Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, September 23, 2013

9-23-13 Schools Matter: ASD Follows Up Again on Charter Corruptionist Story

Schools Matter: ASD Follows Up Again on Charter Corruptionist Story:

July 2013



More From Jeremy at ASD Responding to My Education Agenda
Jeremy had some responses to my earlier 7 points for improving schools:1) socioeconomically integrate the schools (biggest bang for the achievement buck ever);2) return public schools to the public, rather than handing them over to corporations;3) extend Medicaid to poor students;3) demand more qualified teachers, rather than replacing teachers with unprepared temps from TFA;4) base curriculum and

Florida Becomes #4 to Withdraw from Corporate Common Core
First there were Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Missouri.  Now you can add Florida as the latest state to withdraw from PARCC, with bills pending in Michigan and Ohio.  Meanwhile, Arne Duncan creates a straw man and labels it a liar in order to cover his own mendacity.  No one is claiming that ED wrote or mandated the Rotted Common Core, but we are claiming that ED was in total agreement with the cont
Why Daniel Elsener Must Be Removed from the Indiana State Board Of Education Now
Below are more than enough reasons why Daniel Elsener needs removed from the Indiana State Board of Education now.  This information comes from my soon-to-be-released book, Hoosier School Heist.  Below the entry please also read the statement from the Education Community Action Team & Parent Power Indianapolis, and be sure to email the necessary individuals listed below to voice your protest a

Evidence for My School Priorities
Someone asked, and please include your name if you want your comment printed, to provide evidence that my "fixes" could work better than another generation of the corporate status quo based on more testing accountability, segregation, and blaming teachers. I will start with the first one:1) socioeconomically integrate the schools (biggest bang for the achievement buck ever);Find blog pos


ASD Follows Up Again on Charter Corruptionist Story
The ASD remains in response mode to this story and its follow-up, and as long as they are, we will remain responsive to them.  Jeremy writes:1. if by "corporate" you mean the literal definition of a group of people authorized by law to function as a single entity, then i'll submit to your definition. however, the conspiracy theory that you're suggesting simply isn't true and hinders the


9-22-13 Schools Matter
Schools Matter: Trinational protest at Mexican Consulate in solidarity with CNTEProtesting education neoliberalism across borders. En solidaridad con Los maestros de Mexico! #lausd pic.twitter.com/t8sunJeLP6— Robert D. Skeels (@rdsathene) September 21, 2013 On Friday, September 20, 2013 the Trinational Coalition To Defend Public Education organized a demonstration in front of the Mexican Consulate

9-23-13 Ed Notes Online

Ed Notes Online:






Today: Back to Portelos Hearing
It is game 2 of the Portelos vs the DOE et al and we expect some retiree MOREs to be there. We agreed not to reveal details until the case is over but we can write generally about the hearing. Transcripts are available which I assume can be published one day. See my reports from the last session.Portelos Hearing: NY Post Reporter Reuven Fenton C...Heading to Portelos Hearing (Sept 12) This Morning
MORE Petition Calling for Moratorium on Evaluations
Reality-Based Educator reminded us to sign the MORE petition. We some great discussions at Saturday's MORE meeting and the work of the organization around this issue has been intense and effective. Keep the ball rolling. Here's the link to sign. Will it do any good? Well, if MORE can show thousands of signatures that will send a message to UFT leaders. It will make them talk a better game while mo
Merryl Tisch: Might As Well Be a Crook
...when she has a problem with her refrigerator she calls the head of G.E.... Merryl H. Tisch, announced a new program: 13 research fellows would be selected to advise the education commissioner and the 17-member board. The fellows would be paid as much as $189,000 each....Since the appointment of the fellows, public educators' trust in the in New York State Education Department has dwindled to no
Are Success and other charters violating the law in closing schools for political reasons?
...we are planning a pro-charter parent march on October 8th. Our schools are being closed for the morning. Teachers, parents, students, and central office staff are being required to join the march .....  Success Academy teacher to Diane RavitchThis is clearly an attempt to put pressure on De Blasio and also in prep for the Oct. PEP meetings.Of course the press will not raise the issue of the bla

9-22-13 Ed Notes Online
Ed Notes Online: Thanks to General Diane Ravitch for the Shout Out on Preaching to the ChoirIs Diane Ravitch the George Washington of the educational revolutionary wars? Can we call it World War D (for Deform)? Can we get Max Brooks to write that story?As I would expect Diane Ravitch took the point I was trying to make in my column this week in The Wave about and extended it to a place I myself wa

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-23-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:


Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch



Students in Los Angeles, Indiana Outwit iPads
Students in Los Angeles and Indiana wasted no time in cracking the security codes on their iPads and going to sites that were supposedly off-limits, like games, Facebook, and other social media. Who says our students are not smart?
Teacher Rebellion in Montclair
At a meeting of the Montclair, New Jersey, school board, the union president was speaking and was cut off. The teachers in the audience were outraged. So were sympathetic members of the public. Watch the video.
Correction: US DOE Closes Down “Doing What Works” Not “What Works Clearinghouse”
A reader writes and offers this clarification. It still remains the case that nothing mandated by the test-obsessed DOE is based on research or evidence: It’s not the What Works Clearinghouse that has been taken down. It’s still up and running: http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/ WWC does the evaluations–that’s what has been controversial because of the very, very narrow focus of their evaluation efforts.



Who Is Jared Polis? Jersey Jazzman Does His Homework.
After following Jared Polis’s personal attacks on me on Twitter, Jersey Jazzman decided to examine what Polis has done in Congress. He is good on some issues, like gun control and the environment. But when it comes to fiscal issues, he favors tax breaks for corporations and the rich. He praises Colorado’s SB 191, which bases 50% of teachers’ evaluations on test scores, which most researchers say

My Conversation with Salon: What Works and Why Corporate Reform is Failing
You might find it interesting to read a conversation I had with Sara Scribner, a teacher who writes for Salon.
A Recent Exchange with Congressman Polis
A reader asked me to post Congressman Jared Polis’ comment as a separate post. I agreed to do so, along with my response. I also recommend that you read his exchange with Jason Stanford, which I posted earlier. Stanford suggested that it was over the top to characterize someone as “evil” because you disagree with them. Stanford says there truly is evil in the world (think terrorism, think mass mur

Tim Clifford in WNYC Schoolbook on “Reign of Error”
Tim Clifford is a teacher in New York. In this article, published on WNYC’s blog ”Schoolbook,” he reviews my book Reign of Error. Tim focuses on the book’s solutions, which he describes as “womb to dorm.” Tim recounts the research-based proposals that I offer, and concludes: I don’t know about you, but I long for a public school system like this. Imagine a system in which students are healthy and
Florida Governor Appoints TFA Leader, 32, to State Board
Florida Governor Rick Scott appointed Rebecca Fishman Lipsey to the Florida State Board of Education. Lipsey describes herself as “a lifelong educator,” based on her long service to TFA. Meanwhile, TFA leaders continue to pop up in service to the nation’s most reactionary governors, including Jindal in Louisiana, Haslam in Tennessee, and McCrory in North Carolina. All these governors are bent on
Jared Polis Responds to Texas Columnist. Texas Columnist Responds to Polis.
Jared Polis, the multi-millionaire (or billionaire) Colorado congressman, went after me again last night on Twitter with rude, insulting comments. I guess he doesn’t like me. I was beginning to feel sorry for him. To see a public figure acting in such an embarrassing way on Twitter is, well, embarrassing. I wish I knew how to help him. Not only did he, in his rage, post a comment on this blog, b

Can Anyone from Chicago Explain Mayor Emanuel’s Spending Spree?
How many times have we read stories that Chicago faces a huge deficit? I can’t recall it was $600 million, or some other figure. But the huge deficit, plus “underutilization,” gave Mayor Rahm Emanuel the change to make history: He closed the largest number of public schools in history, at one fell swoop (50). But now he is going on a spending spree, building new schools and pledging to spend at le
Outrage: How Extremists Brought Vouchers to North Carolina
The extremists in the North Carolina legislature and in the governor’s mansion have decided that the state’s public education system must be subject to market pressures. That means they want public money put into private hands, as much as possible. North Carolina was once the most progressive of southern states. It is now among the most regressive, competing with Louisiana in a race to the bottom.

Who Is Jared Polis and Why Does He Call Me “Evil,” Part 2
Jonathan Pelto is trying to find out who this Jared Polis is. He took to Twitter to call me an “evil  woman” and compare me to the Koch brothers as someone doing great harm to public education. It was puzzling to me.  I have met him twice. The last time I saw him was three years ago. We know he is a member of Congress from Colorado, we know he sold his family’s greeting card company for $780 milli

Bloomberg Will Eliminate Guarantee of Seat in Neighborhood High Schools
Another parting shot from the lame-duck Bloomberg administration. Students will no longer be guaranteed a seat in their zoned neighborhood high school. Bloomberg has wanted an all-choice system for years, and this is his parting shot. Students list their choices, but the high school or the computer makes the decision. Most students now travel from 45 minutes to an hour to get to their assigned “ch

Who Owns the Public Schools of New York State?
In New York and other states, parents, teachers, and principals often feel as if they are on a runaway train. Someone controls their public schools, and it is not the local community. The state has a super-heavy hand, and decisions are handed down with no consultation. Hearings are held, but no one hears or listens to what the public says. Who took the public out of public education? How did this

Atlanta Journal-Constitution: The Tests Are Loaded with Errors
Heather Vogell, a stellar reporter for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, has done in-depth investigative reporting on the standardized tests that now are used to determine the fate of students, teachers, principals, and schools. She has found a surprising number of errors, though not surprising to those familiar with the testing industry. Read this article. How should a student respond to question
EduShyster: Teachers Advise Hollywood on How to Fix Failing Films
EduShyster discovered a witty teacher who decided that educators know best. That’s why they are educators. This is how it started: “When a teacher came across a recent interview on MSNBC with Hollywood director M. Night Shyamalan about his new book, I Got Schooled: 5 Keys to Unlocking Quality Education, he was struck by a thunderbolt of an idea. If Shyamalan, whose last film was a box office bomb
LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-22-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Why DC Scores IncreasedEmma Brown of the Washington Post explains that DC test scores in math reached a historic high point because of a decision by DC officials. But the math gains officials reported were the result of a quiet decision to score the tests in a way that yielded higher scores even though D.C. students got far fewer m

9-23-13 Wait What?

Wait What?:





Vallas a no-show for Connecticut Supreme Court hearing
The Connecticut Supreme Court held oral arguments at 10am today in the case of Lopez v. Vallas. The question before the court is whether to overturn the Connecticut Superior Court’s ruling that Paul Vallas lacks the credentials to serve as a superintendent of schools in Connecticut. The hearing was the end of the line in […]The post Vallas a no-show for Connecticut Supreme Court hearing appeared f


Even more on the Diane Ravitch hating “neo-liberal” congressman from Colorado
Friend and fellow blogger and education advocate, Jersey Jazzman, has more information on the bully   Democratic Congressman from Colorado who has been on a tear with his insulting tweets about public education advocate Diane Ravitch. Jersey Jazzman is a great investigative blogger and well worth the read at any time, but his latest on […]The post Even more on the Diane Ravitch hating “neo-liberal

Vallas faces Supreme Court, Colorado Congressman returns to twitter rant
A Monday morning in the on-going battle to stop the education reform industry and take back our public schools. Paul Vallas: In a final, desperate move to hold onto his position, faux superintendent Paul Vallas and his taxpayer funded attorneys go before the Connecticut Supreme Court today to explain why he is so special that […]The post Vallas faces Supreme Court, Colorado Congressman returns to
9-22-13 Wait What?
Wait What?: Judge Carmen Lopez explains the Lopez v. Vallas case…Former Connecticut Superior Court Judge Carmen Lopez is not only a leading advocate for public education but she is a true champion when it comes to standing up and speaking out on the most important issues facing our communities, our state and our nation. Born in Puerto Rico, a life-long resident of Bridgeport, a lawyer, […]The post

Journal Sentinel Article Spotlights Charter School Performance | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!

Journal Sentinel Article Spotlights Charter School Performance | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!:

Journal Sentinel Article Spotlights Charter School Performance

Filed under: Charter Schools — millerlf @ 7:16 am 


The following article puts charter schools under the spotlight. A significant point made in the article is the fact that-
“… on a percentage basis, the 134 schools rated in MPS educated three times as many students learning English and twice as many students with special needs, compared with independent charters. The charter schools enrolled a higher percentage of white students and lower percentage of students in poverty than MPS.”
Many independent charter schools miss mark on state report cards
Erin Richards 9/23/13 Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Despite having more freedom over curriculum, budgets and staffing than traditional public schools, the majority of Milwaukee’s independent charter schools are not meeting performance expectations, according to statewide report card results for 2012-’13.
Of the 17 independent charters in Milwaukee that received a rating through the state’s new school report card accountability system, 53% fell below expectations, with two schools authorized by the City of Milwaukee receiving a failing grade.
The report cards released by the state this month are not perfect measures of school progress, but the results still raise questions about whether independent charters should be producing better results. The schools are publicly financed but privately managed, and are given freedom from bureaucratic restraints on school districts in exchange for upholding a promise to deliver on performance.
“It’s pretty clear we all have work to do,” said Cindy Zautcke, who directs the City of Milwaukee’s charter school initiative.
The discussion about performance is also pertinent because of a new law the state Legislature passed this spring that allows independent