Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Diane in the Evening 5-8-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:







Will the Children of Buena Vista Go Without an Education?

The public schools of Buena Vista are closed. The teachers offered to work for free, but they were rebuffed. Some have filed for unemployment. The children are out of school, and no one knows when school will open again. Or if it will.
Joy Resnovits is following this story on Huffington Post.
Buena Vista is a town that got left behind when the American auto industry collapsed.


Michigan in a Nutshell

A comment on the blog about the state of public education in Michigan:
I am a retired high school English teacher in Michigan. After I retired I served 8 years on our board of education. I retired in 2000 and have a son, daughter and daughter-in-law in the teaching profession.
What has happened in Michigan since I retired is appalling. Our teachers are being demoralized, our school aid fund has been raided to give tax breaks to big business, tenure is gone, and evaluations are being based on test scores. Benefits have been reduced for teachers and right to work is in play.
Our legislators believe the EAA which has taken over some schools in Detroit should be expanded when it hasn’t

Selling Out Black Children in Michigan

In the previous post, I noted that the emergency manager in Detroit was instructed to “blow up” the district.
In the other districts controlled by emergency managers–Muskegon Heights and Highland Park–the emergency managers closed down public education and handed the buildings and students over to for-profit operators.
This article in Education Week brings out important facts.
1. “African-Americans make up 88 percent of the students in the Muskegon Heights system, and 98 percent of

Detroit: The Most Sickening Story of the Day

Detroit’s Emergency Manager Roy Roberts announced he was stepping down. But then he said something utterly astonishing. He said that when he took the job, his instructions were to “blow up” the district.
He didn’t say who told him to destroy the district.
Interesting that all of the districts in Michigan that have emergency managers are predominantly African 

8th Grade Student: Why So Much Advertising on Pearson Tests?

A student in a gifted program wrote this piercing analysis of the state tests he and his classmates just endured.
The tests he took had many brand names and registered trademarks. He realized this is product placement.
He wrote:
“Non-fictional passages in the test I took included an article about robots, where the brands IBM™, Lego®, FIFA® and Mindstorms™ popped up, each explained with a footnote. I cannot speak for all test takers, but I 

A Teacher Responds to Obama Proclamation On National Charter School Week

Earlier I posted President Obama’s proclamation on National Charter School Week, which happens to coincide with Teacher Appreciation Week.
A charter school teacher responded with this comment:
“I’ve been an educator in Columbus, Ohio since university. In my 8th year, I currently earn 34,000 before taxes at a 9-12 charter school. I can be fired at any time. I have no tenure, no union, and scarce resources to teach. I 

MI District Broke, Teachers Offer to Work for Free, But Then…

In little Buena Vista, Michigan, the schools have been decimated by budget cuts and declining enrollments. Faced with the threat of bankruptcy, the teachers offered to work for free. The district laid them all off and is closing the schools.
Who says that Americans don’t care about education? Maybe Governor Snyder will send in an emergency manager to give the children to a for-profit charter chain that will rehire the teachers and cut their pay and benefits.
The schools close officially on Tuesday, which is Teacher Appreciation Day.

MI District Broke, Teachers Offer to Work for Free, But Then…

In little Buena Vista, Michigan, the schools have been decimated by budget cuts and declining enrollments. Faced with the threat of bankruptcy, the teachers offered to work for free. The district laid them all off and is closing the schools.
Who says that Americans don’t care about education? Maybe Governor Snyder will send in an emergency manager to give the children to a for-profit charter chain that will rehire the teachers and cut their pay and 

Brian Ford: Why Pressure and Greed Are Not Good

Brian Ford, teacher and author, writes in a comment, responding to John Merrow’s investigative reporting:
It was John Merrow’s interview with Michelle Rhee, when she was still in charge of DCPS, that first raised my hackles. She said, “Pressure is good.” It was a bit like two decades ago, when Gordon Gekko declared, ‘Greed is good.’ In both cases the statement is presented as the hard, unvarnished truth that people are unwilling to accept because they are too politely unrealistic. That the declaration of the goodness of pressure and greed also serves the interest of the speaker is left unsaid.
That was the goal of Michelle Rhee and the others:
Creating A System Of Pressure –
–a system of pressure that would have people teaching children doubt themselves and blame themselves for 

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 5-8-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

mike simpson at Big Education Ape - 2 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: [image: Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch] Texas: The Surefire Plan to Destroy Public Education by dianerav You think it can’t happen here? You think your state is immune? Read about the war on public education in Texas and think again. Some part of this radical agenda is being promoted in almost every state. Yours too. This comment was written by Bonnie Lesley of “Texas Kids Can’t Wait”: “I worry a lot whether public schools will continue to exist in some states. Our organization, Texas Kids Cant John ... more »

#Edchat: Why & How | My Island View

#Edchat: Why & How | My Island View:


#Edchat: Why & How

Each Sunday afternoon there are five Topic questions posted on a poll to determine which will be selected as that week’s #Edchat Topic. There are two #Edchat discussions each Tuesday on Twitter, so the top two topics selected by the poll become the topics of the chats. The number two choice goes at noon, Eastern Time, and the number one selection goes at 7 PM, Eastern Time. The larger audience is the 7 PM Chat. If you did not know it before, I am the person responsible for making up the #Edchat Topic questions that are voted on each week. I admit that I do have favorites each week, but, more often than not, they are not the favorites of the voting public. This week it was a little different. I actually had two favorites, and fortunately for me, they were the chosen topics for the chats. I found both yesterday’s #Edchat discussions thought-provoking, and very much in need of public discussion. The topics were very much connected as well.
#Edchat is very much an open, public discussion by educators from around the world. Ideas on each topic are presented from various points of view as we discuss the varied topics in education each week. As in any public discussion, a person may pick and choose those ideas that suit his/her needs and in this case, educational philosophy. Sometimes it is a new idea, and other times it is validation of what is already being done. Since it is a discussion using Twitter as the platform, most of the participants are educators who are somewhat familiar with technology and social media. As a generalization they tend to be a collaborative group, more progressive in 

Insights on the Faces of Poverty — Whole Child Education

Insights on the Faces of Poverty — Whole Child Education:


Klea Scharberg

Insights on the Faces of Poverty

The Faces of Poverty - ASCD Educational Leadership
With so many families facing hardship now, today's "poor kids" don't fit old stereotypes. And taking such actions as they can to make learning and life better for students facing poverty is now a challenge for all teachers. The May 2013 issue of ASCD's Educational Leadership araises awareness of the impact of poverty on children today and what might be done to help close the achievement gap.
In her "Perspectives" column, Editor-in-Chief Marge Scherer asks whether poverty is predestined. She writes, "The question is whether, in the future, we will be forced to say, 'Poverty should not be destiny, but, unfortunately, statistics say it is.'" After reading her column, do you agree?
Articles in the issue include
View the insights of these and other contributors to the issue in the infographic (PDF) below, and start a conversation with your professional learning community using the free study guide.

FCMAT » Cali Education Headlines Wednesday, May 8, 2013

FCMAT » Fiscal Crisis & Management Assistance Team:





Education Headlines

Wednesday, May 8, 2013

School district politicking criticized

The San Diego Unified School District is bound by law to stop using its website to promote political positions, the county grand jury said in a report on Tuesday.

TEMECULA: School district proceeds with teacher layoffs

The Temecula Valley Unified School board authorized the layoff of more than 40 teachers at its meeting Tuesday, May 7. But board members and district administrators said they are hopeful many of the teachers will be brought back as positions open up through attrition.

Monterey Peninsula USD's interim superintendent to stay on next year

Interim Monterey Peninsula Unified School District interim superintendent Leslie Codianne will remain as the district's top administrator through the 2013-14 school year.

San Rafael voters support schools, approve Measures A and B

San Rafael voters showed strong support for local public schools Tuesday, renewing 24-year-old parcel taxes that will help fund San Rafael elementary and high school districts.

Pomona Unified administrator propose turning Yorba Elementary into charter school

Pomona Unified School District administrators presented a proposal to the district's Board of Education Tuesday night calling for converting Yorba Elementary School into a charter school with an emphasis on science and technology.

Fresno Unified administrator Steve Martinez takes Sacramento-area job

A Sacramento-area school district picked Steve Martinez, an assistant superintendent at Fresno Unified School District, as its next superintendent. The Twin Rivers Unified school board voted Monday to approve the hire, pending contract negotiations, at a special board meeting in Fresno, according to district officials contacted by The Sacramento Bee.

Mt. Diablo trustees finalize agreement with interim general counsel

The Mt. Diablo school board approved an agreement with its new interim general counsel Jayne Williams Monday night but made no announcement related to the search for a superintendent.

School district knew of alleged teacher abuse 3 years before arrest

Los Angeles school district officials knew of sexual misconduct allegations in 2009 against a teacher at a Wilmington campus who was arrested more than three years later, the district's top administrator confirmed Tuesday.

Many charter schools to begin offering transitional kindergarten in fall 2013

After a year's delay, many charter schools will begin offering transitional kindergarten classes in the fall.

Alisal teachers in 'shock' over contract plan

Representatives of the Alisal Teachers Association and district negotiators met Friday. The district presented a counterproposal to the initial plan laid out by the union earlier this year. ATA leaders said they were stunned by the counterproposal, which includes elimination of retirement benefits for ATA members.
Tuesday, May 7, 2013

Peer groups coming to two campuses

Once the programs take effect at the schools in the coming weeks, students rather than adults will be making disciplinary decisions regarding peers who have committed offenses such as repeatedly cursing in class, being defiant toward teachers or tagging school property.

Celebrities join S.F. schools' meditation

The event at Burton High School celebrated the sixth year of the district's Quiet Time program, which uses transcendental meditation techniques to help students focus and stay calm despite the stresses of school or home.

La Costa Canyon students fight for journalism course

The staff of La Costa Canyon High School's newspaper is questioning the motives behind the principal's decision to cut its journalism class as it tries to keep the course alive.
Monday, May 6, 2013

Growing pains hit Panama-Buena Vista district

The Panama-Buena Vista Union School District is redrawing its attendance boundary lines to accommodate growth in the southwest.

Suspensions drop sharply in Stockton USD

The use of suspensions as a form of discipline is under scrutiny in the state Assembly, and Stockton Unified changed some of its conduct codes in 2011, taking suspensions off the table in many nonviolent situations where a student shows "defiance" to staff.

Schools lose $$

Tuolumne and Calaveras county schools lost out this spring on more than $1 million in funding for after-school programs.

UPDATE: Downton Billy + Is the School “Reform” Drought Breaking? – @ THE CHALK FACE knows SCHOOLS MATTER

Is the School “Reform” Drought Breaking? – @ THE CHALK FACE knows SCHOOLS MATTER:



Sweet 16: What Matters v. What Should Matter in Teacher Qualities

My colleague and social studies educator, George Lipscomb, is offering a May Experience course addressing “What Makes a Great Teacher.” He started the course today with a Sweet 16 of teacher values so I thought this idea may be a great way to ask people to confront priorities regarding what our current high-stakes test-based accountability [...]


Downton Billy


Carver High Community Stands Against School Closure

Corporate ed reformers in Memphis are planning to close a dozen schools in order to backfill the current 57-million dollar hole created by the planned opening of more corporate charter schools.  Citizens, however, have a different view on the matter.  Join the fight in Memphis to improve community schools, rather than shutting them down to [...]

Is the School “Reform” Drought Breaking?

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Closing Duncan's Chicago 'Renaissance' Schools

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Closing Duncan's Chicago 'Renaissance' Schools:


Closing Duncan's Chicago 'Renaissance' Schools

Obama came to Dodge school in 2009 and used the visit to announce Duncan's appointment as Sec. of Education
While Arne Duncan was whisking in the children of the rich and powerful into Chicago's elite, selective-enrollment schools, he was also pushing a system of new start-ups and charters under his Renaissance 2010 program.


But, according to WBEZ's Becky Vevea,  in the most recent round of proposed school closings, CPS is shutting down the very schools Duncan created.
Eleven years ago, on April 10, 2002, Duncan announced he would shut down three elementary 

UPDATE: Seattle Schools Community Forum: To the Members of the Executive Committee

Seattle Schools Community Forum: To the Members of the Executive Committee:


Charter Commission - Second Meeting, Part Two

Charter Commission discussion 

The biggest bone of contention at this point is the lottery system for approved charter school applications.

Now my initial read (and others as well) was that if the Board of Education received more than 8 approved charter applications from all authorizers, then they would go into a straight lottery.

The Attorney General's reading is that the seven that get to the BOE's office first will be stamped and approved.  (The BOE has NO role in authorization - they just need to document when applications come into their office.)  The BOE will, however, decide what the word "simultaneous" means. 

Any approved applications that come in eighth (and it's still unclear how big a window there will be - maybe just a 


When Will School Calendar 2013-2014 Be Out?

Found this out at the Executive Committee meeting - intro and action at the May 15th meeting.

Yes, I know this is late.  Yes, I know other districts get this done way earlier.

There is to be a press release between SEA/SPS sometime in the next couple of days.

Tentative highlights:

- school starts on September 4th, ends on June 18th
- full week Mid-Winter Break is back (I was confused during the discussion about why but I will endeavor to get a 


To the Members of the Executive Committee

This is an e-mail I sent to the members of the Executive Committee this morning:

I note that on your agenda this morning for the Ex Ctm is your Board calendar for next year.

I have repeatedly asked about sponsorship of Board retreats since the Alliance was allowed to plan them for this entire school year.  That is NOT part of the Alliance's MOU with the district and appears to look like undue influence from an outside entity.  To avoid that appearance, the Board could do the following:

- the Alliance ends its sponsorship of Board retreats

- the Alliance can handle logistics but nothing else.  They certainly can weigh in on the agenda for any given retreat as is the right of any other group or individual.  They should NOT be setting the agenda nor directing the facilitator.

- the Alliance should NOT have be part of any discussion during the retreats.  No one else is allowed this 

Smith-Blum Withdraws Her Nomination to Board of Education

The candidates for an interim seat on the Washington State Board of Education has narrowed by one.

President Smith-Blum who applied (and was interviewed) has withdrawn her application, saying that she did not want to leave SPS in the middle of the year.

Critical boundary discussions, construction contracts for over $500 million, restorative discipline policies, the Green Resolution – all of these things have been key issues in my tenure and I hope to see them all through to 

Why it is hard to monitor bullying at schools — report

Why it is hard to monitor bullying at schools — report:


Why it is hard to monitor bullying at schools — report

Prevention of Bullying CoverA new report that reviewed years of research says that it is hard to accurately monitor levels of bullying in schools because there is still no consensus on exactly what it is and that educators and scholars “should not limit themselves to the traditional definition” as they seek ways to combat it.
The report, called “Prevention of Bullying in Schools, Colleges and Universities” and just released by the American Educational Research Association at its 2013 meeting in San Francisco, is the work of a blue-ribbon task force that was charged with finding short- and long-term recommendations for institutions to address bullying of young people.
The report is divided into briefs which look at research on specific areas, including:
*Looking Beyond the Traditional Definition of Bullying
*Bullying as a Pervasive Problem
*Bullying and Peer Victimization Among Vulnerable Populations
*Gender-Related Bullying and Harassment: A Growing Trend
*Legal Rights Related to Bullying and Discriminatory Harassment

What teachers really want | Lily's Blackboard

What teachers really want | Lily's Blackboard:


What teachers REALLY want

"Other People's Children": The Corollary of Bad Policy | California Progress Report

"Other People's Children": The Corollary of Bad Policy | California Progress Report:


"Other People's Children": The Corollary of Bad Policy

By Mark Naison
For some time, I have argued that School Reform is the most destructive bi-partisan initiative we have suffered in the United States since the Vietnam War, a policy which has, and will continue to inspire mass movements to limit the damage it inflicts through universal testing of the nation's children, and the humiliation and micro-management of the nation's teachers.
Some have argued, correctly, that people have not lost their lives as a result of School Reform even when schools are closed, teachers are fired, communities destabilized, instruction has been reduced to test prep, and young people's minds have been reduced to mush by relentless testing. That is certainly true. But one thing does seem similar. Both produced PTSD.
read more


The Hollowing Out of Government

Robert ReichBy Robert Reich
The West Texas chemical and fertilizer plant where at least 15 were killed and more than 200 injured a few weeks ago hadn't been fully inspected by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration since 1985. (A partial inspection in 2011 had resulted in $5,250 in fines.)
OSHA and its state partners have a total of 2,200 inspectors charged with ensuring the safety of more than 8 million workplaces employing 130 million workers. That comes to about one inspector for every 59,000 American workers.
There's no way it can do its job with so few resources, but OSHA has been systematically hollowed out for the years under Republican administrations and congresses that have despised the agency since its inception.
read more