Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, June 1, 2019

Top Posts This Week 6/1/19 #REDFORED #CTA

Big Education Ape



Top Posts This Week 6/1/19

Big Education Ape: My New Book Was Just Announced! | Diane Ravitch's blog - http://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/05/my-new-book-was-just-announced-diane.html

















  • Top Posts This Month 6/1/19


















  • Posts This Week  6/1/19





    Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running
    Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running I can’t support us fixing computers and stuff for a charter school co-located with a district school that doesn’t have the same technology .” – Jackie Goldberg Backed by Jackie Goldberg’s overwhelming electoral victory , George McKenna and Scott Schmerelson revisited their motion from last August to temporar
    Seattle Schools Community Forum: Gay Pride Month Starts Today
    Seattle Schools Community Forum: Gay Pride Month Starts Today Gay Pride Month Starts Today The month of June was chosen for LGBT Pride Month to commemorate the Stonewall riots, which occurred at the end of June 1969. As a result, many pride events are held during this month to recognize the impact LGBT people have had in the world. From Nerd and Lace Whether in support of Gay Pride Month or just
    Jersey Jazzman: NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately
    Jersey Jazzman: NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately What follows is yet another year's worth of data analysis on New Jersey's student "growth" measure: Student Growth Percentiles (SGPs). And yet another year of my growing frustration and annoyance with the policymakers and pundi
    Charter Schools Conceived, Organized, and Imposed by the Rich | Dissident Voice
    Charter School Promoters Criticize and Complain About Charter Schools While Pushing For More Charter Schools | Dissident Voice Charter School Promoters Criticize and Complain About Charter Schools While Pushing For More Charter Schools The narrow aim of maximizing profit as fast as possible compels owners of capital to say and do whatever they have to to get richer, no matter how irrational and c
    CURMUDGUCATION: NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education
    CURMUDGUCATION: NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education New Hampshire's education commissioner has decided to push a really terrible education idea . It's called "Learn Everywhere," and it looks like a new approach to replacing public education, a kind of true backdoor approach to vouchering. It comes dressed in pretty language, but it sti
    National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading | Diane Ravitch's blog
    National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading | Diane Ravitch's blog National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading Bruce Baker of Rutgers University reviewed three policy briefs produced by the pro-charter, pro-choice Center for Reinventing Public Educati
    CURMUDGUCATION: Rewarding Failing Schools
    CURMUDGUCATION: Rewarding Failing Schools Rewarding Failing Schools One of the problems with the business oriented view of education reveals itself in the use of the word "reward." As long as the debate has raged, we can find commentators, thinky tanks, and policy makers arguing that giving more resources to struggling schools is "rewarding" them for failure. ( Here's an example , and here's anot
    Michigan: State Attorney General Will Take a Position Opposite to the Governor in Detroit Literacy Lawsuit | Diane Ravitch's blog
    Michigan: State Attorney General Will Take a Position Opposite to the Governor in Detroit Literacy Lawsuit | Diane Ravitch's blog Michigan: State Attorney General Will Take a Position Opposite to the Governor in Detroit Literacy Lawsuit Now, this gets interesting. Two days ago, I posted about the battle in Michigan over who is responsible for the deplorable conditions in the public schools of Det
    My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers - Teacher Habits
    My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers - Teacher Habits My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers I had the pleasure yesterday of serving on my school’s interview team for a third grade position. Five candidates, four of whom just finished their student teaching and one of whom has five years of teaching experience, competed for the job. They each taught a 15-minute lesson and an
    Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE?
    Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE? Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE? You can’t change it without us re-voting. ” = LAUSD Board Member Richard Vladovic That is correct. ” – LAUSD General Counsel David Holmquist Los Angeles students are in desperate need of the funds promised from Measure EE . As noted by Dr. Rocio Rivas , “California ranks 43rd in per-pupil spending with an investment o
    “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors | The Merrow Report
    “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors | The Merrow Report “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors “Charter School” is a vague descriptive term, akin to “Restaurant,” in that neither term tells you very much. One of them, however, is dangerously vague. “Restaurant” is vague but not dangerous. The word tells you only that the establishment serves food of some kind, but
    THIS WEEK Education Research Report
    Education Research Report THIS WEEK Education Research Report Letter writing instruction: too little practice with low frequency letters by Jonathan Kantrowitz / 23h Children’s ability to write letters automatically has been linked to academic achievement. Despite the importance of handwriting, handwriting instruction is often neglected and teachers use inconsistent practices to teach handwriting
    This Week With Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... The latest news and resources in education since 2007
    Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... | The latest news and resources in education since 2007 This Week With Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day... The latest news and resources in education since 2007 My Most Popular Tweets Of The Month by Larry Ferlazzo / 23min PhotoMIX-Company / Pixabay I used to post weekly collections of my best tweets, and used Storify to bring them together. Unfortunate
    KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG | A site to discuss better education for all
    Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG A site to discuss better education for all Big Education Ape: My New Book Was Just Announced! | Diane Ravitch's blog - https://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2019/05/my-new-book-was-just-announced-diane.html Pennsylvania: Charter Lobby Pushes to Remove All Quality Controls and Allow Unlimit
    End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling
    End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling It’s time to end the charter school experiment. Put successful charters under the supervision of the nearby school district. Charters not working well should close. No charter school should get tax dollars without oversight. This should be for both for-profit and nonpr

    YESTERDAY

    MDCPS Board Member Dr. Larry Feldman at Homestead prison camp - YouTube
    MDCPS Board Member Dr. Larry Feldman at Homestead prison camp - YouTube MDCPS Board Member Dr. Larry Feldman at Homestead prison camp This morning activists attempted to deliver letters written by students to the children imprisoned unjustly in Homestead. Dr. Feldman describes the school board's constitutional responsibilities to the children inside. MDCPS Board Member Dr. Larry Feldman at Homest
    CURMUDGUCATION: Jeb Bush: Frying Reform Baloney for Michigan
    CURMUDGUCATION: Jeb Bush: Frying Reform Baloney for Michigan Jeb Bush: Frying Reform Baloney for Michigan The Detroit News just ran a Jeb Bush fluff piece chock full of reformy baloney (reformaloney?) and an embarrassing lack of those fact thingies. It's helpful to know that the writer is Ingrid Jacques, deputy editorial page editor, and a graduate of Hillsdale College, the noted far-right Libert
    Charter schools were supposed to save public education. Why did people turn on them? - The Washington Post
    Charter schools were supposed to save public education. Why did people turn on them? - The Washington Post School’s out Charters were supposed to save public education. Why are Americans turning against them? The charter school movement is in trouble. In late December, the editorial board of the Chicago Sun-Times observed that the charter movement in the Windy City was “in hot water and likely to
    Schools Matter: What the KIPP Model Has Spawned
    Schools Matter: What the KIPP Model Has Spawned What the KIPP Model Has Spawned If you know anything about schools based on the "No Excuses" KIPP model, you have probably heard the motto, "there are no excuses," "failure is not an option," success at any cost," and "KIPP is a family", etc. If you know more about these schools inspired by the "success" of KIPP, you may have heard something about s
    Proposal to cap charter school growth all but dies in California Assembly - SFGate
    Proposal to cap charter school growth all but dies in California Assembly - SFGate Proposal to cap charter school growth all but dies in California Assembly SACRAMENTO — A proposal to cap the number of California charter schools went into a deep freeze in the state Assembly on Thursday, a sign of the difficult fight teachers unions face as they push to stop the growth of the alternatives to tradi
    NYC: Class Size Champion Strikes Again, in Court | Diane Ravitch's blog
    NYC: Class Size Champion Strikes Again, in Court | Diane Ravitch's blog NYC: Class Size Champion Strikes Again, in Court Leonie Haimson is a force of nature. She and her! Student Privacy allies beat Bill Gates’ $100 Million inBloom data-collection project. She and her parent allies forced the NYC Department of Education to back down and keep open high-performing low-enrollment PS 25 in Brooklyn.
    Teachers Paying for Their Own Substitutes? Believe it or Not, It Happens.
    Teachers Paying for Their Own Substitutes? Believe it or Not, It Happens. Teachers Paying for Their Own Substitutes? Believe it or Not, It Happens. A San Francisco second-grade teacher who, due to state law, must pay the cost of a substitute educator while she seeks treatment for breast cancer has made national headlines after parents at her school started an online GoFundMe campaign to cover her
    LAUSD Libraries are Safe (For Now)
    LAUSD Libraries are Safe (For Now) LAUSD Libraries are Safe (For Now) We intend to bring forth a budget in June that will commit to sustaining library aides for all elementary schools for the 2019-20 school year. ” – LA Superintendent Austin Beutner In the days leading up to the strike by Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) teachers, Board Member Nick Melvoin told parents that the teacher
    Capitalism Camp for Kids (Brendan O’Connor) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice
    Capitalism Camp for Kids (Brendan O’Connor) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice Capitalism Camp for Kids (Brendan O’Connor) Brendan O’Connor is a free-lance journalist. This article appeared in the New York Times Online May 22, 2019. * At first, I was startled by this article. Now, I am not naive. I have many miles on my speedometer. Sure, I had heard of ambitious (and anxious)
    NYC Educator: What Are the Techniques and Strategies for English Language Learners?
    NYC Educator: What Are the Techniques and Strategies for English Language Learners? What Are the Techniques and Strategies for English Language Learners? I hear a lot of talk about that, particularly from people who are trying to rationalize Part 154. In case I haven't explained it 500 times, CR Part 154 says that we no longer need to teach English to English Language Learners. So we take away 33
    Joe Biden’s Plan for Education: Democrats Must Do Better | Real Learning CT
    Joe Biden’s Plan for Education: Democrats Must Do Better | Real Learning CT Joe Biden’s Plan for Education: Democrats Must Do Better What a disappointment Joe Biden’s education plan is. Democrats must do better. ” Joe’s Plan for Educators, Students, and our Future” does not mention at all the important issues before us in American education. No mention of the funding of privately managed, taxpaye

    MAY 30

    An Urban Teacher's Education: A Critique of Standards-Based Grading
    An Urban Teacher's Education: A Critique of Standards-Based Grading A Critique of Standards-Based Grading It first happened to me about ten years ago. I was beginning my third year of teaching in a new school in Washington, DC. Social studies teachers were sitting at a department meeting, and the assistant principal assigned as our department head was explaining to us why standards-based grading
    CAN TV – The Future of Chicago Public Schools
    CAN TV – The Future of Chicago Public Schools The Future of Chicago Public Schools Panelists present their vision and roadmaps for Chicago Public Schools in order to achieve greater racial justice in the city’s public education system and society at large at this event hosted by Institute for Research on Race and Public Policy (IRRPP). This program was recorded by Chicago Access Network Televisio
    CURMUDGUCATION: OH: Takeover Battle Comes To Senate
    CURMUDGUCATION: OH: Takeover Battle Comes To Senate OH: Takeover Battle Comes To Senate Our story so far: The Ohio House has passed a bill scrapping Ohio's disastrous takeover bill, HB 70. The new language was incorporated into the budget (HB 166) and, having cleared the House, must go to the Senate, where education committee chair Peggy Lehner is not particularly sympathetic to public education.
    2020 Vision: The Democratic Presidential Candidates on Education – Have You Heard
    2020 Vision: The Democratic Presidential Candidates on Education – Have You Heard 2020 Vision: The Democratic Presidential Candidates on Education From Bernie Sanders on charter schools and segregation to Cory Booker stating, once again, that he is a believer in public education, to higher pay for teachers and free-er college for all (or some), the Democratic presidential candidates can’t stop ta
    Charter schools accused of stealing $50M from California
    Charter schools accused of stealing $50M from California Charter schools accused of stealing $50M from California SAN DIEGO (AP) — A network of charter schools in California stole more than $50 million from the state by creating phantom institutions that enrolled unwitting students it found through other schools and youth programs, prosecutors said Wednesday. A3 Education recruited small public s
    My New Book Was Just Announced! | Diane Ravitch's blog
    My New Book Was Just Announced! | Diane Ravitch's blog My New Book Was Just Announced! I am very excited! My new book was just announced! The title is: SLAYING GOLIATH: The Impassioned Fight to Defeat the Privatization Movement and to Save America’s Public Schools. It will be published on January 14, 2020, by Knopf, the most prestigious publisher in America. The editor is the brilliant Victoria W
    Vote Woman | radical eyes for equity
    Vote Woman | radical eyes for equity Vote Woman Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, I taught in the very conservative small town where I was born and attended school. This added a second layer to the moral imperative I felt as a calling to teach. I recall to this day sitting in a first-year college English class and suddenly feeling out of place . There was something, or some things , I simply didn’t
    Pearson Wants to Expand Its Virtual Schools Market; Its “Connections Academy” in Louisiana Is No Selling Factor | deutsch29
    Pearson Wants to Expand Its Virtual Schools Market; Its “Connections Academy” in Louisiana Is No Selling Factor | deutsch29 Pearson Wants to Expand Its Virtual Schools Market; Its “Connections Academy” in Louisiana Is No Selling Factor Connections Academy is a virtual K12 (and possibly pre-K12) school operated by education business mammoth, Pearson. According to Pearson’s February 2019 earnings c
    US News And World Report Closes Cheating Loophole — Charters Tank | Gary Rubinstein's Blog
    US News And World Report Closes Cheating Loophole — Charters Tank | Gary Rubinstein's Blog US News And World Report Closes Cheating Loophole — Charters Tank U.S. News & World Report produces several influential annual ‘best of’ lists in all kinds of categories. In education they rank colleges, graduate schools, and, of course, high schools. In recent years, charter schools have been dominating th
    The New York State Legislature, Charter Schools and the “Big Ugly:” A Lesson in Civics (aka, Realpolitics) | Ed In The Apple
    The New York State Legislature, Charter Schools and the “Big Ugly:” A Lesson in Civics (aka, Realpolitics) | Ed In The Apple The New York State Legislature, Charter Schools and the “Big Ugly:” A Lesson in Civics (aka, Realpolitics) Realpolitics: political realism or practical politics especially based on power as well as on ideals. Why is politics so contentious? Why can’t people get along? Why i
    NYC Public School Parents: We file an appeal in our class size lawsuit to require NYC Department of Education to lower class size in all grades
    NYC Public School Parents: We file an appeal in our class size lawsuit to require NYC Department of Education to lower class size in all grades We file an appeal in our class size lawsuit to require NYC Department of Education to lower class size in all grades On Thursday May 23, 2019 the Education Law Center filed an appeal on behalf of nine NYC parents, Class Size Matters and the Alliance for Q
    How Closing Schools Traumatizes Students and Communities - NEA Today
    How Closing Schools Traumatizes Students and Communities - NEA Today How Closing Schools Traumatizes Students and Communities Since 2004, Oakland Unified School District has closed 16 schools and is now targeting an additional 24 by the start of the 2019-20 school year. District officials call it “right-sizing,” a term borrowed from corporate America – appropriate given that many of the shuttered
    New report on virtual education: ‘It sure sounds good. As it turns out, it’s too good to be true.’ - The Washington Post
    New report on virtual education: ‘It sure sounds good. As it turns out, it’s too good to be true.’ - The Washington Post New report on virtual education: ‘It sure sounds good. As it turns out, it’s too good to be true.’ The future of education, you might hear some enthusiasts say, is virtual: Online schools have grown significantly over the past decade, as have traditional schools that use online

    MAY 29

    A Teacher’s Scorecard for Democratic 2020 Hopefuls - Progressive.org
    A Teacher’s Scorecard for Democratic 2020 Hopefuls - Progressive.org A Teacher’s Scorecard for Democratic 2020 Hopefuls This time around, teachers unions have announced their intention to cast a wider net for member opinions. I’m happy to step up. T he 2016 presidential elections were not exactly a high point for the two national teachers’ unions, the National Education Association and the Americ
    How school segregation affects whether a black student gets labeled as having a disability
    How school segregation affects whether a black student gets labeled as having a disability How school segregation affects whether a black student gets labeled as having a disability In Florida schools where almost all students are black or Hispanic, 13% of black students were classified as having a disability. Yet in schools where the vast majority of students were white, nearly 22% of black stud
    National Education Policy Center on Virtual Charter Schools: Annual Report | Diane Ravitch's blog
    National Education Policy Center on Virtual Charter Schools: Annual Report | Diane Ravitch's blog National Education Policy Center on Virtual Charter Schools: Annual Report Today the National Education Policy Center released its annual review of research on virtual charter schools. The bottom line was not good. The title of the report is “Virtual Schools in the U.S. 2019.” It was double blind pee
    Thousands Of Charter Schools Perform Poorly | PopularResistance.Org
    Thousands Of Charter Schools Perform Poorly | PopularResistance.Org THOUSANDS OF CHARTER SCHOOLS PERFORM POORLY “Performance-based accountability” is a hackneyed, Skinnerian, neoliberal buzz-phrase often repeated dogmatically by charter school promoters in order to falsely claim that privately-operated nonprofit and for-profit charter schools are more accountable and higher-performing than public
    Online Charter Schools in L.A., San Diego Counties to Close After Conspiracy, Personal Use of Public Money, Theft Indictment | KTLA
    Online Charter Schools in L.A., San Diego Counties to Close After Conspiracy, Personal Use of Public Money, Theft Indictment | KTLA Online Charter Schools in L.A., San Diego Counties to Close After Conspiracy, Personal Use of Public Money, Theft Indictment Eleven people have been indicted on criminal charges of conspiracy, personal use of public money without legal authority, grand theft and fina
    Democrats see energy behind teachers strikes as a force in 2020 :: WRAL.com
    Democrats see energy behind teachers strikes as a force in 2020 :: WRAL.com Democrats see energy behind teachers strikes as a force in 2020 After teachers in California, Kentucky, Oklahoma and a host of other states went on strike for a series of demands in 2018 and 2019, ranging from better pay to more support in the classroom, Democratic presidential candidates and operatives within their campa
    Media Misreading the Reading Crisis Yet Again – Paul Thomas – Medium
    Media Misreading the Reading Crisis Yet Again – Paul Thomas – Medium Media Misreading the Reading Crisis Yet Again Several news articles , videos , reports on new state legislation, and commentaries across mainstream media have built a false narrative about a Reading Crisis. That story includes several key elements: Teachers do not know, and thus do not practice, the science of reading because te
    Kennedy High School seniors await transcripts as charter board investigates ‘malfeasance’ | The Lens
    Kennedy High School seniors await transcripts as charter board investigates ‘malfeasance’ | The Lens Kennedy High School seniors await transcripts as charter board investigates ‘malfeasance’ Ten days after their graduation ceremony, anxious John F. Kennedy High School seniors — still waiting for their high school transcripts — showed up to their charter network’s board meeting Tuesday, hoping for
    Joe Biden’s education plan, explained - Vox
    Joe Biden’s education plan, explained - Vox Joe Biden’s plan to triple spending on low-income schools, explained Biden’s education plan suggests he’s breaking with Obama’s legacy. Former Vice President Joe Biden just announced his first detailed policy proposal of the 2020 campaign: an education plan that calls for a big increase in federal spending on schools and districts serving low-income kid
    Anti-Abortion Legislation and the Perverse Logic of Human Capital Impact + The Opioid Crisis In CT Investing – Wrench in the Gears
    Anti-Abortion Legislation and the Perverse Logic of Human Capital Impact Investing – Wrench in the Gears Anti-Abortion Legislation and the Perverse Logic of Human Capital Impact Investing If an increasingly automated Fourth Industrial Revolution economic system demands an abundance of poverty data to keep global capital markets moving, it makes sense that those in power might seek to increase bir

    MAY 28

    California School Accountability Report: New data on the cost of charter schools | AB1505 passes |…
    California School Accountability Report: New data on the cost of charter schools | AB1505 passes |… California School Accountability Report: New data on the cost of charter schools | AB1505 passes | and more In the Public Interest’s pick of recent news about the ongoing effort to privatize public education in California. Not an email subscriber? Sign up here. New data on the cost of charter schoo
    Transparency, and Accountability, an Example: The MMSD Interim Superintendent Search Process | AMPS
    Transparency, and Accountability, an Example: The MMSD Interim Superintendent Search Process | AMPS Transparency, and Accountability, an Example: The MMSD Interim Superintendent Search Process From “The Glass Ballot Box and Political Transparency,” by Ellery Foutch Television — “See No Evil” (click to listen/watch) Transparency and accountability for government bodies depend on the public knowing
    How much money do public school teachers, principals, employees make? - Business Insider
    How much money do public school teachers, principals, employees make? - Business Insider From cafeteria workers to principals, here's what everyone makes in a public school The Bureau of Labor Statistics provides data on wages and employment in local-government-owned public elementary and high schools. Public schools employ a wide variety of workers, and salaries range from well below the median
    Charter Schools: A Pig With Lipstick Is Still A Pig | Dissident Voice
    Charter Schools: A Pig With Lipstick Is Still A Pig | Dissident Voice Charter Schools: A Pig With Lipstick Is Still A Pig Deregulated, deunionized, segregated, test-obsessed, privately-operated charter schools that lose employees regularly, manipulate student enrollment frequently, and funnel huge sums of public funds to the rich and their allies under the banner of high ideals cannot be prettifi
    Schools Matter: Watch David Coleman, SAT CEO, Slither
    Schools Matter: Watch David Coleman, SAT CEO, Slither Watch David Coleman, SAT CEO, Slither After David Coleman served the Gates Foundation's most effective Common Core flunky-developer-and-promo-man , he was given a most cushy gig as head the College Board , a "non-profit" corporation with a billion "non-profit" dollars in the bank and generosity to its CEO, who is paid more than $700,000 a year
    CURMUDGUCATION: Can Personalized Learning Deliver
    CURMUDGUCATION: Can Personalized Learning Deliver Can Personalized Learning Deliver A new report published by the National Education Policy Center looks at the current state of K-12 personalized learning and finds that there are many reasons for school districts to think twice about embracing this hot new trend. “Personalized Learning and the Digital Privatization of Curriculum and Teaching” was
    Why Has the “School as Factory” Metaphor Persisted? | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice
    Why Has the “School as Factory” Metaphor Persisted? | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice Why Has the “School as Factory” Metaphor Persisted? Why has the image of tax-supported public schools looking like and operating as factories stuck? In an earlier post, I traced the history of the metaphor since the early 1900s and its 180-degree switch from a positive to negative meaning. Ov
    The "X"odus Files: Accountability is the Problem. | BustED Pencils
    The "X"odus Files: Accountability is the Problem. | BustED Pencils The “X”odus Files: Accountability is the Problem. t’s time to stop trying to rescue “accountability.” It’s a horrendous word and its application only results in blame based authoritarianism. I have seen the attempts to “reclaim” accountability and I have taken my fair share of criticism for my critique of accountability. But why r
    A Wise and Witty Review of The Wisdom and Wit of Diane Ravitch | tultican
    A Wise and Witty Review of The Wisdom and Wit of Diane Ravitch | tultican A Wise and Witty Review of The Wisdom and Wit of Diane Ravitch By T. Ultican 5/27/2019 Maybe not as witty and wise as I had hoped but definitely positive and impressed. I admit; I am a Diane Ravitch fan-boy and this latest release from Garn Press reinforces that posture. Diane is a warrior of ideas who has stood courageousl
    Thanks For Coming To My TED Talk (For The Culture) | The Jose Vilson
    Thanks For Coming To My TED Talk (For The Culture) | The Jose Vilson THANKS FOR COMING TO MY TED TALK (FOR THE CULTURE) I’m so proud to share my most recent TED talk about teacher voice with the world for various reasons: I talked about my family (shouts to Luz and Alejandro!) I talked about my own classroom and students (shouts to last year’s 801-803 in the video) I shouted out #EduColor (We rea
    One Size Does Not Fit All | Live Long and Prosper
    One Size Does Not Fit All | Live Long and Prosper One Size Does Not Fit All More than four dozen literacy experts have signed on to a letter expressing concern over the lack of balance in PBS Newshour’s segment about dyslexia . Among the signers of the letter are Reading Hall of Fame members, Richard Allington, Pat Cunningham, Ken and Yetta Goodman, Michael Graves, Stephen Krashen, P. David Pears

    MAY 27

    EXTRA: Ohio Senate’s School Transformation Plan to Replace HB 70 Is Still a State Takeover | janresseger
    EXTRA: Ohio Senate’s School Transformation Plan to Replace HB 70 Is Still a State Takeover | janresseger EXTRA: Ohio Senate’s School Transformation Plan to Replace HB 70 Is Still a State Takeover This blog will take a one-week early summer break and come back in June on a new, three-day, Monday-Wednesday-Friday summer schedule. Look for a new post on Monday, June 3. I have been reading a May 7, 2
    L.A. Charters Suspend Black and Disabled Students at Higher Rates - LA Progressive
    L.A. Charters Suspend Black and Disabled Students at Higher Rates - LA Progressive L.A. Charters Suspend Black and Disabled Students at Higher Rates Los Angeles charters suspended black students at almost three times the rate of traditional schools; students with disabilities were suspended at nearly four times the non-charter school rate. S chool suspensions are out, restorative justice is in. A
    Rachel Cohen: The Untold History of Charter Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog
    Rachel Cohen: The Untold History of Charter Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog Rachel Cohen: The Untold History of Charter Schools Thanks to Los Angeles blogger Sara Roos for calling my attention to this very interesting article by journalist Rachel Cohen . We have had an extended exchange about the article. Cohen says that the typical origin story of charter schools credits the idea to AFT President
    CURMUDGUCATION: Amazon Wants To Read Your Heart
    CURMUDGUCATION: Amazon Wants To Read Your Heart Amazon Wants To Read Your Heart One of the frontiers in creepy computer intelligence is the pursuit of software that can read the details of your face, your breathing, your eyeballs, and out of those details, construct a computer-generated window into your very heart and soul. Some of the attempts are laughable, like the NWEA feature that presumes t
    Jane, the Chicago Women’s Liberation Union and Illinois’ Reproductive Health Act. – Fred Klonsky
    Jane, the Chicago Women’s Liberation Union and Illinois’ Reproductive Health Act. – Fred Klonsky JANE, THE CHICAGO WOMEN’S LIBERATION UNION AND ILLINOIS’ REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH ACT. I remember Marilyn Webb from my SDS days. She was one of the earliest voices I heard talking about women’s rights as a part of the sixties movements for change. Of course, my Mom was a feminist and Grandma Esther was a f
    Sadness and Tears on Memorial Day | Diane Ravitch's blog
    Sadness and Tears on Memorial Day | Diane Ravitch's blog Sadness and Tears on Memorial Day Let us pause and remember the men and women who lost their lives while serving in the military. The older I get, the more I hate war. I despise those who see war as a political tactic, those who stir up war talk to get votes. Those who drop bombs and fire missiles to raise their poll numbers are contemptibl
    John White Co-Founds His Own Nonprofit: Propel America | deutsch29
    John White Co-Founds His Own Nonprofit: Propel America | deutsch29 John White Co-Founds His Own Nonprofit: Propel America On June 06, 2018, Louisiana state superintendent John White filed this business registration in order to co-found his own nonprofit, Propel America ( EIN 83-1867782 ), with former Camden, NJ, superintendent, Paymon Rouhanifard . White mentions himself as a Propel America “offi
    What We’re Waiting to Hear: The Education Fight No Candidate Mentions (Thus Far)
    What We’re Waiting to Hear: The Education Fight No Candidate Mentions (Thus Far) What We’re Waiting to Hear: The Education Fight No Candidate Mentions (Thus Far) All the democratic presidential candidates have plans how to run the country and positively affect the world. Some have good ideas about how to improve public schools and support teachers. But none has yet to speak about America’s educat
    SAT Adversity Score is an Antidote to Poison None of Us Need Take | gadflyonthewallblog
    SAT Adversity Score is an Antidote to Poison None of Us Need Take | gadflyonthewallblog SAT Adversity Score is an Antidote to Poison None of Us Need Take Let’s say someone gave you a vial of poison. Would you drink it? Of course not. What if he gave you the antidote, too. Would you take the poison then? Heck no! Why would anyone knowingly ingest poison even if they knew they could counteract its
    Jersey Jazzman: NJ Public Workers' Health Benefits Are NOT Overly Generous: Some More Evidence
    Jersey Jazzman: NJ Public Workers' Health Benefits Are NOT Overly Generous: Some More Evidence NJ Public Workers' Health Benefits Are NOT Overly Generous: Some More Evidence Warning: This one's going to get wonky... The anti-public worker political wing in New Jersey -- which includes nearly all the state's Republicans and the machine Democrats -- spends a good part of its time trying to convince

    MAY 26

    Baker charter school backtracks after telling students they failed, needed to attend summer program
    Baker charter school backtracks after telling students they failed, needed to attend summer program Baker charter school backtracks after telling students they failed, needed to attend summer program BAKER, La. (WAFB) - Parents of students attending Advantage Charter Academy are fuming Friday night after being told their kids would be held back and would need to attend a 16-day summer school prog
    Michigan: President of State Board Explains Why It Declined to Spend $47 Million for New Charters | Diane Ravitch's blog
    Michigan: President of State Board Explains Why It Declined to Spend $47 Million for New Charters | Diane Ravitch's blog Michigan: President of State Board Explains Why It Declined to Spend $47 Million for New Charters Casandra E. Ulbrich, president of the Michigan State Board of Education, responded to an editorial in the Detroit News complaining that the State Board rejected $47 million for new
    CATCH UP WITH CURMUDGUCATION: + ICYMI: Memorial Day Weekend Edition (5/26)
    CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Memorial Day Weekend Edition (5/26) ICYMI: Memorial Day Weekend Edition (5/26) In my town, we do the whole parade and program in the park business tomorrow. But for today, here are some pieces to read and share. Did You See The Numbers? Yes, I Have. Is there a battle going on inside the NAACP over charters? Nope. Cloaking Inequality has the story. We're Already Losing the N
    Department of Education agenda: Reading, writing and religion | Salon.com
    Department of Education agenda: Reading, writing and religion | Salon.com Department of Education agenda: Reading, writing and religion Amid budget cuts, DeVos supports Christian bible classes in public schools The Trump administration has proposed a 12% cut in Department of Education spending under its yearly budget. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos is busily eliminating programs to help publi
    ‘Borderline criminal’: Many public schools teeter on the edge of decrepitude - The Washington Post
    ‘Borderline criminal’: Many public schools teeter on the edge of decrepitude - The Washington Post ‘Borderline criminal’: Many public schools teeter on the edge of decrepitude RICHMOND — Each morning for several years, Keri Treadway switched the classroom lights on and stomped loudly to frighten away the mice. She checked the sticky traps. She swabbed tables with disinfectant wipes and cleared dr
    Bill Phillis: Our Great American Public Schools Will Prevail | Diane Ravitch's blog
    Bill Phillis: Our Great American Public Schools Will Prevail | Diane Ravitch's blog Bill Phillis: Our Great American Public Schools Will Prevail A couple of weeks ago, Bill Phillis and I had a public dialogue in Columbus, Ohio. Bill has devoted his life to improving public education for all children. He has fought for equitable and adequate funding. Someone asked him, he said, when he would retir
    NYC Public School Parents: Warning: stand-alone field tests ahead & how you can support opt-out bills in Legislature
    NYC Public School Parents: Warning: stand-alone field tests ahead & how you can support opt-out bills in Legislature Warning: stand-alone field tests ahead & how you can support opt-out bills in Legislature Note: You can send letters to your state legislators in support of the Right to Opt Out of High-stake testing bills mentioned below, Senate bill S5394 and Assembly bill A7744 , with the help o
    Countering "Reform Nonsense" with Common Sense - Living in Dialogue
    Countering "Reform Nonsense" with Common Sense - Living in Dialogue Countering “Reform Nonsense” with Common Sense A Review of The Wisdom and Wit of Diane Ravitch By John Thompson. Part 1 of this review. Part 2 of this review. This post completes a three part series of reviews of The Wisdom and Wit of Diane Ravitch that seeks to hold both Diane Ravitch and corporate school reformers accountable f

    MAY 25

    Top Posts This Week 5/25/19 #REDFORED #CTA
    Big Education Ape Top Posts This Week 5/25/19 Why This Teacher Needs Jackie Goldberg on the School Board CATCH UP WITH CURMUDGUCATION: + ICYMI: Birthday Eve Edition (5/19) The Resegregation of Baton Rouge Public 





    Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running

    Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running

    Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running


    I can’t support us fixing computers and stuff for a charter school co-located with a district school that doesn’t have the same technology.”
    – Jackie Goldberg
    Backed by Jackie Goldberg’s overwhelming electoral victory, George McKenna and Scott Schmerelson revisited their motion from last August to temporarily appoint her to the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) Board Seat vacated by convicted felon Ref Rodriguezuntil the votes can be officially certified. Despite the fact that the Brown Act prohibits the Board from coordinating their actions outside of the public view, it appeared from the outset of the May 21st meeting that the decision had made in advance as Board President Monica Garcia had already given Goldberg a seat at the dais. However, the Board had to hear public comment before taking the official vote. This is what I had to say:


    It is great to be here on this exciting day with some positive change for once. I would just like to point out that this should have happened last August. There was no reason why the residents of Board District 5 should have been unrepresented for all of this time. But at least we are finally here.
    Jackie, welcome to the Board. I look forward to standing behind you CONTINUE READING: Jackie Goldberg Hits the LAUSD Board Running

    Seattle Schools Community Forum: Gay Pride Month Starts Today

    Seattle Schools Community Forum: Gay Pride Month Starts Today
    Gay Pride Month Starts Today

    The month of June was chosen for LGBT Pride Month to commemorate the Stonewall riots, which occurred at the end of June 1969. As a result, many pride events are held during this month to recognize the impact LGBT people have had in the world.


    From Nerd and Lace

    Whether in support of Gay Pride Month or just about being a parent, here's a great poem:



    Seattle Schools Community Forum: Gay Pride Month Starts Today

    Jersey Jazzman: NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately

    Jersey Jazzman: NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately

    NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately

    What follows is yet another year's worth of data analysis on New Jersey's student "growth" measure: Student Growth Percentiles (SGPs).

    And yet another year of my growing frustration and annoyance with the policymakers and pundits who insist on using these measures inappropriately, despite all the evidence.

    Because it's not like we haven't looked at this evidence before. Bruce Baker started back in 2013, when SGPs were first being used in making high-stakes decisions about schools and in teacher evaluations; he followed up with a more formal report later that year.

    Gerald Goldin, a professor emeritus at Rutgers, expressed his concerns back in 2016. I wrote about the problems with SGPs in 2018, including an open letter to members of the NJ Legislature.

    But here we are in 2019, and SGPs continue to be employed in assessments of school quality and in teacher evaluations. Yes, the weight of SGPs in a teacher's overall evaluation has been cut back significantly, down to 5 percent -- but it's still part of the overall score. And SGPs are still a big part of the NJDOE's School Performance Reports.

    So SGPs still matter, even though they have a clear and substantial flaw -- one acknowledged by their creator himself --  that renders them invalid for use in evaluating schools and teachers. As I wrote last year:


    It's a well-known statistical precept that variables measured with error tend to bias positive estimates in a regression model downward, thanks to something called attenuation bias. Plain English translation: Because test scores are CONTINUE READING: Jersey Jazzman: NJ's Student Growth Measures (SGPs): Still Biased, Still Used Inappropriately

    Charter Schools Conceived, Organized, and Imposed by the Rich | Dissident Voice

    Charter School Promoters Criticize and Complain About Charter Schools While Pushing For More Charter Schools | Dissident Voice

    Charter School Promoters Criticize and Complain About Charter Schools While Pushing For More Charter Schools



    The narrow aim of maximizing profit as fast as possible compels owners of capital to say and do whatever they have to to get richer, no matter how irrational and contradictory, and no matter the cost to society and the environment. Such an aim is irresponsible and outdated, and needs to be replaced by a human-centered aim that recognizes the need for a modern economy controlled by the working class and people themselves.
    The key distinction between class will and personal will is critical to appreciate here because it cuts through persistent confusion surrounding why major owners of capital do what they do. Individuals are not the only ones with a will. Social classes, as objective phenomena, also have their own will and dynamics. Focusing only on personal whims and intentions limits comprehension of social phenomena.
    Capital is first and foremost an unequal social relationship, not a person or a thing. Major owners of capital are the personification of capital, the embodiment of capital, also known as capital personified or capital incarnate.
    This theoretical insight is critical because it takes us away from the rabbit hole of personal intentions and personal will, and allows us instead to objectively locate greed, insecurity, inequality, poverty, unemployment, and other problems in the intrinsic built-in nature, logic, and movement of capital itself. Recognizing and grasping this shift from personal intentions to the internal core dynamics of capital itself is priceless.
    In short, the concept of individuals as the personification of economic categories helps us move beyond an individual’s personal ambitions and understand the bigger, broader, deeper reasons for unequal relations in society, that is, the structure of social relations under capital.
    As agents of capital, as bearers of specific class interests, major owners of capital cannot exist without constantly amassing socially-produced wealth. The singular aim of capital is to accumulate as much wealth as rapidly as possible,1 no matter how irrational and harmful the consequences are to the common good. Owners of capital will quickly go out of business if they fail to out-compete and out-profit other owners of capital.
    A violent dog-eat-dog world is not a mirage.
    Charter Schools Conceived, Organized, and Imposed by the Rich
    Charter schools were conceived, organized, and promoted with impunity by wealthy individuals, organizations, and corporations, not grass-roots forces, more than 30 years ago. The idea of chartering was discussed even before CONTINUE READING: Charter School Promoters Criticize and Complain About Charter Schools While Pushing For More Charter Schools | Dissident Voice

    CURMUDGUCATION: NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education

    CURMUDGUCATION: NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education

    NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education

    New Hampshire's education commissioner has decided to push a really terrible education idea. It's called "Learn Everywhere," and it looks like a new approach to replacing public education, a kind of true backdoor approach to vouchering. It comes dressed in pretty language, but it still smells like a recently fertilized field on a warm summer day.


    Frank Edelblut was a businessman, venture capitalist, and one-term NH state representative before he decided to run for the governor's seat. He was beaten in the primary by Chris Sununu, son of former NH governor and Bush I White House Chief of Staff John Sununu (full disclosure: my grandmother was a NH GOP representative for decades, including under John Sununu, and she did not have a very high opinion of him). Edelblut gracefully conceded and publicly supported Sununu, who then appointed Edelblut to the top education job, despite Edelblut's complete lack of anything remotely resembling education experience.

    All of Edelblut's children were home schooled. As a legislator, he backed vouchers and as a candidate he backed personalized [sic] learning. Sununu said that the homeschooling was a plus because it meant Edelblut understood alternative methods of education. The state board of CONTINUE READING: 
    CURMUDGUCATION: NH: Outsourcing and Privatizing Public Education


    National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading | Diane Ravitch's blog

    National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading | Diane Ravitch's blog

    National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading


    Bruce Baker of Rutgers University reviewed three policy briefs produced by the pro-charter, pro-choice Center for Reinventing Public Education at the University of Washington and found them to be “generally superficial and misleading.” The apparent intent of these briefs was to influence the policy debate in California, in which Governor Newsom and the Legislature are considering whether to take into account the fiscal impact of charters on public schools. Baker’s review was sponsored by the National Education Policy Center at the University of Colorado.
    Reviewed by Bruce D. Baker University of Colorado Boulder May 2019
    Executive Summary
    The Center on Reinventing Public Education (CRPE), based at the University of Washington, Bothell, recently released a series of three policy briefs on the financial impact of charter schools on nearby school districts in California. The briefs arrive at a time when a Task Force convened by California Gov. Gavin Newsom is deliberating on these exact matters. CRPE’s founder, Paul Hill, was a key source of testimony to the task force, serving as an expert viewed as “sympathetic to charter schools.”
    The three briefs make note of the task force in their introduction and are seemingly intended to inform these ongoing debates over charter school financing and expansion in the state of California. The briefs are as follows.
    • The first brief, Charter Schools and District Enrollment Loss, posits that charter school enrollment growth is not a significant factor in large district enrollment decline in California.
    • The second brief, Do Charter Schools Cause Fiscal Distress in School Districts?, argues that charter school expansion is not a significant contributor to fiscal distress (fiscal stress and/or fiscal impact) in California school districts.
    • The final brief, Do the Costs of California Charter Schools Outweigh the Benefits?, contends that there are “tangible benefits” and “few quantifiable costs” to charter schooling in California, though it does concede that a more thorough cost-benefit analysis is warranted.
    The first brief acknowledges that over the long run, California charter school expansion has resulted in some district enrollment decline. But the brief contends that this decline has been modest and in recent years is no longer occurring. Further, the report asserts that whether charter schools expand or not, many districts will face continuing enrollment decline and “the financial challenges it brings” (p. 10).
    The second brief lays out a set of figures showing charter school enrollment shares and comparing this to county-assigned classifications of district fiscal distress. It concludes boldly that (a) there is no relationship between charter enrollment share and host district fiscal distress; (b) instead, fiscal distress is most often caused by financial mismanagement; and (c) fiscal distress is too important to get wrong.
    The third brief first asserts that there are benefits to, but few if any tangible costs associated with, charter schooling in California. Those benefits are illustrated by reports of differences in test score gains for children in some urban California charter schools versus matched peers in host districts. The brief also cites a handful of studies to support its contention that charter expansion also benefits, or at least does not harm, children in host district schools. Finally, it notes other potential benefits for children enrolled in charter schools, for which quantifiable values are more difficult to assign, including: “The option to choose” (p. 4).
    On the potential-costs side of charter expansion, the third brief provides a short list, including, (a) lacking/losing economies of scale, (b) transfers/fiscal impact, (c) capital costs, (d) educating high-cost students, and (e) social cohesion and societal concerns. The authors then dismiss these five concerns, offering the conclusion that there are “few quantifiable costs to charter schooling” in California (p. 6). Yet they provide little analysis or reference to any valid, rigorous analysis by any other researchers.
    Robin Lake, Ashley Jochim, Paul Hill, and Sivan Tuchman wrote these briefs and qualify their work with identical wording: “Given the time constraints for informing the commis- sion’s and legislator’s questions, we were limited to data available from earlier studies and from federal, state, and local databases, as cited in the three briefs” (p. 2 of each brief).
    These limitations did impair the usefulness of the briefs, but other problems are also evi- dent. The first brief is misleading in its assertion that charter enrollment growth is not to blame for district enrollment decline. It is, and has been for some time, whether in districts with declining, stable or growing overall student enrollments. The brief also attempts to minimize the import of the considerable role played by charters in districts’ enrollment loss, offering up the non sequitur that enrollment loss can arise from other sources as well. The second brief relies on overly simplistic comparisons of charter enrollments and county-assigned “fiscal distress” classifications to conclude that there is no association between charter enrollments and fiscal distress. The contention here is that there can’t be an illness if the patient isn’t dead. In order to rely on this problematic approach, the brief erroneously dismisses a significant, more rigorous, detailed, peer-reviewed and published body of research that illustrates the fiscal impact of charter schools on host districts, and how those fiscal impacts may lead to fiscal stress. The third brief, which presents itself as an analysis of costs and benefits, merely touts the benefits of charter schooling as tangible while being entirely dismissive of numerous known and often measurable costs. Taken together, the briefs are useful only in pointing to some important issues that policymakers should consider; their analyses of those issues are, however, generally superficial and misleading.National Education Policy Center Reviews Claims about Fiscal Impact of Charters and Finds Them Shallow and Misleading | Diane Ravitch's blog


    NEPC Review: California Charter Schools: Costs, Benefits, and Impact on School Districts (Center on Reinventing Public Education, May 2019) | National Education Policy Center - https://nepc.colorado.edu/node/9821 on @NEPCtweet


    CURMUDGUCATION: Rewarding Failing Schools

    CURMUDGUCATION: Rewarding Failing Schools

    Rewarding Failing Schools

    One of the problems with the business oriented view of education reveals itself in the use of the word "reward."

    As long as the debate has raged, we can find commentators, thinky tanks, and policy makers arguing that giving more resources to struggling schools is "rewarding" them for failure. (Here's an example, and here's another.) For many folks, this seems simple and straightforward, but it's really not.


    Imagine two small children. Pat is growing up in a poor home and not receiving the kind of food necessary to thrive. Chris is growing up in a wealthy home and gets all the food and nutrition necessary to do well. Chris is big and strong, well at the top of the charts for growth. Pat is thin and emaciated, near the bottom of the chart for growth.

    Let's imagine a government program for distributing food to families of young children. Who would like to argue that Pat should not get any of this food because it would just be rewarding Pat for failing to grow big and strong?

    For some folks, it seems impossible to view money as anything other than revenue. In business, money is your reward for doing a good job. That's the whole point.

    But (at the risk of repeating myself) public schools are not businesses. They do not generate revenue. They do not produce a profit. And money is not a reward; it's a resource.

    This idea hurts some people's heads. Health care and public education have always treated money mainly as a resource, something you spend in order to take care of people. Yes, there have been plenty of money-related arguments in public education, but they are virtually all (including teacher CONTINUE READING: 
    CURMUDGUCATION: Rewarding Failing Schools


    Michigan: State Attorney General Will Take a Position Opposite to the Governor in Detroit Literacy Lawsuit | Diane Ravitch's blog

    Michigan: State Attorney General Will Take a Position Opposite to the Governor in Detroit Literacy Lawsuit | Diane Ravitch's blog

    Michigan: State Attorney General Will Take a Position Opposite to the Governor in Detroit Literacy Lawsuit


    Now, this gets interesting.
    Two days ago, I posted about the battle in Michigan over who is responsible for the deplorable conditions in the public schools of Detroit. Critics claimed that Governor Whitmer was abandoning her campaign promises.
    The new Democratic Governor Whitmer disappointed some supporters by asserting that the state was not responsible for the miseducation of the children of Detroit, although Detroit has been under state control for nearly 20 years.
    Mackinac Island — Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel said she will file in opposition to the governor’s position in a lawsuit alleging that the state deprived Detroit students of their right to literacy due to deplorable conditions at the facilities and dwindling numbers of teachers and textbooks.
    At the Mackinac Policy Conference Wednesday, Nessel told The Detroit News that while her office has a duty to represent the governor she also is an independently elected official with an obligation to represent the people of the state of Michigan.
    She intends to file parens patriae, or on behalf of the residents of Michigan, “to do what I think is best for them personally.”
    Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Friday argued in a response to the lawsuit filed by the attorney general’s office that because Detroit schools have been returned to local control the state should not be subject to the lawsuit..

    My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers - Teacher Habits

    My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers - Teacher Habits

    My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers


    I had the pleasure yesterday of serving on my school’s interview team for a third grade position. Five candidates, four of whom just finished their student teaching and one of whom has five years of teaching experience, competed for the job. They each taught a 15-minute lesson and answered questions for a half-hour. Here are five thoughts:

    Our kids are in good hands

    I’ve been on interview committees a few times before and I am always impressed by the quality of the candidates. While the data says that our “best and brightest” are going into other fields, I’m forced to take issue with their criteria. These are high-quality people who are signing up for a difficult job because they want to make a difference and help kids. With teacher strikes, social media, a Secretary of Education who’s hostile to public schools, and teacher resignation letters regularly going viral, no one goes into education today ignorant of the challenges. These people are signing up anyway. The banks can have the valedictorians; I’ll take the idealists.
    It’s a limited sample size, but the young people who are becoming teachers today seem better trained than those with whom I competed almost 20 years ago. Frankly, just-out-of-college me would not compare favorably to the current just-out-college teachers-to-be, with their higher-than-mine GPAs, overseas teaching experiences, and CONTINUE READING: My Day Observing and Interviewing Young Teachers - Teacher Habits

    Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE?

    Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE?

    Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE?

    You can’t change it without us re-voting.= LAUSD Board Member Richard VladovicThat is correct.– LAUSD General Counsel David Holmquist
    Los Angeles students are in desperate need of the funds promised from Measure EE. As noted by Dr. Rocio Rivas, “California ranks 43rd in per-pupil spending with an investment of less than $11,000 per student, which is below the national average of approximately $12,526. In addition, California is ranked 48th in class size.” As a comparison, in the 2014–15 school year, New York state spent $20,744 per student. Unable to rely on the state or federal governments to help properly fund our education system, Los Angeles must look to fixing the problem ourselves by passing the parcel tax.
    Despite being the direct beneficiaries of a well-educated workforce, there are members of the business community who are unwilling to make this investment. As of today, they have spent $1,350,261 to fund opposition to Measure EE. These interests support the status quo where class sizes are above what is recommended by experts, school nurses are in short supply and libraries are subject to closure.


    In the event that Measure EE falls short of the two-thirds majority it needs to pass, the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) Superintendent Austin Beutner has delivered his corporate allies a CONTINUE READING: Did Austin Beutner Sabotage Measure EE?



    “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors | The Merrow Report

    “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors | The Merrow Report

    “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors
    “Charter School” is a vague descriptive term, akin to “Restaurant,”  in that neither term tells you very much. One of them, however, is dangerously vague.
    “Restaurant” is vague but not dangerous.  The word tells you only that the establishment serves food of some kind, but nothing else. It might offer great cuisine–or greasy slop.  It might be a fast-food joint or a 3-Star Michelin legend with a 6-month waiting list for a reservation.   And, if you do go there for a meal, that’s the extent of your obligation.  If it’s bad, you can get up from the table and leave….
    So, now imagine you are standing outside a building sporting a sign reading “Charter School.”   All you can discern from the term is that it’s one of about 7,000 publicly funded but privately managed charter schools.   And the possibilities of what that charter school might be are dizzying.  Here are just some of them:
    1. It might be part of a national chain of schools or a stand-alone “Mom and Pop” school;
    2. It might have been authorized locally or set up by a distant authority (which may not be keeping its eye on things);
    3. It might have a Board of Directors made up of local parents and other residents, or it could be controlled from afar by a Board with no local representation whatsoever;
    4. It might have an admissions test, even though it is supposedly a public school, CONTINUE READING: “Restaurant” & “Charter School” Are Vague Descriptors | The Merrow Report



    End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling

    End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling

    End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling

    It’s time to end the charter school experiment.
    Put successful charters under the supervision of the nearby school district. Charters not working well should close. No charter school should get tax dollars without oversight. This should be for both for-profit and nonprofit charter schools.
    Charter School Scandals
    On twitter, educators and parents can follow the Network of Public Education’s (NPE) #AnotherDayAnotherCharterScandal. Executive Director Carol Burris and her team also have several reports outlining how taxpayers lose their money to corruption involving charter schools.
    More recently Burris and Jeff Bryant provided a new NPE report “Asleep at the Wheel: How the Federal Charter Schools Program Recklessly Takes Taxpayers and Students for A Ride” showing more proof that this nation wastes money on corrupt charter schools.
    It is appalling we permit these schools to run without oversight.
    A Recent Charter School Scandal
    In California, eleven people responsible for an online charter school serving students in 13 charter schools were recently indicted on criminal charges of conspiracy. They put the money into their bank accounts instead of the schools! It looks like A3 Education bilked the public $50 million.
    As this scandal continues to unfold, somewhere in California’s public schools, teachers CONTINUE READING: End Charter Schools! Consider Creative Ways to Address Schooling