Latest News and Comment from Education

Sunday, October 6, 2019

CATCH UP WITH CURMUDGUCATION

CURMUDGUCATION

CATCH UP WITH CURMUDGUCATION



The Next Big Problem With School Shooter Preparedness

We think we're seeing the worst side effects of our national preoccupation with school shooters. We aren't. The problems with active shooter drills have already been widely documented. In the best of circumstances, active shooter drills are disturbing, even if they are focused just on the adults in the building. I've been through a drill with shooters using blanks; it's rough . But we've ben seein

OCT 04

A Teacher's Final Lesson

If you live in western Pennsylvania, you may already know the story of Ashley Kuzma. If you don't, I'd like to share it with you. Kuzma was born in Beaver County, PA, and graduated from Freedom Area High School in 2005. She attended Pitt where she earned a Bachelor's in History and Poli Sci, and Edinboro University, where she earned a Master's in Education and a teaching certificate. She worked as

OCT 03

Bad Administrator Field Guide

Is there a lousier job in the world than that of a school administrator. For the past twenty years, it has been all of the responsibility and none of the power. Yet a building principal (and to some extent a superintendent) have enormous control over a teacher's workplace-- how miserable is it, how safe is it, and how hard is it for teachers to do the job they signed up to do? Administrators come

OCT 02

What Is The Real Promise Of School Choice

AEI hosted a pep rally for the DeVos $5 million scholarship tax credi t, and afterwards, Rick Hess put up the latest entry in AEI's 60 second that "reminds" us of the "real promise" of charters and choice: Thank you to @BetsyDeVosED , @KellyannePolls , and state decision makers for a great conversation about Education Freedom Scholarships today! In any discussion about school choice, it's importan

SEP 30

Are School Vouchers A Path To Religious Freedom?

Let me make a confession-- I am not at all unsympathetic to many Libertarian beliefs. I am wary of government involvement in many arenas, and the bigger the government, the warier I am. Additionally, I know some Libertarians personally, and they are perfectly nice human beings. But when you start turning general Libby philosophical notions into specific policies, particularly in areas where my exe

SEP 29

ICYMI: Show Weekend Edition (9/29)

Last weekend was a family wedding in State College, so I did not get this weekly digest done. This weekend I open the local production of The Music Man that I'm directing, so things are a little busy at this house. But I'm still collecting a few good reads for you to read (if you haven't already). Remember to share. Litigating Algorithms Beyond Education Audrey Amrein-Beardsley went to a conferenc

SEP 28

A Good Teacher Is Not Like A Candle

I just hate this kind of thing. First of all, is there any other profession that has to put up with this. Substitute "lawyer" or "plumber" or even "doctor" for "teacher" in this meme, and it just sounds dumb. "Nurse," maybe. (Hmm. What do nursing and teaching have in common as professions. Could it be that they're not commonly associated with testosterone?) We don't expect any professionals to con

SEP 27

Stanford: Opportunity And Testing Baloney

Look, it's not that I want everyone to stop any discussion of Big Standardized Test scores at all forever (okay, I might, but I recognize that I'm a radical in this issue and I also recognize that reasonable people may disagree with me). But what I really want everyone to stop pretending that the BS Test scores are an acceptable proxy for other factors. But here comes a new "data tool" from Stanfo

SEP 26

RAND Plays Corporate Reformy Buzzword Bingo

RAND Corporation, with its vision to be "the world's most trusted source for policy ideas and analysis." regularly contributes to the total thinky tank output of material that wants to be viewed as "a report" or "research" or "a study" or "a paper," but is more like an op-ed or blog post that has put on a tie and juiced up its vocabulary. This week they cranked out a new one entitled " Reimagining

SEP 25



NH: Failing To Learn From Charter History

I have a soft spot in my heart for New Hampshire. I was born there, and much of my family lived there. My grandmother was a legislator for ages, and many of my relatives are still in the state. So it's a bummer to see the state fall into 

Seattle Schools Community Forum: WA State Charter Schools to Benefit from DeVos Largess

Seattle Schools Community Forum: WA State Charter Schools to Benefit from DeVos Largess

WA State Charter Schools to Benefit from DeVos Largess

The Seattle Times has a story about how Washington State charter schools are eligible to apply for dollars from a $20M grant that the Washington State Charter School Association will receive from the Department of Education.  To note, Betsy DeVos has been instrumental in sending out many more federal dollars to help shore up the starting-to-lean-like-the tower-in-Pisa charter school business.  Washington state was just one of five states to receive a grant.

Although they receive state funding for each child who attends, they do not benefit from local tax levies, which pay for school districts’ building and construction costs. Charters have to raise money for these and other upfront costs by fundraising, turning to philanthropists and seeking grants.”
The original charter law would have allowed access to local school levy dollars and luckily, that got changed. I’m glad for a couple of reasons. 
Districts have to pay for these elections and there was no wording in the law that charters would have to contribute. Why in the world would they get the benefit of school levy dollars without helping to pay for levies AND going out to help pass them?

Also, the Gates Foundation has a non-profit group just for charter schools and their capital needs. I’m surprised the Times didn’t admit this fact into the story. Of course, the Foundation has its favorites so only those that Gates wants to see succeed get those dollars.

To note, Seattle charter schools can now access levy funds from the City’s CONTINUE READING: 
Seattle Schools Community Forum: WA State Charter Schools to Benefit from DeVos Largess




New Orleans: A Charter School Finds Out That Making Bold Promises is Not Enough | Diane Ravitch's blog

New Orleans: A Charter School Finds Out That Making Bold Promises is Not Enough | Diane Ravitch's blog

New Orleans: A Charter School Finds Out That Making Bold Promises is Not Enough

This article in The Nation by Casey Parks tells the story of Sci Academy in New Orleans and the lessons it learned over time about making bold promises.
The school pledged that all its students would go to college and encouraged them to apply to four-year colleges that were outside their comfort zone (not close by and predominantly white).
In 2012, almost all of its graduates were accepted to colleges. By 2019, only 18% had graduated from college.
Parks describes what happened to some of Sci’s top students.
Only months after starting college, some students dropped out.
Most couldn’t point to just one reason for their decision. Some missed their families or needed to find jobs to pay for gaps remaining after their scholarships. Students who enrolled in a North Louisiana university found that the food was too bland. No other place in America is like New Orleans—not even North Louisiana—and it hurt too much to lose the city again after they’d been displaced by the hurricane. Others grew unfocused after they left Sci’s CONTINUE READING: New Orleans: A Charter School Finds Out That Making Bold Promises is Not Enough | Diane Ravitch's blog

Indiana was the 2nd state to pass an emergency manager law and 2nd state to realize it doesn't solve their problems | Eclectablog

Indiana was the 2nd state to pass an emergency manager law and 2nd state to realize it doesn't solve their problems | Eclectablog

Indiana was the 2nd state to pass an emergency manager law and 2nd state to realize it doesn’t solve their problems

Back in 2012, Indiana became the second state after Michigan to pass an emergency manager law that allows the state to take control from locally, democratically elected leaders and put it into the hands of an appointed bureaucrat. The law covers any “distressed political subdivision” which, like in Michigan, includes municipalities or school districts. Furthermore, Indiana’s Emergency Managers have the power to, among other things:
  • Review existing labor contracts
  • Renegotiate existing labor contracts and act as an agent of the political subdivision in collective bargaining.
  • Reduce or suspend salaries of the political subdivision’s employees.
  • Enter into agreements with other political subdivisions for the provision of services.
Fast forward to today and, just like in Michigan, Indiana is finding that trying to fix systemic and intractable problems by cutting and gutting doesn’t actually work:
Indiana State Board of Education (ISBOE) member Tony Walker says he is frustrated with the lack of progress in the Gary Community School Corporation since the takeover by the state two years ago.
On July 31, 2017, the State of Indiana hired MGT Consulting to provide emergency CONTINUE READING: Indiana was the 2nd state to pass an emergency manager law and 2nd state to realize it doesn't solve their problems | Eclectablog


Education Insider for October 6, 2019 - Education Votes

Education Insider for October 6, 2019 - Education Votes

Education Insider for October 6, 2019

Don’t steal from military families to fund border wall

The congressional recess is an opportunity to meet with representatives and let them know what you think of President Trump’s scheme to divert money from kids from military families to building the wall Mexico was supposed to pay for. At the president’s direction, the Department of Defense is shifting $3.6 billion from projects approved by Congress to wall construction—a maneuver that will rob schools and childcare facilities on military bases of nearly half a billion dollars. Those projects include refurbishing a severely overcrowded middle school at Fort Campbell, Ky., and remediating hazardous mold at the Child Development Center at the Joint Base Andrews in Maryland. Schools for military families in Puerto Rico, Italy, Okinawa, and Germany are also affected. Military families shouldn’t have to sacrifice their children’s education to fund Trump’s wall, an issue NEA board members raised when they lobbied on Capitol Hill last week. Only Congress—after hearing from you!—can halt the effort to rob military kids of the support they deserve. Tell your representatives to speak out and oppose this travesty. TAKE ACTION

H.R. 4540 begins to fix problems caused by Social Security’s WEP

Nearly 2 million retired educators and other public employees would benefit from fixes to Social Security’s Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) made by the Public Servants Protection and Fairness Act (H.R. 4540), introduced by House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Richard Neal (D-MA) on Sept. 27. Among those subject to the WEP, current retirees would get an extra $150 a month and future retireesan average of $75 a month. Moreover, the bill includes a guarantee that no one would get less than the amount provided under current law. The WEP reduces the Social Security benefits of people who work in jobs covered by Social Security and jobs NOT covered by Social Security over the course of their careers—for example, educators compelled to take part-time or summer jobs to make ends meet. After years of congressional inaction, this bill is a step in the right direction. NEA continues to push for full repeal of the WEP and the Government Pension Offset (GPO) that reduces the Social Security spousal or survivor benefits of people not covered by Social Security themselves. Tell your representative to support H.R. 4540. TAKE ACTION

Senate committee chairman’s higher education bill graded “incomplete”

The Student Aid Improvement Act (S. 2557), introduced Sept. 26 by HELP Committee Chairman Lamar Alexander (R-TN), falls short of NEA’s goals for reauthorization of the Higher Education Act (HEA) that governs student-aid programs, federal aid to colleges, oversight of teacher preparation programs, and more. “Despite tackling a few areas where reform is needed, the bill is a far cry from the comprehensive reauthorization needed to provide all students with an opportunity to obtain an affordable and equitable higher education,” said NEA President Lily Eskelsen García. Key areas that S. 2557 fails to address include loan forgiveness for public service, many student aid programs, teacher preparation, and the 90/10 rule that caps the percentage of revenue for-profit schools can receive from federal financial aid sources—all areas it is essential to address in a reauthorization that reflects the perspective of students and educators. The House version of HEA reauthorization will be released soon. In the meantime, weigh in with senators on what to include in the next HEA. TAKE ACTION

Cheers and Jeers

Rep. Andy Biggs (R-AZ) introduced the Native American Education Opportunity Act (H.R. 4586) to create a voucher program for tribal students. The bill would rob the public schools attended by the vast majority of students of funding and resources.
Education Insider for October 6, 2019 - Education Votes

AFT PRESIDENT RANDI WEINGARTEN CELEBRATES WORLD TEACHERS DAY | Black Star News

AFT PRESIDENT RANDI WEINGARTEN CELEBRATES WORLD TEACHERS DAY | Black Star News

AFT PRESIDENT RANDI WEINGARTEN CELEBRATES WORLD TEACHERS DAY


[Education\World Teachers Day]

AFT President Randi Weingarten: “Educators around the world do so much more than instruct students: They serve as counselors, nurses and caretakers for children facing increasingly complex challenges in an often overwhelming world...Today, on World Teachers’ Day, we honor educators—our change agents—who have chosen one of the most stressful occupations, but who also enable a future to those who do not have access to opportunity otherwise."

American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten issued the following statement in recognition of World Teachers’ Day:

“Educators around the world do so much more than instruct students: They serve as counselors, nurses and caretakers for children facing increasingly complex challenges in an often overwhelming world. A teacher can offer comfort and safety in a time of distress, open a child’s eyes and help them discover new passions, and help them understand and navigate the world with confidence.

“Here in the United States, educators are the defenders of decency and the guardians of our democracy, serving on the frontlines of ensuring our Constitution and rule of law remains intact. Both here and abroad, teachers have become the first responders to everything—addressing students’ social and emotional needs in a world that is deeply challenged.

“Today, on World Teachers’ Day, we honor educators—our change agents—who have chosen one of the most stressful occupations, but who also enable a future to those who do not have access to opportunity otherwise. We encourage our young teachers to press on, and are grateful for CONTINUE READING: AFT PRESIDENT RANDI WEINGARTEN CELEBRATES WORLD TEACHERS DAY | Black Star News


Sacramento schools facing safety questions as district reveals $27 million budget shortfall | abc10.com

Sacramento schools facing safety questions as district reveals $27 million budget shortfall | abc10.com

Sacramento schools facing safety questions as district reveals $27 million budget shortfall
An all out melee was caught on camera at Kennedy High School. It comes at a time when the Sacramento City Unified School District reduced school resource officers.



SACRAMENTO, Calif. — An all out melee was caught on camera at Kennedy High School, prompting safety concerns during a time in which the Sacramento City Unified School District decided to reduce the number of police officers on campus.
District spokesperson Alex Barrios, said there have been as many as 12 fights already this year at Kennedy, but insists the increase in campus fights does not stem from the low number of school resource officers in the district.

"There's no evidence to show a school resource officer being on campus stopped fights because we had just as many fights last year," Barrios said. "They were just as big, and they were on video."
Talking specifically about Kennedy, Barrios said, "We know that there are fights on campus. What we need to do is make sure we are preventing those fights from happening."
In an email to school parents, Kennedy HS principal David Van Natten announced plans to stagger the lunch schedule and bring in additional staff to supervise students in an effort to cut down on fighting.
So, what is going on when it comes to school security? Some blame the district's decision to reduce school resource officers from eight to four. Despite having $1.4 million dollars set aside for school safety, ABC10 was told three of those four school resource officers have not been hired.
"We are going through a process to get the contracts finalized for that," Barrios said. "They'll be approved CONTINUE READING: Sacramento schools facing safety questions as district reveals $27 million budget shortfall | abc10.com


Bill Phillis: New Study Shows That Students Learn No Less in Poor Urban Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog

Bill Phillis: New Study Shows That Students Learn No Less in Poor Urban Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog

Bill Phillis: New Study Shows That Students Learn No Less in Poor Urban Schools


Bill Phillis, founder of the Ohio Coalition for Equity and Adequacy of School Funding, reports on a new study that undercuts the rationale for state takeovers.
He writes:
Research study: Students learn no less in poor, urban schools than other schools
OSU Professor of Sociology, Dr. Douglas Downey, lead author of a recent study , found that students in urban districts with high concentrations of disadvantaged students learn as much during the school year as those in wealthier districts. Disadvantaged students, of course, start school at a lower level of development, but according to the research study, disadvantaged students don’t lose ground while in school.
This research (and common sense) helps dispel the myth that districts serving high concentrations of disadvantaged students are “failing” just because of low test scores.
This study should inform state officials who are bent on state takeover of school districts (HB 70.) Because a school district has low test scores is not justification for state takeover. (Besides Ohio’s takeover of Youngstown and Lorain have not improved the districts.)
If state officials want the state to takeover some school districts, all districts should be in the pool of candidates for takeover, not just those that serve high concentrations of disadvantaged students.
Ditch HB 70. Just do it.
 The Distribution of School Quality: Do Schools Serving Mostly White and High-SES Children Produce the Most Learning?
First Published August 23, 2019 Research Article https://doi.org/10.1177/0038040719870683
Abstract
What is schools’ role in the stratification system? One view is that schools are an CONTINUE READING: Bill Phillis: New Study Shows That Students Learn No Less in Poor Urban Schools | Diane Ravitch's blog

Nevada ‘Abolishes’ Their Achievement School District | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

Nevada ‘Abolishes’ Their Achievement School District | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

Nevada ‘Abolishes’ Their Achievement School District

The ‘portfolio’ model of education reform was pioneered in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina and the creation of the Recovery School District (RSD) in 2005.  Then Tennessee, fueled by Race To The Top money, brought in TFA alum and Michelle Rhee ex-husband Kevin Huffman who hired TFA alum and YES prep founder Chris Barbic to create a similar thing called the Achievement School District (ASD) in 2012.
Even though the Tennessee has been a complete failure by every metric possible (unless you count Huffman and Barbic getting high paying consultant jobs after resigning in shame as one of your metrics), other states around the country have followed their ‘lead’ and proposed or created ASDs of their own.  There was one created in Michigan, North Carolina, and Nevada and others proposed in Georgia and Pennsylvania.
Not surprisingly, the ASDs have all been utter failures.  And since it is hard to keep such failure a secret, states are starting to wake up to this fraud.  So it is somewhat good news that another ASD has bitten the dust, this time in Nevada.
On June 3, 2019 Nevada passed SB321 abolishing their ASD.  The official description is that it is “An act relating to education; abolishing the achievement school district; requiring an existing achievement charter school to convert to a charter school under the sponsorship of the State Public Charter School Authority or cease operations; and providing other matters properly relating thereto.”  So even though their ASD is officially ‘abolished,’ it is not like those schools are converted back to public schools.  Instead they CONTINUE READING: Nevada ‘Abolishes’ Their Achievement School District | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

CURMUDGUCATION: The Next Big Problem With School Shooter Preparedness

CURMUDGUCATION: The Next Big Problem With School Shooter Preparedness

The Next Big Problem With School Shooter Preparedness



We think we're seeing the worst side effects of our national preoccupation with school shooters.

We aren't.

The problems with active shooter drills have already been widely documented. In the best of circumstances, active shooter drills are disturbing, even if they are focused just on the adults in the building. I've been through a drill with shooters using blanks; it's rough. But we've ben seeing stories about drills that went wildly over the top-- execution-style shootings with pellet guns, and drills that are treated as an actual real event.


The trauma experienced by children is widespread and severe. Stories on facebook and twitter and in the supermarket abound. Children who are worried about sneezing or afraid that if they can't learn to stifle tears, they might give their position away to the shooter. The NEA felt the need to create a guide for helping students cope, while a steady stream of articles catalog the fears such drills awaken and the reasons active shooter drills should be stopped.

But from Florida comes news that hints at the next level of trouble sparked by drills and news coverage and the business of building fear into our children:

A ten-year-old girl is facing charges after she brought a steak knife to her elementary school in Florida, according to authorities.

According to the Monroe County Sheriff's Office, the girl said she brought the knife to Stanley CONTINUE READING: 
CURMUDGUCATION: The Next Big Problem With School Shooter Preparedness




Mike Klonsky's Blog: Looking for something better to come from vitriolic contract talks

Mike Klonsky's Blog: Looking for something better to come from vitriolic contract talks

Looking for something better to come from vitriolic contract talks

Striking CTU members gather over two days to study the 2012 contract offer before voting to end the strike. 
The contract talks between CPS and the CTU are going pretty much the way I expected and just the way I feared. In some ways, they are a continuation of the contentious and divisive campaign tactics that marked the mayor's race between Lori Lightfoot and Toni Preckwinkle.

Lightfoot’s victory — winning every single ward — was a blow to CTU’s power and perceptions about its influence. And the union has been struggling to get some of its mojo back ever since. CTU’s dilemma is that it’s trying to wage a war with a mayor who’s not Rahm Emanuel — an enemy CTU knew how to fight. -- Illinois Playbook
The CTU and SEIU Local 73, cornerstones of the progressive movement here in Chicago, both backed Preckwinkle who was soundly defeated by the current mayor. Both candidates ran as "progressives" but in the end, Lightfoot and a group of insurgent city council candidates rode an anti-machine wave to victory.

But as I predicted at the time,


With election day only a few weeks away, and Lightfoot apparently pulling far ahead, internecine warfare has broken out among the progressives to such a CONTINUE READING: Mike Klonsky's Blog: Looking for something better to come from vitriolic contract talks