Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, February 1, 2019

Jack Schneider: Betsy DeVos Should Stop Making Stuff Up About America’s Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog

Jack Schneider: Betsy DeVos Should Stop Making Stuff Up About America’s Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog

Jack Schneider: Betsy DeVos Should Stop Making Stuff Up About America’s Schools



Schneider offers a capsule of education history and concludes:
“When critics contend that America’s public schools are preparing students for the jobs of the past, they are engaging in a kind of rhetorical feint. The implication is that today’s students are already being trained for work, and that such a focus has always been an aim of schooling. It suggests that vocational training is something that Americans broadly agree upon, and that is simply in need of an update.
“In reality, workforce preparation would represent a significant shift in the mission of schools. President Donald Trump made this shift plain in 2018 when he unveiled a plan to combine the Department of Education with the Department of Labor into a new agency called the Department of Education and the Workforce. (There seems to be little movement on the proposal since it was announced.)
“Jobs certainly matter, and the future labor productivity of today’s students will impact the entire economy. Yet even if schools could be reoriented to focus effectively on job training, the result would hardly be an unqualified good. Any shift in the present orientation of schools will come at the expense of school activities organized around the preservation of rights and liberties, as well as the inherent value of education. By and large, Americans of the past were unwilling to make that trade-off. If they’re aware of what’s happening, Americans of the present may be no different.”
in the past, vocational training was often designed to prepare students for occupations that would soon be obsolete.
As a basic rule of thumb, never believe anything DeVos says. If she is not lying, she simply speaks from ignorance. Her knowledge of the real world is very limited.Jack Schneider: Betsy DeVos Should Stop Making Stuff Up About America’s Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog


Tennessee: Is This Possible?
Blogger Andy Spears reports that an admitted sex offender in the legislature has a key role in shaping education policy. He wrote: Yesterday, the House Education Administration Subcommittee met for the first time. The meeting was the first chaired by admitted sex offender David Byrd. Readers will recall that while both former House Speaker Beth Harwell and current Lt. Governor Randy McNally calle
Dutch Historian Tells Davos Elite That Biggest World Problem is Failure of Rich to Pay Taxes
Dutch historian Rutger Bergman stunned the super-elite at the World Economic Forum at Davos by telling them that the biggest problem in the world today is the refusal of the richest to pay their fair share of taxes. He said that listening totheir discussions was akin to a fireman’s conference that never mentioned water. He became an instant folk hero for his bold truth telling. Davos is an annual
Jack Schneider: Betsy DeVos Should Stop Making Stuff Up About America’s Schools
Jack Schneider, historian of education, urges Betsy DeVos to stop telling lies about our nation’s schools. Schneider offers a capsule of education history and concludes: “When critics contend that America’s public schools are preparing students for the jobs of the past, they are engaging in a kind of rhetorical feint. The implication is that today’s students are already being trained for work, an
Michigan: Education Funding Declined More Than Any Other State in 25 Years
The DeVos Plan is working! Education funding in Michigan declined more in the past 25 years than in any other state. Charters and choice were a substitute for funding. Michigan’s NAEP scores dropped from the middle of the pack to the bottom 10. DeVos and the Koch brothers will destroy American education if allowed to continue, and they do so with the help of Bill Gates, Eli Broad, Arne Duncan, An

YESTERDAY

Dallas: Reporter Seeks Information about “Social Impact Bonds”
A reporter in Dallas wants to know why social impact bonds are a bad idea. Or if they are a good idea. Please write him. brett@brettshippmedia.com
Nevada Chief Resigns, after Failure as Charter Cheerleader
Nevada’s State Commissioner Steve Canavero and two of his deputies are leaving. “Nevada’s K-12 system consistently ranks as one of the worst-performing in the nation, according to NAEP scores and Education Week ‘s Quality Counts. This has frustrated state and local politicians, technocrats and practitioners and led to a series of ambitious efforts over the years to improve the system. “Canavero,
Kansas: Students Walk Out to Protest Tech-Based Summit Learning Program
Mark Zuckerberg and the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative funded the Summit learning program, which is computer-based online instruction. not personalized learning. Students in Kansas sent a message to Zuckerberg: Another student #walkout vs #SummitLearning – this time at McPherson MS in Kansas. Like earlier one in Brooklyn, protest was sparked by students’ frustrations about inadequacies of the online
Justin Parmenter: School Choice in North Carolina
Justin Parmenter, an NBCT high school teacher in North Carolina, writes here about the rapid expansion of charter schools in his state, which is doing serious damage to public schools. Charters were not promoted in North Carolina but by Tea Party Republicans who want to destroy public schools and make money. Charter schools are playing a damaging role in North Carolina, acting as a vehicle for re
Washington State: Charters Fail to Make a Difference
“ Poor Bill Gates. He has poured billions into reinventing education, and nothing has worked. Nothing! Not even in his home state. One of his fondest desires was to open charter schools in Washington State. He poured millions into a referendum (the fourth in the state), and it barely passed. Then the highest court in the state said the charters couldn’t be supported by the general fund, because t
West Virginia: Governor Refuses to Add Charter Schools to Pay Increases
Republican legislators in West Virginia want to tie pay increases for teachers—which they were promised when they went on strike last year—to the introduction of charter schools and vouchers. They think that school choice will 

Trump Endorses Teaching Religion in the Public Schools. What Can He Be Thinking? | janresseger

Trump Endorses Teaching Religion in the Public Schools. What Can He Be Thinking? | janresseger

Trump Endorses Teaching Religion in the Public Schools. What Can He Be Thinking?


In the Washington PostJohn Wagner reports that legislators in six states—North Dakota, Missouri, Indiana, West Virginia, Virginia, and Florida—have introduced bills to permit public schools to teach the Bible as literature.  President Donald Trump endorsed this effort last week in a tweet: “Numerous states introducing Bible Literacy classes, giving students the option of studying the Bible.  Starting to make a turn back?  Great!”
The President advocates teaching about the Bible to “make a turn back”—to Make America Great Again.  He wants to appeal to his base.
I suspect the promoters of teaching “about the Bible” also have something else in mind.  Their purpose is obscured by some vague language that very likely tries to hide a violation of the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.  Some promoters of the “teach about the Bible” movement describe wanting their schools to teach Biblical literacy, and some say they are interested in “teaching about the historical significance of the Bible.”  What is implied here can mean very different things to different people.

For 12 years before my retirement, when I worked as an advocate for public education in the setting of the national office of a Protestant denomination, the United Church of Christ, I chaired the Committee on Public Education and Literacy of the National Council of Churches.  The National Council of Churches is an ecumenical partnership of 38 Christian communions in the United States.
During those 12 years, I remember only one intense, heated discussion that ran our committee’s meeting long past the time we were supposed to have concluded.  We had been asked to read and review a lavishly illustrated and expensively produced textbook, supposedly to be used in public schools to teach about the Bible as literature. The book also covered what its authors considered “the historical significance of the Bible.”
The amazing thing about that long and very heated meeting was that we all agreed.  Every one of us believed that the textbook in question should never be used in a public school. And, as CONTINUE READING: Trump Endorses Teaching Religion in the Public Schools. What Can He Be Thinking? | janresseger



Remember the 2018 teachers strikes in Republican-led states? Now legislators in 3 states are trying to retaliate. - The Washington Post

Remember the 2018 teachers strikes in Republican-led states? Now legislators in 3 states are trying to retaliate. - The Washington Post

Remember the 2018 teachers strikes in Republican-led states? Now legislators in 3 states are trying to retaliate.



Remember the 2018 teachers strikes in Republican-led states that captured the attention of the country?
The Red For Ed — or #RedForEd — movement started when West Virginia teachers who were sick and tired of working for low pay and in resource-starved schools walked out of class even though such labor action is illegal in the state. The teachers started the strikes, and their unions followed.
Teachers in other red states saw what was happening and decided to do something exceedingly rare for teachers — stand up for themselves — and they struck, too, in Oklahoma, Arizona, Colorado and other places, and managed to win financial concessions from state legislators.
Now, in three of those states, Republican-led legislatures are retaliating, trying to pass bills that would make teachers' working lives more difficult. Here’s what’s happening:
West Virginia
More than 22,000 West Virginia teachers walked out en masse on Feb. 22, 2018, closing schools in every county for the first time in nearly 30 years. They demanded higher pay and lower health-care costs in a place where many teachers have had to take second jobs to pay their bills.
With the state ranking 48th in average teacher salaries in 2016, according to National Education Association data, legislators finally agreed to a 5 percent pay raise — less than the teachers were seeking — while offering no promise on relief for health-care costs. The teachers returned to class March 7.
West Virginia legislators are taking steps that teachers strongly oppose. In a budget bill the legislature is fast-tracking, teacher raises and funding for the health-care system for state employees would be tied to provisions including:
  • Increasing class sizes.
  • Denying pay during future strikes.
  • Support for “school choice” in the form of charter schools and a program to use public money for private and religious-school education. 
The state’s Republican governor, Jim Justice, who opposed last year’s strike, said he would veto such a bill, but that won’t stop the legislature from trying.
Oklahoma
Oklahoma teachers walked out April 2 demanding higher pay and more resources for schools in a state where tax cuts have slashed public spending on education. They returned to class 10 days later after winning raises and additional school funding, but did not win everything they wanted. Some teachers opposed ending the CONTINUE READING: Remember the 2018 teachers strikes in Republican-led states? Now legislators in 3 states are trying to retaliate. - The Washington Post

Congress: Stand up and say, "I'm public school proud!" - Network For Public Education

Congress: Stand up and say, "I'm public school proud!" - Network For Public Education

Congress: Stand up and say, “I’m public school proud!”


The second annual Public Schools Week will take place from March 25 – March 29.  Now is the time to motivate your representative and ask her or him to stand up and say,  “I am proud of my public schools.”
Here is a first request. Ask that they sign on to this resolution that declares March 25-29 Public Schools Week.
Make that request by clicking here.
In the weeks to come, we will share more ways in which you can spread the word about Public Schools Week and let the nation know you are #PublicSchoolProud! And feel free to download the Congressional resolution and use it as a model for your local school board or government to pass.

MARLA KILFOYLE JOINS THE NPE STAFF
The Network for Public Education is delighted that Marla Kilfoyle  has joined our staff as our NPE Grassroots Liaison. Marla was a public school teacher for 30 years who taught in rural, urban, and suburban communities. A National Board Certified Teacher, Marla was the first educator to be honored as a Finkelstein Memorial Lecturer at Adelphi University because of her commitment to advocacy for public education. Marla also co-authored an Amicus Brief filed in the Supreme Court for Friedrichs vs. CTA and was honored by the NYS Assembly in 2012 as a Woman of Distinction.
She served as the Executive Director of The Badass Teachers Association (BATs) from 2013-2018 and she was on the Steering Committee for the New York State Allies for Public Education from 2014-2018. Throughout her teaching career in the Oceanside, New York School District she held many elected positions in her union.  
Marla has published over 50 articles defending public school teachers, appearing as an advocate for public education on both television and radio. In the coming days, Marla will be reaching out to all of our groups in the Grassroots Network to introduce herself and to find out how to better engage and support Network members. Her extraordinary talents as an organizer will strengthen the service we provide to our Grassroots Education Network, help new groups form, and allow the entire network to expand.
If you know of a Grassroots group that is not part of the network, please complete or forward the form on this link and Marla will be in touch!
NEXT WEEK IS BLACK LIVES MATTER AT SCHOOLS WEEK

Educators from around the nation have joined together to announce the second annual national “Black Lives Matter at School” week of action, which will take place from February 4-8.
To learn more about Black Lives Matter at School and how you can participate, go here and watch and share the video below.





From participating in Public Schools Week, to building our grassroots, to supporting the excellent video above, NPE relies on YOUR generous donations. Please give generously online here or by mail to:
Network for Public Education
PO Box 227
New York, New York 10156
Your donations are tax deductible.
Congress: Stand up and say, "I'm public school proud!" - Network For Public Education

Thursday, January 31, 2019

The Deported Americans — The California Sunday Magazine

The Deported Americans — The California Sunday Magazine

The Deported Americans
More than 600,000 U.S.-born children of undocumented parents live in Mexico. What happens when you return to a country you’ve never known?



The school day at Escuela Secundaria TĆ©cnica NĆŗmero 26 starts early. As the first rays of sunshine make their way over the foothills of PopocatĆ©petl volcano in central Mexico, the narrow streets fill with students in ones and twos and little laughing groups.
Ashley Mantilla’s day starts earlier than most. On a Monday last June, long before the sun rose, the 15-year-old left the small cinder-block house she shares with her sister, brother, and parents. She walked past the lime tree under which the family entertains guests, past the outhouse and the thin horse tied up next to her grandparents’ home, to the road that winds by a deep ravine, and into the center of her small town, perched high in the ridges below the volcano. There, she waited for a minibus that would drive her half an hour to NĆŗmero 26. It’s not a cheap trip to make every day, and her parents are willing to pay for it not because they have extra money but because they think it’s a better option than the local school. There are real teachers there instead of video lessons, and specialty classes include coding in addition to agriculture, food preservation, and beekeeping.
By 7:30, the school’s courtyard was packed with teenagers. They lined up in straight rows and placed their hands across their chests as the Mexican national anthem played on a loudspeaker. Ashley had PE that day, so she had her dark hair pulled back and was wearing her gym uniform: track pants and a polo shirt embroidered with the words NiƱos HĆ©roes, or heroic children, a group of historical figures that the school honors as a kind of mascot. The heroes were six military cadets, the youngest of them 13, who died defending a castle in Mexico City from American invaders in 1847.
It was, in other words, a long way from the school days Ashley used to experience, back when she was an American student growing up in an American town and studying in an American public school. In those days, her father, Felix, worked as a cook in a restaurant and did maintenance on CONTINUE READING: The Deported Americans — The California Sunday Magazine



President Franklin D Roosevelt: The standard of education between the richest communities and the poorest communities

Eleanor Roosevelt Introduces the President | American RadioWorks |

Eleanor Roosevelt Introduces the President

This audio is part of the larger project The First Family of Radio: Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt’s Historic Broadcasts. You can download the entire radio hour from our podcast feed (iTunes).
June 30, 1938
Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt were frequently on the radio on the same day, but virtually never appeared on the same broadcast. One rare exception was the closing address FDR made at the 1938 National Education Association convention in New York. The presidential entourage arrived behind schedule so ER kept her remarks brief. FDR commented on the novelty of being introduced by the first lady. -Stephen Smith

Transcript

ELEANOR ROOSEVELT: I know that it is the privilege of a presiding officer to make speeches in introducing each speaker. We are late today, and so I am not going to avail myself of that privilege. Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the president of the United States.
[Applause]
FRANKLIN ROOSEVELT: Dr. Woodruff, Members of the National Education Association:
I am glad to come here today to this great meeting, and I am especially happy that I think for the first time in my life, I was introduced by my wife.
[Laughter and applause]
If you have followed the arguments of financial experts over the last few years, you have guessed that they have as many theories of keeping books as there are ends to serve. They do not always agree on the definition of capital, and they even disagree on what is an asset and what is a liability. And that is true both in private business and in government.
But whatever differences bookkeepers and financiers may have over the rules of their professions, no man or woman of common sense can forget, or allow government to forget, what are the true and ultimate assets and liabilities of a nation.
The only real capital of a nation is its natural resources and its human beings. So long as we take care of and make the most of both of them, we shall survive as a strong nation, a successful nation and a progressive nation—whether or not the bookkeepers say other kinds of budgets are from time to time out of balance.
This capital structure—natural resources and human beings—has to be maintained at all times. The plant has to be kept up and new capital put in year by year to meet increasing needs. If we skimp on that capital, if we exhaust our natural resources and weaken the capacity of our human beings, then we shall go the way of all weak nations.
Before we can think straight as a people we have to consider, in addition to the old kind, a new kind of government balance sheet—a long-range sheet which shows survival values for our population and for our democratic way of living, balanced against what we have paid for them. Judged by that test—history’s test—I venture to say that the long-range budget of the present Administration of our government has been in the black and not in the red.
[Applause]
For many years I, like you, have been a pedagogue, of course some people who are not over strong arm spelling, will get that word mixed up with the word a demagogue.
[Laughter]
And as a pedagogue, I have been striving to inculcate in the youth of America a greater knowledge of and interest in the problems which, with such force, strike the whole world in the face today. In these recent years we have taught the prudent husbandry of our national estate—our rivers, our soil, our forests, our phosphates, our oils, our minerals and our wild life. Along these lines we have made mighty strides—come further than in all the years before in knowledge of how to grapple with the problems.
With the dissemination of this knowledge, we have taken action. Few men begrudge what that action has cost, because it has been based on operations physically large and spectacular, dramatic and easy to see. I am thankful that I live in an age of building, for it is far easier to dramatize to yourself the importance of the object if you see it while it is going up, than if you come along later and see it only in its completed stage. And so we are fortunate today in seeing the New York World’s Fair of 1939 in the construction stage. This glimpse will make it mean more to us when we come back and see it completed next year.
The other half of the preservation of our national capital is likewise a problem of husbandry—the conserving of health, energy, skill and morale of our population, and especially of that part of our population which will be the America of tomorrow.
This also is a problem of the fullest use, the fullest development of our precious resources of ability, human ability that cannot be stored and will be lost if they remain unused. No nation can meet this changing world unless its people, individually and collectively, grow in ability to understand, ability to handle the new knowledge as applied to increasingly intricate human relationships. That is why the teachers of America are the ultimate guardians of the human capital of America, the assets which must be made to pay social dividends if democracy is to survive.
We have believed, we have believed wholeheartedly in investing the money of the people, the money of all the people in the education of the people.
[Light applause]
That conviction, backed up by taxes and backed by dollars, is no accident, for it is the logical application of our faith in democracy.
Man’s present day control of the affairs of nature is the very direct result of investment in education. And the democratization of education has made it possible for outstanding ability, which would otherwise be completely lost, to make its outstanding contribution to the commonweal. So we cannot afford to overlook any source of human raw material. Genius, genius flowers in most unexpected places. “It is the impetus of the undistinguished host that hurls forth a Diomed or a Hector.”
No government can create the human touch, the human self-sacrifice which the individual teacher gives to the process of education. But what Government can do is to provide financial support and to protect from interference the freedom to learn.
[Applause]
No one wants the Federal Government to subsidize education any more than is absolutely necessary. It has been and I take it it will continue to be the traditional policy of the United States to leave the actual management of schools and their curricula to state and local control.
[Applause]
But we know that in many places local government unfortunately cannot adequately finance either the freedom or the facilities to learn. And there the Federal Government can properly supplement local resources.
[Applause]
Here is where the whole problem of education ties in definitely with the natural resources of the country, ties in with the economic picture of the individual community or state. We all know that the best of schools are, in most cases, located in those communities which can afford to spend the most money on them—the most money for adequate teachers’ salaries, for modern buildings and modern equipment of all kinds. And we know too that the weakest educational link in our national system lies in those communities which have the lowest taxable values, and, therefore, the smallest per capita tax receipts and, therefore, the lowest teachers’ salaries and most inadequate buildings and equipment. We do not blame these latter communities. They want better educational facilities, but simply have not enough money to pay the cost.
There is probably a wider divergence today in the standard of education between the richest communities and the poorest communities than there was a century ago; and it is, therefore, our immediate task to seek to close that gap—
[Applause]
Not to close it in any way by decreasing the facilities of the richer communities but by extending aid to those less fortunate. We all know that if we do not close this gap it will continue to widen, for the best brains in the poorer communities will either have no chance to develop or will migrate to those places where their ability will stand a better chance.
To continue that parallel between natural and human resources, it is well to remember that our poorest communities exist where the land is most greatly eroded, where farming does not pay, where industries have moved out, where flood and drought have done their work, where transportation facilities are of the poorest and where cheap electricity is unavailable CONTINUE READING: Eleanor Roosevelt Introduces the President | American RadioWorks |