Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, March 26, 2017

Weekend Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Weekend Diane Ravitch's blog
A site to discuss better education for all




The Fight to Block the Keystone Pipeliine is not Over
This article reviews the many legal and political challenges that still face the Keystone Pipeline. https://www.ncronline.org/blogs/eco-catholic/legal-challenges-await-keystone-xl-pipeline-after-trump-grants-permit He said it 

Poll: Betsy DeVos is the Most Unpopular Member of Trump’s Unpopular Cabinet
Usually a new presidency has a honeymoon period, a time of good feeling and high poll numbers. As they battle for their policies and legislation, their poll numbers change, for better or worse. Newsweek reports that Trump and his 

Peter Greene: Food Is Overrated
As the previous post noted, the Trump administration wants to eliminate the after school program, because it doesn’t raise test scores. Budget director Mick Mulvaney said the same thing about feeding children: it doesn’t raise their test 

The Daily Signal Salutes Defunding of After-School Programs
The Daily Signal is published by the uber-conservative Heritage Foundation. I am on their mailing list. In yesterday’s report, it congratulated Trump for proposing to eliminate federal funding for after-school programs because they harm children. They hailed the defunding of 21st Century Community Learning Centers. Based on a study published 10 years ago that found that participants in the progra
Jeff Bryant: The Big Lie Behind Trump’s Budget Proposals for Education
Jeff Bryant spells out the Big Lie embedded in Trump’s budget proposal for education. He plans to cut programs that directly aid poor kids while bolstering charters and vouchers, pretending they are equivalent. They are not. Yet much of the mainstream media has fallen for the Trump-DeVos bait-and-switch. “Public school supporters are angry at President Trump’s budget proposal, which plans to cut
New York Opt Out Leaders Prepare for Renewal of Common Core Test Boycotts
The epicenter of New York’s historic test refusal movement is gearing up for a repeat performance when testing begins on Monday. The state is hoping that the introduction of computer-based testing will mollify parents but it shouldn’t. Numerous studies have shown that students get lower scores on computer-based tests than on tests that require pencils. Some children–especially in younger grades–a

YESTERDAY

God Bless Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe!
As reported earlier today, Virginia Governor Terry McAuliffe vetoed legislation that would have allowed privately managed charters to be authorized without the approval of the local school board. This legislation would have invited into Virginia all the scandals, frauds, scams, and profiteering that have marred the charter industry in other states. The state’s major newspaper, the Richmond Times-
Todd Gitlin on Trump’s Rhetoric: Has He Been Reading Avant-Garde Poetry?
Todd Gitlin is a professor of journalism and sociology at Columbia University. In this post, which appear s on Bill Moyers’ website, Gitlin analyzes Donald Trump’s unusual use of grammar, syntax, and logic, as illustrated in the recent interview in TIME magazine. Gitlin’s lucid inquiry leads him to ask: “Is Donald Trump the heir of generations of avant-garde poetry?” One can only imagine the diss
Allen Weeks: Our Texas Schools Are Broken, It’s Time for a Change
Allen Weeks writes in the Austin American-Statesman tha t Texas schools are broken. Th ey are desperately underfunded by a legislature that cut $5.4 billion from the state school budget in 2011. When the economy improved, instead of restoring the money they took from the schools, they cut business taxes. Now, the leadership thinks they can substitute vouchers and choice for the damage done by bud
Steven Singer on the Joy of Opting Out of Standardized Testing
Steven Singer notes that standardized testing season is upon us. While he is at school administering useless standardized tests, his daughter will be home, inventing, playing, using her imagination. “In school I have to proctor the federally mandated standardized tests. But I’ve opted my own daughter out. She doesn’t take them. “So at home, I get to see all the imaginative projects she’s created
Tennessee Court Case: Does a Student Have the Right to a Teacher, or Will a Computer Suffice?
Nashville student, Toni Jones, is suing the state of Tennessee, because she thinks she should be taught by a human teacher, not a computer. The state says those decisions are not left to students. “Do the rights of Tennessee students to a public education extend into the right to have a teacher, and if so, does a computer program count? “Those questions were posed to a state appeals court Tuesday
Virginia: Governor McAuliffe Vetoes Legislation to Expand Charters and Gut Local Control
Congratulations, Governor McAuliffe of Virginia for protecting the children and public schools of Virginia from predatory privatizers. For standing up to Trump, DeVos, and the corporate reform movement inside the Democratic Party, I add you to the honor roll of this blog. Governor Terry McAuliffe vetoed legislation intended to remove the authorization of charter schools from local school boards.

MAR 24

My Conversation with Mike Klonsky on DeVos the Reformer
This was a fun conversation with my friend Mike Klonsky on the challenges of righting back in this new era of privatization as the goal of federal policy. http://michaelklonsky.blogspot.com/2017/03/diane-ravitch-and-kevin-coval-are-our.html?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed:+mikeklonsky+(SmallTalk)&m=1
A Year of Tillerson Emails Lost! Sad! So sad!
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson used a secondary email with an alias “Wayne Tracker.” He used it to communicate with Exxon board meters about sensitive matters like climate change. A year of emails has disappeared! “Exxon Mobil Corp. may have lost as much as a year’s worth of emails that former Chief Executive Officer Rex Tillerson used to discuss climate change risks and other sensitive issues
Mercedes Schneider on Hanna Skandera, Felled by the Common Core
Mercedes Schneider comments here o n the Senate GOP decision not to move forward with Hanna Skandera as Assistant Secretary of Education for Elementary and Secondary Education because of her Common Core love. Skandera is a protege of Jeb Bush. She was deputy commissioner of education in Florida. Since she took the job in New Mexico, despite lacking the statutory requirement of real education expe
GOP Nixes Hanna Skandera for Top Job Because of Her Fervent Support for Common Core
Politico reported this morning that Hanna Skandera, the Commissioner of Education in New Mexico, cannot be confirmed because of her advocacy for Common Core. Skandera is a protege of Jeb Bush. Although she has never been a teacher or a principal, she does have some practical experience in education, unlike DeVos. Skandera is also a proponent of high-stakes testing and VAM. Best not to give her th
Peter Greene: Florida, the Land of Stupid
Peter Greene reports here on a sad tale of education policy in Florida, where stupidity grows faster than citrus fruit. As you may recall, Florida is one of the states with a third grader retention law, declaring that third graders cannot move on unless they pass the Big Standardized Test for reading. This is a dumb law, without a lick of evidence to support it, and several licks to suggest that
Wisconsin Community Schools Threatened by Voucher Expansion
Governor Scott Walker has been a champion of vouchers and charters. He has pushed hard to expand vouchers for religious schools. Some districts will not even lose students but will have to raise taxes to pay for voucher students. http://www.jsonline.com/story/news/education/2017/03/21/tensions-rise-vouchers-pick-up-traction-across-wisconsin/98177206/ “When Superintendent Sue Kaphingst moved to Ch
Nicholas Tampio: State Testing Starts March 28, Don’t Let Them Bully You: Opt Out
Nicholas Tampio is a professor of political science in New York, and a parent of children in public schools. He warns that the State Education Department has a campaign to stop opt out from testing, based on bullying and intimidation. He writes: “All across New York, superintendents and principals have sent versions of the following statements to parents whose children are in grades 3-8 and are s
DeVos Wants More Vouchers in DC, Despite Lack of Results
The Republicans are set to expand the D.C. Voucher program, even though no evaluation has shown better test scores for D.C. voucher students and a high attrition rate. Students who get a voucher will check their constitutional rights at the door. The voucher schools may exclude students with disabilities and LGBT students. DeVos doesn’t care. Republicans have already started moving HR 1387, the S
John Merrow: Who Is Running the Show at the U.S. Department of Education?
John Merrow hears that the Department of Education in a state of confusion . “From one perspective, these are the worst of times for American public education. In his inaugural address, President Trump told the nation that we 
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Rainy Sunday. | Fred Klonsky

Rainy Sunday. | Fred Klonsky:

Rainy Sunday.




Julia, a child with autism, joins the cast of Sesame Street.

Sen. Bernie Sanders cast the GOP as “out of touch” with the public on health care Friday, citing opposition to the Obamacare repeal and replace efforts at a series of contentious town halls as a driving factor behind Republicans’ inability to push through the American Health Care Act.

“I think one of the reasons this legislation went down today is that all over this country we had hundreds of thousands of people coming out to rallies,” the Vermont senator told CNN’s Anderson Cooper several hours after a canceled vote on the Republican health care bill.
“People began the process of fighting back. We have gotRainy Sunday. | Fred Klonsky:

STANDARDIZED TESTING BILL OF RIGHTS

Test Better:

STANDARDIZED TESTING BILL OF RIGHTS


Proposed STANDARDIZED TESTING BILL OF RIGHTS

Parents Have A Right To Opt Out of Standardized Testing .





Current STANDARDIZED TESTING BILL OF RIGHTS

High-quality tests that accurately assess student learning and help teachers understand how to improve instruction are an essential part of an excellent education. But too many students are spending too many hours on ineffective test prep drills and low quality tests.
We believe standardized tests should be in service of instruction, not vice versa. Tests should be fair, reliable, relevant, and aligned to high-quality standards, and students must have the resources and supports they need to learn and thrive.

Students have the right to…
... Tests that provide an objective measure of progress toward college-and career-readiness.

... Testing schedules, policies, and practices that contribute to meaningful teaching and learning.

... Have student learning assessed based on an array of measures.

... An education free of excessive test prep.

... Have their personally identifiable information protected.

... Fair, reliable, and unbiased tests used for their intended purposes.
Teachers have the right to…
... Tests that provide an objective measure of progress toward college-and career-readiness.

... Timely data that measure what the student has learned, help them diagnose student needs and improve instruction.

... Professional development, high quality curricula, and the time and supports needed to teach and prepare their students.

... Have test scores be only one of an array of measures of student learning in accountability systems.

... Have their personally identifiable information protected.
Parents have the right to...
... Know if their child is making progress each year and on track to graduate from high school ready for college, career and citizenship.

... Clear, comparable data about school performance.

... Know the amount of instructional time being used to deliver and prepare for standardized tests, as well as the purpose and timing of standardized tests.

... Detailed, clear and timely results from standardized tests.

... Have their child’s personally identifiable information protected.

... Regular communication about their child’s progress and well-being. 

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Babymoon Edition + Catch up with CURMUDGUCATION

CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Babymoon Edition (3/26):

ICYMI: Babymoon Edition (3/26)


My wife and I are in DC, contemplating the cherry blossoms and coming creative disruption of our lives by two currently-fetal offspring. But I've still collected some reading for you, set to auto-post at the usual Sunday AM time. Read, enjoy and share.

In the Name of Love

A little push back from a Christian about "Christian" legislators

In the America First Budget, Schools Come Last

Andre Perry with an on-point critique of the Trump budget

Are You a Big Fat Idiot

I am happy to welcome back one of my favorite blog titles-- "I Love You But You're Going To Hell," a blog that focuses on interpreting conservative Christian thought for those not of that tribe (and which treats both sides with fairness). It's not always education-related, but this time it has something to say about the teaching of science. 

Words That Hurt Our Public Schools, And Ones That Help

We're doubling up on Jeff Bryant this week. First up, a look at how rhetoric shapes the education debates.

Hillbilly Elitist

Nancy Flanagan takes a look a Vance's widely-touted book, and she's not entirely impressed.

What the Dickens Is Going On

John Merrow takes us inside the mess that is the current ed department, and finds a silver lining stuffed inside a neglected closet.

The Big Lie Behind Trump's Education Budget

Jeff Bryant with another well-sourced breakdown of where exactly the problems lie in Trumps edu-budget.

Are School Leaders Becoming Too Enabled?

Peter DeWitt takes an insightful look at school leadership and using the right drivers to empower, not enable.

Privatizing Recess: Micromanaging Children's Play for Profit

Nancy Bailey looks at one of those scourges that will not die-- the professional recess managers

"We Teach English" Revisited

Paul Thomas looks at Lou LaBrant and the parts of teaching English that never change.

If You Teach and Noone Learns, Do You Really Teach 

Jose Luis Vilson Reflects on parent-teacher conferences and the lenses through which we view our classrooms

 CURMUDGUCATION: ICYMI: Babymoon Edition (3/26):

Catch up with CURMUDGUCATION


Big Education Ape: Catch up with CURMUDGUCATION - http://bigeducationape.blogspot.com/2017/03/catch-up-with-curmudgucation_25.html

The Parent Bill Of Rights For Education – Exceptional Delaware 2017

The Parent Bill Of Rights For Education – Exceptional Delaware 2017:

The Parent Bill Of Rights For Education


Since the Center for American Progress, Delaware Governor Jack Markell, and the President of the National PTA want to get 10,000 signatures on their Testing Bill of Rights within the next month, I think it is only fair parents who opt their children out of high-stakes assessments do the same.  With that being said, this article needs 20,000 commenters, or official signatures, within the next month.  We need to tell these corporate education reformers: NO MORE!  If we get 50,000, even better.
Our parental bill of rights regarding opt out or refusing the test bill of rights will be a work in progress, morphing and changing based on the need.  We will make sure every single legislator and decision-maker as it pertains to education in our country has a copy of this.  Parents and guardians are the stewards of our children, not corporations and politicians.  They are not “your” property.  They are unique and individual.

THE PARENTAL BILL OF RIGHTS FOR OUR CHILDREN IN EARLY EDUCATION, PRE-SCHOOL, ELEMENTARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION

CONCERNING HIGH-STAKES STANDARDIZED ASSESSMENTS, OUR RIGHT TO OPT OUT OR REFUSE OUR CHILD OUT OF THOSE ASSESSMENTS, THE COLLECTION OF STUDENT DATA, AND OUR RIGHT TO GATHER
BE IT ENACTED BY THE PARENTS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Definition of parent: any biological parent, or a parent through legal adoption, or foster parent, or guardian, or court-appointed guardian, for children through the ages of birth to 18 or 21 with guardianship through the end of an IEP, whichever is later.
Whereas parents have been given the responsibility to raise a child and to help guide them to adulthood, as their primary caregiver, and
Whereas parents, through United States Supreme Court decisions and other laws, have the right to decide what is best for our children in education matters until they come to a legal age when they are able to make those decisions on their own, and
Whereas, we believe public education should be reserved for the public at large and not the corporations, be they profit or non-profit, and that decisions based on education are best made at the local level, and
Whereas, we believe any assessments given to our children should provide immediate feedback for the student, teacher, school, and parent as defined for the sole purpose of giving reasonable and interpretive analysis of academic progress for our child’s allotted grade.
Whereas, as the caretakers of our children, we demand that decisions regarding data and the collection of data are parental decisions and that we furthermore have the absolute, unconditional right and ability to consent or not consent to any sharing of said data
(1) As parents, we have the fundamental, moral, and constitutional right to make decisions on behalf of our children in regards to their education.
(a) This includes the type of school we decide they go to, whether it be in a traditional school district, public charter school, vocational school, private school, homeschool, or homeschool co-op program.
(b) This includes our ability to refuse or opt our children out of standardized assessments despite accountability measures placed upon a school.
(1) Once we have submitted our letter indicating our choice to refuse or opt out our child, we shall receive no verbal or written words meant to threaten, bully, or intimidate, in an effort, whether intentional or coincidental, to coerce us into changing our minds.
(2) We expect our children to receive instruction while their peers take the state assessment that is of equal or greater value to the type of instruction they would receive prior to or after the administration of the state assessment.
(3) If our child is forced to take a test after we have already given our consent to refuse or opt out, we reserve the right to call the local police and press charges against the local education administration.
(4) If we witness parents who are bullied or intimidated, we will advocate on their behalf with their consent, if they feel they are unable to do so.
(2) We reserve the right, as dictated by United States of America Federal Law, Title 34, Subtitle A, Chapter 1, Part 99.32 (b), to request all personal identifiable The Parent Bill Of Rights For Education – Exceptional Delaware 2017:
Parent Bill Of Rights 2007