Latest News and Comment from Education

Thursday, June 13, 2013

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 6-13-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch



Writing for the Common Core Tests

Vicki Cobb, an award-winning author of more than 90 children’s books about science, recently received a requestfrom a test publisher to write for the new Common Core assessments. However, when she saw the guidelines, she wondered if she could do it. Will her voice disappear? Will she be compelled to write the same pap that deadens textbooks? Stay tuned.

Pennsylvania: Now We Know the Truth About Cyber Charters

Rhonda Brownstein, the executive director of Pennsylvania’s Education Law Center, says that it is time to stop trusting the claims of cyber charter promoters. For years, they have promised that students would get “innovative” education and that wondrous things would happen when virtual charters became reality, butPennsylvania now knows that none of that turned out to be true.
Pennsylvania has allowed unchecked growth of cyber charters. They have drained funding away from public schools while providing a low-quality of education.
She writes:
“Attorneys at ELC have heard from the families of many students attending cyber charter schools. Here’s what those families have reported: Students spending countless hours behind computer screens without any required 

Charter School Rejects Student with Special Needs

Again and again, we hear the same story: charters excluding children with special needs. This is contrary to federal law. How do they get away with it? Where are the lawyers?
A mother writes:
My daughter is a mainstream student and has been attending Minnesota School of Science since they opened. For 2 years in a row I have been trying to enroll my son who is a special needs student but have been told by the school both years not to enroll him because the special education program is lacking and that my son’s needs 

When Professional Judgment Conflicts with Common Core

This reader explains the conflict between Common Core expectations and her professional judgment. How did she resolve it? She did what she believed was in the best interests of children. It’s not easy.
She writes:
“As a literacy consultant and Title 1 coordinator at my K-6 rural NH school, I sympathize. At my school, we use Fountas and Pinnell’s Benchmark Assessment System as our universal screening tool for literacy. When F&P came out with their revised reading level expectations (obviously inspired by the CCSS, although they refuse to admit this), my colleagues and I came to consensus about the fact that we will not adhere to them, as we feel 

The Negative Consequences of Pressuring Students to Take AP Courses

A reader commented on an ongoing discussion of Advanced Placement courses and the rating of high schools according to how many students, ready or not, take them.
She writes:
“The highly publicized rankings based on AP tests taken did a lot of harm in my sons’ high school. AP courses used to attract the students who were genuinely ready for college-level work, but about seven years ago, the school system instituted a policy that required every student who took an AP course to take the AP exam, and also began to push students into AP who did not really need to be there. There were parent meetings about AP 

Helen Gym: Report from Philadelphia Parents on the Front Lines of Destruction

Philadelphia has had a disastrous year of school closings, budget cuts, and a report recommending privatization of large numbers of public schools. Now, as parent activist Helen Gym reports, the situation is even more dire after massive layoffs. The state of Pennsylvania and the mayor of Philadelphia seem content to let private corporations take over public education  in the city. This is an ominous sign, not only for Pennsylvania, but for other urban districts. This is purposeful abandonment of a basic public function.
Gym writes:
For those watching Philadelphia’s tragic schools situation from afar, hope you might consider a few pieces from Parents United for Public Education.
Topping off a dreadful year that saw 24 school closings, and the stripping away of all educational supports from 

Bruce Baker: Another Look at the Much Hyped Chetty-Rockoff-Freidman Study

Perhaps you recall the hoopla that surrounded the release in late 2011 of a study by economists Chetty, Friedman, and Rockoff, in which they claimed that a great teacher would produce a huge increase in lifetime earnings, fewer pregnancies, and other wonderful life outcomes. It was reported on the front page of the New York Times, where one of the authors said that the lesson of the study was that it was best to fire teachers who couldn’t produce big gains sooner rather than later. The study was discussed reverentially on the Newshour and President Obama referenced its conclusion in his 2012 State of the Union address.
The central claim was that the great teacher produced a lifetime gain of $266,000 for a typical classroom.
First out of the box to challenge the study was Bruce Baker of Rutgers. He pointed out that if a class had 26 

Diane 6-12-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

mike simpson at Big Education Ape - 10 minutes ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Faces of the Layoff: Who Got Pink Slips in Philadelphia by dianerav Numbers don’t begin to tell the story. Nearly 4,000 employees of the Philadelphia public school district learned that their jobs had been terminated. The Teacher Action Group of Philadelphia is gathering photos to put a human face on an inhumane decision. Each one has a story. They are real people, not numbers. *LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 6-12-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all* mike simpson at Big Education Ap... more »

Hey City Council: You’re Supposed to Be Better than Harrisburg | Parents United for Public Education

Hey City Council: You’re Supposed to Be Better than Harrisburg | Parents United for Public Education:

Hey City Council: You’re Supposed to Be Better than Harrisburg

City Council-dontletusdown













City Council’s failure to move a liquor-by-the-drink tax yesterday disappointed parents and school supporters all
 across the city.
Rebecca PoyourowToday over 100 parents, students, and community members packed City Council chambers—in the middle of a workday afternoon—and testified for over three hours to demand movement on the liquor-by-the-drink tax.  For weeks, parents and other community members have made thousands of phone calls, sent hundreds of letters, spent hours on lobbying visits, and gathered countless petition signatures in support of raising desperately needed funds for our public.
Opposite us were a handful of lobbyists, whose sole job is to be paid to gain access to City Council members and state legislators.
To our disgust, Council could not muster enough support on the liquor-by-the-drink bill in order to vote it out of committee.  Despite testimony on the desperate need of our students, and despite presentation of data demonstrating how this tax will not undermine food and beverage establishments, Council could not summon the collective will to do right by our city’s children.
As proposed, the liquor-by-the-drink bill would raise $22 million for Philadelphia’s public schools by increasing the tax rate on liquor by the drink from 10% to 15%.  In effect this would add 15 to 50 cents to the price of a drink and be borne by individual customers as a sales tax—not by businesses.  As a regional hub, Philadelphia will continue to attract suburban visitors and tourists as well as local residents, none of whom will be deterred from patronizing bars and restaurants by paying an additional charge ranging from 15-50 cents per drink.  Indeed research conducted by the PA Budget and Policy Center found that when this tax was first introduced back in 1996, it did not depress sales, job growth, and new business as the restaurant lobby had claimed.  Rather, restaurants experienced phenomenal growth over the next several years as measured both by the number of new 

We're Not Misinformed; We Know What Common Core Is, & We Reject It. | Truth in American Education

We're Not Misinformed; We Know What Common Core Is, & We Reject It. | Truth in American Education:

We’re Not Misinformed; We Know What Common Core Is, & We Reject It.

common-coreIn Utah this year, GOP state delegates passed a resolution that opposed Common Core, by a 65% vote. The National GOP passed a similar resolution. The Michigan legislature passed a bill that defunded Common Core. Indiana legislators passed a year-long time-out bill to pause Common Core. Similar efforts by Republicans and Democrats are growing in North CarolinaGeorgiaMissouri,Iowa,FloridaWyomingIllinois and elsewhere.
Yet Utah’s governor continues to promote the Common Core-dependent Prosperity 2020, and the Utah School Board continues to label as “misinformed” or “erroneous” all who oppose Common Core.
We are not misinformed. We know what Common Core is, and we reject it.
It’s not “state-led.” The authors of the copyrighted Common Core are



Common Core Makes a Surprise Appearance in Texas

A mother of a third grader living in the Dallas-Ft. Worth area in Texas messaged us through our Facebook page(be sure to like us).  She wrote:
Look what came home in my 3rd grader’s backpack today to use as summer practice? This is the book they’ve been using all year (unbeknownst to me). It says ‘common core edition’. I specifically asked our ISD in DFW if they used any part of CSCOPE or Common Core and they said no. I have the email to prove it. I was lied to. Am going back to them asking them to explain. I’m very concerned. Even so, my 1st grader had a very hard time with math and I’ve had to re-teacher her basics since she’s not getting it at school. If you look through the book, it’s exactly everything people say the ‘fuzzy math’ is — full of riddles and lengthy word problems. I’m confused myself and it’s 3rd grade math! I can’t believe this was used without any heads up from the district. Common Core is indeed in Texas!
She included a picture…
common-core-student-activity-book
I don’t know if it is the school trying to bring the Common Core in through the back door or if the school district is 

A Glimpse of Math Homework from a Parent’s Point of View

Meredith Gavin, a parent in New York State, emailed me this morning with a video she made of her third grade son, Liam, doing his math homework.  She wrote:
This is a prime example of how my son’s brain gets confused, when he is given homework that entails knowing several different concepts that he struggles with, and then those concepts are mixed together – he even struggles with taking 0 away from 5.
I will recognize that even if this Math HW was not based around CC he would still be having a hard time. I will also add that CCSS is not helping special ed kids in any- way, shape, or form. They are rushing him through 3rd grade lessons without a solid foundation, and I truly believe it is BECAUSE of Common Core.
She said this video was the result of months of frustrations she has had with him coming home not being able to 

OK State Superintendent of Education Confronted on Common Core

An Oklahoma homeschooling mom, Karen Cuellar, gives a play by play of Oklahoma State Superintendent Janet Barresi’s visit with the Wagner County GOP Central Committee at their meeting this month.
I think she got a little more than she bargained for.
Restore Oklahoma Public Education has the story.
The post OK State Superintendent of Education Confronted on Common Core appeared first on Truth in American Education.

The Snark syndrome in educational policymaking | Get Schooled | www.ajc.com

The Snark syndrome in educational policymaking | Get Schooled | www.ajc.com:

The Snark syndrome in educational policymaking 

Related

Arne Duncan  photo
Johnny Crawford, jcrawford@ajc.com
U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan reads to children at Boyd Elementary School Friday, May 31, 2013. Education Secretary Arne Duncan , Governor Nathan Deal and Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed also participated in a panel discussion on education.
Peter Smagorinsky is Distinguished Research Professor of English Education in the Department of Language and Literacy Education at the University of Georgia. He is a frequent contributor to the Get Schooled blog:
  By Peter Smagorinsky
In 1993, Eileen Byrne published "Women and Science: The Snark Syndrome."
Snarks have been around for some time, first appearing in 1874 in Lewis Carroll's "The Hunting of the Snark." Well, actually they are imaginary, as I learned when sent on a “snark hunt” as a tenderfoot Boy Scout on my first camping trip long ago, much to the delight of the older boys in my troop.
 Byrne in particular draws on the following stanzas to coin the “snark syndrome” or “snark effect”:

'Just the place for a Snark!' the Bellman cried,
As he landed his crew with care;
Supporting each man on the top of the tide
By a finger entwined in his hair.

'Just the place for a Snark! I have said it twice:
That alone should encourage the crew.
Just the place for a Snark! I have said thrice: 

Education officials seek team approach to fight chronic absenteeism | EdSource Today

Education officials seek team approach to fight chronic absenteeism | EdSource Today:

Education officials seek team approach to fight chronic absenteeism - by Kathryn Baron

Why two reform movements — choice and accountability — have fallen short

Why two reform movements — choice and accountability — have fallen short:

Why two reform movements — choice and accountability — have fallen short

arrowPublic education has been rocked over the past two decades by the choice and accountability movements, both launched by reformers in an effort to “fix” failing schools. Why haven’t they worked as well as promised? This post examines this question. It is written by Jack Schneider, an assistant professor of education at the College of the Holy Cross in Worcester, Mass., and the author ofExcellence For All: How a New Breed of Reformers Is Transforming America’s Public Schools. He tweets @Edu_Historian.
By Jack Schneider
Over the past 20 years, two reform movements — choice and accountability — have transformed the face of K-12 education.  With strong support at the state and federal level, as well as among the American public, each has become a standard feature of the modern policy landscape.  As such, parents today frequently choose which schools their children attend, and low-scoring schools are routinely sanctioned for their performance.
Yet while each movement has shown some promise for improving access to good schools, neither has lived up to expectations.  Why?  Critics have a whole host of 

How test scores can be deceiving

Consider this: On the National Assessment of Educational Progress, the test that is commonly referred to as “the nation’s report card,” Massachusetts students performed so well that the state ranked No. 1 in the nation. Sounds good, right? Then consider … Continue reading →
    

Bill Gates Discovers Money Cannot Buy Teachers - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher

Bill Gates Discovers Money Cannot Buy Teachers - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher:

Bill Gates Discovers Money Cannot Buy Teachers

Sunday's Seattle Times tells us of a strange problem encountered by the richest man in the world. He has discovered that his money is not working its magic in education -- teachers are not for sale.
The Gates Foundation has spent the past decade promoting hard hitting education reforms. Organizations they fund have conducted research, lobbied politicians, and advanced policies that have brought us Value Added teacher and principal evaluations, charter school expansion, Teach For America corps members, and merit pay. They have poured millions into efforts to shape public opinion, sponsoring Education Nation and the propaganda documentary Waiting for Superman, and its star, Michelle Rhee. They have told us how important teachers are, but in spite of all this attention, teachers seem positively ungrateful.
So now the Gates Foundation is on what has been called a "charm offensive." According to Seattle Times reporter Linda Shaw, the Gates Foundation last year brought 250 teachers to a hotel in Arizona to share their 

What’s that fishy smell…A Bass Pro shop update… - Wait, What?

What’s that fishy smell…A Bass Pro shop update… - Wait, What?:

What’s that fishy smell…A Bass Pro shop update…

Coalition for Public Education/Coalición por la Educación Pública: The MultiBillionaire Ed Privateers Never Stop Their Pillaging-- Even During the Summer!

Coalition for Public Education/Coalición por la Educación Pública: The MultiBillionaire Ed Privateers Never Stop Their Pillaging-- Even During the Summer!:

The MultiBillionaire Ed Privateers Never Stop Their Pillaging-- Even During the Summer!


Study: Millennials Prefer Traditional Classrooms Over Online Ones | toteachornototeach

Study: Millennials Prefer Traditional Classrooms Over Online Ones | toteachornototeach:

Study: Millennials Prefer Traditional Classrooms Over Online Ones

Study: Millennials Prefer Traditional Classrooms Over Online Ones

by Vignesh RamachandranStudents are warming up to virtual education, but according to a new study, they still believe it’s easier to learn in a traditional classroom.
Millennial Branding, a Generation Y consulting firm, and online marketplace Internships.com, conducted an online survey in May in which they asked 1,345 college students in the United States about their views on the future of education. The study found almost 53% of students polled agree that “online 

NYC Educator: The Incredible Disappearing UFT Rep

NYC Educator: The Incredible Disappearing UFT Rep:

The Incredible Disappearing UFT Rep

In a pivotal career move, a UFT Rep reread Catch 22, and decided his favorite character was Major Major. He immediately determined to emulate him in every way possible. From that moment, the only time he saw members in his office was when he wasn't there. It was much more efficient and convenient. When he was there, and people came, they had all sorts of complaints. Principals were crazy, working conditions were awful, they hadn't had a raise in five years, blah, blah, blah.

On they would go, and they invariably reached a crescendo with, "What the hell is the union going to do to help me?" And no matter what he told them or who he promised to call, they weren't satisfied. The ungrateful bastards.

But ever since he started seeing people only when he wasn't there, things had improved. The office staff was always pleasant. Everyone said hi, how are you, good morning, nice to see you, and no one pressured him to do anything whatsoever. There was coffee, a water cooler, and happy people everywhere. But still, even though he'd stopped seeing people when he was there, that damn phone kept ringing.

Lately he'd made another discovery that further improved his lifestyle. You could place people on hold, and if you