Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, September 20, 2013

TO LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-20-13 Stephen Dyer on “Reign of Error” | Diane Ravitch's blog

Stephen Dyer on “Reign of Error” | Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch


I Will Not Be Part of Education Nation
Yesterday I received an invitation to sit in the audience at NBC’s Education Nation. I regret to say that I will decline, as I am very busy these days. In case you want to know who will be speaking, here is the lineup (http://www.cvent.com/events/2013-nbc-news-education-nation-summit/event-summary-b8182761914b46f69bbb049effaa997b.aspx?i=c201d015-c428-4eae-a71b-b9db619fb3c5). You will see some fami

Alaska: Can We Avoid the Mistakes of the Other States?
Alaska school board member David Cheezem hopes that Alaska can avoid the costly mistakes that other states are making. He writes: “Preparing young people for the future was never easy, but it’s harder today than ever before. We really don’t know what future to prepare them for — what job opportunities they’ll have, what skills they’ll need. All the same, supporting public education has never been

Merrow Vs. Schneider on New Orleans and Rhee
This is a fascinating exchange between John Merrow and Mercedes Schneider. Merrow, a PBS correspondent, explains his independence from his funders. Here are my two cents. Merrow is the only mainstream journalist to pursue the cheating scandal in D.C., and he took a lot of criticism from rightwing bloggers and other admirers of Rhee’s slash-and-burn tactics. I admire him for his courage and integr

Bloomberg’s Board Racing to Give Away More Public Space
Time is running out on the Bloomberg administration, so his compliant board will vote at its next meeting in October on a record giveaway of public school space to privately managed charters. The panel, which has a majority of members appointed by the mayor, will consider more than 40 proposals for co-locating schools at two meetings next month. More than 30 of these plans are for new schools. Com

Sacramento: TFA Kids Staff Charter Schools
No surprise: Sacramento gets new charter schools staffed by inexperienced Teach for America recruits, non-union, of course. Michelle Rhee’s husband is mayor of Sacramento. How many would choose a doctor or lawyer with five weeks of training? Raise your hand. Lots of money from the anti-union Walton Family Foundation, as well as Gates and Broad. Maybe the foundations think that it’s good enough


Brooklyn Event: A Conversation with Me and David Denby
I will be speaking about “Reign of Error” at Congregation Beth Elohim in Park Slope, Brooklyn, on October 8, in conversation with New Yorker writer David Denby. This is part of a book series called “Brooklyn by the Book.” Admission is free but reservations are suggested.
Arthur Goldstein Reviews “Reign of Error” at HuffPost
Arthur Goldstein has taught in New York City public schools for almost thirty years. He has been trying to figure when and how teachers and public schools became objects of scorn rather than respect. He found it in “Reign of Error.” He writes: In Reign of Error, Ravitch demonstrates how, by ignoring poverty, America has managed to shift blame to public schools for its consequences. That’s clear wh

Bobby Jindal’s Voucher Hoax
When the U.S. Department of Justice filed suit against Louisiana’s voucher program, on grounds that it threatened to undermine court-ordered desegregation, Jindal went on a well-publicized rant against the DOJ, claiming politics. Suddenly, Jindal presented himself as a leader of he civil rights movement, trying to save poor black kids from failing public schools. His op-eds appeared in the Washing

Stephen Dyer on “Reign of Error”
Stephen Dyer is a former legislator in Ohio who now works for a public policy organization called Innovation Ohio, in my book, I drew on some of his research. In this post, he situates my work in a longstanding American tradition. I especially liked these lines: “As I read the book, I couldn’t help but think of what Alexis de Tocqueville wrote in 1835 — that America’s commitment to education for

Diane in the Evening 9-19-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Bloomberg Administration Plans to Scrub EmailsA whistleblower inside the DOE in New York City told me the Bloomberg administration plans to eliminate all emails. I assumed they were reacting to the Indiana scandal, where Tony Bennett’s emails showed that he engaged in grade-fixing and assembling lists of campaign donors. Maybe yes,

Reign of Error Coming Soon (click picture) 

9-20-13 Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL

Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL:






Quote Of The Day: “Why Paying Kids to Do Homework Can Backfire”
Why Paying Kids to Do Homework Can Backfire is an article published today at TIME. It doesn’t offer anything particularly new to longtime readers of this blog or my books, but it does provide a good summary of research. Here’s an excerpt:
The Late Educator Paulo Freire Was Born On This Day
Image via Wikipedia The late educator Paulo Freire was born on this day in 1921. You can read more about him at The Zinn Education Project’s Facebook page. You might also be interested in a New York Times post I wrote that includes a lesson building on his work, and a post that appeared on this blog awhile back, What Would Paulo Freire Do If He Was A School Superintendent?
Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL
Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL: September’s (2013) Best Tweets — Part ThreeEvery month I make a few short lists highlighting my choices of the best resources I shared through (and learned from) Twitter, but didn’t necessarily include them in posts here on my blog. I’ve already shared in earlier posts several new resources I found on Twitter — and where I

Changing the Classroom Curriculum: Recapturing How I Taught a Half-Century Ago (Part 1) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Changing the Classroom Curriculum: Recapturing How I Taught a Half-Century Ago (Part 1) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:

Changing the Classroom Curriculum: Recapturing How I Taught a Half-Century Ago (Part 1)



I was a 21 year-old novice eager and anxious to become an first-rate high school history teacher at Glenville High School (Cleveland OH) in 1956. Within six months, I discovered that teaching five classes a day with multiple lessons (I taught world history and U.S. history), grading homework from over 175 students, and learning the ropes of managing groups of students a few years younger than me not only wore me out–I was also taking evening graduate history courses at Western Reserve University– but drove me to rely on lectures and the textbook far more than I anticipated.
By mid-year, I had become dissatisfied about how I was teaching my students–who happened to be nearly all minority (Negro was the preferred word then). I routinely lectured, watched maybe half of the students take notes and the other half stare into the distance or try to look attentive. Some fell asleep. I asked students questions about the textbook pages I assigned and got one-word answers back. Occasionally, a student would ask a question and I would improvise an answer that would trigger a few more students to enter in what would become a full blown back-and-forth discussion. It was unplanned and brief but mysteriously disappeared in the snap of a finger. Periodic quizzes andcurrent events one day a week altered my routines but student disengagement persisted. I was wholly teacher-centered in my instruction concentrating my attention upon history content. I was, as I learned in later years, teaching history in the way that it had been taught for decades: the heritage approach. Yet after six months, I realized that I did not want to teach history mechanically drowning students in forgettable facts that left me drained and dissatisfied at the end of a long day. I wanted to break out of that pattern. But did not know how to do that yet.
These were the years before the civil rights movement had traveled northward. Martin Luther King, Jr. was in the midst of his Montgomery ministry; Rosa 

9-20-13 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.

Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.:




The in box. Bev Johns: “Special ed class size proposal is dead for now.”
From Bev Johns, Chair of the Illinois Special Education Coaliton. The Illinois State Board of Education (ISBE) took NO action today on the proposal to eliminate all State rules on special education class size, and on the 30 percent limit on students with IEPs in a general education classroom. Action could have been taken at their June meeting, or August meeting, but Board members had significant
9-19-13 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.
Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.: Life in Rahm’s Chicago. Walter Payton High School has plenty of toilet paper and is about to get more. Cut to Les Miz.As parents on the West Side collect toilet paper for their schools – the schools that Rahm has still left open – the selective admission Walter Payton High School near the Lakefront wi

9-20-13 Perdido Street School

Perdido Street School:




Only Two Donors To The "Pro-Lhota" SuperPAC
Well, well. The pro-Lhota "super PAC" has not taken in a single donation beyond the Koch family ones already known http://t.co/lgW7T8o64n— Chris Bragg (@ChrisBragg1) September 20, 2013Each Koch Brother gave $145,000.Total funds raised for the pro-Lhota superPAC - $290,000.Someone else notes that the deadline for filing was 9/16, so there may be more donations then are currently listed.St

Using Mayor Bloomberg's Self-Congratulatory P.R. Reports For A Rabbit Cage
The Tweet of the Day:@NYDNBenChapman I can use it 4 the bottom of my rabbits cage it has better use there. Is it January 2014 yet? @NY_GPS @AQE_NY @rweingarten— zakiyah ansari (@zansari8) September 20, 2013I bet there's so much to these self-congratulatory reports from Bloomberg that you could use them to line a few horse stalls. Can't wait for January, either.And then there's this horse hockey fr

De Blasio Says Some Nice Things About Labor Unions
In a Politicker article reporting that Bill de Blasio says he will try and do some retroactive pay for municpal employees working years without contracts under Bloomberg but cannot give full retro to workers, we learn that he said this:Standing behind a wooden podium on the fifth floor of the Alhabrama Ballroom, he said would play a far more active role in helping labor recruit new members and pro

Bloomberg Says Billionaires Are A "Godsend"
That is actually the word he used:So what if there’s an income gap? Mayor Bloomberg says the glaring disparity between the city’s rich and poor only exists because of the city is lucky enough to attract the world’s super-wealthy.“You picture this income inequality measure, but if we could get every billionaire around the world to move here, it would be a godsend,” he said in his weekly radio show

Note To House Republicans: Many People On Food Stamps HAVE Jobs
House Republicans slashed food stamp funding yesterday and claimed the move will help poor people.You see, poor people on food stamps don't have jobs because they get food stamps and don't need jobs.But if the House cuts food stamps, that will force these lazy, welfare kings and queens to go out and get jobs.Only one problem with that theory - many people getting food stamps already have jobs, but

Bloomberg Have Any DOE Emails Erased Yet?
The story first showed up on DNAinfo - the Bloomberg administration plans to erase many of their emails when they leave office, including those from the NYCDOE.Diane Ravitch picked that story up with additional details from somebody she termed a "mole" at Tweed who said the data there is all suspect and should be independently investigated.Norm Scott ran with the story yesterday, compari

Joe Lhota: I'm A Hug-Able Kind Of Guy
From the Wall Street Journal:Mr. Lhota blamed his poll standing on a brutal primary in which his chief opponent, billionaire businessman John Catsimatidis, repeatedly described Mr. Lhota as mean and a bureaucrat. "John [Catsimatidis] was throwing as much mud as he possibly could—I've never met anybody who thinks I'm mean, I've never met anybody who thinks I'm not hug-able," Mr. Lhota sai
Bloomberg's Real Estate Policies Drive Increase In NYC Poverty
This must be the fault of schools and teachers:The latest U.S. Census data is drawing a troubling picture of the struggles of many New Yorkers living in poverty.It also shows the number of city residents living below the poverty level is on the rise.According to the data, 21.2 percent of New Yorkers are in households below that level.That includes 31 percent of children age 17 and under.Meanwhile,

9-19-13 Perdido Street School
Perdido Street School: Performance Assessment ThursdayWe are giving the ELA Measures of Student Learning Performance Assessments to students today and tomorrow so that every teacher in the school can be evaluated to see how much growth students make from September to June.Because it makes total sense that social studies, science, art, physical education and other teachers outside of English Langua

9-20-13 @ THE CHALK FACE

@ THE CHALK FACE:

@TCF on Blog Talk Radio




For District Leaders Considering Adopting the New Orleans “Miracle” Model
New Orleans’ Recovery School District (RSD) is being promoted nationwide as a model of corporate reform “turnaround.”  Thus, numerous legislatures, superintendents and school boards across the country are facing the question of whether or not to emulate RSD. In this post, I address school officials who are tempted to believe and adopt the RSD “miracle.”  RSD success is a […]
This Sunday at 6PM EST, Diane Ravitch is At the Chalk Face to discuss Reign of Error.
Listen to the show here.  I have to get reading.


Merrow Vs. Schneider on New Orleans and Rhee
I don’t blame Merrow for wanting more support and for suggesting that folks reach out to the many media people he mentions. I do blame him for: 1) doing it in such a mewling tone – he’d be more effective to suggest not complain with that “Why aren’t people . . . ” intro that […]

Innovation? No Thank You
There is a problem with really successful people: They tend to believe they are incredibly capable in every field, and that most other people are not. Success is a deluding experience, and if there is anything that innovators are, it is delusional—delusional that being innovative is greater than having field experience or expertise. In education […]

The Indignant Teacher Reviews “Reign of Error”
  The “nation’s children are on a train that is headed for a cliff“. This sentence, unobtrusively embedded in the middle of the first chapter of Reign of Error, effectively identifies the main idea of Diane Ravitch’s newest book. Like it’s prequel from 2010, The Death and Life of the Great American School System, Reign of Error serves to warn America […]



9-18-13 @ The Chalk Face
@ THE CHALK FACE: Achievement Gap? Nope, parts 1 and 2The term “achievement gap” is misleading and thus one of the problems with the education reform debate. Please see the following posts addressing why: Achievement Gap Misnomer for Equity Gap, pt. 1 Achievement Gap Misnomer for Equity Gap, pt. 21 by plthomasedd / 1min Schools Matter @ The Chalk FaceSCHOOLS MATTER @ THE CHALK FACE: Gates Money an