsuit said they planned to expand their efforts to other states, but have not yet specified which ones.
The group behind the lawsuit, Students Matter, was founded by Silicon Valley businessman David Welch and boasts the firepower of the Los Angeles law firm of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, whose attorneys argued the case overturning California's anti-gay marriage initiative, Proposition 8. On Wednesday, a Republican New Jersey state senator said he would reintroduce legislation to eliminate seniority protections for teachers during layoffs, and urged supporters of the California lawsuit to bring their fight to his state.
TEACHER EFFECTIVENESS
Even as supporters of the ruling celebrated, the state's largest teacher unions said they would appeal, issuing a news release indicating the state would fight alongside them.
But a source close to the case said officials from California Democratic Governor Jerry Brown's administration had been meeting to try to decide whether to follow through with an appeal. A spokesman for Brown declined to comment on the issue.
If the state declines to appeal, unions could still mount a case themselves, said Jim Finberg, who argued against the lawsuit for the California Teachers Association. He said he would be "shocked" if the state did not join an appeal.
"We defended the statute shoulder to shoulder, and the attorney general is supposed to defend state statutes," Finberg said.
The California suit alleged that five laws meant to protect teachers' jobs were unfair to poor and minority students by putting them at greater risk of being taught by ineffective teachers.
The overturned laws include such protections as a "first in, last out" rule, which requires that teachers with the least experience be laid off first during cutbacks, along with rules granting teachers tenure after two years on the job and making it difficult to fire them for incompetence.
Backers of the lawsuit said incompetent teachers were often transferred to schools in poor neighborhoods because it was too hard to fire them. New teachers, who often start in disadvantaged schools, are the first to be laid off, causing turmoil for children, the suit argued.


What’s the Future of Unions? | Gatsby In L.A.

What’s the Future of Unions? | Gatsby In L.A.:



What’s the Future of Unions?



 The recent ruling in the Vergara v. California lawsuit, in which Judge Rolf Treu struck a body blow against the power of teachers’ unions by declaring that five of California’s laws protecting teacher tenure, firing and seniority were in violation of the state constitution’s guarantee of equal education to all children, has implications so broad I don’t think we can even fully comprehend them yet.

I’ve written in earlier posts that though I absolutely think that bad teachers should be fired—and that last in, first out policies should be re-thought—they are not the core problem in the fight for equal education. I’m troubled by the witch-hunt zeal, the purge mentality, of this lawsuit, which implies that the layoffs that caused so many eager young teachers to be fired in the first place were some kind of natural disaster inflicted upon us by the gods that we should have diverted onto the heads of bad teachers.
But let’s be honest, California: those layoffs occurred because of budget cuts—and those budget cuts were our collective decision. And they were so radical that even if we had first fired the small percentage of bad teachers, we would still have been laying off a large number of excellent teachers.
We, as a state, were willing to accept that though we are home to the largest number of wealthy citizens in America, as well as the largest number of children in poverty, we would continue to slash education funding until students in low-income communities were packed 50 to a classroom while we turned a blind eye, fingers in our ears, humming and pretending to be shocked, shocked that experienced teachers often did not choose to teach in those conditions. Yes, it’s a disgrace that good young teachers were laid off. They were laid off because we decided that we’d rather slash education funding than raise What’s the Future of Unions? | Gatsby In L.A.: