Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, August 2, 2014

8-2-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum Week

Seattle Schools Community Forum:



Seattle Schools Community Forum



Another Perspective on Seattle Superintendent/School Board Relationship
A thoughtful piece from Northwest Progressive Institute by Robert Cruickshank about the ever-popular issue of departing superintendents.  The real story, the one the Seattle Times does not want to tell for fear of undermining their anti-democratic agenda, is one of repeated mismanagement by a succession of superintendents and of a central staff that is unresponsive or overtly hostile to the board

Education Reform vs. education reform
The back and forth in the comments section of a Seattle Times story about Teachers United got me thinking about the difference between Education Reform and education reform. I don't know if I have written this out before, but I feel a need to write it out now.The goals of many of the millionaire- and billionaire-funded Education Reform Organizations are focused on either reducing the cost of educa

Garfield Field Trip Rape; More Troubling Info
I myself have not spoken with the family of the victim but Charlie has and believes the sincerity of their story.  I see now at their Facebook page -Stop Sexual Assault in High School - that the district is trying to shape the narrative of this incident.Here's what the family says has happened recently:-  Yesterday, the District wrote it was sending out the parents' Oct. 18, '13 response to the Di

Seattle Compassionate Schools Movement
Just heard about this event:From Sandy Hook to Seattle: Building the Compassionate Schools MovementMonday, August 11th - 7 pm-9 pm - $10Tuesday, August 12th - 8 am-4 pm - $20Cleveland High School, 5511 15th Avenue S. Register here. Following the tragedy in Newtown, CT, Dr. Christopher Kukk and Scarlett Lewis, mother of 6-year old Jesse Lewis, began work to weave compassion into schools. They met
Brown is the New Rhee
Move over, Michelle Rhee - here comes Campbell Brown.Did you hear about this?Rhee's star is waning. Her StudentsFirst group has closed up shop in about five states and the billion dollars she was hoping to raise didn't materialize. Well, nature abhors a vacuum and so we have former CNN anchor, Campbell Brown. This newest ed reformer on the block is going after the teachers union and, in specific,
Friday Open Thread
Welcome to August - it's nice to still have a lovely summer.I note that SPS is still looking for an Enrollment and Planning Services director.  I was a bit startled that the salary is much lower than for an Executive Director (considering how important this job is). Very entertaining interview with Project Runway's Tim "Make it Work" Gunn on mentoring in the NY Times.  Last fall, in an i

JUL 31

Stritikus Steps Down
Tom Stritikus announced that he is resigning his position as the Dean of the UW College of Education to accept a position with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.Here is his message to COE students and staff:Dear Students: I am writing to inform you that I will step down from the Deanship of the College of Education in early September. I’ve shared this news with Provost Cauce who is working on
"Do We Really Have a Problem Without a Solution"
(I'm hoping this will be a multi-part thread about public education in this country, where we are, where we are going and what should/could change.) I come to this thread thinking of two different things that really have nothing (but really everything) to do with public education. One is a song by the late Waylon Jennings (a great country/western singer) called Luckenbach, Texas.  In it, he is sin

JUL 30

Public Education News Roundup
In the "wait, what?!" category comes this story from the Washington Post's Answer Sheet - School puts nearly 100 kindergartners in one class in a teaching experiment.  The first sentence in the article says "no, it's not a headline from The Onion."  This is being tried at the lowest-performing school in Detroit.  There are three teachers in the class.Incidentally, the lead teac
Seattle Schools Updates
Further Update:  I asked about Seattle School District's request for a district waiver for NCLB.  (Banda did this back in early July.)  I hadn't heard anything and Communications says time is running out for waivers so an answer will likely come in the next week or so.  I doubt if the district will get it but if they did, that would be good news.)Update:- also Dr Nyland is working this week.  It i
An Alternative Narrative on Turnover
The Seattle Times likes to peddle this story about how a fractious and meddling Board is the driving reason for the turnover of senior staff, including the superintendent, at Seattle Public Schools.It's a good yarn, but it doesn't actually fit the facts. It doesn't fit the facts becauseThe Board isn't all that fractious. Most votes are unanimous or nearly so. And no matter how fractious the Board

JUL 29

Seattle Times "Story" on Superintendents and School Board
Update: And now the Times editorial board weighs in.  Yawn.  Same old, same old (you'd think they would try a new tack but no.)  The Times absolutely refuses to acknowledge the reasons for the turnover in Seattle superintendents.  What is the Board to do in the fact of not one but two financial scandals?  Keep those superintendents?  C'mon. Then they speak of "a curiosity for a change in gove
Tuesday Open Thread
 (Not about education but I wanted to get this out there as so many of us have loved ones with cancer.  A high school friend of mine does cancer research at Tulane University and they just found out that even low levels of light while sleeping may inhibit breast cancer drugs from working.  He also let me know this:"The Louisiana Cancer Research Consortium has special sleep masks that we will
The Anti-Board Advocacy of the Seattle Times
Once again the Seattle Times is whipping up anti-School Board animus.This is an old and discredited lie. And the "news" story is full of misrepresentations and omissions. I'll amend this post when I have time to list them all.
Aspiring athletes, take note of changes to NCAA eligibility
Prep athletes with aspirations to play in college and their families need to be aware of changes to NCAA eligibility requirements. They are stricter than they used to be and they are stricter than the district's requirements.See this story on the Seattle Times web site for more information.

JUL 28

National PTA Sponsoring Common Core Ads on Facebook
I would guess if you are a PTA member and on Facebook, these PTA-sponsored ads will pop up on your Facebook page.Would be nice if someone had proofread it first. Disappointing that National PTA is going this direction rather than having a real conversation about the issue and parents' concerns.
Where's the problem?
Over and over again we see that the problem is not inadequate policies or procedures but the absence of any enforcement and the absence of any accountability for those who violate the policies and procedures.And who has the job of enforcing policy and holding staff accountable? The Board.
Garfield Field Trip Assault: Continuing Questions
Update: So all I was trying to find out - from the FBI and National Park Service - is what was the date that  SPS asked them for their investigation report?  And what was the date that the district filed their FOIA request when the FBI/National Park Service said no to that request?Those two groups now want me to file a FOIA to find out when SPS filed their FOIA. Kind of funny.  (I would ask the di

JUL 27

Downtown School; Maybe Something Deeper Happening
There is nothing on the Seattle Schools calendar for this week.  Well, there is one meeting happening and yet strangely, it does not appear on the district calendar.  It's almost as if this meeting is really for one purpose or group.  It's the meeting at the Downtown Library about SPS taking over the Federal Reserve building. (The meeting is at 6 pm in the "Microsoft" auditorium with a w
Something Horrible Under Every Rock
People frequently ask me "What fuels your activist energy?" and I tell them "Outrage." "But how," they ask,"can you stay outraged for fourteen years?" "I can't." I tell them. "I'm newly outraged every couple days. And you would be too if you watched the District closely. There is something new that crops up - generally twice a week - that is a

JUL 26

Seattle School Board Speaks Out on Garfield Field Trip Incident
Update:  Both KIRO-7 tv and KING-5 tv have done stories on this issue.  I think that the story has legs and that they may continue on (especially now that the Title IX and the Department of Education has gotten involved.)  I note that the KING-5 piece says that the district couldn't get access to the FBI investigation and that the parents of the girl refused to allow the district to talk to her. 
Blather from Blethen
Sorry to pick on the Times but their publisher (and fearless leader), Frank Blethen, put up a speech that he gave recently to a Rotary Club.  He makes a lot of claims without backing up his stats or explaining his thinking.To whit,  We graduate only 18 percent of our high-school students work-ready or college-ready. Let’s break that number down: One-quarter of our high school students fail to grad

8-2-14 Ed Notes Online Week

Ed Notes Online


Ed Notes Online




Norm in The Wave: Memo From the RTC: Gypsy Update – Why Do They Do It?
Gypsy high school gals having fun before going onTonight is the next to last performance as the show closes with the Sunday matinee. All sold out. Monday we strike the set and start putting up Godspell. Published Friday, August 1, 2014 www.rockawave.comMemo From the RTC: Gypsy Update – Why Do They Do It?By Norm ScottAfter a 2nd sold-out weekend, Gypsy heads into the final stretch this weekend at t

Happy 100th Anniversary to World War One
Jeez, we haven't had a World War for 75 years. Our generation are just slackers. But the way things are going there is hope.Yes, August 1 is a big day in these parts. It was known as The Great War for 2 decades - until WWII broke out on Sept. 1 1939.I am celebrating by reading Barbara Tuchman's "The Guns of August." I had that book for about 40 years but lost it in Sandy. So I got a copy
Argentina Called Hedge Hog Paul Singer's Bluff
Many are bewildered as to why Argentina wouldn't come to some agreement in the eleventh hour, given the seemingly manageable amounts of debt in play. But the truth is that Argentina acted sensibly, especially given the limited maneuvering room it had to work with.  ... Foreign PolicyPaul Singer is singing in a high-pitched voice today after getting kicked in the balls by Argentina.See my previous
The Wave: The Amazing Susan Corning
When I saw Susan play the lead in Steel Magnolias back in 2006 - her first show in 30 years - I was blown away by her talent. A few years later I found myself in an RTC acting class - my first time when I was over 60 - with Susan. I was absolutely intimidated at the very idea of being on the same stage with Susan. But she made me feel - and makes everyone - feel so comfortable. She does anything a
Randi/Mulgrew Pal Steve Barr to Head Anti-Union DFER California
Hmm.. Steve Barr of Green Dot charters and then the pretentiously named “Future is Now” charters was always a favorite of Michael Mulgrew and the UFT. Several of his charters were started in NYC w/ their enthusiastic agreement. Wonder if they’ll still love him so much.... Leonie HaimsonOf course they still love Steve Barr, who never changed his true anti-union stripes, but allowed MulGarten to str

JUL 31

Open letter to SUNY board - urging them to stop approving new charters until true accountability is achieved
An article about this letter was in today's Daily News. Excerpt: "We are being oversaturated with charter schools," said Tesa Wilson, president Community Education Council in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. "It's tax dollars being poured into a black hole with no accountability." It's time SUNY is held accountable for its reckless and politically motivated charter school approval proce
Hedge Fund Vulture Hogs Default Argentina - And Public School Systems Too
Be greedy, fuck an entire country. I have an idea. Why doesn't Paul Singer start a charter school chain in Argentina - he could make more money than collecting on defaulted debt.The hedge fund firm of billionaire Paul E. Singer has about 300 employees, yet it has managed to force Argentina, a nation of 41 million people, into a position where it now has to contemplate a humbling surrender. Argenti
AFT Delegate Wants to See Opposition to Unity/Progressive Caucus Control
Hey Norm!I was a delegate at AFT's last convention in Los Angeles.  I'm from a city of about 90000 people. Our union could only afford to send two delegates to the LA Convention, even though we were allowed to send up to 15; we'll probably be able to send four or five to Minnesota because the cost should be significantly less than LA.  I was shocked that NYC was able to send 800 delegates. Somethi
Today: Protest Campbell Brown on Colbert Show - 4:15
I'm glad they are doing this, though I have no doubt Colbert will have some fun with Brown. You know, I watched Brown when she was (briefly) on the Today show - and she made me cringe with her humorlessness and cluelessness. They couldn't wait to get rid of her. FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASEContact:Julian Vinocur, julian@aqeny.org, 212-328-9268Maria Bautista, maria@aqeny.org, 347-622-9706*** Media Advisor
Takin' the Rockaway Ferry to See "Piece of My Heart" - and a Met Game with Old Pals
Thurs, July 31, 1PMGo see a great show - was available on TDF.Bathing Beauty sea sirens at RTC pool party looking to drag guys into water - they all happen to play strippers in Gypsy.I am just back from the theater where Tony had me build a ladder for the upcoming Godspell. When the actors fall off during the show, my name is on the ladder.I've had a fun few days. After taping the Sunday Gypsy per
Mike Schirtzer Thanks MOREistas
I just wanted to thank all the folks who helped organize and present at the today's summer series and the last one a couple of weeks back.Kit, Norm, Ellen, and James really explained well the lessons for MORE from their experiences in past opposition groups. It was such a great history lesson on why they fight so hard and how they were able to achieve some of their goals.Today Kevin did a fantasti

JUL 30

Moaning Mona and Campbell Brown Tenure Suits: An Attack on Special Ed Students
Less than a week after I received the Letter of Possible Discontinuance I received an updated package, which now stated my license could possibly be terminated. Because I voiced concern for the needs of my students I am being dealt a difficult card and an ultimatum.  I am alarmed and concerned for my future as an educator.  As I mentioned earlier, this is where I see myself until retirement, in a
Daily Howler Takes down Recent Ivy League Grad Ed Journalists
Impressive diplomas to the side, have you ever seen these new and slightly older kids challenge the prevailing theme about our floundering public schools? Have you ever seen them push back against this ubiquitous, billionaire-favored theme with the most elementary statistical work?.... People from the finest schools putter around on the public schools beat, failing to identify the groaning conflic
MORE Caucus Press Release: Teacher Tenure is Good for Students
By eliminating teacher tenure, we risk further disconnecting students and teachers, and make it harder for them to have transformational dialogue about what actually needs to be done in our classrooms to further the growth of students... Primi Akhtar (2014 graduate of Queens Metropolitan High School, valedictorian) Real parents and students as opposed to astroturf creations  support tenure. Primi
MORE Summer Series Today: Life Under the New UFT Contract
I can't make this today - taking soon to be demised Rockaway ferry into city for matinee - but this is only a first shot at life under the new contract. How about the health care cost savings?http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/30/nyregion/de-blasios-plans-to-save-on-worker-health-costs-come-into-focus.html?ref=nyregion&_r=0 Life Under The New UFT Contractby morecaucusnyc The Social Justice

JUL 29

A Parent/Filmmaker Comments on Ravitch and Unions
How is it possible that  the Leadership of Teachers Unions maintains this destructive control of the profession?  And how can that control be altered and in what ways, without destroying the Unions altogether.  .....parent perception is predominantly that the Unions speak for and represent the attitudes of teachers.... If the Unions don't speak for the majority of teachers and, if as you say, ther

JUL 28

I'm Shocked, Just Shocked WSJ Reporter Leslie Brody Would Write a Biased Article on Tenure
The Wall Street Journal article is just another example of how the media uses "fuzzy math" to distort and pervert the statistics to suit their ideological aims and to support the attack on teacher "due process rights"... Chaz School Daze Chaz on ICE blog:  The exoneration rate in 3020-a cases has remained consistent over the years at 4%. James Eterno response: You won't find
Francesca Gomes on the New Teacher Contract
While many teachers were able to see the contract for what it was, the only organized protest against it was mounted by the Movement of Rank and File Educators (MORE). Though the effort made by this group was truly commendable, it currently has too small of a base to mount an effective attack or empower the teachers in a city with such a vast, sprawling geography and such a high number of schools.

JUL 27

The Diane Ravitch Contradiction: Educators Should Rebel, but Be Nice When Addressing Oppressive Union Leaderships
....you want the workers to be rebellious, not docile. There is a time for collaboration and a time to stand up and fight... Ravitch on film "Metropolis."  I grow frustrated when union members attack their unions. Of course, they should fight to win democratic control of their unions. But when they begin hurling insults and invective at their allies, they do the work of their common foe.

JUL 26

The Wave: Memo from the RTC: Backstage at “Gypsy”
So I am so involved with the play, the usual education stuff I put up on Ed Notes is taking 2nd place even though I think about the issues all the time - and in fact have written dozens of blog posts -- in my mind -- they disappear almost immediately. I have been deeply involved in all the MORE stuff but haven't had a chance to write much about it. And who actually reads this stuff? It seems more