Latest News and Comment from Education

Thursday, October 3, 2019

Metaphors for School Change | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Metaphors for School Change | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Metaphors for School Change

For a quarter-century, I have taught graduate students, teachers, principals, superintendents, and school board members about the complexity of the word “change.”
The embrace of planned change (one can substitute “reform,” “progress” or “improvement”) as an unvarnished good, particularly in public schools, is understandable in the U.S. The idea of change in of itself is highly valued in the culture and daily life (e.g., fashions, music. and automobiles get re-worked annually. Reinventing one’s self is common. Moving from one place to another is a national habit. Standing in line overnight to buy the most recent technology is unremarkable. Change is equated with moving forward to material or spiritual success (or both). Opposition to whatever planned change is proposed in a family, workplace, school, or community is often clothed in negative labels such as “resistance” or “supporting the status quo.”
Moreover, most Americans do not distinguish between different kinds of planned change such as incremental (or first-order) and fundamental (or second-order). The latter term is also called “transformational” or “radical”. Surface and deep changes do differ (see here, and here).
scale-of-change-l.jpg
While getting most adults to grasp the concept of change as being highly prized CONTINUE READING:Metaphors for School Change | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice