Tuesday, February 9, 2016

solidaridad: Gülen cult’s corporate charter chain’s Magnolia Science Academy

solidaridad: Gülen cult’s corporate charter chain’s Magnolia Science Academy:

Gülen cult’s corporate charter chain’s Magnolia Science Academy





Gülen cult’s corporate charter chain’s Magnolia Science Academy

Gülenist CEO Caprice Young claims that the privately managed Magnolia Science Academy Reseda (MSA) is a “high performing” charter school. Do the facts bear out her marketing claim?

College Entrance Exams

In 2014 students from the Gülen associated school taking the California State University (CSU) entrance exam demonstrated abject remediation rates (Source: CSU).
  • 63% of MSA students NOT proficient in English
  • 38% of MSA students NOT proficient in English

Scholastic Achievement Test (SAT)

The Gülen charter school’s SAT scores are unimpressive, but do explain why so many of their students don’t test proficient (Source:LATimes).
  • 1271 Composite Average for 2011-2012
  • 1321 Composite Average for 2010-2011
  • 1455 Composite Average for 2009-2010
For context 1500 is considered the minimum threshold for college readiness, while 2052 was the composite average for Freshmen accepted into UCLA in 2013.

California Standards Tests (STAR)

The last three years MSA students took the STAR, saw the school achieving sub-par English proficiency, and abysmal math proficiency (Source: LATimes).
  • 2013 English / math proficiency 53.6% / 41.6%
  • 2012 English / math proficiency 58.8% / 46.4%
  • 2011 English / math proficiency 51.7% / 39.6%

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Editorial Boards Weigh in on Recent Republican Legislative Action

Seattle Schools Community Forum: Editorial Boards Weigh in on Recent Republican Legislative Action:

Editorial Boards Weigh in on Recent Republican Legislative Action

Basically, the editorials seem to be asking "what are YOU doing to solve problems besides criticizing others?" (bold mine)
From the Daily Herald:


Peterson was dismissed without being given an opportunity to defend her record, nor was she given the chance to resign or withdraw her nomination.

The high-profile dismissal could reflect poorly on the stability of the state's transportation department and its projects, including the $16 billion package that Peterson help the Legislature assemble last year. The state is preparing to seek bonds to cover the first projects in that package, and the turmoil could be seen as a problem by investment firms and could result in higher interest costs for the state.

Including the departure of Kevin Quigley, secretary of the Department of Social and Health Services, itself in the process of reforms, the state's three largest agencies will be left with interim chiefs for months. Finding permanent replacements may have to wait until after the November election.
 Even then the ranks of qualified applicants may be thinned by a reluctance to deal with the current turmoil here.

Sen. Michael Baumgartner, R-Spokane, made clear his intentions in a tweet after Peterson's firing:

“Note to other Inslee Appointees: Shape up, Do your job. Serve the people w/accountability. Or more heads are going to roll.”

Recall that the state Senate's current plans would give itself two more years to fix funding of basic education for K-12 schools and end the reliance on local school levies. And remember the $100,000-a-day fine the state Supreme Court levied against the Legislature last year because it has failed to come up with an adequate plan.

That's good advice, senator.
It is always amusing when elected officials want to lambast others' work without realizing that a laser gaze can always be turned back the other way. 

From The Olympian:


The education-funding bar was set pretty low for the Washington Legislature this year. So low there was a danger that lawmakers might trip over it. That appears to be happening.
Zing!

In retrospect it was naïve to expect much. But going into the short, Seattle Schools Community Forum: Editorial Boards Weigh in on Recent Republican Legislative Action:

Dora Taylor: Washington's Charter School Fight—Let's Set the Record Straight | The Progressive

Washington's Charter School Fight—Let's Set the Record Straight | The Progressive:

Washington's Charter School Fight—Let's Set the Record Straight

Washington State has been ground zero in the fight over charter schools this past year, and misinformation abounds.
Over the last several years Bill Gates and the Waltons of Walmart poured millions of dollars into Washington to establish charter schools in the state.
Last fall the Washington State Supreme Court decided that those charter schools are unconstitutional, due to a lack of public oversight while using taxpayer dollars. The same organizations backed by Bill Gates including the League of Education Voters (LEV), Stand for Children (SFC) and the Washington State Charter Schools Association along with Democrats for Education Reform (DFER) founded by hedge fund managers, began funneling money to state legislators to bring bills to the floor that will circumvent public oversight of these charter schools.
Why all the flurry of activity over charter schools in our state? It's the money, of course.
Charter school operators, owners and CEO's stand to gain millions by taking Federal, state and district money to run their schools, whether they meet standards set by school district guidelines or not.
Many of these charter schools will take state money allocated for each student and then, particularly if they are special education students  students with behavioral issues, or others who require more resources,will push them back into the public schools while keeping the taxpayer dollars.
Charter schools also make large profits by offering “blended learning” alternatives, which means placing students in front of computers for classes and testing. Some charter schools will place more than 40 students in a classroom in front of computers and have one “teacher” oversee the process. The teacher is not required to be certified, and many times is a Teach for America, Inc. (TFA) recruit who is paid far less than a certified teacher in the district, thus allowing the charter school to pocket money that should be spent teaching and supporting students.
Although charter schools tout themselves as being a better option to public schools, study after study has shown that is not the case. Skewed media coverage of the battle over charter schools, especially from the slick operation “The Seventy Four,”  has created an echo chamber of misinformation about charter schools.
I want to set the record straight.
Let’s start with "the children". At this time approximately 840 students are enrolled in
- See more at: http://progressive.org/pss/washingtons-charter-school-fight%E2%80%94lets-set-record-straight#sthash.gqh0A7Y9.dpuf



United Teachers of Flint: When a Student Asks: Am I Going to Die? - Lily's Blackboard

When a Student Asks: Am I Going to Die? - Lily's Blackboard:
When a Student Asks: Am I Going to Die?

I sat with our brave colleagues and cried with them.  Karen Christian is a math teacher, but after school she’s president of United Teachers of Flint. That’s how it is with most of our union activists; they volunteer to be the union voice of their colleagues after their students head home. Karen’s tears were for those students as much as for her own 10-year-old son. Karen’s tears were for the children who had been drinking contaminated water for over a year; poisoned water. She worries that they have been harmed in ways that might not show for years.
Darlene is a 6th-grade science teacher. She and her grandkids have been drinking the water. Yet she was more interested in telling me about her students.  One of them asked her, “Am I going to die?” She says that her children are traumatized. They develop rashes if they bathe in the water.  Mothers are afraid to wash clothes in it. There are so many poor families here. There is nowhere for them to go.
One after another, these educators told me their stories. Stories of their own families and stories of the students.  They were frightened and angry and confused about how something so cruel and callous had happened to them and their community – a community that’s gone through tough times before, but nothing like this. Not poison coming through the kitchen faucet.DirtyWater
You’ve no doubt read about the Flint water crisis. It’s in all the papers. You may know that Governor Rick Snyder and his friends in the legislature have been systematicallycutting taxes on the One Percent and balancing the books by defunding public infrastructure for some time now. They’ve underfunded public schools, public health, and even the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality, which tests (or is supposed to test) the water. 
It wasn’t an act of God that devastated this town. It wasn’t an Oklahoma twister or a Gulf Coast hurricane. Manmade cuts in public funding made rubble of public services and provided the excuse for Snyder to declare a fiscal “emergency” wherein the governor can replace the elected officials in a city with his handpicked “emergency” manager to find “efficiencies.”
By the way, the people of Michigan didn’t like that law that gave the governor the power to strip local elected leaders of their authority and Michiganders overturned it on public referendum.  But the governor was not to be dissuaded by mere voters and with a little pixie dust, he rewrote the law with a magical minor change that created a loophole designed to make it immune to public referendum. 
Defying voters, he charged ahead, declaring Flint unfit to govern itself and with unrestrained arrogance, installed his man with austerity marching orders to cut costs, cut services, and cut corners. The result was this puny bureaucrat’sdecision to switch the water supply from Lake Huron (which was working just fine) to the filthy Flint River (which wasn’t).  It saved money.
Another savings came from not bothering with the processes to ensure the new water source was safe. The emergency manager didn’t listen to doctors who starting seeing health problems.  He didn’t care.  His job was to balance the budget.  He did.  For over a year, the residents of Flint – the nursing mothers; the grandpas; the kindergarteners; the track team; patients in the hospital; firefighters; grocery store cashiers; teachers and bus drivers; everyone – drank the water.  Everyone was being slowly poisoned.
This act of incompetence; of negligence is shameful beyond words.  But an emerging paper trail of evidence shows that the bureaucrats knew what was happening and covered it up to protect their own skins. It is environmental racism and economic injustice in a city that’s mostly minority and mostly poor. That’s criminal. It better be.  It When a Student Asks: Am I Going to Die? - Lily's Blackboard:

Maestro, Some “Opt Out” Music Please | The Merrow Report

Maestro, Some “Opt Out” Music Please | The Merrow Report:

Maestro, Some “Opt Out” Music Please
Major celebrations always begin with music.  Sunday’s Super Bowl had Lady GaGa, for example.  The national meeting of United Opt Out will have music of its own. A well-placed source inside the organization tells me that the annual meeting (beginning Friday in Philadelphia) will kick off with a variation on a familiar song. The lyrics, leaked to me, are below.
“YOU GOTTA KNOW WHEN TO TEACH ‘EM…
KNOW WHEN TO TEST ‘EM…
KNOW WHEN TO STEP ASIDE AND JUST LET ‘EM LEARN.
THE STATE KEEPS SAYING “TEST ‘EM,”
BUT ALL THAT DOES IS MESS ‘EM.
SCHOOLS DO TOO MUCH TESTING!
LET’S MAKE LEARNING FUN AGAIN”
My source said that the original song is by a Kenneth Ray Rogers, someone I’d never heard of.  However, my source apparently knows Mr. Rogers well because she/he kept referring to him as ‘Kenny.’
United Opt Out plans to sing the song three times, changing line three every so slightly each time, from ‘just let ’em learn‘ to ‘just watch ’em learn‘ and, finally ‘just help ’em learn.’  That covers the bases, I guess.
The United Opt Out gathering is expected to draw a large number of committed Maestro, Some “Opt Out” Music Please | The Merrow Report:
 
UOO Conference, February 26 - 28, 2016: Transcending Resistance, Igniting Revolution - UNITED OPT OUT: The Movement... http://bit.ly/1RmJLJc

NEIFPE Answers Reformer’s Questions | Live Long and Prosper

NEIFPE Answers Reformer’s Questions | Live Long and Prosper:

NEIFPE Answers Reformer’s Questions



I’m a member of NEIFPE, the Northeast Indiana Friends of Public Education(Facebook page: HERE and @NEIFPE on Twitter).

Last week we received an email from someone who is “not a public school teacher,” but “works in a public charter school” and is taking a “class” delivered by the Institute for Quality Education (affiliated with Hoosiers for Quality Education), an “education reform” group in Indiana. The writer asked us to answer three questions. He correctly answered the first, using the group’s mission statement. The other two he phrased in “reformy” ways implying that we were for forced attendance at local public schools and that we want to strip privately run schools (charters and parochial schools) of their funds.
To his credit, he did ask us to clarify whether or not we agreed with his answers. We did not agree with two of them, of course, and below are the three questions he asked along with our answers.
Thanks to the NEIFPE team for their work in composing this response.
From time to time, people have asked us who we are and what we do. Recently, we received a letter asking us to answer the following questions about our organization. Here are the questions and our responses.
What is the goal/vision for the organization?
NEIFPE’s mission statement outlines the goal of support for public education.
We are citizens, teachers, administrators, and parents united by our support for public education and by concerns for its future. Recent federal and state reform measures have created an over-emphasis on testing and have turned over public education to private interests. We believe that these reforms threaten the well-being of our children and jeopardize their futures. Our goal is to inform ourselves and to start community discussion about the impact of these measures on our public schools and, more importantly, on our children.
How is this organization working to improve education in Indiana?
NEIFPE advocates for a strong public school system that serves all children in the state. We believe education will be improved when education policy is 
NEIFPE Answers Reformer’s Questions | Live Long and Prosper:

Pick Me! Pick Me! I Want My Child to *OPT IN*. – Missouri Education Watchdog

Pick Me! Pick Me! I Want My Child to *OPT IN*. – Missouri Education Watchdog:

Pick Me! Pick Me! I Want My Child to *OPT IN*.

ccss test question
*Please please please* opt my child into a test like this!


 Educational reform must include the move from passive permission for student testing/data mining to active permission being required from parents before testing/data tracking of students.  Parents must have the legal right to excuse their students from being subjected to unvalidated testing and unknown entities receiving personally identifiable information on their students.

Parents need to reclaim their rights as taxpayers and guardians of their children, and supported by legislative statutes, to ensure that educational reform not based on research/data is instituted in their children’s classrooms and their children being subjected to substandard educational practices.  Parents have the right and duty to demand assessments their children are taking in school be valid assessments, versus assessments written to determine future social/educational/workforce policies.  Parents should not be required that their children complete assessments due to a funding threat from the USDOEd.  Parents must have knowledge of what data is being gathered by the school district, for what purpose and to whom that data is disseminated.
Lace to the Top points out the obvious disconnect between education reformers and parents in a recent post with an “Opt In Letter”.  If parents loved Common Core, excessive testing with non-validated assessments and data mining of their children, school districts would be inundated with parents begging to be part of these testing/data mining practices.  The letter below is from a fictional parent buying into the schtick of the education reformers: shoddy assessments, questionable results of these assessments, the *need* to become globally competitive, the crony capitalists, and the *need* for student’s personally identifiable information.
Do you know of any parent who would sign such a letter below?   If districts were required to utilized active permission to assess/data mine children, it would be an interesting guess on how many opt in forms would actually be received by districts. It’s dark humor and makes the eloquent point that most parents do not support the CCSSI and would not support such an opt in.

With A Brooklyn Accent: Who's Going to Honor Them?

With A Brooklyn Accent: Who's Going to Honor Them?:

Who's Going to Honor Them?

 When you praise Teach for America, as President Obama did at TFA's 25th anniversary celebration, for bringing "high quality teachers" into schools in high needs communities, it is an implicit insult to teachers already there who have made this work their lifetime commitment. I wonder how many TFA Corps members assigned to the Bronx are still there, in the same schools, after 5 years have passed?

What about all the great teachers such as Aixa Rodriguez, Alietta Gordon,Carla Cherry and Theresa Massaro who started in the Bronx and have stayed in the Bronx, sometimes under the most adverse conditions
Who is going to honor them? Who is going to recognize their contribution to the children and families of the Bronx?With A Brooklyn Accent: Who's Going to Honor Them?:

State Takeovers of Low-Performing Schools: A Record of Academic Failure, Financial Mismanagement & Student Harm

State Takeovers of Low-Performing Schools: A Record of Academic Failure, Financial Mismanagement & Student Harm | Center for Popular Democracy:

State Takeovers of Low-Performing Schools: A Record of Academic Failure, Financial Mismanagement & Student Harm


State takeovers report


 Low-performing public schools have become a critical battleground between corporate-backed initiatives that remove local control of schools and favor the privatization of public education, and proponents of community schools who assert that parents, teachers and students—in short, the public—are the greatest asset in restoring strong educational outcomes.

In the past decade, the debate over school control has shifted to include “takeover districts” in which schools that are deemed “chronically failing” are removed from the local school district and placed in a statewide district with a separate governance structure that is far less transparent and accountable to the public. Three states, Louisiana, Tennessee, and Michigan, had already established districts of this kind by 2014. Another eight states have introduced legislation to create statewide takeover districts in the last year: Arkansas, Georgia, Nevada, Missouri, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, and Wisconsin.
Findings
The rapid proliferation of the takeover district as an educational panacea is alarming. In this report, we examine the record of the three existing takeover districts, and find that there is no clear evidence that takeover districts actually achieve their stated goals of radically improving performance at failing schools. We find that:
1. Children have seen negligible improvement—or even dramatic setbacks—in their educational performance.
2. State takeover districts have created a breeding ground for fraud and mismanagement at the public’s expense.
3. Staff face high turnover and instability, creating a disrupted learning environment for children.
4. Students of color and those with special needs face harsh disciplinary measures and discriminatory practices that further entrench a two-tiered educational system.
Recommendations
Instead of replicating failed statewide takeovers in an attempt to turn around struggling schools, states should pursue tested measures endorsed by educators, students, and community members, and that have been borne out by precedent. States must commit to improving outcomes at struggling schools through programs and policies that reflect the six key principles developed by the Alliance to Reclaim Our Schools. As articulated in The Schools Our Children Deserve, school turnaround strategies should focus on:
• Curricula that are engaging, culturally relevant and challenging;
• High quality teaching rather than high-stakes testing;
• Wrap-around supports such as health care, eye care, and social and emotional services that support academics;
• Positive discipline practices such as restorative justice and social and emotional learning supports;
• Transformational parent and community engagement—the full community should actively participate in planning and decision-making; and
• Inclusive school leadership committed to developing strategic plans that include authentic input from teachers, parents, community partners, non-instructional school staff, youth, and other stakeholders.

Making the case for school gardens as classrooms - NonDoc

Making the case for school gardens as classrooms - NonDoc:

Making the case for school gardens as classrooms

By Tiara Blue -

Garden as classroom
Tiara Blue’s son Dawson sits in a upraised bed of strawberry plants in their family garden. (Tiara Blue)


 TISHOMINGO — Gardening should be taught in schools, and not just because food is kind of important.

School gardens have been tied to higher standardized test scores, fewer discipline problems, lower stress among students and increased engagement, in addition to more fine-tuned personal qualities, such as patience, attention to detail and improvisation.
According to REAL School Gardens, a nonprofit operating in Texas and Washington, D.C., its participating schools have reported increases for standardized test scores pass rates of “between 12-15 percent.” What’s more, 94 percent of teachers reported increased student engagement.
So why aren’t all schools investing in a garden? Inevitably, the conversation goes back to money.
Amidst a $900 million budget shortfall, Oklahoma now leads the country in inflation-adjusted funding cuts for per-pupil education, dropping 24.2 percent from 2008 to 2016, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. Our state is now ranked near the very bottom of the country for teacher pay and per-pupil spending.
It begs the questions: When schools are already so squeezed for money and teachers are strained for time and resources, how can anyone suggest adding something else to their plate?
Because something has to change.
DATA POINT
33.9 % of Oklahoma children are obese. School gardens have been linked to increased physical activity and a greater likelihood that participating students will eat fresh fruits and vegetables, which could reduce this number.
Oklahoma isn’t a friendly place for families hoping to give their children a competitive education, and it hasn’t been for several years. Incorporating gardening into the curriculum could give us that competitive edge. If Making the case for school gardens as classrooms - NonDoc:

CURMUDGUCATION: Maryland University President's Loyalty Purge

CURMUDGUCATION: Maryland University President's Loyalty Purge:

Maryland University President's Loyalty Purge

Remember the story about the university president in Maryland who directed his faculty to "drown the bunnies" in order to improve their retention and graduation numbers? Well, according to Inside Higher Ed, he has gone after and fired faculty members that he considers disloyal-- including the adviser of the school paper that outed his bunny comment.

President Simon Newman was hired as the head of the small Roman Catholic university a year ago, with not an iota experience in higher education. Instead, Newman was plucked from the world of business, specializing in private equity and starting businesses.

Newman fired a tenured professor, Thane M. Naberhaus of the philosophy department, with a letter that included this rationale:

As an employee of Mount St. Mary's University, you owe a duty of loyalty to this university and to act in a manner consistent with that duty. However, your recent actions, in my opinion and that of others, have violated that duty and clearly justify your termination.

Newman seems to believe that loyalty to the university means never questioning the decisions of Newman himself. Newman blamed Naberhaus for "considerable damage" to the university, threatened him with a lawsuit, and banned him from the campus. His page has been wiped from the university website.

David Rehm, the provost who told Newman to hold off on his freshman flushing plan, was removed from his post as provost. 

Newman also fired Edward Egan, a professor of law, alumnus, son of an alumnus, and former trustee of the university. Egan was the advisor of the Mountain Echo, the school newspaper that 
CURMUDGUCATION: Maryland University President's Loyalty Purge:

Equity and Excellence in the President’s Budget for Education | ED.gov Blog

Equity and Excellence in the President’s Budget for Education | ED.gov Blog:

Equity and Excellence in the President’s Budget for Education

16950394577_093a7b35f5_k
Anyone in America can succeed, but success doesn’t arrive overnight. More often, it’s the result of countless hours spent studying, of supportive families and communities, of educators preparing inspiring lessons and staying late with students who are struggling. It was education that drew my parents here as students from India, seeking graduate degrees in science and engineering. And education was the greatest gift they would give my brother and me, always believing that if we worked hard, we could achieve even greater things.
I see my parents’ reflection in many of the parents I meet at the elementary school where my own two children now go. These are parents who may or may not have finished high school or college themselves, but who are going to make sure their own children complete their homework—and make it to college. These are the parents who take time out from their jobs working nights to sit in on PTA meetings, often listening intently through headphones to the Spanish-language translation. Education is the key to success, and these parents know it.
The problem is that too often, parents of children most at risk of falling behind face the highest obstacles to obtaining a quality education for their kids. For example, today, only 41 percent of children in low-income communities are enrolled in preschool, compared with 61 percent of children in wealthier communities. In high school, only 57 percent of black students and two-thirds of Hispanic students have access to the full range of courses necessary to succeed in college and careers, compared to 71 percent of white students. And American Indian and Native-Alaskan students are also disproportionately suspended and expelled, representing less than 1 percent of the student population but 2 percent of out-of-school suspensions and 3 percent of expulsions.
We can and we must do better, for all of our kids.
The President’s 2017 budget request recognizes the importance of this goal through significant new investments in three key areas: high-quality early learning; stronger and more diverse schools; and increased access to evidence and data to help all of us improve outcomes for students.
Boosting access to high-quality early learning:
The President’s budget request aims to ensure access to high-quality preschool programs for 4-year-olds with $1.3 billion in mandatory funding in 2017 and $75 billion over 10 years for the President’s landmark Preschool for All proposal. The budget also supports special education services and early intervention programs for our youngest learners.
The budget also supports local innovation to create stronger, more diverse schools, through:
  • $450 million in additional funding for Title I Grants, for a total of $15.4 billion to help local educational agencies ensure that all students graduate from high school prepared for college and careers, in part through locally developed efforts to turn around our lowest-performing schools.
  • $120 million in grants to launch Stronger Together, a voluntary program to support the development and expansion of new and existing, community-driven strategies to increase socioeconomic diversity in America’s schools.
  • Additional funding to support school choice through high-quality public charter and magnet schools. The budget includes an additional $17 million for Charter School Grants and an additional $18 million for magnet schools.
  • $4 billion over three years to launch Computer Science for All, supporting state efforts to expand access for all students to computer science instruction and programs of study. The budget also includes the $100 million discretionary Computer Science for All Development Grants program for school districts.
  • An increase of $55 million to support new Promise Neighborhoods in up to 15 distressed communities seeking to break the cycle of poverty through the development and implementation of comprehensive cradle-to-college supports for children and families.
Expanding access to evidence and data
Through InformED, the Department will provide the public with expanded, user-friendly access to data to drive decision-making and better outcomes for students.
In his final State of the Union address, President Obama challenged us to “face the future with confidence in who we are, what we stand for, and the incredible things we can do together.”
Central to this challenge is putting the American Dream within reach of every child and young person. The President’s 2017 budget request for education will help provide states, districts, and communities with the necessary resources to uphold excellence and equity in education, and to give all students opportunities and hope for the future, much like those that my parents gave me.
Aparna Kumar is a member of the Communications Development Team in the Office of Communications and Outreach at the U.S. Department of Education.
 Equity and Excellence in the President’s Budget for Education | ED.gov Blog:

Letter to the Auditor – Crazy Crawfish

Letter to the Auditor – Crazy Crawfish:

Letter to the Auditor

I recently received this letter from a friend named Mark Joyce, who has been getting very actively involved in Louisiana’s education scene and in particular the malfeasance at the LDOE.  (Mark has recently been investigating and publishing pieces about campaign financing for candidates in the Advocate and Louisiana Voice.)  After reading about the latest disgusting revelations that have come out about ReNew charter in New Orleans he apparently recognizes this systemic abuse and neglect is something we all need to be concerned about and he as written the legislative auditor to try and rekindle some interest in some of the auditor’s own findings as well as these latest developments.
Mark summarizes some more historical revelations about now LDOE and RSD have squandered precious funding over the years without any repercussions.  Local school districts are also dramatically impacted by the way our state has chosen to implement charter schools. This is putting a strain on local communities and school systems over the same time period that funding for local systems has decreased.
The State has devised a scheme whereby they essentially steal locally local tax dollars allocated to pay for public schools overseen by the local district and hand them off to charter schools that the state “oversees” (not very well if at all as theReNew situation shows) and approve and which the local district has no oversight over.  In light of our state’s current dire financial situation can we afford to Letter to the Auditor – Crazy Crawfish:

Teachers Can’t Fix Poverty or Problems Like Housing Eviction | janresseger

Teachers Can’t Fix Poverty or Problems Like Housing Eviction | janresseger:

Teachers Can’t Fix Poverty or Problems Like Housing Eviction

For twenty years, our society has embraced a theory of school reform whose driving idea is that if schools expect more and teachers work harder, test scores will rise among the students who struggle.  It is a theory that expects public schools themselves to compensate for growing economic inequality and structural racism.  The idea is that schools are primarily responsible for closing the gaps in children’s opportunities.
Social scientists, on the other hand, tell us that children’s standardized test scores seem to correlate not so much with their schools as with their families’ economic circumstances.  Anincome inequality achievement gap has grown rapidly during the past half century.  Here is the theoretical explanation of Andrew Grant-Thomas and John Powell: “A social system is structurally inequitable to the degree that it is configured to promote unequal outcomes.  A society marked by highly interdependent opportunity structures and large inter-institutional resource disparities will likely be very unequal with respect to the outcomes governed by those institutions and structures… In a society that features structural inequalities with respect to opportunities and institutional resources, initial racial inequality in motion will likely stay in motion.” (Andrew Grant-Thomas and Gary Orfield, editors, Twenty-First Century Color Lines, p. 124)
Although we are a society that features structural inequality and structural racism, most of us are not personally familiar with the lives of families on the edge. Because our American ethos credits success to individual grit, we struggle to understand why hard working teachers can’t get the children in their classes to pull themselves up more quickly.  Michael Harrington tried to help 50 years ago by describing The Other America.  To that same end, from time to time this blog is exploring—in Grant-Thomas and John Powell’s words—“highly interdependent Teachers Can’t Fix Poverty or Problems Like Housing Eviction | janresseger: