Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, July 27, 2014

In Support of Public Education: Examining Privatization, Common Core and High Stakes Testing - UNITED OPT OUT

In Support of Public Education: Examining Privatization, Common Core and High Stakes Testing - UNITED OPT OUT: The Movement to End Corporate Education Reform:



In Support of Public Education: Examining Privatization, Common Core and High Stakes Testing

facebooktwitterredditmail
Ch2image2 dpi600
A special thanks to Becky Smith (Opt Out Orlando and SOS) who crafted a large portion of this document, which was shared with and edited by United Opt Out to share here
Our opposition to the Common Core and high stakes testing-HST (which go hand in hand) is not grounded in or allied with any particular political ideology.
Although some groups are against the same issues they do not share the same core beliefs regarding the cause of these reforms, or the solutions. United Opt Out would like to clarify our stance.
Our work is driven by the facts as we see them. First, Common Core is not a “leftist conspiracy.” The facts do not support this assumption. While we concede that many prominent “liberals” and “progressives” (such as Arne, some Union leaders, and Gates who proclaim themselves to be) have sold public education up the river with a false narrative of “equity” or “civil rights” as justification for reform, it is also true that the origins of the Common Core and HST concurrently emerged from conservative-dominated business and corporate leadership with membership in ALEC . We need to call on the carpet ALL perpetrators of destructive reform, not just those whose political ideology differs from our own.
This leads to the second point. We agree that Common Core and HST are harmful intrusions into public education foisted  upon us from the federal government via Race to the Top. Data mining and “big brother” oversight of classrooms and children must end. But the story does not end here. Big government is in partnership with big business (through private-public partnerships), and the template which created Common Core and HST mandates emanate from a privatization model for education. In this corporate model, Common Core is used as a “one size fits all” framework of education which yields private business profits at the expense of quality learning. It was crafted by corporate think tanks and entities with leadership from individuals in the CORPORATE world, such as (but not limited to) Lou Gerstner (IBM and Achieve), David Coleman (Student Achievement Partners and College Board) and Sir Michael Barber (Minster of Education to Tony Blair and CEO of Pearson). They see public education as a profitable venture to be tapped by private interests. The US Dept. of Education got its playbook from the corporate world (see the list of whose who at thispolicy meeting in 2008).

Teacher group rallies in Washington to protest Common Core, Arne Duncan | NJ.com

Teacher group rallies in Washington to protest Common Core, Arne Duncan | NJ.com:



Teacher group rallies in Washington to protest Common Core, Arne Duncan



Last fall, Melissa Tomlinson took on Gov. Chris Christie and his educational policies in a heated exchange that received national attention.
Tomorrow, Tomlinson and other BATs – short for Badass Teachers – take their campaign to Washington, D.C. for a day-long rally on the Department of Education’s plaza.
The BATs, a national organization of some 48,000 teachers, will demand the government end its support of the Common Core State Standards and high-stakes testing. And they will call for Education Secretary Arne Duncan to be fired and replaced with a career educator.
Tomlinson, a middle school teacher in Buena in Atlantic County, said they don’t expect Duncan to get sacked, but they believe their calls for change are being heard.
“It has put him on notice, yes? I think his eyes have been opened a little bit,” she said.
The BATs are hosting a day of activism and advocacy training in the nation’s capital today. It will be followed by tomorrow’s rally.
“We’re trying to bring attention to what is happening in education,” she said. “A lot of what the public is reading puts teachers in a bad light, puts public education in a bad light.”
The BATs promise a different kind of rally, with performances and speakers that highlight the success of public education, she said.
“It’s not going to be your typical angry march, but more of a celebration,” she said.Teacher group rallies in Washington to protest Common Core, Arne Duncan | NJ.com:

Borderland Deaths of Migrants Quietly Reach Crisis Numbers | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!

Borderland Deaths of Migrants Quietly Reach Crisis Numbers | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!:



Borderland Deaths of Migrants Quietly Reach Crisis Numbers

Filed under: Immigration — millerlf @ 9:08 pm 
Sunday, 27 July 2014 09:23 By Bethania Palma Markus, Truthout
Undocumented migrants pass a boy between two cars on a moving northbound freight train known as "The Beast," because of rampant accidents and violent crime, as it passes through Tenosique, Mexico, July 2, 2014. (Photo: Meridith Kohut / The New York Times)Undocumented migrants pass a boy between two cars on a moving northbound freight train known as “The Beast,” because of rampant accidents and violent crime, as it passes through Tenosique, Mexico, July 2, 2014. (Photo: Meridith Kohut / The New York Times)
The sun-bleached bones of a human skeleton lay in disarray: the skull rolled on its crown, an S-curved spinal column about two feet away. Leg bones were in a haphazard pile. There were personal items too – a wallet, pair of walking shoes and a dirt-caked T-shirt.
They belonged to a man, most likely a migrant who had faced off with the Sonoran Desert in an attempt to come north. While most attention on immigration has been directed recently at the human drama unfolding around a surge of children fleeing from Central American countries, the immigrant death toll on the US-Mexico border has quietly exploded, even as undocumented migration overall has plummeted.
The bones were found by Aguilas del Desierto (Eagles of the Desert), an all-volunteer search-and-rescue organization, in the blistering Arizona desert heat of the Organ Pipe Cactus national park just south of Ajo, a sparsely populated region of Pima County that neighbors the Mexican border. As many were hunkering over barbecues or lighting off fireworks, these men rolled out of California on a 300-mile trek across Interstate 8. I rode shotgun in long-time volunteer and Marine Corps veteran Vicente Rodriguez’s old red Forerunner.
Roughly once a month, they leave their families and personal lives to take these trips and plunge into some of the country’s most inhospitable landscapes. They hail from different walks of life – a roofer, a photographer, a medical supply importer, a gardening business owner, a water technician. But their common goal is finding at least some of the hundreds who die every year traversing the borderlands.
According to US Border Patrol statistics, 477 people died crossing in 2012, and 445 died crossing in 2013. The numbers have steadily shot up since 1998, when 263 died, according to the agency’s statistics. A total of almost 7,000 people have died between 1998 and 2013. But the true number is likely higher, considering many are never found.
Throttling along the hot pavement with no air conditioner to speak of, Vicente was blunt about the search prospects.
“Most of the time we are looking for a dead person – cadavers,” he said. “By the time [the migrant group] makes it out of the desert, several days have passed. Lack of water and heat is usually what kills them.”
As we drove with hot air roaring through open windows and volunteers Danny Morales and Ricardo Equivias passing time cracking jokes in the backseat, the border fence came into view and snaked along to my right. Vicente started pointing out seemingly innocuous geographical features that form a killer gauntlet for migrants. Enough people drowned in drinking water Borderland Deaths of Migrants Quietly Reach Crisis Numbers | Larry Miller's Blog: Educate All Students!:

Colonialism, Not Reform: New Orleans Schools Since Katrina • An Interview with Karran Harper Royal

Colonialism, Not Reform: New Orleans Schools Since Katrina • An Interview with Karran Harper Royal:



Colonialism, Not Reform

New Orleans Schools Since Katrina

An Interview with community activist Karran Harper Royal
BY STAN KARP AND JODY SOKOLOWER





Karran Harper Royal
By next fall, New Orleans will have only five public schools—those operated by the Orleans Parish School Board. Everything else will be charters. The post-Katrina path to almost 100 percent charter education began with the post-storm shutdown of the city’s struggling public schools and the firing (recently declared illegal) of some 7,500 unionized teachers and other school employees, predominantly African American women. The assault was accelerated by a massive infusion of foundation and entrepreneurial investment in new charter schools, and years of state and federally supported deregulation and privatization.
Today the city has tens of thousands fewer children than before Katrina and significantly fewer African American residents, but the school-age population of 44,000 remains mostly poor and black. Parents and families must navigate a maze of selective charters, each operating as an independent district with little oversight. Special-needs students have particular problems finding appropriate placements. One 2010 study found 4,000 teens, about 10 percent of the city’s student population, not enrolled in school at all. New Orleans has also been a spawning ground for authoritarian “no excuses” pedagogy, inexperienced Teach For America corps members, and “zero tolerance” discipline policies.
Throughout this transformation, Karran Harper Royal has been a passionate voice for parents and an articulate witness, sounding the alarm to the rest of the nation about the on-the-ground realities behind the New Orleans “miracle.” Rethinking Schools editors Stan Karp and Jody Sokolower spoke with Harper Royal in several sessions over the past year.
Rethinking Schools: What was your experience as a parent in the New Orleans public schools before Hurricane Katrina hit in 2005?
Karran Harper Royal: My start was 22 years ago, in 1992, when my son Khris was in kindergarten and he couldn’t sit still. I worked in the French Quarter, right at the corner of Royal and Toulouse. There was a little school down the street called McDonogh 15 Creative Arts Magnet School [now a KIPP school]. I wanted Khris to go to school near where I worked. So I just went down the street and asked, “Can I enroll my child here?” and they took him. He didn’t have to take a test or audition to get in, but it was a school of choice focused on the arts. It was such a special place, an amazing public school, very child-centered. The founder was Lucianne Carmichael. She’s retired now, but she has an artist retreat across the river called A Studio in the Woods.
RS: Khris was your oldest child?
KHR: My first child. And I was not who you see today. I was a very meek—if you can believe that—quiet mother who just wanted her son to be successful in school, because otherwise he was going to end up like my brother who at that time was in and out of jail. He was on drugs, he was a car thief—the best car thief in New Orleans, but a car thief. And, in my mind, there was a straight line from kindergarten to the prison cell. So I started visiting my son’s school. By the spring of his kindergarten year, I had quit my job and started going to school every day to find out why he was always in trouble. In trouble at that school was not the same as in trouble at a school today. In trouble meant he was asked to sit outside the classroom in the hallway or he was sent up to the librarian. Sometimes his teacher’s husband, a 70-year-Colonialism, Not Reform: New Orleans Schools Since Katrina • An Interview with Karran Harper Royal:

Ira Shor: Opt Out – The Real Parent Revolution - UNITED OPT OUT: The Movement to End Corporate Education Reform

Ira Shor: Opt Out – The Real Parent Revolution - UNITED OPT OUT: The Movement to End Corporate Education Reform:



Ira Shor: Opt Out – The Real Parent Revolution

facebooktwitterredditmail
First posted at Diane Ravitch‘s blog.
ira uooIra Shor is a professor at the City University of New York, where he teaches composition and rhetoric. Shor understands that standardized testing is the foundation on which the entire “reform” project rests. Take away the test scores, and the data-driven teacher evaluation collapses, along with the ambitious plans for privatization.
Shor writes:
We parents can stop the destruction of our public schools. We can stop the looting of school budgets by private charters and testing vendors. We can stop the abuse of our children by the relentless hours of testing. We can stop the closings, the co-locations, the mass firings, the replacement of veteran teachers with short-term Teach for America newbies, the shameful indignity of public schools told they have 24 hours to clear out so a charter can seize their classrooms. To do this, we have to opt-out our kids from the new testing regimes—refuse to let the schools test our kids with PARCC or Smarter Balanced, boycott the pointless and punitive tests which make the best years of our kids’ lives into a digital hell.
I opted-out my 10-year-old son from all state tests this year and will continue to do so when the useless and costly PARCC tests arrive next year. I will encourage other parents to join me in boycotting such standardized tests, which Diane Ravitch has rightly called “junk science” because they cannot accurately report a student’s achievement, learning process, or academic needs, or a teacher’s competence. For commercial and political reasons, it pleases Duncan, Gates and Co. to spread such tools from coast to coast, but they offer no evidence that such tools can do the job they claim, despite the constant promotion financed by Gates’s Ira Shor: Opt Out – The Real Parent Revolution - UNITED OPT OUT: The Movement to End Corporate Education Reform:

Nite Cap 7-27-14 #BATsACT #RealEdTalk #EDCHAT



James Baldwin said it best: 

"For these are all our children, and we will profit by or pay for whatever they become."


A BIG EDUCATION APE NITE CAP



Stanford’s Shavelson & Boulder’s Domingue on VAMs in Higher Ed |
Stanford’s Shavelson & Boulder’s Domingue on VAMs in Higher Ed |: Stanford’s Shavelson & Boulder’s Domingue on VAMs in Higher Ed A few months ago, well over 10,000 educational researchers/academics from throughout the world attended the Annual Conference of the American Educational Research Association (AERA) in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, during which many of the said researchers/academic
Sam Pirozzolo's Hypocrisy Exposed southbronxschool
http://www.southbronxschool.com: Sam Pirozzolo's Hypocrisy ExposedIn light of today's story in the Daily News how Campbell Brown, the Bayou Schicksa, is now joiningthe fray and about to file her own law suit (More to come on this story on these pages this week), we yet again must focus on the comedy stylings of The Crack Team's favorite source of material, Sam Pirozzolo.Yes, this will mark the 7th
Houston school district aiming to recruit North Carolina’s teachers | CharlotteObserver.com
Houston school district aiming to recruit North Carolina’s teachers | CharlotteObserver.com: Houston school district aiming to recruit North Carolina’s teachersBy Megan Cassellamcassella@charlotteobserver.comPosted: Friday, Jul. 25, 2014MORE INFORMATIONNC House OKs charter bill after debate on salary disclosure, gay studentsNorth Carolina teachers struggling with low salaries and repeated pay free
Why I will NOT attend the BAT Rally in D.C. on Monday… | Reclaim Reform
Why I will NOT attend the BAT Rally in D.C. on Monday… | Reclaim Reform: Why I will NOT attend the BAT Rally in D.C. on Monday…Posted on July 27, 2014by Ken PrevitiI want very, very much to attend the Badass Teachers Association rally in Washington D.C. on Monday. I am simply unable to attend; events in my life have gotten in the way. I truly wanted to be at all of the past week’s BAT events.As an
4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit 7-27-14
4LAKids - some of the news that doesn't fit: MOODY’S ASSIGNS Aa2 RATING to LAUSD’s GENERAL OBLIGATION BONDS: $138.4 million new debt affected; rating affirmed on outstanding parity and COP debtThe Wall Street Transcript from Moody’s press Release  |  http://bit.ly/1zjrUb3 New York, July 25, 2014  Issue: General Obligation Bonds, Election of 2004, Series J (2014); Rating: Aa2; Sale Amount: $71,435,
Don’t Trust Charters More than a Sweaty Used Car Salesman (A Citizen Research Template) | Cloaking Inequity
Don’t Trust Charters More than a Sweaty Used Car Salesman (A Citizen Research Template) | Cloaking Inequity: Don’t Trust Charters More than a Sweaty Used Car Salesman (A Citizen Research Template)Recently I have noticed a new snare from charter cheerleaders. Their approach is for them to ask you to tell them which charters school you love/like. This is a clever trap. My response is, “Why don’t you
Would You Believe…? | WagTheDog
Would You Believe…? | WagTheDog: Would You Believe…? As data-driven and evidence-based challenges to the efficacy of the untested Common Core State Standards become stronger and louder, it appears CCSS supporters are growing desperate and resorting to Maxwell Smart’s catchphrase and tactic of backpedaling and shifting between unconvincing and unsubstantiated claims.This “Would you believe…?” strat
Firestorm Over Campbell Brown’s Wall-Street Backed Lawsuit Against Teachers
News - Alliance for Quality Education of New York: Firestorm Over Campbell Brown’s Wall-Street Backed Lawsuit Against TeachersParents and Teachers Slam Bogus Lawsuit as Wall St. Front Group, Dismiss Former TV-Anchor as Out-of-Touch and with No Credibility on Education Issues*Parents, teachers and experts available for comment*(New York, NY) – Today, Campbell Brown announced she will file a bogus l
7-27-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum
Seattle Schools Community Forum: Something Horrible Under Every RockPeople frequently ask me "What fuels your activist energy?" and I tell them "Outrage." "But how," they ask,"can you stay outraged for fourteen years?" "I can't." I tell them. "I'm newly outraged every couple days. And you would be too if you watched the District closely. There
Reframing Expertise (The Habitual Line-Stepper) - The Jose Vilson
Reframing Expertise (The Habitual Line-Stepper) - The Jose Vilson: Reframing Expertise (The Habitual Line-Stepper)In my travels this summer, I’m often asked to ponder this idea of expertise, and specifically, how education researchers and those in higher education can help K-12 teachers.Since I entered the teaching profession almost a decade ago, I’ve had this struggle with this idea. From article
7-27-14 Ed Notes Online
Ed Notes Online: The Diane Ravitch Contradiction: Educators Should Rebel, but Be Nice When Addressing Oppressive Union Leaderships....you want the workers to be rebellious, not docile. There is a time for collaboration and a time to stand up and fight... Ravitch on film "Metropolis."  I grow frustrated when union members attack their unions. Of course, they should fight to win democratic
7-27-14 Jersey Jazzman
Jersey Jazzman: @StarLedger Editorials: Consistently Wrong About Newark EducationI reached the end of my rope with the Star-Ledger Editorial Board and its chief, Tom Moran, a long time ago. When it comes to education -- particularly in Newark -- both the paper's unsigned editorials and Moran's columns have displayed massive ignorance. Frankly, I'm tired of having to address their nonsense when it'
Is Progressive Schooling Just Around the Corner? (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice
Is Progressive Schooling Just Around the Corner? (Part 2) | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice: Is Progressive Schooling Just Around the Corner? (Part 2)Predicting the future, well, is iffy. Except for an occasional Nate Silver who became famous in calling the 2012 election of Barack Obama, more often than not, predictions of what is around the corner range from goofy to funny. I
You can’t take politics out of education | Missouri Education Watchdog
You can’t take politics out of education | Missouri Education Watchdog: You can’t take politics out of educationTwitter was all abuzz Friday night with common core proponents attempting to stem the tide against the common core state standards initiative. Under the hashtag #ccsstime being led by the Learning First Alliance @LFA, a conversation about how to fix the implementation of Common Core is o
Let education professionals handle teaching standards
Let education professionals handle teaching standards: Let education professionals handle teaching standardsWhat does it say about our society when a few powerful spokesmen are more highly regarded than professional educators and parents in regard to opinions and policies governing education? Concern is growing over a shift in educational decision-making that has left teachers and parents with lit
Morning Wink 7-27-14 AM Posts #edchat #edreform
BIG EDUCATION APE - MORNING WINK  AM POSTS7-27-14 Wait What? - Jonathan Pelto: Gubernatorial Candidate and A Really Nice GuyWait What?: Wait What? I didn’t leave my political party, my party left meI’m often asked why, considering I’m a life-long Democratic, I am “leaving” the Democratic Party and running as an independent for Governor.  I start by explaining that as hard as it is to run as an ind
7-27-14 Wait What? - Jonathan Pelto: Gubernatorial Candidate and A Really Nice Guy
Wait What?: Wait What? I didn’t leave my political party, my party left meI’m often asked why, considering I’m a life-long Democratic, I am “leaving” the Democratic Party and running as an independent for Governor.  I start by explaining that as hard as it is to run as an independent, I thought the institutional barriers to winning a Democratic Primary were even greater. But then I add that, […] T
7-27-14 Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida
Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education: Andy Gardiner’s Demogoguery Misleads Floridians on FEA LawsuitThe incoming president of the Florida Senate cannot be trusted on education policy. Not if he’s going to deliberately mislead Floridians while  misrepresenting the position of the state’s teachers. Senator And
7-27-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher
Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.: An ethnic slur.A few days ago, in my continuing sadness about what is happening in Gaza, I posted on Twitter. “One Palestinian child is killed every hour in Gaza.” People all over the world have taken to the streets to call for an end to Israel’s military assault on what is the prison called Gaza. I a
LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 7-27-14 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Why the Election in Georgia MattersBertis Downs is a native of Georgia and a member of the board of the Network for Public Education. He writes: This is the best electoral news in a long time– Georgia Democrat Valarie Wilson won the runoff for state school superintendent, and it wasn’t even close: http://bit.ly/Us7qNi I am proud to
7-27-14 Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL
Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day… | …For Teaching ELL, ESL, & EFL: The Best Resources To Help Promote A Physically Healthy Lifestyle For Our Students© 2014 Juhan Sonin, Flickr | CC-BY | via Wylio I’ve published a fair amount number of posts about lessons and tools I use to help promote a physically healthy lifestyle for my students, including research that shows how essential it is for lea
7-27-14 Perdido Street School Week
Perdido Street School: Campbell Brown Uses A Paid Organizer Of StudentsFirstNY As The Face Of Her Tenure/Seniority LawsuitFrom the Daily News: Seven families will file suit Monday to end teacher tenure in the fiercest attack yet on job protections enjoyed by New York State educators. The families, including five from some of the most impoverished communities in the city, claim their children were
7-27-14 Schools Matter All Week
Schools Matter: Haslam Continues Ed Policy Based on Secrecy, Favoritism, and DupliictyWashington County School Board member Jack Leonard speaks Friday outside the district's central office as state Reps. Matthew Hill, Micah Van Huss and Tony Shipley listen. (Nathan Baker/Johnson City Press)Bill Haslam is up for re-election this year, and if Tennesseans can see beyond the ends of the Obama-hating n
7-27-14 Curmudgucation Week
CURMUDGUCATION: Pearson Set Cut Scores for NYSOver at lohud, actual journalists like Gary Stern have been working long hours trying to pry loose some facts from the state of New York, and it's worth the while of folks from all states to see what they've dug up because it's a bright red warning flag about how the CCSS-linked testing program actually works.Gannett Publishing had to pry open the stat
DON'T SHOOT ME! Read Maureen Dowd's column
DON'T SHOOT ME! Read Maureen Dowd's column: DON'T SHOOT ME! Read Maureen Dowd's columnbyteacherkenFollow    4 Comments / 4 Newwhich is titled Angell in the Outfield, and is about the wonderful writer Roger Angell, being honored by the Baseball Hall of Fame.If you love baseball and/or love good writing and you do not already know the work of Roger Angell, long-time fiction editor of The New Yorker,
NYC Educator: NYSYUT President Karen Mageee Explains How Common Core Enables Life, the Universe, and Everything
NYC Educator: NYSYUT President Karen Mageee Explains How Common Core Enables Life, the Universe, and Everything: NYSYUT President Karen Mageee Explains How Common Core Enables Life, the Universe, and EverythingIn recent debate over the Common Core, NYSUT president, Karen Magee, said:"I pose the questions to you today: If not standards, then what? A free-for-all? Everyone does what they please
Louisiana Educator: White Refuses to Release Raw LEAP Cut Scores
Louisiana Educator: White Refuses to Release Raw LEAP Cut Scores: White Refuses to Release Raw LEAP Cut ScoresA press statement accompanying the release of the Spring 2014 LEAP and iLEAP testing results announced that the percentage of students receiving a rating of "mastery" on the LEAP had improved this year and the percentage of students rated "basic" remained steady this ye
Lisa Nielsen: The Innovative Educator: Are Your Fav #EdTech Resources Keeping Student Data Safe? Find Out!
Lisa Nielsen: The Innovative Educator: Are Your Fav #EdTech Resources Keeping Student Data Safe? Find Out!: Are Your Fav #EdTech Resources Keeping Student Data Safe? Find Out!Are you an innovative educator who loves using digital media, but is a little concerned about the safety of student data?Do you wonder if your classroom tech use is CIPA and FERPA compliant?  You are not alone.This is a hot m

YESTERDAY

Jennifer Rogers Goes From Queens to Georgia southbronxschool
http://www.southbronxschool.com: Jennifer Rogers Goes From Queens to GeorgiaAs readers of this blog know, we spent some time on discussing Jennifer Rogers (neĂ© Jones) former principal of PS 29 in College Park, Queens on  these pages last year. In fact this post, was so well received, there were over 200 comments including several threats to myself apparently by people close to Rogers.So what  has
Nite Cap 7-26-14 #BATsACT #RealEdTalk #EDCHAT
James Baldwin said it best: "For these are all our children, and we will profit by or pay for whatever they become."A BIG EDUCATION APE NITE CAPCan’t be in DC with PAA? Join us anyway! | Parents Across AmericaCan’t be in DC with PAA? Join us anyway! | Parents Across America: Can’t be in DC with PAA? Join us anyway!We know that most of our PAA chapter and affiliate members are not able to