Latest News and Comment from Education

Monday, September 16, 2013

Chicago Teacher: Inhumane Working Conditions are Inhumane Learning Conditions - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher

Chicago Teacher: Inhumane Working Conditions are Inhumane Learning Conditions - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher:

Chicago Teacher: Inhumane Working Conditions are Inhumane Learning Conditions

Guest post by Sarah Chambers.


At my large elementary school on Chicago's southwest side, the mercury on the thermometer soars to a scorching 90 degrees. Sweat drips down the students' little round faces, their hair plastered to their foreheads. It's only 9am, not even at the peak of the day's heat. Already, a student has become ill. Another student tries to cover his nose with a wad of blood-soaked Kleenex as it drips onto his shirt and down to the floor. The boy runs to the bathroom holding his nose with bloodstains on his palms. He stands over the sink with blood gushing out for over 10 minutes, covering the sink a crimson red. His nose does not stop bleeding. Never have I ever seen such a horrendous nose bleed.

As the Chicago Public Schools opened for the year, scenes like this one were not unusual as hundreds of schools have regularly used classrooms without air conditioning. The exact numbers are unknown as when we asked them, CPS themselves didn't know. Unable or unwilling to maintain a solid count or communicate with the power company, we are left to alleviate the suffering of our students. It is important to understand that this is not only incompetence, but also a genuine plan to sabotage and destroy traditional schools and open charter schools. Just this year, the Board took out a multi-decade loan and spent millions to close 50 schools because they said there were too many schools and we had a deficit. Many of the schools were high performing and parents and students fought hard to save the schools they loved and had chosen. CPS ignored their choices and destroyed those schools. The next month, plans were released to approve the opening of a dozen new charter schools at an even greater cost.
I hand the student a roll of paper towels and walk him down to the office to call his mom for an early dismissal. I ask him, "Have you had bloody noses like this in the past?" He tells me that 

School leaders lobby Brown to kill teacher misconduct bill SI&A Cabinet Report – News & Resources

SI&A Cabinet Report – News & Resources:

School leaders lobby Brown to kill teacher misconduct bill
By Kimberly Beltran
Monday, September 16, 2013


As the mid-point in the legislation session ended last week, advocates for school districts turned their attention to lobbying the governor to either support or veto pressing issues.
Toward that end, the Association of California School Administrators has called on members to reject AB 375, legislation designed to streamline thesuspension and dismissal hearing process for teachers and save schools time and money.
Authored by Assemblywoman Joan Buchanan, D-Alamo, AB 375 would maintain the ability of school districts to immediately remove the teacher from the classroom as a result of allegations of child or sexual abuse. It would also provide the ability to issue a notice of dismissal at any time during the calendar year.
The bill is one of scores delivered out of the Legislature before action was gaveled down in the early hours of Friday. Brown has until mid-October to act.
AB 375 places limits on the amount of time the appeals process can last, and restricts the introduction of new evidence after a certain point in the proceedings.
While it has the support of teacher unions, the bill is opposed by various organizations representing schools, including ACSA, which represents more than 14,500 superintendents, principals and school leaders, and the California Association of School Business Officials.
“The problems created for school districts far outweigh any modest improvements contained in the bill,” ACSA 

Mother Crusader: Hebrew Immersion Charter Cheerleader Doesn't Seem To Think Hatikvah Is a "Government" School

Mother Crusader: Hebrew Immersion Charter Cheerleader Doesn't Seem To Think Hatikvah Is a "Government" School:

Hebrew Immersion Charter Cheerleader Doesn't Seem To Think Hatikvah Is a "Government" School



Silly ideologue, you think charters are public schools? 

I got a comment on a post I wrote about the impact the Hatikvah International Academy Charter School in East Brunswick has had on my district. I thought the comment not only merited a response, but a whole new post. Chime in with your thoughts in the comment section if you're so inclined, and let me and my anonymous friend know who you agree with. 

Here's the comment:

Why not let the money follow the child? If parents want their children to attend language immersion school, a Montessori school, a Core Knowledge school etc, why not let them send their children to whatever school they wish and have their per-pupil spending follow them? 
We have a balkanized education system as it is. Kids who live in East Brunswick go to EB schools, kids who live in Metuchen go to Metuchen schools, kids who live in South Brunswick go to SB schools etc. Let kids choose to go to schools that best fit their interests and personalities and this artificial 

There Joel Klein goes again…

There Joel Klein goes again…:

There Joel Klein goes again…




Joel Klein (The Washington Post)
A story in the latest edition of the New York Times Magazine titled “No Child Left Untableted,” by Carlo Rotella, is getting a lot of attention in part because of statements made in it by former New York City schools chancellor Joel Klein, who now runs Amplify, the education division of Rupert Murdoch’s  News Corp. The story is about a big push by school reformers to “transform” public education with technology, specifically, tablets.
In the following piece, education researcher Richard Rothstein analyzes what Klein said. Rothstein is research associate at the Economic Policy Institute, a non-profit organization created to broaden the discussion about economic policy to include the interests of low- and middle-income workers. From 1999 to 2002, he was the national education columnist of The New York Times, and he has written several books, including “Grading Education: Getting Accountability Right” and “Class and Schools: Using Social, Economic and Educational Reform to Close the Black-White Achievement Gap.” This appeared on the institute’s website.
By Richard Rothstein
I don’t mean to pick on Joel Klein, the former New York City schools chancellor, but he has made himself such a caricature of self-styled school reformers who are undermining American public education that it would be a mistake not to respond to the claims on 

Diane in the Evening 9-16-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:





Eli Broad on Philanthropy
This article appeared in the Wall Street Journal. Many educators know Eli Broad mainly through the superintendents trained by his institute to view public education as a business: they shut down struggling public schools and replace them with privately managed charter schools. But here is Eli Broad, lover of the arts, worried about the disappearing middle class: WEEKEND CONFIDENTIAL September 13,

Why Are the 1% Getting Richer?
As states cut the budget for public schools, lay off teachers, increase class sizes, fire librarians and social workers, guidance counselors and teacher aides, we hear the same refrain: Sorry, the money’s all gone. But is it? Read this article and you will find where the money went.
Photo-Essay on the First Day of School in Chicago
A Korean camera crew showed this photo-essay to me. I think they had a hard time understanding the number of police officers that created “safe passage” for students on their way to school in Chicago. They came to interview me about how money affects the politics of education in the United States. The producer had a copy of The Death and Life of the Great American School System, translated into Ko
Alfie Kohn: Encouraging Educator Courage
Alfie Kohn has a terrific article in Education Week with the title above. It is behind a pay wall and I can’t repost it in full, lest I get an angry scolding from Edweek. But here are a few good excerpts: “It pains me to say this, but professionals in our field often seem content to work within the constraints of traditional policies and accepted assumptions-even when they don’t make sense. Conve

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-16-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: United Opt Out Will Sponsor Book Club Discussion of “Reign of Error”Three years ago, when my last book was published, I heard from a professor in Pennsylvania named Tim Slekar who asked if I would join the opt-out movement. I told him no. I thought it was too extreme. I don’t think so anymore. Testing has become extreme. It is now


Built to Last Tour - Year 2013 (CA Dept of Education)

Built to Last Tour - Year 2013 (CA Dept of Education):

State Schools Chief Tom Torlakson Announces National Best Practices Tour of California Green Ribbon Schools



SACRAMENTO—State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson today announced that the California Department of Education (CDE) will co-host the West Coast Tour Leg of the Education Built to Last best practices tour, the national U.S. Department of Education tour of Green Ribbon School facilities.
"I'm thrilled to see these outstanding schools showcased as part of the national tour on best practices," Torlakson said. "The students, teachers, parents, and communities have made countless efforts to improve the environmental sustainability of their campuses, increase school health as well as boost academic achievement."
The school visits are designed to showcase best practices in school buildings and grounds design, construction, operations, and management; school health and wellness; and sustainability education in schools throughout the nation.
The tour was announced this past June at the national Green Ribbon Schools Award Ceremony in Washington, D.C. U.S. Department of Education Green Ribbon Schools are recognized or their achievement in the "three pillars," which are: reduce environmental impact and costs; improve the health and wellness of schools, students and staff; and provide effective environmental and sustainability literacy, incorporating STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) and green career pathways.
The California Leg of the tour includes stops at Journey School (Aliso Viejo), Environmental Charter HS (Lawndale), Grand View ES (Manhattan Beach), Longfellow ES (Long Beach) and Charles Evans Hughes MS (Long Beach). This segment of the tour concludes with a best practices discussion, bringing together facilities experts and community leaders from around the state.
For information on attending the tour or questions regarding U.S. Department of Education Green Ribbon Schools in California, please visit the Green Ribbon Schools Award Program Web page or send an email togreenribbonschools@cde.ca.gov.
# # # #
Tom Torlakson — State Superintendent of Public Instruction
Communications Division, Room 5206, 916-319-0818, Fax 916-319-0100

Philadelphia Graph of the Day | School Finance 101

Philadelphia Graph of the Day | School Finance 101:

Philadelphia Graph of the Day

Posted on September 16, 2013

 
 
 
 
 
 
Rate This

Philly Adequacy Gap
I just can’t drop the Philly issue, because of the complete absurdity of the reformy rhetoric about Philly schools and persistent willful ignorance regarding the role of equitable and adequate funding for Philly schools and the Commonwealth’s failure to provide any reasonable level of support.
For what it’s worth – and I’ve spent a great deal of time critiquing this and similar studies – the Commonwealth in the mid-2000s took on the task of determining the “costs” per pupil of what Pennsylvania school districts needed to get the job done. This cost analysis was then used to guide development of a new formula intended to drive appropriate levels of state aid to districts facing substantive gaps between current spending (2006-07) at the time, and cost estimates developed under state supervision, by independent consultants.
At the time, state officials found that districts including Philadelphia, Allentown and Reading faced funding (relative to cost) gaps between $4,000 and $6,000+ per pupil.  So, in rather bold style, they adopted a new school finance formula with the intent to phase districts toward their adequacy targets.  Then the economy tanked, and a new era of political attacks on state school finance formulas followed (as much a Cuomo/NY issue as a Corbett one!).
So, where are Pennsylvania school districts now, with 2013-14 (July estimates) funding (holding 

REVIEW: “Reign of Error,” Ravitch 3.0 | the becoming radical

REVIEW: “Reign of Error,” Ravitch 3.0 | the becoming radical:

REVIEW: “Reign of Error,” Ravitch 3.0

When faced with the many competing narratives of the religions of the world, comparative myth/religion scholar Joseph Campbell explained to Bill Moyersthat Campbell did not reject religion, as some scholars have, but instead reached this conclusion:
Every religion is true one way or another. It is true when understood metaphorically. But when it gets stuck to its own metaphors, interpreting them as facts, then you are in trouble.
The Death and LIfe of the Great American School System
Reign of Error
Since Ravitch is a respected historian of education, a brief history seems appropriate for context.
Ravitch 1.0 established herself as a leading scholar of the history of education. She also wrote best-selling and influential books on education beginning in the mid-1970s. During the 1970s and into the early 2000s, Ravitch was associated with conservative politics (notably because of her public service from 1991 to 1993 as Assistant Secretary of Education and Counselor to Secretary of Education Lamar Alexander under President George H.W. Bush) and traditional 

Families try to cope with neighborhood school closings | Philadelphia Public School Notebook

Families try to cope with neighborhood school closings | Philadelphia Public School Notebook:

Families try to cope with neighborhood school closings

In North Philadelphia, families were confronted with a shrinking pool of school options.

by Connie Langland and Mark McHugh
Photo: Harvey Finkle
George Metz (left) with stepson Shyheim Saunders, a senior who is attending his third high school in three years as a result of two successive rounds of school closings. Metz’s three daughters were also affected by a school closing – at Anna Pratt Elementary.
George Metz’s family is all too familiar with school closings. 
His stepson, Shyheim Saunders, 17, attended FitzSimons from 7th to 10th grade. When that got shuttered in 2012, he transferred to Roberts Vaux for 11th grade. Now, heading into his senior year in high school, Shyheim will switch once again, attending Benjamin Franklin High School due to the recent closing at Vaux.
That adds up to three schools in three years for Shyheim. 
That’s bad enough if you ask Metz, whose family lives in a two-story townhouse in Raymond Rosen Manor, a housing project in North Philadelphia. 
But then there was even gloomier news for the family. Anna Pratt Elementary, across the street from the housing project, closed in June, except for its pre-K program. 
In many ways, Pratt Elementary had served as an anchor in the neighborhood. Metz, a self-proclaimed overprotective father, could stand at his doorway with his wife, Lakeisha, and watch his children cross Susquehanna Avenue onto the school grounds. 
Metz has three young daughters who were enrolled at Pratt – Diamond, 10, Danasia, 8, and Cheyenne, 5. 
The school, which abuts the project at 22nd Street, had an enrollment last year of about 400 students from pre-K to 6th grade. A vivid mural still dominates one wall of the school, and the clean, polished playground behind it was built just three years ago with funding from the

Michelle Rhee to host town hall meeting on ed reform
by Isaac Riddle Michelle Rhee, the former D.C. schools chancellor who now heads the influential education reform group StudentsFirst, will be holding a town hall meeting tonight at Temple University’s Student Faculty Center Auditorium. The purpose of the meeting, the third in a series held nationwide, is to have an honest and open conversation about improving public education. Rhee asked specifica

NYC Educator: Principals' Blooper Reel

NYC Educator: Principals' Blooper Reel:

Principals' Blooper Reel

Imagine all the principals getting together and having a big party. They've bought pizza, big heroes, all sort
of drinks, and they're wearing lampshades on their heads. They look completely out of control until they all focus on that big TV. And there we are. Oops. You're wearing one black and one brown shoe. Hilarity ensues. Everyone asks how many points it will cause, and principals look to Danielson for guidance.

Uh oh. I don't like the look on that teacher's face. This makes for a negative classroom environment. Let's rewind it and see how severe it is. No, I don't like that at all. And look at that student in the corner. He's not paying attention. Rewind the tape. Yup. This teacher is not motivating these kids. Look at how that kid is texting. How could it be that the teacher didn't catch it? Actually, the teacher is talking to another kid about texting, and is therefore not even paying attention. Negative classroom environment, say I, and there go another 5 points.

But this teacher is excellent. Look at this lesson. We'll give the video to DOE and everyone can look at it. And

Educational apartheid a disgrace | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!

Educational apartheid a disgrace | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!:

Educational apartheid a disgrace

Filed under: Civil Rights Movement Today — millerlf @ 12:25 pm 


Continued budget cuts, growth in voucher schools demonstrate separate is not equal

On Sept. 21, concerned Milwaukeeans will gather for the Public Education is a Civil Right March and Rally. Participants will assemble at Milwaukee High School of the Arts and then march to Forest Home Avenue School for a rally.
It’s been nearly 60 years since the Supreme Court’s landmark Brown vs. Board of Education ruling. That decision declared “separate but equal” was not a valid construct when it came to public education. In that case, the separation was between racial groups.
Apartheid, the government-enforced system of racial segregation in South Africa, endured for almost 50 years until the election of the African National Congress led by Nelson Mandela.
So, why is it that in 2013, we in Milwaukee can’t grasp the fact that many of our city’s students, often the most needy ones, do not have the same access to a free, quality education as their peers in the suburbs? In other words, separation by socioeconomic status.
President John F. Kennedy spoke to the vital importance of truly public education.
“Modern cynics and skeptics …see no harm in paying those to whom they entrust the minds of their children a smaller wage than is paid to those to whom they entrust the care of their plumbing.”
Kennedy unknowingly presaged the current budget battles when he added: “Our progress as a nation can be no swifter than our progress in education. The human mind is our fundamental resource.”
Milwaukee is a city where public schools once were nearly as much a given as the right to exist or even to breathe. The native language of