Sunday, March 14, 2010
Obama Calls for Sweeping Overhaul in Education Law - NYTimes.com
Obama Calls for an Educational Overhaul
President Barack Obama promised to rewrite the nation's sweeping and controversial education law known as No Child Left Behind with a plan to prepare students for life after high school and to place better teachers at the blackboards. (March 13)
Internal Affairs: Big money rules California's political landscape - San Jose Mercury News
Internal Affairs: Big money rules California's political landscape
Lots of tough talk at state GOP convention
In a midterm election year when angry voters are turning on Democrats and turning out at Tea Party protests, California Republicans are talking up volatile issues that have historically resonated in hard times, including getting tough on environmental regulations and undocumented immigrants and their children.
But even in the overwhelmingly conservative venue of the state GOP convention in Santa Clara this weekend, some Republicans expressed concern that efforts by candidates to revive the thrust of Proposition 187, the anti-illegal immigration measure, and roll back California's landmark climate change legislation may hurt the party's long-term outreach to Latino and independent voters in the nation's most populous state.The attempt to find a rallying point for the widespread angst about the economy proved to be a tough balancing act for the GOP during Saturday's sessions, especially as it tries to expand its voter base. Only 31 percent of California voters are registered with the GOP, and no congressional district has a majority of Republicans.
California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner, who is challenging front-runner Meg Whitman for his party's gubernatorial nomination, was the most vivid example of the lengths to which candidates will stretch to win the party's right flank. He called for an end to all taxpayer-funded services to undocumented immigrants, including denying their children public education and health care.
"We're just out of money ... and one of the reasons the state's in trouble is because of illegal immigration," said Poizner, who argued California spends up to $10 billion annually on services for illegal immigrants.
"I'm going to be the truth teller in this campaign. As governor I'm going to stop illegal immigration once and for all," Poizner said to loud cheers from the audience Saturday
Read more: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/03/13/MNI91CFEOE.DTL#ixzz0iAFrH9Fi
The Big Idea -- it's bad education policy - latimes.com
The Big Idea -- it's bad education policy
One simple solution for our schools? A captivating promise, but a false one.
Education is a slow, arduous process that requires the work of willing students, dedicated teachers and supportive families, as well as a coherent curriculum.
As an education historian, I have often warned against the seductive lure of grand ideas to reform education. Our national infatuation with education fads and reforms distracts us from the steady work that must be done.
Our era is no different. We now face a wave of education reforms based on the belief that school choice, test-driven accountability and the resulting competition will dramatically improve student achievement.
Once again, I find myself sounding the alarm that the latest vision of education reform is deeply flawed. But this time my warning carries a personal rebuke. For much of the last two decades, I was among those who jumped aboard the choice and accountability bandwagon. Choice and accountability, I believed, would offer a chance for poor children to escape failing schools. Testing and accountability, I thought, would cast sunshine on low-performing schools and lead to improvement. It all seemed to make sense, even if there was little empirical evidence, just promise and hope.
Today there is empirical evidence, and it shows clearly that choice, competition and accountability as education reform levers are not working. But with confidence bordering on recklessness, the Obama administration is plunging ahead, pushing an aggressive program of school reform -- codified in its signature Race to the Top program -- that relies on the power of incentives and competition. This approach may well make schools worse, not better.
Those who do not follow education closely may be tempted to think that, at long last, we're finally turning the corner. What could be wrong with promoting charter schools to compete with public schools? Why shouldn't we demand accountability from educators and use test scores to reward our best teachers and identify those who should find another job?
Like the grand plans of previous eras, they sound sensible but will leave education no better off. Charter schools are no panacea. The nation now has about 5,000 of them, and they vary in quality.
Obama seeks to overhaul No Child Left Behind - latimes.com
Obama seeks to overhaul No Child Left Behind
The president, in his weekly address, says he'll send a blueprint to Congress to give high school grads 'the best chance to succeed' globally. Republicans insist the economy is being ignored.
Worried that the U.S. is falling behind in education, Obama warned Saturday in his weekly addressthat "the nation that out-educates us today will out-compete us tomorrow."
He said America had "lost ground" over the last several decades, pointing to 15-year-olds who no longer are near the top in math and science compared with their peers around the world, high school graduation rates that have lagged behind most other wealthy countries, and a United States that no longer leads the world in producing college graduates.
"Unless we step up, unless we take action," Obama said, "there are countless children who will never realize their full talent and potential."
In the Republican response to the president's remarks, Sen. Scott Brown of Massachusetts said Obama, in the first year of his administration, had spent too much time and energy on healthcare and other issues and not enough on trying to end the recession.
Brown said that "an entire year has gone to waste. Millions of Americans have lost their jobs, and many more jobs are in danger. Even now, the president still hasn't gotten the message."
Obama said he would push education reforms aimed at making high school students ready for college and careers by 2020 and at emphasizing academic achievements beyond what were called for under President George W. Bush's No Child Left Behind program.
Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, speaking to reporters on Friday, said that No Child Left Behind, signed into law in 2002, had resulted in lower standards and that teachers spend more time preparing for class than actually instructing.
Duncan has begun working with a bipartisan group of lawmakers to rewrite the law, and he plans to tour schools in Iowa with Senate education committee Chairman Tom Harkin (D-Iowa).
How the proposal will fare in Congress is uncertain.
Some teachers' union officials, who have previewed the plan to be unveiled Monday, said it could end up just rewarding the top 10% of schools. Obama did not detail Saturday how his proposal would
California's List of Shame Too bad it tarnishes so many prominent names - The Reporter
California's List of Shame Too bad it tarnishes so many prominent names
Like it or not, 188 schools are held up to shame, ridicule or sympathy. All over the state, teachers and principals in California's several thousand other schools are breathing a sigh of relief that they aren't on the hit list.
How did a school make the slate? Criteria included low test scores in reading and math, lack of significant improvement on the state's academic performance index, low graduation rates for high schools and a variety of other factors.
Poverty and demographic makeup are major causes, but, apparently, you can't blame either of them. Instead, blame the teachers, the principals or the district offices. Close the schools, fire the staff, turn the kids over to a power-hungry charter operator who's after that multibillion-dollar state education budget. But don't point a finger at the real causes for making that list: parental neglect, student apathy, inadequate command of English, broken homes and poverty.
Some educators will be surprised that the number of cited schools located in big cities is not greater. From all the criticism of Oakland and Los Angeles Unified districts, those cities should dominate the chart. They don't. Instead, there's a disproportionate number of rural schools from the Salinas/San Joaquin valleys and
other areas with a large farm labor population.The names of the schools on the list are an indication of the root causes. A handful carry the name of Cesar Chavez. An equal number are named for George Washington Carver. There are no Ronald Reagan nor Calvin Coolidge schools among the 188. Some of the schools listed bring with them a tinge of embarrassment. The names of two renowned Supreme Court justices appear there. Both the John Marshall and the Thurgood Marshall schools are among the lowest achieving institutions in the state. In San Francisco, both the Willie Brown and Phil Burton schools gained this dubious honor. Believe it or not, Horace Mann, perhaps the nation's most prominent 19th century educator, is there, too.
Obama promise: Brighter education futures for kids - Norwalk News - The Hour - Norwalk's Newspaper
A plan to overhaul the 2002 education law championed by President George W. Bush was unveiled by the Obama administration Saturday in hopes of replacing a system that in the last decade has tagged more than a third of schools as failing and created a hodgepodge of sometimes weak academic standards among states.
"Unless we take action -- unless we step up -- there are countless children who will never realize their full talent and potential," Obama said during a video address on Saturday.
"I don't accept that future for them. And I don't accept that future for the United States of America."
In the proposed dismantling of the No Child Left Behind law, education officials would move away from punishing schools that don't meet benchmarks and focus on rewarding schools for progress, particularly with poor and minority students. Obama intends to send a rewrite to Congress on Monday of the law.
The proposed changes call for states to adopt standards that ensure students are ready for college or a career rather than grade-level proficiency -- the focus of the current law.
Obama's Education Reform Push is Bad Education Policy | CommonDreams.org
Obama's Education Reform Push is Bad Education Policy
One simple solution for our schools? A captivating promise, but a false one.
Education is a slow, arduous process that requires the work of willing students, dedicated teachers and supportive families, as well as a coherent curriculum.
As an education historian, I have often warned against the seductive lure of grand ideas to reform education. Our national infatuation with education fads and reforms distracts us from the steady work that must be done.
Our era is no different. We now face a wave of education reforms based on the belief that school choice, test-driven accountability and the resulting competition will dramatically improve student achievement.
Once again, I find myself sounding the alarm that the latest vision of education reform is deeply flawed. But this time my warning carries a personal rebuke. For much of the last two decades, I was among those who jumped aboard the choice and accountability bandwagon. Choice and accountability, I believed, would offer a chance for poor children to escape failing schools. Testing and accountability, I thought, would cast sunshine on low-performing schools and lead to improvement. It all seemed to make sense, even if there was little empirical evidence, just promise and hope.
Today there is empirical evidence, and it shows clearly that choice, competition and accountability as education reform levers are not working. But with confidence bordering on recklessness, the Obama administration is plunging ahead, pushing an aggressive program of school reform -- codified in its signature Race to the Top program -- that relies on the power of incentives and competition. This approach may well make schools worse, not better.
Those who do not follow education closely may be tempted to think that, at long last, we're finally turning the corner. What could be wrong with promoting charter schools to compete with public schools? Why shouldn't we demand accountability from educators and use test scores to reward our best teachers and identify those who should find another job?
Like the grand plans of previous eras, they sound sensible but will leave education no better off. Charter schools are no panacea. The nation now has about 5,000 of them, and they vary in quality. Some are excellent, some terrible; most are in between. Most studies have found that charters, on average, are no better than public schools.
On the federal tests, known as the National Assessment of Educational Progress, from 2003 to 2009, charters have never outperformed public schools. Nor have black and Latino students in charter schools performed better than their counterparts in public schools.
This is surprising, because charter schools have many advantages over public schools. Most charters choose their students by lottery. Those who sign up to win seats tend to be the most motivated students and families in the poorest communities. Charters are also free to "counsel out" students who are unable or unwilling to meet expectations. A study of KIPP charters in the San Francisco area found that 60% of those students who started the fifth grade were gone before the end of eighth grade. Most of those who left were low performers.
Studies of charters in Boston, New York City and Washington have found that charters, as compared to public schools, have smaller percentages of the students who are generally hardest to educate -- those with disabilities and English-language learners. Because the public schools must educate everyone, they end up with disproportionate numbers of the students the charters don't want.
So we're left with the knowledge that a dramatic expansion in the number of privately managed schools is not likely to raise student achievement. Meanwhile, public schools will become schools of last resort for the unmotivated, the hardest to teach and those who didn't win a seat in a charter school. If our goal is to destroy public education in America, this is precisely the right path.
Nor is there evidence that student achievement will improve if teachers are evaluated by their students' test scores. Some economists say that when students have four or five "great" teachers in a row, the achievement gap between racial groups disappears. The difficulty with this theory is that we do not have adequate measures of teacher excellence.
Of course, it would be wonderful if all teachers were excellent, but many factors affect student scores other than their teacher, including students' motivation, the schools' curriculum, family support, poverty and distractions on testing day, such as the weather or even a dog barking in the school's parking lot.
The Obama education reform plan is an aggressive version of the Bush administration's No Child Left Behind, under which many schools have narrowed their curriculum to the tested subjects of reading and math. This poor substitute for a well-rounded education, which includes subjects such as the arts, history, geography, civics, science and foreign language, hits low-income children the hardest, since they are the most likely to attend the kind of "failing school" that drills kids relentlessly on the basics. Emphasis on test scores already compels teachers to focus on test preparation. Holding teachers personally and exclusively accountable for test scores -- a key feature of Race to the Top -- will make this situation even worse. Test scores will determine salary, tenure, bonuses and sanctions, as teachers and schools compete with each other, survival-of-the-fittest style.
Frustrated by a chronic lack of progress, business leaders and politicians expect that a stern dose of this sort of competition and incentives will improve education, but they are wrong. No other nation is taking such harsh lessons from the corporate sector and applying them to their schools. No nation with successful schools ignores everything but basic skills and testing. Schools work best when teachers collaborate to help their students and strive together for common goals, not when they compete for higher scores and bonuses.
Having embraced the Republican agenda of choice, competition and accountability, the Obama administration is promoting the privatization of large segments of American education and undermining the profession of teaching. This toxic combination is the latest Big Idea in education reform. Like so many of its predecessors, it is not likely to improve education.
Diane Ravitch, a historian of education, is the author of "The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education."
Radical reform: 'Lowest achieving' Watsonville High School faces new requirements for change - Santa Cruz Sentinel
Radical reform: 'Lowest achieving' Watsonville High School faces new requirements for change
WATSONVILLE -- The label of failing school is nothing new to Watsonville High.
Since California implemented a standardized testing and school ranking plan a little more than a decade ago, the school has scored at or near the bottom.
The latest reminder of its lagging efforts to improve student achievement came Thursday when the state Board of Education designated Watsonville and four other Pajaro Valley schools among 188 "persistently lowest-achieving" schools.
Watsonville has made progress, but by state and federal standards the pace has been too slow and the new designation comes with a requirement for radical reform, including such measures as replacing the principal and at least half the faculty.
Principal Murry Schekman, who stands to lose his job under any of the reform scenarios, doesn't disagree with the state and federal assessment of his school.
"We can do better," said Schekman, who's in his fourth year as principal. But he added that last year's 21-point gain on the state's Academic Performance Index, after nearly flat scores in the previous three years, shows the school's finally on the right track. "Our reforms are in place, and we're just going to keep on doing it."
STRUGGLING SCHOOL
In 1999, when the state first introduced the Academic Performance Index, which uses standardized test results to score and rank schools, the goal was to achieve 800 points or more. Watsonville scored 475, in
Retirees win ruling Valley news of the week -- March 7-13 - Catching Up - fresnobee.com
Retirees win ruling
What happened: A judge ruled against Fresno Unified School District in a case filed by retired employees. The suit began after the district and its unions agreed in 2005 to start charging retirees up to $70 per month for what were supposed to be free lifetime health benefits.
What it means: Unless officials decide to appeal, the ruling could cost the cash-strapped district at least $4 million, a lawyer for the plaintiffs said.
What readers said:
“That’s the bad thing about these generous benefit packages for government employees. They are the devil to get rid of.”
-- jghall
“Good for the teachers. These men & women have worked very hard over the years to help shape the future. They should get what they were promised.”
-- smedina22
2nd Banana SATURDAY, MARCH 13, 2010
- Local News | Gummy-bear fun offers a taste of scie...
- Schools Matter: Obama's NCLB 2.0: Worse Than the B...
- Schools Matter: Texas Becomes Laughingstock Once A...
- Education Week: Administration Unveils ESEA Renewa...
- Education - Everything you need to know about th...
- Today's EducationNews 3.13.10 EducationNews.org
- Schools Matter: Bill Maher on the Central Falls Ma...
- Can't You See It? Teachers For Technology. Now, ...
- Congressional Black Caucus Member Discusses Obama ...
- New Assembly Speaker Sworn In Close to Home :: blo...
- CSUS student union fee a hard sell - Education - M...
- California Budget Crisis Diaries: Living with the ...
- Castaneda, principals square off at Alisal meeting...
- Conservatives carry Texas curriculum
- The Militant - March 22, 2010 -- ‘We can’t be pass...
- Why Immigration Helps Wages in California - Newswe...
- | state, year, districts - News - The Orange Count...
- USC Provost C.L. 'Max' Nikias to succeed Steven Sa...
- Maldonado to Newsom: Bring it on - San Jose Mercur...
- Student Loan Bill Opposed by Group Packed With Ex-...
- A step down: Federal education standards - The Bos...
- Latino conference explores role in higher educatio...
- State sifting through college transfer requirement...
- Student Loan Provisions May Ease Passage of Health...
- Education foundation hosts forum on teacher pay - ...
- FT.com / US & Canada - Funding squeeze spurs stude...
- Education symposium takes pragmatic look at state ...
- Coastal Voices Guest Opinion: Don’t punish student...
- What State’s 188 Low-Performing Schools Can Expect...
- 2nd Banana FRIDAY, MARCH 12, 2010







