Latest News and Comment from Education

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Joel Shatzky: Educating for Democracy: If Doctors Were Treated Like Teachers

Joel Shatzky: Educating for Democracy: If Doctors Were Treated Like Teachers
Joel Shatzky

Joel Shatzky

Posted: November 2, 2010 01:10 PM

I originally posted a similar column in The Examiner almost a year ago (12/09/2009). I'm afraid, if anything, the situation has become even more dire for the teaching profession in the past year. Mayor Bloomberg's plan to publish the "ratings" of teachers in the press -- on the basis of test scores -- is one more example of the public humiliation many of the best New York City teachers have to endure in the interest of "educational reform. " Perhaps the following article can put this absurd situation into perspective.

If doctors were treated like teachers:

1. "Charter hospitals" could certify "smart people" as qualified to begin practicing medicine without any prior experience in the field if they had had "some business background."
2. Since a "doctor" can "doctor" anything, a cardiologist would be on staff at a hospital in place of a urologist when there was a shortage of urologists. The cardiologist could "learn on the job." Of