Friday, April 25, 2014

4-25-14 LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:








News Flash from L.A.: Science Teacher Suspended for Teaching Science Now Back in Classroom
Strange things happen in Los Angeles. Maybe all that nonstop good weather rattles people. High school science teacher Greg Schiller was suspended after an administrator concluded that science projects made by two of his students were dangerous. Schiller has now been allowed to return to his classroom. “Both projects overseen by teacher Greg Schiller were capable of launching small objects. A st


Breaking News: Colorado Teachers Force Union to Join Fight Against High-Stakes Testing!
This just in: Dear Colleagues: I write to you specifically to inform you of recent action taken at the Colorado Education Association’s delegate assembly. This past Tuesday, April 22nd, Pat Kennedy and I met here at my office at UNC to discuss what had recently transpired at the Colorado Education Association’s delegate assembly held earlier this month. The CEA adopted a new business item which r

North Carolina May Drop Common Core
The North Carolina legislature is deciding whether to back out of the Common Core standards. As a critic of the Common Core, I have mixed feelings about this. On one hand, I would be pleased to see a state that won Race to the Top funding telling Arne Duncan “No, thanks,” we don’t take orders from you. On the other, the North Carolina legislature is so extremist and so hostile to public educatio
CNN’s “Chicagoland” Was Fake Documentary, An Infomercial to Glorify Rahm
Bill Ruthhart, a reporter for the Chicago Tribune, reviewed hundreds of emails about CNN’s “Chicagoland” and discovered that the “documentary” was an infomercial for controversial Mayor Rahm Emanuel. CNN honored him at the very time that he took the historically unprecedented step of closing 50 public schools. CNN has no shame. He writes: “If it seemed as though some scenes of CNN’s documentary
Milwaukee: Why Corporate Takeovers Make No Sense
The previous post reviewed the past history of Milwaukee. You might be tempted to skip past the report by Gordon Lafer on charters that is embedded in the press release. So I urge you to read the full (and short) report on why Milwaukee does not need more charter schools.   Lafer writes:   Upon examination, it appears that charter privatization proposals are driven more by financial and ideologica

EPI: Corporate Takeover of Milwaukee Public Schools Makes No Sense
Poor Milwaukee. It has a thriving voucher sector. It has a thriving charter sector. It has a struggling public sector, overloaded with the children with disabilities and the others that the two private sectors don’t want.   Yet neither the voucher schools nor the charter schools get better test scores, and the higher graduation rate of the voucher schools relies on an extraordinary attrition rate

Obama and Duncan Plan to Control Teacher Institutions with Their Failed Ideas
With the Obama administration’s latest policy pronouncement, the federal grip on American education grows tighter and stupider every day. The latest: the administration plans to reward the best teacher-training institutions and drive the “worst” ones out of business. This is like Race to the Top for teacher preparation programs. What are their measures? Of course, student test scores loom large.

Randi to Pearson: Remove the Gag Order and Test Secrecy
Randi Weingarten, on behalf of the American Federation of Teachers, sent representatives to the Pearson shareholders’ meeting in London and wrote the following letter to the leaders of the world’s biggest testing corporation. By shrouding the tests in secrecy, Pearson denies information to teachers to help diagnose student needs. The tests become useless by having no diagnostic value. Speculation


Chris Rekydal of Washington State: A Hero of American Education
Washington State thoughtfully rejected Arne Duncan’s threat to cancel its waiver from the absurd demands of No Child Left Behind. The decision to say no to federal demands and intimidation was bipartisan. The Legislature refused to bend to Duncan’s insistence that the state adopt test-based evaluation, which has consistently failed across the nation and has been declared inaccurate by the nation’

Gary Rubinstein: Did Arne Duncan Find a Miracle School in Denver?
Gary Rubinstein is quite the sleuth when anyone makes a claim about educational results that seem too good to be true.   A few years ago, he helped me pin down some whoppers when Secretary Arne Duncan, President Obama, and then-Mayor Michael Bloomberg claimed they discovered miracle schools that had a 100% graduation rate, or miraculous score gains, or some other incredible statistic. His research
A Hero Superintendent in Oklahoma Defies the State, Exempts Two Students from Tests
Donna Dudley, superintendent of Moyers public schools in Oklahoma, made a conscious decision to defy the state.   It should not have been an extraordinary decision because it was what a decent human being would do.   Two of her students suffered a terrible loss the weekend before the state tests. Their parents were killed in a car crash.   Superintendent Dudley asked the state for permission to ex
Bob Sikes: The Voucher Hypocrisy of Republicans in Florida
Republicans have been pushing vouchers in Florida, despite the fact that voters turned them down in 2012 by a decisive margin. Republicans have been calling for STEM education (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) at the same time that they want children to go to school where creationism is taught as science. Republicans claim they want more accountability but schools receiving vouch
Alexandra Miletta: edTPA: Good Thing or Bad Thing? Part 1
A few years ago, the Powers-That-Be decided that the biggest problem in American education was the teachers. McKinsey said that other nations attracted the top performing graduates of the most prestigious universities into teaching, while our own sorry teachers came from the bottom of the barrel. In the hunt for perpetrators of what was wrongly assumed to be a national education disaster (after al
4-24-14 LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: Teacher to David Coleman: Yes, What Children Think and Feel Does MatterVeteran teacher Eileen Riley Hall has some advice for David Coleman, architect of the Common Core standards. Coleman famously said, in taped remarks at the New York State Education Department, that   “As you grow up in this world, you realize people really don’t




4-25-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher

Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.:



bundy



And the winner is…
Fred Klonsky:A year ago I reached one million page hits. At the present rate I will reach two million by mid-summer. To celebrate one million I held a haiku/poetry contest. I must think of something to celebrate two million site hits. Originally posted on Fred Klonsky: Remember all entries must have been a tweet, haiku or limerick. The decision of the judge (that’s me) is final. And the winner of

April 29th. S.O.R.E. Action Day.
Contact your legislator here.


Ten minute drawing. The Bundy Decision.
Barack Obama High School and Chicago’s tale of two cities.
On Wednesday, Rahm Emanuel’s hand-picked school board voted to fire every administrator, teacher, paraprofessional and lunch lady from three neighborhood schools and handed those schools over the the corporate-connected Academy for Urban School Leadership. The three schools – Gresham, Dvorak and McNair are on the south and west side.  “Given money, we can do many, many things,” said Diedrus Brown
4-24-14 Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher
Fred Klonsky | Daily posts from a retired public school teacher who is just looking at the data.: Jose Vilson gets the Fred Klonsky treatment.Fred, First, I’m thankful you got around to this. On Cloud 10 even. Secondly, and perhaps more jokingly, I was hoping for the Fred Klonsky treatment with the artwork and all. I’m not mad, though. Honest. Thanks again. It’s like you freaking know me. - Jose V




College Perp | EduShyster

College Perp | EduShyster:



College Perp





 Is harsh discipline really the best way to prepare low-income minority students for college?

silent lines
Quick reader: what is the best way to prepare low-income minority students for college and 21st-century success? If you answered *an obsessive focus on the students’ smallest behaviors (particularly infractions of the uniform variety) paired with plenty of harsh discipline for disciplinary infractions* you are in excellent company. In fact, almost everyone who is anyone these days is in near uniform agreement that harsh punishment today is a recipe for 21st century success tomorrow. Well, not everyone. A group of New Orleans parents recently filed suit, claiming that a *demeaning culture of discipline* at three of the city’s charter schools, including Sci Academy, considered a model charter for New Orleans and beyond, violates the civil rights of students. 
Rights and wrongs 
The parents’ complaint, filed with US Secretary of Education Arne Duncan, the US Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights and the Louisiana Recovery District and others, raises a thicket of thorny questions—like, whether or not students attending privately-run charter schools even have civil rights. Or why sky-high suspension rates are apparently A-ok when done in the name of college prep. The three Collegiate Academy College Perp | EduShyster:

Cutting Through the Hype: Principals as Instructional Leaders | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice

Cutting Through the Hype: Principals as Instructional Leaders | Larry Cuban on School Reform and Classroom Practice:



Cutting Through the Hype: Principals as Instructional Leaders


Jane David and I wrote a book called Cutting through the Hype: (Harvard Education Press, 2010). This is one chapter on principals. I have updated some references and language.
Effective manager? Savvy politician? Heroic leader? School CEO? Reformers press for principals who can not only play these roles but also raise test scores and do so quickly. These days principals can earn thousands of dollars inbonuses for boosting student achievement.
Principals are expected to maintain order, to be shrewd managers who squeeze a dollar out of every dime spent on the school, and astute politicians who can steer parents, teachers, and students in the same direction year after year. They are also expected to ensure that district curriculum standards are being taught, as well as lead instructional improvement that will translate into test score gains.
Being a principal is a tall order. As one New York City small high school principal put it: “You’re a teacher, you’re Judge Judy, you’re a mother, you’re a father, you’re a pastor, you’re a therapist, you’re a nurse, you’re a social worker.” She took a breath and continued: “You’re a curriculum planner, you’re a data gatherer, you’re a budget scheduler, you’re a vision spreader.” Yet, at the end of the day, the pressures and rewards are for raising test scores and graduation rates, today’s measure of instructional leadership.
Where did the idea of instructional leadership originate?

4-25-14 Wait What?

Wait What?:











Greenwich superintendent joins Commissioner Pryor in misleading parents
Here we go again! Instead of fulfilling their legal, moral and ethical duty as a superintendent of a public school system in Connecticut, yet another public school superintendent has decided to join the Malloy’s administration’s ongoing efforts to mislead Connecticut parents into thinking that they do not have a right to opt their children out […] The post Greenwich superintendent joins Commission
Education Advocate Maria Naughton on the Common Core and Smarter Balanced Assessment Test
Here are two new more contributions from public education advocate Maria Naughton.  Maria Naughton is an educational consultant, former teacher and mother of four children in New Canaan Public Schools. She writes a column for the News of New Canaan. The first is a link to a radio show in which Maria Naughton discusses the […] The post Education Advocate Maria Naughton on the Common Core and Smarte
4-24-14 Wait What?
Wait What?: There goes another $1.8 million to an out-of-state corporate education reform consulting companyOnce again you can hear the high-priced consultants laughing their way to the bank with our tax dollars. Over the three years, Governor Malloy’s Commissioner of Education, Stefan Pryor, has been busy signing contracts with out-of-state consulting companies that are costing Connecticut taxpay






4-25-14 The Answer Sheet What teachers really want

The Answer Sheet:






Oklahoma school district accepts Bible curriculum that says sinners must ‘suffer’ for disobeying God
A suburban Oklahoma City  public school district has adopted a curriculum for high schools that its backers say uses Bible stories to teach subjects such as history and the arts and that says all sinners must “suffer the consequences” of disobeying God. It also says that some U2 songs are based in the Psalms. The […]


Does it pay to obsess on where your kid goes to college?
We all know people who seem to spend all of their time obsessing about where their children are going to go to college, as if there is a magical place that will ensure success. There isn’t. Jack Schneider, an assistant professor of education at the College of the Holy Cross, looks at this phenomenon. He […]

Obama plans new regulation on colleges of education
The Obama administration’s obsession with standardized test scores knows no bounds. The newest example: a plan to spend millions of dollars to reward those colleges of education whose graduates, among other things, are successful in raising their students’ standardized test scores. Education Secretary Arne Duncan hopes to have a draft regulation ready by this summer […]



AFT asks Pearson to stop ‘gag order’ barring educators from talking about tests
American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten is sending a letter (see below) to the executives of Pearson, the world’s largest education company, asking them to stop a  ”gag order” that is part of their $32 million contract with New York state to design new standardized tests aligned to the Common Core. The “gag order” […]


4-24-14 The Answer Sheet What teachers really want
The Answer Sheet: How, after 60 years, Brown v. Board of Education succeeded — and didn’tThe 60th anniversary of the historic Brown v. Board of Education Supreme Court ruling is almost upon us and it’s a good time to take a look at whether it succeeded in its mission: to end segregation in public schools. Here is an important report about what has and has not been accomplished by the case. It […]b

4-25-14 Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida

Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education:






Michelle Rhee Slithers Into Florida Voucher Scrap With Another Astroturf Campaign
Michelle Rhee’s corporate-funded tax-exempt 501c4 has  parachuted into Florida and is attempting another Astroturf campaign to support the latest republican voucher scheme. Here’s the email from Rhee’s Florida rep: Dear Friend, Over the next week, the Florida legislature has an opportunity to change the lives of thousands of Florida’s neediest students. But it won’t happen without your help. HB 71


Children With Terminal Diseases Have to Take the Test, But Voucher Kids Don’t
From St. Augustine Record reporter Marcia Lane: A Senate subcommittee approved an amendment on Tuesday expanding the voucher program, known as the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship Program, adding it to a bill that helps parents of disabled children get additional educational services. Opponents say the plan is going to hurt public schools and the state’s children. Among major complaints is the lack


4-24-14 Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida
Scathing Purple Musings | Color me purple in Florida, red in Washington, dark sky-blue in Israel and public school in Education: Gaetz, Senate Republicans Lose Credibility on Accountability in Voucher DealSenate president Don Gaetz once acted as if accountability really mattered. After a legislative career built upon the education chops he earned as a former school superintendent who was an accoun




Christians have grabbed ‘theocratic control over public schools’ in Louisiana, critic says

Christians have grabbed ‘theocratic control over public schools’ in Louisiana, critic says:



Christians have grabbed ‘theocratic control over public schools’ in Louisiana, critic says

By Scott Kaufman


jim dugan


 Yesterday, the Louisiana Senate Education Committee upheld a controversial law that allows science teachers to bring “supplemental science education materials” into the classroom.

The Committee voted 3-1 to uphold the Louisiana Science Education Act (LSEA) — which critics contend allows teachers to introduce creationist literature into science classrooms — on the grounds that no proof that teachers were importing religious-oriented material into the public school could be found.
The LSEA, which was passed in 2008 with the support of Governor Bobby Jindal and prominent state conservatives, allows teachers to use “supplemental textbooks and other instructional materials” so long as they “help students understand, analyze, critique, and review scientific theories in an objective manner.” Gene Mills, president of the Christian Louisiana Family Forum, called it “a reasonable academic freedom policy, one that has become a model for others.”
Critics of the law, including Dr. Jim Dugan, claimed at the hearing that LSEA is a ruse designed to allow for the teaching of creationism and intelligent design in public schools under the aegis of “critical thinking.”
“I think it’s obvious to any thoughtful person that the poorly written and deceptively named ‘Louisiana Science Education Act’ is a crude attempt to provide legal cover for the teaching of creationism and intelligent design in public schools,” he said.
“The bill exclusive targets — and I’m quoting from the bill here — ‘evolution,’ ‘the origins of life,’ ‘global warming,’ and ‘human cloning.’ These are not topics,” he continued, “thought to be problematic by scientists, or science educators, but [are] wedge issues frequently used by Christian fundamentalists to attempt theocratic control over public school curriculum.”
Raw Story spoke to Dr. Dugan this morning, and his reaction to the Committee’s decision was that Christians have grabbed ‘theocratic control over public schools’ in Louisiana, critic says:

Protecting Classrooms From Corporate Takeover | PopularResistance.Org

Protecting Classrooms From Corporate Takeover | PopularResistance.Org:



Protecting Classrooms From Corporate Takeover

Print Friendly
Teachers are fighting the privatization wave by connecting with families right where they live.
Teachers have always held a cherished role in our society – recognized as professionals who know how to inculcate a love of learning in our children. But the “education reform” movement represented by No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top blames teachers for the problems in our public schools.
“The people who seek to privatize the public sector are looking for any excuse to criticize teachers,” says Bob Peterson, veteran fifth-grade teacher and president of the Milwaukee Teachers’ Education Association (MTEA). “We must take responsibility for our profession. If we don’t step up to the plate, public education is going to be destroyed.”
At heart, this is a debate between competing visions of teachers’ roles in public education in America. Teachers, through their unions, are defending the idea that they are best-equipped to teach children to become lifelong learners. Education “reformers,” though, cite studies – such as one from the Goldwater Institute from 2004 – that show that students at privately run charter schools outperform kids in public schools and say that public education would improve if public schools simply looked more like privately run schools. In privately run schools, teachers lack a collective voice, their working conditions are subject to the whims of school administrators, and they can be fired at will. This contrast with the empowered rank and file of unionized public school teachers could help explain the claims of “reformers” that traditional public school teachers are too sheltered, that they can’t be dismissed easily enough, and that their unions need to be eliminated. Firing and replacing teachers based on students’ scores on standardized tests, then, is part of the reformers’ vision for the schools.
Everyone agrees that great teachers are key to a good education. But reform advocates such as former Washington, D.C., schools chief Michelle Rhee say that schools can fire their way to excellence. In September 2013, according to a report on the public policy website Next City, Rhee spoke at Temple University. Exemplifying the rhetoric of the reformers, Rhee said, “Not everyone can do this job. If you have a pulse and pass the criminal check, a lot of school districts will just stick you in the classroom.” But Rhee’s approach is to evaluate teachers by giving their students standardized tests. This approach offers, at best, an imprecise evaluation, failing to measure the intangibles that make great teachers. The result is that some of the best teachers get taken out, along with a few bad ones.
Peterson and other educators say that, unsurprisingly, the reformers’ approach undermines those who have devoted their professional lives to educating kids. In 2010, Rhee fired 241 Protecting Classrooms From Corporate Takeover | PopularResistance.Org: