Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, June 22, 2010

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Thanks for critical thinkers

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Thanks for critical thinkers

Thanks for critical thinkers

Thanks to my those critics of bought-and-paid-for school research, EPIC/EPRU, for shining their light on the latest KIPP study. Gary Miron's preliminary look finds a big problem. The study badly underestimates the impact of KIPPs relatively high student attrition rates and therefore belies KIPP PR guy Steve Mancini's claim that it provides "irrefutable evidence" that KIPP doesn't cream it's kids.

Mancini doth protest a bit too much however, since the concern with the KIPP chain of replicant schools has always been more about attrition, than skimming. It's always been difficult for charter schools to aggressively skim because most are required to admit students through a lottery.