Saturday, January 18, 2014

All Week @ The Answer Sheet 1-18-14

The Answer Sheet:

All Week @ The Answer Sheet







Arne Duncan: Why can’t we be more like South Korea?
For years, Education Secretary Arne Duncan has lamented that the United States isn’t anywhere near as serious about educating its young people as the South Koreans. He did it in 2010, for example, in a speech in which he told the story about how South Korea’s then-president, Lee Myung-bak, once told President Obama that his country’s […]    


Everything you need to know about Common Core — Ravitch
Diane Ravitch, the education historian who has become the leader of the movement against corporate-influenced school reform, gave this speech to the Modern Language Association on Jan. 11 about the past, present and future of the Common Core State Standards. Here’s her speech: As an organization of teachers and scholars devoted to the study of […]    

YESTERDAY

How’s this for cynical?
How’s this for cynical? The Illinois State Board of Education wants to remove class size protections for students with disabilities. If the proposal (officially known as changes to state administrative rule Part 226) is approved, there would be no statewide limits on the size of special education classes, or the percentage of students with disabilities […]    
Maryland schools need $100 million for online Common Core tests, says report
A new report from Maryland’s Education Department to the legislature says that the vast majority of schools in many of the state’s counties are not technologically prepared to give new online Common Core-aligned standardized tests and that at least $100 million will have to be spent by 2015 to get ready. In Montgomery County alone, […]    
Bad news for teachers comes in an automated phone call
Despite decades of failure, merit-pay schemes for teachers continue to be pushed in states and school districts around the  country. In this post, Chris Gilbert, who teaches English at a high school and community college in North Carolina, explains a new scheme in North Carolina that involves merit pay for teachers and a loss of tenure […]    

JAN 16

Dying teacher makes remarkable journey to visit former students
David Menasche was a very popular, albeit unconventional, literature teacher at Coral Reef Senior High School in Miami who listened to punk rock, loved to skateboard and was distinguished from his teaching colleagues by his many tattoos. In 2006, at the age of 34, he was diagnosed with Stage 4 brain cancer, but he resisted […]    
A real school reform agenda for 2014
If you remember your No Child Left Behind history, 2014 is the year that all children were supposed to be scoring proficient on standardized tests. That was, of course, a ridiculous goal, which the authors of the bill knew full well when they wrote it, and a symbol for just how misguided school reform has […]    
NY officials’ excuse for link to vulgar test prep questioned
What did New York state education officials do when they were questioned about why a Common Core website they operated was sending students to other sites with vulgar material? Not what you’d hope. Award-winning Principal Carol Burris of South Side High School in Nassau County wrote in this post about the website, and in the […]    

JAN 15

A case study in misconceived urban school reform
School reformers are looking at a plan being considered in Kansas City, Missouri, to dismantle the school system as the wave of the future for urban districts. This plan calls for the creation of a collection of schools that will each by run by non-profit organizations under a new central authority, all  conceived under the […]    
The kids aren’t all right — an infographic
(Produced by Healthcare Administration Degree Programs)    
A creepy letter school sent to parents
This is an actual letter sent to parents from a school in Georgia. The parent who provided it asked to remain anonymous, along with the school — but administrators know who they are.   Real GA school letter threatens to hold back kids if parents don’t teach test taking strategies at home. #UniteBlue pic.twitter.com/kAo5xGkUl2 — […]    

JAN 14

What Christie failed to mention in State of State speech about his education record
A big part of New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie’s State of the State speech Tuesday was devoted to his record on school reform and his plans for moving forward — and it is worth noting the big difference between what Christie (R) says about his record on public education and what he actually did with […]    
Michelle Rhee gives the nation a D+ in school reform
School reformer heavyweight Michelle Rhee and her advocacy group StudentsFirst are not, apparently, pleased with the way school reform is going across the country. In their second annual State Policy Report Card, the national average is a D+ and the top state, Louisiana (yes! Louisiana) only eked out a B- with a 2.92 overall grade point […]    
What should a school do with a child like this?
What should a school be able to do with a child like this? A third-grade student in a Key Largo, Fla., public school was suspended for two days after he “reportedly threatened to shoot and stab his classmates and teachers during an outburst,” according to the Miami Herald. The unidentified student, according to a report […]    
And now, the Bunkum Awards (you wouldn’t want to win)
We just watched the Golden Globe Awards, and now we have the Bunkum Awards. The Bunkum Awards? Presented by the National Education Policy Center, which brings together interdisciplinary scholars at the University of Colorado, Boulder, these awards are given for what the presenters say is “shoddy” educational research, “work based on weak data, questionable analysis […]    

JAN 13

Is teacher education a disaster?
One of the biggest debates in public education today is over how to best educate student teachers for the rigors of the classroom. This is the third and final part of a series on the subject by scholar Mike Rose, who is on the faculty of the UCLA Graduate School of Education and Information Studies […]    
Weingarten slams teacher evaluation by student test scores
Randi Weingarten, the president of the American Federation of Teachers, the country’s second largest teachers union, has been a supporter of the Common Core State Standards for a long time but she has expressed concern in the last year over the way the standards are being implemented, saying that the rollout  was “far worse” than the […]    
U-Va. medical student saves man’s life during training exam
A University of Virginia medical school student performing a training examination on a “practice patient” assigned to complain about a specific condition discovered that the man actually had the disease — and he saved his life in the process. According to the University of Virginia Health System, student Ryan Jones of Danville, Va., was checking pretend […]    

JAN 12

‘The Procedure’ and how it is harming education
Do you know what “The Procedure” is and why it is a problem for education? Here to explain is Marion Brady, a veteran classroom teacher, who has written history and world culture textbooks (Prentice-Hall),  professional books, numerous  nationally distributed columns (many are available here), and courses of study. His 2011 book, “What’s Worth Learning,” asks and answers this […]    

JAN 11

NY Common Core website sends kids to vulgar test prep
The rollout of the Common Core State Standards in New York state has been riddled with problems that just keep on coming. Here are some of the latest, from award-winning Principal Carol Burris of South Side High School in Nassau County, who has been chronicling New York’s standardized test-driven school reform on this blog for […]    
Single university president signs school contract restricting her love life
How’s this for an unusual agreement between a school and its president? Gwendolyn Boyd, the new president of Alabama State University, signed a contract with the school’s trustees that forbids her from allowing a lover to “cohabitate” with her in the presidential home being provided to her by the historically black university in Montgomery. The […]    

1-18-14 Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Schooling in the Ownership Society All Week



Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog:
Schooling in the Ownership Society

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk 
Schooling in the Ownership Society






Despite next week's sham hearings, new CPS charters a done deal
This morning I received this email from my former fellow Prosser coach, Jeff Bates.Mike,What do you think?I'm sure you are aware of the RFPs for Intrinsic and Noble Charter Schools being considered by CPS at the upcoming Board meeting on January 22nd. Jeff Bates picsOn January 6th the demolition fences were put up around the proposed site of the New Noble School, directly across the street corner
Data Errata
Quote from CPS IG Jim Sullivan -- "The system has incentivized how performance is evaluated based on data, and much of that data is created and can be manipulated at the school level."  Sullivan, a former Cook County prosecutor, said last week that with schools, teachers and principals increasingly being tracked and evaluated based upon data on everything from student assessment scores t

JAN 16

The view from the bottom of the barrel
Fred Klonsky's view of our Ed Sec.Here's how things are looking from down here at the bottom of the academic barrel.For one thing, there seems to be lots of energy and activity on the organizational front. The Network For Public Education is holding a national meeting in Austin, March 1-2. CTU Pres. Karen Lewis and Supt. John Kuhn, (Perrin-Whitt Independent School District in Texas) are the keynot

JAN 15

Another Duncan Doughnut
"Teachers in America often come from the bottom of the academic barrel..." -- Arne DuncanYes, he really said it, and despite his inevitable pull-back once his handlers get hold of him, he really means it. This Harvard jock, who never taught a day in his life, can't open his mouth, it seams without demeaning teachers (or white suburban moms for that matter).I'm not sure what the "aca
Pension wars and Moore
Puerto Rican teachers strike: "No somos criminales, somos maestros." "We're not criminals."The attacks on public worker pensions, especially teachers' pensions, has become a centerpiece of corporate reform strategy aimed at degrading the teaching profession, eroding public space and undermining union contracts. It's a response to the growing public-sector debt crisis that avoid

JAN 14

It's silly to pretend Common Core is not a curriculum
"The Common Core has become a rallying cry for fringe groups that claim it is a scheme for the federal government to usurp state and local control of what students learn. An op-ed in the New York Times called the Common Core "a radical curriculum." It is neither radical nor a curriculum." -- Arne DuncanWell, Arne Duncan got it half-right. It's certainly not radical.I half expec

JAN 13

New CPS Network Chief was at the center of Kansas testing scandal
The word is that BBB has appointed Randy Josserand as District 3 Network chief. The news left lots of teachers I know, shaking their heads.Who is Josserand, you ask? Most recently, he's worked as a deputy chief of 25 high schools and 24 elementary schools on the West Side, a director of the Office of School Improvement (OSI), the director of Strategy and Knowledge Managements (yes Virginia, that's
Weekend Quotables
Roger Ailes (NYT)Fox News Chief Exec. Roger Ailes “I’m walking around, and I feel just all this anger. I can’t figure out where it’s coming from.” -- NYT Sunday Book Review Eric Holder “A routine school disciplinary infraction should land a student in the principal’s office, not in a police precinct.” -- New York TimesMark Anderson  Remind me again: Isn't Pat Quinn supposed to be a man of the peop

JAN 10

Mississippi, with strong Common Core and no unions, is losing Race To The Top
As long as we're racing to the top, let's take a look at how the race is going. The theory coming out of the D.O.E., the Gates Foundation and the think tanks is that implementing Common Core Standards is key to winning the race and that the main problem is "status-quo" teacher unions protecting bad teachers.But according to the latest edition Education Week's Quality Counts report, Missi
Sorry Rahm. Rauner's toast
 If “we don’t fundamentally change direction, we’re toast.” -- Bruce Rauner campaign adSorry Rahm. But your boy Rauner is toast. I know, I know, you're officially supporting Quinn, the Democrat, in the governor's race. But, everyone knows you and Rauner are tight. Even though he's supposedly a Republican, he's been one of your many wealthy patrons you're counting on to get yourself re-elected in 2


What's at stake in privatization?
I don't think so and neither does CounterpunchThe Jan.14th edition of Counterpunch asks and answersNothing short of genuine education itself is at stake. What particularly vitiates the learning process is the introduction of a corporate culture or “market” forces that insist on measuring “student learning outcomes” by “objective” standards such as standardized tests; that place an emphasis on comp

JAN 14

Ohio charters leading in the race to the bottom with a little help from their friends
As I posted here three years ago, to get a charter in Ohio, all you need it seems, is lots of money for local Republican campaigns and a white hat.When it comes to crappy, low-performing, and mismanaged charter schools, Ohio certainly leads the race to the bottom. Columbus alone, had 17 charter school failures in the past year. Nearly 30% of all Ohio charters have closed since 1997. The median lif

JAN 08

More on digedu...
Guest post by Donald Davidson, a Chicago school parent.Digedu is in at least six CPS public schools already (Lane Tech AC, LaSalle II, Hayt, Senn, Lincoln Park HS, Goethe) and also being used at Noble St charters. They provide not only their software, but also lease the hardware (tablets) and provide a fast, dedicated broadband connection that is only available to the classrooms using their softwa