Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, February 25, 2012

Schools Matter: New York Teachers "Assaulted and Compromised:" Lawyers Line Up

Schools Matter: New York Teachers "Assaulted and Compromised:" Lawyers Line Up:

New York Teachers "Assaulted and Compromised:" Lawyers Line Up

When the swindlers of Wall Street joined the education industry to try to make American schools a corporate revenue stream that could not be outsourced, no one who had been watching their cynical maneuvering doubted that teacher professionalism would be the first line of attack in breaking any potential resistance to their charterizing plan. With employment and job insecurity dependent upon the vagaries of test score gains, the Business Roundtable's education industry would have control of not only how learning is mismeasured, but also what is taught and how it is taught. The test would be the chief tool of control.

The current publication of test scores in New York sets a new low for how political whores in Albany and the corporate whores of the media (hello, NYTimes) can join forces to do their ugly work. A clip from the Times:
The ratings, known as teacher data reports, covered three school years ending in 2010, and are

A longer school year? Two responses

skrashen at Schools Matter - 8 hours ago
Two Letters sent to the Orange County Register, Feb 24, in response to “O.C. education chief: students need more school,” Feb. 23. (Richard Moore, Stephen Krashen0 We are on the brink of bankruptcy... and he wants a longer school year? We have the highest poverty rate among industrialized countries, a more powerful predictor of academic success than any other... and it never comes up? We have only 75 schools out of 600 in OC with fully functioning/staffed libraries... and we are surprised by low reading scores? He holds his "summit" at a time when teachers are teaching... so he ... more »

Stand with Corey Husic in Demanding an End to Climate Miseducation by Heartland Institute

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 12 hours ago
Go to Climate Reality and support these high school students in calling out the propagandists at the Heartland Institite.

Diane Ravitch Pt. 2 in New York Review of Books

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 12 hours ago
Last week the New York State Education Department and the teachers’ unions reached an agreement to allow the state to use student test scores to evaluate teachers. The pact was brought to a conclusion after Governor Andrew Cuomo warned the parties that if they didn’t come to an agreement quickly, he would impose his own solution (though he did not explain what that would be). He further told school districts that they would lose future state aid if they didn’t promptly implement the agreement after it was released to the public. The reason for this urgency was to secure $700 million... more »

Lobbyists Making the Rounds In Tallahassee for Bill Offering More in Corporate Welfare Check for Charters

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 1 day ago
From Miami Herald: By Kathleen McGrory and Scott Hiaasen shiaasen@miamiherald.com A legislative plan to give charter schools a cut of local school districts’ construction money would steer millions of additional dollars to large charter-school networks that are already sitting on tens of millions of dollars in cash, records show. The charter-school industry is lobbying hard in the capital to gain a share of tax dollars raised by school districts to cover the construction and maintenance costs of traditional public schools — tax revenue that has dropped dramatically in recent years... more »

Perfect Hour for Parents, Ed Students, and Teachers During Black History Month

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 3 days ago
Posted at WeAreMany: *Still Separate, Still Unequal: Racism, Class and the Attack on Public Education * With Brian Jones Public education is under an unprecedented attack. The powerful people who want to privatize our schools are using many different means: charter schools, mayoral control, high stakes standardized testing, school closures, merit pay and attacking teacher unions are all a part of this assault. Often, these "reformers" claim that the sweeping changes they want will bring genuine educational justice for communities that have long been underserved -- especially for... more »

Reconsidering testing in Texas

skrashen at Schools Matter - 3 days ago
Reconsidering testing: Some fundamentals Sent to the Austin-American Statesman, Feb 21, 2012 A year's delay to reconsider the role of testing is a very good idea (“It’s smart to step back on STARR,” Feb 20). I hope that those assigned to study this issue will look at the evidence showing that increased testing does not result in increased achievement, the evidence showing that teacher evaluation of high school students (grades) is a better predictor of college success than standardized test scores (the SAT), and studies showing how much time is spent on “test preparation” (activities ... more »

The Bookmooch plan: An easy way to help close the achievement gap in literacy and clean up your clutter at the same time

skrashen at Schools Matter - 4 days ago
There is overwhelming evidence that those who live in poverty have little access to books at home, in schools and in public and school libraries, and that the lack of access to books impacts literacy development, and also results in less knowledge of the world. Research, in fact, strngly suggests that lack of access to books is the major reason for the literacy “achievement gap,” the difference in reading ability between children coming from higher and lower income families. Someday, ebooks might be available at a reasonable cost for everybody. But until this happens, I would like ... more »

Become the Lesson You Want Your Children to Learn: Stand Up, Opt Out

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 4 days ago
*To stop the madness, we must stop the madness. There is too much money involved to think that the testing industrial complex will suddenly acknowledge their crimes against children and decide to call it a day. * *Join Aaryn and Sam Belfer--write your school superintendent and rescue your children from the pressure cooker. They used a template to craft their own letter. Here is one of many you can use. * *February 16, 2012* * Bill Kowba* * Superintendent of Schools* * San Diego Unified School District* * 4100 Normal Street, Room 2219* * San Diego, CA 92103* *Dear Mr. Kowba,* *... more »

Corporate Charter Lobbyists Go After Florida School Construction Money

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 4 days ago
With hundreds of millions already in the bank, the vulture philanthropists and their hopped-up hedge funders are looking for more cash for their corporate welfare charter schools. Will the Florida State Legislature destroy the bond ratings of state public schools to win the next election? From *Miami Herald*: By Kathleen McGrory and Scott Hiaasen shiaasen@miamiherald.com A legislative plan to give charter schools a cut of local school districts’ construction money would steer millions of additional dollars to large charter-school networks that are already sitting on tens of millio... more »

Untitled

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 4 days ago
In 2001, the PR firms that the Business Roundtable hired to sell their plan to blow up public schools and to rebuild them in the corporate image for corporate benefit could not have settled on a more cynical and appealing mantra: we must close the achievement gap, and NCLB is the way to do it. Now over ten years later, the gaps are still gaping and growing wider as the achievement disparities map click by click onto to the diverging lines on the inequality chart between rich and poor. Who would have guessed that applying thumbscrews to the most vulnerable of the nation’s teachers an... more »

Rushing Toward the Cliff While “Tweaking” the “Quirks”

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 4 days ago
In 2001, the PR firms that the Business Roundtable hired tosell their plan to blow up public schools and to rebuild them in the corporateimage for corporate benefit could not have settled on a more cynical andappealing mantra: we must close the achievement gap, and NCLB is the way to doit. Now over ten years later, the gaps are still gaping andgrowing wider as the achievement disparities map click by click onto to thediverging lines on the inequality chart between rich and poor. Who would haveguessed that applying thumbscrews to the most vulnerable of the nation’steachers and stude... more »

Charles Murray, KIPP, and the Second Coming of Eugenics

Jim Horn at Schools Matter - 5 days ago
A similar version of this commentary was published by *Substance News*earlier today: The old-school eugenics of the previous century was aimed to eradicate all sorts of unfit and anti-social behavior, from theft to laziness to wandering to sexual deviance. The source of these problems was thought to be a biological defect in the genes, or germ plasm, as that mysteriously-determinative substance was known a hundred years ago. With the rise of behaviorism and the eventual scientific acceptance of what common sense has always told us about the importance of environment in shaping org... more »

Rethinking Teacher Quality and Metrics-mania

P. L. Thomas at Schools Matter - 5 days ago
Once President Barack Obama referred to the claim that teacher quality translates directly into increasing lifetime earnings of students, that assertion and connected study are destined to remain in the public domain in the same way that claims about three quality teachers in a row has persisted. These claims share something other than being quickly and broadly embraced, however; they are also misleading, incomplete, and harmful to our understanding and pursuit of higher teacher quality (see DiCarlo on three great teachers in a row claims and NEPC's review of NBER study connecting ... more »

Jersey Jazzman: The Continuing Humiliation of Teachers

Jersey Jazzman: The Continuing Humiliation of Teachers:

The Continuing Humiliation of Teachers

First, it was LA; now, it's NYC. So why, exactly, do we need to release teacher evaluation data that's out of date, error-prone (53% margin of error?!?!), and can't be used by the public to do anything anyway? What the hell is the point?

Well, let's go back to the LA Times, which led the way in releasing this dreck. What was their justification for releasing (really bad) teacher ratings back in 2010?
Critics, and especially union leaders, railed against The Times' decision to release this information, saying that it unfairly casts teachers as good or bad. They predicted that parents would throng local schools demanding that their children be assigned to one teacher or another based on scores that are at best an incomplete measure of a teacher's effectiveness.

Test scores are indeed just one indicator of a teacher's performance. It's too early to

SchoolBook - Who, What and Why of Teacher Ratings #soschat

SchoolBook - New York City schools news, data and conversation:

The Teacher Data Reports on SchoolBook: An Explanation

SchoolBook at SchoolBook - 10 hours ago
SchoolBook has published the teacher data reports using a new tool that was created by interactive journalists at The New York Times and WNYC. The goal of the tool: to make the data easier to understand and put the rankings into context. Read our explanation.

Release of Teacher Data Is Widely Denounced

Anna M. Phillips at SchoolBook - 10 hours ago
Outside the doors of the Tweed Courthouse, the headquarters of the city's Education Department, there were few champions on Friday of the release of individual performance rankings of 18,000 public school teachers.

An Audio Report on the Who, What and Why of Teacher Ratings

Patricia Willens at SchoolBook - 10 hours ago
WNYC asks its own Beth Fertig and Rob Gebeloff of The New York Times to analyze the teacher data reports and the impact of their release on "All Things Considered." They offer a thoughtful but concise summary. Take a listen.

After Championing Release, City Says It Did Not Want Teacher Data Public

Anna M. Phillips at SchoolBook - 10 hours ago
In a guide sent to public school principals on Friday, city officials suggested that they respond to upset teachers' concerns by telling them that the Department of Education "did not support the release of this data; we were required to do so by the courts." But it was the Education Department that stoked the media's interest in pursuing publication of the teacher reports.

The Response on Twitter

Chris Palmer at SchoolBook - 14 hours ago
Many teachers, advocates, journalists and others have used Twitter these past few days to comment on the release of the teacher data reports. Here's a slice of the day's rolling conversation.

Teachers React to Release of Data

Maria Newman at SchoolBook - 16 hours ago
Teachers throughout the city have been objecting to the public release on Friday of individual teacher performance rankings. Some listed complaints. Others wanted to explain why they got the ratings they did and to try to put them in perspective. Here are some of their comments.

Two Chancellors, Two Different Public Views on Teacher Ratings

Beth Fertig at SchoolBook - 17 hours ago
Chancellor Dennis M. Walcott has expressed reluctance about releasing thousands of individual teacher ratings to the public, striking a different tone if not a different outcome from that of his predecessor, Joel I. Klein, who paved the way for their release.

Queens Students Use Break to Test Science and Music App

Beth Fertig at SchoolBook - 19 hours ago
Ever since the iPad was introduced two years ago, educators and publishers have been developing ways to use its touch-screen technology in the classroom. So has the Icelandic singer Bjork. Her latest album is designed as a touch-screen application to teach about science and music. WNYC’s Beth Fertig caught up with some students in Queens trying out the new app during their winter break.

Teachers, Reply to Your Data Report Here

SchoolBook at SchoolBook - 20 hours ago
Here is the form to respond to your teacher data report.

City Teacher Data Reports Are Released

Fernanda Santos at SchoolBook - 21 hours ago
UPDATED | After a long legal battle and amid much anguish by teachers and other educators, the city Department of Education released individual performance rankings of 18,000 New York City public school teachers to the public on Friday. The rankings are now available on SchoolBook, listed by school.

College Racial Gap Continues to Grow

Mary Ann Giordano at SchoolBook - 1 day ago
Richard Perez-Pena reports in The New York Times that the nation reached a milestone as of last March, with more than 30 percent of American adults holding at least a bachelor's degree, and nearly 11 percent holding at least a master's degree. That is up from 26.2 percent and 8.7 percent 10 years earlier. But the news is less hopeful when it comes to blacks and Latinos, "who not only continue to trail far behind whites, the gap has also widened in the last decade."

Nine Schools Cited for Exam and Credit Irregularities

Anna M. Phillips at SchoolBook - 1 day ago
The City Education Department has called for investigations into nine high schools for irregularities in the way the schools scored examinations or awarded credits, and has identified hundreds of students in the city who were allowed to graduate without meeting basic requirements.

Queens School Aide Arrested in Sexual Abuse Case

schoolbook at SchoolBook - 1 day ago
A school aide in Queens was arrested Thursday on charges of sexually abusing a student younger than 11 years old, the police said, becoming the fifth city school worker charged in the last few weeks with sexual crimes against children.

Teachers: An Invitation to Respond to Your Data Report

Jodi Rudoren at SchoolBook - 1 day ago
UPDATED | The New York Times, like other news organizations in the city and the Department of Education itself, will soon publish the teacher data reports that were the subject of a prolonged Freedom of Information effort. In SchoolBook’s spirit of conversation and community contribution, we are inviting any teacher who was rated to provide her or his response or explanation. We plan to include those responses alongside the ratings themselves, so readers can consider them together. You can find the response form in this post.

School Admissions? Even the Experts Are Overwhelmed

Jenny Anderson at SchoolBook - 1 day ago
Feeling overwhelmed by the search for a school for your young child? An expert in test preparation shares your pain.

Gates Defends Teachers, Denounces Public ‘Shaming’

Mary Ann Giordano at SchoolBook - 1 day ago
In an opinion article in Thursday's New York Times, Bill Gates -- famous for Microsoft and his Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, a deep-pocketed supporter of causes related to school reform, including more accountability for teachers -- comes out strongly against the release of teacher data reports, calling it a public shaming of teachers.

Five Students Arrested a Day, Police Data Show

Anna M. Phillips at SchoolBook - 2 days ago
New figures on police activity in city schools show that in the fall, safety agents and officers arrested about five students a day. On Wednesday, advocates used this statistic to criticize the city for giving the Police Department too much control over discipline in schools.

Why February?

Yasmeen Khan at SchoolBook - 2 days ago
Like many other neighboring districts, New York City public school students and teachers are enjoying a week off for midwinter recess. The break started as an energy-saving measure in the 1970s and later became an annual tradition because of a budget deal between the city and teachers.

Ravitch Says New Evaluation System Is ‘Madness’

Mary Ann Giordano at SchoolBook - 3 days ago
The public schools may be closed all week for February Break, but critics and other writers are busy examining the new teacher evaluation agreement that was reached last week. Among the critics: Diane Ravitch and The Daily News columnist, Juan Gonzalez.

New Rules Planned for School Vending Machines Nationwide

Mary Ann Giordano at SchoolBook - 4 days ago
It's too soon to tell whether the switch to healthier food in school cafeterias -- and in school vending machines -- has had a discernible effect on childhood obesity in New York City. But now the Obama administration seems to be following in New York's footsteps and is considering imposing similar vending machine rules on all the nation's schools, The New York Times reports on Tuesday.