Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, August 26, 2012

Diane Ravitch Kippers for Dinner? Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch

This Made My Day!

A reader commented:
There have been many times in history when the evidence and discoveries by researchers and scientists (such as Galileo and Darwin) was suppressed by those in power. This is one of those times.  

The peer-reviewed unbiased research in biology, neuroscience, education, and social science corroborates a humanistic, child-centered, constructive approach to how we raise and educate our children.  It’s amazing how the biological research into the workings of the brain supports 


Elect This Woman to the Assembly in New Jersey

Marie Corfield is a teacher in New Jersey who is running for a seat in the state Assembly.
I have met her and I can tell you she understands education and cares passionately about kids.
She deserves your support.
New Jersey is a state now controlled by a governor who insults teachers and their unions. He glories in his


Hey, KIPP, Here’s An Offer You Can’t Refuse

Jersey Jazzman has a district to give to KIPP for the challenge: Camden, New Jersey.
The stars are aligned.
Chris Christie wants to take away any control from the citizens of Camden anyway.
The Democratic boss is an ally of Christie and won’t put up any resistance.
Chris Cerf, the acting commissioner of education, is a Broadie and he would certainly support the transfer of


CNN Interview: Curious and Curiouser

On August 18, I was interviewed by Randi Kaye on CNN as a follow up to her sympathetic interview with Michelle Rhee.
She was prosecutorial and asked question after question as if she were channeling Rhee.
The interview was not posted online until a week or eight days later, long after the other interviews in the same


A Memphis High School Teacher Dissents

The Memphis public schools are about to merge with the Shelby County schools into a single district.
The guiding document was written by a 21-member Transition Planning Commission.
The director of the TPC happens to work for the reform group Stand for Children, now best known among educators for its efforts to crush the Chicago Teachers  Union.
Several articles about Memphis have appeared on this blog. The TPC proposed, for example, that the proportion


Gerald Coles Responds to Jonathan Schorr about KIPP

In my initial post about KIPP, I described a critique of the KIPP charter school network by Gerald Coles, an educational psychologist.
Coles raised questions about the reliability of the research on KIPP and about the selection of students.
I suggested a challenge to KIPP, that it should take an entire impoverished district to test its theories, if such a



The Greatest Education Error of All Time?

Justin Snider has written an interesting article in the Hechinger Report.
What if we find out years from now that whatever we are doing is simply wrong?
Why are we doing so many things now in education that have no evidence to support them?
If this were medicine instead of education, would anyone tolerate the experimentation that is being done to the 




Jersey Jazzman: Baker vs. Hanushek

Jersey Jazzman: Baker vs. Hanushek:


Baker vs. Hanushek

Bruce Baker

@SchlFinance101

Professor at Rutgers University specializing in school finance, education policy & quantitative analysis.
The two titans of school fiance battle it out in a Reno newspaper:
Many claims that money doesn’t matter stem from a 1986 paper by Eric Hanushek, who examined numerous studies and concluded: “There appears to be no strong or systematic relationship between school expenditures and student performance.”
Hanushek, an economic analyst of educational issues at Stanford’s Hoover Institution, told Fact Checker: “To be clear, I have never said that money cannot matter. I have only said that the way we have traditionally spent money has not led to better performance. I would indeed pay good teachers a lot more — but I would 

Take note LAUSD: "Starving the Future" by CHARLES M. BLOW (NYT) - Perdaily.com

Take note LAUSD: "Starving the Future" by CHARLES M. BLOW (NYT) - Perdaily.com:


Take note LAUSD: "Starving the Future" by CHARLES M. BLOW (NYT)

Charles M. Blow.jpg
(Mensaje se repite en EspaƱol)

(For a national view of public education reform see the end of this blog post)

 
Starving the Future
by CHARLES M. BLOW (NYT)

(In my war against what has become the mundane day to day fraud of public education at the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) along with purposefully corrupted school districts like it around the country, take a moment to look at the macrocosm view of where this is all going in the not too distant 

Teachers Don't Suck !: Not Bad for a Public School Graduate!

Teachers Don't Suck !: Not Bad for a Public School Graduate!:


Not Bad for a Public School Graduate!


More stuff by Walt at: www.wsautter.com

Bloomington: Solidarity with Chicago teachers. « Fred Klonsky

Bloomington: Solidarity with Chicago teachers. « Fred Klonsky:


Bloomington: Solidarity with Chicago teachers.

  • Public schools and teachers are under attack across the nation.Come hear how Chicago teachers, now preparing for a historic strike, are organizing and building power with parents and communities to defend their schools and improve public education in Chicago.
    A member of the Chicago Teachers Union will speak about the CTUs ongoing battle with the unelected 



The in box. “Run. Pat. Run.”

Fred,
I was wondering! You can all correct me if I am wrong. But aren’t we working stiffs considered “Grass Roots”? We already know how the “Labor Grass Roots” feels about the Governor. I was there, front row and center. He even tried to shake my hand. I told him “You have to be kidding right?” He ran for the limo!!!! Run Pat Run
-Corrections Teacher




Bill Nye: Please don’t teach your kids creationism, because it is crazy | The Raw Story

Bill Nye: Please don’t teach your kids creationism, because it is crazy | The Raw Story:


Bill Nye: Please don’t teach your kids creationism, because it is crazy

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Escalating the Rhetoric so That ALL Educators are Suspect

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Escalating the Rhetoric so That ALL Educators are Suspect:


Escalating the Rhetoric so That ALL Educators are Suspect

Over at the Washington Policy Center, Liv Finne's latest "analysis" is about the Success Academies in NYC, a small charter chain that has big plans to expand throughout NYC.  They do have higher than average test scores but, like other charters, don't serve as many Special Ed students.  And, their operator, Eva Moskowitz, rakes in a big salary and parent voices are not high on her list of priorities.  
This analysis would be okay -it's one in a long string of ancedotal stories about good charters.  They exist  but not in numbers that would support the idea that charters can and do make a big difference in any district where they are located.

She then goes on to rail about principals in Washington State:

In Seattle, for example, the superintendent of the district bureaucracy selects and oversees the performance of 

Can the most anti-labor Illinois governor in 50 years lead a grassroots campaign? « Fred Klonsky

Can the most anti-labor Illinois governor in 50 years lead a grassroots campaign? « Fred Klonsky:


Can the most anti-labor Illinois governor in 50 years lead a grassroots campaign?


You would have to go back before Adlai Stevenson, elected in 1949, to find an Illinois Governor more anti-labor than Pat Quinn.
I couldn’t help but laugh when I read that Illinois Governor Pat Quinn announced this week that he was going tolead a grassroots campaign to strip public employees of their pension rights.
Well, maybe not laugh exactly, since it’s my pension too.
But the thought of Pat Quinn, the guy who got chased out of the Illinois State Fair last week by members of the


The in box. Esther asks, “Did I dream this up?”

Did I dream this up?
Illinois Voters: Give teachers their pensions
August 23, 2012 By IEA Communications
Illinois Voters: Give teachers their pensions; find non-punative solution to pension crisis
Springfield, IL – A new statewide poll shows the efforts of Governor Quinn and other politicians to win public support for proposals to cut pensions for teachers and other public employees has failed. Rather, it shows that voters overwhelmingly believe that teachers are entitled to their full retirement benefits and that politicians should find fixes to the pension mess that do not punish 


The Sunday Mail.


Chicago school activist and CTU organizer Martin Ritter designed this to be used as your Facebook cover. Share it with your friends.
John Dillon’s Pension vocabulary: Pedantic Profits.  Caterpillar’s Chief Executive Doug Oberhelman says that the U.S. manufacturing workforce is lagging, and education is at 

THE GREAT FALLACY « Teachers Fight Back

THE GREAT FALLACY « Teachers Fight Back:


THE GREAT FALLACY

The following quote was taken from one of the many Chicago Tribune’s teacher bashing editorials.
“Teachers’ performance in the classroom is most crucial to students’ success.”
NO, SORRY, IT’S NOT !  If only it was that simple.
There’s a reason why students from underprivileged areas and from broken homes underperform in the classroom. There are also dozens of factors that hinder a student’s progress, all of which are out of a teacher’s control. Most people seem to understand that, but not the Chicago Tribune.
Is a doctor the most important factor in the outcome of a patient with incurable cancer ?  Is a dentist the most important factor in the ability to save a tooth that was hopelessly decayed before the person ever saw the dentist ?  Is an auto mechanic the most important factor in fixing the engine of a car that was completely ruined when 

The in box. Esther asks, “Did I dream this up?” « Fred Klonsky

The in box. Esther asks, “Did I dream this up?” « Fred Klonsky:


The in box. Esther asks, “Did I dream this up?”

Did I dream this up?
Illinois Voters: Give teachers their pensions
August 23, 2012 By IEA Communications
Illinois Voters: Give teachers their pensions; find non-punative solution to pension crisis
Springfield, IL – A new statewide poll shows the efforts of Governor Quinn and other politicians to win public support for proposals to cut pensions for teachers and other public employees has failed. Rather, it shows that voters overwhelmingly believe that teachers are entitled to their full retirement benefits and that politicians should find fixes to the pension mess that do not punish current or retired workers.
The poll, taken in early August, also indicates that a controversial proposal to shift state pension 

The Greatest Education Error of All Time? « Diane Ravitch's blog

The Greatest Education Error of All Time? « Diane Ravitch's blog:


The Greatest Education Error of All Time?

Justin Snider has written an interesting article in the Hechinger Report.
What if we find out years from now that whatever we are doing is simply wrong?
Why are we doing so many things now in education that have no evidence to support them?
If this were medicine instead of education, would anyone tolerate the experimentation that is being done to the entire population?
I actually think we know more than

New U.S. immigration program can help farmworkers – USATODAY.com

New U.S. immigration program can help farmworkers – USATODAY.com:


New U.S. immigration program can help farmworkers



 


TULARE, California (AP) — Much of the attention on a new U.S. immigration program that started Wednesday has focused on the hundreds of thousands of students who are in the country illegally and now have the chance at work permits and deferred deportation. But just as many young workers, especially farmworkers, could benefit as well.
"The stereotype about the young people who are eligible is that they're college students and academic superstars that speak English perfectly. And that is, of course, not true for all of them," said Ed Kissam, a labor policy researcher.
One may be 23-year-old Juan Carlos Martin, who was smuggled through a U.S. border checkpoint from Mexico 

Neil Armstrong's Memorable Commencement Speech - Education - GOOD

Neil Armstrong's Memorable Commencement Speech - Education - GOOD:


Neil Armstrong's Memorable Commencement Speech


neil.armstrong

The words "hero" and "icon" don't do justice to Neil Armstrong, the commander of NASA's Apollo 11 space flight and the first man on the moon. Indeed, Armstrong, who passed away on Saturday at the age of 82 uttered one of the most memorable statements of all time: "That’s one small step for (a) man, one giant leap for mankind." That famous line, the first ever transmitted from the moon to Earth, inspired millions. In a 2005 commencement address (PDF) at his graduate alma mater, the University of Southern California, Armstrong showed that his ability to inspire and offer some much-needed perspective had endured.
Armstrong, who was born in 1930 and began studying aerospace engineering at Purdue University in 1947—he 

Jersey Jazzman: Hey KIPP: Take the Camden Challenge!

Jersey Jazzman: Hey KIPP: Take the Camden Challenge!:


Hey KIPP: Take the Camden Challenge!

The terrific Paul Thomas summarizes the ongoing KIPP charter school controversy. The sad fact is that KIPP and other "successful" charters cannot replicate their "success" on a large scale, because they do not serve the same students as public schools and they are spending more money per pupil. Paul nicely summarizes the research, and you can read Bruce Baker and Ed Fuller for more.

Given this truth, Diane Ravitch has issued a standing challenge to KIPP: take over an entire district. If KIPP really has the "secret sauce," they ought to share it with the rest of the nation.

May I suggest the perfect place for KIPP to take up this challenge? Camden, NJ.

The road has been paved for KIPP's entrance to Camden anyway, what with the NJDOE threatening to 

The Sunday Mail. « Fred Klonsky

The Sunday Mail. « Fred Klonsky:


The Sunday Mail.

Chicago school activist and CTU organizer Martin Ritter designed this to be used as your Facebook cover. Share it with your friends.
John Dillon’s Pension vocabulary: Pedantic Profits.  Caterpillar’s Chief Executive Doug Oberhelman says that the U.S. manufacturing workforce is lagging, and education is at fault.  Oberhelman, who receives $16.9 million in salary alone in 2011 and another $8.3 million in options, describes the potential workforce for his company as lacking.  And he says it is education’s fault, for he has nowhere else to pick from.
I was no fan of Day Hynes, but he was sure right about Pat Quinn. And Harold  sure nailed the guy.
Do you support Chicago teachers? Call CPS CEO JC Brizard on Thursday and every Thursday to let him know: 773 553 1500.
Rahm’s top cop says t

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Banda Interview

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Banda Interview:


Banda Interview

Superintendent Banda was gracious enough to give me a little time last week to talk.  (I note that the office looked quite stern with Dr. Enfield's ducky collection gone.)

How's it going?
He said he had adjusted quickly and he is enjoying Seattle.  He said that he felt like he got a good grasp of the district and its needs early on.

Math is a big issue to many parents and when they see a few schools going off-script (and getting good results), they want to know how their school can do it.  Any plans around that issue?
He said it was a challenging area.  He mentioned that Wendy London had resigned (so she is definitely not in 

Even Sen. John Thrasher Questions Academica Charter Schools’ St. Johns County Bid | Scathing Purple Musings

Even Sen. John Thrasher Questions Academica Charter Schools’ St. Johns County Bid | Scathing Purple Musings:


Even Sen. John Thrasher Questions Academica Charter Schools’ St. Johns County Bid

Well, it’s because they like to cherry-pick students, Senator. And they think they can do so because theydropped $100,000 into choice-privatization zealot, John Kirtley’s PAC before the primary earlier this month. .
But John Thrasher’s  puzzlement is still a bit of a surprise. Reports St. Augustine Record reporter Marcia Lane:
The district would lose about $12.8 million yearly in state funds and need 200 fewer teachers based on the peak number of students that could go to the new charters.
Each student going to a charter pulls the Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) funding away from the district’s traditional public schools. Fewer students also mean fewer teachers would be required in 

Daily Kos: Why Tenure and Unions?: On Democracy and Equity in the U.S.

Daily Kos: Why Tenure and Unions?: On Democracy and Equity in the U.S.:


Why Tenure and Unions?: On Democracy and Equity in the U.S.

Howard Zinn would have turned 90 a couple of days ago. I have to imagine after reading and re-reading most of Zinn's works that if Zinn were alive today, he would remain baffled at how America is a country antagonistic to unions and tenure, especially teachers unions and tenure.
Zinn was a radical historian, activist, and in my opinion, most of all a teacher. And it is at the overlap of Zinn as historian/activist/teacher I find his People's History of the United States an invaluable place to ask, Why tenure and unions [1]?

Romero Challenges Failed DC Chancellor Michelle Rhee for Corporate Lackey Queen | NBC 7 San Diego

Gloria Romero's Revenge | NBC 7 San Diego:


Gloria Romero's Revenge

View Comments (
0
)
|
Email
|
Print
Opinion: Gloria Romero's Revenge
AP
Gloria Romero, former state senator who authored California's Parent Trigger law and state director of Democrats for Education Reform, speaks during open comment on Wednesday, March 28, 2012, at the Adelanto School District board meeting regarding the effects on Desert Trails Elementary School if the Parent Trigger law passes. The Adelanto School District Board of Trustees voted 5-0 to reject the petition for failing to include valid parent signatures representing at least 50 percent of students at the school in Adelanto, Calif. (AP Photo/David Pardo, Daily Press)


IT IS A RULE: YOU CAN'T BE AGAINST PEOPLE AND FOR CORPORATIONS AND CALL YOURSELF A DEMOCRAT...EVER!


Missouri Education Watchdog: First Day of School: Euphoria. Second Day of School: Worries.

Missouri Education Watchdog: First Day of School: Euphoria. Second Day of School: Worries.:


First Day of School: Euphoria. Second Day of School: Worries.

After the first day euphoria of sending students to school, find out what's in the plan for YOUR human capital.



I remember, when as a young mother, I was excited about the first day of school for my children.  This cute blog, Wee Wonderfuls, captures the spirit of what many young mothers feel on the beginning of the school year:

*************************************************************

August 24, 2012

first day of school!

Kindergarten! Here's a peek at her goofball backpack. And thanks to the very helpful etsy seller,