Latest News and Comment from Education

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Research on preschool: Setting the record straight

Research on preschool: Setting the record straight:


Research on preschool: Setting the record straight


President Obama at a preschool in Georgia
President Obama at a preschool in Georgia
Now that President Obama has proposed a new initiative to broaden preschool programs, the debate about the value of early childhood education has gotten a lot louder. To help sort out what is true and what isn’t, W. Stephen Barnett, director of the National Institute for Early Education Research at Rutgers University, has just released a report that details what the best research says about early education — and what it doesn’t.
In the report, called “Getting the Facts Right on Pre-K and the President’s Pre-K Proposal,”  Barnett says that Obama’s proposal draws on valid research and that critics have misinterpreted research to attack it. The report, which can be found in full here, asks and answers four key questions. Here are the questions and excerpted answers:
Question # 1. Do the effects of high-quality preschool programs persist or fade out
by third grade?
…The most recent and comprehensive metaanalysis published in the peer-reviewed literature summarizes the results of 123 studies conducted in the United States since 


What’s worth learning?

What’s worth learning?  Veteran educator Marion Brady tries to answer the question below. Brady was a classroom teacher for years, has written history and world culture textbooks (Prentice-Hall),  professional books, numerous  nationally distributed columns (many are available here), and courses … Continue reading →

solidaridad: Despicable: Mónica García accuses fellow candidates of "standing up for predators"

solidaridad: Despicable: Mónica García accuses fellow candidates of "standing up for predators":


Despicable: Mónica García accuses fellow candidates of "standing up for predators"

Tony Bennett: There Will Be No Delay in Common Core, PARCC | Scathing Purple Musings

Tony Bennett: There Will Be No Delay in Common Core, PARCC | Scathing Purple Musings:


Tony Bennett: There Will Be No Delay in Common Core, PARCC

From an Associated Press report in the Tampa Tribune:
TALLAHASSEE — Florida shouldn’t delay new academic standards it’s sharing with 44 other states or a related test despite looming obstacles, the state’s schools chief said today at an education summit sponsored by business interests.
Other participants at the meeting in Orlando, though, said they were worried Florida was moving too fast by attempting to fully implement the standards in the 2014-15 school year.
Education Commissioner Tony Bennett last week told the State Board of Education he was developing a “Plan B” in case the test designed to assess the new standards isn’t ready in time. The test being developed by a 23-state consortium will replace the existing Florida Comprehensive 


New FLDOE Test Scoring Calculations “Has Potential to Dismantle Public Education”

FLDOE researcher Kathy Hebda has testified before the Florida legislature and the state Board of Education that data that was acquired by the SB736  guidelines was valid and measured what was intended. Meanwhile,  Jeb Bush’s Foundation for Excellence in Education has taken Hebda’s numbers and run with it. In a blog post yesterday, National Policy Director Mary Laura Bragg went this far:
The student performance portion of a teacher’s evaluation is based on whether or not students learned something in the classroom that year.
A few weeks ago, the Florida Department of Education released data showing:
  • A teacher with a classroom of gifted students does not have an advantage over a teacher 

UPDATE: Taxes and Public Education Seattle Schools Community Forum: One More Reason to Wonder about Tom

Seattle Schools Community Forum: One More Reason to Wonder about Tom:



Taxes and Public Education

The Stranger is reporting that the Washington State Supreme Court has struck down the two-thirds supermajority requirement for taxes, 6-3.  Basically, the Constitution sets a minimum already and that's enough for the Court.  Interestingly they also said:

However, we reverse the trial court's decision that the Referendum Requirement presents a justiciable controversy. Because the Referendum Requirement is not justiciable, we make no determination as to its 


One More Reason to Wonder about Tom

From The Stranger Slog (with the headline "Rodney Tom Hates Teachers"):

With zero notice Sunday, just one day before it was heard by the Ways & Means Committee, millionaire state Senate Majority "Leader" Rodney Tom (R-Medina) filed a bill that would eliminate defined pension benefits for most state and public school employees, replacing them with a risky 401-K-style savings plan that would subject future retirees to the whims of the market. SB 5856, of which Tom is the sole sponsor, would apply to all future public employees and all current public employees under the age of 45.

That means if you chose a career as a school teacher twenty years ago, trading the opportunity to strike it rich in the private sector for the promise of a secure retirement, you are totally fucked.
Of course, a lot of states have catastrophically underfunded their public employee pension plans. But not Washington. No, Washington has the second strongest funded pension system in the nation, with an enviable overall funding ratio of 98.1 percent. So I'm not exactly sure what the problem is that Tom is attempting to solve 

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Unions and charters are strange bedfellows | Gary Rubinstein's Blog

Unions and charters are strange bedfellows | Gary Rubinstein's Blog:


Unions and charters are strange bedfellows

When you ask the leader of an allegedly high performing charter school what makes them so successful, they generally say that they have more flexibility with hiring and firing since they are free from pesky union contracts.  This is why I found it quite odd that I received an announcement with job openings at a charter school called Green Dot High School the other day from the New York City teacher’s union, called the UFT.
It turns out that some charters do have teachers who are in the union.  I’m not sure how many charters are like this in New York City, but in addition to this Green Dot High School, there is actually one called ‘The UFT Charter School’ which, much to the glee of ‘reformers’ is one of the lowest rated schools in the city and nearly had its charter revoked recently, but has been given two years to shape up.
Anytime I see the name ‘UFT Charter School’ I chuckle a little as I imagine a Saturday Night Live skit about what must go on in this school:  The teachers all show up at exactly 7:52 AM and leave at 3:32 PM.  Nobody ever helps students on their ‘duty free’ lunch.  Everyone knows the contract by heart and anytime an administrator 

S.322: Ready to Learn Act - U.S. Congress - OpenCongress

S.322: Ready to Learn Act - U.S. Congress - OpenCongress:




Bill Introduced: S.322 Ready to Learn Act

A bill to set the United States on track to ensure children are ready to learn when they begin kindergarten.

Bill Introduced: S.274 Children Eating Well Act

A bill to strengthen nutrition education for elementary school and secondary school students to promote healthy eating choices through developmentally appropriate lessons and activities integrated into the school day.

Bill Introduced: H.R.700 ARPA-ED Act

To direct the Secretary of Education to carry out the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Education to fund directed development projects to support targeted breakthroughs in teaching and learning.

Bill Introduced: S.288 Women and Minorities in STEM Booster Act of 2013

A bill to increase the participation of historically underrepresented demographic groups in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics education and industry.

Bill Introduced: S.282 Counseling for Career Choice Act

A bill to amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to establish a new counseling program.

Bill Introduced: S.283 Investing in Innovation for Education Act of 2013

A bill to amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to invest in innovation for education.

Bill Introduced: H.R.563 School Social Workers Improving Student Success Act

To amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to establish a grant program to fund additional school social workers and retain school social workers already employed in high-need local educational agencies.

Bill Introduced: S.217 High School Data Transparency Act of 2013

A bill to amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to require the Secretary of Education to collect information from coeducational elementary schools and secondary schools on such schools' athletic programs, and for other purposes.

Bill Introduced: H.R.700 ARPA-ED Act

To direct the Secretary of Education to carry out the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Education to fund directed development projects to support targeted breakthroughs in teaching and learning.

Bill Introduced: S.282 Counseling for Career Choice Act

A bill to amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to establish a new counseling program.

Bill Introduced: S.283 Investing in Innovation for Education Act of 2013

A bill to amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to invest in innovation for education.

Bill Introduced: S.288 Women and Minorities in STEM Booster Act of 2013

A bill to increase the participation of historically underrepresented demographic groups in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics education and industry.

Bill Introduced: H.R.563 School Social Workers Improving Student Success Act

To amend the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 to establish a grant program to fund additional school social workers and retain school social workers already employed in high-need local educational agencies.

Bill Introduced: S.195 Mental Health in Schools Act of 2013

A bill to amend the Public Health Service Act to revise and extend projects relating to children and violence to provide access to school-based comprehensive mental health programs.

Zimmer Irate Over Reform Coalition Attacks - LA School Report

Zimmer Irate Over Reform Coalition Attacks - LA School Report:




Zimmer Irate Over Reform Coalition Attacks

Zimmer, Villaraigosa, and Sullivan
It was perhaps no surprise that District 4 School Board member Steve Zimmer was visibly upset when he happened to run into Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s Deputy Mayor for Education, Joan Sullivan, at today’s United Way education event.
“RFK, Joan? Really?” said Zimmer as the two rode the escalator together. “That’s just wrong.”
“I don’t know what you want me to say, Steve,” responded Sullivan.
The exchange, followed by harsh remarks from Mayor Villaraigosa about Zimmer later in the day, reveals just how antagonistic things have gotten between City Hall and the District 4 incumbent who was once considered something of an ally.

The bad blood between District 4 Board Member Steve Zimmer and Mayor Villaraigosa’s allies goes back to 2009, when Zimmer was endorsed by Villaraigosa in his initial race for School Board as part of a cease-fire with UTLA. The two men even stumped together, as you can see from this 2009 Daily Bruin clip.
But then Zimmer failed to show sufficient support for Villaraigosa’s views about school reform once he was in office. Four years later, Villaraigosa’s Coalition for School Reform has spent over $900,000 supporting District 4 challenger Kate Anderson and opposing Zimmer – much of it in the form of  television ads and direct mail flyers attacking Zimmer for laying off teachers and approving the construction of the $500 million Robert Kennedy School.
In total, over $1.7 million has been spent by the Coalition, SEIU and UTLA on the District 4 race alone, with more than $550,000 of it going to negative ads.
In an interview with LA School Report during the United Way event, Zimmer called the Coalition for School Reform’s negative ad campaign against him “morally reprehensible.”
“There are very legitimate things to come after me about,” Zimmer told LA School Report. “Layoffs shouldn’t be 

Education Standards and Totalitarian conformity

Education Standards and Totalitarian conformity:


Education Standards and Totalitarian Conformity

The Future of Education in America? All eyes on charter fallout - Sarasota News | Mysuncoast.com and ABC 7: 7 South Newsroom

All eyes on charter fallout - Sarasota News | Mysuncoast.com and ABC 7: 7 South Newsroom:


All eyes on charter fallout

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Related Stories

Posted: Wednesday, February 27, 2013 5:02 pm |Updated: 6:56 pm, Wed Feb 27, 2013.
SARASOTA COUNTY - Tuesday a judge ruled the principal of Imagine School in North Port could keep his job. However, it looks as though it will be a long fight over the future of the school.
Wednesday we talked to school board and legal experts who say the case moving forward may just impact the future of charter schools across the country.
The future of a local independent charter school and educating more than 1,000 children in it was in a court room this week. "It is not a healthy situation." The judge now suggesting the local school district get more involved. Sarasota County School Board member Caroline Zucker says it's a gray area. "There is no clear cut understanding of who owns what and who is responsible for what."
The fight between the Imagine parent company and the local governing board it appointed will likely continue through the court system. It may also have a bigger impact then just here. "I would expect charter schools and school districts nationwide would be watching this case very closely. Mark Zimmerman is a local attorney who specializes in education law. He says this is what can happen when you mix public funding and profits. "Ultimately this is a contract dispute involving a business entity. That is what is difficult about charter schools 

A lawsuit has been filed in Washington State challenging the legality of charter schools | Seattle Education

A lawsuit has been filed in Washington State challenging the legality of charter schools | Seattle Education:


A lawsuit has been filed in Washington State challenging the legality of charter schools