Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Why False Compromises Won’t Resolve The Education Debate

Why False Compromises Won’t Resolve The Education Debate:



Education Opportunity Network -

Why False Compromises Won’t Resolve The Education Debate




Legend has, political disputes are supposed to be resolvable only when parties “meet in the middle” and shake hands on points of agreement that are possible.
But in the much-contested issue of “education reform,” only one of the disputing parties in the debate tends to be implored to seek compromise.
The latest example of this came from conservative commentator Juan Williams. Writing for The Hill, Williams claimed differing opinions of how to improve the nation’s schools are “stuck in partisan paralysis.” He beseeched “two of the nation’s most politically powerful black men,” President Obama and Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) to make a “deal” on “hotly debated education reforms” and embrace the cause of charter schools.
Such a “grand bargain,” Williams assured, would “deliver on the promise of equal opportunity and solve this generation’s top civil rights problem.”
Similarly, in the same week, liberal columnist Jonathan Chait wrote forNew York Magazine that the fate of the nation’s schools was caught up in a “weird ideological divide” between people who promote charter schools as a solution for the nation’s education problems and those who have doubts about that.
Chait blamed that “divide” on education historian Diane Ravitch who, according to Chait, “portrays charter schools as a corporate plot.” What’s necessary, Chait maintained, is the “Ravitch and union view of the world” to give up “a nostalgic embrace of the old-fashioned organization of public school” and accepts “attempts to apply empirical metrics” that apparently characterize charter schools.
First, set aside how each of these popular columnists jumps to sweeping conclusions without citing any evidence.
(Williams claimed schools are “failing to do their part” to address under achievement of black and Latino students. Yet, results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress show that these students have madegreat strides in improving performance. Chait claimed neighborhood schools in Washington DC and New York City “are open to children who live close by and restricted to everybody else” – which is not true – and “charter schools are more aggressive about creating accountability


2/11/2014 – False Compromises In The Education Debate
February 11, 2014 Subscribe THIS WEEK: School Funding Is Unfair … Republicans Play The Charter School Card … Millennial Unemployment Climbs … Skills Gap Myth … Warren Blasts Billion-Dollar Student Loan Profits TOP STORY Why False Compromises Won’t Resolve The Education Debate By Jeff Bryant “In the much-contested issue of ‘education reform,’ only one of the disputing parties in the debate tend
New York's 50 Most Underfunded School Districts | National Opportunity to Learn Campaign | Education Reform for Equity and Opportunity
New York's 50 Most Underfunded School Districts | National Opportunity to Learn Campaign | Education Reform for Equity and Opportunity: MA Allies Help Draft Guidelines to Curb SuspensionsOTL allies in Massachusetts played a huge role in passing a 2012 law known as Chapter 222 that required schools to provide educational resources to suspended students. Now, these same allies are playing a role in


Testing Resistance & Reform News: February 5 - 11, 2014 | FairTest

Testing Resistance & Reform News: February 5 - 11, 2014 | FairTest:



Testing Resistance & Reform News: February 5 - 11, 2014

The ever-louder drumbeat of opposition to standardized test misuse and overuse is now being heard in more than a dozen state capitals.  Across the country, governors, legislatures, and other education policy makers are responding to their constituents' concerns by eliminating high-stakes exams, reducing the volume of testing, and supporting better forms of assessment.
When will President Obama and Education Secretary Duncan start getting the message?
Regents Likely to Stall Parts of Common Core Implementation
http://www.pressconnects.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2014302100021&gcheck=1
N.Y. PTA Survey Finds Students Stressed Out by Testing, Parents Opposed to Common Core Exams
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/02/07/new-york-common-core-stress_n_4747863.html?utm_hp_ref=education
Gov. Cuomo Appoints Common Core Proponents to Evaluate Common Core
http://www.nysape.org/new-yorkers-outraged-by-governors-flawed-common-core-panel.html
Missouri Board of Ed. Plans Major Reduction in Testing
http://www.semissourian.com/story/2047976.html
Virginia Senate Votes for Delay in Test-Based School Grades, Reduction in Testing Volume
http://www.roanoke.com/news/virginia/article_4e588c5a-8e1d-11e3-bf18-001a4bcf6878.html
"Guinea Pigs" and "Lab Rats" Storm Rhode Island State House as Student Protest Exit Exam
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUonuu4ZJjs
Students Aren't "Guinea Pigs" -- How Field Testing Hurts Children
http://yinzercation.wordpress.com/news/
Chicago Opt Out Leaders Push Back Against Chief Executive Officer's Hollow Threat
http://www.chicagonow.com/chicago-public-fools/2014/02/its-almost-testing-season-in-chicago-opt-out-at-your-peril/
The 95% Participation Rate and How Schools Do Not Lose Funding
http://www.nysape.org/if-my-child-refuses-state-tests-will-my-school-lose-funding.html
Test Scores = Voodoo Data for Evaluating Students, Teachers and Schools
http://www.dailycall.com/news/editorials/3572277/Its-all-so-predictable
Federal Court Upholds New York City Liability for Teacher Licensing Test Racial Bias
http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/school_law/2014/02/appeals_court_upholds_nyc_liab.html?cmp=ENL-EU-NEWS3
Tennessee School Board Reconsiders Role of Student Test Scores in Teacher Licensure
http://www.tennessean.com/article/20140201/NEWS/302010011/TN-state-board-reconsiders-role-learning-gains-teacher-licenses

The Great Chicago Pension Caper is Underway Chicago Teachers Union

Chicago Teachers Union | The Great Chicago Pension Caper is Underway:



The Great Chicago Pension Caper is Underway

BY CTU COMMUNICATIONS  |  02/10/2014


CHICAGO – The Chicago Teachers Union (CTU) vowed to stand firm in its defense of the retirement security of thousands of retired public school educators in the wake of new threats by Mayor Rahm Emanuel and his legislative allies to fire another 3,000 teachers and raise student class sizes. CTU Vice President Jesse Sharkey said instead of good faith bargaining, “that sounds like negotiations at the point of a gun.”  A salvo launched today by Illinois Senator John J. Cullteron is the start of what could be “The Great Chicago Pension Caper.”
While speaking at the City Club of Chicago and upon the heels of a misleading commentary published in the Chicago Tribune, the Senate president acknowledged that Chicago Public Schools (CPS) must make a $613 million payment to the pension fund by June 30, yet failed to mention that the money has already been budgeted for 2014. He also ignores the fact that teachers do not receive social security.  Pensions are not a gift they are the hard won earnings of employees who expect that money to be there when they retire.
Instead of calling on Mayor Emanuel to honor his legal obligation, Cullerton offers a guesstimate of future cuts based on a calculation that uses Senate Bill 1, the pension cutting bill passed by the Illinois General Assembly, as a template. The bill was passed last year to reduce the pension benefits for hundreds of thousands of workers in the state pension systems. When SB1 is used as a model for cuts, city workers and retirees in Chicago are likely to see their retirement incomes reduced by $400 million in five years. The CTU stands in opposition to that bill.
How is the firing of 3,000 more teachers good for children? Non-payment and underpayment into the fund created the problem. Pension issues in Illinois stem from revenues, not expenses. The district made no pension payments between 1995 and 2005 and then was granted relief from the General Assembly in the form of dramatically reduced payments. Their decisions will directly impact the Chicago Teachers’ Pension Fund with 30,000 active employees and 22,000 retirees.
“We’ve had cuts to the classrooms for the past three years,” said Sharkey. “On top of that we’ve already had thousands of teachers, clerks, teacher’s aides, security staff and other educational support personnel laid off.  Any change now won’t reverse those layoffs. On top of that they shuttered 50 neighborhood schools and implemented other cost-saving strategies like student-based budgeting. This isn’t an issue of whether or not there is money for this but whether or not there is the will to fulfill their obligation. We’re not going to stand by and let them rip off retired public servants.”
Further, the district has imposed 9-figure cuts on teachers and other staff each year since 2010. Teachers and district staff have sacrificed. The district has not. Despite claims of “billion-dollar” deficits, CPS ended FY2011 and FY2012 with surpluses in excess of $300 million. CPS could have used some of those budget surpluses to smooth out their pension liability. Instead, CPS officials chose to delay action and faced a huge cliff this year.
Irony is not lost on CTU members that while the district and the Board of Education cry broke it has found tens of millions of dollars to spend on the expansion of charter operations, high-stakes standardized testing.
CTU spent significant resources and time to craft a solution that would stabilize both the pension fund, retiree healthcare, and the CPS operating budget. In fact, CPS and the mayor would not agree with any of CTU’s substantive plans. They pledged minimal guaranteed revenue and wanted cuts so deep that active and retired teachers would pay for the district’s entire normal cost, plus add $50 million to repay the district for payments it failed to make in previous years.
Though the mayor and his political pals would have the public believe the CTU has been unwilling to negotiate the truth illustrates the opposite.  CTU proposed revenue solutions that would ensure a stable tax base that primarily targets corporations and those most able to pay, including closing corporate tax loopholes and ending corporate subsidies.
The CTU remains a good faith partner at the bargaining table but it will not negotiate alone nor at the “point of a gun.”   Impacted municipal employees from throughout Chicago will take a massive caravan to Springfield on Feb. 19th to encourage legislators not to raid their benefits while their wealthy, corporate allies reap the financial benefits of their hard labor.

California's Progress in Advanced Placement Exams - Year 2014 (CA Dept of Education)

California's Progress in Advanced Placement Exams - Year 2014 (CA Dept of Education):

State Schools Chief Tom Torlakson Commends California's
Significant Progress in Advanced Placement® Exams Over Past Decade




SACRAMENTO—Annual Advanced Placement® (AP) results released today show that the number of California public high school graduates taking and passing AP courses continues to climb, with the number of graduates from low-income backgrounds taking at least one AP exam tripling, State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Torlakson announced. 
The 10-year anniversary (2003-13) "AP Report to the Nation" by The College Board shows that 40.6 percent of California's public high school graduates in the Class of 2013 took an AP exam, compared to 25.3 percent of graduates in the Class of 2003. The number of Class of 2013 students in California taking an AP exam grew from 86,303 in 2003 to 152,647, an increase of 66,344. The number of low-income students taking an AP exam during the same period increased from 18,677 to 64,539, an increase of 45,862. 
California placed sixth in the nation in the percentage (26.9) of students who scored at least a 3 out of 5 on an AP exam during high school. California moved up from eighth on the list over last year and is one of 17 states to score above the national average of 20.1 percent. About 17.3 percent of graduates in the Class of 2003 achieved the same score.
"It's important to recognize that not only are more and more students feeling equipped to tackle these college-level courses, but that more and more of them are succeeding," Torlakson said. "Along with their schools and families, they are working hard to be ready for college, and I'm glad to see the numbers continue to climb."
The report also shows growing AP participation among diverse student groups in California. The percentage of Hispanic/Latino AP exam takers in the 2013 graduating class was 38.3 percent, compared to 28.6 percent in 2003. The percentage of AP exam takers in the 2013 graduating class who were African American was 3.7 percent, compared to 3.2 percent in 2003.
Each year, The College Board honors three districts with a special reward recognizing success at expanding access to AP courses while also increasing the percentage of students scoring a 3 or higher on the exams. El Monte Union High School Districts in El Monte, California, was named the 2014 AP Equity and Excellence District of the Year for being the nation's leader among medium-sized districts.
The following 28 other school districts from California were also named to The College Board's most recent honor roll for expanding access to AP and increasing the percentages of students scoring a 3 or higher on AP exams: Alameda Unified, Carlsbad Unified, Central Unified, Chico Unified, Diocese of Sacramento, Diocese of San Jose, El Monte Union High School, Fillmore Unified, Fremont Unified, Huntington Beach Union High School, Irvine Unified, Kings Canyon Unified, Las Virgenes Unified, Los Alamitos Unified, Milpitas Unified, Oak Park Unified, Pajaro Valley Unified, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified, Reef-Sunset Unified, Saddleback Valley Unified, San Lorenzo Valley Unified, San Luis Coastal Unified, San Ramon Valley Unified, Santa Ana Unified, Temecula Valley Unified, Tracy Unified, Tustin Unified, and Walnut Valley Unified.
# # # #
Tom Torlakson — State Superintendent of Public Instruction
Communications Division, Room 5206, 916-319-0818, Fax 916-319-0100

2-11-14 THE WHOLE CHILD BLOG - ED Pulse Poll Results: What Is Most Important in Building School Morale?

ED Pulse Poll Results: What Is Most Important in Building School Morale? — Whole Child Education:




ASCD Releases 2014 Legislative Agenda
ASCD's 2014 Legislative Agenda urges a shift from the overreliance on high-stakes testing in determining student achievement, educator effectiveness, and school quality to a broader, more meaningful vision of success that supports each student from early childhood through graduation. Recently released during ASCD's Leadership Institute for Legislative Advocacy (LILA), the agenda is developed by AS


Kit Harris, ASCD Research

ED Pulse Poll Results: What Is Most Important in Building School Morale?

ASCD continually seeks to provide solutions to the challenges that face educators of all levels. A recentASCD SmartBrief ED Pulse poll asked readers asked readers what they feel is most important in building educator morale at a school.
The topic of school morale is not new. Studies have been done for many years on the effect it has on teacher turnover, how it can be raised, its relationship to teacher effectiveness, and other aspects. But in this era of increased standards, one of the components of school morale—the level of teacher autonomy—has revived a heated examination of the issue.
A new report on teacher morale from the Center for American Progress claims that teacher dissatisfaction is not as low as most people think, but has come under some criticism for its lack of in-depth analysis. This report has sparked some lively debate on blogs and columns and the February 2014 issue of ASCD'sEducational Leadership magazine on the theme "Building School Morale" is very well-timed to add a variety of perspectives to the discussion.
With this in mind, this poll question sought the opinion of ASCD SmartBrief readers on what aspect of school morale was most important. These educators selected school leaders at my school know me as an 

Mayor Bill De Blasio Focuses on Community Schools in New York City — Whole Child Education
Mayor Bill De Blasio Focuses on Community Schools in New York City — Whole Child Education: Mayor Bill De Blasio Focuses on Community Schools in New York CityFebruary 10, 2014 by ASCD Whole Child BloggersPost written by Martin J. Blank, Director and President, Coalition for Community Schools at the Institute for Educational Leadership; and Shama S. Jamal, National Policy Emerson Fellow, Coalition

UPDATE Badass Moms Association

 Badass Moms Association:

Badass Moms Association




 BACKGROUND: A group of mothers found each other this past year while facing school closings, budget cuts, charter school expansions, teacher layoffs and high-stake testing in Chicago Public Schools. We are from all over the city of Chicago and came together with one common goal. 


TO SAVE OUR CHILDREN and OUR NEIGHBORHOOD PUBLIC SCHOOLS. 

We named ourselves Badass Moms (BAM), and hosted the first ever Neighborhood School Fair in Chicago. On November 16, 2013, over 80 public neighborhood schools and community organizations came together to showcase strong communities and neighborhood public schools. (See link below)

http://www.dnainfo.com/chicago/20131117/chicago/badass-moms-organize-fair-touting-neighborhood-school-extracurriculars



WHAT WE BELIEVE: Connected by our strong belief in our communities, public education and our children. We believe our neighborhood public schools are the foundation of our communities. We know from our involvement that our neighborhood public schools are full of exciting programs, amazing students and strong parents. We want to celebrate our neighborhood public schools' accomplishments and diversity.

WHAT WE KNOW: There are mothers all over the country who believe as we believe. Counter to what Arne Duncan believes, more than just "white suburban moms" care about what is happening to our schools. Urban moms care too! Mothers of all races and communities, standing together strengthening public education.

GOALS: This group is to promote public education and our children while encouraging each other as mothers in the fight for education justice. BAM aim to reduce or eliminate the use of high-stakes testing, increase teacher autonomy in the classroom and work to include parent, student and teacher voices in legislative decision-making processes that affect children.

MEMBERS CAN BE BANNED FOR: Supporting corporate deform entities (TFA, StudentsFirst, Pearson, Bill Gates, etc.); supporting Common Core State Standards; excessive arguing or disrespecting decisions made by the mods/admins/founders; making comments that conflict with the mission of Badass Moms Association. We oppose the Common Core State Standards, Teach for America and expansion Charter Schools.


ACTIONS: BAT will engage in organized group actions such as phone calls, emails, or letter writing.


"If it comes to a battle between the billionaires and the moms over the future of public education, I am betting on the moms!" Mark Naison, Founder of Badass Teachers


























2-11-14 This Week in LA - School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District)

LA School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District):







Vergara sisters recall teachers who inspired them to join lawsuit
Beatriz and Elizabeth Vergara, student-plantiffs in Vergara vs. California Beatriz and Elizabeth Vergara, sisters at the center of a state lawsuit in their name, Vergara vs. California, took the witness stand today, describing chaotic classrooms with inattentive and hurtful teachers in their middle school. The sisters, who now attend high school at Cesar Chavez Learning Academies, an LA Unified sc

Watch Now: Livestream coverage of today’s LAUSD Board Meeting
A heavy agenda for today’s LA Unified School Board meeting. Expected to get some attention is a report by board member Steve Zimmer on the role of a ‘caretaker’ appointee to temporarily take the seat recently vacated by the unexpected death of Marguerite LaMotte late last year. LA School Report, is there live NOW. Check us out on Twitter @laschoolreport To access, click: LIVESTREAM LAUSD For meeti

In race to run powerful teachers union: ideology up for grabs
As campaigning begins in earnest at United Teachers Los Angeles (UTLA), the second-largest teachers union in the country, the election for the presidency could be as much about ideology as which candidate has more foot-soldiers. The union has shown signs of deep fracture lately, and with just 20 percent of the union’s 35,000 members expected to vote, the winner’s message will have to capture the v

Morning Read: Wifi upgrades push iPad cost to $1.3 billion

LA schools’ wifi networks to cost about $800 million The Los Angeles Unified School District’s board is scheduled to green light $66 million in wifi upgrades Tuesday, bringing the total reported costs of wifi upgrades need for its iPad proposal to $795 million. With that, iPad and wifi costs together would exceed $1.3 billion if the program is expanded to all district schools. KPCC LAUSD responds
2-10-14 This Week in LA - School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District)
LA School Report - What's Really Going on Inside LAUSD (Los Angeles Unified School District): Zimmer’s plan for District 1 vacancy facing a big voteThe LA Unified school board has an unusually long agenda for its monthly meeting on Tuesday, 39 items plus a handful of reports and updates. Each has consequences but few of them carry the import and emotional impact of Steve Zimmer‘s proposal to fill

2-11-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum

Seattle Schools Community Forum:







Is School Funding Fair (throughout the nation)?
Well, that would be no but here's the latest National Report Card on school funding by the Education Law Center at Rutgers.  The authors are Bruce Baker, professor in the Department of Educational Theory, Policy and Administration in the Graduate School of Education at Rutgers University , David Sciarra, Executive Director of the Education Law Center (ELC) and Danielle Farrie, Research Director a

Tuesday Open Thread
One of the most cherished memories of my childhood is gone.  Shirley Temple Black died today at the age of 85.  She gave laughter and hope to many after the Depression.  It's hard to pick a favorite moment from her films but her dazzling dance ability was apparent when she danced with Bill "Bojangles" Robinson in the The Littlest Rebel.  Or my favorite song, On the Good Ship Lollipop fro




2-10-14 Seattle Schools Community Forum
Seattle Schools Community Forum: What is the Purpose of Education, K-12 and Higher?Such a question.   I looked into this question when I was asked to speak about public education before a group of young early-leader Dems.  If you go back to the start of our country's history (even before we were a nation), it was about intellectual thought.  Being able to read was the key factor.  (The other key f