Latest News and Comment from Education

Saturday, February 2, 2013

MORNING UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 2-2-13 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch





Should Select Schools Be Compared to Non-Select Schools?

A New Orleans research group says comparing select and non-select schools is wrong.
Yet boosters of select charters do it often.


A Billionaire Obsessed by Union-Phobia

What do you say about a billionaire in Idaho who sees unions as the biggest threat to the American way of life?
As most people know, the number of people who belong to unions has declined dramatically in recent decades. As manufacturing jobs were outsourced to low-wage non-union countries, private sector unions shrank. Today, the majority of American workers are hourly workers with little or no job security and no pension.
And yet, here is a man who poured $1 million into a campaign to support Idaho’s so-called Luna laws (for rightwing state superintendent Tom Luna), which would have crushed the unions, which are already weak, initiated bonus pay, and made it easy to fire teachers at any time for any reason.
The good news is that voters across Idaho repealed the Luna laws, while voting Republican for state offices and 

More on Oregon Charter Scandal

An earlier post reported that officials in Oregon are trying to recover $20 million from two Oregon charter founders. A reader in Oregon added the following information:
In 2010, AllPrep academies, Oregon’s home-grown charter founded by educational entrepreneur Tim King (a former North Clackamas School District teacher) began having financial problems. A decade previously, King founded three charter schools in that district: New Urban High, Clackamas Middle College and Clackamas Web Academy. In 2008, he left to start the AllPrep and other charter schools in a half-dozen small districts across 

Pennsylvania Rejects 8 New Cyber Charters

The Pennsylvania Secretary of Education rejected eight applications for new cyber charters.
The state already has 16 cyber charters, with 32,000 students, all drawing from the entire state. The 12 cyber charters that have been around long enough to be rated all failed to make adequate yearly progress.
The eight that were rejected hoped to enroll another 10,000 students, wgphich would have cost the state $350 

Beware! Education Reformers Are Coming for Your School Board

Jonathan Pelto wrote this guest post. A former state legislator, he blogs about politics and education in Connecticut at “Wait, What?” –which can be found at jonathanpelto.com. I think the title of his blog refers to the fact that what is happening these days is often unbelievable.
During the 2012 election cycle, we saw the corporate “education reform” lobby begin to play their hand when it 

How Testing in Virginia Harms Students with Disabilities–And Their Teachers

In response to a post about the New York State tests, a teacher in Virginia sent this comment:
As a VA public school teacher, let me assure you that the VA state tests are as bad as the NY State tests. I did my undergraduate degree in NY. It was very hard for my university to find me a second special education 

Louisiana’s Unbelievable State Board of Education

The state board of education in Louisiana, the Board f Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) is beyond parody.
Just when you think they have hit bottom, they come up with another outrageous idea.
BESE Is now talking about abolishing certification for teachers. They want to go back to the good old days when 

Mercedes Schneider: Who Is NCTQ? Part 4

Mercedes Schneider, a teacher in Louisiana who holds a Ph.D. in statistics and research methods, has been analyzing the board membership of the National Council of Teacher Quality. NCTQ is working with U.S. News & World Report to grade every teacher education program in the nation. Dr. Schneider wanted to see the 

Diane in the Evening 2-1-13 Diane Ravitch's blog

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 2 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog: Why Schools Can’t Do It Alone by dianerav Paul Thomas is one of our most eloquent critics of the idea that schools alone can overcome poverty. In this essay, he explains why. The money quote comes from Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.: “In addition to the absence of coordination and sufficiency, the programs [addressing poverty] of the past all have another common failing — they are indirect. Each seeks to solve poverty by first solving something else. *“*I am now convinced that the simplest approach will prove to be the most effective — the solution to poverty ... more »

The Inconvenient Truth Of Education “Reform” - Jeff Bryant

The Inconvenient Truth Of Education “Reform” - Jeff Bryant:


The Inconvenient Truth Of Education “Reform”

Parent trigger: Can parent takeovers improve schools? | Get Schooled

Parent trigger: Can parent takeovers improve schools? | Get Schooled:


Parent trigger: Can parent takeovers improve schools?

Are parents the solution to failing schools?
That’s the theory behind parent trigger laws, which allow a majority of parents in a failing school to petition and win control of the school and impose their own reform blueprint. Originating in California in 2010, the laws allow parents to take over a systematically failing school if they collect signatures from the majority of families.
But do the trigger laws really fire blanks?
A increasing criticism of parent trigger laws is that, while they involve parents at the start in organizing the petition drives to pull the trigger, the most realistic outcome is the hiring of an outside management firm to run the reconstituted school.
In fact, the possible ascendancy of for-profit education management companies contributed to the defeat of a parent trigger bill in Florida last year because parent groups argued that the law would lead to corporate interests exploiting the schools.
The Georgia General Assembly is now considering the …

DIARY OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHER!: If You're Happy and You Know It...! Happy Students = Happy Teachers!

DIARY OF A PUBLIC SCHOOL TEACHER!: If You're Happy and You Know It...! Happy Students = Happy Teachers!:


If You're Happy and You Know It...! Happy Students = Happy Teachers!

Sacramento parents plea for district not to close school | Sacramento News - KCRA Home

Sacramento parents plea for district not to close school | Sacramento News - KCRA Home:


Sacramento parents plea for district not to close school

11 elementary schools on proposed list for closure



School closure meeting
(Jan. 30, 2013)
Richard Sharp/KCRA


SACRAMENTO, Calif. (KCRA) —More than 100 concerned parents, teachers and students packed into the cafeteria at Tahoe Elementary School in Sacramento’s Tahoe Park neighborhood Wednesday night to hear why the Sacramento City Unified School District wants to close the facility and 10 others.

“Why they sending kids way across town to another elementary school, when they got one right here in this neighborhood?” said Raymond Thompson, the parent of a student at the school.

District officials said the school has been under-enrolled for two decades, and is currently doesn’t have enough students.

“Why are (we) closing schools?” asked Jonathon Raymond, the superintendent of the district. “Because schools like Tahoe are only 40 percent full right now. We have schools from 30 percent to 45 percent enrolled.”

If all 11 schools are closed, the district estimates savings of $2.6 million a year.

Much of the savings will come from lay-offs.

“We have a principal that runs the school, office staff, custodians and plant managers, and utility costs -- those are

Read more: http://www.kcra.com/news/local-news/news-sacramento/Sacramento-parents-plea-for-district-not-to-close-school/-/12969376/18350076/-/ksy2qr/-/index.html#ixzz2JkyVsA00





UPDATE: The inconvenient truth of education ‘reform’ + Is 2013 the tipping point for high-stakes testing obsession?

Is 2013 the tipping point for high-stakes testing obsession?:


The inconvenient truth of education ‘reform’

convenientSeveral important things happened in the education world in the last week. Here’s an analysis of why what happened matters, by Jeff Bryant, a marketing and communications consultant for nonprofits. He is a marketing and creative strategist with nearly 30 years of experience – the past 20 on his own – as a freelance writer, consultant, and search engine marketing provider. He’s written extensively about public education policy. This appeared on the Campaign for America’s Future website.
By Jeff Bryant
Events this week revealed how market-driven education policies, deceivingly labeled as “reform,” are revealing their truly destructive effects on the streets and in the corridors of government.
From the streets, we heard from civil rights and social justice activists from urban communities that school turnaround policies mandated by the Obama administrati



Is 2013 the tipping point for high-stakes testing obsession?


teset1For the last year a revolt against high-stakes standardized testing has been growing around the country, with teachers, principals, superintendents, parents and students speaking out about the negative impact on education of this obsession. Here, educator and author Sam Chaltain (@samchaltain) looks at where 2013 will take us in this movement. Chaltain began his career as an English teacher in New York City. Now he writes about the intersection of education and democracy at www.samchaltain.com. Previously, he was national director of the Forum for Education & Democracy, an 

Ignoring Moms in the Room, Bush Foundation Blames Unions for Watchdog Report | Scathing Purple Musings

Ignoring Moms in the Room, Bush Foundation Blames Unions for Watchdog Report | Scathing Purple Musings:


Ignoring Moms in the Room, Bush Foundation Blames Unions for Watchdog Report

In response to last week’s release of In the Public Interests report based on emails obtained through an FOIA request, Jeb Bush’s Foundation for Excellence in Education didn’t shoot the messenger. They too aim at a union strawman who wasn’t there. Mary Ellen Klas has the foundation’s statement in the Tampa Bay Times:
Jaryn Emhof, spokeswoman for the foundation sent the Herald/Times the following response:
“It certainly is not surprising that In the Public Interest, a union-backed organization, opposes school choice and the expansion of digital education.
“And, it is hardly a secret that the Foundation for Excellence in Education (Excel in Ed) is committed to school choice and openly offers its expertise to legislators and policy makers 

Best of the Ed Blogs | National Education Policy Center

Best of the Ed Blogs | National Education Policy Center:





Best of the Ed Blogs

Teachers are experts | Outside the Cave

Teachers are experts | Outside the Cave:


Teachers are experts

Arthur Goldstein absolutely nails it:
I’m more than a little upset that I, along with tens of thousands of my colleagues, have been deemed unfit to grade tests. It strikes me as unfair stereotyping and just another example of the distrust some people in power feel towards teachers.
But here’s the thing: if I can’t be trusted to design tests and I further can’t be trusted to grade them, I ought not to be teaching. If the state feels that we teachers are so incompetent and 

All Things Education: What's All About Students All About Anyway?

All Things Education: What's All About Students All About Anyway?:


What's All About Students All About Anyway?



I have been meaning and meaning to write about the Virginia Governor's 2013 education agenda, Part I and Part II, and so I will (belatedly) and unlike my response last year, it will be brief (mercifully).

First of all, as it's sprinkled liberally throughout his agenda, it seems that the Governor hasn't received the memo on the term "achievement gap." Even TFA got that memo and has responded with a good ol' liberal arts-style deconstruction (not that I would ever in my wildest dreams imagine that a Virginia GOP political leader would be caught dead reading such a thing).

And speaking of TFA. . .

1. Teach for America Act (HB 2084):

You probably already know what I think. I have written about TFA before. It's my most popular piece.

The only thing new I have to say is why does Virginia need TFA? There are budget and teaching positions being cut across the state and I hear it's hard for our college graduates to get teaching positions. Where is the evidence that there's a teacher shortage anywhere in Virginia? And if there is one, why don't we have a Teach for 

Failed DC Chancellor Michelle Rhee Gets an Education - NYTimes.com

Failed DC Chancellor Michelle Rhee Gets an Education - NYTimes.com:


Failed DC Chancellor Michelle Rhee Gets an Education




 In your new book, “Radical,” you recount that while growing up in a Korean-American household in Toledo, if your brother brought home a bad grade, your mother would ground you, not him. Can you explain her thinking? 
My mother is a very traditional Korean mom. I grew up with clear roles as the girl of the family, and one of them was being responsible for my brothers and specifically to make sure my younger brother was doing well in school. Korean culture is very lenient on boys.