Latest News and Comment from Education

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

MORNING NEWS UPDATE: SEPTEMBER 9, 2026

MORNING NEWS UPDATE:  SEPTEMBER 9, 2026
REMEMBER IN NOVEMBER

 USA.gov Voting and Elections 

State-by-state lookup for registration verification, local election offices, and polling guidelines


Here are today’s top news stories (September 9, 2026), kept strictly separate by category.

U.S. NEWS

  • Investigators report that an Amazon-contracted cargo plane (Boeing 767 operated by 21 Air) tried to abort an unsteady landing at Miami International Airport before overrunning the runway, striking vehicles, and killing five people (mostly cleaning-crew workers in a van) with several others injured. NTSB is reviewing flight data and cockpit recordings; pilots have been released from the hospital.
  • A Georgia National Guard member deployed in Washington, D.C., as part of a crime-fighting task force was arrested for allegedly drawing a gun on a fellow Guard member in a dispute over regulation haircuts.
  • President Trump held a 9/11 commemorative event near the White House with a steel beam from the World Trade Center; the 25th anniversary observances continue.
  • TSA is restoring limited gate access for some people without plane tickets, 25 years after 9/11 restrictions.
  • A large law-enforcement operation rescued nearly 80 missing children.
  • 9/11 25th Anniversary Commemorations Begin: Ahead of Friday’s 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks, a World Trade Center steel beam was displayed on the Ellipse near the White House before returning to New York. President Trump posthumously awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom to Welles Crowther, the "Man in the Red Bandanna" who died rescuing others.

  • Rescues in Major Law Enforcement Operation: Federal and local law enforcement authorities announced the successful rescue of nearly 80 missing children following a coordinated multi-agency operation across several states.

  • Miami International Airport Investigation: Federal investigators with the NTSB and FAA continue their probe into a major tarmac accident at Miami International Airport to determine mechanical or procedural causes.

  • Smithsonian Leadership Change: Lonnie G. Bunch III announced he is stepping down as secretary of the Smithsonian Institution after seven years, bringing significant leadership transitions to the nation's premier museum network.

POLITICS

  • Republicans open an unprecedented midterm “Trumpapalooza” convention in Dallas/Texas, with President Trump front and center amid questions about whether it helps or hurts candidates given his approval ratings.
  • New Hampshire primary results: Republicans nominated former Sen. John E. Sununu (Trump-endorsed) for Senate; Democrats nominated Rep. Chris Pappas. GOP Gov. Kelly Ayotte advanced.
  • Missouri congressional redistricting is in turmoil after conflicting federal court decisions; officials plan to proceed with a GOP-favored map amid legal chaos.
  • Trump administration faces ongoing fights over mail-in voting restrictions and related Postal Service plans; voters and officials are adjusting plans.
  • American Bar Association ends DEI accreditation standards under pressure related to the Trump administration.
  • New Hampshire Primary Results: Voters in New Hampshire went to the polls on Tuesday, with former Senator John E. Sununu winning the GOP nomination for U.S. Senate and Representative Chris Pappas securing the Democratic nomination for the seat. Governor Kelly Ayotte also won her Republican gubernatorial primary.

  • U.S. Supreme Court Decision on Missouri Maps: The U.S. Supreme Court declined to intervene to reinstate a Trump-backed congressional map in Missouri, upholding a state supreme court ruling that blocked its use for the upcoming November midterms.

  • Escalating U.S.–Canada Trade Dispute: The White House announced new import bans on Canadian dairy products, motorcycles, and most alcoholic beverages, escalating trade tensions after Canada instituted retaliatory tariffs.

  • LA Local Government Transition: Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass announced plans to step down from the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority Commission board to focus on executive mayoral duties.

WORLD AFFAIRS

  • Escalating U.S.-Iran conflict: U.S. forces destroyed five Iranian oil tankers after Iranian missile attacks on U.S. Navy ships; Iran then launched missiles at a U.S.-used base in Jordan (Jordan intercepted many) and claimed further strikes near Hormuz. Oil prices surged (Brent near/above $100).
  • UK, France, Canada and others ban imports from Israeli West Bank settlements; Israel responds by closing the British consulate in East Jerusalem.
  • Russia struck Kyiv with drones/missiles after a brief pause, killing several and damaging infrastructure.
  • Houthi forces struck targets in Saudi Arabia, injuring dozens and temporarily disrupting energy facilities; Yemen fighting continues with high casualties.
  • Germany’s far-right AfD scored a strong state election result, intensifying European political debates.
  • U.S.–Iran Military Encounters in the Persian Gulf: U.S. Central Command confirmed military strikes against five Iranian oil tankers following repeated ballistic missile attacks targeting a U.S. Navy warship in the Gulf of Oman. Iran responded by launching missiles toward bases in Jordan used by American forces.

  • Jerusalem Diplomatic Tensions: Israel ordered the closure of the British consulate in East Jerusalem, escalating political friction following proposed UK sanctions regarding regional settlements.

  • Red Sea & Gulf Navigation Security: Maritime authorities brought a vessel fire near Qatar under control as regional transit routes and energy infrastructure face elevated security protocols.

  • Diplomatic Talks in Europe: South Korean President Lee Jae Myung and French President Emmanuel Macron met in Paris to discuss international maritime safety, energy transport lines, and freedom of navigation.

EDUCATION

  • U.S. student performance on a major international assessment reached its lowest point in two decades.
  • Trump administration threats and policy moves (including potential loss of federal funding/tax-exempt status) are raising concerns about medical-school admissions practices involving race/diversity considerations.
  • American Bar Association eliminates DEI-related standards for law-school accreditation under administration pressure.
  • Ongoing fallout from new federal student-loan rule changes has delayed some disbursements and created billing problems for students.
  • International literacy and ranking updates (e.g., Indian institutes in global management rankings; various national literacy awards and programs) continue to appear in education coverage.
  • Higher Education Leadership Shifts: Academic analysts noted an accelerating turnover among university presidents across the country, with institutions like the University of Illinois, Virginia Tech, and Brandeis actively searching for top leadership amid changing state policy standards.

  • College Athlete NIL Management Tools: New AI administrative systems were launched nationwide to help college student-athletes manage Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) brand agreements, with total collegiate NIL deal values projected to hit $4.5 billion for the 2026–27 academic year.

  • Nationwide Teacher & Certification Testing: The Central Board of Secondary Education and regional testing boards announced upcoming fall scheduling and administrative updates for primary and secondary teacher eligibility examinations.

  • Student Internship Stipend Resolutions: Regional medical education boards resolved ongoing intern and resident labor actions by agreeing to stipend adjustments and structured governance reviews.

ECONOMY

  • Oil prices jumped (Brent crude topped $100/barrel for the first time since July) on U.S.-Iran tanker strikes, Iranian retaliation, and related Middle East supply fears; energy-price pressure is feeding inflation concerns.
  • U.S.-Canada trade war escalates: Canada’s retaliatory tariffs took effect; Trump signed orders banning or heavily restricting imports of Canadian dairy, alcohol, motorcycles and other goods.
  • U.S. stock futures declined amid higher oil prices and rising Treasury yields (10-year near multi-year highs); markets await key inflation data later in the week.
  • China’s August inflation data showed rises driven largely by higher energy costs.
  • Broader concerns about elevated yields, potential rate paths, and trade disruptions continue to dominate market commentary.
  • Wall Street Drops as Energy Prices Surge: Rising geopolitical conflict pushed Brent crude oil prices near $98–$99 per barrel, causing the Dow Jones to fall 628 points and putting downward pressure on the S&P 500 and Nasdaq.

  • Upcoming Inflation Data: Markets are closely watching the upcoming August Producer Price Index (PPI) and Consumer Price Index (CPI) releases, which will be the final key economic indicators before the Federal Reserve’s interest rate policy meeting next week.

  • Global Trade & Supply Chain Moves: China reported a 25% year-over-year expansion in August exports, driven by automotive and high-tech manufacturing, even as global energy trade shifts away from conflict zones.

  • Treasury Yields Rise: The 10-year U.S. Treasury yield rose to 4.79%, approaching its highest levels in years as investors recalibrate interest rate expectations ahead of central bank decisions.

TECHNOLOGY

  • OpenAI announced that an internal AI system (using thousands of agents) produced a solution/proof related to the Navier-Stokes Millennium Prize problem (fluid dynamics singularity), with a formalization in Lean; the claim is generating major scientific interest and controversy over credit and research practices involving other mathematicians/Anthropic.
  • Meta launched “Muse,” a personal AI agent that connects to email, calendars, apps, and social platforms to handle tasks.
  • Apple’s hardware event is underway (new CEO John Ternus’s first major event), with expectations centered on a foldable iPhone and other devices.
  • Microsoft’s September 2026 Patch Tuesday delivered a record number of fixes (hundreds of vulnerabilities, including critical ones).
  • Additional AI developments include funding rounds (e.g., Mistral), researcher departures citing safety concerns, and U.S. warnings about Chinese firms distilling capabilities from American models.
  • Enterprise Autonomous AI Agents: Tech sector developments highlighted a growing corporate adoption of autonomous business operating software and open-source models designed to handle complex workflows in financial and administrative sectors.

  • Next-Gen On-Device Hardware: Funding and chip manufacturing deals accelerated for wearable computing devices, focusing on embedding specialized microprocessors into smart rings and compact form factors to perform real-time local processing.

  • Enterprise Data Security Concerns: Industry research published this week revealed growing corporate governance focus around "shadow AI" and ensuring automated data workflows remain compliant with strict privacy regulations.

  • Biological Computing Breakthroughs: Researchers announced major progress in bio-computing, successfully engineering bacterial circuits capable of processing input signals and logic tasks for potential applications in agriculture and environmental monitoring.

HEALTH

  • A study finds that drinking very hot beverages may substantially raise the risk of esophageal cancer.
  • Research shows toilet flushing can generate aerosol plumes capable of spreading pathogens even with the lid closed.
  • Bangladesh is battling a severe measles outbreak that has killed nearly 1,000 children this year despite vaccination efforts.
  • FDA senior leadership appointments (drugs, biologics/vaccines, tobacco) were announced under the current administration.
  • Other coverage includes potential aging-related effects of certain drugs, protein-intake debates, and ongoing public-health trust issues.
  • Dementia Risk Research: Medical studies published this week show promising correlations between long-term statin use and reduced risks of dementia and cognitive decline in older adults.

  • Cancer Treatment Discoveries: Research teams identified novel therapeutic vulnerabilities in treatment-resistant prostate cancer and glioblastoma, opening new pathways for targeted smart-nanoparticle delivery.

  • Gut Microbiome and Metabolism: New physiological findings highlighted direct links between specific gut microbiome compounds, fat metabolism in muscle cells, and broader metabolic health.

  • Air Filtration and Cognitive Function: Public health studies emphasized the measurable cognitive and neurological benefits of using HEPA air purifiers in indoor home and workplace environments.

SPORTS

  • US Open: Ben Shelton upset defending champion Carlos Alcaraz in a five-set marathon that set a record for the latest finish in tournament history; Frances Tiafoe and Aryna Sabalenka also advanced to the semifinals.
  • NFL regular season kicks off (including a high-profile matchup); Baker Mayfield agreed to a large multi-year extension with the Buccaneers.
  • Champions League returned with notable results (e.g., Real Madrid edged Inter).
  • MLB: Several teams posted key wins (Brewers, Yankees, etc.) as the regular season winds down and playoff races tighten.
  • Additional notes include LIV Golf bankruptcy filing developments and other league storylines.
  • NFL Season Kickoff: The 2026 NFL regular season officially kicks off tonight, Wednesday, September 9, featuring a primetime Super Bowl rematch between the defending champion Seattle Seahawks and the New England Patriots.

  • MLB September Pennant Races: Major League Baseball enters crucial late-season play today with a full 15-game slate, including matchups between the Dodgers and Reds, and the Red Sox hosting the Angels.

  • International NFL Expansion: The NFL is finalizing preparations for its historic Week 1 game in Melbourne, Australia, featuring the San Francisco 49ers and Los Angeles Rams.

  • Sports Media & Venue Deals: Streaming and venue distribution platforms expanded partnerships to deliver live commercial broadcasts of regular-season and holiday sports programming to national commercial venues.

Stories are drawn from major outlets and current-events summaries available early on September 9, 2026. Rankings within each category reflect prominence in coverage rather than a strict hierarchy.


EDUCATION SPECIAL
TOP US EDUCATION NEWS TODAY
TOP WORLD EDUCATION NEWS TODAY


The major headlines in K-12 and higher education show a strong focus on international academic benchmarks, federal policy shifts, and the rapid, contentious integration of AI in classrooms.

🌍 Top World Education News

  • Global PISA Results Show Historic Decline in Reading and Math: The OECD released results from the international PISA exam (testing 15-year-olds globally). Student reading scores dropped sharply across OECD member nations. Researchers link the downward trend to "digital distraction," reduced attention spans, and over-reliance on AI for quick answers rather than critical analysis. High-performing systems in Singapore, Japan, South Korea, and Estonia continue to top the global rankings.

  • Disruptions to Education in Conflict and Crisis Zones:

    • Southeast Asia: Worsening haze from regional forest fires forced widespread school closures and a shift to remote learning in Indonesia's South Sumatra province.

    • Middle East: Overcrowding and facility shortages persist as thousands of students in Lebanon shelter in school buildings converted into emergency housing during ongoing regional conflict.

  • Afghani Girls' Education Initiative Expands Abroad: Following restrictions on female education in Afghanistan, the School of Leadership, Afghanistan (SOLA) officially opened a permanent, dedicated campus in Rwanda to educate exiled Afghan young women.

🇺🇸 Top US Education News

  • US Scores Hit 20-Year Low as Public Satisfaction Drops: On the same PISA release, American 15-year-olds recorded their lowest math and reading performance in over two decades. Concurrently, new Gallup poll data shows adult satisfaction with American K-12 education has dropped to 32%—the lowest level recorded in 27 years.

  • Major Districts Pull Back on AI for Young Students:

    • New York City & Los Angeles: NYC Public Schools announced a ban on student AI tools for grades K through 8 alongside screen-time limits. Los Angeles Unified (LAUSD) has similarly restricted student AI usage following concerns over learning depth and data privacy.

  • Federal Civil Rights & Policy Friction:

    • Department of Justice Lawsuits: Federal agencies continue legal actions against state policies, including a Justice Department suit against Kansas policies regarding transgender students.

    • Higher Education DEI Scrutiny: Federal policy proposals are targeting tax exemptions for private colleges and universities maintaining Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) frameworks.

  • State Curriculum & Textbook Battles: The Texas State Board of Education finalized controversial updates to its state social studies curriculum, sparking intense debate among local community organizations and religious groups over the portrayal of world history.


Compact 2.0: What It Is and How We're Fighting Back | AAUP https://www.aaup.org/event/compact-20-what-it-and-how-were-fighting-back






OPINION: Our children need a lot more protection from AI, but they aren’t getting it https://hechingerreport.org/opinion-our-children-need-more-protection-from-ai/

Data Centers Now Facing Backlash Over Contaminated Wastewater – Mother Jones https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/09/meta-data-center-rare-bacteria-backlash-waste-water-contamination/ 

The Revolutionary Roots That Inspired Tupac Shakur – Mother Jones https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/09/the-revolutionary-roots-that-inspired-tupac-shakur-2/ 

Why Families Worldwide Are Losing Interest In Education | HuffPost Life https://www.huffpost.com/entry/why-families-worldwide-are-losing-interest-in-education_l_6aa09cdfe4b03076360548a5 

Why This Small Dutch Town Is Teaching ‘Adolescence’ in School - The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/09/world/europe/netherlands-adolescence-manophere-education.html

This Times Reporter Wants to Hear Your College Gossip - The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/09/insider/new-york-times-extra-credit-newsletter.html 

Should Professors Teach More? Some Colleges Are Trying to Make Them. - The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/09/us/university-professors-teaching-research-quit.html 

Wrongfully Convicted Man Who Got $1.4 Million Had Only 13 Years Before Cancer Took His Life — ProPublica https://www.propublica.org/article/wrongful-conviction-cancer-death 

‘I’m listening hard’: Teens increasingly turn to AI chatbots for mental health support | EdSource https://edsource.org/2026/im-listening-hard-teens-increasingly-turn-to-ai-chatbots-for-mental-health-support/765573 

Ectopic Pregnancy Deaths Have Nearly Doubled. It’s Worse in Abortion-Ban States. — ProPublica https://www.propublica.org/article/ectopic-pregnancy-deaths-doubled-analysis 

‘Don’t take this one for granted’: New Hampshire Democrats brace for a tough Senate race - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/08/new-hampshire-senate-pappas-sununu-01068475

Brooklyn's Democratic boss defied Schumer and Jeffries. So far she's winning. - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/09/schumer-and-jeffries-opposed-a-brooklyn-power-play-it-happened-anyway-01068169

America Is Losing Its Mind. This Governor Wants You to Put Down Your Phone. - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/09/09/spencer-cox-utah-governor-book-politics-01067771 

Louisiana’s abortion pill case could wipe out access in blue states - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/09/louisiana-abortion-pills-mifepristone-5th-circuit-01067429

In Michigan, GOP Senate candidate makes a Canadian-sized gamble on trade - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/09/in-michigan-gop-senate-candidate-makes-a-canadian-sized-gamble-on-trade-01068113

‘They will crawl over glass to vote for the president’: Trump needs to put himself on the ballot to juice the base - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/09/trump-isnt-on-the-ballot-he-wants-republicans-to-pretend-he-is-01067372

‘Gambling with our lives’: AI researcher quits Anthropic with dire warning about safety – POLITICO https://www.politico.eu/article/anthropic-openai-researcher-jacob-coxon-warns-ai-could-kill-humans/

Florida’s midterm drama deepens with concerns over Trump beef import plan - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/09/floridas-midterms-trump-beef-import-plan-ranchers-01068186

‘No good options’: GOP’s midterm hopes suffer under energy inflation - POLITICO https://www.politico.com/news/2026/09/09/no-good-options-gops-midterm-hopes-suffer-under-energy-inflation-01065142

10th Circuit expands state authority to arrest in Indian Country, remands Shawn Walden civil rights suit https://nondoc.com/2026/09/09/10th-circuit-expands-state-authority-to-arrest-in-indian-country-remands-shawn-walden-civil-rights-suit/ 



SHOW ME THE MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE: THE SCIENCE OF READING'S $1.8 BILLION SNAKE OIL PROBLEM

SHOW ME THE MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE: THE SCIENCE OF READING'S $1.8 BILLION SNAKE OIL PROBLEM

A modest proposal for accountability in the education reform industrial complex

Well, here we go again.

The ink is barely dry on the last "miracle cure" for American education — you may remember it, it went by the name Common Core State Standards, came with a $15.8 billion price tag, a decade of standardized testing theater, and reading scores that went precisely nowhere — and already we are rolling out the Next Big Thing™. This time it's called the Science of Reading, or SoR for those of us who prefer our educational snake oil in acronym form.

Now, to be fair — and we will be fair, briefly, before returning to our regularly scheduled outrage — the Science of Reading is not entirely without merit. Phonics works. Explicit decoding instruction works. The research on structured literacy is real. But here's the thing about real research: it doesn't automatically survive contact with a $1.8 billion rollout machine, a publishing industry that smells money, and a political class that loves a shiny new education initiative the way a magpie loves a bottle cap.

So before we spend another generation's worth of classroom time and another billion dollars of public money on the latest pedagogical fashion show, perhaps — just perhaps — we should demand something radical.

A money-back guarantee.

The Education Reform Carnival: A Brief History of Spending Without Accountability

Let's set the scene. For context, here is what we already know about how America spends money on education reform:

  • $1.7 billion per year is spent on standardized testing alone — a figure representing roughly 0.25% of total K–12 expenditures — that, by the Brookings Institution's own admission, tells us primarily which kids are poor and which ones aren't. Not how to fix it. Just... which ones.

  • PARCC charged states $29.50 per student to take a test. Smarter Balanced charged $22.50. States defected from PARCC not because the test was bad, but because the bill arrived before anyone had bought the computers to take the test on. The hidden cost of switching to computer-based testing — laptops, Wi-Fi, IT staff — accounted for 40–50% of total Common Core transition costs in low-income districts. We spent billions upgrading technology so children could sit in front of screens to prove they couldn't read.

  • The Common Core rollout cost an estimated $15.8 billion over seven years. The federal government seeded it with $4.35 billion in Race to the Top grants. NAEP reading scores, after all that investment? Stagnant. For the lowest-performing students — the ones in the 10th and 25th percentiles — scores actually dropped. The grand piano, as they say, has left the building.

And now, the Science of Reading is projected to cost between $1.2 billion and $1.8 billion per year nationally, across 38+ states that have enacted SoR legislation. That's every year. Not a one-time investment. Every. Single. Year.

So yes. We would like a receipt. And a return policy.

The New Snake Oil: Now With Peer-Reviewed Packaging

To be clear about what we are buying, here is the annual national SoR shopping cart:

Line ItemAnnual Estimated Cost
Professional Development & Retraining (LETRS, Orton-Gillingham, etc.)$500M – $700M/year
Literacy Coaches & Specialists$450M – $650M/year
Curriculum Replacements & Screeners$250M – $450M/year
Total Annual National Investment$1.2B – $1.8B/year

Per student, the multi-year rollout runs $120 to $180 per K–3 child in most states — or, if you live in California, a breezy $700 to $900+ per student under the state's Literacy Coaches and Reading Specialists (LCRS) grant program, which has allocated over $1.2 billion cumulatively and sends minimum grants of $450,000 per school site directly to local districts where, in some cases, coaches end up doing substitute teaching and administrative filing.

Meanwhile, Mississippi — the state everyone held up as the model — runs its entire statewide SoR operation on roughly $15 million a year. That's not a typo. Fifteen million. For the whole state. And they moved from 49th in 4th-grade reading to the national average.

California spends 80 times more than Mississippi and produces... variable results, because local control means every district does whatever it wants with the money.

This is the education reform industrial complex in its purest form: take a model that works because it's lean, centralized, and accountable, then scale it up by removing all three of those qualities and adding several hundred million dollars in administrative overhead.

The Elephant in the Classroom: Doom Scrolling Did More Damage Than Any Curriculum

Here's the part that the SoR sales pitch tends to gloss over, and it's the part that should make every taxpayer pause before signing the check.

The PISA 2025 report — the gold-standard international scorecard for how well 15-year-olds can read — found that global reading scores dropped 28 points over the last decade. That is, as the Big Education Ape noted with characteristic precision, "the educational equivalent of watching a grand piano fall off a skyscraper in slow motion." Nearly 1.5 years of formal schooling, evaporated.

The culprit isn't balanced literacy. It isn't three-cueing. It isn't even the absence of decodable readers.

It's the algorithm.

PISA researchers identified the rise of the "Hasty Reader" — students who skim, guess, and abandon anything requiring more than 30 seconds of sustained thought. Between 2018 and 2025, this category of reader nearly doubled, reaching 11% of students. Fluent, accurate readers dropped by 7 percentage points. Students' scores degraded within the test itself — their cognitive endurance gave out mid-assessment, their brains trained by infinite scroll to expect a dopamine hit every eight seconds.

Students who used AI chatbots to shortcut their reading comprehension performed measurably worse than those who didn't.

So here is the honest question that nobody in the SoR rollout is being asked to answer under oath:

If the primary driver of reading decline is algorithmic attention destruction and screen-based cognitive fragmentation, what exactly is $1.8 billion worth of phonics training going to do about TikTok?

We are spending billions teaching children how to decode words at the precise historical moment when the entire digital ecosystem is engineering them to never sit still long enough to read a sentence. That's not a Science of Reading problem. That's a civilization problem. And no amount of LETRS certification stipends fixes it.

The Guarantee We Should Be Demanding

Here is the modest proposal. If the publishers, consultants, curriculum vendors, and professional development companies selling SoR products are so confident in the science — if LETRS is truly the transformative training it's marketed as, if decodable readers are the silver bullet, if the whole $1.8 billion annual apparatus is going to measurably move the needle — then they should have absolutely no problem signing the following:

A performance-based contract. With a refund clause.

Improve reading proficiency by X percentage points within Y years, or return the money. Simple. Elegant. The kind of accountability we demand from every other industry that takes public money and promises results.

Because here's what we know from the Common Core era: the vendors got paid regardless. Pearson got paid. The testing consortia got paid. The professional development consultants got paid. The curriculum publishers got paid. And when the scores didn't move — when the lowest-performing students fell further behind — nobody wrote a check back to the school districts of Mississippi or Ohio or California.

The teachers got blamed. The students got labeled. And the vendors started pitching the next solution.

What Teachers Are Actually Saying About SoR

It would be a journalistic crime to write this article without noting that the people closest to actual children — the teachers — have thoughts about the Science of Reading rollout, and those thoughts are not uniformly enthusiastic.

Here is what educators on the ground are reporting:

  • Mandatory, off-hours retraining with stipends of $500–$1,200 per teacher sounds generous until you realize it's compensation for completing 30–60 hours of coursework on top of a full teaching load, while also managing classrooms, grading, and the general ongoing emergency that is American public education in 2026.

  • Script-heavy curricula — the kind that tell teachers exactly what words to say, in what order, with what materials — are being experienced by many veteran educators not as professional empowerment but as professional deskilling. "I've been teaching reading for 22 years," one teacher told a state board of education. "Now I'm reading from a script like I'm a substitute."

  • English Language Learner advocates have raised substantive concerns that SoR's emphasis on phonemic awareness in English, while scientifically valid for monolingual English speakers, does not adequately account for the linguistic complexity of students acquiring English as a second language. The science of reading for a child who speaks Spanish at home is not identical to the science of reading for a child who has heard English since birth.

  • Special education teachers note that while structured literacy is genuinely effective for students with dyslexia, the wholesale application of a single instructional model to every child in every classroom ignores the extraordinary diversity of learning profiles that teachers navigate daily.

  • And perhaps most pointedly: teachers keep saying the same thing they have been saying for 40 years, through every reform wave, every new standard, every new curriculum mandate. Give us smaller classes. Give us more adults in the room. Give us time to actually know our students.

The Inconvenient Truth That No Curriculum Vendor Will Put in Their Brochure

Here is the finding that the education reform industry has been quietly burying under PowerPoint slides and grant applications for decades:

The single most consistent predictor of improved student reading outcomes is the ratio of caring, trained adults to children.

Not the curriculum. Not the standards. Not the screener software. Not the decodable reader set.

Adults. Per child.

Mississippi's "miracle" wasn't just about phonics. It was about deploying state-employed literacy coaches directly into classrooms — human beings, working one-on-one and in small groups, modeling lessons, analyzing data, and building relationships with teachers and students. The curriculum was the vehicle. The coach was the engine.

And yet, when states scale up SoR, the first thing that gets diluted is the human capital ratio. California sends $450,000 grants to school sites and then watches as coaches get reassigned to cover absent teachers. Ohio buys $64 million worth of new textbooks. The vendors celebrate. The coaches disappear into the administrative machinery.

Smaller class sizes — which every teacher, every parent, and every piece of longitudinal research consistently identifies as among the highest-leverage investments in student learning — remain chronically underfunded because they don't generate vendor contracts, don't produce publishable curricula, and don't create the kind of scalable, packageable, marketable "solution" that education reform investors can pitch at conferences.

You cannot sell "hire more teachers and put fewer kids in each room" at a ed-tech summit. There's no app for it. There's no licensing fee. There's no professional development module. There's just... a human being, with time, and a child who needs to learn to read.

The Bottom Line: What We're Spending vs. What We're Getting

ReformTotal CostNAEP Reading ImpactWho Got Paid
Common Core (2010–2020)~$15.8B over 7 yearsStagnant; lowest performers declinedPearson, testing consortia, PD vendors
Annual Standardized Testing~$1.7B/year ongoingTells us who's poor; doesn't fix itPearson, AIR, Cambium, DRC
Science of Reading (current)$1.2B–$1.8B/yearTBD — ask us in 2030LETRS, OG vendors, curriculum publishers
Smaller Class SizesHigher upfront; lower long-termConsistently positiveTeachers. Children. Society.

The Ask: Simple, Reasonable, Overdue

We are not saying the Science of Reading is wrong. We are saying that right is not the same as sufficient, and evidence-based is not the same as guaranteed.

We are saying that $1.8 billion a year — on top of $1.7 billion a year in testing that doesn't improve outcomes — deserves the same accountability we demand from any other public expenditure.

We are saying that if Amplify, Voyager Sopris, LETRS, and every other vendor in the SoR ecosystem is confident enough in their product to lobby state legislatures for mandatory adoption, they should be confident enough to sign a performance contract with a refund clause.

Improve proficiency by a defined, measurable amount. In a defined timeframe. Or give the money back.

And while we're at it — before we spend another generation's worth of education dollars on the next miracle curriculum — let's try the intervention that has never once failed to show results in the research literature:

More adults. Smaller classes. Less testing. More teaching.

It's not glamorous. It doesn't have a logo. Nobody's going to give a TED Talk about it.

But it works. And unlike the last four education reforms, it won't need a rebranding in ten years.

The Big Education Ape has been documenting the education reform industrial complex since before "disruption" was a compliment. The data in this article reflects current state legislative allocations, federal grant records, and NAEP/PISA assessment findings through 2026. The cynicism is the author's own, earned honestly, over many years of watching the same piano fall.




Sources & References

Show Me the Money-Back Guarantee: The Science of Reading's $1.8 Billion Snake Oil Problem


🔬 Science of Reading — Policy, Legislation & State Rollouts


💰 SoR Funding — State-by-State Financial Data


📊 Common Core State Standards — Cost & Outcome Data


📝 Standardized Testing Costs — PARCC, SBAC & National Data


📉 NAEP & Reading Score Data


🌍 PISA 2025 — Global Reading Decline & "Hasty Reader" Data


👩‍🏫 Teacher Perspectives & Curriculum Concerns


🏫 Class Size & Human Capital Research


🏛️ Three-Cueing Bans — State Legislative Sources


Note: Some archived links (particularly PARCC) may require Wayback Machine access. All state legislative links reflect official government databases. PISA 2025 data was released in September 2026 by the OECD and NCES simultaneously.