Thursday, September 20, 2012

Notes on My Atlantic Profile of David Coleman - Dana Goldstein

Notes on My Atlantic Profile of David Coleman - Dana Goldstein:


Notes on My Atlantic Profile of David Coleman

Today The Atlantic published my profile of David Coleman, the MicKinsey consultant turned education entrepreneur who is one of the school reform movement's most idealistic believers in the power of the traditional liberals arts as a social justice tool. Coleman is important because his ideas about what students should know (from modernist poetry to Euclid's "Elements") and do (more evidence-based, thesis-driven writing, and less personal narrative) are profoundly reshaping American education. Forty-eight states and territories have agreed to adopt the Common Core curriculum standards, which Coleman and his team helped construct. Now, as the incoming president of the College Board, Coleman hopes to rewrite the SAT to make it more of a test of the actual high school curriculum, moving it further away from the fiction that it measures some sort of innate "aptitude."
Coleman is also a delightful guy with whom I really enjoyed spending time. It isn't your usual cab ride when you 

UPDATE: The in box. State Rep. Dan Biss’ forum on state pensions tonight. « Fred Klonsky

The in box. State Rep. Dan Biss’ forum on state pensions tonight. « Fred Klonsky:


The in box. Chest beating? I’m a regular Tarzan.


Fred,
Highest salaries, shortest school days, and shortest school year + ridiculously embarrassing graduation rates makes for some awfully entitled chest beating.
- Kevin
Kevin,
Chest beating? You bet.
When it comes to public schools and public school teachers, I’m a regular Tarzan. Ahooooo!


The Hipster Alderman claimed Karen Lewis was keeping teachers on strike against their will.

First Ward Alderman, aka The Hipster Alderman, Proco Joe Moreno claimed on his website that CTU President Karen Lewis was forcing the teachers to stay on strike while they looked at the settlement framework prior to the House of Delegate vote on Tuesday.
“Enough is enough, Proco said. “I urge the leadership to stop grandstanding and start letting our talented teachers do what the do best…teach.”
It hard for a Chicago alderman to wrap their heads around the idea of democracy. Taking time to read a contrac


The in box. State Rep. Dan Biss’ forum on state pensions tonight.

North suburban Democratic State Representative Dan Biss is holding a community forum on state pensions tonight.
Frankly, Biss is no friend of state employees on this matter. But he has invited Ralph Martire, Executive Director of the Center for Tax and Budget Accountability. Martire calls for revenue enhancement and restructuring pension debt as the means of resolving pension issues.
Biss has also invited Laurence Msall, President of the Civic Federation.  Msall and the Civic Committee think you can solve the $100 billion pension crisis by cutting benefits.
Tell Biss what you think.
Greetings!I wanted to send a quick email to remind you about our third 

Ten minute drawing. The hipster alderman, Poco Moreno.

“Won’t Back Down” fuels education reform wars - The Education Report - Katy Murphy's blog on Oakland schools

“Won’t Back Down” fuels education reform wars - The Education Report - Katy Murphy's blog on Oakland schools:


“Won’t Back Down” fuels education reform wars

By Katy Murphy
Wednesday, September 19th, 2012 at 10:31 pm in Uncategorized.
Liz SullivanLiz Sullivan is an OUSD grandparent, a former teacher and a community organizer. The views expressed in this article are her own.
“Won’t Back Down” will be released in theaters on September 28, but the new film is already stirring up controversy. Produced by the team who brought us “Waiting for Superman,” the movie stars Maggie Gyllanhaal and Viola Davis as two moms who use a “parent trigger” law to turn around a failing school. Michelle Rhee screened the movie at the Democratic and Republican Conventions, and Randi Weingarten, President of the American Federation of Teachers, attacked the film in a press release, saying: “…the movie resorts to falsehoods and anti-union stereotypes.” The film is the latest dust up in the school reform wars. One side blames teachers’ unions for blocking change, and the other side characterizes school reform as a corporate privatization scheme.
The movie’s story line should feel familiar to local folks. Oakland’s parents and teachers have created scores of new schools over the last decade. Yet school reform Oakland-style does not fit easily into the overheated narratives competing on the national stage. The rhetoric of school reform resorts to gross oversimplifications that play well to a crowd. The reality of school reform involves real people navigating a marvelously complex world.
I have seen Oakland parents and teachers come together to start new schools 

Assessment Webinar by Forum on Educational Accountability

About FEA:


FEA PUBLIC EVENTS
Transforming ESEA: Helping Public Schools ImproveTransforming ESEA is a series of public discussions sponsored by the Forum on Educational Accountability. Forthcoming forums includeTransforming ESEA to Meet the Needs of all Learners, addressing needs of English language learners and students with disabilities; and on how the federal government can help schools, districts and states build their capacity to serve all students well.
_________________________________________________ 
CURRENT EVENT:
High Quality Assessment for Instruction and Accountability
An FEA Webinar

High-quality assessment is an essential part of teaching and learning and provides valuable information about school quality and progress. This webinar will present two methods for gathering detailed information – the Learning Record, and performance assessments developed by the New York Performance Standards Consortium. These provide rich feedback to students and teachers, summarize student progress, and in aggregate provide valid and reliable information for public reporting and accountability. We will also discuss how these proven approaches to assessment can inform state and federal policy. The more comprehensive information they provide is more useful than relying heavily on standardized tests. The webinar will begin with three short presentations, followed by questions and discussion.
Who:   Ann Cook, Executive Director, New York Performance Standards Consortium     
            Sally Thomas, former director, Center for Language in Learning/Learning Record
            Monty Neill, Executive Director, Fairtest; Chair, Forum on Educational Accountability
            Moderator: Tom Zembar, Senior Policy Analyst, NEA
When: September 27, 2012, 3:30 – 4:30 Eastern time
To participate: Before 3:30 Eastern time, go tohttps://www.livemeeting.com/cc/nea1/join?id=P7GMW8&role=attend&pw=feaEPP310%24. The slides will come up automatically on your screen. For audio, follow the phone instructions. If you have any problems, see more detailed instructions on the following page or at [fea site page with more detailed instructions]; first time users should read this information.
Presenters:
            Ann Cook directs the Consortium, a coalition of New York State public high schools that have designed a highly successful performance-based assessment system that is practitioner-designed, student focused and externally assessed. She is founding co-director of Urban Academy Laboratory High School in NYC. Seehttp://www.performanceassessment.org.
            Sally Thomas  is a long time teacher, teacher educator, and researcher; user of the Learning Record in grades 2-3, 5-6, HS English, and in teacher education programs; LR coach and Co-Director of the Center for Language in Learning which supported the LR nationally. See http://www.fairtest.org/learning-record.
            Monty Neill, Ed.D., has led FairTest’s work on testing in the public schools for more than 25 years. FairTest advances quality education and equal opportunity by promoting fair, open, valid and educationally beneficial evaluations of students, teachers and schools. Seehttp://www.fairtest.org.
The Forum on Educational Accountability bases its work on the Joint Organizational Statement on NCLB, signed by more than 150 national education, civil rights, religious, disability, parent and civic organizations. FEA has offered proposals for overhauling NCLB/ESEA. Its work on assessment includes the report, Assessment and Accountability for Improving Schools and Learning. Seehttp://www.edaccountability.org.

FEA Assessment Webinar - ATTENDEE LOGIN INFORMATION

FEA and Karen Johnson (NEA) have invited you to attend an online meeting using Live Meeting. Click this link toJoin the meeting<https://www.livemeeting.com/cc/nea1/join?id=P7GMW8&role=attend&pw=feaEPP310%24>.
The slide show will come up automatically. For audio, follow the instructions below (which also will appear on the Live Meeting screen). Please check in before the webinar starts at 3:30 Eastern time, Sept. 27, allowing enough time to link to audio.  
Audio Information 
Telephone conferencing
Choose one of the following:
  • Start Live Meeting client, and then in Voice & Video pane under Join Audio options, click Call Me. The conferencing service will call you at the number you specify. (Recommended)
  • Use the information below to connect:
    Toll-free: +1 (866) 642-1665
    Toll: +1 (719) 387-8317
    Participant code: 494957
First Time Users: 
To save time before the meeting, check your system <http://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=90703> to make sure it is ready to use Microsoft Office Live Meeting.

Troubleshooting
Unable to join the meeting? Follow these steps:
If you still cannot enter the meeting, contact support 
Notice 
Microsoft Office Live Meeting can be used to record meetings. By participating in this meeting, you agree that your communications may be monitored or recorded at any time during the meeting.

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Roberts Rules of Order and TFA

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Roberts Rules of Order and TFA:


Roberts Rules of Order and TFA

I just listened to the KUOW report (not yet available) on the vote of the TFA member to teach Special Ed at Franklin High.  What a mess and yet, interesting.  Here's what I understand happened.

They had six members in attendance (I believe Director Smith-Blum was missing).

Apparently the vote was 3 yeses (Martin-Morris, DeBell and Carr) and 3 abstained votes.  So the Board Manager said it did not pass.

DeBell corrected her and said abstaining votes don't count, they have a quorum and the majority of the quorum said yes.

THEN, Ron English, district counsel stepped up and said he wasn't sure.

Now, as a former PTA president who is supposed to know Robert's Rules of Order (but I don't know them well), I 

Morning UPDATE: LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 9-20-12 Diane Ravitch's blog

Diane Ravitch's blog:

Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch

A Postmortem on the Strike

We will see many discussions of what the strike accomplished, who won, who lost. This one takes a balancedview and sees the strike as a lesson about working with teachers and de-emphasizing test scores.
As another reader pointed out, it is interesting that the anti-union forces usually keep hands off police and firefighters, the male-dominated unions, but go after teaching, nursing and social work. Wonder why?


What the Strike Taught Teachers

Kipp Dawson, a teacher in Pittsburgh, reflects on the lessons of the Chicago strike for teachers everywhere:

This strike, and the democratic and solidarity-packed way the CTU led it, has transformed ALL teachers EVERYWHERE from powerless to having now a sense of how to become powerful. Eyes on what our children need, involvement in the communities in which they live to support their struggles and have the communities see us as part of what they are struggling for, democratic functioning which aims to have ALL members feel and become leaders, clear messages (“The Schools Chicago’s Children Deserve” and a great Facebook campaign), and people “at the top” who are not looking for personal glory but who truly truly represent their membership. WE CAN DO THIS!!!

This Is the Candidate We Want

A reader sent this, commenting on post that asked whether the President would oppose Wisconsin’s Act 10:
Submitted on 2012/09/18 at 1:02 pm
“Don’t label a school as failing one day and then throw your hands up and walk away from it the next. Don’t tell us that the only way to teach a child is to spend too much of a year preparing him to fill out a few bubbles in a standardized test…You didn’t devote your lives to testing. You devoted it to teaching, and teaching is what you should be allowed to do.” — Candidate Barack Obama, Summer 2007

Parent Review of “Won’t Back Down”

A New York City parent went to a screening of the new movie “Won’t Back Down,” which promotes the parent trigger idea. Various privatization advocates are pushing parent trigger laws that enable parents to “seize control” of their public school and hand it over to private corporations.
The parent stayed afterward for a panel discussion involving Leonie Haimson, leader of the pro-public school group Class Size Matters (I am one of her board members), and two others who are not public school parents.
Here is the report:
From: nyceducationnews@yahoogroups.com [mailto:nyceducationnews@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of 

The Real Story Behind “Won’t Back Down”

The Center for Media and Democracy keeps a careful watch on the activities of ALEC, the ultra-conservative organization of state legislators. One of ALEC’s model law is a “parent trigger” bill.
The new film “Won’t Back Down” pulls together the threads of corporate backing for the privatization of public education.
Read about it here.


Kevin Lee Is Still Worried

During the strike, I printed a letter from Kevin Lee, a teacher in Chicago, to explain why he was striking. The letter was read by thousands and reprinted widely. The editors of the Guardian, a publication in London, read Kevin’s post and asked for his email address. He wrote this wonderful article for them about the strike and about conditions in the Chicago schools.

A Personal Note from Karen Lewis

Karen Lewis stood up to the national media. She stood up to the mayor. She could do it because she knew she had the support of 98% of the teachers in the Chicago Teachers Union. The CTU had a strategy to build parent and community support. And that support meant more than the screeching from the editorial boards of the newspapers and the commentators on FOX and CNN.
I told Karen how much the readers of this blog admire what CTU did and what she did. Here is her response, which she said I could share with you:
I do not understand why people think what we did was special. I do not understand why people think I’m a leader. 

A Great Story about the Strike

Harold Meyerson wrote a great story about the strike in the Washington Post. Please read it.
The mainstream media, the pundits and the editorial writers were so hostile to the strike that it is refreshing to read someone who really understands what happened in Chicago. Meyerson sees the strike not just as a job action, but as a strike against the national faux-reform movement, which demands incessant testing and pushes privatization.
He gets it.
And as you would expect, someone writes in response and says the teachers are not the union, the union is not the teachers. Oh, please. Who were the 98% of teachers who voted to authorize the strike? Who was it that 

How Cyber Charters Make Big Profits

No surprise here. The biggest of the for-profit virtual school corporations, K12, has as many as 275 students to one teacher, according to this report in Florida.
This is what is described by promoters of the “Ten Elements” of digital learning as personalized, customized learning for the 21st century. Others might call it a profitable scam.
Remember P.T. Barnum said that there is a sucker born every minute. Someone else said that no one ever went


No, You Are Not Paranoid

A reader from Maine writes:
I think you’re right to feel paranoid–Sometimes they really are out to get you!
One thing that is starting to get some notice, but is still too far below the radar, is that while the state’s pile on more and more restrictive and demanding requirements for public schools, simultaneously they are pushing for reducing or eliminating those requirements for charters and virtual charters. As the Portland Press Herald noted 

Some People Never Learn

Here is an article written by a Texas businessman and former legislator complaining that young people in Texas are woefully underprepared for college or the workplace.
The answer: more testing and accountability.
He fails to note that Texas has been pushing that testing and accountability thing for at least 20 years. Remember Ross Perot? Remember the Texas miracle? The whole country is stuck with NCLB because of all the 


A Teacher Explains How to Fix the Schools

Bruce Adams, a veteran teacher and artist in Buffalo, explains how to fix the schools in nine not-so-easy steps.
His recipe does not involve firing teachers or closing schools. It does not rely on standardized testing. It takes time.
Wall Street hedge fund managers, Eli Broad, and the Gates Foundation won’t like his plan, because he warns 


Jeb Bush: There Should Be No Public Sector Unions

Jonathan Pelto reports on Jeb Bush’s recent visit to Connecticut. While there, he saluted the “reforms” pushed through the legislature by Governor Dannell Malloy, especially his efforts to curb teachers’ tenure and seniority. And he boasted about Florida’s achievement (he didn’t mention the class size reduction initiative, which voters approved and he tried to roll back). And choice, choice, choice!
Funny that no one mentioned that Connecticut is one of the top two or three states in the nation on NAEP, even though it has strong teachers’ unions, seniority and tenure. It is far ahead of Florida. Since when does a state 



Still No Miracle in New Orleans

We have felt the full court press of the faux reform movement for more than a decade. Chicago has been burdened with it for nearly 20 years, New York City for 11 years, Washington, D.C., for five years.
The one city that reformers love to cite as their victory is New Orleans. Hurricane Katrina, in their narrative, was a blessing in disguise (and Arne Duncan said it was the best thing ever to happen to education in New Orleans).
New Orleans now has more of its students in charters (about 80%) than any other city, so it is the paradigm of the reform movement, the model for all other cities, which–if reform continues to advance–will one day have no


Who Looks Down on Teachers?

This is an excellent piece reblogged by Valerie Strauss.
The author Corey Robin asks the reasonable question, why do so many well-educated, seemingly liberal people look askance at unions.


New State Tests=”Total Garbage”=Opt Out

This Ed school Professor, Tom Slekar, is not silent. He blogs, makes satirical videos, has a radio program (The Chalkface). He even ran for school board in his town in Pennsylvania. And he is leading the fight against high-stakes testing.
Slekar has called on his colleagues to join him on the barricades.
Read this post for more information about Tim.
Slekar writes:
Parents get ready for new tests this schoo



The Inside Story of Great Hearts Charter in Nashville

We have been following the unfolding saga of the Metro Nashville school board’s refusal to approve a charter for the Great Hearts charter school in Arizona. The school board voted four times to deny the charter. The state board and the education commissioner Kevin Huffman ordered the Metro Nashville school board to approve the charter but it refused. The state is punishing Nashville by withholding $3.4 million from the district. So far, what we know about this affair is what we have read in the local Nashville newspapers. But here is an insider’s report


How Chicago’s Children Were Educated by the Strike

This reader commented about how the strike enhanced her grandchild’s education:
The strike taught my grandchild and so many more children like her that people should stand up for what they believe in; to thoroughly read any document you sign; to join with people who have the same causes because many things can’t be done alone and that democracy is messy and hard to achieve, but worth it in the end. Not 





Salman Rushdie Said: Don’t Be Afraid

The novelist Salman Rushdie lived under a death threat for many years after the Iranian leader Ayatollah Khomeini ordered his death in 1989. He was interviewed by the New York Times.
Something he said struck a chord:
Q. What advice do you have for someone who might find himself under a similar threat?
A. Two bits of advice, really. One has to do with the head and the other is practical. The thing in the head is: 

The Education Upstarts - Rachael Brown - The Atlantic

The Education Upstarts - Rachael Brown - The Atlantic:


The Education Upstarts

Education policy has long featured two players—the government and teachers unions. But in recent years, a new generation of activists has stepped up to lobby legislators and drive the conversation. A rundown of worthy upstarts.
Share0

By RACHAEL BROWN

Graphics by Kiss Me I'm Polish
Stand for Children
Who: Co-founder and CEO Jonah Edelman is the son of the civil-rights leader Marian Wright Edelman.
What: The most grassroots of these groups. Leads efforts to lobby state governments for reforms such as value-added teacher evaluations and more-equitable school funding.
Democrats for Education Reform
Who: Bankers, CEOs, and other wealthy Democrats. Adviser Cory Booker lends liberal star power.
What: Offers political cover to Democratic politicians who alienate teachers unions by supporting education reforms such as mayoral control of schools and national curriculum standards. Has helped loosen the unions’ grip on the party.
Students First
Who: Founded by Michelle Rhee in 2010 after she stepped down as schools chancellor in D.C.
What: Uses its 1 million–strong e-mail list to lobby for data-based teacher evaluations and against seniority-based teacher layoffs. Rhee garners lots of attention, but her group has yet to establish itself as a major player on



Just Like Michelle Rhee's Students first only BETTER


Astroturf lobbying refers to political organizations or campaigns that appear to be made up of grassroots activists but are actually organized and run by corporate interests seeking to further their own agendas. Such groups are often typified by innocent-sounding names that have been chosen specifically to disguise the group's true backers

Just Like Michelle Rhee's
 Students first Astroturf lobbying (only Better) 
Other Astroturf lobbying groups


Just Like Michelle Rhee's
 Students first Astroturf lobbying (only Better)