Latest News and Comment from Education

Friday, December 28, 2012

Questions for Illinois’ so-called progressive Democrats who have chosen to run and hide on Janurary 3rd. « Fred Klonsky

Questions for Illinois’ so-called progressive Democrats who have chosen to run and hide on Janurary 3rd. « Fred Klonsky:


Questions for Illinois’ so-called progressive Democrats who have chosen to run and hide on Janurary 3rd.

Popout.
The great heavyweight champion Joe Lewis is famous for saying, “You can run, but you can’t hide.”
Thousands of Illinois public employees, teachers included, made plans to talk to state legislators when they were going to meet in lame duck session January 3rd.
Emails were sent out. Phone calls were made. Buses were rented. Vacation plans were changed.
Chicago area’s so-called progressive Democrats like

Stotsky: Common Core Writing Standards Not Linked to Appropriate Reading Standards | Truth in American Education

Stotsky: Common Core Writing Standards Not Linked to Appropriate Reading Standards | Truth in American Education:


Stotsky: Common Core Writing Standards Not Linked to Appropriate Reading Standards

Dr. Sandra Stotsky, professor of education reform at the University of Arkansas, wrote a piece for the Indiana Policy Review that critiques the Common Core ELA Standards and called Indiana to re-adopt the standards they had before that were superior to the Common Core.  She also pointed out a problem with the Common Core’s writing standards that very few are talking about – they are not linked to appropriate reading standards.  Reading and writing go hand in glove with one another.  I had written before that I was concerned how a dependence on informational text would impact writing as one learns to write well by reading great writing, but Stotsky points out a problem that is even more basic than that.
The standards are not age-appropriate, nor do the elementary standards adequately prepare older students for what the standards require of them later on.
She wrote:
Common Core’s English language arts standards don’t have just one fatal flaw, i.e., its arbitrary division of reading standards into two groups: 10 standards for “informational” text and nine for 

Modern School: Knights of Labor Founded Today in Labor History

Modern School: Knights of Labor Founded Today in Labor History:


Knights of Labor Founded Today in Labor History


The Knights of Labor

(From the Knights of Labor website)
The Knights of Labor (KOL), officially known as the "Noble and Holy Order of the Knights of Labor," was founded on December 28, 1869, when both American capitalism and the labor movement were young and relatively disorganized. It began as a secret society, but quickly grew into the largest and most significant labor organization in the U.S. by the 1880s. The Knights are considered by many to be a predecessor to the more well-known Industrial Workers of the World (IWW). Like its more radical cousin, the IWW, the KOL called for the abolition of the wage system and fought to organize all workers into one big union, including women and immigrants. And, like the IWW, one of the KOL’s slogans was, “An Injury to One is the Concern of All.”
Terence Powderly
 The KOL was founded by seven members of the Philadelphia tailors' union, led by Uriah Smith Stephens and James L. Wright. However, the Knights’ most rapid growth occurred under the leadership of Terence Powderly, who replaced Stephens as Grand Master, and convinced the organization to give up its secrecy. The Knights originally denounced strikes, 

All My “Best Of 2012″ Lists In One Place! | Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day…

All My “Best Of 2012″ Lists In One Place! | Larry Ferlazzo’s Websites of the Day…:


All My “Best Of 2012″ Lists In One Place!

I’ve posted many “Best of 2012″ year-end lists, and I thought readers might find it useful for me to put them all together.
You might also be interested in:
All My “Best Of 2011″ Lists In One Place
I apparently didn’t do this kind of compilation in previous years, but you can find all 1,050 “The Best…” lists categorized here.
Here are All My “Best Of 2012″ Lists:
The Best Resources, Articles & Blog Posts For Teachers Of ELL’s In 2012 — Part One
The Best Online Learning Games Of 2012 — So Far
The Best Science Sites Of 2012 — Part One
The Best Infographics Of 2012 — So Far
The Best Social Studies Sites Of 2012 — So Far
The Best Articles (And Blog Posts) Offering Practical Advice To Teachers In 2012 — Part One
The Best Articles, Videos & Posts On Education Policy In 2012 — Part One
The Best Videos For Educators In 2012 — Part One
The Best Ways To Create Online Content Easily & Quickly In 2012 — Part One

The Best Places To Find The Most Popular (& Useful) Resources For Educators – 2012 (So Far)

The Best Websites For English Language Learner Students In 2012 — Part One

The Best Theory Of Knowledge Resources In 2012 — Part One

My Best Posts On New Research Studies In 2012 — So Far

The Best “Fun” Sites You Can Use For Learning, Too — 2012 (So Far)
The Best Comic Strips For Students & Teachers In 2012 — So Far
Best Tweets Of 2012

The Best Videos I’ve Shared On Google Plus In 2012

“My Best Posts On Building Parent Engagement In Schools — 2012 (Part Two)”

”The best — and worst — education news of 2012″

The Best “Words Of The Year” Features For 2012

My Best “Pins” On Pinterest In 2012

The Best Websites For English Language Learner Students In 2012 — Part Two
The Best Resources, Articles & Blog Posts For Teachers Of ELL’s In 2012 — Part Two
The Best “Fun” Sites You Can Use For Learning, Too — 2012 (Part Two)
The Best Science Sites Of 2012 — Part Two
The Best Social Studies Sites Of 2012 — Part Two
The Best “Year In Review” Features That Aren’t Photo Collections — 2012
The Best Year-End Collections Of Images — 2012
The Best Articles I’ve Written In 2012
The Best Theory Of Knowledge Resources In 2012 — Part Two
All My 2012 “The Best…” Lists On Education Policy In One Place
The Best Articles, Videos & Posts On Education Policy In 2012 — Part Two
The Best Articles (And Blog Posts) Offering Practical Advice & Resources To Teachers In 2012 — Part Two
The Best Videos For Educators In 2012 — Part Two
The Best Ways To Create Online Content Easily & Quickly In 2012 — Part Two
The Best Web 2.0 Applications For Education In 2012

MORNING UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 12-28-12 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch


Why the Double Standards?

Arthur Goldstein, who teaches ESL and English in a Queens, New York, high school, writes a consistently excellent blog (nyceducator.com).
In this post, he raises an intriguing question: Why is that reformers can criticize teachers nonstop and say ridiculous things about them but get twisted into paroxysms of outrage if anyone dares to defend teachers or–

Inside Story on Louisiana Spin and Failures

If you are a fan of mystery writing and novels, this will interest you.
If you love non-fiction, it will also interest you.
This is a true-life drama from Baton Rouge about a school that was taken over by the state in 2008 and has seen no improvement. The story involves money, politics, power, hidden agendas, intrigue and data. What could be better?
In trying to get to the bottom of the story, it is mandatory that you read the comments. That’s where the best stuff is.



Time to Crack Down on Cheating

Matthew Di Carlo at the Shanker Institute has a good post about the importance of test security in an era of high-stakes testing.
As long as we have high-stakes testing–which I oppose–we need to guard against cheating.
He points out that the scandal in Atlanta was thoroughly reviewed by independent and well-trained investigators. They got to the bottom of it.
But the other major cheating scandal in D.C. was swept under the rug by officials who wanted to see it 


Value-Added Ratings for Our Secretaries of Education

A little known group called Educators for Shared Accountability designed a rubric for evaluating Secretaries of Education. It incorporates multiple measures.
By its metric, Richard Riley was our best national leader.
Check out Secretary Duncan’s value added rating.

Another Way to Crush Teacher Morale

The Louisiana Department of Education is bringing to fruition the acme of corporate reform salary schedules for teachers. It may have been jointly designed by ALEC and TFA.
Neither experience nor degrees count. The only thing that matters is value-added test scores. The LDOE recommends big bonuses–merit pay–of $10,000 or more for the teachers whose students get higher scores.
Bear in mind that the budget for the schools is stagnant. The law doesn’t permit salary reductions, so any bonuses will be funded by freezing the salaries of the overwhelming majority of teachers.
This is a recipe for massive demoralization of the state’s teachers.

I Need Your Help

I am in search of information and I can’t find it by googling.
So I am turning to you to help me answer these questions.
1. In your state, are special education students required to take the same grade-level tests as regular students? Are there exceptions based on IEPs?
2. Are charters in your state required to administer the state tests?
3. In your state, which state regulations are charters exempt from?
When you reply, please identify your state.
Thanks,
Diane

The Ultimate Reform School!

Drop whatever you are doing, and read this. EduShyster serves up a delightful portrait of an award-winning school in Minneapolis that embodies every new reform strategy. And here is the best part: It hasn’t opened yet! It won’t open until next September and it is already a great success!

Chicago Teachers Union Sues District, Claims Racial Discrimination

This should be of interest to readers. The Chicago Teachers Union has filed a federal lawsuit against the Chicago Public Schools, claiming that African American teachers have been disproportionately harmed by school closings. Over the past decade, their numbers have dropped dramatically in the school system.
Chicago Teachers File Federal Lawsuit Charging CPS with Racial Discrimination
CHICAGO – The oft-maligned Chicago Public Schools (CPS) policy of subjecting neighborhood schools to 

The Happiest Teachers in America?

A few weeks ago, I spoke at he annual conference of the New York State Music Teachers Association in Rochester. As I was going through the lobby of the conference center, I saw many teenagers carrying their musical instruments, preparing to practice and play together. There was a spirit of happy anticipation in the air–at least, that’s what I sensed. It occurred to me that teaching music must be the most joyful of all teaching jobs. The students come to you with different skill levels. They want to learn to play. They understand that they can’t 

On the Transiency of Big Ideas in Education

Diana Senechal has written a thoughtful reflection on the tendency of policymakers to foist big ideas on education. Fads come and go. The ones we live with today, say I, seem especially pernicious because they are backed by the power of the state in alliance with the profit motive.
Yet I remain confident that truly bad ideas will fade away. This is not from a sense of resignation or historical inevitability, but because I believe that educators and parents and school boards will rise up and say “Enough!” It is beginning now, and the roar of protest will grow.

What Is the Point of Reading?

A post about the Common Core standards “No One Opposes Reading Non-Fiction”) was followed by a lively discussion among readers. Among many excellent comments, this one stood out. Written by Robert D. Shepherd, it raises important issues about how publishers will interpret the standards. And even more important, why do we want to read?
Back in the 1960s and ’70s, many educators around the country implemented Phase Elective Programs. Students would take mini-courses, six or nine weeks long, on specific topics like American Transcendentalism or The French Revolution and read a bunch of related materials–fiction, poetry, plays, and nonfiction–on those topics. These programs came under heavy fire from conservatives because many of the topics dealt with popular culture or left-wing politics (e.g., Superheroes, The Literature of Protest, The Haves and the Have Nots). What 

Diane in the Evening 12-27-12Diane Ravitch's blog

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 2 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog: Chicago Teachers Union Sues District, Claims Racial Discrimination by dianerav *This should be of interest to readers. The Chicago Teachers Union has filed a federal lawsuit against the Chicago Public Schools, claiming that African American teachers have been disproportionately harmed by school closings. Over the past decade, their numbers have dropped dramatically in the school system.* *Chicago Teachers File Federal Lawsuit Charging CPS with Racial Discrimination* *CHICAGO – *The oft-maligned Chicago Public Schools (CPS) policy of subjecting neighborh... more »


Common Core Standards: Sky is not falling, but ground is shifting | Get Schooled

Common Core Standards: Sky is not falling, but ground is shifting | Get Schooled:


Common Core Standards: Sky is not falling, but ground is shifting

Mel Riddile is the associate director for high school services at the National Association of Secondary School Principals. His work in turning around schools in Virginia earned him the 2006 MetLife/NASSP National High School Principal of the Year award. This is his first piece for the AJC Get Schooled blog
By Mel Riddile
To answer a couple of the education questions on the minds of Georgia citizens these days:
Yes, we can expect to see a significant drop in the first year of the new Georgia Performance Standards assessments.
No, the sky is not falling.
But the ground is shifting.
Previous Georgia standards and assessments aimed 

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Record Chi-Town murder rate, but not in the schools

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Record Chi-Town murder rate, but not in the schools:


Record Chi-Town murder rate, but not in the schools

Last night in Austin community
The fatal shooting of a 40-year-old man last night on the West Side pushed Chicago's 2012 homicide toll to the 500 mark. Gun deaths have risen sharply since Rahm took office. Is there a direct connection? I can't say. That's for him to explain.

The Tribune blames it on the weather:
Largely contributing to the spike was the unusual number of homicides that occurred during the 

Schools Matter: A multiple choice quiz with only one question

Schools Matter: A multiple choice quiz with only one question:


A multiple choice quiz with only one question

Who said this?

"... the revolution in business ... will, over time, take place in education, too. We will move away from a system that assumes every child of a particular age moves at the same pace in every subject, and develop a system directed to the particular talents and interests of every pupil."

(a) John Dewey
(b) Susan Ohanian
(c) Tony Blair
(d) Robert Reich

The answer is (c), Tony Blair, Prime Minister of the UK, 1997-2007. According to Roland Meighan (http://www.tes.co.uk/article.aspx?storycode=305041), it was quoted by Michael Barber in the Guardian, 

NYC Educator: Have You No Shame?

NYC Educator: Have You No Shame?:


Have You No Shame?

"Reformers" are having a field day criticizing Diane Ravitch. Apparently, she had the audacity to not only call teachers from Newtown heroes, but also to mention they were unionized.

Therefore, she has a political agenda. Therefore, she's saying that non-union teachers are not heroes. Therefore, she's pursuing her own agenda and exploiting this tragedy for her own selfish goals.

And yet, I've been reading everything that crosses my desk about education, and here's what I've learned about teachers:

1. They are lazy. They don't want to do whatever it takes to make sure kids learnget adequate test scores. Why won't they work 200 hours a week, like they do at KIPP? If they did, all kids 

Thursday, December 27, 2012

Schools Matter: Public Schools Falling Like Dominoes

Schools Matter: Public Schools Falling Like Dominoes:

Public Schools Falling Like Dominoes

The forces of education privatization scored a major victory this November in Georgia, thru passage of a cleverly written constitutional amendment backed by a multiimillion dollar deceptive ad campaign, and the active backing or complicit silence of much of the black political class.


Those of us who have been closely following education policy over the past decade, have always known and understood that a test and punish pedagogy would destroy public education, the souls of our nation's children, our democracy and our basic human rights. 

Once upon a time it was just cafeteria or janitorial services that were privatized. Slowly but surely, however, everything from pay and benefits for teachers to curriculum are increasing coming under the control of corporations and business '

Rozy WOW Press: The voice of a UTLA teacher

Rozy WOW Press: The voice of a UTLA teacher:


Rozy WOW Press: The voice of a UTLA teacher

Schools Matter: The fiction vs. non-fiction debate: A distraction from a more important question

Schools Matter: The fiction vs. non-fiction debate: A distraction from a more important question:


The fiction vs. non-fiction debate: A distraction from a more important question

Sent to the Los Angeles Times, Dec. 27, 2012

The debate over fiction vs. non-fiction in the Common Core is diverting us from a more important question: should we have common core standards?

The rational for the standards is the belief that our schools are “broken.” There is no evidence this is true: Middle class American students who attend well-funded schools score at the top of the world on international tests. Our unspectacular scores are because US has such a high percentage of child poverty, 23.1%, the second-highest percentage among 34 economically advanced countries. High-scoring Finland has less than 5.3% child poverty.

Poverty means poor diet, poor health care, and little access to books; all have a devastating effect on school performance.

There is no evidence that standards and tests improve school achievement. The money budgeted for standards and tests to enforce the standards should be used to protect children from the effects of poverty.

Stephen Krashen
Professor Emeritus
University of Southern California

Re LA Times editorial: “What students read,” Dec. 27, 2012: http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/editorials/la-