Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, May 27, 2011

Locating the Coordinates of School Reform in 2011 | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Locating the Coordinates of School Reform in 2011 | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Locating the Coordinates of School Reform in 2011

Where is the U.S. in school reform now?

To answer this question, I will do what lawyers often do when arguing a case. I will stipulate certain statements as facts. These statements may not sound like facts but as an historian and practitioner of school reform I claim they are. Should readers quarrel with these statements, I do have supporting references and we can discuss those in dispute later. I stipulate the following:

FACT 1

Historically, school reformers have overstated defects in the existing system and made gloomy predictions of disaster. Then they have understated difficulties of changing the system by proposing rose-colored solutions.

Exhibit A is what has occurred over the past three decades.