Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, January 4, 2020

KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all


KEEP UP/ CATCH UP WITH DIANE RAVITCH'S BLOG 
A site to discuss better education for all

Slaying Goliath: The Passionate Resistance to Privatization and the Fight to Save America's Public Schools





John Thompson: Why Is Tulsa in Crisis?

John Thompson is a historian and a retired teacher, who blogs often, here and on other blogs. He has keen insight into what’s happening in Oklahoma. He writes: Since 2015, the Tulsa Public Schools have cut $22 million from its budget, even dipping into its reserve fund to balance the books. Now it must cut another $20 million. Given the huge support for the TPS by local and national edu-philanthr
Audrey Watters: Don’t Believe the Techno-Pundits and Don’t Put a Ring Camera in Your Home

Audrey Watters may be our most articulate critic of tech obsession. I enjoy her regular posts, and her ability to connect birds with events. Open this link to see what I mean. She begins every post with a bird and finds a way to connect it to what she is thinking about. In this post, she begins with: This week’s Columbidae is the Gallicolumba luzonica — the Luzon Bleeding Heart Dove. The bird, wh

YESTERDAY

Happy Birthday, Lucretia Mott!

A gem from Garrison Keillor’s daily website “A Writer’s Almanac”: Today is the birthday of women’s rights reformer Lucretia (Coffin) Mott , born in Nantucket, Massachusetts, in 1793. She went to public school in Boston for two years, and then, when she was 13, she enrolled in a Quaker boarding school near Poughkeepsie, New York. After two years there, she was hired on as an assistant, and then a
Angie Sullivan Tells Every Nevada Legislator to Read SLAYING GOLIATH

Angie Sullivan teaches in a Title 1 elementary school in Carson County, Nevada. She teaches the children who were left behind. She sent this post to every legislator in Nevada: A small group of vocal teachers, parents, and activists have been publicly concerned about national public school privatization for two decades. Diane Ravitch is the leader of that pack. Her new book is coming out soon. He
The Most Important School Case Before the U.S. Supreme Court This Session

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear a case called Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue that will determine whether the United States–or any state–may still respect a separation of church and state. In the wake of Donald Trump’s choice of two far-right Justices to the Supreme Court, this case might well be decided in a way that removes all prohibitions on the use of public funds for religious sc
Carol Burris Cites DeVos to Prove Failure of Federal Charter School Program

The Network for Public Education has issued two reports documenting waste, fraud, and lack of oversight in the federal Charter Schools Program. The CSP was created by the Clinton administration in 1994 at a time when there were few charters; it was intended to give aid to start-ups. Over the years it has evolved into a slush fund for rapacious corporate charter chains and for the advocacy groups
These Are the Court Cases That Could Reshape K-12 Education in 2020

The courts have become the arbiters of much that happens in American education. The U.S. Supreme Court now has a 5-4 conservative majority, due to Trump’s appointment of two Justices. This article summarizes the most important court cases of 2020. The country is three years deep into Donald Trump’s presidency, which has seen, among other changes, significant policy overhauls from the U.S. Departm
Jennifer Berkshire: The Democratic Candidates and Their School Choice Problem

Jennifer Berkshire writes in The Nation about the quandary of Democratic candidates . For years, charter schools had bipartisan support. Clinton and Obama both supported charter schools, and joined with Republicans to expand the federal Charter Schools Program, which is now the single biggest source of funding for charter schools at $440 million annually (the second biggest source is the Walton F

JAN 02

Harold Meyerson: Bloomberg as “the Manchurian Candidate”

Harold Meyerson adds a few reasons to believe that Michael Bloomberg is not the right candidate to beat Trump: January 2, 2020 Meyerson on TAP Bloomberg: The Manchurian Candidate. If there’s anyone out there who believes Michael Bloomberg would be a strong candidate to unseat Donald Trump, a very well-documented story in today’s Washington Post should tank any such delusions. Some of the particul
John Merrow Cancels His Congratulations to You

Last week, John Merrow posted his congratulations to readers for matching up with an algorithm that selected them to make a substantial contribution to a worthy organization. In this post, he cancels his congratulations and explains why he was in error–or just kidding around.
Houston: Community Members and Students Speak Out Against State Takeover of HISD

The following statement was released on New Year’s Day by Community Voices for Public Education, a coalition of parents and students in Houston. As their statement demonstrates, the state takeover is a fraud intended to strip the school district of its elected school board and to replace it with a hand-picked governing board selected by a non-educator who wants to privatize public education. It i
Houston: The Betrayal of the Public Schools As State Attacks Democracy

The public schools of Houston are going to be taken over by the incompetent State Education Department, which has never run a school district of any size and which has failed in its previous takeover efforts. The Houston Chronicle hailed the pending takeover, while noting that the Houston Independent School District has been acknowledged in the recent past as the best urban school district in the
A Book You Should Own That Explains Education Today

Perhaps you have been confused by the proliferation of organizations that claim to be all about fixing schools and teachers. Perhaps you can’t figure out who is who in the galaxy of billionaire-funded world of fake reformers. Buy this reference book! I t names names! It is the glossary you have been waiting for! EDSPEAK AND DOUBLETALK: A Glossary to Decipher Hypocrisy and Save Public Schooling. I
Politico on Trump’s Busy Day

Politico reports: TRUMP’S THURSDAY — The president has nothing on his public schedule. He could always go golfing. Or tweet all day. So much yo do. So little time.
G.F. Brandenburg: U.S. Teachers Work Longer Hours Than Their Peers in Most Every Other Country

G.F. Brandenburg posted a graph from a recent report of the OECD –the same organization that sponsors the PISA tests–which shows the number of hours that teachers work in every country tested. Teachers in the United States reported working an average of 46.2 hours a week, according to the Teaching and Learning International Survey , which was coordinated by the Organization for Economic Cooperati

JAN 01

Los Angeles: Tragic Death of Integration Advocate

Courtney Everts Mykytyn was a force of nature in Los Angeles, where she led the fight for racially integrated schools. She founded an organization called “Integrated Schools,” which posted on its Facebook page the news of her tragic death in an automobile accident on Monday. She was struck and killed in front of her home. Go to the website to read more about Integrated Schools and its mission. To
My New Year’s Day Adventure

Today I did something I had never done before. I went to Coney Island, the fabled beach on the coast of the Atlantic Ocean in Brooklyn, to watch the Polar Bears Club take their annual New Year’s Day plunge. The Polar Bears have been doing this since 1903. The weather was pretty good. About 40 degrees, but a strong wind was occasionally gusting, making it seem colder. Thousands of people were ther
Justice John Roberts Defends the Independence of the Federal Judiciary

Over the past three years, Trump and Mitch McConnell have worked tirelessly to stuff the federal judiciary with extremists, libertarians, and lawyers who were unwilling to say that the Brown decision was correctly decided. Trump’s attack on the judiciary will outlast his time in office since federal judges have lifetime appointments. On the bright side, Chief Justice John Roberts has defended the
The First Review Of “Slaying Goliath!”

Thomas Ultican, retired teacher of advanced mathematics and physics in California, has written the first review of my new book SLAYING GOLIATH: THE PASSIONATE RESISTANCE TO PRIVATIZATION AND THE FIGHT TO SAVE AMERICA’S SCHOOLS. He liked it! He calls it “spiritually uplifting” and describes it (accurately) as a “fight to save the commons.” Enjoy!
Here Are My New Year’s Resolutions: What Are Yours?

I seldom write New Year’s Resolutions because they tend to state all the things I haven’t been doing and want to do differently but probably won’t. So here is what I would like to do. Take better care of my health. Ride my indoor bike 20 minutes every day. Every day. Walk outdoors at least a mile a day (which I do by walking my 100-pound dog Mitzi). Read fiction. Spend less time blogging. Lose we
Happy New Year!

To everyone who reads this blog, I thank you and wish you a happy, healthy New Year! Thank you being part of this wonderful community of people who care passionately about children, education, and the common good. May you find many reasons for joy, many reasons to celebrate, many reasons to feel happiness in your work and your daily life! Look around you and find the goodness and the beauty in on

DEC 31 2019

Audrey Watters: The Most Important Post of the Decade: The 100 Worst EdTech Disasters of the Decade

I just opened my email and discovered this brilliant post by Audrey Watters , whose critical voice on EdTech is indispensable. Watters lists the 100 biggest EdTech debacles of the past decade, and seeing them all in one place is astonishing. What strikes me is the combination of unadulterated arrogance (i.e., chutzpah), coupled with repeated failures. What is also impressive are the number of ent
Garrison Keillor on the Traditions of New Year’s Eve

I recently subscribed to Garrison Keillor’s daily “Writer’s Almanac.” He sends poems and interesting stories. Here is one from today’s missive: Today is New Year’s Eve , in which the old year is ushered out, and the new one welcomed in, with parties, socializing, and alcohol — often champagne. In the United States, we have a tradition of dropping, or raising, a large object exactly at midnight. T
Robert Shepherd’s Not Really 2020 Resolutions

Bob Shepherd writes, tongue in cheek: New Years Resolutions, 2020: A Report from Trumplandia Peace derives, of course, from within—from detachment of the kind I seek in my daily mindfulness meditation practice. But it’s not about me, never about me. For this reason I shall continue to engage in worldly affairs despite my instinctive, bookish reticence. Nothing’s really changed in my priorities fo
Thomas Ultican: The Best Book of 2019

Thomas Ultican recommends Kochland as far and away the best book of 2019. He begins: This may be the finest book thus far in the twenty-first century. Kochland; The Secret History of Koch Industries and Corporate Power in America is the second book by former agribusiness reporter for the Associated Press, Christopher Leonard. His first book, The Meat Racket; The Secret Takeover of America’s Food
John Merrow: The Governor’s Inaugural Address That You Have Been Longing to Hear

John Merrow writes here about the Governor’s Inaugural Address. It could be delivered in any state. It should be delivered in every state. It is about the importance of education to creating the future we all hope for. Read the entire address and email it to your governor. Perhaps he or she will crib a few lines. Let’s remind ourselves that public education serves an important public purpose . Ye
Fulfilling FDR’s Dream: His Second Bill of Rights

I have engaged in a heated exchange off line with people who are upset about taxing billionaires. They feel sure that taxing the 1% or the .00025% is a slippery slope, and soon enough we will all pay taxes so high that we will have to give up our homes. This is a good time, I think, to revisit Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s 1944 State of the Union Address. FDR came from the landed gentry but he some

DEC 30 2019

A Film You Should See: “Where Is My Roy Cohn?”

On a flight yesterday, I watched a documentary that was a biography of Roy Cohn. It is called “Where Is My Roy Cohn?,” a phrase uttered by Trump when he was disgusted by his attorney general, Jeff Sessions, who apparently had some scruples about destroying the Justice Department on behalf of the man who appointed him. The biography is short. The story is compelling. It portrays a man who had abso
Mike Rose: Why Teaching “Grit” Is Not Necessarily a Good Thing

Mike Rose opined a few years back about “grit” and its limitations. This is one of those articles that is never dated. Rose, one of my favorite authors, writes: In a nutshell, I worry about the limited success of past attempts at character education and the danger in our pendulum-swing society that we will shift our attention from improving subject matter instruction. I also question the easy dis
Education Law Center Opposes Charter School Pre-School Programs in New Jersey’s Poorest Districts

The Education Law Center is one of the nation’s pre-eminent civil rights organizations committed to improving equality of educational opportunity. It points out in the following release that the charter schools have never signed the legally required contracts to participate in court-ordered universal pre-school programs in the state’s poorest districts, the “Abbott Districts.” About Us News ‌ ‌ D
The Teacher Strikes: Teachers Speak Out about Their Activism

California Sunday Magazine published interviews with teachers about their role in striking, walking out, negotiating, bargaining. It begins: On February 22, 2018, some 20,000 teachers in West Virginia — many of them wearing red in solidarity — walked out of their classrooms. That April saw strikes in Arizona, Colorado, and Oklahoma, as teachers vented their collective frustration in what became k
Chalkbeat: How GreatSchools Inc. Contributes to Segregation

Matt Barnum and Gabrielle LaMarr LeMee wrote a provocative article a bout the way that a private school rating agency rates schools and steers patents toward white affluent schools and away from schools where children of color predominate. Larry Cuban reposted the article on his blog. GreatSchools ratings effectively penalize schools that serve largely low-income students and those serving largel

DEC 29 2019

Kentucky: First Charter School

Kentucky passed a law authorizing charters but never provided funding for them. The new governor of Kentucky, Democrat Andy Beshears, was elected in part because of his strong support by teachers and his commitment to public schools. https://www.fox19.com/2019/12/28/latest-kentucky-news-sports-business-entertainment-am-est/ CHARTER SCHOOL-DENIED First charter school application in Kentucky reject
Reader: I Taught SAT Prep. It’s a Sham.

An anonymous reader left this comment about the SAT. Once upon a time, 25 years ago, I ‘offered’ SAT tutoring (at a rather high price of $50/hr.) to denizens of a tony private school. I could charge that much because I ‘got results’. But, it was rather easy to improve scores. First, there was the fact that almost all of my clients had scored ‘too low’ when they first took the test. The probabilit
A Powerful Statement by Russian College Student on Trial for His Words

This is a beautiful and powerful statement spoken in court by a young man on trial for “extremism” in a Russian court. It was translated by Masha Gessen and appears in The New Yorker online. it explains the power of Resistance to tyranny and the importance of individual responsibility and love. Gessen writes: A twenty-one-year-old university student named Yegor Zhukov stood accused of “extremism,
Robin Lithgow: Christmas Time for Boy Actors in the Tudor Age

Robin Lithgow, former director of arts education in the Los Angeles school district, is writing a history of arts education for children. This the last of her installments about the boy choirs in England, and it is enthralling. “Let’s start with the tradition of the Boy Bishop, celebrated all over Europe, dating back to the the early years of Christianity. In English villages the Boy Bishop was t
Robin Lithgow on the History of Boys’ Acting Companies: The “Little Eyasas”

Robin Lithgow, former director of arts education for the Los Angeles public schools, has been researching the history of children’s theater, in particular, the boys’ acting companies that were popular in England. This is Part 4 of her series. She begins: If you’ve been on the edge of your seat waiting for this final post on the boys’ companies active in the Tudor Age, you are probably alone, and

DEC 28 2019

Sue Altman: A Leader of the Resistance in New Jersey Fights the Democratic Machine

New Jersey is a corrupt state, whose Democratic leadership controls the state and patronage. The Democratic machine worked happily with Republican Governor Chris Christie. The Working Families Party is fighting to upend the Democratic establishment, whose titular head is boss George Norcross, who happens to be a member of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago club and the Democratic National Committee. One WFP memb
Mercedes Schneider Discusses Richard Phelps’ Critical History of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute

Among rightwing think tanks, none has more intellectual firepower than the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, due to its leading thinker Chester E. Finn Jr., who has an Ed.D. from Harvard Graduate School of Education and worked in the administrations of Reagan and Nixon, as well as working for Daniel Patrick Moynihan and Lamar Alexander. The Institute, formerly a foundation, is based in Washington, D.C
John Merrow: Congratulations, You Are a Winner!

John Merrow has good news for you! You have been selected as a winner by his crack marketing team to do a good deed!. Since he has selected the Network for Public Education as one of his honorees, I urge you to open his link.
Gene Glass: Why Markets in Education Don’t Work

The distinguished education researcher Gene Glass reads this blog and occasionally comments. Yesterday I quoted a short statement by Margaret Raymond, director of CREDO, the Walton-funded evaluator of charter schools, who stated publicly that markets don’t work well in schooling. We can speculate on why markets don’t work: parents don’t have enough information, information is distorted by marketi


Robin Lithgow: Boys’ Acting Companies Launch “the Golden Age”

Robin Lithgow, former director of arts education in Los Angeles, is researching the history of children’s theater. This is Part 3 of Lithgow’s series on boy actors . She begins: If Charles William Wallace, in The Evolution of the English Drama up to Shakespeare, is to be believed, it was at Blackfriars Theatre, in the early 1580s, that the Golden Age of Elizabethan Theatre was launched. He makes


Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Friday, January 3, 2020

Angie Sullivan Tells Every Nevada Legislator to Read SLAYING GOLIATH | Diane Ravitch's blog

Angie Sullivan Tells Every Nevada Legislator to Read SLAYING GOLIATH | Diane Ravitch's blog

Angie Sullivan Tells Every Nevada Legislator to Read SLAYING GOLIATH

Angie Sullivan teaches in a Title 1 elementary school in Carson County, Nevada. She teaches the children who were left behind.
She sent this post to every legislator in Nevada:
A small group of vocal teachers, parents, and activists have been publicly concerned about national public school privatization for two decades.  
Diane Ravitch is the leader of that pack.  
Her new book is coming out soon.  
Her last books included characters who are national culprits in destroying American Public Schools.  Some have come from my state of Nevada.  
Reform was meant to change a system of education that needed to change.  Still needs change. Admittedly we need to improve.  No one argues against that.  Teachers have always been willing to improve.  
This reform was not ever meant to improve.  
Change came.   The wrong kind.  
Big bad horrific and public school destroying change came.   
It was bad change bought by corporations who do not love children, will not love CONTINUE READING: Angie Sullivan Tells Every Nevada Legislator to Read SLAYING GOLIATH | Diane Ravitch's blog

Choosing Democracy: SCUSD and Black Parallel School Board Seek Settlement

Choosing Democracy: SCUSD and Black Parallel School Board Seek Settlement

SCUSD and Black Parallel School Board Seek Settlement



SACRAMENTO, CA - The Sacramento City Unified School District (District) and plaintiffs suing the District for alleged discrimination against students based on race and disability asked the federal court to pause litigation so the parties may seek potential resolution through settlement.   

The lawsuit, alleged as a class-action, was filed by a coalition of nonprofit advocacy groups on behalf of the Black Parallel School Board (BPSB) and three students in the District. The suit alleges that the District’s policies and practices in the areas of special education and student discipline harm students with disabilities, and in particular, Black students with disabilities. 

While the District does not agree with the allegations in the lawsuit, “we appreciate plaintiffs’ willingness to work with us,” said District Superintendent Jorge A. Aguilar. “The District believes that we should work cooperatively with the plaintiffs to identify potential policies and practices that may not serve the best interests of the District’s students with disabilities, and to jointly find solutions to those issues, which would include addressing factors which limit service options or strategies for serving District students,” said Superintendent Aguilar. 

The parties have asked the Court to grant a seven-month stay of the litigation. During the stay, and by early February, the District has offered and agreed to implement several measures intended to benefit students with disabilities, including Black students with disabilities. These measures include:
  • Halting all District suspensions based on “willful defiance” not only for students in kindergarten through third grade, but up and through eighth grade;
  • Offering students a special education assessment plan within 15 days of a request for such assessment; and
  • Directing school administrators and staff not to ask or require students to leave school as an informal response to concerns with student behavior.
  •  
“These measures are significant to students with disabilities and their parents and guardians whom we and other advocates in our community fight for and support,” said BPSB Chairperson Darryl White. “The District’s willingness to implement these interim measures has encouraged BPSB to engage in cooperative discussions with the District about potential broader and more permanent reforms and protections for our students.” 

Also, during the stay, an agreed-upon set of experts will review the District’s data and practices in the areas of special education, student discipline, and implicit bias.  That review will include expert interviews of students, parents, District staff, and other stakeholders. After the assessment and study of the information gathered, the experts will issue recommendations that the parties will consider as part of a possible settlement to create positive, lasting change for students and their families. 
The Court granted the requested stay of litigation today, December 20, 2019. 


Media Contacts
Melody Pomraning, Communications Director, Disability Rights California
916-504-5938, Melody.Pomraning@disabilityrightsca.org
For more information regarding Disability Rights California, visit: disabilityrightsca.org
Communications Department, Sacramento City Unified School District
916-643-9042
Darryl White, Black Parallel School Board
916-529-3587, darrywh1@aol.com
Keith Kamisugi, Director of Communications, Equal Justice Society
415-288-8710,  Kkamisugi@equaljusticesociety.org
For more information regarding Equal Justice Society, visit: equaljusticesociety.org
Patty Guinto, Director of Communications, National Center for Youth Law
626-512-4974, pguinto@youthlaw.org
For more information regarding the National Youth Law Center, visit: youthlaw.org


Choosing Democracy: SCUSD and Black Parallel School Board Seek Settlement

John Thompson: OKCPS teacher complaints should be taken seriously

OKCPS teacher complaints should be taken seriously

OKCPS teacher complaints should be taken seriously

I’ve read school climate surveys and listened to teachers for decades. In my experience, most educators hold their frustration in — until they can’t take it anymore. I thought morale bottomed out in Oklahoma City Public Schools under former Superintendent Aurora Lora, before the recent statewide teacher pay raises, when the American Federation of Teachers’ OKCPS teacher survey prompted 291 comments in 2017. However, I’ve never read anything like the AFT’s November 2019 survey.
Among survey respondents, the only thing which prompted more scathing criticism than this year’s Pathway to Greatness (P2G) district realignment was the increase in disorder and violence. Only 11 percent of respondents said that “Student welfare and school climate has improved.” Twenty-five percent said their site has received “trade ups,” but 38 percent said their class size increased after P2G closed schools and realigned feeder patterns.
Eighty-eight percent reported disruptions of the learning environment, with 50 percent reporting distractions due to wireless devices, 43 percent reporting bullying, and 19 percent reporting “assault and battery against school personnel.” Moreover, 47 percent added comments.
My reading of about 373 teacher comments this year was that fewer than 2 percent were positive about P2G CONTINUE READING: OKCPS teacher complaints should be taken seriously

Mailer encourages Washington state teachers to stop paying their union dues and ‘save up to $1,200’ | The Seattle Times

Mailer encourages Washington state teachers to stop paying their union dues and ‘save up to $1,200’ | The Seattle Times
Mailer encourages Washington state teachers to stop paying their union dues and ‘save up to $1,200’


Get the Facts about the 'Freedom' Foundation - http://freedomfoundationfacts.com/

When Seattle teacher Alice Lippitt checked the mail last week, she was puzzled by a flyer she found.
“What the heck?” she said she remembers thinking. “How did they find my address?”
At first glance, the flyer, sent to thousands of Washington teachers over the holidays, looks like a last-chance sale advertisement from a department store.
It was actually an invitation from a conservative think tank to “save up to $1,200” by opting out of paying membership dues to the Washington Education Association (WEA), the statewide teacher’s union.
“Give yourself a raise this Christmas and every Christmas to come!” it reads.
The mailers are part of a wider and litigious political battle between the state’s labor unions and the Freedom Foundation, an Olympia-based conservative think tank, whose website says the group is “working to reverse the stranglehold government unions have” on state and local policy. Using information gleaned from public records requests, the Foundation has also knocked on doors and sent emails to public employees notifying them of their right to opt out of paying dues under a 2018 ruling from the U.S. Supreme Court in Janus v. AFSCME.
Reached by phone last week, Jami Lund, the Foundation’s senior policy analyst, said the communications are intended to place a check on the power of unions, keep them accountable and prevent them from “overcharging” their members. He added that some public employees, including those who are conservative, don’t want to fund union activities they don’t agree with and feel pressured to be “in lockstep.”
WEA, a formidable lobbying force with close to 100,000 members, has been aware of the group’s efforts for years. A post on the union’s blog advises members to ignore the Foundation’s “annoying tactics.”
“We see it as nothing but an attempt to harass and intimidate school employees,” said Rich Wood, a WEA spokesman. 

Anyone get this anti-union, Scrooge, mailer for Christmas?

They r trying to get educators to drop out of @OurVoiceWEA—giving up the collective bargaining rights that won us the raises & rights we have received.

They should have donated the $$ spent on the mailer to schools!



View image on TwitterView image on Twitter

The Foundation is a nonprofit and member of the State Policy Network, an alliance of conservative think tanks, some of which are engaged in similar anti-union marketing campaigns, The Guardian and The Intercept reported.
One mailer from the Foundation obtained by The Guardian said, “The consequences of a favorable ruling [in the Janus case] are huge. Imagine tens, even hundreds, of millions of dollars currently used to push damaging CONTINUE READING: Mailer encourages Washington state teachers to stop paying their union dues and ‘save up to $1,200’ | The Seattle Times

The Most Important School Case Before the U.S. Supreme Court This Session | Diane Ravitch's blog

The Most Important School Case Before the U.S. Supreme Court This Session | Diane Ravitch's blog

The Most Important School Case Before the U.S. Supreme Court This Session

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear a case called Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue that will determine whether the United States–or any state–may still respect a separation of church and state.
In the wake of Donald Trump’s choice of two far-right Justices to the Supreme Court, this case might well be decided in a way that removes all prohibitions on the use of public funds for religious schools.
The facts of the case are these: Like many states, Montana’s state constitution forbids the funding of religious schools. The Montana legislature passed a tax credit program that funds vouchers for religious schools. The Montana Supreme Court ruled that the law violated the state constitution. Now, the case is before the U.S. Supreme Court.
Many states have such prohibitions (and in some of them, like Indiana and Florida, the state courts decided to ignore the explicit language of the state constitution and allow vouchers for religious schools on the claim that the money goes to the family not the religious school that actually gets the public money). The typical attack on state bans on funding religious schools is that such prohibitions are “Blaine amendments,” adopted in the late 19th century at the height of anti-Catholic bigotry; because they were passed in a spirit of bigotry, the argument goes, they should be struck down.
In Montana, the prohibition on funding religious schools is CONTINUE READING: The Most Important School Case Before the U.S. Supreme Court This Session | Diane Ravitch's blog