Tuesday, June 18, 2013

UPDATE: The Madman blinks. + The in box. Pension reform. What is the moral basis for it? | Fred Klonsky

The in box. Pension reform. What is the moral basis for it? | Fred Klonsky:

Children and hedge fund profits.

child-and-money3
Diane Ravitch wisely chose to feature Ken Previti’s blog post on turning children into profit centers.
Ken, Illinois retiree now living in Florida, is a member of our unofficial Constitution Bloggers Association.
Once people realize that their own children are being experimented upon and used for profits, the greed grab will end. The testing craze, the corporate education reform industry, the for-profit and non-profit charter industry, the online educational programing business, etc. will dwindle and either die out or become minuscule.
The profit margins are estimated, the marketing planned, and the technologies used to lure parents 

Representative Ives’ HB3303. Again with turning our pension into a 401(k)?

Between now and July when the General Assembly again meets to go after public employee pensions, Representative Jeanne Ives will be pushing her HB3303. It is another Republican attempt to turn our defined benefit pension into a Vegas-style gamble.
Last week, Constitution Blogger Association member Glen Brown took on this foolishness.
Don’t be fooled by some Illinois politicians’ saccharine prevarications about stabilizing the public 

The Madman blinks.

kent-wallis-lady-jane-grey-queen-for-nine-days-is-beheaded-at-the-tower-of-london-on-charges-of-treason_i-G-17-1753-L5S3D00Z-1
There will be no votes taken on any pension bill tomorrow.
Let’s take a second and review what happened leading up to today.
In the General Assembly session that ended the end of May, nothing happened.
Madigan ordered his House to pass SB1, a pension bomb so punitive to state employees that it would make Alcatraz look like an all-inclusive resort.
Meanwhile We Are One, the coalition of public employee unions, worked out a deal with Senate President Cullerton. It still put the total burden of the continuing pension liability on the employees. However, Cullerton 

The in box. Pension reform. What is the moral basis for it?

The authoritative Springfield observer Jim Broadway.
Prediction: Neither Madigan nor Cullerton will budge. No pension reform bill will be passed and sent to Quinn’s desk. (Did you hear he said he thinks he may have been “put on this Earth” to solve the pension crisis? Wondered what the reason could have been.)
What moral basis? To say, as I have, that Madigan’s plan (or anyone’s plan) “lacks a moral basis” needs to be explained.
A college professor long ago rephrased for me Socrates’ admonition that “an unexamined life is not worth living.” That seems a bit harsh, he said. But he held firmly to assertion that “an unexamined belief is not worth holding.” I found that persuasive.
So I examine my beliefs and therefore hold few of them. Opinions? Oh, I’m full of opinions as anyone can tell you. But opinions can change as new information arrives. Beliefs rarely change. They just get more deeply embedded. People will fight for their beliefs, will die in a clash with those 


Not even toilet paper for schools. Rahm’s bread and circuses instead.

20130618_BRAZIL_EMBED-slide-DOAD-articleLarge

A hundred thousand protest in Sao Paulo, Brazil. 
I was on a field trip to the Loop when word came that Sao Paulo, not Chicago, would get the 2016 Olympics.
Thousands gathered in Daley Plaza in front of City Hall to hear the announcement.
Sao Paulo lost. They were given the Olympics.
As I looked at the pictures of thousands of protesters in a half a dozen Brazilian cities protesting government austerity, inflation and money going to build fancy arenas, I thought to myself, that might have been Chicago.

Minority Kids With Autism Less Likely to Use Specialty Services: Study - US News and World Report

Minority Kids With Autism Less Likely to Use Specialty Services: Study - US News and World Report:

Minority Kids With Autism Less Likely to Use Specialty Services: Study

Compared to white children, black and Hispanic patients may be missing out on certain types of care

June 17, 2013 RSS Feed Print
By Maureen Salamon
HealthDay Reporter
MONDAY, June 17 (HealthDay News) -- Black and Hispanic children with autism are markedly less likely than children from white families to receive specialty care for complications tied to the disorder, a new study finds.
Researchers from Massachusetts General Hospital for Children in Boston found that the rates at which minority children accessed specialists such as gastroenterologists, neurologists and psychiatrists, as well as the tests these specialists use, ran well below those of white children.
"I was surprised not by the trends, but by how significant they were," said study author Dr. Sarabeth Broder-Fingert, a fellow in the department of pediatrics at MassGeneral and Harvard Medical School. "Based on my own clinical experience and some of the literature that exists on this, I thought we'd probably see some differences between white and non-white children in getting specialty care . . . but some of these differences were really large, especially gastrointestinal services."
The study is published online June 17 in the journal Pediatrics.
According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, about one in 50 school-age children has been diagnosed with an autism 

Modern School: Nanny State Gone Wild—More Stupid Rules to Make School More Unpleasant

Modern School: Nanny State Gone Wild—More Stupid Rules to Make School More Unpleasant:

Nanny State Gone Wild—More Stupid Rules to Make School More Unpleasant


Image from Flickr, by KazVorpal

Last week, in her column “The Answer Sheet,” Valerie Straus listed “eight weird things schools banned this year.” Some of the bans were absurd overreactions to freak accidents that were unlikely to ever occur again and that could be averted much more simply through greater caution by students and teachers. For example, frilly socks were banned at Kingshold Primary School in Gloucester, England, after a child tripped over her dangles and fell, according to the Independent. In another bizarre example, Castle View School in Essex, England, prohibited triangular flapjacks (in England, flapjacks are hard cookies, not pancakes) after one was tossed and hit a student in the eye, the independentreported. To “solve” this dangerous problem, school officials are now requiring that flapjacks be square—apparently these officials had flunked geometry class or missed the lesson in which they were taught that squares have more sharp corners than triangles.

Other bans stemmed from the hysteria over bullying, (here andhere), and are equally misguided. The Eagle-Tribune wrote that the Wyndham School District in New Hampshire, for example, has banned dodge ball and other “human target” games as a way to reduce bullying. Yet bullying (as well as run of the mill teasing, 

The Common Core Loses This Teacher's Support - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher

The Common Core Loses This Teacher's Support - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher:

The Common Core Loses This Teacher's Support

Guest post by Katie Lapham.
In April I carried a guest post written by New York City elementary teacher Katie Lapham, expressing support for the Common Core standards, but opposing the tests attached to them. Since then, Ms. Lapham has shifted her views. She explains:
When I first learned about the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) two or so years ago, I didn't question their implementation. I've always preferred designing my own lessons and was sold on the idea that the standards were mostly a guide; we were free to choose our own curriculum.
Since writing to Dr. John King, head of New York State's Education Department, about the excessive CCSS state assessments administered in April, I have spent countless hours educating myself on education reform and Race to the Top polices. I now feel duped. CCSS are much more than a set of learning objectives. By attaching them to government initiatives such as high-stakes testing and teacher evaluation plans, the standards are being used as an instrument to standardize and control public education in the US. Teachers and schools feel increasingly micromanaged, which is insulting and demoralizing. We have less autonomy and choice, and my own personalized instruction is being threatened. Below are the main reasons why I, a teacher and parent, 

NEA Provides Educators with Guidance on Preventing Workplace Bullying | NEA Today

NEA Provides Educators with Guidance on Preventing Workplace Bullying | NEA Today:

NEA Provides Educators with Guidance on Preventing Workplace Bullying

By Cindy Long
Kim Werner’s former principal was identified by her union as the most abusive principal in the district.
“He has been targeting educators for fifteen years,” she says. “He lies. He coerces.  He intimidates.  He screams and uses profanities.”
And he’s still a principal, while Werner is now an Olweus Bullying Prevention Program Trainer.
After a year and a half of constant abuse, Werner took medical leave and reported her principal. She was covered by the district’s Bullying and Harassment policy, and while on leave, requested public records about complaints filed by other educators at her school.
“I soon discovered the horror other educators had experienced under his leadership,” Werner says. “I was shocked and sick inside.  These were simply people who spoke up and addressed his intimidation tactics. They suffered greatly–both professionally and emotionally.”
Bullying leadership is often based upon fear, Werner says, and because bullying principals are scared they 

6-18-13 @ THE CHALK FACE knows SCHOOLS MATTER

@ THE CHALK FACE knows SCHOOLS MATTER:

gears





Robert Skeels Attends a pRev Meet and Greet

Reblogged from Diane Ravitch's blog: Robert Skeels attended a "meet and greet" sponsored by pRev (the organization formerly known as Parent Revolution). Read what he learned as he socialized with those who are prepared to close down 50 public schools in Los Angeles. Why? Well, firing people makes better schools. Or does it? We know […]

Barista Kids Aren’t Drinking the Kool-Aid

Parents of the Barista Kids in Montclair, New Jersey are Opting Out.  Reported by teenage journalists who still know what education should look like. Here’s the petition. Pass it around. The petition states: We are parents and community members of Montclair, New Jersey. We write because we believe in Montclair’s identity as a community of intellect, […]

I’ve visited @NCTQ, we should all be underwhelmed #teacherprep

Paul Thomas and Jim Horn have already warned us about NCTQ and its thoroughly biased “advocacy.” There are some updated links in there, here’s a few more on the new report specifically: From NPR; NCTQ’s chief hypocrisy; And MSNBC. and the Wall Street Journal. Kind of a mixed bag here. I’m not sure if there’s […]

Microsoft No. 1–in Turning Over Data to NSA

You might say that Gates got the ball rolling.  From the PRISM slide show recently exposed (click to enlarge): 

 prism-slide-5

6-17-13 @ THE CHALK FACE knows SCHOOLS MATTER

mike simpson at Big Education Ape - 7 hours ago
@ THE CHALK FACE knows SCHOOLS MATTER: [image: gears] KIPP in Arkansas Gives “Whatever It Takes” New Meaning by Jim Horn Recent conversations with KIPP high school teachers reveals many cracks in KIPP’s Five Pillars. Apparently, KIPP’s Helena, AK high school has interpreted “whatever it takes” to include violating state laws for student transcripts and what can count as course credits. From The Inside Scoop Online: The Arkansas Department of Education has determined that the Helena-West […] PAR NoT PARCC in New Jersey by freetoteach Looking to replace the test driven, evaluatio... more »

U.S. News Releases NCTQ Teacher Prep Ratings - US News and World Report

U.S. News Releases NCTQ Teacher Prep Ratings - US News and World Report:

U.S. News Releases NCTQ Teacher Prep Ratings

The ratings are part of a larger, independent review of undergraduate and graduate education programs.

June 18, 2013 RSS Feed Print
New ratings released by U.S. News and NCTQ evaluate programs that train teachers to teach.
New ratings released by U.S. News and NCTQ evaluate programs that train teachers to teach.
Teaching was once dubbed "the profession that eats its young" and many educators liken their first few years in the classroom to a hazing ritual. The result is an industry that hemorrhages new teachers nearly as fast as it can license them.

One factor feeding the high turnover rate is lack of preparation, according to Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, a national union representing 1.5 million educators.
"Newly minted teachers are tossed the keys to their classrooms … and left to see if they (and their students) sink or swim," she wrote in a December 2012 report for the AFT. The report called for higher standards and accountability in teacher training programs.
The 2013 NCTQ Teacher Prep Ratings, released today by U.S. News, are a step in that direction.
[Read U.S. News Editor Brian Kelly's opinion on the NCTQ ratings.]
Part of a broader effort by the National Council on Teacher Quality, the ratings are a subset of the NCTQ Teacher Prep Review, published toda

FAQs on the 2013 Teacher Prep Ratings

Learn more about the National Council on Teacher Quality ratings of undergrad and grad programs.

Show Me the MOU! | Crazy Crawfish's Blog

Show Me the MOU! | Crazy Crawfish's Blog:

Show Me the MOU!

Today, June 18th 2013, John White and BESE are meeting to try and persuade the public of the need for participating with external Cloud Based vendors like Ed-Fi and inBloom. At the last BESE meeting (several months ago) White promised to released a copy of the MOU/agreement between LDOE and inBloom. To date John White has not released this document, even in response to several Freedom of Information Act requests filed by Tom Aswell at Louisiana Voice and BESE member Lottie Beebe. Demand to see that MOU (Memorandum of Understanding) before they leave today or move on to another topic. If they report no such document exists I recommend appealing to the DA to file charges against White for a million cases of Identity Theft.
Below is a cheatsheet of relevant questions to ask any DOE stooge who tries to deliver a presentation on how wonderful inBloom and data Clouds are:
(FYI – Chas and White may try to spin bus routes as an example of a non-educational use of data, but don’t let them.)

  • Why is DOE sharing actual name dob and SSN instead of just the de-identified GUID built internally for 

There Are Good Schools Out There - Bridging Differences - Education Week

There Are Good Schools Out There - Bridging Differences - Education Week:

There Are Good Schools Out There

Today, Todd Sutler of the Odyssey Initiative joins Deborah Meier for a two-week blogging engagement.
Dear Debbie,
It is an honor to be invited to correspond with you here. I have enjoyed reading your blog for years, and I am lucky to now have you as a friend and adviser to The Odyssey Initiative, an organization I founded with Michelle Healy and Brooke Peters last year. When we set off to research some of America's best schools, it never crossed our minds that we would get a chance to sit down and talk to you. When we met, I was pleased to find that your outspokenness in person was just as engaging and inspiring as it is in your writing. I am disappointed, however, that your readers did not benefit from more of that frankness during your conversation with Mike Petrilli. More on that disappointment in a moment.
Matt Candler, of 4.0 Schools, recently introduced me to Clayton Christensen's book, The Innovator's Dilemma. Christensen's theory, I believe, happens to describe the education reform movement of the last 20 years. The "dilemma," he argues, is the choice companies face when deciding whether to allocate time and resources to address their customers' current needs or to anticipate their future needs. Some companies are reticent to inves

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 6-18-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch


Linda Darling-Hammond on the NCTQ Report

Linda Darling-Hammond of Stanford University is one of the nation’s leading experts on teacher preparation. This is her commentary on the report released by the National Council on Teacher Quality, which attempts to rate the quality of the nation’s colleges of education by reviewing their catalogues and course syllabi.
What Can We Learn about Teacher Education Quality
from the NCTQ Report on Teacher Prep?
Linda Darling-Hammond
This week, the National Council on Teacher Quality (NCTQ) issued a report titled: NCTQ Teacher Prep Review. Billed as a consumer’s guide, the report rates programs on a list of criteria ranging from selection and content preparation to coursework and student teaching aimed at the development of teaching skills. While the report appropriately focuses on these aspects of teacher education, it does not, unfortunately, accurately reflect the work of teacher education programs in California or nationally.
NCTQ’s methodology is a paper review of published course requirements and course syllabi against a check list 

That NCTQ Report on Teacher Education: F

The just-released NCTQ report on teacher education gives an F to the nation’s colleges of education. It was published in association with U.S. News & World Report.
But the report itself deserves an F.
To begin with, there are professional associations that rate the nation’s education schools, based on site visits and clear criteria.
NCTQ is not a professional association. It did not make site visits. It made its harsh judgments by reviewing course syllabi and catalogs. The criteria that it rated as most important was the institution’s fidelity to the 

Hillsborough County: A Culture of Fear

Many years ago, the U.S. Supreme Court decided that students have First Amendment rights.
In 1969, in a decision called Tinker V. Des Moines Community School District, the High Court voted 7-2 that the school could not prevent students from wearing black armbands to protest the war in Vietnam.
Hillsborough County, Florida, never heard of that decision. At the high school graduation ceremonies, theprincipal of a high school cut off the salutatorian mid-speech and withheld his diploma. This was not a response to anything he said, but apparently retaliation against him for posting a YouTube video criticizing the condition of the boys’ bathrooms. Even the local media noticed.
Teachers responded by saying that they too had experienced the same top-down, heavy-handed approach. “All across the country, teachers are afraid to speak up. No where is that more true than in Hillsborough county, the

How Pennsylvania Betrayed Its Schools

This commentary was written by a retired superintendent of schools.
Pennsylvania’s Tragic Betrayal of its Public Schools
By Joseph Batory, Former Superintendent of Schools, Upper Darby School District, Drexel Hill, PA
With regard to the inadequate funding of Philadelphia Public Schools, the city’s politicians have been and continue to lacking in political courage and moral fiber. Far too many of them are much too self-serving and most of them do not even understand what the fiscal insanity that continues to cripple the schools and the children of their city.
Likewise, the recent array of superintendents has each been far too meek and without the commitment to confront the system’s financial deficiencies.
But the worst villain of all has been the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. In the early 1990’s, Pennsylvania government consciously destroyed its Equalized Subsidy for Basic Education (ESBE) formula. That method of 

Michael Weston: Teacher Evaluation Will Not Change the BIG Problem

Michal Weston, a teacher in Hillsborough County, Florida (at least for now), is running for the local school board. Regular readers know that he was recently fired by his principal for speaking out too much. Since Hillsborough County was one of the few that received a big Gates grant, it is heretical to question the idea that teacher evaluation is the very biggest problem in the world and that the right model will make all students proficient and college bound. Weston displays his heretical views here:
He writes:
Don’t get me wrong – teaching can and should be practiced and improved. My point is that teachers are not the 

What Is the Role of Profit in School Reform?

Ken Previti, a retired teacher, has been watching the evolution of school “reform,” and he wonders when the public will catch on to the schemes and fear-mongering. What is it all about? Sell-sell-sell.
Just doing what business does. Monetizing the children.

NY Commissioner King Will Speak at Gulen Charter Graduation

New York State Commissioner of Education will speak at the graduation ceremonies of a charter school in Syracuse affiliated with the Gulen network. King himself came out of the charter sector, so his favoritism towards charters is not surprising.
The Gulen network is the largest charter chain in the nation. It is allied with a reclusive Turkish imam who lives in 

Major Rally in Harrisburg, Pa., on June 25

A new groups called GPS (Great Public Schools) Pittsburgh plans a major rally at the state Capitol in Harrisburg to demand adequate funding for public education across the Keystone State. The state funds low-performing cyber charters and expands the number of privately managed schools that perform no better than public schools. Meanwhile the lights are going out in public schools across the state, especially in urban districts. Will Pennsylvanians unite to save public education. Come to Harrisburg on June 25 for the beginning of the movement to stop privatization in the Keystone State.

Diane in the Evening 6-17-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

mike simpson at Big Education Ape - 3 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Jan Resseger on Absurdity of Ohio VAM by dianerav This just in from an advocate for children who live in poverty: This week the Cleveland Plain Dealer has a new series, “Grading the Teachers.” It is basically an endorsement of the new Ohio Value Added Measures (VAM) program by which teachers will be rated. Scores are being made available on-line. Ohio’s VAM formula, according to the news account, does not consider the socioeconomic information about the children. Here are the articles thus far in the series: ·... more »

Teacher Preparation Program Rankings Make U.S. News Debut

Teacher Preparation Program Rankings Make U.S. News Debut:

Teacher Preparation Program Rankings Make U.S. News Debut

Kate Walsh wants to bust up the teacher preparation market.

That's why on Tuesday her group, the National Center for Teaching Quality, is releasing its first ranking of teacher preparation programs on the U.S. News & World Report website. The nearly across-the-board extremely low scores pull back the curtain on "an industry of mediocrity," according to a report released in conjunction with the rankings.

"The field of teacher preparation has rejected any notion that its role is to train the next generation of teachers," the authors write. "Any training regimen in classroom management or reading instruction runs the risk, the field worries, of new teachers pulling from a fixed bag of tricks rather than considering each class as something new and unique."

NCTQ's uses a four-star rating system based on training programs' curricula, syllabi and admissions standards. Less than 10 percent of the programs rated earn three stars or more. Only four programs, Liscomb, Vanderbilt, 

UPDATE Daily Kos: Help Advocate for Children in Virginia!

Daily Kos: Help Advocate for Children in Virginia!:

Success!! At least temporarily!

There are only two things my beloved Leaves on the Current has regularly enjoyed drinking while on chemotherapy.
Unsweetened iced black tea lemonade with extra lemonade from Starbucks -  which they now offer in a size larger than Venti.
Canada Dry Bitter Lemon -  which first our local Harris Teeter stopped carrying, which then we found at a Wegman's about 40 miles away, but which they sadly informed us their distributor could no longer provide.
But today we got a reprieve.  Leaves went on Amazon, found some, and ordered it.
Just now 23 bottles were delivered.  That should last for more than a month.  It is a reprieve.
Today, the first day off on the two weeks on and one week off chemo, is always one of the rougher days of the 3-week cycle, as is tomorrow.
Right now Leaves is beaming, even as we wait for news from the neurosurgeon.
She is happy.
That makes me happy.


Help Advocate for Children in Virginia!

Today marks the kickoff of a statewide campaign by Strong Kids, Strong Virginia, which is an effort by Every Child Matters Virginia, the state effort of the Every Child Matters Education Fund.
This is a 501(c)(3) effort, which is non-partisan.  We are communicating to elected officials of both parties.
Perhaps these statistics from the website will help you understand why:
There are 1,847,182 children under 18 in Virginia• Children Living in Poverty (2009) - 253,000
• Mother-only Households (2008) - 406,002
• Children Not Covered by Health Insurance at Any Time (2008) - 167,000
• Share of Medicaid-enrolled children not getting dental care (2007) - 59%
• Additional Children Covered by Expansion of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program - 79,500
• Total number of child abuse and neglect reports (2009) - 59,995
• Child Abuse Victims (2009) - 5,951
• Child Abuse Deaths (2001-2009) - 259
• 3-4 Year Olds Not Enrolled in a nursery school, pre-school, or pre-kindergarten education program (2009) - 122,000
• % of 4th Graders Scoring below Basic Reading Levels (2009) - 26%
• Home Foreclosures (2008-2009) - 101,138
• Kids Count Overall Rank (2009) – 16
Keep those statistics in mind as I offer a few thoughts below the squiggle.

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Riding Lessons

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Riding Lessons:

Riding Lessons

Eh? What's that, sonny...?

Funny thing happened in first day of summer session. My students went around the table and introduced themselves and said the usual about what they do; where they teach; goals and passions. One student says, "I give writing lessons out in Oswego."  My interest is perked. I ask, at what school do you teach writing? Student responds: "No not writing -- RIDING LESSONS."  She's taking a few needed ed courses to become a certified riding instructor.

Lots of friends and colleagues gathered at the Ayers/Dohrn home yesterday to give a nice send off to Kevin Kumashiro who is leaving Chicago to become Dean of the Ed School at San Francisco State. Our loss is definitely S.F.'s gain.

Kevin is currently professor of Asian American Studies and Education at  UIC. where he was formerly Chair of Educational Policy Studies, Interim Co-Director of the Institute for Research on Race and Public Policy, and Coordinator of Asian American Studies. On the national level, he is the president (2012-2014) of the National Association for Multicultural Education (NAME). Here in Chicago, he is a foundin