Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 6-4-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch



NYC: On Thursday, Join a Demonstration for Education!

This just in:
Hope you can join us and spread the word!
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Thursday, June 6th, 2013
NYC public school children will sign John Hancocks to their own “Declaration of Education” on Chancellor’s Day
City Hall Park gathering injects a positive message into the standardized testing debate, favors giving administrators room to create learning communities and giving teachers time to do what they do best: teach!
MANHATTAN—Parents, New York City public schoolchildren and community members will gather in City Hall 

John Merrow: His Concerns about the Common Core

John Merrow does not ally himself with most critics of the Common Core.
But he is concerned. He is concerned about whether a school with its own innovative curriculum and methodology will survive. His film crew visited the eighth grade at King Middle School and were impressed by what they found. How will this program fare?

What Is Going On in Cheatham County, Tennessee?

A teacher in Cheatham County, Tennessee, sent me this article about the unusual exodus of teachers from the county’s schools. Twenty-five percent of the staff have resigned in the past year, including the football coach and the basketball coach (whose teams had good seasons).
There is a local school board meeting tonight to hear all sides. Parents and citizens should show up and get involved. Learn what is happening in your local schools.

Is School Reform Really About Economic Development?

Leslie T. Fenwick, dean of education at Howard University, argues that what is called school “reform” is really about urban land development, not about improving the lives of disadvantaged minority children. She says, follow the money to understand the “reforms.”
Dean Fenwick doesn’t mince words. She writes:
“The truth can be used to tell a lie. The truth is that black parents’ frustration with the quality of public schools is at an all time righteous high. Though black and white parents’ commitment to their child’s schooling is comparable, more black parents report dissatisfaction with the school their child attends. Approximately 90 percent of black and white parents report attending parent teacher association meetings and nearly 80 percent of black and white parents report attending teacher conferences. Despite these similarities, fewer black parents (47 

The Patron Saints of Standardized Testing

Two political leaders—Arne Duncan and Dannell Malloy, governor of Connecticut–recently held a press conference where they both pretended to disdain high-stakes testing. Duncan went so far as to claim that he had decreased standardized testing when he led the Chicago public schools.
If only it were true! Jonathan Pelto and Sarah Darer Littman did some fact-checking, and the only question is why these guys don’t own up to their public record. They are both champions of standardized testing. Their 

Good News: Illinois Enacts Moratorium on Virtual Charters

Thank you, Governor Pat Quinn!
And congratulations to the 18 suburban districts that protected their students.
Governor Pat Quinn signed legislation that enacts a one-year moratorium on virtual charters, allowing time to study their performance. Any impartial study will reveal that online charters get poor results. They have high student dropouts every year, students get low grades and have a poor graduation rate. The beneficiaries of online charters are the corporations that own them. They make huge profits.
Eighteen suburban districts had previously banned the virtual schools, which allegedly wanted to target at-risk students. Online charters have no record of success serving at-risk students. These are the students most in need of human contact with caring teachers.

Gary Rubinstein: The Illegal Trojan Horse in King’s Evaluation Plan

Gary Rubinstein, who teaches mathematics, analyzed Commissioner John King’s plan to evaluate NYC teachers, which he imposed in the absence of an agreement between New York City and the United Federation of Teachers. Gary went a step further and read the law that King based his plan on. Gary concludes that Kingmisread the law and that his plan is fundamentally flawed.
Step back a minute and ask yourself how many other professions are evaluated based on legislative mandates. 

A Brilliant Post By Anthony Cody: How to Win

Anthony Cody gets stronger and sharper with every column he writes.
In this post, he explains how the best defense is a good offense.
He shows how critics of NCLB were tricked in 2008, then tricked again by Race to the Top.
It’s time to stop collaborating with those who want to destroy public education, he says.
It’s time to recognize, he writes, that Common Core is old wine in new bottles. Instead of getting rid of the 

EdTrust: Failing Charters in Michigan Are Expanding

The theory behind charters was that they would produce better results or lose their charter.
Education Trust Midwest reports that this is not happening.
Low-performing charters are not closed. Instead, they are expanding.
Charter operators have learned how to work the political system to their benefit. Not so much for the kids.

Camins: What Would Real Reform Look Like?

Arthur Camins is director of the Center for Innovation in Engineering and Science Education at the Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken, New Jersey.
In this excellent article, he notes that the advocates of the status quo are those who are in power and who impose high-stakes testing and privatization on districts and states. Oddly enough, the leaders of the status quo dismiss critics by calling them “defenders of the status quo.”
Camins suggests that real reform would be very different from the current evidence-free status quo.
He argues that: “the pillars of current education reform are more likely to preserve rather than change the status 

Diane in the Evening 6-3-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

mike simpson at Big Education Ape - 1 hour ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Rally in L.A. For Reduced Class Size! by dianerav A reader in Los Angeles welcomes all who care about improving public education: Parents from all across Los Angeles are Mobilizing!!!! Please gather tomorrow, Tuesday June 4 at 8:30 am out front of LAUSD central offices on Beaudry street downtown. Lend your voice to a collective choir that demands to be heard. We are Students, Parents and Angelenos for Real Classroom Support: SPARCS. We must ignite the SPARCS of this truth in front of our elected school board: KID... more »

Why schools should relax about cheating

Why schools should relax about cheating:

Why schools should relax about cheating

growing-pains_12Here’s a rather unconventional view on cheating. It was written by Penelope Trunk, who founded Brazen Careerist and two other startups. Her career advice runs in 200 newspapers. She lives on a farm in Wisconsin and homeschools her sons. This appeared on her blog.
By Penelope Trunk
Eric Anderman, professor at education psychology at Ohio University, has studied cheating for decades, and he says that 85 percent of students admit to cheating. (The number is probably higher since some do it but don’t admit it.) Harvard recently had to have a public discussion about campus cheating, and Stuyvesant, a New York City magnet school that’s harder to get into than Harvard, had an incredibly organized cheating system that rivals best practices for productivity types in Fortune 500 organizations.
It’s completely ridiculous that schools are so uptight about cheating because what schools call cheating is what people in the work world call effective workplace behavior.  For example:
1. Networking
In school, looking at someone else’s paper to get the right answer is forbidden.  But in the work world, the people who rise the fastest are the ones who know the right person 

Why teachers should present new material as stories

In this post Cognitive scientist Daniel Willingham writes about how students best learn new material. Willingham is a professor and director of graduate studies in psychology at the University of Virginia and author of “Why Don’t Students Like School?” His … Continue reading →
    

solidaridad: SPaARCS calls for support of the Lower Class Size resolution at LAUSD

solidaridad: SPaARCS calls for support of the Lower Class Size resolution at LAUSD:

SPaARCS calls for support of the Lower Class Size resolution at LAUSD


Tuesday, June 4, 2013 at 9am downtown (Beaudry),

our school board will consider a special resolution to

LOWER CLASS SIZE

As parents ~ WE MUST SPEAK LOUDLY IN SUPPORT OF THIS CRITICAL IMPROVEMENT.

There has been some suggestion that this measure is little more than a self-serving trick of organized labor.

We must QUASH this mindset that ignores our children's needs.

KIDS NEED SMALLER CLASSES IN ORDER TO LEARN BETTER

...it's about their education.

We Need You To Take Action:

(1) Join with SPaARCS by liking the Facebook page:  http://www.facebook.com/SPaARCS

(2) Ally yourself with the resolution to lower class size here: http://www.facebook.com/events/632196470142748/

(3)  Be heard at Beaudry on Tuesday; declare your intentions here: http://www.facebook.com/questions/632198140142581/

(4) Raise our voice by:
 
      *  encouraging other Students, Parents and Angelenos to join SPARCS:  SPREAD THE WORD!!!!!
 
      *  PLEASE, phone 10 parents and invite them to join Tuesday's rally for support of lowered class size:
IT'S IMPORTANT!

__________________________________
Who We Are:

We are many.  We are parents from across all of Los Angeles Unified's seven districts.  We have children in LAUSD.  We are children in LAUSD.  We are concerned with and about children in LAUSD.

We are Students, Parents, Angelenos for Real Classroom Support:  SPARCS


What We Stand For:

Strong, Truly Public Schools.  In Los Angeles, we demand truly public schools accountable to the public, administered and run by individuals dedicated to educating every child.

Democracy Fortified Through Public Education.  Every child in Los Angeles has a civil right to attend a good public school dedicated primarily to their education.

Dynamic, Responsive Public Education.  Appropriate, effective evaluation of our public schools, with parents welcomed, respected and contributing to decisions regarding the school system at every level.


What We Stand Against:

Privatizing Public Schools.  The educational system is a sacred public trust, part of the social contract.  We have a moral responsibility to the social and educational welfare of all among us.

Mechanized Schooling.  All learners are individuals; standardization of classes and tests eliminates the unique contribution of a professional teacher to education and learning.

Public School Control By Non-participants.  Educators should drive educational public policy; family and society its social components.  Political demogoguery has no place in our social contract to provide effective Public Schooling for all.

If you stand with us, amplify our SPARCS by joining here:  http://www.facebook.com/SPaARCS

NYC Educator: The Young Teacher and the Chapter Leader

NYC Educator: The Young Teacher and the Chapter Leader:

The Young Teacher and the Chapter Leader

by Curious Teacher

Young Teacher knocked on Chapter Leader's door. "Can I speak to you for a minute?"

"Sure," said Chapter Leader. She was a kindly looking old lady. "What's going on?"

Young Teacher explained her tale of woe. It was the old story: administration was harassing her when they had never bothered her before, she felt enormous pressure to resign, they didn't want to give her tenure, etc. Her AP had brought her up on charges of "professional misconduct" and was putting letters in her file every day when in her previous years she'd never even had a counseling memo. Tears ensued.

Chapter Leader assured Young Teacher she'd talk to administration.

A few weeks later Young Teacher returned. Things had gotten even worse. Young Teacher was being barraged 

What Critical Problems in K-12 Schools Does Online Instruction Solve? (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

What Critical Problems in K-12 Schools Does Online Instruction Solve? (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:

What Critical Problems in K-12 Schools Does Online Instruction Solve? (Part 2)

K-12 online instruction attracts policy-inclined school reformers and reform-minded policymakers because it appears as a technological and inexpensive solution for serious problems at a time when public schools are viewed as a double failure: in urban districts where largely poor and minority youth get a third-rate education and many suburban and rural schools that fall short of producing skilled and knowledgeable graduates who can contribute to a strong, competitive global economy.
Here is a brief list of those problems that promoters say will get solved through virtual instruction.
Traditional whole-class instruction. Teaching lessons to the whole group of 25-30 students at one time generation after generation has resulted in tedium and boredom for students who already know the content or are too far behind to grasp the lesson. It has been difficult for teachers with these size classes and district and state requirements to cover the curriculum to hit the sweet spot of learning that brings all students along at the same time.
With online instruction, lessons finally become individualized. Online instruction and blended learning provide “differentiated instruction” that can take each student from where he or she is and go to where each one can be–the Holy Grail pedagogical reformers have sought for generations. Moreover, these technological innovations 

Chicago pension fund sends thanks for the no vote on SB1920. | Fred Klonsky

Chicago pension fund sends thanks for the no vote on SB1920. | Fred Klonsky:

Chicago pension fund sends thanks for the no vote on SB1920.

In the final hours of the Illinois General Assembly, Mayor Emanuel conspired with Speaker Madigan and President Cullerton to try to pass SB1920 which would allow for another so-called pension holiday for CPS.
Rahm threatened (and continues to threaten) to raise class sizes if CPS was required to meet their pension obligation.
I advocated a no vote.
The bill failed to pass.
This morning the Chicago Teacher’s Pension Fund sent out a thank you to its members.
The Illinois House of Representatives rejected a measure which would have granted CPS an additional $350 million in pension funding “relief.”House Amendment #2 was heard and debated in the Illinois House of Representatives from 6 p.m. until 7:45 p.m. on Friday, May 31. The bill needed 60 votes to pass, but received only 39 votes.  Click here to read the roll call.
The proposed legislation would have reduced CPS contributions to our pension fund to $350M in 2014 (from $612.7M) and $500M in 2015(from $631.5).
We want to thank our members who called and e-mailed legislators, and asked elected officials to hold CPS accountable for paying their pension bills. We know that our members sent more than 

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Portugal's hot!

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Portugal's hot!:

Portugal's hot!

"Against the Troiks"
"We are faced with a wall of intransigence. The government better understand that negotiating is not the same as imposing." -- Carlos Silva, the head of the 500,000 members-strong UGT
It's hot here in Lisbon and I'm not just talking about the weather.  Luckily we're able to get around the city pretty well, arriving in town just after another strike shut down the Lisbon Metro for the 4th time in the past year.

Lots of young people in the streets. Graffiti is ubiquitous. Unemployment is at a record level, 17.8% with youth unemployment at a record 42.5%. Among Lisbon's large African immigrant population from Portugal's former colonies, it's much higher. The whole country is reeling under the burden of imposed austerity and while things are pretty peaceful here, say as compared to Turkey, neighboring 

Monday, June 3, 2013

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Stranger Danger

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Stranger Danger:

Stranger Danger

From My Northwest, a report of three (apparent) attempts to abduct a child in three different areas in the Puget Sound Region (including outside of two schools including Coe Elementary).  Talk to your children about strangers and what to do if they are approached.  From the story:

The National Child Prevention Council offers these tips for talking with kids about stranger danger:
  • You should also talk to your children about how they should handle dangerous situations. One way is to teach them "No, Go, Yell, Tell."
  • If in a dangerous situations, kids should say no, run away, yell as loud as they can, and tell a trusted adult what happened right away.
  • It's good to practice this in different situations so that your children will feel confident in knowing know what to do. Here are a few possible scenarios:
-A nice-looking stranger approaches your child in the park and asks for help finding the stranger's lost dog.
-A woman who lives in your neighborhood but that the child has never spoken to invites your child into her house for a snack.
-A stranger asks if your child wants a ride home from school.
-Your child thinks he or she is being followed.
-An adult your child knows says or does something that makes him or her feel bad or uncomfortable.
-While your child is walking home from a friend's house, a car pulls over and a stranger asks for directions.
In addition to teaching children how to recognize and handle dangerous situations and strangers, there are a few more things parents can do to help their children stay safe and avoid dangerous situations.
  • Know where your children are at all times. Make it a rule that your children must ask permission or check in with you before going anywhere.
  • Teach children to trust their instincts. Explain that if they ever feel scared or uncomfortable, they should get away as fast as they can and tell an adult.
  • Teach your children to be assertive. Make sure they know that it's okay to say no to an adult and to run away from adults in dangerous situations.
 I would echo that "teach your children to trust their instincts."  One of the best books about protecting your children is by noted security expert, Gavin deBecker, and his book, "Protecting the Gift."  We have this tendency to socialize our children (especially girls) to be "nice" and it's worth remembering we have gut instincts for a reason.

The Illegal Trojan Horse In King’s Teacher Evaluation Plan | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

The Illegal Trojan Horse In King’s Teacher Evaluation Plan | Gary Rubinstein's Blog:

The Illegal Trojan Horse In King’s Teacher Evaluation Plan

The state education commissioner of New York, John King, recently imposed a teacher evaluation system on New York City after years of disagreement between the city and the teacher’s union.
The evaluation system will consist of three components:  55 points for principal observations, 40 points for test scores, and 5 points for student surveys.  Much of this was inevitable as last year the state legislator updated education law 3012-c, which dictated the components and weights of the test scores and ‘other measures’ which now include principal and student ratings.  The whole idea of ‘multiple measures’ is that teachers won’t be unfairly punished for struggling in one category if they make up for it with success in the other categories.  And the most important and reliable measures, therefore, get the most weight, in this case, the principal evaluation.
Reading the 240 page report issued, there were two mentions of a very unusual provision, which has been noticed by several bloggers:
On page 37 it says:

Don’t let that American Flag in the corner of the room confuse you. - Wait, What?

Don’t let that American Flag in the corner of the room confuse you. - Wait, What?:

Don’t let that American Flag in the corner of the room confuse you.

New data shows school “reformers” are full of it - Salon.com

New data shows school “reformers” are full of it - Salon.com:

New data shows school “reformers” are full of it

Poor schools underperform largely because of economic forces, not because teachers have it too easy




 Michelle Rhee(Credit: © Hyungwon Kang / Reuters)
In the great American debate over education, the education and technology corporations, bankrolled politicians and activist-profiteers who collectively comprise the so-called “reform” movement base their arguments on one central premise: that America should expect public schools to produce world-class academic achievement regardless of the negative forces bearing down on a school’s particular students. In recent days, though, the faults in that premise are being exposed by unavoidable reality.
Before getting to the big news, let’s review the dominant fairy tale: As embodied by New York City’s major education announcement this weekend, the “reform” fantasy pretends that a lack of teacher “accountability” is the major education problem and somehow wholly writes family economics out of the story (amazingly, this fantasy persists even in a place like the Big Apple where economic inequality is particularly crushing). That key — and deliberate — omission serves myriad political interests.
For education, technology and charter school companies and the Wall Streeters who back them, it lets them cite troubled public schools to argue that the current public education system is flawed, and to then argue that education can be improved if taxpayer money is funneled away from the public school system’s priorities (hiring teachers, training teachers, reducing class size, etc.) and into the private sector (replacing teachers with computers, replacing public schools with privately run charter schools, etc.). Likewise, for conservative politicians and activist-profiteers

Oath of Office OR Looney Tunes? | Reclaim Reform

Oath of Office OR Looney Tunes? | Reclaim Reform:

Oath of Office OR Looney Tunes?

What Oath of Office must be made by every state legislator?
“I do solemnly swear (affirm) that I will support the Constitution of the United States, and the Constitution of the State of Illinois, and that I will faithfully discharge the duties of the office of …. to the best of my ability.”
(Source: Illinois Constitution.)

That’s it. Nice. Simple. Direct.
What’s not to know? “… will support the Constitution.”
Well, a bunch of Democratic and Republican politicos couldn’t do it. Who? See HERE. (Thanks to Glen Brown.)
Foghorn Leghorn
A bunch of elected office holders being paid to do what they took an oath to do went even further than that. They spoke and put in writing in their newsletters that they knew that Senate Bill Number One (SB1) was unconstitutional. Many openly and vociferously promised active 

Daily Kos: Rep. Carolyn McCarthy has lung cancer - with small personal update

Daily Kos: Rep. Carolyn McCarthy has lung cancer - with small personal update:

Rep. Carolyn McCarthy has lung cancer - with small personal update

as you can read in this NY Times story.
She is a dear friend, and I found out earlier today in an exchange of emails on another topic.  Some of her House colleagues knew, because she was not a secretive person.  She had discussed this earlier with political colleagues.  The announcement was made several hours ago.
She says her doctors are quite hopeful about the prognosis.  She is getting superb treatment.
She is a good person, and has in my opinion been a very good Representative, although I acknowledge we have some disagreements on issues.
I am holding her in  the light.
I do not want to lose her - and that has nothing to do with her political service. We are close friends.
Peace.
Update - Carolyn McCarthy is on the House Committee that oversees education, which is how we came together.  We have talked about education, we have talked about guns - her husband was killed and her son seriously injured by the Long Island RR gunman - we have talked about unions, we have talked about many issues.  She advised me against going work on the Hill, but encouraged me to stay involved - from the outside.  She has been a dear friend to both my wife and myself.  This has been very hard for both of us, and as people at the National Democratic Club began to learn the news they were devastated.  I do ask that if you pray you include her in your prayers.
Thanks

A Note On Teacher Evaluations [A Memo For Sanity] - The Jose Vilson | The Jose Vilson

A Note On Teacher Evaluations [A Memo For Sanity] - The Jose Vilson | The Jose Vilson:

A Note On Teacher Evaluations [A Memo For Sanity]


UFT Prez Michael Mulgrew, NYS Education Commissioner John King, and NYS Governor Andrew Cuomo
UFT Prez Michael Mulgrew, NYS Education Commissioner John King, and NYS Governor Andrew Cuomo
Remember a few years ago when I told you that trying to create equations for the intangibles is calamitous forany profession, especially education? If think tanks prognosticate that the 21st century needs ideals like collaboration and transparency, then we’re doing a poor job of exemplifying that in schools.
On Saturday, for example, Commissioner John King released New York State’s mandated teacher – and principal – evaluation system because the United Federation of Teachers and NYC Department of Education couldn’t come to an agreement on their own. (N.B.: Mayor Mike Bloomberg came at the last minute and put a stop to the almost-finished negotiations, but that’s another story completely.) In his press release, King waxes poetic about students, saying “they’ve waited too long” for these reports to come out, an empty statement since 

LA Unified school board considers two plans for Brown's proposed boost in school funding | Pass / Fail | 89.3 KPCC

LA Unified school board considers two plans for Brown's proposed boost in school funding | Pass / Fail | 89.3 KPCC:

LA Unified school board considers two plans for Brown's proposed boost in school funding

Monica Ratliff District 6
Monica Ratliff's fifth grade classroom at San Pedro Street Elementary.; Credit: Rebecca Hill/KPCC
Board members at L.A. Unified will hold talks Tuesday morning about how to use funding increases expected from Governor Jerry Brown’s proposed student funding overhaul.
Board members have written up two proposals.
The first includes a long list of uses for the expected funds: Hire more teachers to reduce class size, rehire counselors, librarians, and campus maintenance workers. The proposal lists current L.A. Unified class sizes:
• Grade K-3 = 24 students to 1 teacher
• Grades 4-6 = 30 students to 1 teacher
• Grades7-8 = 30 or more students to 1 teacher
• Grades 9-12 = 30 or more students to 1 teacher
The proposal would also direct the superintendent to draw up a three-year strategy to raise employee wages.

Reform of California’s complex school finance system likely | EdSource Today

Reform of California’s complex school finance system likely | EdSource Today:

Reform of California’s complex school finance system likely - by Louis Freedberg