Monday, May 9, 2011

The Failure of American Schools(to turn a profit) - Magazine - The Atlantic

The Failure of American Schools - Magazine - The Atlantic

The Failure of American Schools

Who better to lead an educational revolution than Joel Klein, the prosecutor who took on the software giant Microsoft? But in his eight years as chancellor of New York City’s school system, the nation’s largest, Klein learned a few painful lessons of his own—about feckless politicians, recalcitrant unions, mediocre teachers, and other enduring obstacles to school reform.

By JOEL KLEIN

Above: Joel Klein in Brooklyn on the first day of school, two months before he resigned as chancellor
IMAGE CREDIT: RAMIN TALAIE/CORBIS

THREE YEARS AGO, in a New York Times article detailing her bid to become head of the American Federation of Teachers union, Randi Weingarten boasted that despite my calls for “radical reform” to New York City’s school system, Mayor Michael Bloomberg and I had achieved only “incremental” change. It seemed like a strange thing to crow about, but she did have something of a point. New York over the past nine years has experienced what Robert Schwartz, the dean of

Illegal Students Entitled To K-12 Education, Dept. of Education Reminds Schools

Illegal Students Entitled To K-12 Education, Dept. of Education Reminds Schools

Illegal Students Entitled To K-12 Education, Dept. of Education Reminds Schools

Arne Duncan

CHRISTINE ARMARIO 05/ 6/11 07:38 PM ET AP

MIAMI — The U.S. Department of Education sent a letter to districts around the country Friday, reminding them that all students – legal or not – are entitled to a public education.

The letter comes amid reports that schools may be checking the immigration status of students trying to enroll, and reminds districts they are federally prohibited from barring elementary or secondary students on the basis of citizenship status.

"Moreover, districts may not request information with the purpose or result of denying access to public schools on the basis of race, color or national origin," said the letter, which was signed by officials from the department's Office of Civil Rights and the Department of Justice.

"We put this letter out now because we know school districts are in the process of planning for the next school year, and wanted to make sure they had this in hand," said Department of Education spokesman Justin Hamilton. "We were concerned about the number of reports that we've received and heard about, and felt it was necessary to make it clear that this has been the law of the land

Indiana Voucher Bill is Federalism in Action - E.D. Kain - American Times - Forbes

Indiana Voucher Bill is Federalism in Action - E.D. Kain - American Times - Forbes

Indiana Voucher Bill is Federalism in Action

Conor Friedersdorf is excited about the new voucher bill signed into law in Indiana by governor Mitch Daniels. Dana Goldstein is more skeptical, pointing to a number of aspects of the legislation that are counterproductive, such as requiring students to receive permission to attend a class taught by a teacher rated as ‘ineffective’ two years in a row. And finally, Cato’s Adam Schaeffer thinks the law is little more than a mountain of regulations waiting to crush private schools participating in the voucher program.

They’re all probably a bit correct. Personally, I’m a fan of federalism, even though I know it will lead to ideas I don’t support. Vouchers, for instance, seem like a pretty Utopian reform, and contra Schaeffer, I think you’re pretty much bound to have strings attached to government money. Private schools that don’t want government

Why Healthcare Reform Requires Market Reforms

The American healthcare system is a mess. Buried under regional insurance monopolies, supply-side cartels, and a vast web of ad hoc government intrusions is something remotely resembling an actual market. But only remotely. A true healthcare market would not be so opaque that healthcare consumers could not identify prices. Nor would it require consumers to acquire health insurance via their employer.

Under presidential hopeful Mitt Romney, Massachussettes attempted to solve some of the many problems our healthcare system has created by creating, essentially, Obamacare (though predating the recent healthcare law by several years). The problem is, Romneycare created subsidies for purchasing health insurance without applying market reforms to increase access and competition of healthcare provision. And so we get this:

A new poll of 838 Massachusetts doctors finds patients are still waiting weeks — in some cases

Afternoon Update: Big Education Ape: Ed News Now

Big Education Ape


“Untapped Resource? Engaging Parents in the Learning Process” | Engaging Parents In School...

“Untapped Resource? Engaging Parents in the Learning Process” | Engaging Parents In School...

A great success: Walker-Corbett-Rhee rally in DC

Teamster Nation: A great success: Walker-Corbett-Rhee rally in DC

A great success: Walker-Corbett-Rhee rally in DC

Koch whore Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker cannot have been pleased by the reception he got in front of the Washington Marriott today. Nor can Chainsaw Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett or Erasergate star Michelle Rhee.

The energetic protesters in front of the hotel got plenty of press attention, which detracted from the message flogged by the three enemies of public education. It can't have helped that the protest helped expose the extremist billionaire backers of the voucher movement.

The program went off without a hitch. Parents, teachers and students were all heard. It was well worth the effort for all those

State of Emergency Week gathering national attention « State of Emergency

State of Emergency Week gathering national attention « State of Emergency

State of Emergency Week gathering national attention

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Dozens of California teachers rallied Monday in downtown San Francisco, launching a week of statewide protests over the threat of deep budget cuts to public education.

The demonstrations and teach-ins were planned as schools face the prospect of mass layoffs, program cuts and shorter school years. The protests will culminate Friday with a sit-in at the state Capitol.

“We’re here to make a statement,” said Dennis Kelly, president of United Educators of San Francisco, which represents more than 6,000 employees of the San Francisco Unified School District.

You can find the rest of the article here on Huffington Post.

The L.A. Times Does Not Appear To Understand What “Irony” Means | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...

The L.A. Times Does Not Appear To Understand What “Irony” Means | Larry Ferlazzo's Websites of the Day...

The L.A. Times Does Not Appear To Understand What “Irony” Means

Yesterday, I posted about the Los Angeles Times decision to publicly rank 11,500 more teachers (seeL.A. Times Releases Their Ratings Of 11,500 More Teachers Today). In their article announcing the new rankings, the paper wrote about a letter they received from leaders of the LA Unified School District, Chamber of Commerce and other groups asking them not to publish their analysis of each teacher.

Today, Alexander Russo (I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: he writes a “must-read” blog) asked the Times for a copy of the letter, but the paper refused because of privacy concerns: “”The letter is not a public document and

The Nation describes the far-right DeVos family, a partner of Rhee's, and their involvement in dismanteling public education

The Nation describes the far-right DeVos family, a partner of Rhee's, and their involvement in dismanteling public education

L.A. Unified: Teacher evals “should be private conversations”

The nation’s second-largest school district, Los Angeles Unified, opposed press efforts to publish teacher evaluations, according to a letter from the school district (PDF) to the Los Angeles Times that was obtained by the writer Alexander Russo.

The letter urges the Los Angeles Times not to publish a second batch of teacher evaluations that the newspaper calculated and published anyway on Sunday. It was signed by LA superintendent John Deasy as well as the president of the city’s school board and two civic leaders, the president of the city’s chamber of commerce and its United Way chapter.

“The individual evaluations, in our opinion, should be private conversations that are intended to help professionals improve their performance in the classroom,” the letter argues.

Deasy’s position stands in sharp contrast to the one New York City school officials are taking in a

L.A. Unified: Teacher evals “should be private conversations” | GothamSchools

L.A. Unified: Teacher evals “should be private conversations” | GothamSchools

L.A. Unified: Teacher evals “should be private conversations”

The nation’s second-largest school district, Los Angeles Unified, opposed press efforts to publish teacher evaluations, according to a letter from the school district (PDF) to the Los Angeles Times that was obtained by the writer Alexander Russo.

The letter urges the Los Angeles Times not to publish a second batch of teacher evaluations that the newspaper calculated and published anyway on Sunday. It was signed by LA superintendent John Deasy as well as the president of the city’s school board and two civic leaders, the president of the city’s chamber of commerce and its United Way chapter.

“The individual evaluations, in our opinion, should be private conversations that are intended to help professionals improve their performance in the classroom,” the letter argues.

Deasy’s position stands in sharp contrast to the one New York City school officials are taking in a

Retirement party season. « Fred Klonsky's blog

Retirement party season. « Fred Klonsky's blog

Retirement party season.

In a few minutes I’ll be heading over to the Snuggery in Edison Park. On the calendar, today is the final meeting of the year of the Governing Board of our Local.

It is traditional to invite all the members to a local restaurant, do a little business and then honor our retirees

It is retirement party season.

Each building will hold a party for their retirees.

The IEA Region will honor retiring union activists at a dinner later this month at Hackney’s, a local restaurant that serves good burgers and an incredible fried onion ring loaf.

Our district used to host a retirement reception. They stopped doing that. I don’t know why. They continue to

Will charters agree to limit enrollment in return for discounted buildings? | Philadelphia Public School Notebook

Will charters agree to limit enrollment in return for discounted buildings? | Philadelphia Public School Notebook

Will charters agree to limit enrollment in return for discounted buildings?

The School District of Philadelphia hopes to preserve its declining ability to manage the growth of charter schools by offering a discount on unused school buildings only to charters that agree not to expand their enrollment.

But will charter school operators – who are gaining growing clout under the school-choice-focused Corbett administration – go for it?

Featured Title:
More on the facilities master plan

read more

Schools Matter: The Amazing Effect of KIPP on Howard Gardner

Schools Matter: The Amazing Effect of KIPP on Howard Gardner

The Amazing Effect of KIPP on Howard Gardner

Dean McCartney of the Harvard GSE (and Bellwether Board Member) and Howard Gardner, of multiple intelligence fame, did a drive-by evaluation back in January at KIPP in Revere, MA. The deftly-edited video below, with classical piano accompaniment, is the result.

Dr. Gardner was there long enough, obviously, to forget everything he ever wrote about, taught about, preached about, regarding multiple intelligences. Also, please note that Dr. Gardner praises the "flatness" of the KIPP

School Tech Connect: Negotiating With Terrorists

School Tech Connect: Negotiating With Terrorists

Negotiating With Terrorists

It's done all the time.

Ok, I regret the title of this post already. Sears is not a terrorist; they're a corporation--- they have a duty to increase shareholder value, and they're going to do whatever it takes. When Rod Paige called the NEA a terrorist organization, I was appalled.

The problem is this: these tax-break relocation incentives-- they build a house of sand. Whatever good they do a community, they do an equal bad somewhere else--- and then there's the permanent, pernicious threat that

Shanker Blog » Shanker Institute Counters Efforts To Undermine Common Core State Standards; Repeats Call For Matching Curricula

Shanker Blog » Shanker Institute Counters Efforts To Undermine Common Core State Standards; Repeats Call For Matching Curricula

Shanker Institute Counters Efforts To Undermine Common Core State Standards; Repeats Call For Matching Curricula

The “Closing the Door on Innovation” manifesto issued today by a group of conservatives distorts the purpose of the nonpartisan Albert Shanker Institute-sponsored Call for Common Content statement released in March. The statement was signed by a diverse group of education and other leaders from across the political spectrum – and emphasized that teachers must have access to voluntary curriculum guidelines in order to teach effectively to the new state-led common core standards. Aligning the new standards to high quality curriculum is critical to ensuring that all children in the U.S. receive a rigorous education.

“While we agree that curriculum should be designed before assessments, their claim that the ‘Call for Common Content’ is about creation of a ‘national curriculum’ and ‘national standards’ is just plain wrong,” said Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT), one of the signatories to the Shanker Institute statement.

“What we argued then, and what the AFT’s own committee on implementation of common core standards will

Who's the power behind CMS? | CharlotteObserver.com & The Charlotte Observer Newspaper

Who's the power behind CMS? | CharlotteObserver.com & The Charlotte Observer Newspaper

Who's the power behind CMS?

If you follow the money, you'll find the Broad Foundation. And skeptics are questioning its clout.

By Ann Doss Helms
ahelms@charlotteobserver.com

Superintendent Peter Gorman may be the face of public education in Charlotte, but is a Los Angeles billionaire the power behind the scenes?

Locally and nationally, skeptics are questioning the clout wielded by Eli Broad. His foundation, which has helped put Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools in the national spotlight, has also paid to train Gorman and the school board, and to help CMS hire administrators with a business bent.

As public money dwindles, "venture philanthropists" such as Broad (rhymes with "road") and Bill Gates play a growing role in driving education reform. CMS is in the thick of their quest to find better ways to educate low-income and minority students, using principles that helped the benefactors earn their fortunes.

"With budget cuts, it's impossible to make student gains unless every penny at central-



Read more: http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2011/05/08/2281054/whos-the-power-behind-cms.html#ixzz1LtGHAHwR

Michelle Rhee joins Scott Walker at school voucher group's "policy summit" - War Room - Salon.com

Michelle Rhee joins Scott Walker at school voucher group's "policy summit" - War Room - Salon.com

Michelle Rhee joins Scott Walker at school voucher group's "policy summit"

Every rich Democrat's favorite school reformer addresses a right-wing non-profit with the Wisconsin governor

ASCD Inservice: The Overpressured Student

ASCD Inservice: The Overpressured Student

The Overpressured Student

Do some students get the message that their only value is their ability to achieve academically? When do high expectations cross the line? "The Overpressured Student," in the May 2011 Educational Leadership, offers ways that schools and families can rein...

Bin Laden's Death as Teachable Moment

Last Monday morning, how were or weren't you discussing Osama bin Laden's death with your students? This was the most popular topic in ASCD SmartBrief last week. Teachers grappled with the age-appropriateness and paradoxes within the news that was broadcast...